What this covers

This is a half-hour conversation between Maggie L and Jared Dillian, author of The Daily Dirtnap. It starts from the question of whether oil, which has fallen for three months, is close to a bottom. From there it moves into the economy, the Federal Reserve, bonds, China, copper, emerging markets and housing. The energy argument rests mainly on positioning rather than fundamentals. Dillian cites Goldman Sachs prime brokerage data showing hedge funds more short energy stocks than at any point in ten years, and says oil futures shorts exceed even 2020 levels. His rule is that an asset called "uninvestable" is a candidate to buy, which he frames as sentiment trading. He also claims that Middle East flare-ups, including Israel and Hezbollah, have historically marked oil tops, not bottoms.

The macro section is where the disagreement sits. Dillian reads the cooling labor market, with job openings down from 11 million to 7 million, as normalization from pandemic distortion, not weakness. He argues that wage fights at Boeing and among longshoremen show inflation expectations far above official readings. He suggests the 1970s pattern of three inflation waves leaves us in the trough before a third. He also argues that resetting expectations would take a Paul Volcker-scale recession, which he thinks is politically impossible. Maggie L pushes back on commodities, noting that rolling bubbles make broad positioning tricky.

Several smaller turns are worth noting. Dillian expects China's stimulus to be inflationary globally and good for copper and emerging markets. He argues tech is badly over-hired, citing Google and DocuSign. He doubts Kamala Harris's three-million-home target, and thinks mortgage rates have bottomed. The conversation closes on time horizons, drawdown and what would change his mind.

Sharpest takeaway

Jared Dillian argues the U.S. economy remains strong and labor market normalization is being misinterpreted as weakness by the Fed, making rate cuts a policy error that will reignite inflation; he recommends contrarian positioning in energy, commodities, and emerging markets while shorting overvalued tech.

  • Fed is 90% focused on jobs and misreading post-pandemic labor normalization as economic weakness rather than healthy adjustment from pandemic distortions
  • Inflation expectations remain firmly anchored high in wage negotiations (Boeing, longshoremen) despite low reported CPI, making rate cuts into reflation dangerous
  • Extreme short positioning in energy and negative sentiment on commodities creates squeeze dynamics while China stimulus will be inflationary force for global markets

The claims · ranked49 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

People cannot distinguish between the level of prices and the rate of inflation, causing them to perceive 2.6% inflation as impossible despite 2% to 3% annual price increases, because they focus on absolute price levels (e.g., $300 grocery bills) rather than rates of change

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Jared Dillian

“people people cannot differentiate between the level of prices and the rate of inflation so if you tell somebody that inflation is 2.6% they think you're nuts they're like well I go to the grocery store and it's 300 bucks how can you tell me there's no inflation I'm like no prices went up but they're going up at a slower rate that's all that means but people like 99% of people cannot distinguish between the two”

0.74

Controlling inflation expectations requires inducing a severe recession equivalent to Volcker's 1980s rate hikes (to 14%, resulting in 6% annual GDP decline), which is politically impossible in modern era even post-election

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Jared Dillian

“you would need a really bad recession and that's what vulker rate hikes did in the early 80s he raised rates to 14% And we that recession that resulted was one of the most severe recessions that we ever had GDP was down 6% in a year so you're talking about a massive deflationary force and that's what you need to get rid of those inflation expectations and it's it's really hard to imagine that any fed would be able to do that in this day and age is to to create a recession like that in order to kill inflation especially right not before an election”

0.70

Managing money requires smoothing volatility between thesis conviction and real-world execution, which is harder than holding the thesis itself because of large drawdowns that occur along the way

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Jared Dillian

“there's a lot of ups and downs in between and you have to smooth out the volatility and I mean this is what professional investing is all about so it's good to have a thesis the thesis is really a luxury for strategists like me like I have a thesis I write it in my newsletter and it's really up to everybody else's job to executing it but executing it is very messy right because you know you can take big drawdowns um it's hard”

0.69

Time horizons are the most important thing in investing because they determine how much volatility and drawdown a thesis can tolerate before needing to be abandoned or adjusted.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jared Dillian

“time Horizons are the most important thing right because on a broader level you have a thesis right like my thesis is buy Commodities like that's my thesis so and for the like the next three to five years and that's great but if you're managing money there's a lot of ups and downs in between”

