
Is the World Coming Apart? Drama at Davos | Global Stage | GZERO Media
What this covers
This is a Global Stage livestream from Davos, hosted by GZERO with Microsoft after the forum's two-year pandemic break. Nicholas Thompson moderates a conversation among Ian Bremmer, Microsoft president Brad Smith, UN Foundation president Elizabeth Cousens, and former Danish prime minister Helle Thorning-Schmidt. The framing is that Davos is now driven by geopolitics rather than business. Bremmer contends the war is less a fight inside Ukraine than one between Russia and NATO, with cyberattacks, disinformation and espionage as fronts, and he expects the knock-on effects to be larger than most people realize.
The technology thread is the most concrete. Smith dates the Russian cyberattacks to February 23, a day before the ground invasion, and describes roughly 300 coordinated attacks on government and banking systems. He explains how Microsoft moved 16 of 17 Ukrainian ministries into distributed cloud infrastructure, and argues that disinformation and cyber operations are coordinated rather than separate. Bremmer notes that cyberspace has nothing like the nuclear non-proliferation regime. Thorning-Schmidt argues that coalition politics in Europe produces humility and a functional middle, which the US two-party system lacks, though that claim is contested.
The wider crisis discussion is about whether institutions can respond. Bremmer's Goldilocks crisis idea holds that Ukraine and climate are big enough to force action but still solvable. He also argues that delegitimized institutions can only be reformed in the middle of a crisis, and that some nationalism reflects a rational view that elites have lost touch. Cousens warns that crises accelerate one another and erode the trust cooperation needs, while pointing to smallpox eradication during the Cold War as proof that cooperation is possible. Smith offers the Cold War as a template for decades-long coalition effort. He also suggests using data, as with COVID reporting, to forecast and redistribute food. The discussion ends on food insecurity and whether governments cooperate or turn nationalist.
Global crises like Ukraine, climate, and food insecurity require unprecedented cooperation between governments, tech companies, and international institutions, but current political fragmentation and loss of trust in elites threatens the coordinated response needed.
- The war in Ukraine represents a 'Goldilocks crisis'—severe enough to mobilize response but not so catastrophic as to paralyze action—that can reinvigorate institutional reform if seized
- Cyberspace, disinformation, and AI demand integrated public-private responses that mirror Cold War-era transatlantic unity, yet the US two-party system and European multiparty consensus create asymmetric vulnerability to information warfare
- Food insecurity affecting 276 million people (50 million at famine risk) is solvable through diplomatic breakthrough on Black Sea grain exports and data-driven logistics, but requires political will that nationalist sentiment and elite distrust are eroding
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Accelerating crises themselves act as accelerants of other crises; corrosive inequality and toxic media environments make international cooperation harder, creating a vicious cycle where the conditions needed for crisis response become scarcer.
“Accelerating crises, which I have to say, are accelerants of crises, which worry me almost more than the crises themselves. And you know, one of those is just corrosive levels of inequality across societies, between societies, and the other is this question of a toxic media environment that just makes polarization so much greater in so many of our societies. So, all of those make what we most need, international cooperation, that much harder.”
A valuable analytical approach is to spend more time defining problems using data and analytics before rushing to debate solutions, which could help unlock solutions to disinformation and other challenges.
“Let's spend more time talking about problems instead of just rushing to debate solutions. Can we, you know, add more data? Can we inform conversations? Can we use data analytics? Can we use technology to, you know, just start to agree on the problem and then start to solve it?”
Russian cyberattacks on Ukraine actually began on February 23, 2022 (one day before the ground invasion), not February 24, involving 300 coordinated attacks targeting government and banking systems.
“People think the war began on February the 24th. No, it began on February the 23rd. That's when we saw 300 Russian coordinated cyberattacks all seek to take down the Ukrainian government and Ukrainian banks.”
Disinformation attacks and cyberattacks are not separate threats but coordinated attacks designed to reinforce each other, with disinformation functioning as propaganda that coordinates with technical cyberattacks.
