What this covers

This lecture, given by the instructor Jeff in a college history of philosophy course, takes up the moral psychology and ethics of Thomas Aquinas. It begins with the idea that everything in Aquinas has to be read through the relation between God and creation, since God is the efficient cause of the whole causal order and human agents are secondary causes. From there it builds up the psychology: sensory appetites split into the concupiscible (desire for what pleases) and the irascible (aversion from what threatens), and above them the will, which cannot act without an intellect supplying something to choose. The lecture suggests, following Westberg, that the will may resemble the biblical "heart." It also holds that the will always aims at what it perceives as good, so evil enters through misperception, which the lecture ties to confusion and fallenness.

The ethics follows from this. Virtue is built by repeated choice in the Aristotelian manner, which raises the question of how one knows what to choose. Aquinas answers with a natural law whose first precept is that good is to be done and evil avoided, and whose content is drawn from inclinations such as self-preservation. Conscience is treated as a network of such inclinations, and the lecture sets out a four-part hierarchy of law running from eternal law to natural, divine and human law. It also adds three theological virtues, faith, hope and love, to the four cardinal ones, and says that grace presupposes nature. The highest end is becoming like God, not the philosopher's life of Aristotle.

The passages most open to dispute come late. The lecture explains double intention through just war teaching, where the collateral damage from destroying a bridge may be permissible if it is only a secondary intention, and it notes that some Protestant ethicists find the doctrine too casuistical. It also says that pursuing money, power or status amounts to idolatry, and it presents the classical natural law argument against homosexual behavior drawn from Romans 1.

Sharpest takeaway

Thomas Aquinas develops a theological moral psychology grounded in natural law and virtue ethics, where the will operates as intellectual inclination directed toward the good by both natural inclinations and rational understanding, fundamentally different from modern mechanistic conceptions of free will operating in a causal vacuum.

  • The will is not free in a causal vacuum but is intellectual inclination informed by natural inclinations and perception of good, embedded in a theological rather than mechanistic worldview
  • Human virtue develops through habits formed by repeated choice aligned with natural law precepts derived from our natural inclinations toward self-preservation, procreation, and rational community
  • Aquinas distinguishes between ultimate good (God) and immediate goods, with moral culpability determined by primary intention rather than secondary consequences, illustrated through just war doctrine

The claims · ranked22 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.71

There are two fundamentally different historical concepts of will: the modern mechanistic concept (emerging in the 17th century) of a free will operating in a causal vacuum independent of all influences, and Aquinas's theological concept of will as intellectual inclination directed and informed by natural inclinations and the perception of good while still remaining free.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — A History of Philosophy | 26 Aquinas' Moral Psychology and … [ZFJwc2tyzFU]

“you have um in the history of Western thought at least two concepts of will there is one concept of will that um emerges in the 17th century perhaps a little earlier with William of aam uh that would be in the 15th century uh but the concept of will that emerged at least clearly in the 17th century and I would suggest is your concept of free will because we've all ingested it in the very intellectual atmosphere of our times it's the concept of a free will operating in a causal vacuum that is to say a free will which is not directed influenced determined by any causes at all”

0.69

The intellect must be informed in order to direct the will, and it can be informed in multiple ways: God may inform it directly, it may be informed by knowledge of scripture and theology, or it may be informed by reason in terms of natural law ethics.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — A History of Philosophy | 26 Aquinas' Moral Psychology and … [ZFJwc2tyzFU]

“the intellect then needs to be informed and it can be informed in a variety of ways hypothetically God might directly inform it it might be informed by our knowledge of scripture and yes indeed he does a lot with theology logical ethics might be informed by reason in terms of a natural law ethic but in any case the intellectual inclination is what provides the direction of orientation of the will which is the efficient cause Of Human Action okay”

0.69

The will always inclines toward what it perceives as good (which may not actually be good), not toward evil directly, but the perversion of personality occurs when the intellect misperceives evil as good through confusion of understanding and other causal factors including the fallenness of the sinful state.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — A History of Philosophy | 26 Aquinas' Moral Psychology and … [ZFJwc2tyzFU]

“the will automatically chooses no inclines towards rather than chooses inclines towards what it perceives as good which may not in fact always be good but if if the intellect perceives something is yes yes well my question then is that it seems like the will and just being at the efficient cause has a static nature but comparing it to the heart as that lecture did it seems that it now what do you mean by aesthetic nature well just in the fact that it seems like it it always inclines towards what is perceived as good”

