
The Atlantic's George Packer on the End of Democratic Delusions
What this covers
This is a conversation between Al Franken and George Packer about Packer's Atlantic essay on the 2024 result. It runs about 42 minutes. Packer places the election inside what he calls Historical Ideological Eras, long stretches of liberal or market-minded dominance. He treats it less as a swing in one cycle than as the close of the Roosevelt Republic and the Reagan years. Franken pushes, adds his own readings, and in places sharpens Packer's claims into more contested ones.
The middle of the conversation is about class and education. They discuss how a college degree has become the dividing line between economic winners and losers. Packer describes a professional "new aristocracy" that hands its advantage down through the generations, and Franken applies the description to his own cohort. They tie this to Democrats becoming the party of the college-educated, and to the claim that such voters felt inflation less sharply than wage earners did. The argument that voters will pick the party culturally closer to them when neither party improves their living standards is where Franken's Cultural Alignment Over Economic Interest idea comes in. They also look at Bill Clinton's concession that "the era of big government is over" and at the shift of Latino and Black male voters toward Trump.
The conversation also covers Democratic strategy and governance. They debate whether Bidenomics was sound policy that failed politically because infrastructure pays off slowly and Biden could not claim credit. They also discuss the limits of antitrust action under Lina Khan and a party Packer calls calcified and risk-averse. The most contentious material looks ahead. Packer argues that Trump's reactionary movement is harsher than old conservatism and has parallels abroad. He worries that loyalty-based appointments at the FBI and Justice Department could leave no one to resist illegal orders, and he raises the possibility of dynastic succession. Franken predicts a tax cut that favors the wealthy, which would cut against the grievances of Trump's working-class base.
George Packer argues that Trump's 2024 victory represents a fundamental realignment away from both the Roosevelt Republic (1930s-2008) and the Reagan Era (1980-2008), driven by economic anxiety and the perception that democratic institutions have failed ordinary Americans rather than threats to democracy itself.
- Trump voters interpret democracy as already having failed them under current elites; they see Trump as restoring it, not destroying it—inverting Democrats' core election message
- Decades of globalization, deindustrialization, and widening inequality have created a college-educated urban elite ('new aristocracy') perceived as controlling politics, while working-class Americans lack economic mobility
- Democrats lost working-class and minority voters not by losing on policy but by appearing as the party of status quo and elite interests, while failing to address the emotional weight of inflation and stagnant prospects
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Trump voters who tell pollsters that democracy is a major concern do not fear democracy's demise but believe democracy has already failed them under current elite control, and they see Trump as restoring democracy to ordinary people—a complete inversion of the Democratic interpretation that democracy-concerned voters are anti-Trump.
“asked by pollsters if they're concerned about the state of democracy these voters answer answer yes not because they fear its demise but because it has already failed them they don't think Trump will destroy democracy he'll restore it to the people”
The Democratic Party has become the party of college-educated professionals while the Republican Party has become the party of high school-educated working-class voters, reversing a century-long alignment and making Democrats insensitive to inflation's impact because college-educated voters experience it less acutely than wage earners.
“the Democratic party has become more and more the party of the college educated and the Republican party has become more and more the party of the high school educated that is to say the working class and that's a complete reversal of most Century the college educated don't feel inflation the way people without college degrees who are making a wage rather than a salary due”
Bill Clinton's statement 'the era of big government is over' represented a landmark concession by Democrats that libertarian ideology had become politically inevitable and that the Democratic Party could no longer advocate for expansion of social welfare state—a shock within Democratic tradition.
“when he said the era of big government is over that was a landmark for a Democrat it was shocking it was shocking he was saying yeah you remember it he was saying whatever our fathers and mothers thought the Democratic party was about it's no longer about it's something else we're not going to give up on Social Security and Medicare and equal rights for women and minorities but we are going to accept it the libertarian ideology is sort of with us now and we can't we can't avoid it”
College education has become a primary dividing line between economic winners and losers in America, with non-college-educated workers facing substantially worse economic prospects than two generations ago, generating resentment against an emerging meritocratic aristocracy that perpetuates advantage across generations.
“people are so afraid of going to college and whether the debt that they incur will whether they can deal with that I think that's right but they also probably recognize that without a college degree their economic prospects are a lot worse than they were two generations ago”
Globalization and information technology have produced significant wealth for people in major metropolitan areas and their suburbs (computer programmers, media, professors) but beyond 20 miles from major cities, visible decay persists and economic prospects have deteriorated.
“now I think it's pretty pervasive other than in our big metropolises where you know people are computer programmers and media types and professors and where the suburbs are part kind of connected to the cities and to the economies of the cities and essentially globalization and information have produced a lot of wealth but once you get beyond that you don't have to drive very far if you drive like 20 miles in any direction from a major city you pretty quickly start seeing certain yeah kind of Decay”
College debt discourages people from pursuing higher education, and lack of a college degree significantly worsens economic prospects compared to two generations ago, creating a sense of being 'left behind.'
“people are so afraid of going to college and whether the debt that they incur will whether they can deal with that I think that's right but they also probably recognize that without a college degree their economic prospects are a lot worse than they were two generations ago and that too gives that feeling of we've been left behind”
Trump's reactionary movement is not old-fashioned conservatism but something harsher, more bitter, and more aggrieved, and similar reactionary movements are emerging worldwide against decades of globalization that has created clear winners and losers.