“these are all connected, that disinformation attacks, and they are attacks. These are really propaganda attacks, are coordinated with other cyberattacks and, you know, they're designed to reinforce each other and they will be, I think, for as long as this war continues.”
Coalition governments inherently instill humility in leaders because they lack majorities for every policy; this forced dialogue and listening to other parties creates institutional conditions that prevent the kind of polarization seen in majority single-party systems.
“The joy of coalitions is really a big thing. Everyone was always criticizing Angela Merkel for being indecisive and, you know, prolonging all discussions. It was because she was used to coalitions. I mean, I ran a three-party coalition that didn't even have a majority. Every day, you wake up and you don't have a majority for your policy. And I think that gives you humility. You have to listen to others. You have to have the dialogue.”
The Cold War provides a valuable historical template for long-term crisis response: it required sustained unity among many countries from 1945 to 1990 around common values, never escalating to direct hot war, and demonstrates that problems requiring 30-40 years of commitment can be successfully managed through sustained coalition-building.
“I'd probably look back at the Cold War. You know, in a couple of ways. I mean, first of all, I think we tend to use the word crisis to define a short-term problem. And you know, the truth is, unfortunately, some problems require long-term sustained efforts. And you know, the Cold War is a testament to the unity of many countries from basically 1945 to 1990. You know, so that's an extraordinarily long period of time. I think it was, you know, a transatlantic partnership...a commitment, you know, by countries to stick to common values, to never go so far as to precipitate a hot war, but to remain united for as long as it took.”
There is no governance framework remotely equivalent to the nuclear non-proliferation regime when discussing cyberspace, representing a critical gap in technology governance.
“There's nothing remotely like that when we talk about the cyberspace that we've been discussing just now.”
Microsoft's immediate response to the war was to migrate 16 of 17 Ukrainian ministries from on-premises government servers into cloud infrastructure distributed across European data centers, solving the vulnerability of centralized digital infrastructure to cruise missile strikes.
“Before this war began, the Ukrainian government ran entirely on its own digital infrastructure, on its own servers, in its own government buildings... we've literally worked with the Ukrainian government to move 16 of the 17 Ukrainian ministries into the cloud, into our cloud and data centers across Europe.”
Disinformation thrives in environments of political fragmentation and disagreement on basic facts, where different parties treat the same problem as if it were completely different issues.
“And that's the environment where disinformation thrives. I mean, it really feeds off that.”
Cyberspace by definition requires both government and private sector roles because cyberspace defies traditional territorial borders and is owned and operated by private companies, making pure government or pure private sector approaches insufficient.
“You know, it defies traditional borders. Much of it is owned by private sector companies. They operate data centers and cables and the like, but if you leave it to tech companies alone, that's not a good path. We really need both together.”
Even at the worst moments of the Cold War, global cooperation on health (smallpox eradication) was possible, providing historical proof that cooperation on crises is achievable even under deep ideological division.
“even at the worst moments of the Cold War, we solved smallpox. So, it is possible to cooperate, even under the most divisive and contested of conditions.”
Tools for crisis response evolve over time; countries must be willing to use novel tools (like data and digital technology) as they emerge, constantly innovating to address each crisis as it unfolds.
“Tools evolve over time. You know, and to some degree, you have to make yourself available to use the tools that emerge, constantly innovating...We see the power of data. We see the power of digital technology and we see the ability to use these to address each crisis as it unfolds.”
Public perception of crisis outcomes is characterized by loss of trust in elites (media, corporate, banking, and government), resulting in a sense of instability and feeling disempowered to make a difference.
“people feel they do not have the tools, are not empowered to make a difference, feel they've lost so much trust for all of their elites... media, and it's corporates, and it's bankers, and it's their governing officials. And that's why you have such a greater sense of instability today because people just don't trust the folks that are supposed to be showing them the way.”
Climate change today represents a Goldilocks crisis—large enough and urgent enough to demand response, but not so catastrophic that solutions don't exist.
“Climate change today, in my view, reflects a Goldilocks crisis.”
European democratic debate is less hostile and less fragmented than US debate because of multiparty coalition structures that preserve a functional middle ground, in contrast to the US two-party system that eliminates the middle.
