
Neil Howe: "Deep Demographic Problems Plaguing The U.S. Economy" (Hedgeye Investing Summit)
What this covers
This is a Hedgeye Investing Summit conversation between demographer Neil Howe and Hedgeye CEO Keith McCullough, recorded in March 2019. It starts from the numbers. Working-age population growth in the U.S. peaked near 1.2-1.3% around 1998 and is projected at roughly 0.1% by 2021. Employment growth has stayed at 1.5-2%, which Howe likens to Wile E. Coyote running off a cliff. Howe also notes that about three-quarters of global aging comes from falling fertility, not longer lives. He places the U.S. in the demographic-economic quadrant) with moderate population growth and high income, ahead of Germany, Italy and Japan, and credits Anglo-Saxon birth rates and immigration for that. The echo of the Millennials gives only a temporary lift.
The conversation then moves through several areas. One is the aging recession, in which shrinking labor forces produce negative growth even at full employment, a label flagged as contested. Another is monetary theory: Howe explains how population and productivity growth drive the natural rate of interest, recalls Alan Greenspan's mid-1990s soft landing, and says post-2008 deleveraging explains the weak recovery. He describes Modern Monetary Theory) through the state theory of money and cites WWII and the New Deal as precedents for merged fiscal and monetary policy. McCullough adds a case for gold tied to falling real yields.
The more contentious turns are political and financial. Howe applies the Fourth Turning) framework, argues that young Europeans are radicalizing toward populism, and notes how little presence Generation X has had in presidential politics. He also predicts that governments will push out physical cash to make negative rates possible. On cryptocurrency, he says Bitcoin was misconceived as money, and he describes calling the December 2017 top. He links that call to a broader claim about ideology distorting market judgment. McCullough, for his part, argues that recessions are normal and necessary for renewal.
McCullough and Howe argue that demographic headwinds—particularly the collapse of working-age population growth—are the dominant force shaping economic cycles and political outcomes over the next decade, making 'slower for longer' growth inevitable and positioning crisis-driven populism and policy experimentation (MMT, negative rates, currency devaluation) as the central economic and political story ahead.
- Working-age population growth has collapsed from ~1.2-1.3% in 1998 to ~0.1% by 2021, creating a structural ceiling on employment growth regardless of monetary policy
- This demographic cliff explains why Europe and Japan face 'aging recessions'—negative growth even at full employment—and why the US will eventually face recession and political upheaval
- When the next recession hits, MMT and massive fiscal spending will become politically inevitable, forcing currency devaluation and favoring emerging markets with population growth over aging developed economies
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Global aging is overwhelmingly driven (approximately three-quarters) by declining fertility rates rather than increasing longevity, meaning fewer young people are being born to replace aging cohorts and support dependency ratios.
“global aging is overwhelmingly driven at least three-quarters driven by falling fertility that's what's causing aging there are fewer young people replacing that and it's taking a population pyramid that used to look like this making it horizontal and then obviously with a lot of countries now around the world South Korea Japan and so on it's inverting sort of right in verdict”
The natural rate of interest (r*) is positively influenced by population growth and productivity growth (essentially real GDP growth) and negatively influenced by savings rates, meaning demographic and productivity decline drive lower natural rates
“if you look at neoclassical theory our star is positively influenced by population growth and and productivity growth basically multiplied times each other so it's basically GDP real GDP growth and it's negatively influenced on the kind of the denominator side by the savings rate so more savings less GD real GDP growth you're gonna get a lower art star okay”
There are two competing intellectual theories about the origin of money: the barter theory (libertarian view that money emerged from exchange) and the state theory (that government creates money through fiat as social credit), with modern monetary theory drawing from the latter tradition
“there kind of two theories about the origin of money one is the barter theory you know we started out bothering Bob Barton just treating goods for goods and then you know then gold and other things and so on so it's basically that's the kind of the libertarian theory so the Canadian guy from like the Hudson's Bay Company like yeah you know forever that piece of paper but then there's a whole nother theory which also has a long kind of intellectual pedigree which is more the purview of sociologists and that is government the money was really creation of governments”
Working-age population growth in the United States peaked around 1998 at approximately 1.2-1.3% per year and has declined to approximately 0.1% by 2021, representing a structural floor beneath employment growth capacity.
