YouTube46m· Sep 2024· cataloged

U.S. Can ‘No Longer Afford Debt’, Only One Way To Avoid Biggest Default In History | Luke Gromen


What this covers

This is a 47-minute interview in which David Lin talks with Luke Gromen, founder of Forest For The Trees, recorded in mid-September 2024 during the presidential campaign. Gromen's argument runs from fiscal arithmetic to portfolio consequences. He starts with true interest expense, meaning entitlements plus net interest, which he says hit 150% of federal receipts in August 2024. From there he argues that austerity is off the table because a spending cut of around 5% of GDP would trigger a recession and widen the deficit. He also holds that the Fed's rate cuts are driven by financing needs, not by economic data, and that the stock market now carries the fiscal system through capital gains and IRA distributions. He cites 2022-2023, when falling stocks coincided with the deficit going from $1 trillion to $2 trillion.

The middle of the conversation applies this to the election. Gromen goes through Harris's $25,000 homebuyer subsidy and her grocery anti-price gouging proposal, which he calls inflationary or political theater, with a nod to price controls creating shortages. He weighs this against Trump's oil drilling plan, which he favors, and criticizes Trump's 100% tariff threat against countries that leave the dollar as self-defeating for the bond market. His claim that markets will not depend much on who wins is among the more contested ones.

The final stretch is about assets. He calls gold the most mispriced asset, pointing to central bank buying since the seizure of Russia's reserves and to BRICS settlement. He expects $3,000 gold, says Bitcoin is also well positioned, and prefers US industrials tied to grid buildout. He is bearish on long-dated Treasuries and gilts, and expects a stock market that rises in dollars but falls against gold. The talk closes on national security and recession signals.

Sharpest takeaway

The US dollar-centric global monetary system is breaking down due to unsustainable fiscal dynamics: true interest expense now exceeds tax receipts, forcing the Federal Reserve to maintain negative real interest rates indefinitely to prevent fiscal collapse, which will inevitably drive inflation and devalue the dollar regardless of which political party governs.

  • US true interest expense (entitlements + net interest) reached 150% of government receipts in August 2024, making austerity mathematically impossible without triggering recession
  • The Fed will prioritize keeping rates low to finance deficits over price stability because allowing rates to rise would expose the government's structural insolvency
  • Global central banks have shifted from accumulating treasuries to accumulating gold, signaling loss of confidence in dollar-denominated reserve assets

The claims · ranked31 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.69

The repo rate spike at the end of 2019 was the first time the Treasury market significantly dysfunctioned, and the Fed responded within 48 hours by growing its balance sheet, after which the dollar weakened through June 2021.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“we had covid and the FED came in and did sort of whatever it takes to maintain treasury market functioning uh really that started at the end of 2019 with uh the repo rate Spike that was the first time the treasury market really dysfunctioned it was at the front end the FED came in in 48 hours they grew their balance sheet they said it wasn't QE blah blah blah Market said I don't care it acted like it was QE dollar went down uh you saw the FED start to try to normalize that in early 2020 we had covid again fed came in did whatever it took after March 2020 treasury market uh dysfunction at the lows uh in in March of 2020 related to co they grew their balance sheet in enormously the dollar weekend through call it June of 2021”

0.68

The reserve currency issuer of the world cannot afford their debt unless real rates are negative over some sustained period of time, and it is a matter of national security for the United States that the S&P 500 divided by the TLT (20+ year Treasury bond ETF) continues to rise because the system has evolved such that capital gains and taxable IRA distributions are 200% of annual growth in US consumer spending, meaning if stocks don't rise, consumer spending cannot rise, and if consumer spending doesn't rise with debt-to-GDP at 120%, the US enters a debt spiral.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“the reserve currency issuer of the world cannot afford their debt unless real rates are negative over a some sustained period of time over the cycle it is a matter of national security for the United States that the S&P 500 divided by the TLT continues to rise”

0.68

The Fed is cutting rates not because economic conditions warrant it, but because the US government's fiscal situation warrants it—the point is to help finance deficits and prevent fiscal collapse, and this will be done regardless of economic indicators because there is zero chance the US government will default on its debt; instead inflation will be the release valve and the dollar will depreciate.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“the point is not is the Fed doing this because the economy warrants it or not doesn't matter the US government's balance sheet the US government's fiscal situation warrants it now and so it's going to get done because like I just said there is zero chance US government is going to default on its debt they're going to do what they have to do to make the ends meet and inflation is going to be the release valve the dollar is going to be the release Bel”

