
'The Whole System is One Big Carry Trade' | Brent Johnson
What this covers
This is a one-hour conversation between Julia La Roche and Brent Johnson, founder of Santiago Capital, who is the only guest. It opens on the Fed and whether a soft landing can be engineered. Johnson credits Jerome Powell's Fed with handling the post-COVID inflation shock better than predicted, taking rates from zero to 5.5% without a collapse. He then argues that cutting into a strong economy, with low unemployment, record equity prices and solid earnings, risks re-accelerating inflation. He also notes that equity sell-offs have often followed the first cut, since cuts come when the economy is already slowing.
The middle of the episode is a walk through the Dollar Milkshake Theory. Johnson describes every central bank adding liquidity while the US, as reserve-currency issuer, pulls it into its own markets. He grounds this in the eurodollar market: the rest of the world owes dollar debt to itself on a scale comparable to the US national debt, so a rising dollar creates deflationary pressure abroad. He reads 2022's dollar peak as coinciding with crises in China, Italy, the UK and Japan. He also says the theory describes a bad outcome, not a good one, and that gold and the dollar rising together signals systemic stress. Gold gets its own treatment, as a buy-and-hold asset that cannot be inflated away, though he concedes it falls alongside other assets when carry trades unwind.
The final third turns to the carry trade. Johnson defines it, shows how leverage makes it attractive, and traces the Yen carry trade through repeated blowups in 2000, 2008, 2020 and 2024. His closing claim is that the whole dollar system is one large carry trade. Along the way he argues for holding 20–30% in cash or T-bills for optionality, and the discussion touches on the 2024 election and protectionism across both parties.
Johnson argues that markets are currently priced to perfection with gold as the key contrarian signal, the next three months will see extreme volatility, and the dollar milkshake theory—where the US dollar and hard assets rise together in a crisis—represents the endgame of the global carry trade system.
- Gold's rise despite equity and labor market strength signals underlying systemic stress that markets are ignoring
- The eurodollar system creates a global carry trade dependency where dollar strength triggers cascading crises in other economies
- Central banks globally are structurally trapped in a debt-management cycle that can only end in either perpetual monetary easing or a sovereign debt crisis
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Historically, equity market sell-offs have often occurred after the first Federal Reserve rate cut, not before, because the reason the Fed cuts rates is that the economy is slowing and crisis conditions are developing, not improving
“typically you will see that after the first cut equities have historically or when equities have sold off it has often been after the first cut and the reason for this is is because the reason that the FED would be cutting is the economy is slowing right now”
The rest of the world collectively owes approximately as much in US dollar debt to each other as the United States owes in national debt (roughly $35-36 trillion), with borrowing concentrated in dollars because the dollar is the global reserve currency
“the whole world borrows in dollars it's not just the United States so a lot of people know that the United States owes like 35 36 trillion in the national debt now the heck of a lot of money you know not going to sit here and say that's not an issue what most people don't know is that the rest of the world owes about the same amount to each other in dollars”
Gold falls during carry trade unwinding crises alongside other risk assets despite being a 'hard asset', contradicting the narrative that hard assets provide protection against all fiat debasement scenarios
“those periods of time gold went down with everything else a lot of people say would just buy gold because Fiat doesn't matter well in when those crises hit gold went down as well”
Anyone advising a portfolio with zero cash allocation is providing poor advice; cash provides optionality and positioning flexibility
“if somebody tells you you can't have any cash in your portfolio don't listen to them run the other way”
Gold cannot be inflated away due to limited supply, high global demand, and historical use as money, making it the primary safe haven when fiat currencies come under attack or during inflationary environments
“one of the things you can't inflate away is gold there's a limited supply of it it's in wide you know it's it's in big demand it's been used as money throughout history and so many times when you get into an inflationary environment or even just a chaotic environment where fiat currency starts to come under attack gold is one of the go-to um you know places to do that”
The Yen has been near-zero rates for decades due to Japanese monetary policy attempting to combat deflation and low growth since the 1990s, enabling the Yen carry trade to grow so large
“the reason that the Yen carry trade got so big and has gotten so quote unquote famous is because they have had interest rates at zero or close to zero for decades right they have been running these uh you know extraordinary monetary policies since the 90s because they've been dealing with deflation and low growth for a long time and so that that's what allowed the Yen carry trade to grow so big”
As US interest rates rise or dollar supply becomes constrained, it becomes harder for the rest of the world to service dollar debt, take on new debt, and pay down principal when it comes due, creating deflationary pressure globally