“we peaked in your over your growth in the working-age population probably around 1998 up from the late 90s and that was about one I can't remember about 1.2 or 1.3 percent year of a year still small bike you know longer-term historical standards but that was the that was the mini peak of that of that era we are going down to the year I think 20:21 I have a chart on that somewhere but to near absolute zero I think it's about point one”
The United States is positioned in demographic quadrant 2 (moderate population growth, high GDP per capita) relative to other developed nations, making it relatively well-positioned compared to aging European economies like Germany, Italy, and Japan, which face negative or near-zero population growth despite high affluence.
“China and Russia are negative... Germany and Italy and Portugal and Greece... they're kind of in your quad I guess that's your that's your quad threads because they're on the wax that have negative population negative population even though they're relatively affluent and then you look at your opposite northwest corner are all of the poor more relatively growing states... the United States is sitting there we are by far the largest country in that what you know the kind of that quad quad - and there are a few others out there and it's as Australia that Israel is the great outline”
Ideological bias warps market-driven judgment; people who start with an ideology (particularly libertarian ideology about Bitcoin or government-free currency systems) tend to make bad investment decisions and lose money because ideology overrides evidence.
“ideology always warps your market driven judgment right big time you don't want to start with ideology if you're marketing an ideology and you're good at it you might make a lot of money in a short period of time but that doesn't mean that your views on it or going to be non cyclical and or crashing and that's that's that's what you know sadly is happening a lot of purveyors or sales people at the Bitcoin”
'Aging recessions' are a structural phenomenon in aging societies like southern Europe and Japan where working-age population shrinks faster than the economy can grow even in good years (with productivity growth often below 1%), resulting in recessions with full employment and negative GDP growth quarter after quarter.
“an aging recession is an aging recession is when you're working age population which is going to be true of much of southern Europe over the next you know 15 years is actually shrinking faster than your economy is growing even in a good year think about that so wealth a lot of the southern Europe is going to be shrinking at over one percent per year... well productivity today in much of the developed world is often not above one percent positive per year okay which means an aging recession is a recession with full employment meaning that even in a good year with no cyclical problems you are actually having negative GDP growth quarter after quarter”
Employment growth has remained stuck between 1.5-2 percent year-over-year despite the underlying working-age population floor sinking out, creating a massive structural gap that resembles Wile E. Coyote running off a cliff
“the year of your employment growth is still stuck in the you know well it used to be just a bit over two but it's still between one and a half and two percent growth right you're over a year and it's like wily coyote because the underlying growth rate in the working age population the floor is sinking out underneath so it's this huge gap now right”
The core spending population (ages 35-54) in most developed economies is declining sharply, and this is the demographic group with the highest earning and consumption capacity, making declining spending population the most important constraint on economic growth.
“so this is these are the people that make the most money therefore have the most capacity to consume and spend money in an economy so it's the same way of coming to the same answer but lo and behold what did Neil say you know the rate of change and again we're both looking at rate of change the rate of each peak rate around look at that and then all this all it's done has gone down”
The Millennial generation represents the second wave of the Boomer 'echo boom,' and this demographic echo will provide a temporary boost to working-age population growth in the early 2030s and 2040s, though it will not fully offset the ongoing decline.
“the Millennials were the original echo boom of the Boomers right and this is gonna be the echo echo so these are gonna be the Millennials kits so you're gonna have a little bit of that this was there was actually a famous Swedish economist who term this effect so that when you get a very large bump on the population you get an echo bump and an echo bump you see this around the world in certain countries like Iran where you have this enormous shifts and fertility it gives rise to these bombs yeah echoes that kind of go through time”
The precedent for MMT-style large government spending occurred during WWII and the New Deal, and a Green New Deal type program would follow similar patterns of merging fiscal and monetary policy to restore full employment
“so long as you got the economy back working again what's the matter we did it with in World War two we did it during the New Deal...the green New Deal come on you got bad you got a New Deal and the green New Deal”
Bitcoin was fundamentally misconceived as 'money' and will fail because governments cannot and will not tolerate a functional cryptocurrency that undermines tax revenue and monetary control, and the first use cases were illicit transactions, limiting its economic utility.
