What this covers

This is a 27-minute interview from PoliticsJOE with Paul Wallace, European economics editor at The Economist and author of Tanked. Wallace does nearly all the talking, with an interviewer prompting him. The conversation runs from Britain's postwar economic history to the current government's fiscal bind. Its central question is why growth has stalled. Wallace cites growth of about 3% a year before 2007 falling to little more than 1% from 2007 to 2022, and per-capita growth dropping from around 2.5% to under 0.5%. He points to productivity growth, which the Royal Statistical Society named the statistic of the decade, as the underlying culprit.

The range after that is wide. On the political side, he treats Liz Truss's mini budget as a loss of confidence comparable to the 1976 IMF crisis, and argues that financial markets matter because they are the government's creditors. He also notes that think tanks warned about thin fiscal headroom before the election. Brexit gets a historical framing: Britain's absence from the European project in the 1950s, and a referendum he calls frivolous and ignorant of that history. He also argues the exit weakened sterling and made Britons poorer.

Several of his positions are contested. He argues for infrastructure funded by borrowing, with the case that markets will tolerate debt that finances productive investment. He also says taxes probably need to rise further. On immigration, he judges it good on balance but not a fix for productivity, and says care-sector shortages should be met by raising pay. He also discusses the City of London, whose pre-crisis prosperity he calls partly meretricious, and manufacturing, which he says is still larger than financial services. He singles out life sciences, citing GSK and AstraZeneca, as a real strength worth backing with an aligned industrial strategy.

Sharpest takeaway

Britain's poor economic performance since 2008 stems from a fundamental collapse in productivity growth driven by decades of underinvestment in physical infrastructure, human capital, and skills—not from recent political decisions alone—requiring sustained, consistent government strategy rather than electoral-cycle policy shifts.

  • UK GDP growth fell from ~3% annually (pre-2007) to ~1% annually (2007-2022), with per-capita growth dropping from 2.5% to <0.5%, driven primarily by productivity collapse
  • Root causes are chronic underinvestment in physical capital (infrastructure, hospitals, water systems) and human capital (vocational training, skills development) that have been diagnosed for years but not remedied
  • Fixing these foundational issues requires consistent, long-term infrastructure spending and industrial strategy alignment rather than political quick-fixes or electoral-cycle chopping and changing

The claims · ranked39 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

A lack of investment in physical capital infrastructure (water systems, hospitals, buildings) and human capital (vocational training, skills development) is the root cause of Britain's productivity slowdown and poor economic performance.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Paul Wallace

“I think at the root of it is a lack of investment a lack of of physical investment in infrastructure we see this around the economy you know the uh the the state of of of our water you know on the public side the state of hospitals um and um and also you know very uh lackluster business investment um and so we're not we're not and that that's on on the physical Capital you know kit buildings but then you have people and and I mean it's clear that we just have such a big problem in in a lot of skills you know we're lacking we we we we let down people who uh who aren't necessarily going to go to university but or are going to do more want to do more vocationally oriented courses and and you know we have a we have a real skill shorted”

0.75

Consistent, long-term infrastructure spending creates planning certainty that allows the construction industry to invest in skills and personnel, whereas sporadic high-spending years fail because the industry cannot scale and plan effectively.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Paul Wallace

“you want to have a consistent stream of infrastructure projects going through and then the construction industry can plan for that and can uh can invest itself in the skills it needs in the people it needs so it's it's you know it's we want to be more like the tortoise than the hair the hair will always you know sort of run out of steam”

0.74

Liz Truss's mini budget, framed as a 'plan for growth,' failed because it involved unfunded tax cuts that caused a loss of confidence in the British government, comparable to the 1976 IMF bailout crisis.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Paul Wallace

“the mini budget was a um was a disaster um and uh you know I liking it to the um the IMF you know um having to having to have a bailout loan from the IMF in 1976 it was sort of a complete disaster that that um there was such a a loss in confidence in in um the British government but that's what you do if you if you make unfunded um tax cuts”

0.74

Britain's exit from the European Union devalued the economy through currency depreciation, making Britons poorer by increasing import costs and reducing purchasing power, with the pound remaining below pre-referendum levels against both the Euro and Dollar.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Paul Wallace