0.68

Labor market weakening observed recently is not a sign of economic weakness but rather normalization from pandemic distortions, as job openings have come down from 11 million to 7 million after four years of working off post-pandemic excess

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jared Dillian

“my thesis is that this labor market weakening that we're seeing is not a sign of economic weakness and really what it is is it's a process of normalization from the pandemic four years ago so in the pandemic we put $4 trillion into the economy we created all these labor shortages... and we had these labor shortages for like two years and you saw job openings at like 11 million and that's come down to 7 million”

0.68

Fed officials are too focused on labor market metrics and insufficiently focused on inflation expectations, which remain firmly anchored and grounded in wage negotiations across the economy

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jared Dillian

“They are too focused on the labor market and interestingly you did see two-year yields pick up a little bit this week”

0.68

Commodities can experience rolling bubbles with huge spikes followed by rapid moves against you, so broad commodity positioning can be tricky rather than a simple supercycle play

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Maggie L

“he was talking about the prospect Jared of rolling bubbles in Commodities because Commodities are tricky right they can sort of have these huge spikes and then they can move against you very quickly um and and he feels like that this is an environment where rather than just being a broad super cycle for Commodities you could see individual markets moving really quickly”

0.68

A potential longshore strike would be highly inflationary, and wage expectations across industries (Boeing workers rejecting 6% annual raises, longshoremen negotiations) indicate inflation expectations of 6-10% per year, contradicting official low inflation readings

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jared Dillian

“It's super inflationary number one and second of all the interesting thing is is that um Boeing workers two or three weeks ago uh they're in negotiation for a new contract their Union and they were offered a 24% pay increase over four years 6% a year and they rejected it right so what does that tell you about inflation expectations”

0.66

Price levels are sticky downward—once prices or wages rise, they rarely decline unless forced by severe recession, so inflation is essentially irreversible without major deflationary shock.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Jared Dillian

“nobody's going to you know my cable bill is not going down nothing goes down it's very hard I mean food may be but it's but it's kind of rare unless it's unless demand falls off and people are forced to basically you need you would need a really bad recession”

0.64

Current oil short positioning in futures exceeds the short positioning that existed in 2020 when oil prices went negative, indicating the current bearish consensus is more extreme than at the historical low point.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Jared Dillian

“if you look at Short positioning in Futures it's actually there's people are more short oil now than they were in 2020 when prices went negative like that's how consensus this is”

0.62

Federal Reserve initiated rate-cut cycle in December 2023 after Christopher Waller's speech indicating real rates were too high and policy too restrictive, but actual cuts were delayed until just before 2024 election

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jared Dillian

“there's a lot of politics involved and look the F we got to go back to December 2023 when Christopher Waller gave that speech saying that you know the real rate is too high and Monet AR policy it was too restrictive and we started pricing in rate Cuts around December of 2023 and we didn't get them until now we got them in the last fed meeting before the election”

0.62

Bulk purchasing behavior (e.g., buying $800 of goods at Costco) driven by inflation psychology perpetuates actual inflation despite official statistics showing lower inflation rates, creating a self-reinforcing cycle

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jared Dillian

“they go down to Costco and they buy like 800 bucks worth of stuff and they put it in their house and inflation just keeps keeps rolling”

0.57

FOMC meeting scheduled for day after election creates uncertainty about Fed policy post-election based on who wins and what political environment emerges

forecasthigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Jared Dillian

“and that's another thing like we have an fomc fomc meeting the day after the election right so what's that going to look like and what does the election look like and who wins and what does it mean and do we get protests or whatever like a headline risk out there”

0.57

Energy sector positioning is extremely crowded on the short side—Goldman Sachs Prime Brokerage reports hedge fund clients are most short energy stocks in 10 years, making the asset similar to a beach ball held underwater that will bounce when released

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Jared Dillian

“everybody is short okay everybody is short I saw an article today um from Goldman Sachs uh their Prime brokerage Department said that hedge fund clients are the most short energy stocks in like the last 10 years um it's this is one of these things like... like this is massively crowded and people are pressing and pressing and pressing on the short side and it's like holding a beach ball underwater like it's G to bounce”

0.57

The Fed is making a policy error by cutting interest rates into an economy that is 'incredibly strong' with visible signs of strength everywhere, and rate cuts are unnecessary despite arguments that real rates of 2.5% are too high relative to a neutral 1% target

