
Stoicism as a philosophy for an ordinary life | Massimo Pigliucci | TEDxAthens
What this covers
This is a 19-minute TEDxAthens talk by philosopher Massimo Pigliucci, who presents Stoicism as a practical philosophy for ordinary life. He places it in the Greco-Roman world and sketches its afterlife: it declined with the rise of Christianity but left traces in Paul of Tarsus, Thomas Aquinas, Descartes, and Spinoza, whose ethics he says rest mostly on Stoic ideas. Most of the talk's authority comes from Epictetus, whose blunt, sarcastic aphorisms Pigliucci uses throughout, including the one contrasting death, which we cannot control, with lunch, which we can.
Two pillars structure the argument. The first is the Four Cardinal Virtues: practical wisdom, courage, justice, and temperance. The second is the Dichotomy of Control. Pigliucci admits it sounds counterintuitive, since we assume we control our bodies, property, and reputations, and he argues that we only control our choices, never the outcomes. He tests it on a job promotion, on being loved by another person, and on an archery image in which everything becomes uncontrollable once the arrow is released. One contested claim is that taking the dichotomy seriously would end blame and make for a markedly better world.
The later part turns to Role Ethics, drawing on Brian Johnson of Fordham. Pigliucci distinguishes the universal role of human being, the roles circumstances give us, and the roles we choose, and he uses the theater-mask image to say that a good life means playing each role with integrity. The test of "is this good for humanity?" outranks the other roles. Epictetus's example of a father who abandons his sick daughter to escape his distress shows how duty differs from feeling. For models, he offers Cato the Younger, Nelson Mandela's encounter with the Meditations, Susan Fowler's stand against Uber, and, more lightheartedly, Spider-Man.
Stoicism is an ancient philosophy based on living according to human nature (reason and social cooperation) through four cardinal virtues and the dichotomy of control, which teaches that happiness comes from focusing effort on what is within your control while accepting what is not, and from playing life's various roles with integrity.
- Stoic philosophy rests on the premise that human nature consists of being highly social animals and rational creatures, and the best life applies reason to improve social living
- The dichotomy of control—distinguishing between what is up to us (opinions, efforts, intentions) and what is not (outcomes, bodily events, external circumstances)—is the practical tool for achieving serenity and happiness
- Happiness emerges from internalizing goals about effort and intention rather than outcomes, and from playing diverse life roles (human being, family member, professional) with integrity and balance
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Epictetus illustrates role ethics through the example of a distressed father whose daughter is sick and who abandons her to escape the emotional pain, teaching that while feelings (being distraught) are natural and not controllable, the ethical duty to stay with one's daughter is separate from those feelings and requires the virtue of courage (to endure emotional cost) and justice (to do right by one's child)
“Epictetus talks about a father who is very distraught because his daughter is sick, and he just can't take it. He leaves the house, and leaves his wife to deal with the daughter. And Epictetus says, "Wait a minute. Do you think you were right to have acted that way?" The father thinks about it for a minute and says, "Well, I was behaving naturally. I was, you know, distraught. I couldn't help it." Well, that brings up the distinction [13:41] between what is natural to us, our feelings - You don't control your feelings. If you're distraught because your daughter is sick, there's nothing you can do or should do, probably, about it. But that's different from the ethical duty that you have toward your daughter: you are her father. You 're supposed to stay there even though it does cost you in terms of emotional energy. So the two virtues that come into play here are courage, to actually do the right thing, to stay with the daughter, and justice, that is, do the just thing, the correct thing, for your daughter.”
In role ethics, there are trade-offs between different roles (being a good parent, spouse, sibling, colleague, friend), and Stoicism teaches how to balance these competing demands rather than aiming for perfection in all of them simultaneously
“These roles come with trade-offs. Yes, you want to be the best mother or father and son or daughter and colleague and friend and so on and so forth, but there are trade-offs, and a lot of what Stoic philosophy tells you about, or teaches you about, is how to balance these things.”
Epictetus taught through memorable aphorisms using blunt and sarcastic humor, such as the teaching about death and lunch: acknowledging that death is not under one's control so one should not worry about it, but lunch is under one's control so that is where effort should be directed
“The reason I like Epictetus is because he's blunt and he has a sarcastic sense of humor. And I'll give you a taste of this in a second. Here's what he says in "The Discourses": "I'll have to die. If it is now, well, then I die now. If later, then now I will take my lunch, [6:48] since the hour for lunch has arrived, and dying, I will tend to later." Don't worry about death; worry about lunch. (Laughter) You know you're going to die; that isn't under your control. Lunch, on the other hand, is under your control.”