“the fall in the exchange rate made is all poorer um that's that's without any doubt but but clearly the impact of brexit is is is quite profile I mean a sense foreign exchange markets were saying you have devalued the economy I mean and and and contributing to um you know poor living standards by by making things more expensive because that's what happens when you have a weak currency”

0.74

UK economic growth fell from approximately 3% annually in the 15 years before 2007 to little more than 1% annually between 2007 and 2022, and GDP per capita growth fell from around 2.5% to less than 0.5% annually over the same periods.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Paul Wallace

“before in that in those 15 years up to 2007 you had the economy growing by almost 3% a year which is incredibly good for given historical standards and since then by little more than 1% a year if you look at the GDP per person per head it's even more of a Slowdown from around 2 and a half% in in the period up to 2007 down to less than half a percent a year”

0.74

Financial markets cannot be ignored because they represent creditors to whom the government must maintain confidence; poor public finances prevent a government from ignoring the views of those lending to it.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Paul Wallace

“you can't ignore the city at all you know you've got to you've got to be uh you know you've got to keep the the state of our public finances is not so good that we can ignore the people who are are lending to us”

0.74

Britain's failure to join the European project in the 1950s created lasting losses by preventing Britain from shaping the emerging community, a historical lesson that was neglected in the Brexit debate.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Paul Wallace

“if you go back to the 1970s you know there was a debate about why didn't we join the whole project in the 1950s and all the losses that ran on from that because we weren't able to shape the you know the emerging communities eventually EU um and all that was neglected”

0.69

The fundamental reason for Britain's economic slowdown is a collapse in productivity growth, which the Royal Statistical Society identified around 2019-2020 as the statistic of the decade.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Paul Wallace

“the fundamental reason for that is a collapse in productivity growth and I think the um Royal statistical Society at sometime around 2019 2020 um had a statistic of the decade and it was very low productivity growth”

0.69

If the population is increased through immigration, the government must provide adequate infrastructure for these additional people, but Britain has not been doing this sufficiently, creating a mismatch.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Paul Wallace

“if you increase the population you've got to clearly provide the infrastructure for these extra people now that's we haven't done that enough you see so you know I think that's that's part of the problem”

0.69

Infrastructure investment should be financed primarily through borrowing (as companies do), and financial markets would be receptive to rising government debt if it is genuinely financing productive investment, because a larger economy resulting from successful investment can support higher debt sustainably.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Paul Wallace

“investment should primarily be be financed through borrowing I mean you know this this is how companies behave I mean you know we we should do that um so the the the the real problem as I see it is that you know they're constrained by the fact that debt is high”

0.69

Fixing Britain's economic foundations through infrastructure and skills investment is not a one-year or two-year project but the work of a whole parliamentary term or longer.

forecasthigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Paul Wallace

“I don't think that's fixing the foundations in the first year and then everything I mean I think fixing the foundations could be the work of a whole term really it's not it's not longer”

0.69

Britain has genuine sources of competitive advantage in the manufacturing sector, particularly in life sciences (through firms like AstraZeneca and GSK), which should be bolstered through government support.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Paul Wallace

“we do have sources of competitive advantage in the manufacturing sector they should be bolstered you know we we clearly have uh a good life sciences um industry you know big firms like astroica and and GSK so you know we we need to support that”

0.68

The City of London's apparent prosperity before the financial crisis was partly meretriciously (deceptively) obtained and harmful to the broader economy, though one should not see financial services as acting directly to the detriment of other regions due to circulation of income and wealth.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Paul Wallace

“obviously the city was doing incredibly well in fact meretriciously well before the the financial crisis so some of that apparent Prosperity was was was fake um and was harmful um I I I mean I don't think we should see the city as as as actually um acting to the detriment of other regions because there's a lot of circulation of of income and wealth you know I mean for example you know um financial institutions will relocate some of their activities outside London”

0.68

Government should have an industrial strategy that aligns public policy actions across different areas to work in unison rather than contradictory ways, ensuring coherent business support rather than causing uncertainty through constant policy shifts.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Paul Wallace

