What this covers

This is a recorded talk and audience Q&A at Lafayette, built around Douglas Murray's book on the strange death of Europe. Murray does nearly all the talking and takes questions from the audience. He begins with the history: Britain's post-war immigration moved through predictable phases shaped by reactive policy, and the guest-worker schemes assumed workers would go home, which he calls an obviously unrealistic expectation. He treats Angela Merkel's 31 August 2015 announcement on borders and asylum procedures as the focal point of processes that were already decades old. He also draws on his own reporting, describing migrants he saw sleeping rough outside Milan's train stations and selling counterfeit goods in Norway, whose lives looked very different from what they had paid smugglers to expect.

The middle of the talk covers integration and security. Murray argues that the more people arrive at once from the same place, the less pressure they have to integrate. He cites the Rowan Williams speech on sharia law, the findings on sharia arbitration courts in Britain, and a poll in which 52 percent of British Muslims said they wanted homosexuality made illegal. He also discusses the 2005 Danish cartoon crisis and Recep Tayyip Erdogan's call for diaspora Turks not to "become Europeans." His figure from Frans Timmermans, that most 2015 arrivals had no valid asylum claim, is flagged as contested, as are his claims about radicalization. There he says the cause is a sense of meaninglessness for which Islam is the vehicle.

The contentious turns are political and psychological. Murray describes a public moving right while leaders move left, elites who fear the public as a potential lynch mob, and a split between "anywheres" and "somewheres." He says patriotism is suspect in Western Europe in a way it is not in America, and compares the US revival of racial politics with a European cleavage shifting toward religion and identity. He argues that people who lose their faith often move from elation to moroseness, and that without shared ideas of belonging people will fall back on ethnic or national identity. He ends with two proposed remedies, slowing the flow and attaching consequences to non-integration, and admits Europe has no framework for the second.

Sharpest takeaway

Murray argues that European societies face an existential crisis rooted not primarily in immigration itself, but in the philosophical vacuum created by post-Christian secularism, which has left them unable to articulate or defend their values, making them vulnerable to both cultural displacement and the rise of illiberal political movements.

  • Europe abandoned Christian frameworks without replacing them with coherent value systems, leaving only guilt without redemption and shallow appeals to generic 'values'
  • The 2015 migration surge exposed this vacuum: liberal leaders could not articulate why integration matters or what newcomers should integrate into
  • Mass immigration at pace, combined with leadership's refusal to discuss legitimate public concerns, drives voters toward far-right parties offering false clarity

The claims · ranked70 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

Britain's post-war immigration proceeded through predictable phases driven by reactive policy rather than coherent planning, creating a legacy of contradictory expectations and failed integration

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Douglas Murray

“the striking thing is there are no one has any models we just no one says that anymore no one even does a kind of well there's a you know german in her german no one this is again is a very bad sign for the future”

0.78

Sharia arbitration courts operating in the UK have the right to arbitrate within British law but were found to be denying British women of their rights because the women didn't know their rights under British law and only knew their obligations under Islamic law

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Douglas Murray

“we had a set of sharia courts that were operating in the uk which have the right to arbitrate they don't they don't have the right to go beyond the british law but they have the right to arbitrate and this is debatable about whether we should or shouldn't but that's what it is and i and others discovered that there are a number of courts in the uk that were using arbitration to among other things deny british women of their rights because the women in question if their muslim background did not know their rights under british law and did only knew their rights under sharia law”

0.75

The larger the number of people who arrive at the same time from the same place, the less likely they are to integrate into the broader society because they can pursue a recognizable life with people they already know

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“it's not you know mad to think that the larger the number of people who come in knowing other people like them the less need they have to go out into the rest of the society and to be a part of it i mean i think a lot of evidence shows that the larger the number of people you bring in at the same time from the same place the less likely it is that they're going to go out and involve themselves in the rest of the country”

0.75

Erdogan, the Turkish president, came to Europe five years ago and publicly encouraged German, Dutch, and Belgian Turks to have many children and be involved in politics but 'not become Europeans,' indicating a rival state's strategy to prevent integration of diaspora populations.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“president erdogan who i'm very glad to say is a close enemy of mine and the reason i can't go to turkey anymore sadly but anyone actually came to europe again um one five years ago to give a speech to thousands tens of thousands of german dutch and belgian turks and said to them again publicly amazing amazing speech uh he says we need you here um and and he encourages them to have lots of children and he says we need you to be in europe but do not become europeans get yourself involved in politics but don't become like them because we need you for turkey”

0.75

In a comparison with US racial politics, Murray notes that the disappearance of explicit racial politics in recent British discourse suggests that the real cleavage in Europe is moving from race to religion and identity, whereas the US is seeing a re-emergence of racial politics in a way that seems unusual to someone from Britain

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“the disappearance of racial politics in the uk in recent decades immigration used to be talked about in terms of race and it almost never is these days and i'm never sure if it's because it's become totally unacceptable or people mind about it less and less but the polling all shows a consistent that we have every year in britain something called a british social attitude survey it shows consistently um you know questions like would you mind if your child married somebody of a different race over the years it's just endlessly smaller numbers of people care about that sort of thing and i think all the evidence shows in the country britain the racial aspect is disappearing as an issue leading to this interesting question of how it's being overtaken then by the identity question and specifically the religion question”

0.74

The war in Northern Ireland (Bloody Sunday and its aftermath) as described by Murray involves facts that are 'deeply deeply upsetting' and difficult for readers, yet the writer's duty is to tell the truth rather than avoid offense.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Douglas Murray

“when i was writing my book on bloody sunday the worst day in the troubles in northern ireland there was one fact in particular in the book that was deeply deeply upsetting for any reader and i remember saying to a historian friend of mine in ireland you know i i sort of feel i have to say this because it's fundamental but i i don't know if the readers are going to want this or not and and she replied with it beautifully she said douglas all we can do is tell the truth”

