YouTube31m· Aug 2023· cataloged

Countries are souring on the US dollar. Is dedollarization really a risk? | Peter Zeihan


What this covers

This is a roughly half-hour interview from Straight Arrow News, timed to the BRICS Summit, in which Peter Zeihan is asked whether de-dollarization is a real threat. Much of the argument is historical. He traces reserve currency status through Spain, whose silver-backed money was wrecked by inflation from the Potosi mines, and Britain, whose pound lasted 150 years because it was the only industrial power. He then turns to Bretton Woods, which he describes less as a negotiation than as the result of US dominance. The US offered to protect Europe, supply dollars, and patrol the oceans in exchange for anti-Soviet security coordination. Interviewer questions cite the dollar's slide from 71 percent of world reserves to under 59 percent.

The middle of the conversation goes through the candidates one by one. The euro lost credibility when the EU confiscated insured deposits during the banking crisis, and it has fallen from first to about fifth in trade finance. The yen failed in the 1980s because Japan would not open its financial sector. The Yuan remains well below its pre-financial-crisis share of China's trade. Zeihan also discusses a supranational alternative, arguing it would be either corrupt or captured by one country, and Britain's proposal at Bretton Woods that the US lend it all its gold at zero interest for 50 years. A more contested claim is that the real benefit of reserve status is the ability to export inflation and debt, and that the Federal Reserve could offset a Chinese bond dump by expanding the money supply.

The last stretch covers crypto, where Congressman Brad Sherman calls it a pyramid scheme and a "garden of snakes." Zeihan argues that fixed-supply currencies leave no one responsible for withdrawing liquidity. He closes on demographic decline in Germany, Japan, South Korea, China, and Italy, and on the breakdown of globalization, which he says leaves the US, the G20 country least dependent on trade, relatively well placed.

Sharpest takeaway

De-dollarization is a cyclical concern driven by geopolitical frustration rather than economic viability; the U.S. dollar will remain the global reserve currency because no alternative currency can meet the structural requirements of scale, reliability, and political neutrality that reserve currency status demands.

  • Every alternative currency (euro, pound, yuan) has failed or cannot function as a reserve currency due to political control issues or lack of volume
  • The U.S. has structural advantages (healthiest demography in G20, largest economy, rule of law, least dependent on trade) that no competitor possesses
  • A true global alternative would require either an independent authority (inducing corruption) or subordination to some country's control (making it useless to others)

The claims · ranked43 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

The U.S. government, unlike crypto, is responsible for regulating a $23 trillion domestic economic system and managing roughly $25 trillion in global trade, which requires a monetary authority capable of expanding and shrinking the money supply as necessary to maintain stability.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Peter Zeihan

“the government is also responsible for regulating a 23 trillion dollar economic system and managing roughly 25 trillion dollars in global trade so the scale and the reach and the active management that is required to do that also requires a monetary Authority that can expand and Shrink the monetary Supply as is necessary one of the many many many many many many things that the crypto Bros Miss is that the money supply is not a one-directional thing and if the entire money supply is held by private interests who has to give it up when it's time to go the other direction and who decides who has to give it up”

0.80

The Bretton Woods system changed global demographic structures by urbanizing and industrializing populations, causing children to shift from being free labor (7+ children per family in pre-industrial agriculture) to expensive dependents in urban settings (now less than 2 children per family globally), fundamentally altering the economic model for the next 75 years.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Peter Zeihan

“one of the many many outcomes of the Bretton Woods Accords is it change demographic structures because in the pre-industrial world we all lived on farms and kids were free labor so you'd have as many as you could stand plus one because that's how you find out it's too many um but as we urbanized and industrialized and started taking industrial jobs and we moved into towns where kids become really expensive Conversation Pieces so we went from on average around the world having seven of them today having less than two”

0.74

The European Union's euro was the closest competitor to the dollar, but during the 2000s banking crisis the EU confiscated insured bank deposits to pay for bailouts, which destroyed confidence in the currency's reliability; as a result, the euro has declined from the number one trade finance currency to approximately number five.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Peter Zeihan

“the closest wasn't very close but the closest was the European Union's Euro but then back in the 2000s when they had their banking crisis They confiscated insured Bank deposits to pay for the bailouts now if they had to do that for political reasons but that meant economically that no one would ever use the euro ever again if they could help it and as a result the Euro has gone from the number one trade Finance currency to I think their number five now”

0.74

Spain's reserve currency status was based on silver from the Potosi mines in Bolivia, which produced more silver than the rest of the world combined, causing severe inflation as Spanish monetary authorities directly mined the currency they used, disrupting supply chains and creating both supply and demand-side inflation.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Peter Zeihan

