YouTube14m· Apr 2020· cataloged

Is This The Only Way Out Of This Trillion Dollar Debt Crisis..


What this covers

This is a solo video by Mark Moss, about fifteen minutes long, that sets the economy of 2020 beside the early 1930s and asks whether a debt jubilee is the way out of the current debt load. He begins with a split in American life. The wealthiest 40% have gained from a decade of rising asset prices, while the bottom 60% face stagnant wages, heavy consumer debt, and thin emergency savings. He then lists four political conditions he says precede a jubilee: a widening wealth gap, cultural threats from minorities or immigrants, an ineffective government, and anger at elites. A chart of populist vote spikes is offered as supporting evidence, and he claims all four conditions are now met, which is contested.

The middle of the video is historical. He notes that jubilees appear across ancient and modern history, then argues that American versions were not the universal forgiveness of the biblical model but transfers of wealth. His main case is 1933. Roosevelt closed the banks for four days, forced citizens to surrender gold at $20 an ounce, and then raised the price, which Moss says wiped out nearly 70% of the savings of those who complied. He also covers the elimination of the gold clause in contracts, the 5-4 Supreme Court ruling that upheld it, and a Harvard estimate of roughly $700 million a year taken from bondholders. He adds that European countries wrote off an average of about 20% of their debt between 1932 and 1939.

From there he moves to Nixon's 1971 default on gold convertibility. The dollar lost about 30% of its value, inflation more than doubled, and stocks fell nearly 50% in two years. Jimmy Carter's Swiss franc bonds serve as evidence of lost trust. He then returns to the present: zero interest rates, roughly six trillion dollars added by the Federal Reserve, and the claim that new money flows to the rich. His forecast is hedged, since he says a jubilee may be one of the only exits but is not certain. He closes by urging ordinary savers to learn the history.

Sharpest takeaway

Mark Moss argues that the current economic environment—unprecedented debt, extreme wealth inequality, populist sentiment, and massive central bank money printing—mirrors the 1930s conditions that preceded major debt jubilees, suggesting a debt jubilee may be imminent and poses significant risks to ordinary savers and investors.

  • Four political preconditions for debt jubilees are present today: widening wealth gap, cultural threats from minorities/immigrants, ineffective government, and growing anger toward elites
  • Economic metrics from 1930-1933 (zero interest rates, money printing, asset inflation, wealth concentration) nearly perfectly match current conditions
  • Historical debt jubilees in America (1841 bankruptcy act, 1933 Roosevelt policies, 1971 Nixon default) systematically transferred wealth from ordinary savers to the government/wealthy through devaluation and confiscation

The claims · ranked41 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.74

Between 1932 and 1939, countries across the European Union abandoned the gold standard and wrote off liabilities, with an average debt write-off of approximately 20%, though France and Greece wrote off 40-50% of their debt.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Mark Moss

“between 1932 to 1939 countries from all over the EU basically abandoned the gold standard and they had to start writing off their liabilities the average amount of debt written off during that time was about 20% but it was a lot higher for more France and Greece wrote off about 40 to 50% of their debt”

0.74

The government cannot restore confidence in a currency through force alone; people must have genuine confidence in the currency, otherwise it ends up like Venezuela where currency is worthless paper.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Mark Moss

“but force doesn't give the dollar confidence people have to have confidence in it otherwise you end up like in venezuela where there's paper all over the street you need to have confidence”

0.69

The U.S. federal government became so desperate after Nixon's 1971 default that it issued bonds (Carter bonds) denominated in Swiss francs rather than dollars, because the U.S. dollar could no longer be trusted.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Mark Moss

“believe it or not the federal government got so desperate check this out got so desperate that it issued carter bonds now these were denominated in swiss francs because the US dollar couldn't be trusted anymore nobody had any confidence in the dollar”

0.69

FDR eliminated the gold clause in all contracts, which had previously allowed creditors and investors to require repayment in gold rather than fiat currency, effectively converting their gold-backed claims into worthless paper promises.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Mark Moss

“he went on to eliminate what's known as the gold clause in all contract so back then gold was still considered money and in in loans and bonds and other financial instruments like that people you know people were afraid that the government might come in and try to inflate away the value of their money kinda like we're seeing now and so they were afraid of that back then and so they added this gold clause which basically said that repayments could be required to be made in gold so if they Reeve if they inflate it away the money I'd say you know I don't want that fake paper I want real gold and that was a gold clause in that but he took that away”

0.69

After forcing Americans to turn in gold for $20 per ounce worth of paper money, the government immediately raised the price of gold, wiping out almost 70% of the savings of anyone who followed the rules.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Mark Moss