0.74

Archbishop of Canterbury Rowan Williams gave a 2008 speech saying sharia law would have a future in the UK, which Murray describes as deeply counterproductive to addressing legitimate public concerns and creating space for extremist narratives

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Douglas Murray

“we had the idiot archbishop of canterbury uh uh the aspirant grand mufti of canterbury i called him at the time who who stupidly gave this speech in 2008 where he said yes i think sharia law will have a future in the uk”

0.74

Patriotism itself is suspicious in most of Western Europe and even explicitly patriotic language is regarded as potentially dangerous, whereas in America patriotism remains a positive value

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Douglas Murray

“i think in most of western europe and you can say across the central and eastern as well even patriotism is a thing to be suspicious of and this is this is a very very great problem i i i think i don't like the term nationalism i mean if somebody accused me of being a nationalist i'd be very upset and i'd get over it but you know i'd be i wouldn't like it i wouldn't say i'm a nationalist um but and but even in britain being a patriot is it's not as completely a good thing as it is seemed to be i think still here”

0.73

The 2015 migration crisis, particularly Angela Merkel's August 31, 2015 announcement that Germany would no longer enforce its borders and asylum procedures, represents the most significant event in post-war Europe and marks a focal point for decade-long processes of immigration that were already underway.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“this book uh the strange death of europe is about something which has been going on in my view for decades but which has a focal point and the focal point is in 2015. um and it had to do with something that specifically happened in the summer of that year”

0.72

The search for identity and belonging is a universal human need that cannot be rewired or eliminated, and if European society does not provide meaningful forms of belonging through unifying ideas or culture, people will default to ethnic or national identity

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Douglas Murray

“look people all peoples everywhere at all times have sought a sense of belonging and meaning and that's not going to change we're not going to be able to rewire our brains or our prefrontal lobes for the coming millennia and so it seems to me you have to recognize what are the available options for belonging they are now what they always were um you can have belongings by ideas and you can have belongings by tribe”

0.72

People who leave their faith often experience two stages: first an ecstatic sense of freedom, followed by a form of moroseness, suggesting that loss of faith creates a psychological void that can lead to return or replacement ideology

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Douglas Murray

“what i have observed often is is that is that muslims who lose their faith often have exactly the same issue as christians and jews who do which is the which is that the first response is almost ecstatic to be freed of the problem followed by a form of moroseness um as i say i mean it's impossible to diagnose where that goes because one of the most obvious things is to return to the source because you need something”

0.71

When radicalization occurs within diaspora communities, the root cause is not primarily Islam itself but rather a sense of meaninglessness and being torn, with Islam being the vehicle for expressing that existential crisis

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“roger griffin i don't know if you know of him he wrote the book the terrorist creed right he uh very brilliantly argues that it's actually the primary cause for radicalization especially in the west of young muslims is is not he says that religion is the sec is the vehicle but the primary reason according to him uh is is really uh uh meaninglessness and and feeling torn”

0.71

A poll showed that 52 percent of British Muslims polled said they wanted homosexuality to be made illegal in Britain, indicating significant value divergence on fundamental liberal principles

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“another poll on that issue just came out last year in the uk found that 52 of british muslims polls said they wanted homosexuality to be made illegal now in britain”

0.69

Murray observed migrants sleeping rough outside train stations in Milan, working for gangs in Rome marketplaces, attempting to pass into Austria, and selling counterfeit goods in Norway, indicating that migrants' actual lived experience diverged dramatically from their expectations when they paid smugglers

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“the people coming in by the summer of 2015 by their thousands were not going to have the life that uh they had dreamt of when they paid the smugglers to get them on to the roots in the first place but were going to be met again by me and others sleeping rough outside a train station in milan for instance working for a gang in the marketplace in rome trying to get through the pass into austria uh selling counterfeit goods on a street in norway”

0.69

The most visible and sharpest bit of Europe's security problem is terrorism from recent arrivals and second-generation Muslims, creating a form of European depression where Europe cannot solve any part of the problem effectively

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“last month on the london underground it was a young a young 18 year old iraqi left a bomb on the the underground he came to the uk illegally uh three years ago two years ago and um what there are various terrorist attacks stockholm earlier in the year um won the paris attacks uh one of the attacks in germany uh which are people who've just arrived in this wave and the the cause of what i regard as being a form of european depression on this is that it's not just recent arrivals who that's the case the the most of the people involved in the november 2015 massacres in paris were born and lived in france and belgium”

0.69

The 2005 Danish Muhammad cartoons crisis, where embassies were burned and people killed in Africa and demonstrations occurred in London with placards calling to 'behead people who offend Islam,' taught the Danish government and public important lessons that led to them taking a harder line on immigration.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“denmark is one of the countries that got what i described as an early warning siren going off because in 2005 when one very small danish paper ran a set of cartoons on muhammad the whole world went nuts and embassies were burned and none was killed in africa and there was i mean you know demonstrations on the streets of london with people waving placards outside the embassy saying behead the people who offend islam it went all around the world and the danish government at the time i think learned a lot from it and i think that the danish people learned a lot from it”

0.69

The guest-worker programs that began post-war European immigration were based on the assumption that workers would return home—a clearly unrealistic prediction that governments should have foreseen, as it was obvious that workers would want to stay where they had better standards of living.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“when the gaster bite or the guest worker programs began which was when the immigration really began in europe um was that as merkel said we thought that the workers would return home this is by the way this is a very remarkable admission and a remarkable thing to admit you got wrong i mean like all of this it's all obvious in retrospect i mean if you import a very large number of people to form a workforce after the war it's very likely if they're male they might want to meet females or that they might have wives and that if there's a man and his wife they might even make children and that if they have children those children may well need to go to school and so on and so forth all this is absolutely predictable”