“I thought Bitcoin was a bad idea from the beginning and I thought bubble well all the epic bubble yeah particularly when people started to talk about it as the new money I mean if it's just sort of a speculation because it's this weird new technology and we haven't decided what to do with it yet that's to announce right that my attitude is let them did it but when they begin to justify it as the new money I said no that's not going to work”
In Europe, particularly southern Europe, Millennials are radicalizing and voting for populist and authoritarian parties (Five Star in Italy, Yellow Jackets in France) because they are a generation with no prospects for growth, no jobs, and no future, making populism an expected response to demographic stagnation.
“and this is a generation that's getting used to you know kind of a no growth feature yeah and it's and it's radicalizing this generation by the way it's Millennials in Italy that overwhelmingly voted for you know five star in the leg and yard I mean this is this is being pushed by Millennials in France as well the yellowjacket well France the same way but again it's the populism but both the right and the left”
Governments are moving toward digital currency systems to drive physical cash out of circulation, which serves two ends: eliminating illicit activity and enabling negative interest rates by forcing digital-only transactions that governments can monitor and penalize.
“Governments are moving toward digital currency systems... to drive cash out of circulation which has been their goal for a long time because the whole idea is that well two things first of all... Rogoff so Rogoff also wrote another book... if we got rid of cash you know the whole world would be a safer and more moral place right so the reason why I get REM is don't like cash is is as you already pointed out cash is where most the criminal activity the world goes on... but I believe most of the actual currency is held by foreign countries probably by you know mobsters and terrorist group... but if we could run the cash out of existence we'd get rid of all this way of all the underworld activity and also the next time there's a bad recession we can engineer negative interest rates we could really have not only dessert but nerve because everyone who'd be forced to use digital currency so we could actually penalize you for keeping money in your account”
Boomers retiring and aging past 65, increasingly past 70, represents a huge exodus from the working-age population, and while senior labor force participation is rising, it cannot offset the demographic outflow
“the biggest reason is boomers are ready to retire boomers are all going over age 65 and increasingly now they're going over age 70 and yeah senior labor force participation is rising but nonetheless that's just that's a huge exodus there”
Recessions and market crashes are normal and historically necessary for institutional renewal, and avoiding them indefinitely would be unhealthy for long-term social and economic progress.
“I actually think around October to December you were brown right you're on this side of the you know this side of the earth on the right side of the grass yeah the markets went down yes this is memories are so short... I actually do I think that is when we correct institutions and we rebuild institutions I think the idea that you would have an economy just constantly dribble along you know is actually not good for us”
Alan Greenspan executed a successful soft landing in the mid-1990s by reducing interest rates while keeping employment growth aligned with working-age population growth, creating a model that typically is impossible to repeat because employment growth normally rises well above population growth before hitting a wall.
“occasionally historically you bet look back in the mid-1990s when Greenspan the maestro he was able to design an engineer a soft landing you know think about that he did he he reduced interest rates and he got us to that soft landing you see take a look at that slide again I cuz that's a good one you see those rates come down and kind of touched the the tops of those blue bars you see that soft landing but typically what happens is we go up a cliff”
During deleveraging cycles (like post-2008), economies grow very slowly because debt is being paid down, constraining credit expansion and consumption growth, which is why the recovery was weak despite extraordinary monetary measures.
“and I never thought it was it was a great call either that's why the economy was very slowly or deleveraging him is it was a terrible recession but I think it's really interesting how we work together because my short just overlaps a little bit with your long”
Anglo-Saxon countries (US, UK, Australia) generally have had higher birth rates than continental European countries since post-WWII, plus higher-than-average immigration, explaining why they appear in better demographic quadrants
“all of the kind of anglo-saxon countries generally have had a higher birth rate than the continental European yeah generally that we had a bigger baby boom after World War Two and we've generally had a higher birth rate plus countries like Australia and the United States have much higher than average immigration certainly that's part of the reason why Australia's there yet with us in in Quad -”
Economic slowdown and recession directly cause political problems—the rate of change of French and Italian economies shows they are "careening towards recession," making the demographic setup of these countries predictive of future political instability.
