What this covers

Shane Parrish interviews Sheila Heen about what makes a difficult conversation difficult and how to handle one. Heen traces her field to Roger Fisher and the Harvard Negotiation Project, whose work grew out of Fisher's experience as the only one of six college roommates to come back from World War II. From there she lays out a framework of three layers running at once: the "what happened" story, the feelings underneath, and the identity question of what the situation says about you. The "what happened" layer, she argues, quietly asserts who is right, who is to blame, and what the other person's motives must be, and we mistake that story for objective truth.

The conversation then covers a good deal of ground. Heen draws on John Gottman's research: couples still argue about two-thirds of the same issues five years on, small "bids" for attention are best met with a roughly 5:1 ratio of positive to negative responses, and a five-minute observation can predict divorce partly from signs like eye rolling. She cites Antonio Damasio to argue that feeling and reasoning cannot be separated. She also treats anger as a secondary emotion that covers hurt, disappointment, or loneliness.

The practical turns are more varied. Heen describes a pattern where one partner's calm reads as indifference and so escalates the other's upset. She argues that a negative response beats silence, since silence communicates something too. She advises waiting out the adrenaline before answering an upsetting email, and picking a channel to suit the task and the other person rather than your own convenience. She also discusses teaching children to negotiate by taking an adult's perspective, and parents modeling apology and taking responsibility.

Sharpest takeaway

Sheila Keen argues that difficult conversations succeed through understanding the other person's perspective and feelings rather than proving yourself right, and that listening—especially when most frustrated—is the most persuasive and transformative tool available.

  • Listening is a persuasion strategy, not a last resort, because it builds reciprocity, uncovers underlying interests, and shifts relationship dynamics
  • Difficult conversations operate on three simultaneous layers—what happened, feelings, and identity—and addressing all three transforms outcomes
  • The internal conversation with yourself must shift first from blame and certainty to curiosity and joint contribution before external conversations can succeed

The claims · ranked43 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

When you are most frustrated and least want to listen, you need to lean into the conflict to understand it better and understand the other person's perspective first, even though they still don't understand your perspective—training yourself to do this is counter-instinctual but it's when listening matters most.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Sheila Keen

“when I least want to listen and when I am most frustrated I need to actually lean into the conflict to understand it better and understand their perspective better first even though they still don't get my perspective”

0.76

In some relationships, a complementary coping pattern emerges where one partner responds to upset with calm, which the other partner interprets as not caring, causing the upset partner to escalate further, while the calm partner becomes more confused about why their strategy is not working.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Sheila Heen

“there's a funny contribution system sometimes it happens in some relationships where the more upset someone becomes the more calm the other person gets because their coping strategy in the face of upset is calmness... so and the more calm they get the more upset the other person goes right... the person who is so calm doesn't know what to do because they're like I don't know what else I can do and the other person is like why are you reacting like there's no reaction whatsoever to it I'm right... the converse is like will you stop being so hysterical and the person who is getting more and more upset is like okay you're not getting either you're not getting how important this is or you don't care right and both of those are even more upsetting”

0.74

Teaching children about negotiation involves teaching them to take others' perspectives and understand what adults care about or worry about, which helps them craft proposals that satisfy both their interests and the adult's interests.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Sheila Heen

“what are my concerns what do you think my concerns are about delaying your homeworks you're getting him to take your perspective yeah you're trying to teach them what we would call second position skills can you step into someone else's shoes and imagine what the world looks like to them and what they care about what their priorities are and not that you're supposed to guess accurately but ask them questions learn as much as you can because that's what's going to help you craft an option that means your own interests as well as the other person's”

0.74

Choosing the right communication channel should be based on matching the task to the medium and considering the other person's preferences and reactions, not just what is most efficient for you.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Sheila Heen

“I think that there are a couple of axes to think about... do we have a preference and a reaction to some channels right... there's one axis which is just preferences mm-hmm right so so my husband hates talking on the phone like hates it... although it would be a more efficient way for us to figure this plan out when he answers the phone... he basically says why are you bothering me... he's already annoyed to start out with the conversation so although it would be a more efficient medium yeah it ends up being a less effective medium... I'm always trying for effectiveness first and efficiency sort of a second”