“the democratic debate in Europe is less hostile and less fragmented what you see in the US. I mean, I think that's something that Ian has been writing about for years, that you see the fragmentation and the loss of, the vacancy of the middle, there is no middle anymore in the US debate. And I think that is making it prone to disinformation.”
Some nationalist sentiment is driven by the rational perception that elites are so far from what citizens need that people are willing to break existing systems rather than continue the status quo.
“some of them do want the nationalist response because they believe that the elites themselves are so far from what they need to do that they are prepared to argue to have things get broken.”
For the first time in European history, Europe is speaking with one voice geopolitically because Putin's invasion unified even countries historically aligned with Russia, reversing the divide-and-rule strategy that had previously been effective.
“for the first time, Europe is actually speaking with one voice. They used to divide and rule between European nations. They can't do that anymore. Even countries that used to be with the Russians, they have to be with the other European nations.”
European governments approach tech regulation through oversight and rule-setting more than US governments, which is why the Digital Services Act originated in Europe rather than America.
“Europeans believe much more in regulation than the US does. And that's why it's, for me, it's natural that the first Digital Services Act that we have, a real big regulation of tech, comes from Europe.”
Microsoft and other tech companies can support food security by using data to forecast where shortages and surpluses will occur, enabling coordinated logistics and redistribution.
“to use the power of data to make sure that we're assisting with forecasting... where are there likely to be shortages? You know, where might there be a surplus? You know, where are there opportunities to move food from one place to another?”
COVID demonstrated the power of data to manage crises, with daily reporting on cases and hospitalizations enabling real-time public health management, a model applicable to food security forecasting.
“just think about how much of a role data played, even like every morning, you'd get up and you'd read about, you still do, you know, the rate of cases. The rate of hospitalization, the power of data to help manage this.”
Ukraine's traditional government infrastructure was located in physical government buildings vulnerable to cruise missile strikes, not dispersed or cloud-hosted—a vulnerability that was always present but not recognized until war began.
“Before this war began, the Ukrainian government ran entirely on its own digital infrastructure, on its own servers, in its own government buildings. And people recognized something that, frankly, was always there, but no one was talking about. If your build, if your servers are in government buildings, they can be destroyed by cruise missiles.”
Institutions become de-legitimized when the world's power structures move away from the way institutions are supposed to function, such as NATO's design for a bipolar world that no longer exists.
“when you have an environment where institutions aren't working very well and they're eroding over time, and you know that they're eroding because the world's power structures are moving away from how the institutions are supposed to function, whether it's NATO or the WTO or the Security Council, what happens, over time, is those institutions become de-legitimized.”
An intergovernmental panel on artificial intelligence modeled on the IPCC (climate panel) could establish authoritative problem definition globally, reducing disinformation about AI risks and enabling more unified governance approaches.
“I would start with a intergovernmental panel on artificial intelligence or on disruptive technologies or on cyber, 'cause one of the reasons why, even though the Americans and the Chinese don't agree and trust each other, anything you do on climate is largely moving in the same direction. And the reason for that is because you have a group, a global group, that is seen as responsible and authoritative that has gotten together and defined the climate problem. So, you no longer have significant disinformation that really undermines that.”
De-legitimized institutions can only be fixed in response to crisis, not through anticipatory reform, because institutional dysfunction impairs the capacity to anticipate problems.
“And the only way you're gonna fix them is in response to crisis, 'cause you can't really anticipate a crisis if your institution doesn't work very well, but you can respond to it”
The war in Ukraine is not primarily a war inside Ukraine but a war between Russia and NATO, involving dimensions of cyberattacks, disinformation, espionage, and potential further NATO expansion through Finland and Sweden membership.
“people are mostly thinking about this as a war inside Ukraine. But it's not a war in Ukraine. It's actually a war between Russia and NATO. I mean, Russia was engaged in cyberattacks against the United States through, you know, criminal organizations and the rest a year ago... What about disinformation? What about espionage? Well, you know, what happens when Finland and Sweden, in relatively short order, join NATO?”