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Jared Dillian

“everywhere I go I see signs of strength in the economy I think it's incredibly strong I think that cutting rates however much they're going to cut it is a mistake I think it's absolutely a mistake”

0.57

Tech industry is dramatically over-hired relative to actual work being performed; examples include Google (probably needs 20,000 of 184,000 employees) and DocuSign (doesn't need 3,000 employees), with excess only revealed in recession through layoffs

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Jared Dillian

“Tech the tech industry has over hired to an ENT that we haven't seen even a company like DocuSign has 3,000 employees like why does DocuSign need 3,000 employees so there's a lot of people in the tech World specifically Tech that just aren't doing any work”

0.57

Kamala Harris's proposal to build 3 million houses is unrealistic given current supply constraints; current construction of 1.4 million annually is insufficient and doubling that wouldn't be enough for 10 years

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Jared Dillian

“KLA Harris says she wants to build three million houses I don't think I take the under on that I don't think that's happen um right now we build 1.4 million houses a year and if we did that for the next 10 years it is not enough if we did double that it's not enough we are chronically under supplied”

0.55

China's fiscal stimulus announcement was inevitable and necessary for China's economy, and stimulus will be massively inflationary globally, particularly benefiting commodities

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jared Dillian

“one of my part of my thesis around Commodities was that China would stimulate they had no other choice they had to so I mean I think if you weren't involved in Chinese stocks uh the day before they decided to do the stimulus then it's too late like 26% in a week”

0.54

Mortgage rates have bottomed and won't go significantly lower despite recent Fed rate cuts, though housing prices remain supported by secular factors like immigration driving demand

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Jared Dillian

“mortgage rates have bottomed right so we had had a surge in refi we had a surge in purchases but uh mortgage rates have bottomed uh housing housing prices are bulletproof for a whole bunch of secular reasons and the biggest one is immigration”

0.54

Jared believes third inflation wave is likely because inflation expectations are grounded and people will demand wage increases to maintain purchasing power, perpetuating price increases

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Jared Dillian

“I actually think that's pretty likely because there like I talked about with Boeing in the long Shan like inflation expectations are so firmly grounded people people cannot differentiate between the level of prices and the rate of inflation”

0.52

New York's concentrated financial community creates 'bubble thinking' where everyone shares same ideas and crowded trades, whereas relocating to South Carolina provides perspective to identify when consensus positions are overcrowded and vulnerable

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jared Dillian

“I wrote The Daily dirt nap for about 18 months in New York before I moved to South Carolina and when I moved to South Carolina like I just got a lot better because I'm not in the middle of this group thing bubble that everybody is in in New York like everybody goes to idea dinners and drinks and stuff like that and they share all these same ideas and everybody's in the same trade you know so I'm here in South Carolina and I'm like guys like this is this is massively crowded”

0.52

When an asset is called 'uninvestable,' that's the signal to buy it; sentiment is so negative that positioning is extreme and ripe for squeeze

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Jared Dillian

“when people start calling something uninvestable like that's the time to buy it you know um like like oil for example like energy like that's that's to the point that we are in energy like people are calling it uninvestable and that's the time to do it”

0.51

Andreas and others have documented inflation pattern showing three waves of inflation in 1970s with current period in trough between second and third waves, potentially setting up third inflation wave

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Jared Dillian

“Andreas and a bunch of other people have this chart uh this overlay chart of inflation in the 70s and inflation now how you had these three waves of inflation and we are at the trough in between the biggest wave”

0.48

Sentiment trading approach of buying uninvestable assets and selling those that everyone wants to buy is how Jared makes his living professionally

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jared Dillian

“that's sentiment trading right like that's pure sentiment trading you can use charts to back it up um this is kind of how I make a living you know like I buy stuff that nobody else wants to buy I sell stuff that everybody wants to buy”

0.48

U.S. has experienced massive immigration (10 million people) that requires housing, creating trickle-up effect in housing prices and chronic undersupply that persists regardless of new construction targets

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jared Dillian

“you know we just let 10 million people into the country they need a place to live there's going to be this trickle up effect in housing prices um I we we still have massive housing housing shortages”

0.48

Geopolitical events (Israel-Hezbollah, Iran tensions) have been historically conditioned to mark tops of oil rallies rather than bottoms, so recent Middle East developments will not trigger oil rally and market will sell into them