“I'm a big believer just because market history is that if you give if you show me an economic slowdown certainly one that's developing into a recession I'll show you political problems so I mean you know what McCrone rating looks like the rate of change of the French economy it is you know not drifting it is careening towards recession just like Italy's did so you're that's the biggest question I have with charts like this which is this is the most this is the most sure thing and I'm very much unsure above many things in markets but I am certain that with time and space that is the demographic setup of the core spending population in Europe so why are we constantly asking ourselves if Europe can't go into a protracted recession”
The 'Fourth Turning' framework predicts that generational shifts create recurring cycles of crisis and institutional renewal, with younger generations wanting 'more order, more certainty, more rules' and preferring authoritarian leaders, signaling a shift from post-war to pre-crisis conditions.
“in a post-war era it's the the generation that just created the new era they were just went through the crisis so they really identify with the institution's they build and generally younger people tend to want more freedom they want less order they want less rules that well write less conformity and all that but eventually as time goes by right those younger leaders are in power and generally have a pretty less a fair you know libertarian world it's younger people who want more order more certainty more route”
Gold is an absolute-return asset that competes inversely with real interest rates; when real yields are falling or negative, gold outperforms, and when real rates are rising, gold underperforms, making falling real yields the foundational bull case for gold.
“gold competes with real interest rates rising only likes it when real rates are falling I think it's slide 84 in the current macro deck guys if you want to find it just the empirical evidence of that”
Bitcoin peaked in December 2017 near its all-time high, coinciding with mainstream media and institutional hype about cryptocurrency as 'the new money,' and Howe made a presentation at that peak calling for the top, supported by historical analysis of money and government currency monopolies.
“I did a presentation as avocados in December's right near the peak it was right at the end and because I we have the hate mail to prove prove that”
Generation X has been conspicuously underrepresented in U.S. politics relative to the Boomer generation at the same age; Gen X has produced almost no presidential contenders until 2016, and the youngest contender in every presidential election from 1986 through 2012 was a Boomer, reflecting Gen X's lack of political ambition and dominance of their party's libertarian wing.
“as proof of how absolutely disinterested Generation X has been in politics you know they're way behind the age curve it actually in Congress you know taking the house taking the Senate taking us governor's at their current age you know boomers had already we're into the third president and already at pluralities in both the house in the Senate Gen Xers have been so slow you know Gen X is in both parties tend toward the libertarian edge of their party right but as proof positive of how disinterested Gen Xers are in politics we look back and found we looked at all of the contenders for the primaries in the every presidential election since 1986 and for the past almost 30 years the youngest contender in either party was a Boomer all the way up through all the way up through 2012”
The negative real yields observed in Japan, Switzerland, and other developed economies represent a long-term equilibrium outcome of demographic decline and productivity collapse, not primarily central bank policy or financial repression
“if everything just drifts on the way it's going yeah you can expect lower real rates for the long term...it's the Bank of Japan is all the know it's probably kind of a long term a new long term equilibrium right now I think”
The GI Generation (WWII generation) that created post-war institutions held the White House from John F. Kennedy through George H.W. Bush, completely bypassing the Silent Generation despite their experience of the Great Depression and WWII.
“between the GI generation which fought in World War two you know the so-called greatest generation right of that was in the white house for a long time from John Kennedy you know born in the century all the way up through you know George Bush Senior and then we had a Boomer that completely bypassed the Silent Generation yeah anyone who remembers the Great Depression and World War two as children but were you know not old enough to serve that an entire generation nearly twenty years was completely bypassed for the White House”
Modern Monetary Theory (MMT) argues that governments can issue currency freely without constraint so long as the economy remains at full employment and inflation is controlled, and this theory will become politically practical and important only when the next recession hits and unemployment rises, forcing policymakers to seek alternatives to traditional monetary policy.