0.74

Roger Fisher, founder of the Harvard Negotiation Project, developed his life's work focused on finding better ways for people to manage conflict after being the only one of his six college roommates to return alive from World War II.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Sheila Keen

“Roger Fisher who founded the negotiation project the Harvard negotiation project and who wrote getting to yes he fought in World War two and in both the Atlantic and Pacific theatres and when he came home from the war he found that of the six college roommates who started college together at the end of that first year they stopped out it was called to go to war he was the only one who came home and it sort of motivated the rest of his life and to try to find better ways to help people manage conflict”

0.74

Listening as a persuasion strategy works because good listening lets you learn what's underneath people's positions (their interests, concerns, priorities, worries, anxieties), it changes the relationship, and it activates reciprocity—the strongest social dynamic where if you really listen to someone they're much more likely to listen to you.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Sheila Keen

“really good listening means you're learning a ton about not just what is under people's positions you know their interests concerns priorities worries anxieties that is meaning that they're saying no so far but also you're changing the relationship and then the third thing is that there is this dynamic called reciprocity I'm sure you're familiar with it right like one of the strongest social dynamics is that you'll mirror back whatever you get so if you attack me I'm going to attack you back but if you really listen to me I'm much more likely to then be willing to really listen to you”

0.69

When people email strangers or leave online comments, it's easier for them to forget there's a real human being on the other side, so they vent frustration with their own lives and the world rather than engaging with the actual recipient, and they don't understand that their words will actually impact that person.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sheila Keen

“I think that people it's easier particularly when they are emailing strangers or leaving comments online for strangers it's easier for them to forget that there's a real human being on the other side and so they're sort of venting their frustration with the world and their life sometimes etc at someone else frame who is more about them it says more sometimes about them and where they're at how they're feeling treated by the world then it says about you and they're not thinking that it's going to impact you right there like Shane's not gonna care Shane's famous Shane has this amazing you know followership so he's not gonna listen to me and they don't understand that actually if you read them you lie awake sometimes especially in the early days where you were taking them as if they really were about you”

0.69

Anger is often a secondary emotion that masks primary emotions like hurt, disappointment, confusion, or loneliness; people translate feelings into anger because they're not comfortable naming the primary emotion, so unpacking anger by asking 'what's really going on here' helps access the more complete set of feelings underneath.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sheila Keen

“anger is often a secondary feeling so how can you say more about that yeah anger is often when I say secondary I mean initially what we feel is something else maybe it's hurt so you hurt me and I don't feel totally comfortable saying like hey you hurt me um but it's very clear to me I should not have been hurt and you should not have hurt me so now I'm mad at you angry at you for underlining angry at you right and it might not even occur to me that under that anger is actually hurt or disappointment or confusion or loneliness what I actually experienced it as anger or frustration and so sometimes it actually takes a little bit of work on my part to think I am really pissed Oh like what's that about let me just unpack that a little bit”

0.69

Parents should model the skills they want their children to develop in conversations: specifically, they should be willing to apologize to their children when they handle something poorly, let children speak up when they don't feel treated well, take responsibility for their contributions to problems, and shift responsibility to children to make their own mistakes (within safety bounds).

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sheila Keen

“I want my kids to be able to see someone else's point of view even when they feel strongly the other way I want them to take responsibility and for what they contribute to the problem right to own their part and to apologize and work to fix it but also I want them to stick up for themselves and speak up for themselves when they feel like they're not being treated well mm-hmm and so if that's what I want them to learn they have to have a model for learning that which also means I have to be willing for them to speak up to me right when they don't feel like I've handled something well they have to see me apologizing to them when I handle something Forly yeah even though I hate that and I'm so disappointed in myself”

0.69

With people you know well, you can tell when they're upset because subtle changes appear in their email—missing greeting, different formality level, changed punctuation, different language choices—even when you can't articulate why, your 'spidey sense' goes off.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sheila Keen

“well your spidey sense kind of goes off yeah literally like they usually have a greeting and there's suddenly no greeting right right or and sometimes you can't even like articulate why ya feel that way but you're just like hey something's up like I see yeah some are you okay like yeah it's okay and you could be wrong yeah right but they've either gotten more informal or more Curt mmm their language choices changed there's no punctuation all the sudden nothing something has changed maybe they've gotten more formal and you're just like whoa did I offend you or just”