“that's why I call him a reactionary and why I call it the Trump reaction it's not old-fashioned conservatism it's something harsher more bitter more aggrieved and we see it in a lot of countries right now it's a kind of worldwide reaction against uh Decades of globalization which has created these winners and losers”
Working-class Americans feel that recent immigrants have 'cut in front of them' and are doing better, and though some of this reflects prejudice, much of it reflects legitimate recognition that they are falling behind while others are advancing.
“people maybe who came to this country more recently have already cut in front of us and are doing better and there's bound to be a certain amount of of prejudice in that but there's also a certain amount of just simple recognition that I'm not doing well and that the sort of the tide of History seems to be against me”
The Democratic Party and college-educated professionals (the host's cohort) have become a 'new aristocracy'—inheriting professional status and economic advantage from generation to generation—which functions as an inherited aristocracy despite being called meritocracy, and this transformation excludes working-class people without college degrees from upward mobility.
“the billionaires and not just the billionaires but the people one or two tiers below them people like me who are college educated and work in a profession and make a good income and have their children on the the path to the same thing and have kind of become a new aristocracy we call ourselves meritocrats but I think really it's become an aristocracy that's inherited from one generation to the next and it is very hard now for people who don't go to college to break into”
If neither Democratic nor Republican parties can improve the standard of living for the bottom 60% of Americans, those voters will choose based on cultural proximity (values, language, social issues) rather than policy, which increasingly favors Republicans as the party culturally closer to working-class Americans.
“if neither party is really able to improve the standard of living and the life prospects of the bottom 60% let's say then that bottom 60% is going to vote on who seems closest to them in terms of just values culture uh social issues even language and that's become more and more the Republican party so if the Democrats don't seem like they're really going to make your life better which has been the then what good are they”
After losing in 2012, the Republican Party conducted an autopsy and concluded they needed to do something different to win Latino and minority voters because the party was becoming a party of old white people which would face extinction, but Trump's approach completely reversed this strategy by appealing to grievances rather than policy outreach.
“that's why in 2012 after Romney lost the Republican Party looked Inward and said we need to do something different in order to win these Latino voters and minority voters in general were becoming a party of the old white people people and that means we're going to be extinct pretty soon well Donald Trump came along and changed all the calculations because he was not saying what Romney had been saying”
The FTC under Lena Khan made progress suing major tech corporations, but full-scale antitrust regulation did not materialize during the Biden administration despite having full control of government.
“I thought more would come of that but well it it didn't I mean I think they did push some things they brought lawsuits against Google um and other big Tech corporations”
Trump's 'Make America Great Again' slogan appeals to voters by promising to restore a time 'when you The Real Americans were at the center of things' after waves of displacement from globalization, automation, and demographic change.
“Trump by saying make America great again is saying we're going to go backward to a time when you The Real Americans were at the center of things and that's why I call him a reactionary and why I call it the Trump reaction”
Throughout American history, political ideology has cycled between liberal periods focused on expanding rights and welfare (Roosevelt Republic, 1930s-1970s) and conservative periods emphasizing markets and deregulation (Reagan Era, 1980-2008), with distinct ideological dominance lasting several decades, not mere electoral cycles.
“there's been these periods in which a kind of U political ideology dominated and earlier in my life it was sort of the tail end of the Roosevelt Republic I call it that went from the New Deal to like the 70s till Reagan... that was a time of of growing social welfare for Americans kind of a widening of Rights and equality to groups that had been locked out through our history”
Latino voters shifted dramatically toward Trump, with approximately 50% supporting him in 2024 compared to far lower levels for McCain (low 30s), Romney (even lower), and Bush in 2004 (high 30s), representing the largest Latino Republican support in recent memory.
“you point in the article to people who are in that income category that for example Latino voters at 50% almost 50% which voted for for Trump what was the percentage on say McCain...I think that the last time it came anywhere close to that was George W Bush in 2004 but that was way down in the 30s I believe and McCain was even lower and Romney was even lower”
The guardrails of law may not hold if Trump is in the White House, Cash Patel at the FBI, and Pam Bondi as attorney general, all appointed purely for loyalty, because there will be no FBI agents or prosecutors willing to resist illegal orders to prosecute political enemies.
“is is our system of law capable of resisting this if you've got Trump in the White House cash Patel at the FBI Pam Bondi as the attorney general and a bunch of underlings they've appointed who are being appointed purely for their loyalty then where is the guardrail like what where's the US attorney or the FBI field agent who's going to say no there's just not anything on this person we're not going to do it”
Latino voters swung toward Trump in 2024 to nearly 50%, compared to George W. Bush's ~30% in 2004, McCain's lower share, and Romney's even lower share in 2012—the biggest shift in minority voting since at least Bush's time.
“Latino voters at 50% almost 50% which voted for for Trump what was the percentage on say McCain... I think that the last time it came anywhere close to that was George W Bush in 2004 but that was way down in the 30s I believe and McCain was even lower and Romney was even lower”
Male black voters shifted toward Trump between 2020 and 2024, with approximately one-third voting for Trump in 2024, continuing a trend Obama had observed and criticized (attributing it to sexism about voting for a black woman).
“to a lesser degree black voting male black voters what was a third yeah in or quarter to a third in 2022 well really starting in 20 and then in 24”
Neither emotion nor policy alone determines electoral outcomes; rather, emotions are more powerful than policies, and neither Harris nor Clinton tapped into the emotional reality of how voters were feeling, instead offering menus of specific small-bore policies.