“you had Spain which was basically a a metals-based currency based off the Potosi Silver Mines in what is today Bolivia and for several decades the Potosi mine produced more silver than the rest of the world combined and so we got the worst kind of inflation you can possibly imagine out of that silver was available in limited quality and so if you wanted to have trade you had to get silver which push up the value of the currency but the Spanish were literally mining the currency and whenever the Spanish had an interest they would go into a local market and buy up whatever they needed equipment steel ships men whatever to launch Wars so you got disruption you got supply side inflation you got demand side inflation at the same time you had Global disconnects and disruptions”

0.74

When Nixon ended the gold standard in the early 1970s, the Treasury Secretary stated 'it's our currency, it's your problem' because the alternative for everyone else was worse, and this situation persists today despite dollar weaponization.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Peter Zeihan

“what happened during the Nixon period when we decided to go off the gold standard there weren't conversations about that internationally the Nixon Administration just decided almost overnight that we're going to move off and go to a full float and in the words of the treasury secretary at the time it's our currency it's your problem because the alternative for everyone else was worse still is today”

0.72

The real superpower of reserve currency status is that it allows the US to avoid fiscal responsibility by exporting inflation and debt to other countries, not military or geopolitical power.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Peter Zeihan

“that's probably the real superpower it allows us to not be fiscally responsible”

0.72

The fundamental problem with fixed-supply currencies (like cryptocurrency) is that if the entire money supply is held by private interests, no one is responsible for withdrawing liquidity when the cycle turns, and no mechanism exists to decide who must surrender currency when contraction is needed.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Peter Zeihan

“one of the many many many many many many things that the crypto Bros Miss is that the money supply is not a one-directional thing and if the entire money supply is held by private interests who has to give it up when it's time to go the other direction and who decides who has to give it up”

0.69

To serve as the world's dominant reserve currency, a country's currency must be absolutely massive in circulation to lubricate every transaction on the planet, and the country must not care about the currency's daily value or it will manipulate exchange rates for trade purposes, causing others to avoid using it.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“there's a couple of things that you have to guarantee if you even want to consider playing that role number one your current the currency you have that's in circulation that's internationally available has to be absolutely massive because you have to be able to lubricate every transaction on the planet whether it's Financial trade or otherwise second you have to not care at all what happens to the value of your currency on any given day because if you go in and actively manipulate the exchange rates for trade purposes say then no one's going to use your currency”

0.69

The euro was the most prominent alternative currency to the dollar, but it is nowhere near replacing it; the next candidates (pound and yen) are non-contenders, making the dollar still the dominant reserve currency with no serious competitor.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“color me a skeptic look I think the say is the most predominant currency outside of the US dollar that everyone's saying this could replace it well people talk about the Yuan but it will never be that it was the euro until the financial crisis and then that went away the next one Downs the pound and until brexit has figured out one way or another it's a non-canidate the Japanese tried to internalize yeah excuse me the the Japanese tried to internationalize back in the 1980s and got burned”

0.69

Japan attempted to internationalize the yen in the 1980s but failed because Japan was unwilling to open its financial sector, and Japan will never play a reserve currency role again because it will never accept the financial openness requirement.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“the Japanese tried to internalize yeah excuse me the the Japanese tried to internationalize back in the 1980s and got burned because like the Japanese they weren't willing to open their financial sector and they will never play that role again”

0.69

Reserve currency dominance provides the United States with a capital account and monetary flexibility, but this also makes it harder to regulate the US financial system because of hot money flows going both directions.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“it's not as much as you might think because it requires you have a capital account which makes it more difficult to regulate your own Financial system you have a lot of hot money going both ways but it does mean that there is a stability injected into your system and that stability allows you a lot more ballast”

0.68

Britain proposed at Bretton Woods that the pound remain the reserve currency if the U.S. would lend Britain all of its gold at zero percent interest for 50 years—a proposal no one considered viable because Britain lacked the volume to support such a currency.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Peter Zeihan

“the only other serious proposal on the table was the Brits were saying hey how about we use the pound but we have to be able to support that because we don't have the volume anymore so how about the United States lends us all of their gold at zero percent interest for 50 years and we use the pound and um you know no one seemed to think that that was a viable option”

0.66

At the Bretton Woods conference during World War II, the United States was the only country with real negotiating power because other nations would have faced consequences if they disagreed with the U.S., making the resulting dollar-based system less a negotiated agreement and more a natural consequence of military and economic dominance.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Peter Zeihan