“they got to turn it in for $20 an ounce today it's about what seventeen seventeen fifty an ounce they turned in for $20 and sixty-seven of paper money fake paper money and then as soon as they did that the government turned around and raised the price of gold and what that did is it wiped out almost 70 percent of the savings of anyone to follow the rules so he got them to turn in their gold for fake paper money and then instantly devalued their money they lost almost 70 percent overnight”

0.68

In 1933, President Franklin D. Roosevelt closed all banks for four days and forced Americans to turn in all their gold at $20 per ounce.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Mark Moss

“back in 1933 in order to deal with all these mounting debts and to print money for the you know all these new social programs that came out President Franklin D Roosevelt he closed all the banks for four days and a forced Americans to turn in all the gold downed”

0.68

Debt jubilees have occurred many times throughout history, including in both ancient and modern times, demonstrating the practice is not merely biblical but empirically recurrent.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Mark Moss

“however we do know that it has happened many times throughout our own history and even and not even just in remote history but even in modern times”

0.68

If one does not know history, one is bound to repeat it; therefore, ordinary people should not let a debt jubilee happen to them by remaining ignorant of historical precedent.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Mark Moss

“and what do we always say if you don't know history you are bound to repeat it so don't let it happen to you”

0.64

The wealthiest 40% of the American population has experienced good asset price growth over the past decade, while the bottom 60% has experienced stagnant wages (declining since the 1970s), high consumer debt, and insufficient emergency savings.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Mark Moss

“we are living in two different Americas we've been living in two different Americas we're about the 40% of the wealthiest population life's been pretty good over the last decade asset prices have been going up life's been good but for the 60% at the bottom hasn't been so good consumer debts been sky-high wages have been stagnant been going down since the 70s most of them have no emergency funds 40% of Americans couldn't come up with $400 for emergency expense”

0.63

Elimination of the gold clause by FDR effectively stole billions of dollars from private investors, with a Harvard paper estimating that this single rule took approximately $700 million annually from private investors who had bought government bonds.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Mark Moss

“when Roosevelt outlawed the gold clause basically what he did is he stole billions of dollars from investors in fact there was a Harvard paper that estimated that this this one rule that he did took about 700 million dollars a year from private investors who had bought government bonds billions more were stolen from folks who lost money from the elimination Gold closet in private contracts bank accounts and insurance deals”

0.63

Investors sued the government over FDR's elimination of the gold clause, and the case went to the Supreme Court, where the Court ruled 5-4 in favor of Roosevelt despite his stated intention not to recognize an unfavorable ruling.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Mark Moss

“eliminating the gold clause was so controversial that investors actually sued the government and the case went all the way to the Supreme Court now Roosevelt said hey even if they rule against me I'm not gonna recognize it I think he swayed them and the court ended up ruling 5-4 in Roosevelt's favor so they didn't side with the people they sided with the government with the with the government on that one”

0.63

Following Nixon's 1971 default and dollar devaluation, the dollar lost approximately 30% of its value within a couple of years, while inflation more than doubled, and the stock market fell almost 50% in just two years.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Mark Moss

“now in the 70s at around that time over the next couple of years the dollar lost about 30 percent of its value right over those couple of years in inflation more than doubled at the same time as the dollar was losing value inflation doubled and the stock market fell almost 50 percent just in two years alone”

0.62

When the government printed money in both 1933 and currently (2020), it went to the rich, driving up asset prices while doing nothing for the poor, thus exacerbating the wealth gap.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Mark Moss

“when they printed money went to the rich and when they gave it to the rich it drove up asset prices and as you can see from these charts on the screen this caused the stock market and other risky assets to boo during both of these periods back in 33 and and obviously now and this boosted the wealth of the rich but it did nothing for the poor which is exactly why we see that gap growing bigger and bigger and bigger”

0.62

Forty years after the 1933 debt jubilee, President Richard Nixon executed another debt jubilee in 1971 by completely defaulting on the promise to pay gold for dollars held by foreign creditors.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Mark Moss

“and then 40 years later we had another debt Jubilee in America and this is in 1971 President Richard Nixon he completely defaulted on any promise to pay gold for our foreign creditors so at that time the foreign creditors were still able to redeem the fake paper money for actual gold in the 1971 he closed that window said no more we're defaulting on that we're not gonna give you gold anymore”

0.61

All four preconditions for a debt jubilee are currently present in America: the wealth gap is at its largest on record, there are rising protests and fights over immigration and race, the government is ineffective at providing solutions, and there is extreme dislike for the elites.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Mark Moss

“today we had the largest gap between rich and poor we've seen we have rising protests we have fights over immigration race we do have an ineffective government right now you know they're not even doing basically they're not even really practicing they're just you know dealing with impeachments and the virus and things like that and then of course like I said we have the extreme dislike for the elites”

0.57

In 1933, the government engaged in massive money printing, a pattern that is repeating in 2020 but at a much larger and more dramatic scale.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Mark Moss