“as us interest rates rise or as dollar supply becomes constrained it becomes harder for them to service that debt it becomes harder for them to to take on new debt it takes it it makes it harder to be pay off the principle when it comes due”
The Federal Reserve has done a pretty good job managing the post-COVID inflation shock, raising rates from zero to 5.5% and bringing inflation down dramatically without causing a complete economic collapse, despite earlier predictions that even one rate hike would cause severe recession
“when they have started to try to get inflation under control they have done a pretty good job of doing that they raised rates much more than anybody thought possible and they were able to do it without causing a complete collapse of the economy... if they did they would cause a severe recession but not only did they raise rates once they raised them many times they took it from you know zero to 5 and a half half percent and now they've start and since that time inflation has dropped tremendously”
A carry trade is fundamentally defined as borrowing cheaply in one place and investing proceeds in a higher-yielding location; the Yen carry trade example is borrowing at ~0% in yen and buying US Treasury bills paying 4-5%
“a carry trade actually is is when you borrow cheaply in one place and then you go invest those proceeds somewhere else that's paying a higher rate very simple example we'll use the Yen carry trade as an example... you borrow in Japanese Yen because interest rates are at zero and the Yen has been weakening so you cost you nothing to borrow it... you can do something as simple as borrowing and Yin and go buy t- bills so you're borrowing at something that costs nothing and you're buying t t bills that pay you four or 5%”
The Yen carry trade has blown up multiple times (2000, 2008, 2020, 2024) without being eliminated, demonstrating that carry trades repeatedly recur despite historical evidence of crashes
“the Yen carry trade has blown up several times it's not like it's been out there for 20 years and nothing bad ever happened it blew up in 2000 it blew up in 2008 it blew up in 2020 now it blew up again”
Leverage amplifies carry trade returns: borrowing at 0% in yen, buying T-bills at 4-5%, and leveraging 2-3x can produce 10-15% returns, making carry trades seductive and driving massive positioning
“it's a pretty easy trade right it's very seductive and then you can lever it up a couple times and all of a sudden you're making 10 or 15% right”
If the Fed cuts rates now when unemployment is near all-time lows, stock markets are at all-time highs, and earnings are strong, there is significant risk that inflation will re-accelerate because demand-side stimulus would be inappropriate in a strong economy
“if they cut now with unemployment near its all-time lows stock markets near its all-time highs you know earnings pretty strong wages not falling they risk having the inflation re accelerate that's number one”
A crisis develops not when dollar liquidity is scarce and the dollar is weak, but when the dollar rallies quickly versus foreign competitors, which signals a demand for dollars exceeds supply—this is when the carry trade unwinds catastrophically
“a crisis develops when there is no dollar liquidity a crisis develops when you can't access funding but if there's plenty of dollars in the world and as a result the dxy or the trade weighted dollar or the however you want to Def or the dollar versus its foreign competitors is falling that is the central banks remaining in control and the system the status quo continuing to function what causes problems is when the US dollar rallies quickly versus its for competitors”
The dollar has declined from a 30-year high over the past two years but remains at pre-COVID levels, and the trade-weighted dollar is still near all-time highs, meaning virtually every other currency has fallen in value relative to the dollar, not strengthened
“the dollar has come down quite a bit over the last two years but you have to remember it's coming down from a 30-year high it's still about the same level that it was kind of just preco and so you know if you look at the trade weighted dollar since the 1980s it's it's near its all-time high that means every other currency is falling versus the dollar”
Countries have a strong desire to dollarize and escape dependence on the dollar simultaneously, but this desire reflects their lack of control over money supply—they are exposed to US monetary policy whims and want sovereignty, but the eurodollar market has become so large and entrenched that escape is extremely difficult
“the countries that want to dollarize in many ways don't have control over their own money supply and they don't have control over their own funding and they are somewhat and in many cases very exposed to the whims of the United States and they don't like that most governments want to be in control that's the whole point of the government in the first place is to kind of control things but when they have to use a foreign currency that they can't print that they can't access on their own that they need to be kind of under the good graces of the United States to get that causes problems so the fact that this euro dollar market exists they don't really like it they would prefer to to you know have a currency that they can control um but because the euro dollar market has gotten so big and so entrenched it's very hard to get out from underneath it”
Gold should be part of a buy-and-hold long-term portfolio with no need for active monitoring since there are no earnings to track, no management team to evaluate, and minimal costs besides storage, making it fundamentally different from equities