“emotions are powerful and policies are less powerful and in terms of emotion I think neither Harris nor Clinton tapped into the way people were feeling about the country instead they were giving them a a menu of of relatively small boore policies”
Trump will pursue tax cuts similar to his 2017 tax cut, which primarily benefited the wealthy, contradicting the grievances of working-class voters who believe the wealthy and elites control the system.
“I do I do and I I also believe that now that Trump has won he is going to get his and and they have the Congress that he is going to get his tax cut that's going to be just like the one in 2017 which really go to those at the top yep yep so the people who are voting against Democrats because they take care of the wealthy don't realize that uh the Republicans uh that's that is their main job”
Bidenomics was sound economic policy (bringing manufacturing back, the Chips Act, major infrastructure investment) but failed politically because it had a long delay effect—infrastructure projects take 10 years to construct—and Biden could not give effective speeches to claim credit, so voters did not associate him with the benefits before inflation eroded his approval.
“Biden could not give a speech and meanwhile inflation would was going wait a minute what do you mean Biden could not give a spech he couldn't talk he he just had no rhetorical force”
The Democratic Party has become 'very risk averse', 'calcified', 'gerontocratic', and status quo-protecting, unable to imagine proposing changes to the current system, which is counterproductive because status quo messaging alienates voters experiencing real economic anxiety.
“the Democratic party has become this very risk averse kind of calcified gerontocratic a party oh Oher yeah like from geriatric geriatric and Status Quo status quo protecting and that is not the way you're going to win the a great many American voters by saying we need to not make any major changes but to keep things pretty much the way they are because that's our democracy”
Trump's presidency may result in dynastic succession within the Trump family, making it like autocracies in Syria and Hungary where power passes from father to child for personal enrichment.
“he may try to create a legacy for his family his children or a daughter-in-law or a daughter-in-law it's a it's going to become like autocracies you know in God forbid Syria and in Hungary and in a lot of countries where it goes from father to child and it's going to be about enriching the Trump family”
Trump as a reactionary represents a worldwide pattern of reaction against decades of globalization, which has created clear winners (urban professionals benefiting from global trade and capital flows) and losers (deindustrialized regions and working-class communities).
“we see it in a lot of countries right now it's a kind of worldwide reaction against uh Decades of globalization which has created these winners and losers”
Inflation peaking at 9.1% in mid-2022 was the decisive issue in the 2024 election, more powerful than policy or institutional arguments, because college-educated Democrats do not experience price inflation the way working-class wage-earners do, and thus underestimated its political potency.
“I really do believe the inflation in middle of 2022 going up to 99.1%... I think that was the margin in this”
Trump doesn't care about consistent policy positions and will change his stated positions if it serves his immediate interests, as illustrated by his unpredictable approach to tariffs.
“Trump doesn't care about anything except himself and if tariffs suddenly seem bad for Trump well just increased prices in in the United States I mean just inflationary right I don't know what he's gonna do with tariffs I don't know anything about tariffs all I know is Trump doesn't give a damn about what he said five minutes ago if what he's saying now seems like it's going to get him what he wants and what he wants is not the good of the American people it never has been”
Packer wrote an Atlantic article in 2020 titled 'How to Destroy a Government' predicting that if Trump won reelection in 2020, there would be a huge exodus from the federal government, but the predicted exodus did not materialize to the scale expected, demonstrating the stickiness of institutional positions.
“I wrote a piece for the Atlantic called how to destroy a government in 2020 just before the pandemic and what I heard from people in the justice department and the state department was if Trump wins again in 2020 there will be a huge Exodus from federal government”
Clinton's statement 'the era of big government is over' was a landmark ideological shift for a Democrat because it signaled acceptance that the libertarian ideology of deregulation and limited government had become permanent, even if Democrats maintained Social Security, Medicare, and equal rights commitments.
“when he said the era of big government is over that was a landmark for a Democrat it was shocking it was shocking he was saying yeah you remember it he was saying whatever our fathers and mothers thought the Democratic party was about it's no longer about it's something else we're not going to give up on Social Security and Medicare and equal rights for women and minorities but we are going to accept it the libertarian ideology is sort of with us now”
Harris received only 107 days between Biden's withdrawal from the race and the election, compared to Hubert Humphrey's 8-9 months in 1968 and Kamala Harris's predecessor's typical timeframes, putting her at a structural disadvantage in campaign preparation and messaging development.
“she had 107 days...I mean even Hubert Humphrey in 1968 had eight or nine months after LBJ dropped out”
Trump won the 2024 popular vote by only 1%, suggesting the election was close by traditional standards, and Harris overcame severe structural disadvantages (late campaign start, inflation, elite-appointed candidacy) while actually gaining support among college-educated voters and voters earning over $100,000.
“it was it was a close election by by traditional standards yes...Harris increased support of white voters and voters making over $100,000 over Biden but the other categories black Latino and under 100,000 Trump did better”
The Affordable Care Act passed with exactly 60 votes in the Senate, with Franken being a crucial 60th vote, and the legislative process was dramatic and cliffhanger-like, ultimately requiring the use of reconciliation procedures after Scott Brown's election in Massachusetts.
“we made it we were there were 60 of us in the Senate and that that's what it needed I remember well I was sitting in the Senate Gallery in the Press row watching you guys take those votes and it was a a cliffhanger and yeah your Victory which you were the last of the 60 right right yeah yeah it was uh dramatic when I got when I got there Ted Kennedy was sick so we really had 59 until Paul Kirk replaced him after he had died right and then came Scott Brown”
Biden staying in the race until late July, giving Harris only 107 days instead of the 8-9 months Humphrey had after LBJ dropped out in March 1968, was a major strategic error that hampered her campaign.