0.68

Gold is the most mispriced asset on the board; US official gold at market value as a percentage of foreign-held Treasuries was never below 20% from 1945-1989, was at 40% for most of the prior 60 years, and was at 131% in 1980 during a genuine gold bubble, but is now at only 8%, implying gold would need to rise 3x to reach historical low range.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“if you look back over the last 60 years uh the US's uh foreign held treasuries excuse me Us official gold at market value uh as a percent of foreign held treasuries it was never before 1989 it was never below 20% uh in other words Us official gold at market value in 1989 was collateralizing US foreign debt official foreign debt at 20% uh most of the prior 60 years uh it was at 40% today the number is at 8% 8% in 1980 when we had a a legit gold bubble it was at 131% so like gold would need to rise Rel about 3x just to get to the low range of the longterm um the long-term uh uh range of where gold would be given our uh long-term ratio of official gold at market value relative to our foreign debt”

0.68

Trump's proposal to impose 100% tariffs on countries abandoning the dollar is self-defeating: tariffs either raise prices for US consumers or force foreign nations to sell treasury bonds to pay for tariffs, both of which create upward pressure on US interest rates and harm the bond market, effectively shooting themselves in the foot since China's factories back the US bond market.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“when they sell their treasury bonds that they have in savings to pay for the tariffs you're just shuffling money from one pocket to the other at the end of the day you still are going to have interest rates going up uh or upward pressure on interest rates I should say to be accurate if you're going to force foreign trade Partners to pay for their own tariffs you know it's not like they have a dollar printing press they're going to sell the dollar savings they have which is either going to push stock prices down or or bond prices down”

0.68

Trump's oil drilling proposal is economically more favorable than Harris's housing subsidy because increased US oil production lowers prices for consumers and inputs for industry, and creates demand for dollars offshore (since foreign buyers need dollars to purchase American oil), supporting the dollar, whereas Harris's subsidies are purely inflationary with no dollar support mechanism.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“if you drill more oil supposed you know in theory the oil production increases oil prices go down uh Americans pay less the gas pump and of course oil being an input commodity for a lot of different things that would presumably uh bring down your um input cost for production and Manufacturing which would help inflation”

0.68

The stock market's performance is not significantly dependent on which presidential candidate wins in the near term (maybe for 'a cup of coffee'), because by one year into their term, the only viable policy option is to keep the stock market rising at an accelerating rate to generate consumer spending and tax receipts needed to service debt, regardless of the administration.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“do you think that the stock markets will be dependent on who wins the elections maybe for a cup of coffee um maybe for a cup of coffee but ultimately policy makers over the last 30 40 years have allowed our economy to evolve such that uh this stock market effectively is the driver of marginal us consumer spending”

0.68

When the Fed successfully brought inflation down in 2022-2023, the bad news was that inflation was the only thing keeping the US government solvent on a nominal basis, because inflation had inflated away the real value of debt and increased nominal GDP (and thus tax receipts) faster than debt accumulated.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“inflation was the only thing keep in the US government solvent on a nominal basis”

0.64

The US government cannot implement austerity to reduce the deficit because debt is already 120%+ of GDP; attempting a 5% of GDP spending cut to reduce deficits from 7-8% to 3% would trigger immediate recession, which causes deficits to rise 6-8% of GDP, making the situation worse rather than better.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“if they wanted to take that back to say 3% of GDP deficits that implies a 5% of GDP spending cut immediately that implies a 5% drop in GDP immediately to get that without cutting rates you would have to cut entitlements or defense uh by 25 to 30% immediately and permanently neither of those things are going to happen but you could do that now if the debt wasn't 120% but because the debt is 120% what you're going to do by by cutting 5% of GDP just to get the deficit back to 3% of GDP is you're going to trigger a recession and in recessions the deficit Rises by 6800 basis points of GDP so you're actually by trying to cut with debt as high as it is all you're going to do is spur a recession that ends up increasing the deficit of percent of GDP instead of shrinking it”

0.64

Both Harris and Trump are projected by multiple think tanks to increase the national deficit over the next 10 years, with Harris adding approximately $1+ trillion and Trump adding approximately $5 trillion, yet both claim to prioritize fighting inflation—a logical contradiction that exposes the futility of political discussion about deficit reduction.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“it's projected by several tanks including the pen Warton budget study that both Harris and Trump would likely increase the national def deficit uh over the next 10 years due to their policies so um Harris by the order of1 something trillion dollars uh Trump five times that according to this estimate so either way we're expected to get higher deficits”

0.63

The 10-year Treasury yield is currently mispriced and needs to be back over 4%, probably between 4-4.5%, because the US fiscal situation will force inflation and growth re-acceleration, even though yields won't reach 1980s levels (double digits) because yield curve control will be implemented before rates get that high given debt is now 125% of GDP versus 25-30% in the 1980s.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“I think I think the 10year yields mispriced here I think it probably needs to be back over four you know I don't know that it goes all the way back to you know the highs near five late last year or even back to 47 earlier this year not necessarily but uh ultimately again this fiscal situation of the US I think is dominant uh to everything else”

0.63

The 2022-2023 fiscal year experience proved the link between stock prices and government revenues: when the Fed hiked rates and stocks fell, the deficit went from $1 trillion to $2 trillion in a year, driven primarily by declining non-withheld tax receipts (stock options and equity compensation).