“there's not much else to do there's no earnings that you have to follow to see whether earnings are growing or falling there's no management team you know there's no costs associated with it other than your storage fees so to me part of the reason I don't spend the time just hammering and talking about gold all the time is it's it's one once you buy it you're kind of done right”
A 20-30% cash or T-bill allocation is a smart portfolio positioning given current conditions, providing optionality to deploy capital at better prices if an adverse scenario develops, with the cost of opportunity loss in inflationary periods being outweighed by the advantage of being a distressed buyer in downturns
“I think having a 20 to 30% allocation and just in cash or t bills right now is a smart move and even if you lose against inflation over the next two or three months the reason it's worth it to have that is if we get some into some kind of an adverse scenario some kind of a downturn now you already have liquidity you're not seeking liquidity you're somebody who who can be a distressed buyer rather than being a distressed seller and if you're patient and you you wait and you you wait for that great opportunity and you put that money to work at a good price and then that whatever you bought does well you will more than make up for whatever amount of money you lost versus inflation”
Both countries are engaging in an implicit 'America First' or protectionist approach despite different political labels, because all countries are withdrawing and prioritizing domestic self-interest due to global debt levels and economic constraints
“we're again we're kind of in this place where countries are kind of withdrawing and they're they're trying to take care of themselves first right that's Trump's America first but even around the world you see the same thing and so and that's a political reality that I don't think that the other side meaning the Democrats can ignore and I think they're even you know of that mindset maybe not to the same extent As Trump but I think they're kind of of a similar mindset”
In 2022, when the US raised rates for inflation control, it simultaneously created a 30-year high in the dollar (August-September), which coincided with multiple sovereign crises: Chinese real estate collapse, ECB Italian bond crisis, Bank of England pound crisis, and Bank of Japan yen crisis—this is not mere coincidence
“when the dollar was really strong economies around the world were in crisis the Chinese real estate market bubble popped and has fallen tremendously since then that's due to deflationary pressure that's partly due to a strong dollar the ECB had to you know Institute a program to to buy Italian bonds and some periphery bonds because those yields were spiking the bank of England had to bail out their Sovereign market and the bank of Japan had to bail out their Sovereign market and their currency this it's not and this all happened in August and September of 2022 which coincided with a 30-year high in the dollar that is not mere coincidence”
The dollar milkshake theory posits that in a crisis or slow-growth scenario, all central banks print liquidity (creating a 'mix'), but the United States as global hegemon with reserve currency status has the 'straw' to suck up that liquidity into US markets, creating a self-reinforcing cycle of dollar strength and outperformance
“the whole world has the same technology of a printing press... the whole world will print or generate this liquidity mix right they will they will shoot this this liquidity out in into the global economy but for many reasons some of them deserve and some of them not deserve the fact that the United States is the global hgim and has the global Reserve currency they have a number of advantages that the rest of the world just does not have and as a result the US is the one that has the straw so all this liquidity gets mixed but the US has the straw and the US sucks up that liquidity”
The whole global financial system is essentially one massive carry trade: countries borrow dollars at the risk-free rate (US Treasury), invest in assets or consumption, and assume currencies and assets will rise, but when the carry unwinds (dollar rises), the entire structure breaks
“here's here's the kicker the whole world the whole system is essentially one big carry trade and what I mean by that is because the US is the global Reserve currency... by definition the risk-free rate should have the lowest yield... the US Treasury is the lowest yielding rate and that's what makes it the risk-free rate and that is why everybody not only because of the euro dollar market but it's also because of the rate while the whole world borrowed in dollars right so we have all of this investment around the world that's funded by Dollar debt that's why when the dollar goes up in value the whole world suffers because it's the carry trade unwinding”
The dollar milkshake theory is essentially explaining what happens when the largest carry trade in history (the global dollar funding system) unwinds: dollar strength, capital flight to hard assets, and widespread crisis
“so the dollar milkshake theory is essentially explaining what happens when the biggest carry trade in history which is on the US dollar unwinds does that make sense”
The fundamental difference between the US dollar and other currencies is demand-based: the whole world needs dollars for trade, investment, and funding (foreign demand), whereas other currencies are used primarily domestically, meaning in a crisis, demand for dollars rises relative to all other currencies