Applying the dichotomy of control to job promotion: the outcome (getting the promotion) is outside one's control because of factors like the boss's mood or other candidates' merits, but one should focus effort on what is controllable—thorough interview preparation, strong resume, and deserving the promotion through hard work
“Let's say you're up for a promotion for your job. Now, the normal thing to do would be to worry about whether you're going to get the promotion or not. According to the Stoics, that's the wrong way to look at it: the promotion itself is outside of your control. Your boss may have gotten up on the wrong side of the bed, [9:27] he's upset, he's got something else on his mind, and the interview is not going to go well. Or maybe somebody else deserves the promotion better than you do even though you did well, and again, that's not up to you. What is up to you, of course, is to prepare the best you can for your interview, to put together the best resume possible, to work really hard to actually, in fact, deserve that promotion. That's the locus of your control; that's where you should focus your efforts.”
Applying the dichotomy of control to relationships: being loved by someone is not under one's control (depends on the other person), but what is under one's control is being the most lovable person—being affectionate and present—and one should not worry about whether they decide to stay with you
“Or think in terms of relationships. You know, everybody wants to be loved. But that's not up to us. It's up to the person who may or may not love us. [10:00] What's up to us is to be the most lovable person, to be affectionate, to be there for them. Whether they decide to stick with us or not - not under our control. So if you take this seriously, Epictetus says, you will, in fact, have a happy life because a great part of happiness lies in the serenity, into the idea that you always walk through life by knowing that you've done your best and that nothing else could be done on top of that.”
One way the Stoics recommended learning to play roles well is to identify and observe role models—people who do well in their roles—and use them as patterns to change one's own life; the ancients used historical figures (Cato the Younger, Odysseus), people they knew, or imaginary figures
“Now, how do we learn to play well our roles in life? [15:21] There's many ways - the Stoics were famous for a number of exercises, practical exercises, about these things - but fundamentally, one of the best ways to go is to simply imagine people that actually do well, people that are your role models, people that you can see and use as a pattern after which you change your own life. The ancients used people that they knew, people that they heard about or even imaginary people.”
The dichotomy of control seems counterintuitive because we believe we control our body, property, and reputation through our choices, but in reality we can make decisions affecting health (going to gym, eating well) and reputation without controlling the outcome, because external forces (viruses, accidents, others' judgments) determine the actual result
“And note, if you stop for a second and think about it, it's like that is weird. He's saying that my body, my property, my reputation are not in [my] power? What do you mean? I can decide to go to the gym and eat healthy; of course my body's under my power. Unless a virus strikes you down. Unless you have an accident and you break your leg. The idea is that you can do things, [7:50] you can make decisions about your health, your reputation, etcetera, etcetera, but ultimately, you don't control the outcome. So what does that mean in practice? It means that we should try to walk through life by internalizing our goals, not worry about the outcomes, because those are outside of our control, but worry about our intentions and our efforts because those are very much under our control.”
According to Epictetus, like actors in ancient Greek theater who wore different masks for different characters and were reminded by the masks of their current role, humans wear multiple roles throughout life and change them continuously, and a happy life is one in which one plays all these roles as the best actor possible, with integrity and balance
“So the general idea, according to Epictetus, is that just like actors in the ancient world, [17:58] in ancient Greece, we wear a number of masks, and we change them continuously. The same actor would come out on stage and wear a different mask, and the mask will tell the audience which character he was playing in the moment, and it would remind the actor himself that he was now playing a different character. And the idea is that a happy life is, in fact, a life well-balanced, where you play all these roles as the best actor you can possibly be.”
Susan Fowler is a modern role model for Stoicism: a couple of years ago she stood up to Uber to denounce their widespread sexual harassment culture despite significant personal risks to her career and friendships, acting from a Stoic perspective with awareness that she was doing what is right regardless of the controllable outcomes
“Another one of my favorite role models is Susan Fowler, who a couple of years ago came out and stood up to the Uber motor company to denounce their sexual harassment culture that was quite widespread at the time. She risked a lot personally, in terms of career, in terms of friendships, and she did it from a Stoic perspective. [17:25] I happen to know Susan, and she is, in fact, a practicing Stoic.”
The archery metaphor illustrates the dichotomy of control: what is under one's control includes practice, choosing good equipment, caring for equipment, and focusing until releasing the arrow, but after release everything becomes outside one's control (wind, target movement), so the hitting of the mark should be chosen but not desired—one should not attach self-esteem to the outcome but only to the quality of one's attempt
“One of the beautiful metaphors that the Stoics introduced was that of an archer. Imagine that you are trying to hit a target. What is under your control? Well, the practice of archery - you can practice for hours and hours. [8:24] You can choose the best bows and arrows that are available to you. You can take care of those bows and arrows. You can focus up until the second in which you let the arrow go. But after that, things are completely outside of your control. A gust of wind can ruin your best shot. The target may move, especially if he's an enemy soldier, and you missed. So what do you do? According to Cicero, the actual hitting of the mark would be to be chosen but not to be desired. So you do not attach your own self-esteem to the outcome; [8:56] you only attach it to what is under your control, to your attempt.”