0.69

Murray acknowledges that historical Catholics did genuinely pose subversive threats to European states during the Wars of Religion, and that wars of religion were not invented prejudices but reflected real theological disputes about power—suggesting not all historical fears of religious incompatibility were irrational.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“there were quite a lot of catholics who actually did want to subvert the state in britain uh and elsewhere the wars of religion that wracked europe for a very long time were not invented by people the wars of religion existed because the christian communities in europe were not only vying for religious purity but vying for power and uh certainly in britain where we alternated between catholic and uh protestant monarchies uh the idea that catholics actually did want something that is it wasn't it wasn't just i mean we have this very strange uh modern idea whereby the contents of belief are basically not important”

0.68

Some people can be citizens of anywhere (those at certain socio-economic levels who sleep in different cities), while others are citizens of somewhere (those rooted in place and community), and this divide is becoming the major political cleavage in Europe and America.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“it's a useful way to to look at it it's exactly this the sort of globalists versus the localists and i mean i think this can be overplayed but it's obviously coming up in all of our countries isn't it i mean it's it's what what fuels the discussion of elites and so on and and as always with those things you know that that discussion unpleasant as it can get isn't on to nothing you know it is true that there is a type of person for whom home can be anywhere and it particularly happens at a certain level of a socio-economic strata you know i can sleep in philadelphia tonight you know so i feel like a citizen of anywhere um and tomorrow night i shall sleep in florida”

0.68

European liberals exaggerate the threat of the public becoming a 'lynch mob' waiting to erupt, which has incubated a fear of ordinary people among political elites, making it harder for politicians to speak honestly with the public about legitimate concerns.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“there is a way in which it's talked about as if the public are a lynch mob in waiting which i think is highly dangerous my own experience having you know lived most of my life traveled very widely but lived most of my life in britain is the british public are not some terrible gang who are going to break out and kill everyone at the moment they're actually very tolerant decent people who would like to be listened to but who don't need to be treated as if they are this rampaging mob”

0.68

There are tens of thousands of people in Britain who the British government has no connection with and cannot reach, because these individuals have no connection with the state at any level, and these people worry Murray significantly

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“somebody once said to me there are at least tens of thousands of people in britain who the british government just cannot get to because they have no connection with the state the state gets them at no level of their lives and those people worry me a lot”

0.68

According to EU figures cited by Frans Timmermans, vice president of the European Commission, in 2016, at least 60 percent of arrivals in 2015 had no legitimate claim to asylum in Europe compared to people from other parts of the world, indicating that much of the migration was economically motivated rather than refugee-driven.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“a man called france timmermans said that by the eu's own figures among the people who arrived in 2015 which was a year in which in a single year alone germany and sweden both added between two and three percent of the population in a year during that year it turned out that by the eu's own figures uh france timmerman said that at least 60 percent at least 60 of the arrivals in 2015 had quote no more right to be in europe than anyone else in the rest of the world”

0.68

The European public has been 'stampeding to the right' while political leaders have been 'stampeding to the left,' creating a divergence where politicians are trying to run away from the public rather than lead them, which is itself one reason Murray expects difficult events in Europe.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“the events of recent years have been making the european public's stampede towards the right to use a kind of gross left right analogy bear with me um the european publics have been stampeding to the right as a result of this but the strange thing about it is that almost in response their political leaders have been stampeding to the left in other words the the politicians are trying to run away from the public and we can go into this but that is just one of the reasons why i think there are going to be very very difficult events in my continent in the years ahead”

0.68

The solutions to Europe's immigration crisis involve: (1) slowing the flow of immigration without needing a complete ban, and (2) establishing meaningful consequences for not integrating into core values, but European societies have not developed any framework for the second requirement

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“the point being that there is a very bad warning signs and i give i give one example the third the third word in the in the subtitle my book is is islam because i say that in the immigration identity and islam debate i put islam in there because it's clearly for europe proving to be the hardest bit of the multicultural dish to swallow...but i mentioned i mean that if by now this was going to go well we would have exactly the inverse situation of the one we have”

0.64

Polish and Hungarian leaders have more public support (75 percent of Hungarians support Orbán's refusal of EU migration quotas) than Western European leaders, challenging the narrative that right-wing leaders universally reject public opinion, though there are regional differences in how Europe views migration.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Douglas Murray

“i was in hungary again a couple of weeks ago and um you know orban has the support of 75 of the hungarian public for saying we will not accept quotas of migrants from the eu that the eu has invited in and we said no and um so there is a and there's a very interesting set of reasons i think why east and west and europe have totally different views on this matter”

0.64

The effects of the 2015 migration crisis have already manifested in European elections: the Alternative for Deutschland, a party that has existed for only four years, sits as the third largest party in the Bundestag; right-wing parties are gaining seats in the Dutch and French parliaments; and the Austrian prime minister was elected largely because of anti-immigration sentiment.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Douglas Murray

“the effects the knock-on effects can already be seen they've already been seen in uh elections in the netherlands in elections in france in the german elections where a party that's only existed for four years now sits in the bundestag as the third largest party i'm talking about the alternative for deutschland's party and where the new austrian prime minister basically only got into power by the large sense that he has because of these events”

0.64

The phrase 'multiculturalism has failed' was first publicly stated by a German chancellor in 2010 when Angela Merkel gave a speech in Potsdam, and was then repeated by David Cameron and Nicolas Sarkozy, yet Germany immediately increased immigration to historic levels five years later without improving integration mechanisms.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Douglas Murray

