
The Green New Deal’s Bad Science
What this covers
This is an eight-minute Manhattan Institute video in which Mark Mills and James Meigs are brought in by a host and narrator to test the claims behind the Green New Deal. The framing is a contrast between what sounds appealing and what works, illustrated with a "free apple pie" analogy. The opening point is that the proposal polls well, with 64% of Republicans and 92% of Democrats supporting it, even though the speakers regard its goal of zero fossil fuel use as unimaginable to anyone who understands how energy is produced.
The technical argument comes first. Mills holds that wind, solar and batteries have already improved about tenfold and cannot improve another tenfold without materials that physics limits rule out. Meigs stresses intermittency, which means backup power, transmission lines and storage. The narration adds material and land costs: roughly 1,000 pounds of material per battery pack, forests cleared for turbines, bird deaths, and a forecast of 100 to 1,000 times more mining. It also notes that solar supplies under 1% of U.S. energy and wind about 2% despite large subsidies, and that electric cars on a coal-and-gas grid still burn fossil fuels.
The video then turns to distribution and nuclear power. It calls green subsidies an "upside down Robin Hood" that favors owners of $100,000 electric vehicles and rooftop arrays while raising energy costs for poor households. Nuclear power is presented as the best zero-carbon option. Evidence offered includes France's 70%-plus nuclear share, Germany's turn to coal after closing plants, and Vermont's rising emissions after its reactor shut. Some of the safety arguments are contested, notably that Fukushima's deaths came from evacuation rather than radiation, that Chernobyl's toll fell far short of forecasts, and that more people have died falling from roofs while installing solar panels than in the history of U.S. nuclear power.
The Green New Deal and aggressive renewable energy targets are scientifically infeasible, economically harmful to the poor, and distract from nuclear power as the only viable large-scale zero-carbon energy source.
- Renewable energy hits physics limits and cannot improve 10x further; solar and wind require massive material extraction, fossil fuel energy input, and backup infrastructure
- Green subsidies disproportionately benefit wealthy people while raising energy costs for poor households, creating regressive redistribution
- Nuclear power has the best safety record (more deaths from solar installation than nuclear history in US), produces reliable zero-carbon baseload power, yet is being abandoned due to political fear rather than engineering reality
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Renewable energy infrastructure is inconsistent because wind doesn't always blow and sun doesn't always shine, requiring massive backup power systems, long-distance transmission lines, and energy storage batteries.
“Renewable is especially hard because it's so inconsistent. Because the wind doesn't always blow and the sun doesn't always shine. You can't just put in wind turbines and solar panels. You also have to build all this infrastructure to connect them with energy consumers possibly very far away, and you always need some kind of backup power. That means many more transmission lines, and bigger batteries to store more energy.”
Green New Deal policies disproportionately harm poor people because higher energy costs represent a larger percentage of their household budget than wealthy households.
“If the Green New Dealers win, who's hurt the most? Poor people. Having energy and food cost more means it's a higher percentage of the household budget, that's who we hurt. We're charging more for people who can't afford it”
Germany foolishly shut down nuclear plants, resulting in increased coal burning instead of reducing carbon emissions.
“Germany foolishly shut down a lot of their nuclear plants. So what did they wind up doing instead? They wound up burning more coal.”
France gets more than 70% of its electricity from nuclear power, pays some of the lowest electricity rates in Europe, and has excellent carbon emissions.
“France, on the other hand, gets more than 70% of its power from nuclear energy. They pay some of the lowest electricity rates in Europe and their emissions are excellent.”
Vermont, a liberal state known for environmental advocacy, shut down its only nuclear plant and subsequently saw carbon emissions increase.
“In Bernie Sanders' home state of Vermont, they shut down their one nuclear plant. Guess what happened? Their carbon emissions went up. So, this supposedly green state, ultra-liberal Vermont, actually went backwards.”
