What this covers

This is a roughly two-and-a-half-hour panel in which Sam Harris talks with four Atlantic writers: Ann Applebaum, David Frum, Barton Gelman, and George Packer. It moves from a reconstruction of what happened after the 2020 election to a forward-looking question about how the next one could be taken. Gelman describes the schemes in detail, including proposals to have federal agencies or the National Guard seize voting machines in at least six states, and he treats January 6 as an attempt at the final, irrevocable moment of deciding the outcome. Packer adds that the officials who resisted, Brad Raffensperger among them, are now targets for replacement by loyalists.

The range is wide. Applebaum places the American case alongside Venezuela, Russia, and Hungary, where democracies erode through elected officials rather than tanks, and she describes the flood of conflicting false narratives that produces Epistemological Collapse. She also argues that engagement-optimized social media is neither publisher nor utility. Frum emphasizes that American government rests on unwritten norms, that most of what Donald Trump did was not criminal, and that democracy works more like a dimmer switch than a light switch. Gelman presses for reform of the Electoral Count Act, whose 1870s drafting leaves the vice president's role unclear, and argues that bipartisan support is plausible.

Several turns are contentious. Gelman defends the view that Russiagate was not a hoax and points to the Robert Mueller report's obstruction findings. Frum describes an asymmetry in which one side issues corrections and the other never does. Packer traces the Republican base's hostility to institutions from the Tea Party onward, and argues that power has become an end in itself for the party, citing McConnell's use of the filibuster. Frum also questions whether more education stabilizes democracy, and the panel closes on what Biden needs to do before 2024.

Sharpest takeaway

American democracy faces an existential threat from a coordinated effort by Trump and Republican allies to systematically undermine electoral integrity through election subversion rather than policy disagreement, enabled by a propaganda strategy that floods the zone with lies to create cynicism and a loss of shared truth.

  • Trump attempted multiple coordinated schemes to overturn the 2020 election including pressuring state officials, seizing voting machines, and inciting violence on January 6, all carefully planned rather than spontaneous.
  • Republicans are systematically replacing election officials and changing laws to install loyalists who will subvert future elections, creating machinery for undetected election theft independent of voter will.
  • Authoritarian propaganda tactics deliberately create epistemological collapse—multiple conflicting false narratives flood the information space so people abandon belief in knowable truth itself, mirroring tactics used by Putin in Russia and Chavez in Venezuela.

The claims · ranked49 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.84

Authoritarian regimes use a propaganda tactic of flooding the information space with multiple conflicting false narratives to create epistemological collapse where people abandon belief that truth can be known.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Ann Applebaum

“if you tell one lie once in a while you know then people can argue about it it can be proved or disproved if you tell hundreds of lies if you tell them over and over again different lies from different directions every day what you create is cynicism and nihilism and confusion and belief that no truth can ever be known”

0.80

Trump understood that democracy is not like a light switch that is on or off but a dimmer switch constantly adjusted, and history shows American democracy was less inclusive in the 1940s when South Carolina had only 50,000 voters and no secret ballot until the 1950s; Trump was proposing to simply dial back participation by 11,000 votes without overturning democracy entirely.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· David Frum

“democracy is not like a light switch that is on or off it's a dimmer switch that is constantly being adjusted and the history of american democracy is as the democracy has got it wasn't that the united states was ever an authoritarian country it was just a country where the circle of participation was narrowed in very often very brutal ways backed by violence i think in in the 1940s in the state of california sorry in the state of south carolina only about 50 000 people voted south carolina didn't get a secret ballot until the 1950s...trump wasn't talking about overturning all of that system just dialing it back by 11 000 votes”

0.80

American democracy historically survived because presidents accepted election losses despite ambiguities in the Electoral Count Act (1870s) and the vulnerability of certification procedures; Lincoln Nixon (1960), Ford (1976), Bush (1992), and 2000 Bush-Gore all occurred under similar institutional vulnerabilities but were accepted because of elite commitment to democratic norms.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Barton Gelman

“it was a mess in 1960 when there was a republican president and richard nixon the vice republican vice president lost to john f kennedy and stepped aside it was a mess in 1976 when gerald ford accepted his very very close defeat at the hands of jimmy carter was a mess in 1992 when george h.w bush stepped aside and it was a mess in the year 2000 when very bitter democrats accepted the bushwick or outcome it's not because of the laws that americans accept elections”