Europeans are more worried about disinformation as a democratic threat compared to Americans, and can achieve consensus on what constitutes hate speech and disinformation more readily than Americans can.
“Europeans have a generally better sense of what they consider to be disinformation. - Yeah, that's true. Yeah. - Just like they do on say, hate speech. - Yeah. - The Americans do not.”
Solving information problems requires first achieving agreement on what the problem actually is; when two parties define the problem differently, resolution becomes nearly impossible even with improved detection capabilities.
“You can't solve a problem unless you agree on what the problem is. I mean, if two parents have an issue with the kids and they both think it's a completely different issue, it's very unlikely they're gonna resolve it... The Americans do not [agree on what disinformation is]. And so, I mean, the issue is fundamentally politicized and therefore, resolving it for one part of the political spectrum in the US literally means making it worse for the other.”
Democratic governments have inherent limitations on pronouncing truth and falsehood, requiring the role of private sector, NGOs, and academics in detecting foreign disinformation while keeping government's role narrowly defined to preserve public acceptance.
“There's a real limit on the ability of democratically elected governments to play a role in pronouncing what is true and what is false... the work to really detect and combat, you know, foreign propaganda attacks is gonna require a different set of roles, roles by the private sector, roles by NGOs, roles by academics and roles by government. But I think the government role, by definition, is gonna have to be somewhat more narrowly defined in order for the public to accept it.”
Negotiations involving the UN, International Committee for the Red Cross, Russia, and Ukraine have successfully evacuated over 700 civilians from Mariupol, demonstrating that even in active conflict, diplomacy can achieve humanitarian objectives.
“the negotiations on Mariupol in getting the civilians out, that the UN and the International Committee for the Red Cross, 700 plus civilians, they got out. They're alive today because of diplomacy that involved the Russians and the Ukrainians.”
Finland and Sweden joining NATO results in Russia gaining approximately 1,400 kilometers of new border with NATO, an outcome Putin did not anticipate when planning the invasion.
“Russia is basically getting 1,400 of new kilometer border to NATO if those two countries join. They cannot have anticipated that.”
The world's immediate crisis is not only the Ukraine war but also global economic mood depression caused by anticipated hunger at scale not seen in decades, supply chain disruptions, and the risk of European recession driven by energy supply structure.
“it's also what's happening in the global economic mood. People are getting depressed about what's happening. We will see, because of hunger issues, or because of supply issues, we will actually see hunger in a scale that we haven't seen for a long time... We will see countries keeping their own goods to themselves. We are still seeing supply chain issues. And then of course, we are talking about Europe going into recession.”
Advances in wind, solar, fusion, green hydrogen, long-duration battery storage, sustainable aviation fuel, and direct air capture suggest that by 2050, these technologies will be fundamental to preserving planetary habitability.
“advances in wind and solar, think about fusion and green hydrogen. When you think about long duration battery storage, when you think about sustainable aviation fuel, when you think about direct air capture, yeah, these are all things that, in 2022, look like they're somewhere between they're here to we hope someday they'll be here, but by the year 2050, I think we'll look back and we'll say, that is fundamentally what helped us do what we needed to do to preserve the habitability of the planet.”
The world's wealthiest nations have only funded 8% of the UN's combined humanitarian appeals, and the UN humanitarian appeal for the Horn of Africa is only 2% funded ($93 million against a $4.5 billion need), despite this being remediable with available resources.
“the world's wealthiest nations have not seen fit to do more than fund 8% of the UN's combined humanitarian appeals. You know, the UN humanitarian appeal for the Horn of Africa is 2% funded, 93 million against a need of four and a half billion.”
Putin was providing the West with a Goldilocks crisis by invading Ukraine, inadvertently creating an opportunity for institutional reform that he did not realize he was giving.
“funny thing is Putin didn't realize that what he was giving the West by invading Ukraine was a Goldilocks crisis.”
Europe emerged from COVID stronger as a supranational entity, consolidating vaccine acquisition at the EU level and implementing wealth redistribution from wealthy to poorer member states, reversing austerity politics from the 2009-2010 Eurozone crisis.