“it is what it is that is that is the that is the actual reality this is the main difference between the US dollar and all its other competitors it's a demand and my point is it's a demand story what the US has that the rest of the world doesn't is De is foreign demand for its local currency people in Japan don't need Brazilian and real right people in Turkey don't need Japanese Yen people in Norway don't need Turkish l but the whole world needs dollars”
The dollar milkshake theory doesn't describe a desirable outcome; gold and dollar strength rising together signals serious systemic problems, not success, because it indicates sovereign debt rejection and global crisis conditions
“a lot of like gold Rising is not necessarily A positive event for the world and for Humanity that's a sign that some things are seriously wrong right the Dollar Rising dramatically is the sign of the system not stopping functioning correctly in other words the system was not designed for the dollar to get dramatically stronger than the rest of the world if you think about it the dollar under I the entire global economy if the dollar is rising that would mean that most things are falling right if most things are falling that's not a good situation”
The popular narrative that 'just buy hard assets because fiat will be inflated away' is itself a carry trade: borrowing cheap fiat currency and investing in assets that will rise as fiat loses value
“there's been this I don't know this ground swell that all you have to do is go buy hard assets because fiat currency is going to get inflated away and the Commodities are going to rise in value as they print more money and it's just easy streak right that's kind of a carry trade borrowing something that's losing value or cheap and you invested in something that's going to go up in value”
Most gold demand over the past year has come from outside the United States, particularly from Asia, driven not by dollar devaluation but by people seeking alternatives to their own depreciating fiat currencies (such as the Chinese yuan) and domestic economic problems
“the interesting thing is that most of the demand is coming from not the United States it's coming from outside the United States and primarily it's coming from Asia and I don't think this is a dollar story this is a fiat currency of their locals their local fiat currency story The the people in China buying gold they're not buying it because J Powell is going to you know jack up the printer again they're they're buying because the Yuan that they use every day is a horrible currency”
The US controls the price of US dollars through US interest rates, and this power exists only because the rest of the world is addicted to the dollar for commerce, trade, and investment—countries hate this dependency but it remains the structural reality
“the the US controls the dollar the price of US Dollars and that's the US interest rate um if it wasn't for this euro dollar market outside that everybody owes each other and uses the for Commerce for trade for Investments for in the US would not have this power but the fact that the rest of the world is is uh addicted to the dollar for lack of a better way of saying it gives the US this power and countries hate it and many people hate it but it is what it is that is that is the that is the actual reality”
Johnson owns traditional assets—stocks, bonds, commodities, gold, and real estate—and uses the dollar milkshake framework to manage risk and volatility rather than to justify hiding from markets; the framework enables him to stay invested while being prepared for crises
“95% of my business I own traditional assets I own stocks I own bonds I own Commodities we own gold people own my clients own real estate... part of my job is not just trying to figure out how to make money but how to protect it and be ready for these rogue waves that come out of nowhere and part of doing that is understanding how the system works and so you know so far this framework has allowed me to remain invested in traditional assets but be prepared for volatility and not lose sleep”
Central banks globally use the playbook of trying to inflate away debt by holding interest rates low and creating negative real rates, with the implicit goal being to maintain 3-4% inflation rather than the stated 2% target, which slowly erodes debt without triggering political unrest as double-digit inflation would
“the typical Playbook is to try to inflate the debt away the way you do that is you hold interest rates low and you know the you get real rates negative and over time you know the inflation above the the borrowing rate and overtime the debt gets eaten away... if you can have you know um 3 to 4% inflation over a 10-year period annual inflation over 10 year Peri that eats away 30 to 40% of the debt”
This self-reinforcing cycle means that as the dollar gets stronger, the rest of the world enters crisis, prompting capital to seek safe havens (the dollar and gold), which causes even more dollar strength and gold strength, creating a vicious cycle
“liquidity is the lifeblood of an economy you always want liquidity the lack of liquidity is bad so if if if the US gets the liquidity that means it's coming from somewhere and if it's leaving someplace else the place that it's leaving is now going to suffer or is going to struggle more than the place that has the liquidity and so the the point has been is it becomes kind of a self-reinforcing cycle dollar strength begets more dollar strength uh because as the dollar gets stronger the rest of the world goes into crisis as they go into crisis people seek out a safe haven as they seek out a safe haven the dollar and gold is the two places they go”