0.79

Trump and his allies are now systematically targeting the state and county officials who resisted their 2020 attempts to overturn the election, working to replace them with loyalists who will execute the subversion next time.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“and now what we see happening bart again has written about this in in his most recent piece is again a concerted attempt by trump and his allies to target those offices that most people have never even heard of and fill them with loyalists who next time around can be counted on to um to do the corrupt thing that others were unwilling to do in georgia uh and in michigan and in arizona um and in pennsylvania last time”

0.79

Trump solicited proposals to have the Justice Department, Department of Homeland Security, or National Guard seize voting machines in at least six states and re-run the election under 'national security establishment procedures', representing a classic dictator move.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Barton Gelman

“we're learning more even in recent days since i wrote my piece about the extent to which trump was trying to get people who had theoretically the power to do things to do those things that would have overturned the election most recently we're learning more about proposals that were discussed with trump and that he solicited further information about that would have seized the voting machines i mean an absolute sort of classic dictator move in which he was going to have in various iterations either the justice department or the department of homeland security or the national guard go around the country and seize voting machines in at least six states and quote unquote re-run the election under sort of national security establishment procedures”

0.78

Democracies in the modern era do not typically fall through visible coups with tanks in the street but through gradual erosion as elected officials who are unscrupulous take advantage of the political system to change the constitution, ignore rule of law, and illegally remain in power, as seen in Venezuela, Russia, and Hungary.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Ann Applebaum

“if you look around the world and you look at the way in which democracies fall in the modern era you know we all have this idea that they're going to be tanks in the street and there's a lieutenant colonel in the presidential palace and he shoots a gun in the air and you know that's how that's how the coup d'etat happens when we think of coup d'etat we have this kind of 1960s 1970s vision of it in fact most democracies fail and i mean venezuela i mean russia i mean hungary it's happening in other places now as well because elected officials who are unscrupulous take advantage of the current political system they change the constitution they ignore the rule of law they ignore the sense of the law and they seek to remain in power illegally or immorally one way or the other”

0.78

When a political party that lost elections believes the other side cheated, more of that party comes to believe they won't trust future election results from their opponents, and more are willing to use political violence, creating a vicious cycle of escalating anti-democratic behavior from both sides.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· George Packer

“there's also more willingness to use political violence across partisan lines than there have been in in recent years so those are tendencies that are in the minds of people and that have a way of intensifying and ample and and sort of driving each other to extremes and that's something that worries me a lot because it's it's just very hard to slow it down once the acceleration toward the extremes and towards the liberalism of all kinds uh starts”

0.78

The Electoral Count Act from the 1870s is confusing and poorly written, leaving unclear whether the vice president has power to discard electoral votes; fixing it to explicitly state the vice president doesn't get to do the counting should be a major focus with potential bipartisan support.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Barton Gelman

“one part of the answer is to fix the electoral count act uh which is what interprets and gives direction to the invocation of the 12th amendment for how how the electoral count is supposed to go this was passed in the uh 1870s and is one of the most confusing and laws ever passed by congress i defy anyone to read these 300 word sentences and make any sense out of them there's some possibility of consensus between republicans democrats on fixing the electoral count act because republicans are sitting around thinking they don't really want vice president harris to have the powers that trump thought pence had”

0.74

Democracy relies on integrity of individuals within institutions because we cannot write laws that prevent a corrupt person in a position of institutional power from abusing it; most of American government rests on people not doing things just because they didn't do those things, not because it's illegal.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Sam Harris

“democracy can only exist when the populace is educated well there's one thing i would add i don't want us to go down this rabbit hole but and i've gone down it many times on the podcast but it's the degree to which our institutions still rely on the integrity of individuals right you can't take the monkey out of the apparatus here and if just a few people had decided they were trumpists to the core things could have happened very differently”

0.74

January 6 was not just a violent mob taking selfies but a coordinated attempt to overturn the election through violence, at the direct instigation and beck and call of President Trump, representing an attempt at the final irrevocable moment of deciding the election.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Barton Gelman

“january 6 was an attempt by a violent mob to stop the congressional account of the electoral vote the final stage the final sort of irrevocable moment in deciding the election and it was done at the at the beck and call and instigation of the president i mean it it it couldn't be more serious”

0.74

Democracy's power has historically come from its ability to deliver material results for ordinary people—blue jeans, bananas, fun music—making the difference between democracy and authoritarianism palpable; authoritarian undermining blurs this difference by making things stop delivering.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· David Frum