“Europe comes out of COVID stronger as an entity than it went in, both because they took on vaccine acquisition and distribution at an EU-wide level... And most importantly, redistribution of wealth from wealthy European countries to poorer European countries. It's something that they wouldn't have conceived of doing during the global financial crisis or 2009, 2010, with the Eurozone crisis.”
This is the first time Russia, a G20 country, has been forcibly decoupled from the world or from the advanced industrial democracies, representing an unprecedented break in post-Cold War order.
“there is an enormous concern that not only is globalization unwinding a bit, but also that the Russians, a G20 country, first time we've ever forcibly decoupled a G20 economy from the world, or from at least the advanced industrial democracies, which are, you know, sort of dominating the stage here.”
The West's ability to detect cyberattacks is three years ahead of its ability to detect disinformation attacks, representing an asymmetric vulnerability in information warfare.
“I think we're on a path to start to develop that capability, but we're just three years behind... we're three years behind where we are with respect to other forms of cyberattacks.”
A fundamental question emerging in Ukraine food insecurity is whether the world should agree to allow limited military operations to open Black Sea ports, enabling grain exports to resume and feed millions of starving people.
“Does anyone think, do either of them think, does the rest of the world think that there should be an opportunity to have a limited war that opens a port so that food can leave to feed the world?”
Russia's failure to employ more forceful cyber and disinformation capabilities in Ukraine may indicate a strategic choice to escalate carefully rather than demonstrate full capabilities, with intelligence communities debating why restraint is being exercised.
“why has Russia not come in more forceful than they have in Ukraine? Everyone loves the tale that it's because they don't have the capacity and all those things. And that might be true, but they are better than they're showing now, in cyberattacks, for example. And I think the whole intelligence community are debating, why have they not done that?”
In the Ukraine conflict, defense has proven stronger than offense in almost every category, particularly in cyberspace, due to innovation in cybersecurity and collaboration over the past five years since the NotPetya attack.
“so far in this war, defense has proven to be stronger in offense, frankly, in almost every category, but especially when it comes to cyberspace. And it's, I think, a real testament to the amount of innovation in cybersecurity protection, collaboration, over the last five years, really since the NotPetya attack on Ukraine.”
If Putin had invaded only the Donbass rather than attempting to take all of Ukraine and remove Zelensky, the international response would have been vastly weaker and more divided, and he likely would have succeeded as he had with Crimea in 2014 and Georgia in 2008.
“if he had just done that and not gone into Kyiv and not sent 190,000 troops in to try to remove Zelensky or kill him, that the international response would've been vastly weaker, would've been much more divided. He wouldn't have been an international pariah... he could have gotten, much more likely he would've gotten away with it, the way he got away with Crimea in southeast Ukraine in 2014, the way he got away with Georgia in 2008.”
We are at a milestone of 100 million forcibly displaced people globally, a humanitarian crisis that was not anticipated by international institutions and reveals the compounding nature of current crises (COVID, climate, conflict).
“We're seeing now a milestone reached in forced displacement. I don't think any of us thought we would be here, a hundred million people now forcibly displaced in the world.”
The nuclear non-proliferation regime has successfully managed high-risk technology distribution over 80 years, providing a model for managing emerging technologies like AI and cyber capabilities that only certain actors should possess.
“We've done that in the past with the Nuclear Club and nuclear non-proliferation, and over 80 years, we've done a reasonable job.”
Solving food insecurity requires addressing underlying fundamentals of food systems, climate systems, and economic systems, not just acute humanitarian needs, and requires international cooperation on export controls rather than nationalist border closure.
“we have to look at the underlying fundamentals of this crisis as well, beyond the most immediate and acute needs, how we address food security writ large. So that requires the kind of cooperation we're talking about because it's food systems, it's climate systems, it's economic systems. It's dealing with things like, you know, export controls. It's a very tempting thing to want to, you know, fall back within your own borders and preserve, but it's the worst possible thing you could do at a moment like this.”
European governments have stepped up their capacity in NATO and EU frameworks to respond to cyberattacks, but no one believes this can be done without the tech sector.