“we should have a strategy for business you know extending more widely the manufacturing which creates greater certainty I mean because you see the government intervenes in the in the economy in so many different ways that actually it's quite a sensible thing to actually think well you know are we actually acting in unison or are we acting against ourselves so I I think it is sensible to have uh such a policy”

0.66

Britain's de-industrialization process and collapse of the manufacturing sector has coincided with the rise of financial services from the 1980s onwards.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Paul Wallace

“that sort of um skill if you like talent for financial services and its growth from the 80s through to Now sort of coincides sits alongside a sort of de-industrialization process and a sort of well collapse really in our manufacturing sector”

0.65

The Brexit referendum was taken in a frivolous manner without safeguards, in stark contrast to previous UK referendums, and reflected an extraordinary ignorance of Britain's own economic history regarding the benefits of European integration since the 1950s-70s.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Paul Wallace

“it it still amazes me that that this decision could be taken in such a frivolous way in my opinion I think that it's obvious that that there should have been a much there should have been breaks on this process that we shouldn't put a policy which had been desired since the early 1960s and achieved in the early 1970s to a vote a referendum that will decide it according to potentially just one vote you know I mean it's it's completely ludicrous um with no safeguards”

0.63

Before the election, think tanks like the Institute for Fiscal Studies were saying there was not enough fiscal headroom in the public finances, suggesting structural revenue/spending problems regardless of which party was in power.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Paul Wallace

“and I think that before uh the election that's what think tanks like the ifs were saying you know there isn't enough margin um here”

0.63

Big firms in oil and aircraft manufacturing historically had very long planning horizons and were skillful at planning capital investment, which is why long-term government policy alignment with business planning horizons is important.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Paul Wallace

“you know when he worked for shell and you know the the planning Horizons of big firms in in the oil industry or you know in in aircraft manufacturing were very good at some aspects of that um they're just very long you know so so you need to have government policy that is aligning itself with that rather than constant chopping and changing”

0.63

Manufacturing is a small but very important section of the modern British economy and is actually bigger than financial services in overall size, though it was much larger as a proportion of GDP in the post-war period.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Paul Wallace

“manufacturing is a Rel is is a small but very important section of the economy I mean actually it's bigger than than financial services so I mean you know we um but but it's not it would be unwise to have a policy which is directed solely to manufacturing I mean in in in uh you know in the period after the war it was a much bigger proportion of the economy”

0.63

Economic policy in Britain has been characterized by constant chopping and changing as a product of electoral cycles rather than consistent long-term strategy.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Paul Wallace

“that that is sadly how you know one would Describe economic policy in this country a product of electoral Cycles I guess”

0.63

The real problem with public finance constraints is not a logical prohibition on borrowing but rather the fact that interest payments have risen sharply due to high inflation, creating a burden on public expenditure.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Paul Wallace

“so the the the the real problem as I see it is that you know they're constrained by the fact that debt is high so they they they are concerned about borrowing too much um and you can see why because interest payments shot up um during the uh during the um the period of high inflation and so that is a sort of big burden on the exer”

0.62

Immigration is on balance economically good for Britain and part of the country's appeal as an open society and global economy, but it has limitations for solving the central productivity growth problem.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Paul Wallace

“I think that immigration is on balance good uh for the economy um but in terms of the central problem which I diagnose and I'm I think I'm not alone in this of improving productivity growth I I can't see that it's actually necessarily going to raise productivity so um it's clear that we need to be open um but we shouldn't um I think there are limitations to the economic benefits from immigration”

0.62

Rather than turning to foreign workers to fill occupational shortages (such as in care homes), the government should raise pay in those sectors to attract domestic workers, at least after addressing any immediate staffing crises.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Paul Wallace

“I also have some concern about um always turning to foreign workers to deal with shortages in occupations like like for example the Care Homes when really what we should be doing is certainly you know if we have an immediate problem doing that but raising pay in that sector so that we can attract more workers into it”

0.62

Taxation has risen significantly as a proportion of GDP in Britain, but probably needs to rise further to pay for public services which are in a terrible state.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Paul Wallace