0.65

John Gottman's research shows that two-thirds of the things couples fight about today they'll still be fighting about in five years because those conflicts reflect fundamental differences between people (messiness, spending habits, risk tolerance) that won't change, so the work is learning how to handle them, not resolving them.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sheila Keen

“two thirds of the things you're fighting about today you're gonna be fighting about in five years and you were fighting about them five years ago right those recurring recurring theme issues because about two thirds of what you fight about are not solvable they just reflect differences between you right who's Messier and his less messy and drives them crazy who spends the money and who gets anxious and wants to save the money all of that stuff those preferences aren't going to change those are the friction points between you know is just how do you handle them”

0.65

John Gottman can watch a couple for five minutes discussing a stressful topic and predict with 90 percent accuracy whether they'll divorce within five years based on observable behaviors, specifically looking for eye rolling (expressing contempt/dismissal) and other indicators of how couples manage conflict.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sheila Keen

“his claim to fame is that he can watch a couple for five minutes and predict with ninety well it's two percent yeah it's crazy whether or not they're gonna divorce within years five years”

0.65

Burying things that you want to talk about in a relationship leads to greater distance between people because the more you bury things the farther apart you get, whereas people in strong relationships bring up difficult topics because they feel safe being understood and listened to, even though it will be a struggle to get there.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shane Parrish, Sheila Keen

“one of the things that sort of correlates to a negative place is their inability to talk so somebody will bury thing that I want to talk about it for whatever reason be it anxiety they don't want to talk about the feelings they don't want to have a recurring conversation that they bury it but the more they bury the more like the farther apart people get in a relationship yep and so they're not coming back and they're not connecting and the people that have the strongest relationships will bring up stuff that they know is going to be a difficult conversation but they sort of feel safe that they're going to be understood or listened to and they're going to get to a better place even though it's going to be a struggle to get there”

0.65

Silence and absence of communication in relationships are themselves communicating something to the other person; even when you're not speaking to someone, they may hear about it through the grapevine or interpret your silence, and what they understand may not match what you intend.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sheila Keen

“when you're in this field you just think everything is in your field so you're gonna colonize the whole world so we would say that you are communicating with the other side even when you're not speaking to them right because maybe they're hearing it through the grapevine so and you may or may not realize they hear it through the grapevine but your silence also is communicating something it's hard for them to interpret and what they get may not be what you intend”

0.65

One of the mistakes people make is getting an upsetting email and writing back right away instead of waiting until adrenaline has gone down, re-reading it, and thinking about what response they want to give rather than reacting—shifting from reactive to purposive choice.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sheila Keen

“and one of the mistakes we make is that we get an email that's upsetting and we write back right away mmm-hmm instead of taking time in a sort of liking time to wait until the adrenaline has gone down we reread it and we think about what we want to respond with rather than how we want to react how we will react with because we're not thinking about it”

0.65

There's a dynamic called 'micro-bids' or 'tiny bids' where one person expresses something ('it was cold today') and the partner can respond positively, ignore them, or respond negatively, and the ratio of positive to negative responses matters for relationship health, with the optimal ratio being approximately 5:1 positive to negative interactions.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sheila Keen

“he talks about positive and negative interactions mm-hmm and they're tiny little bids my cousin micro bids right so and you can get a positive reaction as as simple as you know it was cold today and then you actually say yeah freezing but you responded to me in some way that heard I read it altered and acknowledged you could also ignore me I get no response or you could respond negatively like it wasn't that cold you know you're just a wimp and so a couple of things I'm like you know this research I find it really interesting the optimum is what is it five to one I think so yeah five to one positive interactions - negative interactions”

0.65

A negative response is actually better than no response in a relationship because a negative response at least signals that you care enough to engage, whereas no response signals total indifference, and zero engagement is worse for relationships than negative engagement.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sheila Keen

“the other thing I find interesting is a negative response is actually better than no response book has no response just signals that you just don't care right you're just totally being ignored and so it's actually better in the relationship if you say wasn't that called you're just a wimp because at least we're still in relationship right”