0.69

Natural inclinations toward the good, as they develop through repetition and habit, form networks of inclinations that constitute the conscience (syneidesis), which is fundamentally a basic natural inclination to live for the good in accordance with reason.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — A History of Philosophy | 26 Aquinas' Moral Psychology and … [ZFJwc2tyzFU]

“these inclinations need to be developed veled and as these inclinations develop so they form a network of inclinations that becomes the conscience cerasis the conscience in which the basic natural inclination is to live for the good in accordance with reason however it may be stated”

0.68

In addition to the four cardinal virtues (which are natural virtues achievable by natural processes of moral psychology), Aquinas adds three theological virtues—faith, hope, and love—which are dependent on grace and not achievable by natural processes alone.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — A History of Philosophy | 26 Aquinas' Moral Psychology and … [ZFJwc2tyzFU]

“but he's not satisfied with those four cardinal virtues so he adds three theological virtues and the three theological virtues of course are faith hope and love uh now while these are additional virtues dependent on Grace the natural virtues are achievable by the natural processes of moral psychology”

0.68

In Aquinas's ethics, the highest good (ultimate end) is not to be like Aristotle or to achieve the philosopher's life as it is for Aristotle, but to be like God and to become a saint, reflecting the theistic rather than Aristotelian foundation of the ethic.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — A History of Philosophy | 26 Aquinas' Moral Psychology and … [ZFJwc2tyzFU]

“the highest good for Aristotle was the actualization of a life lived in accordance with reason perhaps the highest state for Aristotle that a person could achieve was to be a practical-minded philosopher living a full life arist did I say Aristotle yes to be like our Aristotle in Aristotle's ethics is to be someone just like Aristotle yeah okay okay but for aquinus the highest end is not to be as Jeff says like Aristotle the highest end is to be like God the highest end is not a philosopher but a saint you say and isn't that what you'd expect of a Christian eist”

0.68

The first principle of practical reason and the first precept of natural law is based on the notion of good: 'good is that which all things seek after,' and therefore the first precept of law is 'good is to be done and pursued, and evil is to be avoided,' with all other precepts of natural law based on this fundamental principle.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — A History of Philosophy | 26 Aquinas' Moral Psychology and … [ZFJwc2tyzFU]

“as being is the first thing that falls under the apprehension simply so good is the first thing that falls under the apprehension of practical reason directed to action so every agent acts for an end under the aspect of good aspect yes as perceived good so the first principle in Practical reason the first principle of natural law if you like is one founded on the notion of good that good is that which all things seek after oh there's theology good is that which all things seek after hence the first precept of law is good is to be done and ensued and evil is to be avoided is that the first thing your mother ever told you do what's right don't do what's wrong do good avoid evil um all other precepts of natural law are based on this”

0.66

Everything in Aquinas's thought must be understood in terms of the relationship between God and creation, including human nature and ethics, because God is the efficient cause of the entire causal order and human agency is a secondary cause of which God is continually the cause.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — A History of Philosophy | 26 Aquinas' Moral Psychology and … [ZFJwc2tyzFU]

“like any theist ainus thinks of everything in terms of this relationship between God and cre cre ation and if you're going to talk of human nature and ethics uh you have to do so in terms of the relationship between God and His creatures”

0.63

In Aquinas's sensory psychology, sensory inclinations (the appetites of the animal soul) are of two kinds: the concupiscible, which involves desire for what is pleasing and desirable, and the irascible, which involves aversion from what is perceived as bad, threatening, or dangerous.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — A History of Philosophy | 26 Aquinas' Moral Psychology and … [ZFJwc2tyzFU]

“in that sense our inclinations are informed by the intellect and as ainus examines our sensory inclinations inclinations that that is uh that have to do uh with the um sensory Soul sensory appetites like Aristotle he distinguishes rational soul from animal Soul you see with its sensation so forth so the sensory Soul the animal Soul the passive intellect uh has its sensory inclinations of two sorts there are inclinations passions that are concus uh that is to say these are desires for inclinations towards what is pleasing what is design horable okay uh the concus concupiscible uh concus concus sub okay I think that's it and the um the other um inclinations towards the erasable the concus what we perceive as good the erasable what we perceive as bad bad in the sense of being threatening unpleasant dangerous”