“just like in 1933 the government went into a massive money printing mode sound familiar as you can see from the chart that's on the screen the same thing happened as it did back in 1933 but this time it's way bigger way more dramatic”

0.57

Interest rates hit zero in both the period leading up to 1933 and in the current moment (2020), a key economic parallel.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Mark Moss

“interest rates hit zero leading up to each one of these periods”

0.57

Current economic conditions (2020) eerily mirror or almost exactly match conditions from 1930-1933, the period immediately preceding the most radical debt jubilee in American history.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Mark Moss

“it proves that what we're experienced in today is eerily similar if not almost exactly what happened back in the 1930s so right right back then in the 1930s right before the biggest and and probably the most radical debt Jubilee in all of American history you can see on the chart on the screen it shows the economic comparison between 1930 and now and it's stunning when you look at it I mean it almost lines up perfectly”

0.55

For a debt jubilee to occur in America, four specific elements must be present: (1) the wealth gap must be getting dramatically bigger, (2) there must be cultural threats from those with different values or from outsiders like minority populations and immigrants, (3) the government must be ineffective at providing solutions, and (4) there must be growing anger toward the elites.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Mark Moss

“in order for this to occur we need to see four elements all right we're looking for four different elements in place I'm gonna tell them to and you can see if you think these are relevant for where we're at today so first the wealth gap must be getting dramatically bigger hmm that makes sense the division between the rich and the poor is that getting bigger or smaller the second thing that we're looking for is there must be cultural threats from those with different values or from like outsiders so in other words like a minority population and immigrants hmm sounds familiar the third thing we're looking for is that the government must be ineffective at providing solutions and I would say that with the way the virus is being handled and the debt I would say that's probably more true than ever and then forth and finally there must be a growing anger towards the elites like banning billionaires maybe things like that”

0.55

A chart showing the timing of populist politicians receiving the most votes in America and abroad reveals clear spikes that correspond to periods when debt jubilees occurred.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Mark Moss

“so you can see I put this chart up on the screen right here it's when you see this chart it's really easy to see that these big spikes show when populist politicians got the most votes in America and abroad”

0.54

A debt jubilee could be one of the only ways out of the current debt crisis, but it is uncertain whether one will actually occur.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Mark Moss

“now how is this gonna turn out are we gonna see a debt Jubilee i think it could be one of the only ways out of this we don't know”

0.53

The Federal Reserve alone has added approximately six trillion dollars to the money supply since the COVID-19 epidemic began, and central banks worldwide have collectively added trillions more.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Mark Moss

“central banks around the world are adding trillions of dollars just the Federal Reserve alone has added about six trillion dollars just since this virus epidemic happened”

0.52

Unlike biblical jubilees, American debt jubilees are not universal forgiveness but government wealth redistribution: the government steals from one group and gives to another because the government cannot produce something it has not taken.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Mark Moss

“unlike biblical Jubilees where was the people that got their debt forgiven in the American Jubilees that we that we've seen it's basically the government stealing from one group and giving it to another remember the quote I always like to say that the government cannot produce something it has not taken so the government redistributed so the government steals from one group gives to another”

0.52

American debt jubilees have historically occurred under unique, extreme political environments, not in normal times, suggesting debt jubilees require radical political conditions to be implemented.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Mark Moss

“when we see when we see American history when we see the American history and we look at the debt Jubilee we see it happens under unique extreme political environments I'm gonna explain this to you because maybe you'll see some correlation to where we're at right now so it happens in unique extreme political environments”

0.52

Populism is characterized by extreme anger at the government, the wealthy, the establishment, and newcomers; it may explain how Trump was elected.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Mark Moss

“populism would be characterized by extreme anger at the government really at the wealthy at the establishment at the newcomers hmm maybe that's how Trump got elected right things like that”

0.51

The political pendulum swings between individualism ('me' cycles) and collectivism ('we' cycles) every 40 years, completing an 80-year roundtrip, creating patterns of nationalism and populism.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Mark Moss

“basically it says that every 40 years this pendulum swings from one side to the other and it's a so it takes 80 years roundtrip and it swings from me cycle to a we cycle so me is about individual it's about me personally a Wii is about collectivism globalism and so it shifts back and forth back and forth and you might have heard terms like nationalism or populism right maybe you don't know what those mean”

0.48

The last couple of times the government implemented a debt jubilee, it made ordinary people poor by stealing money from one group and giving it to another, a pattern that is relevant to current circumstances.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Mark Moss

“you need to be careful because the last couple times that we did see the debt Jubilee as I just Illustrated for you in detail here and the last couple times the government did this it basically made the people poor right they stole it from they stole all the money from one group and gave it to another very similar to what's happening today”