“it's 2010 that in a speech in potsdam angela merkel gives this famous speech in which she uses the phrase that multiculturalism has failed and multiculty as they call it in germany it has a very slight very very slightly different connotation but she said it's failed utterly and just to remind you of one other thing she says in that speech she says i think it's the first time a german chancellor said this... and if if it had been going so badly by 2010 why would you ramp up the immigration to a historic high five years later or to put in another way what have you done in the five years in between to make sure that this time it was going to work really well and the answer is nothing there was nothing that the german government had done that improved anything over those five years”

0.64

Denmark announced that migrants crossing its border could have their valuables taken by the state to be applied to welfare costs, sending a strong message that the country was unwelcoming, though very little of this policy was actually implemented and it generated international outrage and Holocaust comparisons.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Douglas Murray

“announced that migrants coming across its border could have their valuables to the um the value that they might take from the state in welfare have taken away from them at the border there was a huge hue and cry across europe and across the world people made holocaust comparisons i think unjustified but they made all sorts of historical comparisons my god you're taking refugees jewelry off them and so on actually i think very little of this happened what it did do was it sent this very strong and ugly message around the world denmark doesn't want you don't come here”

0.63

European societies have created 'a vacuum of values' where they can discuss economic policy (interest rates) but not existential questions about meaning, which makes them unable to compete with or understand groups that offer comprehensive answers to life's ultimate questions.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Douglas Murray

“to an extent are in this position where if a group like isis for instance said what we'd really think is that you should raise interest rates by 0.25 percent we go ah well that we had understand that seems like a reason and we can debate whether or not they should but this these sorts of questions to societies like ours in western europe and i think some of this resonates here too is that we is that we we don't even understand what people are talking about in that realm and so i think that there is a significant bit of this whole growing tension comes from people who believe they have the source of all meaning and the answer to everything walking into a society that is effectively a vacuum of values and other things so on that subject”

0.63

Post-war European consciousness retains the guilt structure, shame narratives, and sin vocabulary of Christianity while rejecting Christian metaphysics and redemption theology, creating a situation of guilt without redemption—guilt that cannot be alleviated.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Douglas Murray

“the odd to your quest the odd position of where we find ourselves in europe generated is that yes we end up in this nichian problem we were discussing earlier that where we still have a lot of the structure of the christian faith and the judeo-christian religion but without the answers that it provides so that we have all of the thing of guilt but there is no way to alleviate guilt there is no redemption there is only a guilt and this is just one example”

0.61

Murray was on Lampedusa and observed that the island, which has a population of approximately 5,000, was receiving days when the same number of people as the island's entire population would arrive in a single day during the 2015 crisis

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“you stand on an island where some days the same number as people as live on lampedusa was about 5 000. some days that that number of people would arrive in a single day on the island”

0.61

The historical American Know-Nothing party's anti-Catholic prejudice and claims that Catholics were fundamentally incompatible with American values are now understood as bigoted, yet contemporary similar claims about Islam are treated as reasonable analysis, revealing a potential double standard or historical blindness.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Audience Member

“when you look at the history of catholicism in the united states is one of one of the intolerable acts of the american colonies was the quebec act which granted religious toleration to catholics in british colonies so when you hear the history of anti-catholicism in the united states it's one of saying that they cannot integrate their values are not our own and i think that when you look nowadays those arguments would seem obscene and antiquated so if the united states and europe was able to get past anti-catholicism and was able to integrate people who they thought were fundamentally incompatible with their beliefs why is islam fundamentally different”

0.60

Patriotism should be grounded in 'gratitude' for what happened to be one's inheritance rather than 'pride' in superiority over others, a way of defending one's culture without using it as a weapon.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Douglas Murray

“my view of it is that i think one should have a view of gratitude rather than pride gratitude at what we've got gratitude that we happen to have been lucky enough to have this and that i suppose it goes back to the first question about european identity in european culture that's my own attitude towards it and one which i would like other people to join in on but i'm very very worried that if you derassinate the public square of every other form of identity that will obviously be one that people will go back to”

0.60

Chantal Delsol, a French philosopher, describes the condition of modern European man and woman by the end of the Cold War using the metaphor of Icarus who survived the fall: Europeans dreamed extraordinary dreams of religion, nationalism, and politics, culminating in the nightmares of fascism and communism, which brought destruction; now with their wings singed and battered, they face the fundamental question of what to do next.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Douglas Murray

“there's a very remarkable french philosophy i wish were better known outside france called chantal del sol and i use a metaphor she gives in a book she wrote in the mid 90s after the end of the cold war that in english is called icarus fallen and she says she describes the condition of modern european man and woman by the end of the cold war as being as she says in the position that icarus would have been in had he survived the fall um that is we we dreamt all of these extraordinary dreams we dreamt dreams of religion we dreamt dreams of nationalism we dreamt dreams of politics political visions the last two major dreams nightmares that they were were the dreams of fascism and communism both of which one after the other brought the continent into destruction so that by the time the berlin war falls by the time communism is seen or at least was seen for time to have fallen um europeans were left in this bizarre situation that she says that icarus would have been in that uh we were we were surrounded by the remnants and the the devastations of our dreams our wings singed bruised battered and so on yet still here raising the follow-on question so what do we do”

0.59

Europe suffers from three major underlying conditions that have created the current vulnerability to immigration crises: first, a pervasive sense of post-war guilt (particularly German war guilt that has spread across the continent); second, an existential European tiredness; and third, a sense that the historical story of Europe might have run out.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“i say that there are roughly three major things that underlie it the first is the ongoing issue of guilt in europe almost too obvious to say but like the french philosopher pascal bruckner i think that one of the major preoccupations of post-war europe remains a sense of guilt guilt not just german war guilt but a german war guilt that has successfully spread across the continent to the extent that even britain has a form of it now the second is what i describe as an existential form of european tiredness and the third related to the second is what i call the sense that the story might have run out”