“we need to work together in the EU. We need to work together in NATO to do that. And both organizations have actually stepped up what they're going to do about cyberattacks, but no one thinks we can do it without the tech sector.”
The UN Foundation estimates that 276 million people are currently food insecure globally, up from 140 million at the end of 2021, with nearly 50 million on the brink of famine.
“By the end of last year, we were at over 140 million food insecure. We're now at 276 by UN estimates. So, that's just an extraordinary number of people in very dire circumstances, nearly 50 million of those are on the brink of famine.”
President Zelensky's virtual speech at Davos received a standing ovation from all attendees except the Chinese delegation, signaling unified Western support for Ukraine but highlighting China's distinct positioning.
“President Zelensky just beamed in with his virtual speech. First time I've seen a virtual speech in Davos that literally got a standing ovation, except for the Chinese delegation that was attending.”
The latest IPCC reports indicate that the climate window for action is closing rapidly; a window still exists to prevent catastrophic warming, but the timeframe is much smaller than previously indicated.
“The latest IPCC reports...say, there's still a window, but the window is getting much smaller.”
Small crises affecting countries that elites don't prioritize result in no institutional change, while massive crises that exceed available tools result in paralysis; only Goldilocks crises of intermediate severity trigger genuine institutional reform.
“if they're a really small crisis that affect people or countries that you don't care enough about, then you're not gonna change the way you behave. If it's a massive crisis that you legitimately don't have tools to fix, even though you want to, then you're gonna curl up in a ball in the corner and it's all over. So, you need a Goldilocks crisis.”
Ian Bremmer considers misuse of AI the most existentially worrying cyber threat, though he understands why the public focuses on disinformation—people experience disinformation daily and feel anxious about it, whereas cyberattacks feel abstract despite high costs.
“I mean, timeframe matters. I'd probably say misuse of AI is the thing that worries me in the most existential way, but the reason I'm not surprised that disinformation is what people responded with is because disinformation is what people engage with on a daily basis. They feel it, they see it, it makes them anxious, it unnerves them, and they have no idea how to respond to it.”
The fact that poll respondents do not all say "no significant change" indicates that public engagement with global crises has increased; people recognize that major forces have been set in motion and can no longer assume the status quo.
“No significant change. We've gotten beyond the point of sort of ennui and indifference. And I think that is itself important, you know? And I think a lot of people recognize that, whether you're looking at the United States domestically...or whether you're looking at the Russian invasion of Ukraine...that too much has been set in motion to say, "We can forget about it. We can go on and keep on getting on."”
Poll respondents do not want nationalist responses to crises; rather, they anticipate nationalism, suggesting they understand the risks even as they pessimistically expect governments to pursue isolationist policies.
“Ian, I don't think your followers, they don't want the nationalist responses. They just anticipate it. So, I think what they're saying is that they are listening to you and they see what's at stake.”
Young people globally show determination, strategy, and seriousness of purpose about trying to do better than the current generation, representing a source of hope for addressing compounding crises.
“I see so much determination, so much strategy, so much seriousness of purpose about, frankly, trying to do a better job than we all did.”
A GZERO Media poll of social media followers shows that 42% consider disinformation the biggest cyber threat, followed by cyber warfare (not specified percentage), misuse of AI, and malware (least concern).
“Which of these cyber threats worries you most? The choices were malware, disinformation, misuse of AI, cyber warfare. Here's how people answered. 42% said disinformation was their biggest concern. Followed by cyber warfare, misuse of AI, and malware.”
The 2022 Davos gathering is the most geopolitically driven World Economic Forum on record, driven by the convergence of pandemic aftermath, the Ukraine war, climate change, and rapid digital transformation.
“This is the single Davos that's been most driven by geopolitics that I've ever attended. It is a crisis rich environment.”
A GZERO Media poll shows that 76% of respondents believe cybersecurity leadership should involve both technology companies and governments working together, compared to 15% for governments alone and 9% for tech companies alone.
“who should lead cybersecurity efforts globally? The choices were technology companies, governments, both together... technology companies, 9%... Governments, 15%... Both together, coalitions... 76%.”