“essentially we need to raise taxes to pay for public services you public services are in a terrible mess so although taxation has risen a lot as a proportion of GDP probably needs to rise more”

0.62

The City of London is a strategic economic asset where the UK has demonstrated comparative advantage in financial services, as shown in trade figures, and should not be wrapped in 'cotton wool' regulation but should be allowed to operate.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Paul Wallace

“I mean you've got to it is one of our strategic Assets in the economy we seem to be good we I mean you can see it in in the trade figures we are good at Financial Services there has of course been a loss through brexit and you see that in the trade figures too”

0.61

The growth that Britain achieved in the run-up to 2007-2008 came at a terrible cost because it was partially based on unsustainable financial excesses, which led to the worst recession since World War II and subsequently an even worse pandemic recession.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Paul Wallace

“clearly the the higher growth we achieved in the run up to 2007 2008 came at a terrible cost because we then had the worst recession since the war and subsequently we've had the Corona virus recession which was even worse”

0.61

Brexit could not have benefited the British economy under any realistic negotiation scenario because it represents a deliberate act of deglobalization.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Paul Wallace

“no I don't think so no because because I mean as as Mark Cary said it's a sort of unusual thing I mean you know it is a deliberate Act of deglobalization um and it it still amazes me that that this decision could be taken in such a frivolous way”

0.57

Public investment represents approximately 2-3% of GDP, while business investment is approximately 10% of GDP, making private sector investment a much larger share of total capital formation.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Paul Wallace