Role ethics, as explained by Brian Johnson at Fordham University, is an approach where one achieves a happy life by balancing multiple life roles well; there are three fundamental types of roles: the basic universal role as a human being (member of the human polis), roles given by circumstances (family relationships), and roles one chooses (career, parenthood)
“Now, my colleague Brian Johnson at Fordham University explained Epictetus' approach as a type of role ethics. The idea is that we all play a variety of roles in life [11:05] and that a happy life consists in balancing these roles as best as we can. There are, in fact, fundamentally, three kinds of roles. First, our basic role as a human being - we're all members of the human polis. The Stoics were the ones that introduced the term "cosmopolitan," literally meaning "a citizen of the universal polis." We're all human beings, we're all in the same place, and we have to take care of the same place. Then there are roles that are given to us by circumstances. You could be, you know, somebody's son or daughter. [11:37] That wasn't your choice; it just happened. And then there are roles that we choose depending on the circumstances: our career, being a mother or a father - things like that.”
The fundamental premise of Stoicism is that we should live our life according to nature, which the Stoics understood not as living in the forest but as living according to human nature, which consists of two essential aspects: being highly social animals who thrive in groups, and being capable of reason
“Well, the first thing is it's based on a crucial premise [3:37] that we should live our life according to nature. Now, before you go and run into the forest naked to hug trees - that's not what it is about. The Stoics thought that we should take seriously human nature. And human nature fundamentally consists of two things, two aspects. One, we're highly social animals. We can survive on our own if we have to, but we only thrive in groups of people, we only thrive when we have healthy social networks. And two, we're capable of reason.”
For the Stoics, it follows logically from human nature that the best kind of human life is one in which a person applies reason and intelligence to improve social living and to improve everybody else's life
“For the Stoics, it followed that the best kind of human life you can actually have is one in which you apply your reason, your intelligence, to improve social living, to improve everybody else's life.”
In role ethics, one's basic universal role as a human being takes precedence over all other roles (family roles, professional roles), and the fundamental test for any action is to ask 'Is this good for humanity?' If the answer is no, don't do it, which paradoxically leads to doing less but also saves energy
“These three sets of roles are related in the following way: your basic role as a human being trumps everything else. Everything you do, you should ask yourself first, Is this good for humanity? If it isn't, don't do it. It's a simple test. You will end up doing much less, by the way, if you follow this, [12:07] as we saved you energy. And then the rest, you simply balance things out.”
The four cardinal virtues are the first fundamental pillar of Stoic philosophy: practical wisdom (knowledge of what is good and bad for you), courage (especially moral courage to do the right thing), justice (knowing how to interact with others and treat them rightly), and temperance (doing things in right measure—neither excess nor deficiency)
“There are two fundamental pillars of Stoic philosophy, which we will see, in a minute, applied very practically to our life. One is the four cardinal virtues: practical wisdom, courage, justice and temperance. [4:40] Practical wisdom is the knowledge of what is good for you and what is not good for you. Courage is not just physical but especially moral: the courage to stand up and do the right thing. Justice is what tells you what the right thing is, how to interact with other people, how to treat other people. And temperance is the idea that you should always do things in right measure - not overdo them nor underdo them.”
The dichotomy of control is the second fundamental pillar of Stoic philosophy: the basic idea that some things are up to us and other things are not up to us, and one should focus worry and effort only on what is up to you
“The second pillar is called "dichotomy of control." This is the very basic idea that some things are up to us and other things are not up to us. [5:13] Now, you can divide everything you do into these two categories and only worry about the first one and not the second one.”
Cato the Younger was such a famous ancient role model for Stoic virtue that Romans would excuse their own failures by saying 'Not everybody can be a Cato,' using him as a standard of integrity that people could aspire to emulate
“One of their favorite role models was Cato the Younger. I mentioned him earlier; he was the father of Porcia Catonis. He had such a level of integrity [15:53] that when people in Rome did something wrong - they made a mistake, they didn't hold up to expectations - they would say, "Well, not everybody can be a Cato." He was used as an excuse. It was like, "Not everybody can be that good." Well, right, but you can try.”