“we would have had a process by someone you know that would have taken you know a couple years instead of 104 days or whatever she had 107 that's right I mean even Hubert Humphrey in 1968 had eight or nine months after LBJ dropped out that's right LBJ dropped out in March”
Trump's appeal to Latino voters was not based on easing tax burdens or offering economic benefits, but on appealing to grievances by scapegoating groups (Haitians in Springfield, Mexicans at the border) and Elites, creating a 'hodgepodge of grievances' that resonated across identity categories.
“he wasn't doing something to ease the tax burden on workingclass people he was appealing to grievances he was saying that problem is them those Haitians in Springfield Ohio Mexicans who were coming coming across the border and committing crimes uh and those Elites who look down their noses at you and think they know better and want to tell you what you can say and how to live and all of that became a prettyy potent brew a kind of hodg podge of grievances”
Silicon Valley tech moguls (Peter Thiel, Elon Musk, Mark Andreessen) have aligned with Trump in expectation of enrichment and deregulation, and will exploit their access to reshape government in their interests rather than the public interest.
“Silicon Valley has made its peace with Trump a whole r of tech Moguls have run down to maral Lago since the election to try to Peter teal is JD Vance's uh sugar daddy and yeah and there's Mark Andre and and of Elon Musk the big um who should not be forgotten I think that they are salivating at the prospect of being brought into the White House in order to remake the government they claim to want to make it more efficient maybe they do but what do you want to bet that a more efficient government is a government that benefits them they're going to be at the trough of the public coffers for the next four years”
Building infrastructure in the modern United States takes approximately 10 years per project (e.g., a bridge that in the Great Depression was built in slightly over a month), due to Democratic Party interest groups using environmental regulations and other regulatory tactics to prevent or delay construction.
“in fact these days a bridge takes about 10 years it seems uh the Golden Gate Bridge went up in a little more than a month but it was pretty damn fast in the depression now we take 10 years to build a bridge why is that”
Democrats wrongly attributed Trump's 2016 gains with minority voters to racism and sexism, failing to understand they signaled an economic realignment, and therefore were unprepared for further gains in 2024.
“this was the big mistake Democrats made after 2016 they thought it was all about racism and therefore they were not prepared for the big swing in Latino and to a lesser degree black voting male black voters”
Arab American and Palestinian American voters in Michigan likely swung toward Jill Stein or stayed home in significant numbers due to Harris's refusal to address Gaza concerns, and this shift contributed to Michigan being one of the closest swing states after Wisconsin.
“how many of the Muslims in Michigan voted for Jill Stein I don't know but it's pretty clear that Michigan was I think the second closest of the Swing States after Wisconsin yeah Wisconsin was the closest yeah and the Arab American vote that went for Jill Stein or for Donald Trump or stayed home must have played a pretty big role”
Some government employees will remain in their posts during the Trump administration despite concerns about politicization and retribution, telling themselves they can prevent the worst outcomes by being present, though this rationalization may be self-serving.
“there are going to be people who want to quit but won't quit because they want to be there to prevent what we're talking about I heard a lot of that in 2020 I wrote a piece for the Atlantic called how to destroy a government in 2020 just before the pandemic and what I heard from people in the justice department and the state department was if Trump wins again in 2020 there will be a huge Exodus from federal government will there be one in January it's probably a little harder than it sounds because it's a decent job it's secure it's got benefits and pensions and even the illusion that yeah you can maybe be there to help prent the worst people always convince themselves of of that if I go then it'll get worse so I have to stick around”
The unfairness of two highly competent women (Clinton and Harris) being defeated by a 'degenerate' man (Trump) suggests something is broken in American political culture that prevents women from reaching the presidency despite their qualifications.
“how unfair and awful a thing it is that two very impressive women have been defeated by a degenerate Man twice right it just says something that I don't like about about the country that that's happened it doesn't mean we're hopeless misogynous it just means there is something that isn't working yet it isn't rising to meet history about us”
There are other qualified women available to lead the Democratic Party (Gretchen Whitmer and others) who should have been given a chance in the 2024 primary instead of Harris being installed by party elites.
“there are women who are incredibly successful and Powerful in our politics in the Democratic party way more than the Republican Party who should be given a chance and they weren't given a chance this year which is as you were saying was a big part of the problem”
The Democratic Party should have allowed a Palestinian American speaker at the convention to signal openness to dissent and new policy ideas, which would have demonstrated generosity of spirit and possibly retained Arab American voters in Michigan.
“why didn't the party allow one Palestinian American to speak at the convention yeah would it have really hurt them to have a note of dissent at the podium I don't think so it would have shown a kind of generosity of spirit and openness to criticism and even to new policy ideas and they couldn't bring themselves to do it”
Packer was writing for the New Yorker about the Senate during the Affordable Care Act debates and remembers the chamber being largely empty except at key moments, with the absence of senators signifying the lack of collegial deliberation and the Senate's dysfunctionality.
“I was also writing about the sen at the time for the New Yorker I wrote a long article about the Senate that was called The Empty chamber because you guys never were around listening to each other except at Key moments like on health care and what I remember is silence I couldn't quite hear what you were saying but every now and then a laugh coming from Senator Franken”
Elites benefit from decisions in Congress and the White House more than ordinary people do, and corruption between elites and government is real, making it understandable why people feel the system is rigged.