“one of the reasons the democracy was so powerful an idea from the gi bill until name your date was that it really delivered results for ordinary people you didn't have to have a theory about communism versus free markets you didn't have to theory about democrat totalitarianism versus democracy to see we had blue jeans and bananas and fun music and they didn't obviously it was better here we were doing something right and so a lot of the power of democracy comes from its ability to deliver...one of the things that you do when you're trying to undermine democracy is you blur that difference you make things stop delivering”

0.74

Democracy is fundamentally a system based on the equal dignity and sovereignty of the people, and while specific democratic forms may change, the principle of consent as the source of government power cannot be dispensed with without creating worse alternatives.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Ann Applebaum

“the thing that you can't dispense with is the sovereignty of the people as as the source of ultimate power of government as somebody who spends a lot of time studying and writing about autocracies i promise you that there is no alternative system out there that is better”

0.73

The Republican base became increasingly populist and hostile to mainstream institutions (media, schools, universities, CIA, FBI, military) starting with the Tea Party period and accelerating with Obama's election, creating the conditions for Trump's anti-institutional politics.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“the base of the republican party has been increasingly populist increasingly hostile to the mainstream institutions of the country whether it's the media or schools and universities or the cia the fbi even the military it didn't hurt trump to trash uh the national security institutions and the national security heroes gorgia john mccain i mean exactly because the base of the party had stopped revering those institutions and had begun to think of them as elitist uh self-serving indifferent to the the lives and the the problems of the mass of people so the base of the party and the tea party period was a key moment in this because that's when the kind of nihilistic attitudes of republican voters really set in”

0.73

When one side makes many mistakes or receives corrections (like the New York Times needing to run corrections or the Steele Dossier being discredited) but the other side never acknowledges mistakes, asymmetric scoring ensues where the volume of lies from the side that never corrects overwhelms any damage from corrections on the side that cares about accuracy.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Frum

“since trump doesn't ever acknowledge a mistake there isn't ever a sort of commonly adjudicated lie or misstatement um on the trump side then the score is you know some new york times has had 10 errors and trump has had none and the volume of lies that george is talking about does not just produce the nihilism that ann was describing it also produces a view among those who are disposed to believe trump that with all their evidence all this evidence some of it must be true”

0.73

American government has historically operated through unwritten norms and unspoken understandings about what leaders won't do to each other, with these norms beginning to be violated intensely only recently, turning what were once safe implicit rules into explicit weapons in political warfare.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Frum

“we're into a world in the 2020s where a lot of things were just things that were not done things that were understood things that parties the parties didn't do what he do to each other are now being done and we're taking a again what was it once a very intense game but that wasn't played with working weapons and we're playing that same intense game but now with weapons that can kill”

0.73

Modern politics is increasingly about identity and self-realization rather than material things, which is harder to compromise on because identities are intrinsic rather than negotiable policy matters.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· David Frum

“when i was a a young man...an expat...he said what i like about democracy is not voting because he was someone who was interested in jazz in literature in his very complicated personal life and he knew that however the election would come out all of that would be fine...a lot of the power of democracy comes from its ability to deliver...so a lot of the power of democracy comes from its ability to deliver one of the things that you do when you're trying to undermine democracy is you blur that difference you make things stop delivering...one of my rules for sanity on the internet is if you hadn't heard of the person before they said this thing don't let it bother you...but we have we have a politics now that is about self-realization and that's in a country that is so diverse and getting more diverse all the time and not just in the census categories but as people become richer more prosperous they become more different one from another as they realize who they are”

0.73

Most of the terrible things Trump did were not criminal, and most of the criminal things he did were technical violations; the real threat Trump posed was non-criminal but deeply corrupt and norm-violating behavior that relied on people choosing not to do things rather than laws preventing them.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· David Frum

“this question of what's in the mueller report what's in the steel dossier if you watch the cable news conversation you think that the you would think that the important question is what crimes did donald trump commit and a drama i've been banging since 2017 is we're going to find with trump that most of the terrible things he did were not criminal and most of the criminal things he did what's so bad i mean if somebody trips over some technical statute or failed to file their individual personal income taxes properly that's that's obviously they shouldn't do that but that's not the end of the world but most of the american government rested on people not doing things just because you didn't do those things it turns out it's not illegal for the president to operate a business that solicits money from people who want things in the united states government a lot of that isn't illegal just presidents just didn't used to do that because it was wrong”