The way one plays life roles should be characterized by integrity; Epictetus says we each know our own worth and should not sell ourselves cheaply—the goal is not to achieve perfection but to be better than yesterday, improving one small step at a time, because once one has sold oneself there is nothing left to sell
“How do you play these roles? Well, the most important thing is you play them with integrity. What does that mean? Well, Epictetus again explains: "You are the one that knows yourself, of how much you're worth to yourself [12:39] and for how much you're selling yourself. Consider at what price you sell your integrity, but please, for God's sake, don't sell it cheap." What that means is that the goal here is not to reach perfection, whatever that means; it's just to be the best you can. Don't compromise and sell yourself cheap, because you only have yourself to sell. That's it - once you've sold yourself, then there's nothing else left. The idea is to be not perfect but just better than you were yesterday, [13:09] one little step at a time.”
Nelson Mandela is a modern role model for Stoicism: he spent more than 20 years in prison fighting apartheid, was very angry during that period, but a turning point came when a fellow inmate smuggled him a copy of Marcus Aurelius's Meditations, after which he understood the path forward lay not in anger or hatred but in extending reconciliation even to his captors and tormentors, and this approach changed his life and the life of South Africa
“Some of my favorites are Nelson Mandela, who, as we know, spent more than 20 years in prison fighting the apartheid regime. He was very angry, understandably, during that period. But one of the changing points in his life was when one of his fellow inmates smuggled in a copy of Marcus Aurelius' "Meditations." Mandela read it and understood that the way forward was not through anger or hatred, but on the contrary, by extending a hand [16:54] also to the people, even to the people who were his captors and his tormentors. And that changed his life and changed the life of the people in South Africa.”
According to Epictetus, if one takes seriously the dichotomy of control (understanding what belongs to you and what does not), one will never be subject to force or hindrance, will never blame others for circumstances, and will do everything willingly—and this would create a significantly better world than one where people blame others for things outside their control
“He says, "If you have the right idea about what really belongs to you [10:33] and what does not" - in other words, what you do control and what you don't control - "you will never be subject to force or hindrance, you will never blame or criticize anyone, and everything you do will be done willingly." And this would be a significantly better world than the one in which everybody goes around blaming other people for what they don't have control over.”
To manage multiple life roles well, one must use practical wisdom (understanding what is good for you) and temperance (balancing different activities by putting the right amount of energy into each), as Epictetus illustrates by encouraging reflection on what each role entails (e.g., what it means to be young, old, a father) and then playing the role as you think is right while respecting the duties inherent in it
“We also have to, as I said before, balance different social roles. And this has to do with two other virtues: the practical wisdom, the idea of knowing the difference between what's good for you and what's not good for you, and temperance, the idea that you can balance things by putting the right amount of energy into everything you do. Epictetus explains it this way: "Reflect on the other social roles you play. If you're young, what does it mean to be young? If you're old, what does age imply? If you're a father, what does father entail? Each of our titles suggest the acts appropriate to it. [14:50] Imagine you are an actor, you play a role. Now, the role is not completely determined. You can play the role of a mother, for instance, in many ways. You don't have to play in the way in which society largely tells you to play. You just have to play in the way you think it's the right way to play it. But still you're a mother or a father, so you have certain duties. The way you cash out these duties, the way you actually exercise those duties, is up to you. But you do have them.”
According to Epictetus, what is within one's power includes opinion, motivation, and desire—essentially whatever is of one's own doing—while what is not within one's power includes one's body, property, and reputation—essentially whatever is not of one's own doing
“Here's how Epictetus himself explains it. He says, "Some things are within our power, while others are not. Within our power are opinion, motivation, desire, [7:19] and in a word, whatever is of our own doing. Not within our power are our body, our property, reputation, and in a word, whatever is not of our own doing."”
Stoicism eventually declined with the rise of Christianity but influenced Christian thinkers including Paul of Tarsus (arguably the founder of Christianity), Thomas Aquinas (most influential medieval theologian), René Descartes (important modern philosopher), and Baruch Spinoza (whose ethics were based mostly on Stoicism)
“Now, Stoicism, like all ancient schools of philosophy, eventually died down or was closed with the rise of Christianity, but it kept influencing people throughout the following two millennia. The reason many people today are familiar with some of the Stoic ideas is because they influenced Christianity, [3:06] beginning with Paul of Tarsus, arguably the founder of Christianity, and continuing with Thomas Aquinas, the most influential theologian of the Middle Ages, and then into more modern times with René Descartes, arguably one of the most important modern philosophers, and Baruch Spinoza, whose ethics was, in fact, based mostly on Stoicism.”