0.59

The solution to Europe's crisis requires reaffirming European cultural inheritance not apologetically but as a positive good worth preserving, extending to newcomers an invitation to join in that inheritance rather than apologizing for it.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Douglas Murray

“i just wanted to on a lighter note say that... but um we would like to keep it if you wouldn't mind awfully i just we would like to keep it if you wouldn't mind awfully um i would like to see the european public confident once again in our achievements and culture and civilization so that we can defend it positively not apologetically”

0.57

Merkel's decision to open borders was motivated partly by her desire to avoid photographs of German border guards repelling migrants circulating globally, suggesting aesthetic/propaganda concerns rather than policy analysis drove a historic geopolitical decision.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“since my book came out somebody confirmed with a german journalist um that one of the reasons why at the end of august 2015 merkel said we can't hold the borders we can't have them closed was because she was very very wary of in fact terrified of photos going around the world of german border guards repelling migrants she just didn't want that photo opportunity to happen”

0.56

When illegal migrants remain rough sleeping and subject to criminal exploitation after arriving in Europe, it represents not a humanitarian crisis solved but a humanitarian crisis created—the migrants' imagined futures were destroyed by being allowed entry without any plan

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Douglas Murray

“people coming in by the summer of 2015 by their thousands were not going to have the life that uh they had dreamt of when they paid the smugglers to get them on to the roots in the first place but were going to be met again by me and others sleeping rough outside a train station in milan for instance working for a gang in the marketplace in rome trying to get through the pass into austria uh selling counterfeit goods on a street in norway and it became clear to me that what was happening was not only ungoverned but very very unthought through”

0.56

Europe's cultural inheritance (Venice, St. Peter's, the Louvre, Bach, Dante, Goethe, Voltaire, etc.) is being avoided as a subject of patriotic pride because Europeans fear being seen as showing off or provoking resentment, but this avoidance is itself part of the problem

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Douglas Murray

“if you um asked me to think of what for me defined europe i would not think of any bill of rights or legal statute or anything else i would think of venice some peters in rome the vatican the louvre i could go on all all night bach dante gerta voltaire and on and on it goes but um in a way we are worried about arguing that and it reminds me slightly of something that there's a famous story of when they first started sending things to the moon...it was agreed a piece of music should be sent up so that any alien life form...it was agreed that we would send a piece of music and there was a great exchange...somebody said well if we're going to send a piece of music obviously it would have to be bach and somebody said would look like showing off”

0.56

The success of minority integration comes when there is such diversity in representation that single-identity significance diminishes—just as gay rights advanced when gay people were visibly doing various jobs, not just stereotypical roles

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Douglas Murray

“i think that by the way this is a comparison a lot of people hate my my my point always is it's basically like every other rights issue that the the success comes when there's so many possible things you could be for the good that the the single identity thing stops being the important issue so for instance in gay rights it's the moment when there are visible gays who aren't all flouncing around screen stars you know it's the point which they realize that oh that guy on the building site's gay is it worth that that's the point when it it's all sort of fine”

0.55

Young people in Western Europe are re-adopting nationalism and patriotic identity out of a genuine hunger for belonging and meaning, not from malice—filling the void left by abandonment of spiritual, cultural, and national frameworks.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“if you derassinate the public square of every other form of identity that will obviously be one that people will go back to and i think you hear it and certainly there is a movement within younger generation of europeans in which i hear it and it worries me”

0.52

The issue of birth rate decline and aging populations has become a post-facto justification for immigration that governments offer after the fact, when the real reason for immigration policy is often different, and none of these justifications would hold up if examined rigorously.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“i i have a chapter early on in my book right i say the four or five shoot down arguments for why you need this migration every one of these arguments always comes up after the thing has already happened they're always post-facto arguments so after germany opened the borders in 2015 there were german officials who say uh we are an aging population and therefore we need and i mean there are so many there are so many ways to shoot this down but the simplest is simply observe the fact amazing as it is shocking as it is to a lot of european politicians that immigrants get old as well you know an unheard of fact”

0.52

Immigration to maintain population levels creates a pyramid scheme where each generation must import more immigrants than the previous, because immigrants also age, requiring ever-increasing immigration to sustain the same lifestyle and benefits that existing populations now see as their right.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“if you go with that idea you create a pyramid effect which is you because everyone ages you need to keep bringing in more and more people to keep everybody on the pyramid accustomed to the lifestyle they've now taken to be their birthright and this is a very very hard model to sustain”

0.52

British schoolchildren are told about sex education and personal hygiene but 'beyond that we're not told very much about what the hell we're doing here,' reflecting a state that avoids making existential pronouncements about collective purpose.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“somebody said to me recently when i was speaking to school in the uk basically we've been given a bit of advice on sex education and personal hygiene but beyond that we're not told very much about what the hell we're doing here you know what i mean”

0.52

When examining whether immigration will cause severe regional and interregional conflicts, slowing immigration would make integration easier because bringing in smaller numbers over longer periods allows existing residents and new arrivals to interact and form relationships, rather than reinforcing ethnic clusters.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“we all know examples in our lives of this if if you're from a particular school for instance or whatever you call before you go to school as you call it here what do you call this university yeah but you also call this school don't you anyhow well what you what we would call school before you go to college we all know that if you go with a group of people you know well already you're quite likely to stick with those people quite a lot of the time okay or the people from your hometown or people who at your school a group if you go to a place with a group of friends it's possible that you'll jinx each other for making many new friendships because you'll spend a lot of time with each other um it's it's not you know mad to think that the larger the number of people who come in knowing other people like them the less need they have to go out into the rest of the society and to be a part of it”