0.69

The reason Trump didn't succeed in overturning the 2020 election was partly because of the civic virtue of certain state officials including Brad Raffensperger in Georgia and others who refused to overturn election results or deadlock on certifications.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“he tried very hard he didn't succeed partly because of the what you might call the civic virtue of some of those state officials and secretaries of state and legislators and county officials”

0.69

Russiagate was not a hoax; there were extensive Russian efforts to help Trump win the election, Trump and his people solicited and welcomed these efforts, and the Mueller report showed a clear roadmap to successful prosecution for obstruction of justice with at least three occasions meeting all elements of the crime.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Barton Gelman

“russiagate was not a hoax there were extensive efforts by the russians to help trump win the election trump and his people solicited those and welcomed them and it did not rise to the level of of conspiracy but the mueller report showed very clearly a roadmap to a successful prosecution for obstruction of justice it named multiple occasions on which trump could be said to have obstructed justice and at least three of them uh met all the elements of the crime”

0.69

Trump operated a building with his name on it at which people would put money on the counter for meetings with him, and he explicitly told the New York Times, National Review, and everyone that you don't get a meeting with the president unless you've given him money first—operating a system of openly acknowledged bribery in plain sight.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Frum

“the idea that you say okay my idea for taking bribes is i'm going to go to acquire a building on pennsylvania avenue and put my name on it and put a red carpet down to the street and cars will come up and people will come out and they will put money on the counter for me the president and i will tell everybody i will tell literally everybody i will tell the new york times i will tell national review i'll tell everybody that you don't get a meeting with me unless you've given me the money first at my building on pennsylvania avenue right who will say well i i guess he seems to have a clear conscience it can't be so bad”

0.69

Republicans have gradually transformed from a party with ideological goals to a party where power itself became the end, as illustrated by Mitch McConnell's use of the filibuster to prevent Democrats from accomplishing anything when they held power.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“at the top of the party you had a kind of uh corruption that set in not just financial but the corruption of power power at any cost power for its own sake power without a real higher purpose and conservatism which had a set of goals political goals ideological goals sort of faded out it lost its color and power itself became the end of the party and mitch mcconnell became the perfect embodiment of that he was the one who brought the filibuster to the floor of the senate as the tool for preventing the other party from doing anything when they add power”

0.69

After Trump lost to Biden, Trump retained power not through instruments of office (which he lacked as a former president) but as a demagogue with direct control of Republican base sentiment, which is why Republican elites couldn't simply move past him.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Barton Gelman

“because as david just said trump's power was not primarily expressed through the instruments of office because he didn't have a policy program his power was as a demagogue and a politician and as someone who had this tremendous control of the sentiments of a large base republicans might have thought and hoped he would go away and might have thought and hoped he would stop talking about the election”

0.69

Civic education in America has nearly disappeared from schools during the same decades that Americans have become increasingly polarized and live in separate informational universes, correlating with the loss of shared civic knowledge.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“civic education has all but disappeared from a lot of american children's schooling in the decades in which we have moved into these incredibly polarized camps that don't seem to live in the same universe any longer”

0.69

To prevent daily corruption, Trump had to continually tinker with the structure of law, meaning the accumulation of corruption was not a series of isolated incidents but required constant institutional modification to enable ongoing theft from the taxpayer.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Frum

“the accumulation of corruption had the effect because these things are often technically illegal or certainly inappropriate or certainly frowned upon you have to every day the president had to tinker with the structure of law in order to cope with the thing that he was fundamentally about which was stealing from the taxpayer”

0.69

Republican office holders who want to keep their seats understand they must support Trump's lies because otherwise they face primary threats from Trump-endorsed candidates, money against them, and Trump's public ridicule, so a handful of figures like Liz Cheney are cast out while most capitulate.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“the reason why there's you can count them on one hand is because the rest of the republican office holders want to keep their seats and they understand that to keep their seats they have to go along with the lies because otherwise they're going to face a primary threat and they're going to face a lot of money coming at them and they're going to face trump's ridicule and and hostility and that is going to be the end of their career”

0.69

The Steele dossier was largely irrelevant to the Mueller investigation and not the basis for its findings, but its sensational details became the focus because people remember sensation at the expense of reality, allowing Trump supporters to dismiss all Russian interference evidence based on Steele's discrediting.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ann Applebaum