“public investment is is perhaps two 3% where does that public investment come from if the labor party has constricted itself with the fiscal rules that it said it's going to adhere to they may or may not raise I think they will raise taxes in the budget if we are sat here saying the social good the economic good as a product of this investment is really quite significant whether it's in literal sort of economic growth whether it's in um Health outcomes crime outcomes from let's say improved house building whatever it is how should they go about actually physically getting that cash should they borrow should they raise taxes should they discard the fiscal rules they said they're going to adhere to well I I mean investment should primarily be be financed through borrowing I mean you know this this is how companies behave I mean you know we we should do that um so the the the the real problem as I see it is that you know they're constrained by the fact that debt is high so they they they are concerned about borrowing too much um and you can see why because interest payments shot up um during the uh during the um the period of high inflation and so that is a sort of big burden on the exer um but but I I think that I I actually personally think that the city would be by which I mean you know financial markets in general would be fairly okay with debt Rising if it is actually financing investment because they can see you know I mean if the if the investment works then ultimately you will have a bigger economy and then that's means that you you'll you know you needn't worry too much about about debt I mean the whole issue about debt is how sustainable it is you know are the public finances on the sustainable footing so yeah but we'll you know we'll see what they do about the fiscal rules what do you think the uh the pressure is or the disinclination is towards higher borrowing is it do you think that's the point where the sort of the politics of it come into it that essentially the labor party is terrified of being accused of as the conservative party regularly does mismanaging the economy of debt rising and they're scared of getting into it for that reason difficult for the conservatives to make that CLA to the others yeah so um well look I mean the I think the uh the reason for the concern about the public finances is that um the uh essentially we need to raise taxes to pay for public services you public services are in a terrible mess so although taxation has risen a lot as a proportion of GDP probably needs to rise more and it and it was actually really um irresponsible of the outgoing Chancellor um hunt I'm you know essentially presumably uh with sunak pushing him towards it to to lower ni taxes in the way in which they did um because really you know we it was it was not a it was not a sound public finances move the argument that uh starm is making to kind of lay the groundwork for whatever he is about to announce in the budget whatever re will announce in the budget is this 22 billion pound black hole in the finances that he's been talking about um attributed to at least in part um to the LZ trustman budget to potential overspend or claimed recently discovered departmental overspend what's your yeah what's your assessment of the sort of validity of that figure is it fair is it correct for the low parties to come in and argue there's this huge gap in the public finances we had no idea that it was here before so it's about the current fiscal year okay and um the uh question is you know why there already seems to be claims on the reserve why um some of the spending seems to be higher than expected but I think that really it's neither here nor there because her budget will be setting um uh taxes for coming years and that's what really matters and I think that before uh the election that's what think tanks like the ifs were saying you know there isn't enough margin um here is it fair to attribute um as much blame for the kind of dire economic situation we find ourselves in to the conservative party and to Liz truss is it a deeper longer term Trend I mean as you sort of argued here that actually we have to broaden our time Horizon quite significantly and to say that it's all the thought of this you know terrible mini budget this plan for growth no that's I mean the the mini budget was a um was a disaster um and uh you know I liking it to the um the IMF you know um having to having to have a bailout loan from the IMF in 1976 it was sort of a complete disaster that that um there was such a a loss in confidence in in um the British government but that's what you do if you if you make unfunded um tax cuts um so I mean which shows you know I mean you can't ignore the city at all you know you've got to you've got to be uh you know you've got to keep the the state of our public finances is not so good that we can ignore the people who are are lending to us but um yeah I mean it's it's much broader than it includes the the the you know massive self-inflicted harm of brexit um and it in but but fundamentally the productivity growth slowdown had started before that so it's it's deeper than that and and the sort of the the failure to um remedy things um I think is quite deep standing you mentioned brexit um you write in the book you say that brexit devalued the economy can you can you explain what you meant by that well I mean I was really referring to the exchange rate having for um uh but I mean that's a sort of metaphor really I mean but but but the the fall in the exchange rate made is all poorer um that's that's without any doubt but but clearly the impact of brexit is is is quite profile I mean a sense foreign exchange markets were saying you have devalued the economy I mean and and and contributing to um you know poor living standards by by making things more expensive because that's what happens when you have a weak currency but but they were anticipating the effects of brexit and they got it right and I mean I mean when I wrote that um you know sort of concluding it earlier this year you know the pal was still below where it had stood on the eve of the referendum vote you know against both the Euro and and the p and and the dollar and that remains the case is that was that case inevitable if we let's say we vot we went through the I don't know the the politicians in charge were different the way we negotiated our exit was different any of those various factors would we always end up in the situation where as you say brexit would devalue the economy is there a world in which it could have benefited our economy no I don't think so no because because I mean as as Mark Cary said it's a sort of unusual thing I mean you know it is a deliberate Act of deglobalization um and it it still amazes me that that this decision could be taken in such a frivolous way in my opinion I think that it's obvious that that there should have been a much there should have been breaks on this process that we shouldn't put a policy which had been desired since the early 1960s and achieved in the early 1970s to a vote a referendum that will decide it according to potentially just one vote you know I mean it's it's completely ludicrous um with no safeguards I mean none of the safeguards that for example occurred um in in in some previous votes referendums in this country um so I think