0.63

In Aquinas's moral psychology, there is emphasis on both intention and act—a good intention can exist without a good act (one may bungle the execution), and conversely, the moral evaluation must consider both dimensions of action.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — A History of Philosophy | 26 Aquinas' Moral Psychology and … [ZFJwc2tyzFU]

“these inclinations um in as much as the emphasis is on inclination you can see this is an ethic in which there is going to be emphasis on the intention as well as the ACT the intention may be towards the good even though the ACT is not right morally is not good morally the intention can be good without the ACT being good you may just plain bungle you see”

0.63

The development of virtue in the Aristotelian tradition requires repeated choice and repeated action as the mechanism by which virtues are habituated, and the crucial question that arises is: how do we know which to choose and how to act?

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — A History of Philosophy | 26 Aquinas' Moral Psychology and … [ZFJwc2tyzFU]

“the emphasis however on the development of virtue in the Aristotelian tradition the emphasis on the development of Virtues requires all the time that we develop these virtues as habits habits by as Aristotle said repeated choice and repeated action so the question arises how do we know which to choose and how to act and it is there that the natural law ethic of aquinus comes into play”

0.61

There is no innate clear idea of God, but there is an innate vague inclination toward God (a hunger and thirst for what satisfies), and the vagueness of this inclination results from human fallenness, which is why Calvin taught that special divine self-revelation (the sensus divinitatis clarified by Scripture) is necessary.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — A History of Philosophy | 26 Aquinas' Moral Psychology and … [ZFJwc2tyzFU]

“exactly that's why the first question regarding the existence of God the first article is whether the idea of God is innate and he says no except in a very vague way there's no innate idea of God but there is innate inclination towards you know we hunger and thirst for what is it you see the vague way yeah now of course you might ask why is it so vague you see and you could say that vagueness is due to the for which was precisely what John Calvin said read the first seven chapters of Calvin's Institutes of the Christian religion celvin talks of a vague sense of the deity a sensus detis you see which is so vague as a result of human fallenness that we need the special Divine self-revelation you see”

0.60

Everything in nature seeks the preservation of its own being and resists destruction, exemplifying a law of self-preservation that applies to every kind of thing in nature, making it a universal teleological principle.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — A History of Philosophy | 26 Aquinas' Moral Psychology and … [ZFJwc2tyzFU]

“every substance it's the preservation of its own being doesn't it you're a substance a thing everything since seeks the preservation of its own being yeah this quarter does I can't break it seeks the preservation of its own being you see this paper no initially it resists it seeks the preservation of its own being”

0.60

Grace presupposes nature in its operation, and divine grace sustains the normal operation of human psychology while adding certain causal influences from the work of the Holy Spirit, analogous to how Revelation presupposes reason and knowledge by nature while revealing what reason cannot know alone.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Jeff (Instructor)

“the operation of Grace presupposes um nature and uh the normal operation of human psychology so that um what Revelation does and remember our discussion of faith and reason if what Revelation does is to reiterate some things that reason tells us and then to tell us things that we cannot know by reason alone so the operation of Grace you'll see operation of Grace sustains the normal operation of um human psychology and adds certain causal influences the work of the Holy Spirit”

0.60

The will cannot act without intellect providing something to choose—'the will is not acting if there is an empty mind no thought no perceptions how can you choose if you don't conceive of something, if you're not choosing something'—establishing that choice always has an intentional object provided by intellect.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Jeff (Instructor)

“the will is not acting if there is an empty mind no thought no perceptions how can you choose if you don't if you're not choosing something you see and if you choose something uh you're choosing um what you either ought or what you want or both um”

0.60

There is a metaphysical basis grounded in reality for the morality that Christians have espoused in the form of a natural law basis for ethics, making Thomistic ethics a theological ethic not because it relies on revelation alone but because it has both natural and divine law grounding.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Jeff (Instructor)

“there is in other words for aquinus a very clear metaphysical basis a basis in reality for the morality which Christians have espoused you'll see a natural law basis for ethics becomes very plant theological ethic”