“the steele dossier was in in almost entirely irrelevant to the mueller investigation it had nothing it was not the reason why the fbi investigated trump in the first place it was a sideshow you know if you read the mueller report none of it is based on the steele dossier it all comes from different places...the steele dossier had one advantage which is that it had a few little sensational anecdotes tucked into it...it seemed to it had an element of sensation that the real material didn't have but this i think is another thing that trump and the people around him have understood which is that people will focus on the sensation at the expense of the reality”

0.69

Biden must win the 2024 election and protect himself against impeachment by a Republican House; his success will require perception of success and focusing the country on other challenges like potential war in Europe, climate, and competition from China.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Frum

“in 20 to 2024 biden has to win and protect himself against the risk of being impeached by a republican house and that's going to take all the things i talked about that's going to that's going to take success the perception of success and that's going to take focusing the country on other kinds of challenges of which there aren't a few and one of the things that is haunting all of us is that we may be about to confront in the very near future a major war on the european continent”

0.69

Historically accurate civics materials to promote civic education already exist from well-meaning organizations and textbook writers who have thought about left-right differences, suggesting the barrier isn't lack of materials but lack of institutional implementation or teacher time.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ann Applebaum

“at that time all kinds of worthy organizations that promote civics education and people writing civics textbooks that have thought a lot about left-right you know differences and a lot of this exists it's out there i mean if teachers wanted to use it it's available and so i have some cynicism about the possibility of incorporating that because it's not as if it's you know it would be very hard for people to to do more of it if they wanted to”

0.69

Social media platforms like Twitter and Facebook function as neither pure publishers nor public utilities; they publish speech but according to algorithms optimized for engagement rather than truth, amplifying emotional, divisive, and false content over constructive conversation.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ann Applebaum

“the problem with twitter and the problem with facebook is that it's actually neither a publisher nor the phone company...it doesn't just give you the right to speech it publicizes your speech and and the same is true of facebook and it publish sizes it according to a set of rules that are semi-secret...what spreads on facebook...it's facebook has defined this as things that keep people on facebook that's actually facebook's goal is to keep you on the platform as long as possible and it is essentially the metric that decides what spreads and what doesn't then it turns out that what spreads are things that are very emotional things that are divisive sometimes things that are surprising and shocking and the things that are surprising and shocking are often false stories”

0.69

Despite claims that education is key to democracy, the 2022 American electorate is far better educated than in more stable democratic periods like 1962 or 1972, suggesting more education alone doesn't guarantee stability and may interact with other factors.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Frum

“can i challenge a little bit the premise of the question...the american electorate of 2022 is far and away the best educated american electorate ever much more educated than the american electorate of stabler times like 1972 or 1962. if more education were the path to stability we should we should have the stability of a barca lounger right now”

0.69

Proportional representation and independent redistricting commissions could potentially reduce polarization and democratic threats by reducing the threat of primary challenges and changing the incentive structure, though these are uncertain improvements.

forecasthigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“it's certainly true historically and internationally that countries that have proportional representation representation have a you know there's a wider variety of parties and there's also greater pressure to achieve compromises um and if you if you look i've seen political science studies that show that show depending on the system because there are different systems that show better outcomes for pr countries”

0.68

Trump refused to commit to a peaceful transfer of power when explicitly asked on multiple television occasions to do so, which alone should have signaled we were in uncharted territory and facing an explicit threat to democracy.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Sam Harris

“i'm amazed by a phenomenon that david you've pointed out a lot really every time you've you've spoken about trump which is that some of the most egregious things he ever does he does in plain view i mean there's there is no debate about the fact for instance that he would not commit to a peaceful transfer of power i mean that that alone that one detail which is attested to by you know endless evidence he was given multiple chances to do this on television and he declined”

0.68

Democracy's future depends not on which candidate wins in 2024 but on the individual choices and engagement of citizens who must believe in democracy and understand that its future is in their hands rather than inevitable.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Barton Gelman

“the future is always open it's always been open the possibility that american democracy would collapse was always there and the possibility that it will never collapse is also always there and people should remember that and one of the reasons why democracy will succeed or fail is to do with how engaged citizens are in it”

0.66

Mike Pence had military power at his disposal and theoretically could have misused it based on Trump's legal theories about presidential power; if Pence had thrown away votes and sent the election to the House, there would have been a constitutional crisis with no clear remedy and potentially military involvement.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Barton Gelman