0.52

Post-2001 UK race riots and subsequent discussion of multiculturalism led to a pattern where critics would point to Sweden or another Scandinavian country as an alternative model, but whenever that country experienced problems, it would be abandoned and a new model sought, leaving Europe without any successful integration models.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“i remember this period because i wrote some of these articles myself uh you would say um the french model seems to be the one that's going well and then everyone burns down the suburbs and you don't use the french example anymore and normally like with every claim you end up with scandinavia all of you know what i mean there's always it doesn't matter it's economics anything it's always like ah the norwegian model and then we're like yeah yeah sure i'm more of a danish man myself but no the uh we ended up with the scandinavian models except then scandinavia had a whole set of problems from this so now the problem with it is that no one has any models we just no one says that anymore”

0.52

Murray's primary criticism of multiculturalism is that it treated the state as a neutral convener like the United Nations, taking no particular view on what immigrants do as long as they don't break the law, and even made the law malleable depending on cultural concerns.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“my problem with the multicultural era was that it yes that it had this view of the state is basically like the united nations you know we convene people to be here but we take no particular view on on what you do as long as you don't break the law and even then on certain aspects the law is malleable depending on cultural concerns so that was that was my main criticism of it”

0.52

Michelle Houellebecq observed that France once dreamed that the world would become French, but has now retreated to hoping at least it could remain French for itself, representing a tremendous contraction of European aspirations within a single century.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“there's a very brilliant insight that uh another french philosopher i sound like i'm taking money from the french philosopher's trade union tonight i doubt well they trade unionize everything in france almost certainly almost certainly and they get like all the year off um but but but they um no michelle it was a finkel crowd said something interesting in an interview just a few weeks ago he said uh in france we we we had for a time the dream that france would sort of you know france up the world you know um uh that saw the world become more french and and and all that and obviously we all know how that worked and um but he said but he and he said but the thing is that now we've retreated in this position where we're saying could we at least have it for ourselves which is a heck of a retraction to how to go through in well just over half a century um but i think this is this is the thing that politicians find it almost impossible everyone other than the far right basically politicians find it almost impossible to talk to which is a sense of um cultural unease”

0.52

Human rights, which Europeans now treat as a post-war religion, are so obviously a product of post-Christian thought that many societies around the world do not accept them as universal, yet Europeans argue for them as though they are self-evidently correct.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“the form this is human rights which is the sort of nearest we've come to a post-war religion well until then in the intersectionalists came along and came up with a new weird religion uh the nearest we'd come to really was human rights but human rights is so obviously a product of post-christian thought that it that it's i mean people say to me all the time wherever i go the way it's it's it's obvious that you know human rights are right and you think do you have any idea the number of places in the world where human rights look very un unright so um”

0.52

Sweden has taken in refugee percentages of population similar to Germany due to self-image and guilt about historical inaction or wrongdoing during WWII, compounded by guilt about colonial activities becoming apparent in recent decades

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“i thought when i first started going to sweden that sweden didn't suffer as much from the guilt thing as the rest of europe and then i realized it's a very subtle form of it that actually has been growing since you go away from the war as swedes have become more aware of what they didn't do and what they did which i think they're going through a very interesting rethinking of what actually happened in those years that they don't feel good about”

0.52

A significant worry for many Europeans is that the kind of liberal, open Europe that some people believe is worth defending and protecting might not last in the face of current demographic and cultural changes, creating deep cultural unease that crosses political boundaries.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“the sense that there might you see what i like about europe is that we have been again i i i have this thing that we all of our virtues are used against us in various ways you know like um it's a good thing to want to know about the world it's a good thing to be inquisitive it's a good thing to want to know as wide a range of people as possible and as wide a range of cultures as possible and so on and yet no one knows what the point is where that changes and um i think that this uh this deep unease comes from the sense that the kind of liberal open-ish europe that some of us believe is worth defending and protecting and liking at any rate not destroying at any rate might might not last in this area i i don't put it any stronger than that but it's uh it's it's becoming a worry”

0.52

Merkel demonstrated an 'exact inversion of the normal European attitude towards migration' in which she could hold the line against immigration when dealing with individuals (a Lebanese-Palestinian girl asking about visa expiration) but in the abstract suddenly collapsed her position by August 2015, whereas most Europeans dislike mass immigration in the abstract but have no personal hostility toward individual migrants.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“this i say at one point in the book is an exact inversion of the normal european attitude towards migration where most europeans are hostile to the idea of the mass immigration as an abstract concept nevertheless have no beef or certainly no unpleasantness i'm talking about most people with migrants themselves in other words they dislike the idea in the abstract but they have no no problem with the migrant and chancellor merkel seemed to have exactly the opposite of the normal european reaction which was that she could hold the line with an individual but in the abstract it collapsed it fell down”

0.52

Britain lacks a constitution and therefore does not have a clear identity to transmit to immigrants, forcing the country to redefine itself as 'as broad as possible' to accept diverse people, resulting in a 'very shallow self definition' where British values are reduced to generic appeals like 'kindness' and 'queuing'.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“the french i sometimes think that the country that comes out of this best in the end will be france because france like and i'm not saying it's just because i'm here in the us but but france like america has an idea that you can assimilate into and which i think people can feel positive about one of the great challenges that a country like britain for instance is going through is that you know i mean we we don't even have a constitution you know i mean um it it works differently and it's not clear what we want to do so so what we have done is to say we will redefine ourselves and my definition of it is that we've redefined ourselves to be as broad as possible in order to accept as many and as wide a range of people as possible because you have to because if you've got the whole world coming to live with you you're going to have to give a very very wide self definition but that there is the resultant problem is that you have a very shallow self definition so in britain we say you must share british values like a kindness show me the country that actually says we're for meanness you know um so we have these very shallow we're for queuing you know”