0.56

The doctrine of double intention has been applied in Roman Catholic just war teaching: if the final intention is to restore just peace, then taking out military infrastructure (a bridge) with foreseeable collateral damage to enemy troops and civilians can be morally permissible if the collateral damage is secondary intention rather than primary intention.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — A History of Philosophy | 26 Aquinas' Moral Psychology and … [ZFJwc2tyzFU]

“this has come out for instance in Roman Catholic teaching with regards to the conduct of War where if the final end is appropriate to just War namely the restoration of a just peace for friend and foe alike therefore the resistance of unjust violent aggression if that is the final end the final intention the immediate intention may be to take out a bridge which may involve um the death of um enemy troops uh maybe the um collateral that's the term that's used remember um collateral damage to property and even the loss of Civilian lives but you see the secondary intention of doing damage to um to Bridges and troops and the collateral damage which is known would result you see uh that is not the primary intention”

0.55

Aquinas distinguishes four kinds of law that exist in a hierarchy: eternal law (in the mind of God, the archetypal divine law), which is promulgated in two ways—as natural law (accessible to all people) and as divine law (given in scripture and entrusted to the church), with divine law applied to particulars by canon law and natural law applied to particulars by human law.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — A History of Philosophy | 26 Aquinas' Moral Psychology and … [ZFJwc2tyzFU]

“a little more detail the picture he gives us overall is that there are four kinds of law so that he distinguishes between the Eternal law which is in the mind of God this if you like is the archetypal law in the mind of the Divine logos the Eternal wisdom and counsels of God which Eternal law is revealed or using governmental terminology as he does is promulgated in two ways it is promulgated in natural law and it's promulgated in Divine Law the Divine Law being given in scripture and entrusted to the church and as the medievals um would say um this is applied to particulars by the church in its canon law whereas natural law is applied by rulers to society in human law”

0.52

Because there is a built-in natural inclination toward the ultimate good (God), many people who pursue material goods, money, power, or status are effectively committing idolatry by substituting god-substitutes for the true ultimate good, deliberately or unthinkingly making gods of their own out of what they perceive as their good.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Jeff (Instructor)

“the fact is that in so much as there is this builtin desire for good ultimately God you'll see we make gods of our own God substitutes this is why um uh material mindedness can become an idolatry you see when the highest good is to make money gain power you see that's the god you see so um uh the point is that the substitution of some higher good deliberate ly or unthinkingly is still idolatry you see”

0.50

The doctrine of double intention has been criticized as too casuistical by some Protestant ethicists but remains an important principle in Aquinas and Catholic moral theology for applying ethics to complex and troublesome cases.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — A History of Philosophy | 26 Aquinas' Moral Psychology and … [ZFJwc2tyzFU]

“the doctrine of double intention becomes pretty important in the application of Ethics to Troublesome cases and it's been very much criticized as too casuistical by some Protestant ethicists but um it's an important thing to be aware of that more by way of parenthesis footnote”

0.49

Following Westberg's suggestion, the will in Aquinas may be akin to the biblical concept of the heart—the guiding core of the whole personality and the moving and motivating force—operating out of its natural direction and orientation, influenced and shaped by what one knows and perceives through experience.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — A History of Philosophy | 26 Aquinas' Moral Psychology and … [ZFJwc2tyzFU]

“one of the writers um the one who did the first paper on Friday morning Westberg suggested that the term will in ainus may be Akin the equivalent perhaps of the biblical use of the term heart out of the heart of the issues of Life The Heart Is The Guiding core of the whole personality as the moving Force the motivating force now if the will is intellectual inclination you see it's out of the heart and its orientation its inclination the will is not in a vacuum in a causal vacuum it has a natural Direction a natural set which is influenced and guided and shaped in its particulars by um what we know what we perceive by experience okay”

0.45

There are things which are contrary to nature and the classical argument about homosexuality based on Romans 1 roots this claim in natural law—that homosexual behavior is contrary to natural law and to the natural end and natural use of sexuality.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — A History of Philosophy | 26 Aquinas' Moral Psychology and … [ZFJwc2tyzFU]

“the good ends we should pursue and he quotes the first chapter of Paul's letter to the Romans as natural law ethicists usually do um that there are some things which are contrary to Nature you see the classic argument about homosexuality uh is rooted there in that Romans 1 passage that homosexual behavior is contrary to natural law to the Natural end to the Natural use”