“modern monetary theory... the idea of mmt is is I should just say just broadly and speaking about money... government that creates money... it's government that creates money I mean forget this whole idea that it all comes from gold and there's some intrinsic value no god it's a system of Social Credit and Society it makes a collective decision to create it they can do it as they wish all government all currency has always been fiat currency... you don't have to worry about how much you issue because you can issue any amount you want so long as the economy is it is running at full employment and so long as you keep inflation to you know down to a reasonable degree”
Strong US dollar environments compete with gold demand, as demonstrated by 2011's weak dollar coinciding with gold highs and more recent periods where rising dollar strength during mid-cycle US growth acceleration caused gold weakness
“so you know it and it makes sense I mean if a gold hit its all-time high of course in 2011 when Bernanke was devaluing the dollar to a 40-year low...he almost had like this mid cycle swell nut myth almost when US growth had a cyclical acceleration what real interest rates do they went into quad to in Quad to Gold gets smoked because gold competes with real interest rates”
Once inflation resumes after deflation/deleveraging, keeping interest rates low provides monetary policy traction to stimulate demand, whereas low rates during deleveraging are ineffective—the inflation-deflation dynamic determines monetary policy effectiveness.
“suddenly now your monetary policy has teeth once you get inflation going again then holding that interest rate low right actually gives traction to your monetary policy and and we are gonna see that if this next time puts us in that same situation we were gonna see a lot of the stuff that was only discussed before”
Democrats are more receptive to MMT theory than Republicans, with particular support among younger Democratic politicians, and MMT's implementation chances will be hugely improved at the right political juncture when the economy is in crisis
“there's a professor out of Stony Brook who's kind of a big promoter of that and has been to Congress and talking to it particularly on the Democratic side of the aisle to Democrats...there are many more Democrats believe in this mmt then certainly like you said libertarians but their but their chances of introducing that are going to be hugely improved at the right political juncture with the economy on the right conditions”
Millennials will likely dominate U.S. presidential politics earlier than Generation X (their predecessors), with Pete Buttigieg (age 37) emerging as the first viable Millennial presidential candidate in 2020, bypassing Gen X almost entirely from the presidency.
“but interestingly enough you have a millennial candidate running you know this guy Pete Bennett reach out of South Bend Indiana he's 37 years old... as proof positive of how disinterested Gen Xers are in politics... we looked at all of the contenders for the primaries in the every presidential election since 1986... the youngest contender in either party was a Boomer all the way up through all the way up through 2012 there were no gen extra candidates actually contending for the presidency obviously in 2016 you had a lot of them the two younger ones were Marco Rubio... and that guy from Louisiana... bobby Jindal... were born in 1975 and interesting Lena 2020 we have a millennial contender so only one year only one president of presidential election was a gen Xer the youngest contender and it's already moving on to Millennials”
Slower-for-longer growth in real GDP and mean-reverting inflation are now widely accepted assumptions in macro strategy, with Daniel Lacki representing the consensus view on this outlook.
“a lot of people we Daniel loci and I take for almost a given slower for longer in terms of real GDP growth in the US and slower for longer on inflation or a mean reverting nature to inflation so you get you know cyclical inflation then it goes away then bonds go down bond yields go down bonds go up etc”
Hyperinflation predictions following the 2008 financial crisis and government stimulus have been 'dead wrong' for approximately ten years, with each prediction at inflation cycle peaks continuing to fail.
“we get questions on that all the time which has been a dead wrong thing for people to go with any time we see inflation at its cycle peak like we just did last year well that's been dead wrong for about ten years right yeah ever since the GFC and you know when the Fed took extraordinary measures”
Bernie Sanders and Donald Trump both represent the rise of a new populism and authoritarianism on both the left and right in American politics, with Sanders representing top-down government control and Trump representing the first galvanizing figure of right-wing populism, but right-wing populism is likely to ultimately dominate.
“Trump and I thought that the two most interesting fascinating and path breaking developments in 2016 were Bernie Sanders and Donald Trump because there's a recurring edge on both the left and the right of this whole new kind of populism and authoritarianism right the three chairs on the left every bit as much of possibilities of thorough tourism on the right and you know Bernie Bernie Sanders is a guy who believes in top-down government just you know government and baking big decisions creating winners and losers... Donald Trump is the kind of the exponent of the leader the first one who really galvanized this new populism but if I had to bet I would say that when those final populism finally takes shape in America it's gonna be a little afternoon on the right”
The longest U.S. economic expansion in history (from 2009 to 2018+) has created policy convergence between Republicans and Democrats, with both parties favoring monetary accommodation ('more cowbell') and loose financial conditions regardless of ideological differences.