“and there is corruption at top and the billionaires are that the fix is in with the billionaires and not just the billionaires but the people one or two tiers below them... and to a certain extent it's hard not to believe that the fix is in and there is corruption and there is corruption at top”
Regulatory complexity and environmental regulations have been weaponized by diverse interest groups (particularly Democrats and progressive organizations) to prevent construction projects, causing infrastructure delays; Mark Duneier's book 'Why Nothing Works' argues the Democratic Party became the party of veto coalitions that stop things from being built.
“a guy who has written a book his name is Mark duneman and the book is called why nothing works and his argument is that the Democratic party kind of became the party of lots of different interest groups that all had a stake in preventing things from happening especially using environmental regulations and other kinds of regulatory uh tactics to stop things from being built”
The bottom 60% of Americans have received no improvement in standard of living or life prospects from either party in recent decades, so they vote based on cultural proximity and values rather than policy, and the Republican Party now seems closer to them on those dimensions.
“if neither party is really able to improve the standard of living and the life prospects of the bottom 60% let's say then that bottom 60% is going to vote on who seems closest to them in terms of just values culture uh social issues even language and that's become more and more the Republican party”
Harris made a mistake by being too careful and refusing to subject herself to difficult questions from the beginning, which allowed Trump to define her without response.
“I think being too careful being afraid to give interviews subject herself to difficult questions from the very beginning and to maybe piss off a few Democratic constituencies”
When Obama criticized younger Black voters, he attributed their lack of support to sexism and unwillingness to vote for a woman, but this approach of moral hectoring is politically ineffective and alienates voters rather than persuading them.
“I don't think it's a very effective way to persuade people it's like hectoring them and telling them you're bad you need to get better you need to be better it's like the basket of deplorables or clinging to guns and religion it's it's a kind of way of speaking down which Barack Obama didn't do as president he spoke to us as fellow citizens but every now and then he gets professorial and it doesn't work politically I don't think”
Packer's Atlantic article was titled 'The End of Democratic Delusions' and focused on specific delusions Democrats held going into the 2024 election, particularly the misinterpretation of what Trump voters meant by citing democracy as an important issue.
“George wrote a piece about the election uh which was an eyeopener for me the end of democratic delusions and he meant Democratic as in the Democratic party but one of the delusions that he writes about is the delusion that I had”
Trump won the 2024 popular vote by only 1%, and Harris faced multiple structural disadvantages including Biden's delayed exit from the race (only 107 days before the election versus Humphrey's 8-9 months in 1968), the lack of an open primary process that confirmed public cynicism about elite-controlled parties, and the lingering effects of 2022 inflation at 9.1%.
“Trump win the popular vote by oh 1% yeah 1% so it was it was a close election by by traditional standards”
Trump voters who report democracy as an important issue do so not because they fear Trump will destroy democracy but because they believe democracy has already failed them under the current system, and they expect Trump to restore it to the people rather than preserve the existing institutions.
“asked by pollsters if they're concerned about the state of democracy these voters answer answer yes not because they fear its demise but because it has already failed them they don't think Trump will destroy democracy he'll restore it to the people”
The mechanisms that might prevent Trump from using federal law enforcement for retribution (loyal prosecutors and FBI field agents refusing to prosecute political enemies) are likely to be weak because Trump has appointed loyalists (Cash Patel at FBI, Pam Bondi as AG) and there are no clear institutional guardrails preventing politically motivated prosecutions.
“if you've got Trump in the White House cash Patel at the FBI Pam Bondi as the attorney general and a bunch of underlings they've appointed who are being appointed purely for their loyalty then where is the guardrail like what where's the US attorney or the FBI field agent who's going to say no there's just not anything on this person we're not going to do it”
Trump's core motivations are retribution (punishing enemies) and personal enrichment, neither of which serve the public interest, and this will become increasingly clear to the public as his presidency unfolds.
“Trump's two major goals and running again are retribution and enrichment neither which has a whole lot to do with the public interest”
Franken was one of the final 60 senators needed to pass the ACA, replacing Ted Kennedy after his death and obtaining the necessary vote before Scott Brown took the seat.
“I was sitting in the Senate Gallery in the Press row watching you guys take those votes and it was a a cliffhanger and yeah your Victory which you were the last of the 60 right right yeah yeah it was uh dramatic when I got when I got there Ted Kennedy was sick so we really had 59 until Paul Kirk replaced him after he had died right and then came Scott Brown”
After Romney's loss in 2012, the Republican Party's internal review concluded they needed to appeal to Latino and minority voters to survive, since the party was becoming the party of old white people and would be 'extinct pretty soon' without demographic change.
“which is why in 2012 after Romney lost the Republican Party looked Inward and said we need to do something different in order to win these Latino voters and minority voters in general were becoming a party of the old white people people and that means we're going to be extinct pretty soon”
Harris lost support among Black, Latino, and voters earning under $100,000, while gaining support among white voters and those earning over $100,000 compared to Biden in 2020, indicating a class-based realignment away from working-class voters.
“Harris increased support of white voters and voters making over $100,000 over Biden but the other categories black Latino and under 100,000 Trump did better so that those are indicators trajectories that any Democrat should be really worried about”
Packer spent significant time in Western North Carolina and Youngstown, Ohio (a steel city abandoned by the steel industry and government) where resentment against the establishment is particularly acute.
“and is is this particularly felt in uh rural areas where that you visited after the Great Recession right yes oh I spent a lot of time in Western North Carolina in even an urban area like Youngstown Ohio where it was also felt because steel steel city that had been abandoned by the steel industry and and by government yeah”
Obama's Affordable Care Act was the last major act of the Roosevelt Republic, occurring late in the era and facing significant opposition before eventually passing through reconciliation in the Senate.