Critics of the dollar milkshake theory point to dollar weakness over the past two years as disproving it, but this reflects a misunderstanding: periods of dollar weakness can occur when the US runs easier monetary policy than its peers or begins QE first, but this merely 'kicks the can down the road' because other economies will eventually follow with their own QE
“some people have said to me well the dollar has fallen over the last couple years doesn't that prove the theory wrong well I so I suppose you could say it proves the theory wrong and that we haven't had the crisis yet U and I'm the first to say I thought we would have already had a sovereign debt crisis and we have not um but the point I'd like to make is that you can have periods of dollar weakness if the if the US is running a weaker monetary policy than its peers for a short period of time or if the US is you know do does starts QE before the rest of the world you could have a period of I don't know a couple months or a couple years where the Falls versus its competitors but if that happens then the those other economies as their currencies rise they will start to struggle with deflationary pressures and they will eventually have to do QE as well and so all this all all dollar weakness does is Kick the Can down the road”
There is nothing the rest of the world can do to send the dollar lower if the US doesn't want it to go lower; if the US desired, it could easily take the dollar index back to 105-110 by signaling no more rate cuts for a year
“there is nothing the rest of the world can do to send the dollar lower if the US does not want it to go lower so the fact that the dollar has been falling over the last couple years that's because the FED is getting what they want that is not the result of some other country doing something and that the in other words if the US wanted to take the dollar the dollar Index back to 105 or 110 it would be very easy to do so all they have to do is say you knowbe they cut once on Wednesday and then they say you know what we're done we're not cutting for the next year the dollar Index would rally like crazy”
Three out of four possible economic scenarios favor being primarily invested in the US: no crisis with everyone growing, global crisis where everything falls (US no worse off), or rest of world declining while US stays okay; only the scenario of rest of world doing well while US does poorly is unfavorable, and Johnson considers this low probability
“there's there's kind of four things that can happen as far as the global economy one is that we don't have a crisis and everybody grows together and everything's fine in that case being invested in the United States works just fine for me or being invested primarily in the United States works just fine for me we could have a situation where the whole world goes down together some kind of a crisis and all assets fall all over the world in which case I'm no worse off being primarily invested in the United States versus the rest of the world a third thing that could happen is that the rest of the world could do really well and the us could do really poorly um I think that's a very very very low probability event but I can't completely rule it out but that's it is possible and the last thing that could happen is that the rest of the world could do poorly but the United States could do okay um so three out of those four things I'm better off being in the United States”
In a sovereign debt crisis where the world rejects government bonds, capital is most likely to flow to gold and US equities rather than other sovereign bonds, driving a simultaneous rise in interest rates, the dollar, US equities, and gold
“a sovereign debt crisis is when the world decides they are no longer going to fund governments now that's not just when they decide to no longer fund the United States it's when they no longer fund Italy and France and Australia and Japan and China so when when Sovereign bonds get rejected where does that Capital flow to I think the most likely place for Capital to flow if they start rejecting Sovereign bonds is gold and US equities and so that's why I said you will get into a situation where interest rates will rise the dollar will rise us equities will rise and um gold will rise”
The problem with assuming 'Fiat doesn't matter, all fiat declines' is that while true over long periods, relative movements between fiat currencies cause crises—when currencies move significantly against each other in short periods, it creates market dislocations
“everything is priced in Fiat and even though over long periods of time Fiat does lose value it's the change in relative levels of Fiat currencies that cause crisis if again if you go back to like every major crisis over the last 25 30 years almost all of them not all of them but almost all of them have some characteristic of a carry trade wrapped up in there or were either exacerbated exacerbated or caused by a carry trade blowing up”
The United States can use the dollar as the 'Ultimate Weapon' in geopolitical negotiations—either as a shield or sword—and has done so explicitly, using monetary tightening in 2022 to create crisis pressure on other countries during inflation while domestically justifying it for domestic anti-inflation purposes
“the United States can use the dollar as quote unquote the Ultimate Weapon in my opinion the dollar is the biggest weapon the United States has now whether they choose to use it as a shield whether they choose to swing it as a sword I think that changes from time to time but the US can ab absolutely use the dollar as a weapon and the thing that makes it so powerful is they can do it under the guise of what's good for the United States”
History shows people repeat carry trade mistakes repeatedly; despite past crises caused by carry trade unwinding (2000, 2008, 2020, 2024), people continue building carry trade positions because the allure of easy, leveraged returns overcomes historical memory