0.65

A difficult conversation is whatever feels difficult to you, and what starts as difficult for one person can quickly become difficult for the other because once one person puts something on the table that the other didn't foresee or expect, and they realize the disagreement or frustration, it becomes difficult for both.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sheila Keen

“we kind of define a difficult conversation as whatever feels difficult to you okay right it could be difficult for one person not for the other and not for the other although what's interesting is that that quickly changes like I may be worried about the conversation and ahead of time I'm thinking this is going to be difficult you may not anticipate this is gonna be difficult but as soon as I put something on the table that you didn't foresee her expect and you realize how much disagreement there is or how frustrated I am with you that I haven't told you all these years or whatever then it becomes a little more difficult for the other person in most cases”

0.65

Emotions and rational decision-making are not separate but deeply intertwined; feelings change how you think and thinking changes how you feel, and objective decision-making doesn't actually exist because feelings are essential information about what you care about and what worries you.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sheila Keen

“I think we have and this is changing a lot actually recently but there's sort of a traditional story that there's rationality and there's irrationality right there's being objective and then there's being emotional and that those are you know totally separate spirits fears and never the twain shall meet mmm and I think what we're learning over time and neuroscience is learning is that these two things are just really intertwined mm-hmm that how you feel changes how you think and how you think changes how you feel yeah and that objective decision-making does not exist actually and that feelings are actually really important information right”

0.65

Antonio Damasio's research on split-brain patients (people with damage separating emotion centers from prefrontal cortex) shows that people without access to their emotions can't make decisions at all, even simple ones like when to come to an appointment, proving that you must access feelings to know what you care about and what worries you.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sheila Keen

“I'm sure you're familiar with Antonio Damasio x' work so he's at the University of Iowa and he wrote a book called des cartes error okay I think I've heard of the book I don't think I've read it there yeah so he is one of the researchers that took a look at what are called split brain patients okay so there are people who either fully rational or fully emotional a congenital defect or an accident right an injury it means that the part of the brain that processes emotion is actually physically separated from okay severed from the prefrontal cortex which is your executive function thinking what we think of as the rational decision-making brain and he and other researchers are like well there are is a population of people who can't access their feelings actually just physiologically so these split brain patients are the perfect population so that we can learn how to make objective decisions because they must be the perfect decision-makers and what they found is that these people can't make decisions at all at all I mean just asking them when would you like to come into the lab they have no idea like they'll recite their schedule but they have no instincts about well it's kind of a busy day but that's gonna be a little tight or inconvenient or I kind of prefer to come in on a Friday like they have no preferences they don't know what their preferences are and that you have to access feelings to know what you care about and what worries you it's a signal it's a it's a signal”

0.65

As conflict escalates in couples, having an 'escape hatch'—often involving humor—that allows partners to self-observe and break the cycle of escalating frustration is a positive indicator of relationship health because it signals they can step outside the pattern.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sheila Keen

“on the positive side one of the positive corollary or clues that he looks for is as things escalate that they have an escape hatch and which often involves humor so it's an affiliation move to reconnect and to break the cycle of escalating conflict so you know it's an old joke or it's a something that just gets people out of the escalating frustration to be able to self observe and be like okay well we're having the same argument again and to shift the dynamic”

0.61

Eye rolling signals contempt or dismissal in conversations, indicating that someone has stopped actually listening and is already formulating counter-arguments, making it an important behavior to watch for in relationships.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sheila Keen

“it's things like eye rolling which is sort of leaking out of contempt or dismissal like I've heard this like a million times I'm not listening I'm already formulating my counter-argument right so that's an indicia of not actually listening right”

0.56

The what-happened story serves three functions by answering: who is right (my interpretation is correct), who is at fault (you are to blame), and why they are acting this way (judging their character or motives as bad), and we mistake our subjective story for the objective truth without recognizing alternative valid perspectives exist.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Sheila Heen

“the first is the what happened conversation which include which is really our story about what has happened what is happening now and what should happen okay and that that story has three key components it answers the question who's right by the way me always I be right... whose fault is it so that's the blame piece okay and why are they acting this way like what are their motivations or intentions or character... because we think the way that we see the world is the way that everybody sees the world it's not the way everybody swirl that's the way everybody should see the world”