“let's say that healthc care was maybe the last Act of the Roosevelt Republic quite late later these things aren't don't have neat beginnings and endings”
Harris employed a 'politics of Joy' messaging strategy that did not resonate with voters because the host's reporting found Americans were not feeling joy but rather anxiety and economic distress.
“I think the politics of Joy was was not right I think that was uh I was very skeptical when I started Ed hearing about uh Joy because I'd been doing some reporting this year and I was finding something other than joy”
The Democratic Party installed Harris without a primary process, which confirmed the cynical public view that political parties are a game played by elites for their own benefit, replicating the same dynamic that hurt Hubert Humphrey when elites installed him over Eugene McCarthy in 1968.
“LBJ dropped out in March but it was similar it was similar in that you could say the party Elites installed Humphrey uh instead of your fellow Minnesotan Eugene McCarthy and the party Elites installed Harris and in that way the deck was stacked against her too because the the public already thinks that political parties are a a game played by Elites for their own benefit so without the primary process it seemed to confirm this kind of cynical view of Party politics”
Democrats should focus their opposition on regulating out-of-control corporations, particularly tech corporations and social media platforms, because this issue has the potential to split Republicans (appealing to populist elements) and divide Trump's inner circle (especially between JD Vance and Elon Musk).
“I think regulating outof control corporations which does split the Republican Party to some extent because they do have this populist Wing that's come up lately especially Tech corporations social media platforms I think that's a very ripe Target for Democrats um to to go for because it also it divides Trump's Inner Circle it divides JD Vance from Elon Musk and that's democrats should always be trying to to split them off”
Trump's cabinet appointments reveal his true priorities—retribution against enemies (Liz Cheney, Adam Schiff) and enrichment of himself and his family—with no genuine interest in governing or making the government function, and appointees like Tulsi Gabbard, Elon Musk, RFK Jr., Matt Gaetz, and Cash Patel were selected for loyalty rather than competence.
“Trump's two major goals and running again are retribution and enrichment neither which has a whole lot to do with the public interest and the people he's naming for his cinet what do you think of the people he's been picking it's frightening...this is nakedly about loyalty to Trump and the use of government for personal purposes retribution and enrichment that's all it is and it's it could not be clearer”
The Democratic platform was excessively narrow and targeted, offering attractive but incremental economic policies (like down-payment assistance for first-time homebuyers) while failing to evoke the emotional resonance and sense of systemic change that mobilizes voters.
“they were giving them a a menu of of relatively small boore policies and then she did the thing which was describing the the plures she was wasn't she didn't mean that was deplorable people she meant that characteristic of deplorable...emotions are powerful and policies are less powerful and in terms of emotion I think neither Harris nor Clinton tapped into the way people were feeling about the country instead they were giving them a a menu of of relatively small boore policies”
Career federal employees face a dilemma: many will consider quitting to prevent Trump's abuses, but most will stay because federal government jobs offer decent pay, security, benefits, and pensions, plus the illusion that staying might prevent worse outcomes—a rationalization that enables institutional rot.
“will there be one in January it's probably a little harder than it sounds because it's a decent job it's secure it's got benefits and pensions and even the illusion that yeah you can maybe be there to help prent the worst people always convince themselves of of that if I go then it'll get worse so I have to stick around”
The host (Al Franken) confesses that hearing Packer's article was an 'eyeopener' and made him realize that his own interpretation of polling data about democracy was incorrect, demonstrating how media and political elites can miss basic facts about voter sentiment despite paying close attention.
“you know for a change because one of my favorite writers George Packer of the atlantic is my guest George wrote a piece about the election uh which was an eyeopener for me the end of democratic delusions”
Biden had severely limited rhetorical capacity and essentially stopped speaking publicly after the 2022 midterms, making it impossible for him to claim credit for his policies; voters in Phoenix reported Biden 'never came up' in their conversations, as if he didn't exist for them.
“Biden could not give a speech and meanwhile inflation would was going wait a minute what do you mean Biden could not give a spech he couldn't talk he he just had no rhetorical force and he stopped speaking eventually I mean he really rarely spoke publicly uh after the midterms he kind of disappeared I went to I wrote a long piece about Phoenix for the Atlantic last summer about them baking out there yeah it was5 degrees um many days I asked a local Democratic legis later what do your constituents think of Biden and she said he never comes up like they just don't mention him he didn't exist for them”
Trump's 'Make America Great Again' narrative appeals to people feeling left behind by saying 'we're going to go backward to a time when you The Real Americans were at the center of things,' tapping a reactionary nostalgia for status and centrality rather than offering forward-looking policy.
“that's why Trump by saying make America great again is saying we're going to go backward to a time when you The Real Americans were at the center of things”
Democrats are now in the minority in both the House and Senate, limiting their ability to pass legislation, so they should focus on regulating out-of-control corporations (particularly Big Tech and social media platforms), which both appeals to populist sentiment and creates divisions within Trump's coalition (e.g., between JD Vance and Elon Musk).
“I think regulating outof control corporations which does split the Republican Party to some extent because they do have this populist Wing that's come up lately especially Tech corporations social media platforms I think that's a very ripe Target for Democrats um to to go for because it also it divides Trump's Inner Circle it divides JD Vance from Elon Musk and that's democrats should always be trying to to split them off”
The Arab American vote loss in Michigan—through defections to Jill Stein, direct support for Trump, or staying home—played a critical role in Trump's victory in that state, which was the second-closest swing state after Wisconsin.