“one of the things you learn from history is people don't learn from history they repeat the same mistakes over and over and over and part of the reason is the Allure of these carry trades is so much and the Allure of making quick money easily is something that Humanity just Falls for again and again and again and so when you see one of these opportun arise and you see your friends making money on it and you see your competitors making money on it it's very hard for you not to engage in it”
Johnson expects liquidity to disappear between now and year-end, which would be negative for risk assets including gold in the short term, but gold typically recovers faster and stronger than other risk assets during liquidity crunches
“I would expect between now and the end of the year we're going to have a period of time where liquidity disappears or at least Falls from current levels when that happens that's typically bad for risk assets that's and if you get into some kind of a liquidity event gold often Falls just as fast and sometimes more than other risk assets the difference is that gold typically recovers faster and stronger than anything else”
The 2024 US presidential election matters primarily for geopolitical positioning differences between Trump and Harris rather than economic policy differences, since both maintain similar economic policies to their predecessors
“from an economic standpoint I think it would it would only matter to a degree of extremes... the economic policies that Biden has done are not that much different than what Trump had done before... Trump mentioned this in his debate and it's actually true you know if if they thought that Trump's economic policies were so horrible why haven't they changed them and they really haven't they left a lot of Trump's economic policies in place”
Markets are fairly priced to perfection with the exception of gold, which is signaling that things aren't as rosy as labor market and stock market prices suggest, indicating underlying systemic stress
“everything is pretty well where the FED would probably want them to be and and as such the I think the markets are fairly quote unquote price to Perfection... gold is saying hey guys hold on there's something wrong here right but other than that everything is pretty well where the FED would probably want them to be”
Trump would likely create more market volatility than Harris simply because he's outside the political establishment and system, not necessarily because his policies are dramatically different; Harris represents continuity with the status quo
“if you get somebody in there who is not part of the status quo was very clearly not part of the status quo the opportunity for volatility is just heightened just as a result of that person being in there I didn't ask you this but we only have a few minutes left and you put out um a report on the macro Alchemist about the Yen Cary Trade”
Gold is front-running an expected global monetary policy easing cycle as the ECB has started cutting rates and the Fed is expected to cut, creating a consensus that all major central banks will ease simultaneously
“I think gold is is kind of front running an expected Global monetary policy easing cycle if that's the right way to say this”
Despite Johnson's theoretical framework predicting sovereign debt crisis outcomes, he acknowledges the central banks may continue kicking the can down the road indefinitely through perpetual monetary easing, and a sovereign debt crisis may never materialize
“maybe the sovereign debt crisis will never come maybe this central banks and the governments and the monetary authorities can continue to Kick the Can down the road we won't have any kind of fiscal crisis or Sovereign crisis or Market crisis and the dollar Index will bounce around between I don't know 90 and 110 and we'll have periods of you know growth and what have periods of slowdown and 20 or 30 years will go by and nothing will have changed with regard to the monetary system or a sovereign debt crisis”
Currently, the biggest near-term catalyst for the Fed to engage in dramatic rate cuts would require more economic downside to provide political cover for larger cuts; without visible crisis, maintaining current rates or minimal cuts is more likely
“in order for them to really cut interest rates in a dramatic way I think there needs to be a lot more downside they need cover to do it and at this point I don't think that they have cover to do it”
Most listeners who have personal investments in Bitcoin, gold, or hard assets also work for companies involved in commerce or run businesses where fiat versus fiat currency movements are critical, making them vulnerable to carry trade unwinding despite hard asset holdings
“even if as an investor you have all your money in gold or silver or Bitcoin or whatever this hard asset allocation that you have is even if you have all your personal investment in there a lot of people that are listening I assume work for a company that does business that is in involved in Commerce a lot of people have their own company that they started maybe they work for a multinational firm maybe they're managing portfolios that don't have just gold in them and for those people Fiat versus Fiat matters tremendously”
Johnson recommends a 10-20% portfolio allocation to gold, which is high for many people but represents the right amount to balance portfolio protection with traditional asset exposure
“I think if you have a 10 or 20% position in gold which for many people that would be high but I to me that that that's the right amount of gold to have in a portfolio”