0.53

The identity conversation—the implicit beliefs about what a situation says about you as a person—is the deepest and often the hardest layer of difficult conversations because it raises stakes and creates anxiety by threatening core beliefs about who you are.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Sheila Heen

“the deepest level the third level is what we call the identity conversation which is kind of the conversation I'm having with myself about myself what does this situation suggest about me that I'm not a good spouse that I'm not a good person that I'm not competent that I'm not worthy of love... if a conversation feels difficult there's often something about identity something the situation's suggest about you that raises the stakes on the whole conversation and so that's part of the anxiety that then drives the intensity of the feelings”

0.52

Being 'emotional' (venting and leaking emotions) is different from 'describing emotion' (naming the emotion professionally); in business contexts, naming emotion like 'I'm frustrated and I don't think we're getting anywhere' is effective and appropriate without being emotional, because it names the emotion rather than exuding it.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sheila Keen

“what does it mean to be emotional great question I think of emotional as sort of exuding leaking the emotion all over right so you know in that meeting it might be like this is ridiculous you guys like it's so obvious now I am expressing frustration mm-hmm but I'm not actually very effectively saying guys I'm frustrated because this feels obvious to me right so describing emotion feels to me effective and putting it on the table for discussion that's different than being emotional demonstrating emotion or often we translate emotion into blame or accusations”

0.52

Kids are amazingly intuitive negotiators not because they learned new strategies, but because they're paying attention to what works and they repeat behaviors that are rewarded, while parents are often stuck in their ways, creating a mismatched competition where kids constantly evolve to test the edges of what adults allow.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sheila Keen

“kids are amazingly intuitive negotiators because whether it's conscious or unconscious they're really paying attention to what works mm-hm and as the adult in their relationship sometimes you're just not paying attention to what you're rewarding right so if they ask the fourth and the fifth time and you're just like enough fine go you've just taught them to pester four or five times or throw the tantrum because then they get something out of it right and so they actually just repeat the behavior that works and it takes you a while to realize what you are accidentally rewarding and teaching them to do that's successful with you and the other thing about kids is that you as the parent are relatively stable meaning stuck in your ways but kids are evolving all the time so every time you think you've figured them out they change”

0.52

Being 'purposive' means consciously choosing how to respond rather than reacting to what the other person just did, which means shifting from 'why did you do this to me' to 'for what purpose am I choosing to do this next thing and what effect do I want it to have,' thereby taking responsibility for your own choices rather than treating yourself as simply reacting to their behavior.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sheila Keen

“one of the things that Roger taught that has stuck with me all these years is the idea of being purposive in the next thing you choose to do so the easiest way to understand is right when your kids are fighting you have boys or girls two boys two boys right so you say to one of your boys why did you hit your brother and what's he gonna say guess he did this yeah it's like a boy yeah exactly he hit me he called me and he deserved that he's early exactly and sometimes he does that's true and exactly and so what Roger was saying is I I'm sorry when I asked you why did you get your brother I don't mean what caused you to hit your brother right I mean for what purpose did you hit your brother what is it that you were trying to accomplish yeah”

0.52

Shifting your internal conversation from 'I'm right and you're wrong' to 'I wonder why we see this so differently' and from blame to joint contribution (acknowledging what we each did or failed to do that got us here) is not about agreement but about understanding and is the prerequisite to having a different kind of conversation.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sheila Keen

“part of the challenge is that from inside that story you're not going to have a better conversation so you have to actually shift your internal voice meaning that's what you're thinking and feeling in the conversation you have to shift it first so that your first negotiation is really with yourself hmm to move from being focused on what I'm right about to being starting to be a little bit curious about why we see this so differently because it seems so obvious to me that I'm right so I'm not getting why you don't see that or what is it that I'm missing here and to move from blame to joint contribution”

0.52

People develop an emotional footprint—learning early which feelings are okay to talk about and which are better left alone based on family signals—and each person brings these lessons to relationships, where together they co-construct a new set of patterns about what feelings can be discussed.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sheila Keen