“by virtue of not having a recession this is the longest u.s. economic expansion in US history Republicans and Democrats when it comes to monetary policy have gravitated to the same thing there's no difference you know there's no difference between Donald Trump wanting more cowbell and Barack Obama wanted more cowbell”
China remains a poor country despite urbanization and industrial coastal development, sitting on the negative population growth side of the demographic quadrant even though it is a large economy, and has not escaped the middle-income ceiling
“obviously China and Russia are negative I mean they're you know China is a big economy but it's sitting there negative that's what it's still that up to middle income you know ceiling I mean China remains a poor country but it has is very urbanized in industrial coasts but it remains a poor country”
The natural interest rate (r*) is an academic concept from late-19th century neoclassical economics, revived as "r-star" in modern Fed policy discussions, which purports to measure the long-term equilibrium real interest rate based on demographic and productivity factors.
“it's a function of the of the demographic reality they look like interest rates truly look like the slope of this line and like this have gone to a negative number this is why you know talk about the natural interest rate which was an you know an invention of the late 19th century by new to excel the stockholm school no he actually quoted it's a natural interest rate and it's been revived now the monetarist the Taylor rule is really based on a non accelerating inflation idea of sort of the long term you know real rate of interest and it's often in academic models this is called our star you know the our star and all the Fed president interesting little tidbit John Williams who's now you know used to be a San Francisco Fatty's now with what yeah I think he's vice chair of the New York Fed a New York Fed had vice chair of the Fed he says he dreams about our star he'd read he dreams about our stars”
Bitcoin was a speculative bubble driven by anarcho-libertarian ideology (particularly appealing to Gen X and boomer Xers like James Dale Davidson and R.E. Samuelson who believed in sovereign individuals and no-trust societies) rather than rational monetary theory
“the great irony is that the real ideological edge of the whole Bitcoin movement was was guys like you know James Dale Davidson and REE smog and they there were sovereign individual these are boomers and all the Xers that followed them these are all libertarians they believe radically in the idea of no government you know and we're just you know the with no need for trust I mean talk about an ideal Society for most Gen Xers no trust necessary”
Governments can engineer inflation through index-linked wage or account adjustments (e.g., indexing bank deposits to inflation at 1% per month) if they have incentive to do so, but lack political will—Japan came close to implementing such a policy during its liquidity trap.
“I believe Japan was very near that point a couple of years ago and and the way they would have done it was simply to say any worker or anyone with a payroll you put your stuff in a bank and we just we're gonna index it out by a percent a month or something like I mean thank you guys”
Every age-gender group in the U.S. except Millennial males has higher employment-to-population ratios in 2018 than in 2007, indicating that the economy has truly run out of workers in most demographic categories and future employment growth must come from pushing employment participation above previous peak levels.
“if you look at where we are in age gender groups every single age gender group except for millennial males is above where they were in 2007 that's my point and when I say we're running out of workers means you have to assume that we are going to go above the peak of previous expansions in terms of our employment to population growth by age gender”
Market declines disproportionately benefit younger investors who can buy assets at discounted prices, creating a two-sided transaction where older asset holders suffer losses but younger investors gain opportunity.
“whenever the prices go down it's like a terrible tragedy yeah for all the older people that owned everything but the next generation is coming on right it's their opportunity there are always two sides to a transaction and and for life to go on we have to think about what's coming on after us”
If the U.S. experiences the slowdown that both speakers predict and MMT is deployed alongside currency devaluation, the emerging-market thesis becomes extremely attractive because emerging-market assets will be revalued upward in dollar terms while the dollar itself declines.