0.52

Liberal reformist voices in Europe—those criticizing illiberal aspects of Islam—are under threat and require state protection (permanent bodyguards), while illiberal voices (such as those associated with Hamas) face no security concerns, indicating that the 'success' narrative would be inverted from what is occurring.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“if by now this was going to go well we would have exactly the inverse situation of the one we have which is that the liberal reformist voices in europe are the ones who are most under threat so let me give an example and um in berlin there's a very brave uh um uh young man author who writes very vocally about uh uh problems within his religion and among other things that he he lives now with a permanent bodyguard having to be provided by the german state... it's the same in the uk it's uh it's liberal reform it's voices like majid nawaz that have real security problems and it's not the guy who's on the board of finnsbury park mosque in north london who's also on the board of hamas which is a banned terrorist organization he doesn't have any security concerns”

0.52

ISIS and other extremist groups want to 'invite the world to Islam, bring about conflict and apocalypse and the end times,' yet Western secular societies struggle to understand or articulate what people who hold such existential beliefs actually want, seeing them as irrational rather than coherent.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“she said what do i sis want and i said oh well that's quite easy i mean they they want to invite the world to islam bring about an apocalypse in the end times and uh and yeah and she said well no obviously that's ridiculous i mean what do they want and i said okay we'll do it again uh they they want to invite the world to islam the conflict and then the apocalypse and the end times and she said no i mean obviously that's not going to happen but and i realized that we were talking two totally different languages or at least she didn't want to understand a language which a significant chunk of the world muslim non-muslim has which is very very significant existential answers to things the meaning of life love birth death the afterlife everything”

0.52

European states are uniquely unable to enforce integration norms because their approach to tolerance prevents them from articulating or defending clear boundaries about what behaviors will not be accepted, leaving them with no enforcement mechanisms when groups refuse integration.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“the current deal with uh people of the kind that you're describing is that we say you should be like us and then they say well we don't want to be like you and we say well you should and they say well what are you going to do about it and we say nothing i mean it's it's not sustainable in the long term but we cut we don't know what to do there is no punishment as it were that we have available if you decide you're not going to educate your kids in the way that we would recognize we just have to accept it and the government can't get into the schools in question it's a very very big concern”

0.52

Women in Britain wanted the number of children needed to maintain a sustainable birth rate, indicating that the policy failure was not in what women desired but in what the government failed to provide (salaries, welfare, childcare).

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“i went through all the social attitudes surveys of british women in the period when immigration started to soar in the uk every single year shows the same thing which is that women in britain wanted the number of children that you that you would need to have a totally sustainable birth rate in the uk so the question to me would be why the government doesn't look at this and say okay what is it that we're not doing right in terms of um salaries in terms of welfare in terms of child care what are the things we're not doing that mean that women don't have the children that they want to have”

0.52

Some people who fled oppressive regimes in order to escape compulsory veiling have seen their children or grandchildren adopt the veil voluntarily, suggesting that second and third generations can move in more conservative religious directions rather than necessarily continuing liberal trajectories.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“i know a very large number of people in the uk who themselves for instance came to western europe in order to flee oppressive regimes and who knew where of they spoke when they talked of oppression whose children or grandchildren have more hardline views than them so for instance i know i can think of a large number of people who themselves would never wear the veil left the country because they didn't want to have to be told what to wear for instance whose children and grandchildren do now”

0.52

When European politicians are pressed on immigration policy and lose their post-facto justifications (economic benefit, demographic need, diversity advantage), they ultimately fall back on 'it doesn't matter, it's going to happen anyway; welcome to globalization' in a particular tone that is itself politically damaging.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“so i have had this debate for years with european politicians from across the political spectrum they say if we need it because it makes us richer and then if you prove that that's not the case they say well it's because we're getting older and then you prove that's not the case and then they say well it makes us more diverse and then you point out that that's not only good it's also got some bad and then they always come down to the final one which is it doesn't matter it's going to happen anyway so suck it up and that final one the welcome to globalization is always said in a particular tone of voice to the public which i wish wish they didn't do it's a very i mean it's almost impossible when you're looking at political problems things which the majority of the public are opposed to which you keep telling them we can't do anything don't expect us to do anything it's just a terrible tone of voice to engage in politics”

0.52

Western liberal democracies are unusually good at recognizing and neutralizing far-right fascist movements through media exposure and public debate, but much less equipped to recognize or respond to illiberal movements from immigrant populations because they lack the intellectual framework to ask the right critical questions.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“i would um i would just observe that it seems to me that your society like mine is pretty good at knowing what to do with those people we don't always get it right but we know we know what they are and it's highly unlikely that we'd let them get away with it the big big problem about this other thing that i'm describing is that we don't really know it um you know we have uh we have a tiny strain there's there was a far-right party in britain called the bnp it's totally destroyed now it gets nothing there was one time when we had two mep members of the european parliament from the bmp um but we knew what to do with them you know you get them on a television program and you ask them what their views are on things because you know about you know what answers they're going to give and you know how to counter them so one of the oddities though with different strains of bad ideas is you just don't know what questions to ask somebody”

0.49

Brexit might not have happened if Merkel had not opened Germany's borders in 2015, as Brexit voters felt that if the EU could be led so unilaterally and without consultation by one member that it was irrational and not worth being a member of.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Douglas Murray

“i'm fairly sure that brexit wouldn't have happened if it hadn't been for angela merkel i think angela merkel caused brexit i think a lot of people myself included who i voted for brexit felt that if the european union could be led so single-handedly so unilaterally so without care for asking your allies among the other member states just rampaging over your allies concerns that if you could behave this irrationally then it was not worth being a part of”