“one of the things we talk about in the book is this idea that we each have an emotional footprint mm-hmm and the idea behind that is that we all grow up learning which feelings are ok to talk about and which you've learned quickly are better left alone mmm so because every family has signals that are sent about what we do talk about and what you don't talk about and then you know you go to school you have friends you have early professional relationships etc so all of our individual relationships have footprints but also we're bringing a set of sort of lessons with us from early experiences right about what's ok to talk about and so now you're married to somebody who also has all this early stuff at a particular footprint and then together you've co-constructed something hmm”

0.50

Parents should give their children warning signals when they're approaching their frustration limit, because children are naturally pushing boundaries and if they can see the warning signals they can adjust their behavior rather than getting an abrupt response that feels like a sudden switch.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Shane Parrish

“like you cross that switch and so now I'm like we're getting to the line like I'm gonna feel it right and like I give them warning warning what you used to do with this information is up to you but that was what they wanted they wanted more of a like a transition where cuz they're kids they want to push their boundaries and they want to push it to the berry max and then they'll back off so it's like okay we're getting there and just that information given to them super helpful for them to realize like what's happened because it's not always visible with me yeah because I am like very patient but then not patient at all right”

0.49

When a major decision (like a job move) is made, the relationship resentment often comes not from the decision itself but from how the decision was made—whether the partner felt heard and respected in the process.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Sheila Heen

“about a third of the things you're fighting about are transitory like we decided to take the job or not move or not right and sometimes it's not over because somebody resents the way the decision was made you made any move here right right so now that's gonna live on at a deeper level in terms of ongoing resentment and it's gonna rear itself in ways that don't come out as like you made me do this it's gonna come out as something else”

0.49

Recognizing your own low frustration tolerance or tendency to become dictatorial when frustrated is valuable self-knowledge because it identifies patterns you can work to change, and taking a break to reset is often more productive than pushing through.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Sheila Heen

“one of is how little patience I have sometimes right and when I get frustrated I can get dictatorial like we're done this is not a negotiation just do it and that's not necessarily helping in some cases right but it's where I go when I get frustrated so realizing that for myself helps me be like okay this is the strategy isn't helping it's just escalating the conflict I've got a take a break walk away come back”

0.48

Difficult conversations operate within the iceberg model where what's visible above the surface (the words people say) is only a tiny fraction, while below the surface is a vast ocean of unsaid and unexplored thoughts and feelings.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shane Parrish

“so I came up this the iceberg of conversation so you have what's above the surface which is a very small fraction of the iceberg which is like the words that people say yeah and then you have below which is sort of like your unexplored or unsaid thoughts and feelings and it's totally oceans totally yeah”

0.48

Roger Fisher believed that as a teacher you must walk your talk and demonstrate what you're teaching through how you teach it, because teaching itself is a negotiation where you're negotiating for people's engagement, willingness to take risks, and willingness to admit mistakes.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sheila Keen

“he was a really inspirational person and a really wonderful teacher because part of his philosophy was that you you have to walk your talk and you have to demonstrate what you are teaching and how you teach it because teaching itself is a negotiation you are negotiating for people's engagement and willing to take risks and to admit mistakes and to see what they have to learn which is not easy with Harvard Law School students right like failure muscles not so well developed in that population”

0.48

Getting to Yes, the foundational negotiation book by Roger Fisher and others, presents interest-based negotiation as a method, but Sheila and her colleagues at the Negotiation Project found that while it worked well in many situations, some people reported it made particularly challenging conversations worse.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sheila Keen

“we had been teaching negotiation at the negotiation project I joined in the early 90s and you know we were teaching getting to yes and interest based negotiation and people were taking our courses and going out in the world periodically they come back and be like this is great let me tell you how I'm using it out in the world but every once in a while people would come back and be like this is great in a lot of situations but there are actually some conversations I'm in where it's really not helping hmm and in fact when I use your approach I think it might be making things worse”

0.48

Negotiation is an interdisciplinary field that touches on everything in life because all human interactions contain negotiation elements, from personal relationships to professional dealings to conflicts.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sheila Keen

“and negotiation in itself is such an interdisciplinary field that I just felt like this touches on everything in life and I want to learn it all”