“if we go to a slowdown like one that's beyond stagnating to slow down in the US and then you have political change and you have MMT the dollar is going to get castrated in that environment and those countries that are in quod one that you just showed are gonna have in dollars don't forget that eeehm does very well when when when the US government is burning its currency at the stake so you know that is you know the units the rebalancing of global power so rebalancing of incentives it's a rebalancing of growth expectations to where you actually have the population growth going okay”
Pet care is an emerging growth industry with strong demographic tailwinds because Boomers and Gen X have reimagined pet ownership, treating pets as family members ('pets have parents and grandparents') and spending on premium pet food, healthcare, and services.
“one is pet care there are a lot of interesting ways you know everyone's owning pets and boomers and Xers have completely reimagined how we treat our animals right I mean you know everything about them is is you know the food and you know it's organic it's every the amount of money we spend on my father treats my his two dogs better than I was ever treated today they know if dogs have now have parents and grandparents and you know they weekend”
Online dating is a high-growth opportunity because people are marrying later, divorcing more frequently, and older age cohorts are underserving in the online dating market—creating a large gap between current market penetration and potential future penetration.
“another is a huge change there and in particularly assertive although I'm not big social media generally they've got the kind of Google Facebook duopoly I'm not very positive on I think that you know online dating is an incredible growth opportunity and we had a piece recently on that because you know virtually everyone is waiting a lot longer to get married older people are getting divorced and that's an entire area where there's been very little market penetration in your long the screening process”
McCullough uses a 'trades, trends, and tails' framework that divides investment time horizons into: trades (less than 3 weeks), trends (3 months to multiple years), and tails (tail risk 3+ years), with this framework helping contextualize different temporal perspectives on markets.
“I talk in the framework if you can throw up slide twenty guys of trades trends and tails so that that's you know in many cases it can be considered shorter term relative to Neil's work... but this trade trend tail model lives in this three weeks or less what are we talking about today immediate term type stuff three months or more which is intermediate term trends that's why we call them trends they matter big time to getting your portfolios right asset allocations... and then long term to tail risk I never go beyond three years because I'm really bad at that but Neil's really good at that”
Sub-Saharan Africa's high population growth combined with very low GDP per capita ($1500 or lower) places it off the scale of meaningful demographic quadrants and represents economically irrelevant populations from a global capital allocation perspective
“if you go into sub-saharan Africa just what I call the economically irrelevant part of the world I mean just realistically they're not relevant but then their be off the scale and I'm you know very high growth of very poor they're beneath I think the end of that chart is like fifteen hundred dollars per person yeah I'm DP per capita yes I'm even lower than that”
Cannabis is an emerging growth industry due to demographic shifts toward legalization and increasing substitution from alcohol consumption, with young investors and institutions beginning to treat cannabis consumption as a higher-growth alternative to alcohol.
“but there was a point to where the number one thing you could say back to me because I was defending you by the way because you're the one who made the call taeho the panic I'm the one I got the hedge I bran down my forehead so it's like I would always I'd always have to see the point but it's a great technology and I I do I read write I think five or six books on the topic I tried to educate myself the best I could there was a lot of narrative based you know storytelling there and it wasn't a tremendous amount of just hard-coded rate of change fact that's more to my liking... cannabis we've done a extensive amount of work there you could see that the well we have lifting we home security that does that silly but but it's it's not shocking to see Shane Laidlaw as hockey sticking charts on cannabis consumption relative to alcohol consumption”
For Millennials to build wealth in the context of demographic stagnation and slower growth, they should diversify geographically into emerging markets (particularly Malaysia, Indonesia, Philippines) that have high population growth and reasonable governance, avoiding developed economies facing demographic decline.