0.48

Ray Dalio, one of America's richest men and former head of Bridgewater, studied political environments over the past century and concluded that populism was the last major force in the 1930s and has again emerged as a major force starting around 2017.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Mark Moss

“Ray Dalio you know I quote him all the time one of the richest men in America I ran one of the largest funds in America bridgewater and he studied all these political environments over the past hundred years and he concluded that well he wrote this back in 2017 but after studying for over all these different political environment for over a hundred years he said the last time that populism existed as a major force in the world was back in the 1930s and that's when most countries became populist and they said over the last year so this is back in 2017 that it's again started to emerge as a major force which over the last couple years we've seen that right”

0.41

In 1380, Pope Boniface VIII proclaimed the first Christian Jubilee, marking the integration of debt jubilee concepts into Christian religious practice.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Mark Moss

“in 1380 Pope Boniface the eighth proclaimed the first Christian Jubilee”

0.41

In the year 2000, the G8 countries orchestrated a major movement called 'Jubilee 2000' (with U2's Bono as spokesperson) and collectively forgave approximately one hundred million dollars of debt owed by lower-income countries.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Mark Moss

“in the year 2000 there was actually a big movement called jubilee 2000 if you remember the band u2 bono from u2 was out there he was the spokesperson and basically the g8 countries got together and decided to forgive a hundred million dollars of debt to these lower income countries”

0.41

In 1841, the United States passed the Bankruptcy Act, which wiped out the debts of over 40,000 Americans, representing one of the first major American debt jubilees.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Mark Moss

“in 1841 in the United States they put forth the bankrupt D a bankruptcy Act in the US where before that got repealed over 40,000 Americans had all their debt wiped out”

0.41

A debt jubilee originates from Hebrew law in the Old Testament, where debts were forgiven every seventh year, and on the 49th year all debts would be cancelled, land reclaimed, and slaves freed.

definitionestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Mark Moss

“a debt Jubilee basically comes from the Old Testament in the Bible it's this old old Hebrew law principle where it says that debt should be forgiven on the seventh year so every seventh year the debts would be forgiven and then on the 49th year all debts would be cancelled and any land that had been given away or sold would be reclaimed back to the original family slaves be free debt cetera”

0.41

In 1953, at the end of World War II, Germany used the London Debt Agreement to wipe off approximately 280% of their GDP in debt.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Mark Moss

“in 1953 at the end of World War two Germany had to wipe out a lot of debt they used what's called the London debt agreement and they wiped off so much debt it was about 280 percent of their GDP”

0.37

Some biblical scholars question whether the debt jubilee actually occurred as described in the Old Testament, though it remains debatable.

normativecontestednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Mark Moss

“some scholars that go back into the Bible say that maybe this never actually happened I mean it's in the Bible but maybe it never actually happened where all that was cancelled and that's debatable”

0.37

In 2015, the country of Croatia wiped off debt for over 60,000 citizens, demonstrating that debt jubilees remain a current policy tool.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Mark Moss

“in 2015 Croatia the country of Croatia wiped off debt for over 60,000 citizens”

0.37

Gold clauses appeared in federal loans, bank deposits, insurance contracts, and private agreements across the American financial system.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Mark Moss

“these gold clauses there and everything there in federal loans they're in bank deposits their insurance contracts private agreements they're all over the place”

0.37

At the time of Nixon's 1971 default, the dollar was still backed by approximately 25% gold, which Nixon immediately ended.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Mark Moss

“and as a matter of fact at that time the dollar was still backed by about 25 percent gold he ended that so right away boom overnight the government simply just wiped the state is the slate clean by defaulting on their debt just wiped it out and nobody could redeem dollars for gold any longer”

0.34

In 1792 BC, King Hammurabi of Babylon forgave all debts owed to the government by citizens, high-ranking officials, and dignitaries.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Mark Moss

“all the way back to 1792 BC before Christ we said we saw king Hammurabi of Babylon he forgave all the citizens debts that were owed to the government high-ranking officials and dignitaries so this is about 1800 years before Christ”

0.29

The 70% wealth destruction caused by FDR's gold confiscation and immediate devaluation made people unhappy, but FDR went further with additional confiscatory measures.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Mark Moss

“as you might imagine people weren't happy about that but he went even further that was only the beginning”

0.29

Unemployment rose to approximately 10% following Nixon's 1971 jubilee, adding to the economic crisis created by the default.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Mark Moss

“unemployment went sky-high was about 10 percent”

0.19

Gold was exchanged at $20 per ounce in 1933, whereas today (in the 2020 video) gold trades at approximately $1,750 per ounce, demonstrating significant currency devaluation over the 87-year period.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Mark Moss

“downed you might have heard about this I know a lot of people talk about I talk about gold on his channel a lot and he basically made it where every American had to turn in their gold and they got to turn it in for $20 an ounce today it's about what seventeen seventeen fifty an ounce”