“if this this would have been a crisis precisely because we don't know how it could have been resolved and there was a sitting president who would have been the beneficiary of this gigantic electoral theft who theoretically had the power of to control uh federal law enforcement and military resources and if as one could expect this led to serious civic unrest could have invoked the insurrection act and given direct orders to the military”

0.66

Period after World War II shows how democracies can restabilize after periods of extremism and political violence, through material prosperity, broadening participation (including women's suffrage in countries where communists were strong), and most importantly elite agreement on things that elites won't do to one another.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· David Frum

“you can point to things and i don't know that i have like a one but material prosperity that sure helps broadening participation helps and one of the things that the united states and his friends did to defeat the communists in western europe was to ensure that there was women's suffrage and in france and italy where the two places were the communists were strongest the communists appealed strongly to men didn't appeal to women women got the vote commune suddenly became a very small party compared to what they had been when women didn't have the vote but what really really helps is elite agreement that there are things that elites won't do to one another”

0.63

In 2015-2016, Trump's Republican opponents initially welcomed his candidacy thinking he would eliminate Jeb Bush and clear the field for them, allowing Trump to rise unopposed rather than party elites uniting against him early as a dangerous threat.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· David Frum

“donald trump materializes in the summer of and a lot of people who are the second tier candidates say obviously this is nowhere this joke trump candidacy but he might take out jeb bush and clear the field for me and so uh there was this game where trump was simultaneously so useful to a number of people that they stood out of his way hoping that he would wreck jeb bush and jeb bush in turn hoped that he would trump would knock aside everybody else everybody was hoping to be left alone in the room with donald trump on the assumption that they would be in and so there was never that moment where people said this is dangerous this is that this is threatening this is destructive let's all unite together against them”

0.63

Vice President Pence was invited to stay at a Trump golf course on the far side of Ireland during an official visit to Dublin, requiring a million-dollar taxpayer expense for military transportation to his actual meetings, putting thousands of dollars into Trump's personal pocket through one day of official activity.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· David Frum

“vice president pence made a visit to ireland...he had meetings at in in dublin with the dublin government he's opted to stay at the trump golf course on the other side of the island dublin faces toward england he stayed up toward the atlantic and in order to go to his meetings he had to take military transportation from the atlantic ocean to the uh to the english side of ireland uh in order to have his meetings at a cost the taxpayer of something like a million dollars uh all of this in order that the united states could put a few thousand dollars into donald trump's personal pocket”

0.62

Trump was not a truly productive president relative to post-FDR standard; he had no major policy agenda, was relatively conventional as a Republican on actual policy, and his threat to democracy came from norm-breaking and stolen goods rather than from any new policy vision.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Frum

“the least productive president of the post franklin delano roosevelt era i mean he didn't do much there was nothing much other than the stealing there wasn't much that he he wanted to do and so the idea of him is some big threat to the way washington does its proper policy business that he became a very very conventional republican president where he was unconventional is what is he did things that nobody not republicans not democrats nobody would want a president to do”

0.61

Georgia Republicans passed a law removing Brad Raffensperger from his voting seat on the state board of elections so that even if he wins re-election as secretary of state, he will not be the one to certify election results.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Barton Gelman

“the republicans in the state legislature have passed a new law that just in case raffensberger wins again they have removed him from his voting seat on the state board of elections so if the election were held again today in national election he would not be the one to certify it they have simply defanged him”

0.61

By November 2020 a significant portion of Republicans had stopped believing in the importance of fair elections, majority rule, and norms of transfer of power, making it easy to kick those values aside when convenient.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“by november of 2020 a lot of those republicans really had stopped believing in the importance of things like fair elections and majority rule and um the norms of the transfer of power they just though those things no longer held any strong value for them so it was not all that difficult to kick them aside when it became convenient to do so”

0.61

What Trump did in Georgia—repeatedly lying about voter fraud, attacking the validity of the vote through multiple theories (Arizona voting machines, Georgia cheating, dead voters, Chinese intervention in machines)—was part of a deliberate tactic to pressure state officials into changing election rules and get people to believe the election was rigged.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ann Applebaum

“the method by which trump after the 2020 election the method by which he started to attack the validity of the vote if you remember it wasn't just one form of you know the vote is rigged it was voter machines not working in arizona it was people cheating in georgia it was you know dead people voting somewhere else there was a theory about the chinese having intervened in the machines there was a theory about the venezuelans having something to do with the machines...but it had another effect which i believe was also deliberate um which was to do what steve bannon once described as flooding the zone with [ __ ]”