“I mean I often get asked which areas of the we you know you're the demographer which areas of the world I should be you know invested in from that point view and you can see that I mean if you just look at any of my you know 20 charts on the subject you can look at areas which are reasonably decent in terms of you know security legal structure corruption and all that and yet have high population growth so if you're really looking for that wave you know you're looking at the at the Malaysia's and Indonesia's the Philippines and so on there there is there is again looking at quadrants there is an area there where you can find economies for the long run that are probably going to you know they still have a lot of catch-up to do in terms of productivity they're still gonna have a proactivity you know dividend over the so if you're looking long term but be diversified because you know how any one of those countries is gonna go”
Hedge fund managers who lack macro investment track records and have struggled in currency, fixed-income, and equities for a decade became Bitcoin experts and promoted it as a core asset allocation position, representing desperation rather than insight
“in institutional investing all of a sudden we had all these Bitcoin experts that were not experts at getting any kind of return in macro for like a decade and also now they're gonna tell me how you know which they edit a very hard time getting anything right and currency fixed-income or equities now they're gonna tell me precisely why I don't know anything about all those calls”
Bitcoin was promoted as a 'great technology' narrative by books that lacked hard-coded rate of change facts and whose economic history was rooted in misunderstandings of how money actually functions historically
“I'd always have to see the point but it's a great technology and I I do I read write I think five or six books on the topic I tried to educate myself the best I could there was a lot of narrative based you know storytelling there and there wasn't a tremendous amount of just hard-coded rate of change fact that's more to my liking and the history that was recounted by a lot of Bitcoin authors really was one that was a base in the realm of unawareness I guess no no real comprehension of in economic history”
Bitcoin peaked in late 2017 when CBOE introduced futures contracts, which was supposed to broaden financialization and institutional adoption but instead marked the peak as ideology-driven buyers were exhausted
“Bitcoin CBOE abandons futures contractor [26:04]...that was the big cat deal of course now it's gonna broaden the financialization of Bitcoin and asset allocations worldwide are now going to be sufficient for institutions because you see they're gonna trade properly with futures and options contracts just like any other asset class...that ended up being the peak”
U.S. markets experienced a 27% decline from August 30 to December 24 (2018), representing a bear market, which McCullough notes is often forgotten by observers who assume markets can never decline.
“if you're along the Russell 2000 which is a pretty broad index of US stocks and now 27 percent from August the 30th to December the 24th what could go wrong that's that's called a bear market yeah yeah”
Moderate, centrist political leaders fail in societies with strong extreme-right and extreme-left movements (e.g., France under Macron), making the center-right or center-left viable only when populist extremes are weak, and Macron's approval ratings are worse than the Socialist candidate he replaced.
“in Europe if you want to know where moderate middle-of-the-road leaders are least likely to succeed it's in societies where you have a very dominant both extreme right and extreme left in France is one of those societies which was why we predicted from the beginning that Emmanuel macron approval ratings I wasn't going to look any better than what's his name that socialist he came before him ya know where it was just you know down it's pathetic I mean you know macro right now you know dreams about having Trump's approval approval rating”
If the economy enters "Quad 3" or "Quad 4" (using a growth vs inflation framework with 3-year to tenure window), this establishes "slower for longer" conditions, the most certain economic forecast, yet markets and policymakers constantly fail to act accordingly.
“if you use a 3 year to tenure window that's the easiest call to make that is called slower for longer quads breanne for or the same thing happens if you look at slide 6 guys they're the only two quadrants where you have growth slowing okay”
Futures markets are already predicting Democratic victory in the 2020 election despite unemployment being at 3.4%, but this forecast will likely reverse if the economy enters recession and unemployment rises, demonstrating the tight coupling between economic cycles and political outcomes.
“when you look at you know futures markets and remember again I come back to this the economy is now at three point something percent unemployment and already you have futures markets predicting right that that Democrats are going to come in and sweep in 2020 wait and until the economy is yeah a little more negative you take that outlook and maybe last question on this”
Neil Howe coined the term 'Millennials' and has written at least nine books, primarily focusing on generational theory and demographics as drivers of economic and political outcomes.
“we could kind of met cuz you're the guy who coined Millennials you've written how many books nine on demography yeah at least and you're gonna be another one coming I think yeah”
McCullough claims he is Canadian (not politically aligned with either US party) and therefore views market history and economic analysis through a data-dependent rather than ideological lens.
“I'm not trying to be political I'm not a Republican or Democrat I'm Canadian I've said that all the time because it's it's it's of course true”
Climate change is real but the effects have been overstated by alarmists, and the 'lukewarmer' position (that CO2 causes modest warming, not catastrophic warming) is more credible than extremes on either side
“he thinks that rising carbon dioxide levels are responsible for a little bit of warming but not not a lot and not nearly the kind of alarmist picture that people think I'm kind of more of a lukewarm ER”