“so remember the context of Bretton Woods those talks began while World War II was still going on so if the Brits or the Dutch or someone else had tried to stick it to the United States on financial terms the U.S could barely use is it okay um well a you would clearly can't read a map so we're just going to let the Germans hang on to that chunk while we work with the rest so you know everyone was going to do whatever the United States said at that deal”

0.66

The British pound was the dominant reserve currency for 150 years because Britain was the only industrial power during that period, and without industrial competition, Britain was the largest economy by far and could ignore daily currency fluctuations that might affect trade.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Peter Zeihan

“for 150 years the United Kingdom was the only industrial power the reason the Brits did so well for so long is they literally brought guns to knife fights for a century and a half and when you have one industrial power and everyone else is non-industrial they were the largest economy by far and so they didn't care what the value of the trade was on any given day”

0.65

Most of the advanced world ran out of children 40 years ago, and during this decade most will run out of working-age adults, with Germany, South Korea, Italy, China, and Japan being furthest along in this demographic decline.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“the advanced World ran out of children 40 years ago this decade most of the advanced world runs out of working age adults with the Germans and the Koreans and the Italians and the Chinese and the Japanese furthest along”

0.64

China has not returned to the high levels of trade handled in yuan that it used to have before the financial crisis; it remains well below those historical levels even with all the de-dollarization talk.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Peter Zeihan

“even today with all this talk they're nowhere near the high level that they used to have for the percentage of their trade that was handled in Yuan they're not even back to where they were before the financial crisis”

0.64

The US dollar has declined from 71 percent of all world reserve currencies to under 59 percent, representing a significant shift away from dollar dominance.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unnamed interviewer

“there's certainly been a movement away from the dollar from the time the euro launched in 99 as far as world Reserve currencies being held the dollar went from 71 percent of all World Reserve currencies to now it's under 59 percent”

0.60

The U.S. offered at Bretton Woods to protect Europe, provide dollars for their financial systems, and patrol global oceans for trade in exchange for allowing European security forces to coordinate with the U.S. for countering the Soviets—a security agreement Europeans broadly favored.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Peter Zeihan

“we said that we will protect you and we will provide our currency to service your systems and we will use our Navy to patrol the global ocean so that global trade can happen for the first time if in exchange you allow your security forces to be put under ours for purposes of countering the Soviets so for a security agreement that the Europeans were broadly in favor of”

0.56

While large portions of U.S. debt are held abroad, the U.S. federal reserve controls the U.S. money supply (mostly digital), so even if China dumped all $3 trillion in bond holdings, the Fed could expand the money supply by exactly that amount and retire the debt instantly, while China would lose $2 trillion in value.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Peter Zeihan

“every once in a while there's this delightful conversation uh between some wakadu Chinese ideologue in the U.S fed in St Louis where the wackadu island says you know you know if we really want to stick to the United States we're just going to dump all three trillion dollars of our uh Bond Holdings overnight and you always get the same snarky response from the St Louis fed that some something like well you know that would be really interesting because the uh the debt would probably trade at 30 cents on the dollar very very quickly but I don't know if you knew this China but the U.S federal reserve controls the U.S money supply and it's mostly digital now so we would just like click a couple buttons and expand the money supply by the exact number of that 3 trillion discounted 70 and retire the whole thing you would save us over two trillion dollars in an hour and you would be out over 2 trillion dollars in an hour”

0.55

Any independent global currency authority would be the most corrupt system imaginable, as countries would bribe it to serve their interests; alternatively, if one country manages the currency, that country uses it for its own benefit and everyone else is excluded—creating an impossible choice.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Peter Zeihan

“so then the question becomes whose control is it under because as if it's an independent Authority wow the best way to get what you want for your country is to bribe the hell out of that Authority and that's one of the reasons why this just can't work you can really only have one and Peter is this why the idea of the brics currency can't work because there's no possible way that it kind of can't be uh you know paid bought and paid for by somebody yeah I mean either it's independent in which case it's the most corrupt system you can imagine or one of the countries manages it in which case that country manages it for his or her own economy in which case everyone else is left on the outside”

0.55

Crypto advocates claim that crypto creates value out of thin air by making money and then getting people to buy it from them, which is fundamentally a pyramid scheme structure requiring constant new money to sustain value.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Brad Sherman (U.S. Congressman)