Spider-Man exemplifies Stoic virtue through the principle 'with great power comes great responsibility'—while people are not superheroes, everyone has the power of exercising choices, and this power comes with the responsibility of exercising the best choice possible
“My favorite role model at a fictional level is Spider-man, who famously said that with great powers come great responsibility. Well, we don't have great powers - we're not superheroes - but we do have power. We have the power of exercising choices, and that power comes with the responsibility of exercising the best choice we can possibly make.”
Stoicism was unusual among ancient philosophies in attracting a significant number of women, including Roman matrons who organized convivia (social gatherings) to discuss Stoicism and lived according to its principles
“Now, unusual for ancient philosophy, Stoicism attracted a number of women. A lot of Roman matrons used to organize convivia, which were sort of get-togethers with their friends, to talk about Stoicism. But many of them also lived the philosophy.”
In ancient Athens, philosophers walked the streets and were casually encountered by ordinary people, unlike other philosophical schools such as Plato's Academy or Aristotle's Lyceum which required going to specific physical locations
“Because that was Athens at the time: philosophers were just walking by.”
Stoicism became one of the major philosophies of antiquity, spreading through the Hellenistic world, then to the Roman Republic and Roman Empire, producing major thinkers like Seneca (senator and playwright who influenced Shakespeare) and Marcus Aurelius (a king-philosopher who wrote the Meditations)
“Stoicism became one of the major philosophies of antiquity. It spread through the Hellenistic world first and then to the Roman Republic and then Roman Empire. It produced some of the major thinkers of the time. Seneca, who was a senator, a playwright - he influenced Shakespeare - and the unfortunate advisor to the Emperor Nero. That didn't end up well for Seneca. Marcus Aurelius, one of the few king-philosophers of all of history, [2:05] who wrote "The Meditations," his own personal diary, which is now read by millions of people around the world.”
Zeno of Citium was a Phoenician merchant whose shipwreck destroyed his possessions, after which he moved to Athens and began reading philosophy, particularly Xenophon's Memorabilia about Socrates, which inspired him to seek out philosophers
“Zeno of Citium. He was a merchant, a Phoenician merchant. He was doing very well until a shipwreck destroyed everything [0:30] and he lost everything he had. So he made it to Athens, and what did he do? One of the first things he did was to walk into a bookshop and started reading books. He read Xenophon's "Memorabilia," which is a book about Socrates.”
Crates was a Cynic philosopher who happened to be walking by in Athens and became Zeno's first teacher after Zeno asked a bookseller where to find a philosopher
“The guy walking by was Crates, a Cynic philosopher. And Zeno became his student, eventually went on to study with a number of other of the major philosophers in Athens.”
Porcia Catonis was a famous example of a woman who lived Stoicism; she was the daughter of Cato the Younger (archenemy of Julius Caesar) and wife of Brutus (co-conspirator against Caesar), facing significant life challenges which she approached in a Stoic manner
“One of them, the most famous one, was Porcia Catonis, who happened to be both the daughter of Cato the Younger, [2:35] who was an archenemy of Julius Caesar, as well as the wife of Brutus, one of the co-conspirators against Caesar. So she had a lot to deal with in her life, and she approached it in a Stoic fashion.”
Epictetus was one of the most important Stoic philosophers of antiquity; he was born a slave (whose name 'Epictetus' means 'acquired') in Hierapolis, brought to Rome where he eventually was freed, began preaching Stoicism, was exiled by Emperor Domitian, then established a famous school in Nicopolis in northwestern Greece
“Let me introduce you to Epictetus. He was one of the most important Stoic philosophers of antiquity. He was a slave. He was born in Hierapolis, in modern-day Pamukkale, in Turkey. [5:44] He was acquired - in fact, his name means "acquired." We don't know his real name; Epictetus just means acquired. And [he was] brought to Rome to the court of the Emperor Nero, where he did pretty well. Eventually, he was freed. He was, you know, a bright guy, so he started going through the streets of Rome preaching Stoicism. And for his troubles, he got punched on the nose. So he figured that wasn't a good approach. It was in his power to change the approach, so he started over, and he established his own school, which was very successful [6:15] until the Emperor Domitian kicked out all the Stoics out of Rome because he did not appreciate their "speaking truth to power," as we would say today. So Epictetus moved and went to Nicopolis, in northwestern Greece, reestablished his school and became one of the most famous teachers of antiquity.”
Odysseus is another ancient role model in the Stoic tradition: he gave up immortality twice and endured 10 years of travel to return home to his wife and child, exemplifying commitment to family duty and perseverance through adversity
“One of the favorite ancient role models was Odysseus, who gave up immortality twice and endured 10 years of traveling just to get back home, to get back to his wife and to his child.”