
What this covers
This six-minute School of Life film is delivered by a single unnamed narrator. It begins from a cultural observation: among educated people, pride in one's country has come to look suspect, close to jingoism and racism, and disavowing it has been a mark of sophistication for generations. The film argues that nationalism cannot be switched off, only neglected, and that neglect leaves it open to the worst voices. It then sketches a utopia as a way of showing what a country worth being proud of might look like.
The historical contrast is between the Spartans, proud of military strength, and the Athenians, proud of the Parthenon, their playwrights, and their philosophers. The film also makes a psychological case: one life never supplies enough to be proud of, so collective pride spreads the work of finding meaning across a whole society. It adds that patriotism appeals most to people with the narrowest opportunities, and that elites have not always treated this with compassion. Some of these claims are flagged as contested, notably that a fine society is one proud of admirable things rather than one that has outgrown pride, and that fear of episodes like the Nuremberg rallies has made us too wary of healthy forms.
The utopia itself takes up most of the film, and it is deliberately whimsical. A part-time café waiter is a national celebrity for his balance, a primary school teacher is admired for her freestyle dancing, and a fifteen-minute annual sky-gazing event is held on 2 October. The richest person is a psychoanalyst, school heads out-earn financiers, and honours go to wisdom, beauty, and maturity rather than dominance. Other details cover streets made charming by censored advertising, elections that tweak a long-term direction rather than turn on leaders' personalities, a ministry of human relationships that makes divorce easy but rare, and shared ownership of high-speed trains set against the private luxury car.
Sophisticated nationalism directed toward genuinely admirable collective achievements—rather than military dominance or jingoism—provides essential psychological and social benefits that cannot be replaced by individual achievement alone, and serves as a counterweight to destructive impulses when left unguided.
- Ignoring nationalism doesn't eliminate it; it leaves it vulnerable to exploitation by destructive voices
- Collective pride in shared accomplishments distributes the burden of meaning-making across society, making happiness accessible to those with limited individual opportunities
- A healthy society directs national pride toward beauty, wisdom, human development, and the meeting of higher needs rather than military or economic dominance
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Among most intelligent people, feeling proud of one's country is considered deeply suspect, perilously close to jingoism and racism, and has for several generations been a mark of sophistication to disavow any nationalistic emotion.
“among most intelligent people feeling proud of one's country is a deeply suspect emotion perilously close to jingoism and racism it has for several generations been a mark of sophistication to disavow any nationalistic emotion”
The desire to feel proud of one's community is a natural and noble impulse that requires sophisticated ways of directing.
“the desire to feel proud of one's community is a natural and noble impulse we just need sophisticated ways of directing our urge for pride”
Patriotism proves especially appealing to those who have the narrowest opportunities in a society, a fact that elites have not always treated with the requisite compassion.
“that's why patriotism invariably proves especially appealing to those who have the narrowest opportunities in a society a fact that elites have not always treated with the requisite compassion”
We have been too sensitive about what can go wrong around various kinds of collective pride, allowing fear of phenomena like the Nuremberg rallies to prevent us from embracing healthy forms of nationalism.
“we've been too sensitive about what can go wrong around various kinds of collective pride the rallies in nuremberg evoke a constant fear of collective aggression and insanity”
We aren't capable of doing without nationalism; the challenge is to find our way to the better kinds.
“we aren't capable of doing without nationalism so the challenge is to find our way to the better kinds”
Ignoring nationalism doesn't make it go away; it leaves it unguided and undeveloped, ready for exploitation by the worst voices in a society.
“the problem is that ignoring nationalism doesn't make it go away it leaves it unguided and undeveloped ready for exploitation by the worst voices in a society”
A really fine society is not one that has outgrown collective pride, but one where people are proud of genuinely great and admirable things.
“a really fine society is not one that's outgrown collective pride it's one where people are proud of genuinely great and admirable things”
The ancient Spartans directed their pride towards military strength, while their neighbours the Athenians felt proud of the beauty of the Parthenon, the quality of their playwrights, and the wisdom of their philosophers.
“the ancient spartans directed their pride towards military strength their neighbours the athenians felt proud of the beauty of the parthenon the quality of their playwrights and the wisdom of their philosophers”
A nation which we can feel ready to love is essential for human meaning and flourishing in modern life.
“a nation which to put it romantically we can feel ready to love”
Collective pride is important because there's never enough to be proud of in a single life; nationalism takes the pressure off by allowing us to find meaning through membership in something larger.
“collective pride is so important because there's never enough to be proud of in a single life nationalism takes the pressure off all of us it lightens the oppressive responsibility we'd otherwise feel to ensure that our own lives could always be stellar and heroic”
In this utopia, one of the top celebrities is a part-time waiter in a cafe regarded as the most well-balanced person in the country, influential for his attitudes toward shoes, travel, camping, and relationships.