“Michigan of course there was there was that so how many of the Muslims in Michigan voted for Jill Stein I don't know but it's pretty clear that Michigan was I think the second closest of the Swing States after Wisconsin...the Arab American vote that went for Jill Stein or for Donald Trump or stayed home must have played a pretty big role”
Bidenomics—policies including the CHIPS Act, infrastructure investment, and manufacturing job creation—was sound economic policy but provided no political benefit because infrastructure projects have long lead times (bridges now take ~10 years to build) and the benefits were not visible to voters during the 2024 campaign.
“there was a real bid nomics and I I actually thought it was a great Economic Policy which was to bring back manufacturing to bring jobs to oh he did that and he's bring the chips act and uh infrastructure uh piece the biggest infrastructure since uh since Eisenhower but I didn't see the benefit from that we didn't see the political benefit from that...it has kind of a long delay effect like sure infrastructure and and factories that make microchip the bridge doesn't go up in a month right in fact these days a bridge takes about 10 years”
Packer wrote a long article for the New Yorker titled 'The Empty Chamber' about the Senate, observing that senators were rarely present except at key moments like the healthcare votes, indicating institutional dysfunction and lack of deliberation.
“I was sitting in the Senate Gallery in the Press row watching you guys take those votes and it was a a cliffhanger and yeah your Victory which you were the last of the 60 right right yeah yeah it was uh dramatic when I got when I got there Ted Kennedy was sick so we really had 59 until Paul Kirk replaced him after he had died right and then came Scott Brown and then Obama used what's the name of that trick that parliamentary it's reconciliation I was in the uh I was in the damn Senate I know reconciliation you know I remember watching that vividly because I was also writing about the sen at the time for the New Yorker I wrote a long article about the Senate that was called The Empty chamber because you guys never were around listening to each other except at Key moments like on health care and what I remember is silence I couldn't quite hear what you were saying but every now and then a laugh coming from Senator Franken”
The Affordable Care Act was the 'last Act of the Roosevelt Republic,' representing the end of an era where Democrats could achieve major expansions of government's role, as the political climate had shifted decisively against this model by the early 2010s.
“let's say that healthc are was maybe the last Act of the Roosevelt Republic quite late later these things aren't don't have neat beginnings and endings”
Trump will now enact tax cuts similar to his 2017 tax cut, which primarily benefited the wealthy, even though working-class voters who switched to Trump believed they were voting against a system that benefits elites, creating a fundamental contradiction between voter expectations and actual policy outcomes.
“I also believe that now that Trump has won he is going to get his and and they have the Congress that he is going to get his tax cut that's going to be just like the one in 2017 which really go to those at the top yep yep so the people who are voting against Democrats because they take care of the wealthy don't realize that uh the Republicans uh that's that is their main job”
There is a pattern of globalization and information technology creating winners and losers in the American economy, with wealth concentrated in major metropolitan areas (computer programmers, media types, professors) and decline visible just 20 miles beyond city limits.
“globalization and information have produced a lot of wealth but once you get beyond that you don't have to drive very far if you drive like 20 miles in any direction from a major city you pretty quickly start seeing certain yeah kind of Decay”
There have been distinct political eras in American history dominated by particular ideologies: the Roosevelt Republic (New Deal through 1970s focusing on expanding social welfare and rights), the Reagan era (1980s-2008 emphasizing free markets, free trade, low taxes, and deregulation), and now the Trump era representing a new reactionary period.
“as the piece says there's been these periods in which a kind of U political ideology dominated and earlier in my life it was sort of the tail end of the Roosevelt Republic I call it that went from the New Deal to like the 70s till Reagan...Reagan are you better off than you were four years ago and Ronald Reagan and the Reagan Revolution as it was called called really began a new period I think and it it too lasted several decades”
Harris made a critical error by being overly cautious and avoiding difficult interviews or positions that might alienate Democratic constituencies, which signaled weakness and prevented her from reaching voters who needed to hear her directly challenge the system.
“I think being too careful being afraid to give interviews subject herself to difficult questions from the very beginning and to maybe piss off a few Democratic constituencies well Michigan of course there was there was that”
Trump is unpredictable on tariffs—he doesn't care about policy consistency and will reverse positions if they seem advantageous to him, though tariffs would likely increase prices and cause inflation if implemented broadly.
“I doubt it really I I mean Trump doesn't care about anything except himself and if tariffs suddenly seem bad for Trump well just increased prices in in the United States I mean just inflationary right I don't know what he's gonna do with tariffs I don't know anything about tariffs all I know is Trump doesn't give a damn about what he said five minutes ago if what he's saying now seems like it's going to get him what he wants”
Packer spent significant time in Western North Carolina and Youngstown, Ohio (a steel city abandoned by industry and government) and found that the resentment and feeling of being left behind by globalization is pervasive outside major metropolitan areas.
“I spent a lot of time in Western North Carolina in even an urban area like Youngstown Ohio where it was also felt because steel steel city that had been abandoned by the steel industry and and by government”
A core driver of voter resentment is the perception that elites profit from all government and policy decisions while ordinary people have no say, a feeling that is partially true (there is corruption at the top and billionaires have disproportionate influence) but exaggerated by the media environment and grievance politics.