“crypto Bros make money literally by making money and they've made over a trillion dollars out of thin air um they'll accuse the U.S government of making money out of thin air maybe we do but we're the US government if you pass it but let's just use Bitcoin because most people are familiar with that one it's a little bit more sophisticated uh they they print currency out of thin air and then they get someone to buy it from them there's a second step there that's basically a pyramid scheme”

0.55

Crypto is fundamentally a garden of snakes, lacking the legal, regulatory, and enforcement infrastructure that makes government currencies functional as media of exchange, and cannot prevent drug dealers and tax evaders from using the system.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Brad Sherman (U.S. Congressman)

“crypto is a garden of snakes they do not play at prevent drug dealers from being able to get uh their uh Financial transactions handled Arena”

0.52

Financial sanctions weaponized the US dollar against a significant state (Russia) for the first time, which is why de-dollarization talk has intensified—countries are concerned about dollar dominance being used as a geopolitical weapon.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“the financial sanctions actually weaponized the US dollar really for the first time against a significant State I mean when you do it against Iran and North Korea it's really pretty small for it doesn't matter Russia Russia matters”

0.52

Globalization is currently breaking down, and the United States is already the major G20 country least involved in international trade, meaning the U.S. is in a position of advantage as global trade systems fragment and countries retreat into more localized or regional trade.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“we are now entering a period where globalization is breaking down and the United States was already of the major countries the one least involved in trade so again at this moment the United States is the only one on the board”

0.52

The problem with expecting imminent change to the dollar system is that the United States and Mexico have two of the healthiest demographics in the world, meaning the country that benefits most from the current system and is most able to maintain it without changing rules has no incentive to adopt something new.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“the problem with saying that that change is going to be front loaded is that the United States and Mexico are two of the healthiest demographies in the world and that's where the currency is headquartered so for the country that benefits the most from this system and is most able to maintain it without changing the rules of the game there's not really an impetus to go for something new”

0.52

Before a meaningful transition away from the dollar can occur, countries like Germany, Japan, and South Korea will have to figure out a post-consumption economic model and a post-export economic model, which we cannot yet predict the parameters of.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“we have to wait for these other countries to figure out what is a post-consumption economic structure what is a post export economic structure and until that is figured out we won't know what kind of the parameters are of the new economic model and only then can we start talking about currency”

0.52

The U.S. dollar is supported by three key structural advantages: the healthiest demography of all G20 countries except Argentina, the largest economy by far, and rule of law, while competing currencies fail to satisfy even one of these categories much less all three.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“the United States has the healthiest demography of all of the G20 countries except for Argentina it's the largest economy by far it's the least involved in international trade and it has rule of law so you might not like the United States for this that or the other reason but from a mechanical point of view of what makes a good currency no one else even scratches one of those categories much less all three”

0.50

Even in the worst-case scenario where a competitor currency takes over global reserve status, the primary cost to the U.S. would be forced fiscal responsibility—the country would no longer be able to dump debt onto the international system and would have to balance its budget.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“there is a cost in that scenario that would probably Force our political leaders to be a little bit more judicious with their spending in the long run because we wouldn't be able to just dump our debt on everyone else's system that's probably the real superpower it allows us to not be fiscally responsible”

0.49

De-dollarization concerns recur cyclically every six to nine months whenever the United States does something annoying to a country or when a country thinks it has found a way to replace the dollar, but these efforts have never amounted to anything.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Peter Zeihan

“this is something that pops up from time to time whenever the United States does something that some country finds annoying or whenever some country thinks that they found a way to crack the code it has never amounted to anything but we'd go through this every six to nine months”

0.49

The BRICS countries collectively have a network where Russia and Nigeria compete, Russia and Saudi Arabia have a fraught relationship, Russia and India don't trade, India and China don't trust each other, and China won't allow the coordination needed to make anything move—leaving Brazil and South Africa isolated.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Peter Zeihan

“we've got RNC whose relationship is a trist we've got R and S who compete we've got r and i who don't trade I and C who don't trust C won't let enough happen to make anything move and that just leaves B and S”

0.48

Reserve currencies in history average about a century in power, and the U.S. dollar is approaching that point, raising questions about whether another currency will rise and take its place.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“if we look at the timelines of Reserve currencies in history I would say they average about a century in power the U.S is kind of getting up to that point now so why is it so out there for you to think that another currency is going to rise and take its place”

0.48

The Federal Reserve is not staffed to monitor all global monetary exchanges, so the U.S. does not routinely interrupt international transactions unless a specific sanctions regime is in place, but the U.S. has the option and optionality is valuable in a world of demographic decline and geopolitical upheaval.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“now the FED is not staffed to monitor Global monetary exchanges so we don't do that unless there's a specific sanctions regime in place but we have the option and in a world of demographic decline in geopolitical upheaval options are good”