“it's a country obsessed with celebrities one of the top celebrities is a part-time waiter in a cafe and is widely regarded as the most well-balanced person in the country his attitude to shoes travel he loves going camping near the lakes and relationships have been highly influential”
In this utopia, another public hero is a primary school teacher deeply admired for her freestyle dancing and her attempts to deal with adversity.
“another public hero is a primary school teacher she is deeply admired for her freestyle dancing and her attempts to deal with her”
In this utopia, an annual event on the 2nd of October, lasting about 15 minutes, involves everyone contemplating the sky, with celebrities discussing favorite types of clouds and the elderly reminiscing about spectacular weather events like a 2010 cumulonimbus.
“an annual event which takes place early in the evening on the 2nd of october everyone takes time usually around 15 minutes to contemplate the sky there's quite a bit of build up celebrities discuss their favorite kinds of clouds and why these mean so much to them and what they're hoping to see this year the elderly reminisce about a spectacular 2010 cumulonimbus”
In this utopia, the richest person in the country is a psychoanalyst, the heads of primary schools earn more than financiers, and there's a world-renowned network of public swimming pools.
“the richest person in the country is a psychoanalyst the country has the world's most beautiful network of public swimming pools on average the heads of primary schools earn more than financiers”
In this utopia, public honours are taken very seriously but are given for encouragement of maturity, display of wisdom, promotion of beauty, and alignment of profit with meeting of higher needs rather than for military or economic dominance.
“public honours are taken very seriously but what's really notable is what they're given for the encouragement of maturity the display of wisdom the promotion of beauty and the alignment of profit with the meeting of our higher needs”
Pride in genuinely good things creates a powerful and hugely welcome sense of belonging that assuages loneliness and provides benign motivation.
“pride in genuinely good things creates a powerful and hugely welcome sense of belonging it assuages loneliness and provides benign motivation”
With well-focused nationalism, we don't have to do it all ourselves; we can find happiness in something in which we have a small stake but that goes far beyond us.
“with well-focused nationalism we don't have to do it all ourselves we can find happiness in something in which we have a small stake but that goes far beyond us”
If our longing for collective pride were taken more seriously, we would invest more money and energy in things that were owned by everyone because we would recognize that this would include us.
“if our longing for collective pride were taken more seriously we learned to invest more money and energy in things that were owned by everyone because we'd recognize that this would include us”
There is something properly stirring about being part-owner along with 300 million others of a collection of next-generation high-speed trains that cross the land at close to the speed of sound, compared to the gratification of owning a luxury car.
“it may be gratifying to own a luxury car but there's something properly stirring about being a part owner along with 300 million others of a collection of next-generation high-speed trains that cross the land at close to the speed of sound”
In a utopian society, citizens would have diffuse general pride in the beauty of their urban environments, with ordinary streets looking exceptionally charming due to censorship over public advertising and signage.
“citizens are proud of the diffuse general beauty of their urban environments in this utopia it's normal for a very ordinary street to look exceptionally charming there's a lot of censorship over public advertising and signage”
In this utopia, elections are not about the personality of party leaders but more about tweaks to the direction in which the state is traveling.
“elections tend not to be about the personality of party leaders but more about tweaks to the direction in which the state is traveling”
In this utopia, divorce is entirely straightforward legally but people tend not to divorce because of collective investment in the stages leading up to marriage and sophisticated state support when relationships get tricky, with the ministry of human relationships having a powerful voice at the cabinet table.
“it's entirely straightforward to get divorced but people tend not to because of the collective investment in the stages leading up to marriage and because of the sophisticated support provided by the state when things get tricky the ministry of human relationships has a powerful voice at the cabinet table”
In a secular, complex, and specialized world, we need to feel that we're not just stray individuals dependent for our esteem on our own achievements, but also that we are members of a wider entity for which we're prepared to work and make wise sacrifices.
“in a secular complex and specialized world we need to feel that we're not just stray individuals dependent for our esteem on our own achievements but also that we are members of a wider entity for which we're prepared to work and make wise sacrifices”
In this utopia, good government is not dependent upon which particular elected representative is in charge because issues affecting everyone's life are linked to policies developed and applied over many years.
“good government is not dependent upon which particular elected representative is in charge mostly the issues which affect everyone's life are linked to policies which are developed and applied over many years”
In this utopia, alcohol consumption is not illegal or particularly frowned upon, but people drink elderflower and other cordials instead because they are keen on keeping cheerful and focused.
“it's not illegal or even particularly frowned upon to drink alcohol but they drink so much elderflower and other cordials because on the whole they're very keen on keeping cheerful and focused”
In this utopia, health insurance plans cover treatment for addiction to internet pornography.
“health insurance plans cover treatment for addiction to internet pornography”