“the feeling that uh the elites are controlling things is that Elites are making more money than I am they're they benefit from any decisions that are made in Congress by the White House and that I don't have a say in that I think that's a common feeling I think it's not totally true and let's remember that there are Elites in Trump's Camp too”
Tech moguls supporting Trump and seeking government positions are 'salivating' at the prospect of access to government and public coffers, and while they claim to want a more 'efficient' government, a more Trump-friendly efficient government will likely benefit them through favorable regulation and access to public resources.
“they're going to be at the trough of the public coffers for the next four years and uh these are people who really don't know how the government works so what they're trying to do is get rid of the deep State and use this for revenge and getting rid of the people who've been running the government and replacing them with people who will answer uh Donald Trump...what do you want to bet that a more efficient government is a government that benefits them”
Packer wrote a piece for the Atlantic last summer about Phoenix, Arizona, finding that local Democratic legislators reported their constituents never mention Biden—he doesn't exist in their political consciousness—which was before Biden dropped out of the race.
“I went to I wrote a long piece about Phoenix for the Atlantic last summer about them baking out there yeah it was5 degrees um many days I asked a local Democratic legis later what do your constituents think of Biden and she said he never comes up like they just don't mention him he didn't exist for them this was before he dropped out”
The FTC chair Lina Khan pushed lawsuits against Google and other major tech corporations, but the Biden administration didn't fully capitalize on antitrust enforcement as a political narrative, and Trump's administration is unlikely to continue this work despite having donors who benefit from tech deregulation.
“when we had the majority in the Senate and the house and uh Biden in there that we could have addressed that kind of that stuff and we had uh you know the Ft uh FTC yeah uh chair lenina Khan yeah I thought more would come of that but well it it didn't I mean I think they did push some things they brought lawsuits against Google um and other big Tech corporations”
Biden had severe rhetorical limitations—he could not give effective speeches and had no rhetorical force—which prevented him from claiming credit for Bidenomics or other achievements, and he largely disappeared from public communication after the 2022 midterms.
“Biden could not give a speech he couldn't talk he he just had no rhetorical force and he stopped speaking eventually I mean he really rarely spoke publicly uh after the midterms he kind of disappeared”
Barack Obama's attribution of Black male voters' defection from Harris to sexism and discomfort with a Black woman president was politically ineffective because it amounts to hectoring voters about their moral failures rather than engaging with their actual grievances.
“he attributed it to not liking the idea of a black woman president I think or a woman president he sexism and and that may be true I don't know there are a lot of different individuals out there you can't generalize but I don't think it's a very effective way to persuade people it's it's like hectoring them and telling them you're bad you need to get better you need to be better”
Donor interests talk louder than populist base interests in Republican politics, so Trump may side with his billionaire donors on corporate regulation rather than with his populist base.
“we'll see if Trump goes with his base or his donors my guess is donors talk”
Political parties and political elites are already perceived by the public as 'a game played by Elites for their own benefit,' so when the Democratic party elite installs a candidate without a primary process (as happened with Harris in 2024), it directly confirms this cynical public view.
“the public already thinks that political parties are a a game played by Elites for their own benefit so without the primary process it seemed to confirm this kind of cynical view of Party politics”
It is unfair and troubling that two exceptionally impressive and qualified women (Hillary Clinton and Kamala Harris) have been defeated by Trump, who Packer characterizes as a 'degenerate man,' suggesting something is fundamentally wrong with the country's willingness to elevate men over women in politics.
“how unfair and awful a thing it is that two very impressive women have been defeated by a degenerate Man twice right it just says something that I don't like about about the country that that's happened it doesn't mean we're hopeless misogynous it just means there is something that isn't working yet it isn't rising to meet history about us”
Hillary Clinton's 'basket of deplorables' comment was misinterpreted by some as describing people as deplorable (immoral, contemptible), when she meant it as a descriptor of characteristics, but this distinction was lost in perception and the comment signaled to voters that Democratic elites looked down on them.
“she is a status quo establishment Democratic candidate who couldn't imagine saying anything that might go against exactly where the party establishment yeah her proposals were money so you could buy your first house I mean they were attractive economic policies weren't they they were good policies Hillary Clinton had some good policies in 2016 I interviewed her just before the election and we went over some of her economic policies and they were you could say they were populist but a no one knew about them B emotions are powerful and policies are less powerful and in terms of emotion I think neither Harris nor Clinton tapped into the way people were feeling about the country instead they were giving them a a menu of of relatively small boore policies and then she did the thing which was describing the the plures she was wasn't she didn't mean that was deplorable people she meant that characteristic of deplorable I really believe that”
Trump was the subject of two assassination attempts, including one that actually grazed him, which could be considered politically significant though the exact weight of this factor in voters' calculations is unclear.
“he also got was the subject of two assassination plots and including one that actually hit him in the head you could say could say”
Franken recalls hearing Senator Al Franken laugh during the Senate gallery (the pun is that Franken is talking about himself in the third person here), which made the sound audible across the entire gallery, confirming Franken's presence during the health care votes.
“that made it all across the gallery there was no doubt you were there because I heard your laugh um and that punctuated all those um dramatic Maneuvers over Healthcare well I have an easy laugh it's easy to get me to laugh yeah comedians like me”
The Obama administration's attempt to credit-claim for policies is complicated by the fact that Barack Obama occasionally becomes 'professorial' in his communication style, which 'doesn't work politically,' in contrast to his more effective approach as president of speaking to citizens as equals.
“but every now and then he gets professorial and it doesn't work politically I don't think well that's uh that was a very small uh misstep yes there it did not change the result”