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jared Dillian

“the thing about geopolitical events in oil is that everybody has been trained that geopolitical events usually Mark the top of a move rather than the bottom so no matter what happens in Israel or Iran or the Middle East like people have just been condition to sell the rally right so you know over the weekend they uh Israel killed the Hezbollah leader whatever his name is and you know oil was up like 20 or 30 basis points this morning then it was down then it was up um not a lot of reaction out of that”

0.45

Bond market is pricing in two factors: (1) large fiscal issuance regardless of election winner due to no spending cuts; (2) inflation risk, particularly if Harris wins as she won't cut government size and will increase issuance

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Jared Dillian

“what you're starting to price in is two things number one really no matter who gets elected you're going to get a lot of issuance right especially if it's kamla har if it's KLA Harris she's not going to cut the size of government at all you're going to get a ton of issuance and that's going to weigh on bonds”

0.43

Short-term recession pain from tech layoffs would be offset long-term by better resource allocation, as displaced workers find more productive employment and companies achieve higher profit margins

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jared Dillian

“short short term short term it would be bad long term it would be good long term it would be good why longterm it would be good because it well because people would find employment someplace else so their skills would be better put to use uh the companies that fired them would have greater productivity they'd have higher profit margins like everybody wins”

0.43

Real economy remains strong independent of financial economy/equity market strength, so Fed rate hikes that helped equities are not necessarily correlated with real economy improvements

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jared Dillian

“the real economy is just fine it really is yeah”

0.41

Market is currently pricing in 9-10 rate cuts bringing fed funds to approximately 3%, but Jared predicts only 6 rate cuts will occur, leaving fed funds around 4% at a neutral real rate of 1%

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Jared Dillian

“we were pricing in about nine or 10 rate Cuts they were pricing in taking fed funds down to about 3% uh I don't think that's going to happen I think look if we got back to neutral where you had a real rate of 1% you would be looking at fed funds of 4% so that's 150 basis points of cuts uh I would bet against 10 rate Cuts but I am too chicken”

0.39

Emerging markets are now highly correlated due to China stimulus and will all perform well if the thesis of weaker dollar, commodity rally, and China stimulus are correct

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Jared Dillian

“I think with the China stimulus they have all become correlated and I think you can it's literally as simple as buying an Emerging Market ETF and I think it's fine”

0.36

Buying energy and shorting tech stocks and holding for a year would likely produce attractive returns given current sentiment positioning.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Jared Dillian

“I think if you bought energy and shorted Tech and put it away for a year you'd probably be pretty happy”

0.35

A specific holding in Dillian's newsletter is the DVY ETF, a high-dividend emerging market ETF, which has appreciated significantly on China stimulus.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Jared Dillian

“one of the Holdings I have in my newsletter it's this ETF called dvy it's a it's a high dividend Emerging Market ETF um I I've had it for like two years and it gapped up like six or seven percent on the China stimulus”

0.35

Republicans have at least some sentiment toward government efficiency improvements (e.g., Trump appointment of Elon Musk to eliminate waste committee) vs. Democrats with no such intention, though historically both parties have increased government size over 50 years

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Jared Dillian

“there's at least for the last 50 years all everyone's done is s and increase the size of government yeah there's at least with Republicans there's a chance I mean you probably heard that Donald Trump is going to appoint Elon mus to this committee to like eliminate government waste and stuff like that like there's there's at least some sentiment towards that direction”

0.32

Dillian's thesis would break only if the Fed reversed course and tightened policy, or if the Fed implemented a 100 basis point cut total (3 × 25bp Nov/Dec plus stop) rather than the consensus 10 cuts.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Jared Dillian

“what it would take would be a complete reversal out of the fed and uh a tightening of monetary policy or maybe not even a tightening but maybe you know we got some comments out out a PO today which we haven't talked about which were a little bit hawkish um but if the FED let's say cut 25 in November and cut 25 in December and then said they were done and sort of you know manag people's expectations along the way and they only did a 100 basis points of rate Cuts then yes this thesis would probably be busted”

0.24

Jared wrote his first short story at 21, thought it was amazing then, but looking back now sees it was terrible, showing growth in craft over time

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Jared Dillian

“I wrote my first short story when I was 21 years old and uh I thought it was amazing at the time and now I go back and look at it and it was it was terrible”