0.61

A traditional article of faith in First Amendment doctrine is Louis Brandeis's counter-speech doctrine: that evil speech is cured by more speech in the free market of ideas, but this has been proven false in the Trump era where 35,000 lies overwhelm corrections.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Barton Gelman

“one of the reasons we're having a hard time thinking about this is because a long time article of faith in first amendment doctrine or free expression philosophy is is under challenge here...louis brandeis...wrote the famous counter speech doctrine in 1927 saying that the cure for evil speech or wrong speech is more speech that the free market of ideas uh necessarily will respond and correct itself and as we discussed earlier that just hasn't been true in this trumpian age when you have as as george said you have a president who who lied 35 000 times and who floods the zone”

0.55

The independent state legislature doctrine, promoted by Trump Republicans, claims Article II of the Constitution gives state legislatures absolute authority to choose electors for president, potentially allowing them to discard state votes and substitute electors for Trump.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Barton Gelman

“trump republicans are promoting a theory called independent state legislature and it comes from the fact that article two of the constitution says that each state shall choose electors for president according to the preferences of its state legislature that the state legislature is the ultimate authority about how you choose electors and so what we saw in the last election was an attempt by trump and his people to persuade republican state legislators...to discard the votes of the people of that state and to substitute electors for trump on their own authority because article 2 of the constitution says in this extremely muscular and implausible reading of the constitution”

0.55

The January 6 Committee has learned through document and testimony that people around Trump including Sean Hannity tried to persuade him to stop talking about the election and fade away quietly rather than continue fighting, but Trump didn't understand or couldn't control his need to keep talking about it.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Barton Gelman

“we've seen from the work of the january 6 committee fascinating little artifacts of that have come out in which in which people around trump in on the government side and and among his outside advisors like sean hannity are trying to persuade him to stop talking about the election let's let's fade away quietly and and build your posterity uh based on the fabulous record that you created as president but they don't understand that it's a core thing to him that he's not going to stop talking about it”

0.51

Illiberalism on the left is concentrated in culture—schools, universities, media, philanthropy, and arts—while illiberalism on the right is concentrated in politics and a political party, making the right's threat to democracy more direct than the left's.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“the liberalism of the left is mostly in culture right now it's mostly in institutions like schools and universities and the media and philanthropy and the arts the illiberalism of the right is mostly in politics it's mostly concentrated in a political party and so it is a much more direct threat to democracy”

0.48

Democratic focus on voting access legislation has failed to move opinion and distract from the real threat of election subversion, where specific state officials and election boards are changed to ensure they will corrupt the count if Republicans lose.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· George Packer

“i wish both parties but especially the democratic party were focusing on that and really holding the republicans feet to the fire and say do you not see a problem with laws state laws state politicians and a confused national law the electoral candidate that makes it likely that the will of the majority is going to be overthrown because that's a harder thing for a republican to to defend”

0.48

Democratic Party and those who care about democracy need to find better ways to talk about it not as an abstract concept but in terms of what people will lose—their right to choose their governing, something fundamental to American identity.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ann Applebaum

“the democrats and those members of the republican party who want america to remain a democracy need to find better ways to talk about it even the title of this event you know the future of democracy once you talk about democracy as an abstract thing you know...what is is there a better way and one of the ways is if politicians talk about what it is that we could lose as a nation you know you you could lose your right to choose who your governing is you know but also you could lose something fundamental about the american identity you know we are americans what brings us together it's the fact that we you know that we are able to to come together to make these decisions”

0.48

Media and entertainment could do more to address polarization and its effect on personal relationships through content like Netflix series about how propaganda affects ordinary Americans, but this may face similar barriers to civic education.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ann Applebaum

“i wonder why people don't think more broadly about education you know whether they're are not online campaigns or whether they're not civic education for adults you know ways of reaching people whether there aren't ways of reaching people through the media or through entertainment you know i'm a little disappointed in the american entertainment industry that it hasn't thought harder for example about doing a netflix series about the effect of propaganda on ordinary americans and how they stop speaking to one another you know are there no you know is there no there's no hollywood drama that expresses the anxiety of the last four years”

0.23

Donald Trump does not have a stable identity or authentic convictions; his behavior is comprehensively driven by narcissism and his desire to avoid the identity of 'loser', making him unpredictable and willing to pursue any strategy that avoids losing.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Sam Harris

“trump is a loser the one thing you know trump can't stand to be uh and derides everyone else on earth for uh he now is”