Wind turbines require clearing forests and kill large numbers of birds due to their land footprint and operation.
“They take enormous amounts of land. You gotta clear cut the forest. These machines kill a lot of birds.”
Policy proposals should be evaluated based on whether they actually work rather than whether they sound appealing, using the analogy that most people would support 'free apple pie' even if it were economically impossible.
“People support all kinds of things that sound good. I mean, I would support free apple pie for everyone, but whatever policies we put in place to protect the planet, your first responsibility is to make sure they work.”
The Fukushima nuclear disaster proves nuclear power is safe because no one was killed by radiation; people were killed during the evacuation due to fear of radiation causing unnecessary evacuation of elderly people from homes.
“Fukushima helps prove how safe nuclear power really is. No one was killed. People were killed during the evacuation. The fear of radiation is what killed people. They evacuated a lot of older people out of nursing homes and apartments that really didn't need to go.”
Battery mining and production require extraction of 1,000 pounds of material per battery pack and consume 100 barrels of oil's worth of energy in China, using large fossil fuel-powered machines, so green energy production itself consumes significant fossil fuels and is therefore not a net-positive energy strategy.
“You have to consume a 100 barrels of oil's worth of energy in China to make that battery pack. I have to dig up a 1,000 pounds of stuff to process it. Digging up is done with oil, by the way, big machines, so we're consuming energy to quote, save energy. It's not a good path to go.”
More people have died falling off roofs installing solar panels than in the entire history of nuclear power in the United States.
“More people have died falling off of roofs installing solar panels than in the entire history of nuclear power in the US.”
Most of America's electricity comes from coal and natural gas, so electric cars powered by this grid are effectively burning fossil fuels rather than eliminating them.
“Electric cars are great for the environment. If we just switched to electric cars we'd use less fossil fuels. How do you make electricity? Coal, and natural gas. Yeah. Fossil fuels. Yeah. Exactly. Many electric car buyers don't realize that most of America's electricity comes from coal and natural gas.”
Solar energy currently makes up less than 1% of America's energy generation, and wind just 2%, despite billions in subsidies, showing that subsidized green technology has not scaled to meaningful proportions.
“Solyndra was granted a 34.5 billion dollar subsidy. Billions in subsidies… but solar still makes up less than 1% of America's energy, and wind just 2%.”
Nuclear power is the best available energy source because it produces large quantities of power with no carbon emissions.
“But there is one energy source that produces LOTS of power, with no carbon emissions. Nuclear power. Nuclear is the best answer we have right now.”
Green New Deal subsidies disproportionately benefit wealthy people in the form of subsidies for $100,000 electric vehicles, expensive rooftop solar arrays, and wind farm investments, creating an 'upside down Robin Hood' system transferring money to the rich from the poor.
“and we give money to wealthy people in the form of subsidies to buy 100,000 dollar cars, to put expensive solar arrays on their roof, or to be investors in wind farms. So we have an upside down Robin Hood going on in our country to the tunes of 10s and 100s of billions of dollars.”
Chernobyl had an idiotically bad plant design, and actual thyroid cancer rates from Chernobyl increased but not even remotely in the range of thousands of deaths that were forecast, because radiation exposure limits are set extremely conservatively.
“The plant design was idiotically bad. Reporters said that thousands of people living near Chernobyl would die. Thousands of cancer deaths. She's wrong about that. The rates of thyroid cancer did go up, but nothing, not even remotely in the range of what was forecast. Those radiation limits are set extremely conservatively.”
Majority of Americans support the Green New Deal idea (64% of Republicans and 92% of Democrats), despite the policy being technically infeasible and economically harmful.
“Polls show majority of Americans support the idea. People support all kinds of things that sound good. I mean, I would support free apple pie for everyone, but that includes 64 percent of Republicans and 92 percent of Democrats.”
Green New Deal policies, even if scientifically possible, would hurt poor people, cost everyone more money, and make energy less reliable, yet remain popular because people support policies that sound good without evaluating whether they actually work.