Gold functions as a put option against the status quo and against central bank interference, with rising global awareness since the 2008 financial crisis that central banks and governments are backed into a corner due to unsustainable debt levels
“gold to me and I think in general gold is kind of a put option against the status quo right or against political ysy or against Central Bank interference um there is a rising awareness throughout the whole world especially over the last call it 10 to 15 years since the global financial crisis and monetary policy has become more extreme That central banks governments around the world not just the US are somewhat backed into a corner”
The eurodollar market is the reason dollar strength creates global crises: most Americans don't need to understand foreign exchange because they use dollars domestically, but the rest of the world borrows and invests in dollars for trade and funding, making them extremely sensitive to dollar appreciation
“As Americans we don't really have to know what it is because we grew up with the dollar as our do home domestic currency and so most people in America if you ask them what the dollar euro exchange rate or the Brazilian real us they they they wouldn't even know what you were talking about but if you flew to Rio and you asked them with the dollar exchange you found a random person on the street with the dollar exchange rate they would know what it was same in Australia same in China same in Japan and the reason is because the whole world uses dollars for funding for trade um and for for invoicing”
The Fed faces a real challenge this week in managing market expectations: if they cut only 25 basis points, markets expecting 50 will be disappointed; if they cut 50 basis points, they must explain why they're cutting so dramatically when everything is priced to perfection, raising questions about what they know that the market doesn't
“some people are expecting them to cut 25 or see just about everybody is expecting a cut it's just a question now of whether will cut 25 basis points or 50 basis points if they only cut 25 then the marker will be dis probably be disappointed because a lot of it is expecting 50 basis points but if they cut 50 basis points then they have to explain why are you cutting 50 basis points when everything is priced to Perfection”
We're in a bubble, but Johnson expects the bubble to contract first before expanding much larger over the next 2-3 years, with US equity markets outperforming due to the logic of the dollar milkshake
“I I think yes we're in a bubble I think the bubble will get smaller but then I think the bubble will get much much bigger so in other words I'm expecting at least in the US um I expect... over the next two 3 four years I think us Equity markets will go much higher I think gold will go much higher I think the dollar will go much higher”
The economy is not as strong as economic indicators suggest; there are several underlying problems that could create downside, including issues in China, the Yen carry trade unwind, and geopolitical risks, rather than problems originating from the US itself
“I think underneath the uh surface I think I don't think the economy is as strong as you know a lot of the economic indicators would say they are... a lot of the problems that I think that could develop are not necessarily due to a problem in the United States in other words downside could come because of a problem in China downside could come because of uh the war going on in the Middle East downside be could become because of the Yen carry trade that there's a number I'm much more worried about the external US market causing a crisis than I am about the US market causing a crisis”
Between now and the end of 2024, markets will experience extreme volatility similar to what was seen in early August and early September, with particular intensity into October around the election and potentially through year-end
“I think the next three months between now and the end of the year are going to be extremely volatile we saw a little bit of that volatility at the beginning of August we saw it a little bit again at the beginning of September I would expect to see that same type of volatility into October into the election and potentially into the end of the year”
Gold at all-time highs signals stretched positioning among speculators and high sentiment, so while Johnson owns gold for long-term portfolio protection, he advises existing gold holders not to buy more at current prices
“I don't like buying anything at an all-time high and if if we have volatility... if you already own gold you've done very well you don't need to buy more of it at these prices if it goes much higher great you've already got your position you're making money uh but if it pulls back you know five or 10% that would be an opportunity to then potentially buy more”
Johnson expects both gold and silver to be lower 1-2 months from now due to expected liquidity compression, though this is not a recommendation to sell holdings, and prices could surprise him by remaining elevated
“I expect silver to go much much higher but in the short term I expect it to go lower I think both gold and silver will be lower a month or two from now now if they're not that's fine and I'm not tell this is not this is not be saying that everybody should go out and sell their gold”
Although dollarization is desired by many countries, it is much harder to actually accomplish than to discuss, and the fact it hasn't been done years ago despite the desire proves how difficult it is
“it's much easier to say that you want to do it than to actually do it if it was easy to actually do it it would have already been done years ago but the fact that it hasn't been done is proof of how difficult it is to do”