0.20

The concept of 'being a bad stock picker' prevents Jared from trying to pick individual energy companies; he prefers index exposure (XLE) or the commodity itself to avoid security selection risk

normativespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Jared Dillian

“for my time at Leman I was an index TR I'm a terrible stock picker right like if you if you gave me 30 energy stocks and you asked me to pick the best performer like I couldn't do it like I don't know how to do that so I just buy the index I just buy XLE right or you could buy the commodity either way”

0.19

Yield curve has steepened with front end at positive 23 basis points, while back end acts poorly and yields have crept up despite Fed rate cuts

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Jared Dillian

“we've had a decent steepening so the I checked the curve last week and it was like positive 23 basis points so we've had a decent Ste deepening um the back end of the yield curve acts poorly right the front end of the yield curve is still pretty bulletproof but the backend acts poorly”

0.19

Commodities had a major bottom about a month before the interview with broad rallies across all commodity types except oil, which is particularly interesting

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Jared Dillian

“basically what happened a month ago is that we had a big bottom in Commodities and commodities had pretty much rallied across the board except for oil oil is super interesting”

0.17

Jared has been a contrarian writer for two years and is happy he didn't get caught up in China stock rally but remains bearish on China long-term

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Jared Dillian

“I am always bearish on China I'm happy to be bearish on China um I'm not sad that I missed that at all”

0.13

Copper has become difficult to trade; Jared thought it was topping two days before China stimulus announcement, then it gapped up 20 points, showing he 'totally screwed up copper'

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Jared Dillian

“I have totally screwed up copper I've totally screwed it up um actually a couple of days before the stimulus I thought it was kind of topping out and then like two days later it gapped up like 20 points so uh I don't have a good feel for copper right now”

0.13

The Fed was not aware at the time of its rate cut announcement that China would stimulate, which would make the rate cut even more inflationary than it would have been otherwise.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Jared Dillian

“The last time they cut rates they didn't know China was going to come out and stimulate”

0.13

Heating oil and gasoline charts look compelling to buy with the same bullish energy thesis, though Dillian doesn't follow natural gas closely.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Jared Dillian

“I don't know anything about Nat gas but I've looked at the heating oil chart I've looked at the gasoline chart it all it all looks it all looks really compelling it does because everyone's so bearish”

0.13

Technical analysis of oil shows prices bottomed two weeks ago with a recovery and subsequent pullback; the bottom is in and Jared is waiting for a rally, avoiding specific catalyst predictions

forecastspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Jared Dillian

“when I look at technicals I actually think it bottom two weeks ago we bounced a little bit we came back down I think the bottom is in and uh I'm just hanging out waiting for a rally”

0.13

Jared purchased long-dated call options on XLE (energy sector ETF) about 1-2 weeks prior to interview, expressing conviction in energy bullishness through leverage strategy

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Jared Dillian

“actually bought some calls on XLE for the personal account about a week or two ago uh some long dat calls”

0.13

Economic demand remains strong as evidenced by airport crowding (Charlotte Airport at capacity, high demand for premium lounge access), contradicting Fed assumptions of weakening demand

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Jared Dillian

“I took a trip to Connecticut over the weekend uh stayed in mgan Sun visited my high school stuff like that and the the airports the Charlotte Airport I have never seen it more crowded never seen it more crowded it was it was a mad house uh I go to the AMX Lounge there's like a half hour wait to get into the AMX Lounge it's it's a food fight it's full like I think there's always a food fight at the lounges now”

0.13

Chinese equity rally of 26% in 6 sessions is too rapid to front-run for late arrivals; timing the China stimulus was a pre-existing thesis, not a trade that could be executed after announcement

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Jared Dillian

“I mean I think if you weren't involved in Chinese stocks uh the day before they decided to do the stimulus then it's too late like 26% in a week like it's you know it's it's too late”

0.13

Jared plans to trade election night actively and expects significant volatility with 'heroes and body bags' as markets price different outcomes

forecastspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Jared Dillian

“I'm going to be trading the election I'll be up that night trading for sure um and there's going to be a lot of Heroes and a lot of body bags but stuff is going to be moving on Election night”

0.10

Jared's just-published short story collection 'Night Moves and Other Stories' is dark, has limited happy endings, but has received excellent reviews for writing quality despite one reviewer finding characters unsympathetic

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 0/4· Jared Dillian

“this is a great short Story collection it's a little bit on the dark side um not a lot of Happy Endings uh I'm really really pleased with the writing the reviews I've gotten back so far are amazing um the only thing resembling even a neutral review was somebody said the characters were unsympathetic”