“So the Green New Deal, even if it were scientifically possible, would hurt the poor, cost everyone more, and make energy less reliable, Yet it's popular. Majority of Americans support the idea.”
The Green New Deal goal of zero carbon emissions with no fossil fuels is only imaginable by someone with no understanding of how the energy economy works or how energy is produced in the country.
“That is the goal. That's a goal, you could only imagine possible if you have no idea how the energy economy works or how energy is produced in this country.”
Renewable energy technologies have hit physics limits; wind, solar, and batteries are now 10 times better than they were historically, but cannot achieve another 10-fold improvement without believing in magical materials that physics makes impossible.
“Wind and solar and batteries now are 10 times better than they were. And then they stopped getting better because they hit physics limits. You have to believe in kind of magical materials to get 10 times better again. In comic books we have that I can fly Tony Stark has that magic power source. Can do things that are unimaginable today, but we know that the physics make it impossible to make solar 10 times better again.”
The belief that renewable energy sources can be adopted without environmental cost, land use, material consumption, or hydrocarbon use is magical thinking; every energy source requires land, materials, and hydrocarbons at some point in production.
“There's a magical thinking that there's somehow a free lunch. If I pick this energy source, it doesn't do anything, it doesn't emit anything, it doesn't consume anything. This isn't comic book land. Every energy source, of energy, every kind, uses land, uses materials to make the technology and always uses hydrocarbon along the way.”
Countries are shutting down nuclear plants in response to accidents despite evidence that nuclear safety is demonstrated by how well the industry responds to accidents.
“Nuclear plants, their safety ironically is actually evident in their accidents. More people have died falling off of roofs installing solar panels than in the entire history of nuclear power in the US. And yet, from these accidents, countries all over the world are shutting down nuclear plants.”
The energy used to manufacture existing wind turbines globally has consumed billions of tons of hydrocarbons, and we have only begun manufacturing at the scale that renewable advocates claim is necessary.
“We use billions of tons of hydrocarbons to make the number of windmills that are already in the world and we've only just begun to make them at the level people claim they would like to have them to be built.”
Pursuing a path of wind, solar, and batteries as primary energy sources would increase mining and material movement by 100 to 1,000 fold compared to current levels.
“If you pursue a path of wind, solar, and batteries, we increase how much we dig up and move by 100 to a 1,000 fold.”
People who believe they are helping the environment by buying a Prius are actually just burning coal and natural gas from shale fields indirectly through the grid.
“People think they're doing something wonderful buying a Prius. They're basically burning coal and natural gas from the shale fields.”
People are vulnerable to fear about nuclear power despite not being inherently stupid, suggesting that fear-based reasoning rather than technical understanding drives nuclear policy.
“All this talk about nuclear catastrophe reveals that people don't really understand how these plants work. They're not bombs. People aren't stupid, but they are vulnerable to fear.”
Electric cars will improve somewhat (cheaper, better performance) but the improvement rate is insufficient; they can never achieve a 10-fold improvement, so incremental progress is not adequate to the scale of the decarbonization goal.
“Sure they will. I'll make the windmills a little better and they'll get cheaper. Solar arrays will get cheaper. The problem isn't that they'll get a little better, a little better is not enough. They can never get 10 times better.”
Green New Deal policies that mandate 100% renewable energy in 10 years, while well-intentioned, would impoverish humanity by spending money today to solve a future problem that may not materialize, which is immoral.
“We have to get to a 100% renewable energy in 10 years. They want to impoverish all of humanity today to solve a putative problem in the future. I think that's immoral.”
Modern nuclear plants have been operational since the 1960s and work well and are safe.
“These plants have been around since the 1960s. They work well, they're safe.”
Germany announced it would phase out nuclear energy within a decade, demonstrating that political fear overrides rational energy policy.
“Germany says it will give up nuclear energy within a decade.”