it was it was an act of complete Folly and you know it was it's absolutely extraordinary the of of understanding of your own economic history because if you go back to the 1970s you know there was a debate about why didn't we join the whole project in the 1950s and all the losses that ran on from that because we weren't able to shape the you know the emerging communities eventually EU um and all that was neglected and we we learned through bitter experience then that you were much less influential outside than inside the the European project you right that you interpret um brexit in part as a response to the sort of as as a backlash to 2008 and you write the Left Behind resentment of well-healed Metropolitan Elite in the city of London you also write the city's gain was a loss for other parts of the economy can you explain what you meant by that um well I I think that obviously the city was doing incredibly well in fact meretriciously well before the the financial crisis so some of that apparent Prosperity was was was fake um and was harmful um I I I mean I don't think we should see the city as as as actually um acting to the detriment of other regions because there's a lot of circulation of of income and wealth you know I mean for example you know um financial institutions will relocate some of their activities outside London um but but overall I mean you know I mean clearly the the higher growth we achieved in the run up to 2007 2008 came at a terrible cost because we then had the worst recession since the war and subsequently we've had the Corona virus recession which was even worse but but at that point it was easily the worst do you think the city requires a greater degree of Regulation or possibly less well I think that you know there's there's it has it is now much more regulated um and then the the what happened after brexit uh was perhaps attempts to roll back some of that regulation um I mean I think that uh we don't want to sort of wrap it up in in Cotton wool really you know I mean you've got to allow it to uh to you've got to it is one of our strategic Assets in the economy we seem to be good we I mean you can see it in in the trade figures we are good at Financial Services there has of course been a loss through brexit and you see that in the trade figures too that sort of um skill if you like talent for financial services and its growth from the 80s through to Now sort of coincides sits alongside a sort of de-industrialization process and a sort of well collapse really in our manufacturing sector do you relating to that product lack of productivity growth that we were talking about the beginning of the interview how do you see those two things connecting and actually um labor spoken a lot about sort of having an industrial strategy do you think there is a a possibility in which we can kind of Revive Our manufacturing and would that feed into an increase in productivity growth and a resulting increase in overall GDP growth well manufacturing is a Rel is is a small but very important section of the economy I mean actually it's bigger than than financial services so I mean you know we um but but it's not it would be unwise to have a policy which is directed solely to manufacturing I mean in in in uh you know in the period after the war it was a much bigger proportion of the economy so therefore you know you it was sensible perhaps to to focus on it I mean I I think that uh we do have sources of competitive advantage in the manufacturing sector they should be bolstered you know we we clearly have uh a good life sciences um industry you know big firms like astroica and and GSK so you know we we need to support that now the case for uh you know the industrial strategy that was a thatch you know the demoting of it the you know turning it into something we shouldn't do I think that's just basically a mistake I think I think we should have a strategy for business you know extending more widely the manufacturing which creates greater certainty I mean because you see the government intervenes in the in the economy in so many different ways that actually it's quite a sensible thing to actually think well you know are we actually acting in unison or are we acting against ourselves so I I think it is sensible to have uh such a policy and and I don't think it's necessarily protect I mean the argument against it has always been oh well you're going to subsidize losers you know you you back you say you're going to back winners but you'll end up supporting losers I think that's fairly fairly weak really just going on on this I mean Vince cable who was an advocate of an industrial strategy in in the coalition government you know he um would hark back to his time when he worked for shell and you know the the the planning Horizons of big firms in in the oil industry or you know in in aircraft manufacturing were very good at some aspects of that um they're just very long you know so so you need to have government policy that is aligning itself with that rather than constant chopping and changing that that is sadly how you know one would Describe economic policy in this country a product of electoral Cycles I guess Ju Just just finally we've mentioned about um skills and vocational training and particularly within the context I guess of um that Manu manufacturing sector I have to ask you a question about immigration how do you see immigra fitting into that puzzle is it a viable alternative to let's say um you know an investment in human capital in skills and in education is it an alternative that we can say actually let's bring in the people that have these skills from abroad so I think that immigration is part of Britain's appeal we're in an open Society open economy we've always I mean one of the things about the UK is you know we we are a very global economy I we have got lots of links you know it's partly due to at one time running a massive Empire but you know that's that's that's the Legacy so I I think that immigration is on balance good uh for the economy um but in terms of the central problem which I diagnose and I'm I think I'm not alone in this of improving productivity growth I I can't see that it's actually necessarily going to raise productivity so um it's clear that we need to be open um but we shouldn't um I think there are limitations to the economic benefits from immigration so that that would be in a nutshell I mean it's it's a very complex it's a very complex uh subject even just being dispassionately looking at the economics and demographics um and there are clearly some negatives viewed in that respect I mean simply you know if you increase the population you've got to clearly provide the infrastructure for these extra people now that's we haven't done that enough you see so you know I think that's that's part of the problem I I also have some concern about um always turning to foreign workers to deal with shortages in occupations like like for example the Care Homes when really what we should be doing is certainly you know if we have an immediate problem doing that but raising pay in that sector so that we can attract more workers into it we've uh and we've come full circle back to infrastructure and investment um Paul Wallace author of thank thank you so much for coming in speak to me I really appreciate it okay thank you for”