0.48

Many countries don't publish their full currency reserve data for national security reasons, so the reported IMF data on reserve currency composition is incomplete and requires careful interpretation beyond face value.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“well it's remember that a lot of countries don't publish their full currency Reserve data for national security reasons but if you look at even what is reported it's not so much that the dollar has fallen a long way it's the euro is basically vanished”

0.47

The European Union made the decision during the Russia sanctions to align the euro legally as a subsidiary of the U.S. dollar system, moving it into lockstep with the dollar and yen, meaning anyone seeking an alternative currency system must now build one outside the control of the three biggest currency blocks and the three largest economies.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“the Europeans made the decision as part of that process to basically make the Euro from a legal point of view a subsidiary of the U.S dollar system so you now have the three biggest currency blocks in the world the dollar the Euro and the Yen that have basically moved into lockstep and so if you want to have a currency system you have to have one that is now outside three of the four largest economies in the world”

0.47

China's primary concern is maintaining full control over its own financial system, which precludes the concept of an open international currency exchange, so China will never serve as the basis for a global reserve currency.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“the Chinese their first and foremost issue is about making sure that they have full control over their financial system that precludes the very concept of an open International is current currency exchange”

0.45

When Russia tried to pull yuan reserves out of China after depositing large amounts, the Chinese refused to return it, forcing Russia to go back to acquiring dollars on international black markets and flying gold around because these were the only viable alternatives.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Peter Zeihan

“one of the things that the Russians discovered when they dumped a much money into the yuan is they went back a few months later and tried to pull it out and the Chinese were like no no that's okay we don't want it back you can keep it and they had to go back to basically pulling dollars off of international exchanges on the black market uh and then flying gold around because it was really the only other option they had”

0.43

If the dollar lost reserve currency status and became merely a normal domestic currency, the U.S. would still retain 90% of its economy within U.S. borders and another 5% within Mexico and Canada, meaning only 5% of U.S. economic activity would be exposed to the wider world.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Zeihan

“if the dollar did break as the reserve currency overnight let's just say that happened uh then we're a normal currency and we're still the currency for the U.S domestic economy and roughly 90 of the US economies held within the United States and another five percent is held within Mexico and Canada so you only really have five percent exposure to The Wider world”

0.42

Bangladesh claims it will pay Russia in rubles for a nuclear power plant that it could never afford to build in the first place, making this a non-credible gesture since the project was already dead.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Peter Zeihan

“The Bangladesh deshis are saying that they will pay the Russians in Rubles for a nuclear power plant that they could never afford to build in the first place so it was already a dead project”

0.41

Russia and India got into an argument about a week and a half ago where neither side thought the other side's currency was worth anything, which dropped India out of the de-dollarization coalition.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Peter Zeihan

“the Russians and the Indians actually got into an argument about a week and a half ago about how neither side thought the other side's currency was worth anything and that dropped the Indians out of the coalition”

0.39

The US dollar is essentially the same whether digital (as a central bank digital currency) or paper; the question is whether there is a use case for a currency outside federal reserve control, and from the Fed's perspective, there currently is no such use case.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Peter Zeihan

“the idea of a central bank currency is really just a digital version of the paper currency and I would argue we're kind of going that way anyway um they don't even have checks in the United Kingdom anywhere and we're getting to a greater and greater percentage of transactions that are handled online the question is whether there's a use case for something that's separate and from the federal reserve's point of view there really isn't one at this point”

0.24

Argentina should never be looked to for financial guidance, as evidenced by their pattern of repeated financial defaults and mismanagement.

normativeestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Peter Zeihan

“you know at the top of the list the argentines say they're all in and I would argue that you should never look to the argentines for financial guidance unless you're looking for ways to you know do more truancy”

0.19

The fact that some major crypto exchange arena (Crypto.com Arena, formerly Staples Center) does not enforce basic legal concepts like know-your-customer requirements is a symbol of crypto culture's fundamental rejection of regulatory frameworks.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Brad Sherman (U.S. Congressman)

“my city the Lakers play at crypto Arena they do not play at know your customer Arena”

0.17

Congressman Sherman characterizes cryptocurrency as fundamentally volatile and unreliable, comparing cryptocurrencies to an 'electronic pet rock' as a metaphor for their lack of intrinsic utility.

normativespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Congressman Brad Sherman

“well right now it's not a currency at all right it's a pet an electronic pet rock”