0.48

The medium or channel of communication dramatically affects whether a difficult conversation escalates or resolves, with email being the most likely to escalate because it's serial monologue rather than dialogue, emotions leak through word choice and tone, triggered reactions build on each other, and there's often an audience which adds to the reaction and creates a permanent record.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sheila Keen

“although it would be a more efficient medium yeah it ends up being a less effective medium because he comes in already all right unhappy and I'm always trying for effectiveness first and efficiency sort of a second exactly so that's one axis which is do we have a preference and a reaction to some channels right”

0.48

Work-life balance is often an identity conflict where you hold identities as both a responsive professional and a present parent, and the binary framing prevents solutions because you cannot be 100% available to both roles simultaneously.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sheila Heen

“let's talk about like work life work and family conflicts because on the one hand I think of myself as someone who's very responsive to clients but I also think of myself as someone who pays attention to their kids right... is who you are... now I've got two parts of myself or two stories about Who I am that are you conflict... so I think of myself as a good parent who listens to and is there for their kids so now I've got two parts of myself or two stories about Who I am that are in conflict”

0.47

Many people hold rigid identity stories that are black and white (e.g., 'I'm not a quitter') that actually prevent necessary life decisions; reframing these identities from either-or to more nuanced versions (e.g., a quitter is someone who quits when it gets hard, but someone who makes good decisions for themselves is different) allows people to make better choices aligned with their actual values.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sheila Keen

“well so one thing to do is to stop holding our identity as either or black or white because if you think about it logically you can't go through life never quitting anything because you can't do everything forever all the time right so you have been quitting things so it's shifting that - okay a quitter is someone who quits because it gets too hard or they're not committed enough or they're not willing to stick it out through the hard parts hmm but a person who makes a good decision for themselves that actually putting more of my energy toward this doesn't make sense mm-hmm that's actually someone who's making good decisions for themselves so maybe that's different than being a quitter or it's a reframing affirming it right and and realizing actually this is a simplistic story this quitter story that I have right on myself of what I can't be because it's getting in the way of something I need to be also mm-hmm”

0.46

Expressing multiple or contradictory feelings in one statement—like 'I love you and you're driving me crazy, I hate you right now'—can lower the stakes of a conversation by making it more complete and honest than expressing only anger or criticism.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Sheila Heen

“let's talk about marriage I love you and you're driving me crazy like I hate you right now ready both of those are true bull those are actually true in this moment... actually it's an easier conversation to have if it's a more complete conversation right like on the one hand I'm really grateful to you and I really appreciate you know the following things that you did and I felt really frustrated and disappointed when you didn't do this other thing that's easier than just walking in the door and saying like what the hell... actually interestingly sometimes putting more feelings into the conversation lowers the stakes”

0.45

High achievers often have the hardest conversations with themselves because they hold themselves to very high standards and feel disappointed in themselves when they fall short of their identity stories, making these the moments when they're most critical of themselves.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sheila Keen

“and by the way those can sometimes be your hardest conversations because it's where I'm disappointed in myself yeah especially maybe for high achievers because we hold ourselves to a really high standard yeah like I should have known better I should have seen that coming I can't believe I did that”

0.45

When Shane apologized to his kids for losing his patience, his youngest responded with comfort, and Shane learned that apologizing was easier than he expected and that it created a new groove where children expect apologies and reciprocate understanding.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Shane Parrish

“I apologized to my kids and it was like oh my god like this I was like walking myself through this only what am i doing right and I apologized to my kids and it was like I'm sorry like I I responded disproportionately to what happened and had lost my patience and lost control of my emotions and reacted in a way that I don't want you to react yeah and my youngest just put his hand on my shoulder and was like it's okay done... it became easier than I thought it was like so much easier because you're wearing a New Groove between my where like that's normal”

0.43

Children have different emotional processing speeds and emotional recovery times, so one child may shift immediately from reactive to constructive when guided toward joint contribution, while another child needs more recovery time before they can access a non-reactive state.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sheila Heen

“One of my boys caught on to joint contribution really quickly at a pretty young age... My other son Jess we get it's totally stuck emotionally... he'd be like he called me a name mom I'm like I understand that we're dealing with that separately... I learned that I actually just needed to give him more recovery time to go to anything out of the reactionary period and then come back and now let's talk about it”