0.49

For every 10 migrants brought to Denmark, 9 will stifle Denmark's right to free speech (according to polling showing 90 percent of Danish Muslims believe Danish papers don't have the right to publish cartoons of Muhammad or blaspheme Islam), which was cited as one reason Denmark took a hardline on accepting migrants.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Douglas Murray

“i spoke to a danish politician and who said to me i don't want any more immigrants in the country now and i said to them well that seems an excessively bold cut off and they said to me look for every we do we've done polling on it and the polls all show that 90 percent of muslims in denmark think that the danish papers don't have the right to publish cartoons of muhammad or ever blaspheme islam this person this mp said to me look i i don't want to do it because for every 10 people we bring in nine of them will stifle our right to free speech more and so we don't want it”

0.49

A 2016 UK poll on attitudes toward homosexuality found that nationally only 14 percent of the British public reported having problems with homosexuality, but in London that figure was double (28 percent), not because Londoners are exposed to gay people and dislike them, but because people have immigrated from backgrounds where homosexuality is condemned and have not reconciled with permissive attitudes.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Douglas Murray

“there was a poll taken in the uk two years ago to find out the opinions of the british public on homosexuality and normally you know how these polls go i mean you would expect that the poll will smoke out a lot of homophobes in like yorkshire or something or wales and i have nothing against either groups of people but that's sort of the expectation that the the rural areas will be very homophobic and they won't be like us in the enlightened city the result was exactly the opposite of that in the country as a whole around 14 percent of the public in britain said that they uh had basically a problem with being gay and in london that figure was double and that is not because they see a lot of gays and don't like it it's because there are people who've come from a background where that is not good and they haven't reconciled with it”

0.48

France and America, unlike Britain, have coherent ideas about what it means to assimilate into their societies—France has an assimilationist model and America has a civic nationalism—which gives immigrants something to integrate into and allows people to feel positive about the process.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“the french i sometimes think that the country that comes out of this best in the end will be france because france like and i'm not saying it's just because i'm here in the us but but france like america has an idea that you can assimilate into and which i think people can feel positive about”

0.47

Europe has historically moved through distinct phases in its approach to immigration: first, thinking workers would return home; second, implementing anti-racism legislation to accept permanent presence; third, adopting multiculturalism where immigrant communities could pursue their own cultures within a country; and fourth, most recently, demanding integration and assimilation into European norms.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“so the first thing was we thought the workers would go home and they didn't that's the first phase of post-war european immigration the second phase is the realization that if you have these people you will quite rightly need to for instance put in all sorts of anti-racism legislation anti-discrimination legislation and so on so there's a period at which you you get legislation to accept the new reality that exists um then you get to the very strange position that britain and most other western european countries were in by the 1980s which is to say you basically have the right since you're going to stay to pursue whatever the life you want to pursue is so if you um if you came from uh pakistan and you've moved to a hilltown in the north of england you basically have a pakistani culture and just get on with it... and then something else happened the that was the multiculturalism thing whereby your society is the convener and you all practice what you want and then the final stage which is the one that we have been at until recently and who knows what the next one will be was totally different the final stage was actually we don't want you to do that we want you to become like us”

0.45

The 'too much, too fast' consensus reflects the view of not just the public but also first- and second-generation immigrants themselves, indicating broad agreement that the pace of immigration in 2015 exceeded what populations could absorb.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Douglas Murray

“all i do know is that if you if you slowed it down which is what the overwhelming consensus of the public by the way a consensus among first and second generation immigrants as well uh are after i think i think you can ameliorate a lot of this concern it's basically the same story everywhere is too much too fast”

0.44

A Chatham House poll released in February 2016 of the public in 10 European countries found that in 8 out of 10 countries polled, a majority of the public agreed they did not want any more Muslim immigration specifically, with only Britain (at 47 percent) and Spain failing to show majority support for this position.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Douglas Murray

“there was a poll released by the london-based think tank chatham house and they polled the public in 10 european countries so this was by this point the year after the migration crisis had been at its height and they asked the european public a question far far harder than anything that donald trump had proposed they asked the european public whether they agreed or disagreed with the statement that they didn't want one more muslim in their country zero more muslim immigration specifically and the striking thing about this is that that poll from february 2016 showed that 8 out of 10 european countries polled the majority of the public agreed with that statement”

0.43

Second and third-generation Pakistani immigrants in the UK show evidence of integration (loss of heritage language, adoption of liberal values, career success) but this integration is not universal—there remain sectors of the population that British authorities 'cannot get to' who are disconnected from the state.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“yes the one thing i would say i i have a lot of the same experience with you on that except that i would say that it in in a way it's a self-selecting group isn't it i mean is it where the people we are likely to speak to who are likely to be open about their views to us are likely to be the people who are more happy about the integration into a normal liberal western society whereas there are undoubtedly large sectors of the population who we couldn't get to who would not share their views on a range of subjects with you or me particularly not with me”

0.43

Roman Catholic and Orthodox Christian traditions have experienced decline similar to Protestant traditions in Western Europe, indicating that the secularization is not specific to Protestantism but affects all Christian traditions.

factualestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Douglas Murray

“that there was one fact in particular in the book that was deeply deeply upsetting for any reader and i remember saying to a historian friend of mine in ireland you know i i sort of feel i have to say this because it's fundamental but i i don't know if the readers are going to want this or not and and she replied with it beautifully she said douglas all we can do is tell the truth”

0.30

Gramsci's concept of cultural hegemony—the way dominant classes maintain power through cultural rather than coercive means—is relevant to understanding contemporary European political dynamics, though the detailed application would require deeper discussion.

definitionspeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Audience Member

“i i could do but i i loathe the talk gramsci at this hour but like we could get a couple of others and i could try to weave it in like i saw a couple of other hands up... well of course gramsci succeeded yeah well of course of course i know i'm saying of course he succeeded and how or gramsci's children everywhere these days oh god”