0.56

The outgoing Conservative Chancellor (Hunt), presumably pushed by then-Prime Minister Sunak, irresponsibly lowered National Insurance taxes in a way that was not a sound public finances move.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Paul Wallace

“it was actually really um irresponsible of the outgoing Chancellor um hunt I'm you know essentially presumably uh with sunak pushing him towards it to to lower ni taxes in the way in which they did um because really you know we it was it was not a it was not a sound public finances move”

0.55

The common argument that industrial strategy will inevitably lead to subsidizing losers is fairly weak as a policy objection and does not outweigh the benefits of coherent business strategy.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Paul Wallace

“the argument against it has always been oh well you're going to subsidize losers you know you you back you say you're going to back winners but you'll end up supporting losers I think that's fairly fairly weak really”

0.48

Starmer's pre-election mission statement that the British economy should outperform other G7 members is not a sensible objective because what matters is what the UK does itself, not relative performance comparisons.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Paul Wallace

“before the election um was saying that he wanted to he stated as one of his missions that he wanted uh the British economy to outperform other members of the G7 um I I don't personally think that's a terribly sensible objective because you know I think it should be what we do ourselves rather than the the the comparison”

0.48

The Labour party faces political constraints on borrowing because the Conservative party regularly accuses it of mismanaging the economy, making the party hesitant to appear fiscally irresponsible even when investment-financed debt would be economically sound.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Paul Wallace

“well it's just that um I'm not a great fan of these monthly figures go on uh you know there's just too much volatility going on there isn't enough data in my opinion to really uh you know put much Credence in what they mean so I'm I'm much Keener on just looking at the quarterly figures so the quarterly figures in the first half of the year”

0.46

Economic policy should aim for consistency and predictability rather than volatility driven by electoral cycles, comparing the preferred approach to the fable of the tortoise and hare, where sustained effort beats sporadic bursts.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Paul Wallace

“so it's it's you know it's we want to be more like the tortoise than the hair the hair will always you know sort of run out of steam we we've we've got to be more like a Tortoise looking Beyond”

0.43

It would be unwise to have an economic policy directed solely at manufacturing because manufacturing was a much larger proportion of the economy in the post-war period, but now requires a broader policy approach.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Paul Wallace

“it would be unwise to have a policy which is directed solely to manufacturing I mean in in in uh you know in the period after the war it was a much bigger proportion of the economy so therefore you know you it was sensible perhaps to to focus on it”

0.37

The City of London is now much more regulated than before, and attempts have been made after Brexit to roll back some of that regulation.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Paul Wallace

“I think that you know there's there's it has it is now much more regulated um and then the the what happened after brexit uh was perhaps attempts to roll back some of that regulation”

0.29

Wallace prefers to analyze quarterly GDP growth figures over monthly figures because monthly data contains too much volatility to provide meaningful information about economic trends.

normativeestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Paul Wallace

“well sorry if I can CH there I mean well it's just that um I'm not a great fan of these monthly figures go on uh you know there's just too much volatility going on there isn't enough data in my opinion to really uh you know put much Credence in what they mean so I'm I'm much Keener on just looking at the quarterly figures”

0.19

In Q1 and Q2 of the recent year, the UK economy grew by over half a percent per quarter, which is pretty good especially given that the economy was emerging from a technical recession at the end of the previous year.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Paul Wallace

“you know the quarterly figures in the first half of the year so q1 January through March Q2 the through to June uh you had the economy growing by over half per a year that's pretty good especially since we were emerging from a technical recession at the end of um the previous year”

0.19

A 22 billion pound 'black hole' in public finances claimed by the Labour party upon taking office relates primarily to the current fiscal year and questions about why there are claims on the reserve and higher-than-expected spending, but this is 'neither here nor there' because the budget will be setting taxes for coming years.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Paul Wallace

“About the current fiscal year okay and um the uh question is you know why there already seems to be claims on the reserve why um some of the spending seems to be higher than expected but I think that really it's neither here nor there because her budget will be setting um uh taxes for coming years and that's what really matters”

0.17

The host framed Starmer's growth pursuit as potentially a matter of aiming to do better than current performance rather than it being a response to poor current economic conditions.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — Economist explains how Brexit ruined Britain | Paul Wallace… [WxyxDnr2DJU]

“is starmer's um focus and pursuit of said growth should we understand that as being a kind of an ambition to do even better than we already are rather than necessarily a diagnosis that where we are at the moment is necessarily that great what's the correct way of interpreting that Focus”