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“we saw a very brief glimpse of that 2023 when uh fiscal 23 right uh 2022 2023 when the FED hiked rates uh the deficit went from one trillion to two trillion in a year and it was heavily driven by stock prices Falling by uh uh non- withheld uh tax receipts which is code for stock options and other stock related comp”

0.61

Harris's anti-price-gouging legislation on grocery stores will not work and is either not serious or merely political theater because: (1) grocery stores operate on 3-5% pre-tax margins and cannot subsidize prices further, (2) price controls create shortages as seen in Cuba and Venezuela, and (3) Harris could invoke antitrust law to break up large food companies instead but doesn't because she needs their campaign funding.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“what's the average pre-tax margin of a grocery store you know 5% 3% like like they're not getting rich selling you know selling Cheerios to people uh the issue isn't the grocery stores and even if it you know even if it was like you could use the labor or the antitrust laws to break them up but she's not talking about doing that”

0.55

Harris's plan to give $25,000 to home buyers to make housing more affordable is inflationary and will not work because when the government gives money for something, the price level of that thing rises—similar to how college tuition rose from $7,000 to $222,000 per year at University of Cincinnati as government-backed loans expanded.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“she wants to give $25,000 uh to home buyers um to make housing more affordable when I went to college at the University of Cincinnati I paid $7,000 a year in tuition uh the government gave me and lots of people like me and lots of people since cheap loans to go to college today college at the University of Cincinnati costs $222,000 a year I know because I just cut the last tuition check for my son about six months ago so same college education same teachers nicer buildings uh better football team uh worse basketball team uh but my point is is said when the government gives you money for something all that ends up happening is the price level of that thing goes up”

0.54

Long-term US and UK sovereign debt (10+ year Treasuries and gilts) is the least attractive asset to own, though they may be good for short trades as yields are expected to move higher from current levels.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“what do I like the least uh I like uh longterm us and UK sovereign debt the least another 10 plus year treasuries 10 plus year gilts uh but again they're probably good for a short here as a trade I like I said I think 10e yields going back to four four and a quarter four and a half”

0.52

The Federal Reserve will not allow a significant stock market correction to occur or be sustained because to let the markets freefall would expose the structural dependence of the US fiscal position on stock market appreciation, which is a matter of national security, so there is an implicit guarantee that the Fed will backstop equities.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“we're not going to get a significant stock market correction because the Federal Reserve perhaps even at a certain level the government understands that to let the markets freefall would be to to your point uh greatly expose weaknesses in National Security weaknesses in the treasury market it weaknesses in their funding it would expose that they are critically dependent on stocks going up uh to fund their own fiscal largess in Washington”

0.52

The US stock market will continue rising in dollar terms but has been flat and will continue falling in gold terms, following an Argentina-like pattern where nominal prices rise due to currency debasement but real purchasing power (measured in gold) declines.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“I think I think we're in a a stock market environment with Argent you know you Argentine characteristics which is to say in dollar terms I think stocks keep going up I think in Gold terms the stock market has been flat S&P has been flat for several years in Gold terms and I think going forward I think the S&P is going to fall in Gold terms uh but in dollar terms I think the S&P is going to rise”

0.49

US true interest expense (sum of Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, net interest, and veterans benefits) reached 150% of US government receipts in August 2024, and was 120% in July 2024, meaning on a fiscal-year-to-date basis (11 of 12 months) the number is 99%, so US government receipts are covering true interest expense items and basically nothing else—not defense, not labor, not education, not national parks, not transportation.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“if you add Social Security you add up Medicare you add up Health which is Medicaid you add up uh net interest and you add up veterans benefits um all of those things are either the interest on the debt or the current portion of the United States government uh off-balance sheet debt right at the end of the day Medicare social security health uh Veterans Affairs those are all off-balance sheet debt uh that only come on balance sheet when they have to pay cash to pay benefits and so when I total those up and then I compare them to the receipts uh of the productive US economy in August the true interest expense was 150% of receipts”

0.49

Gold prices in dollars have completely separated from inverted US real rates since 2022, a phenomenon historically seen in emerging markets where rising nominal rates coincide with gold appreciation, signaling the beginning of the end of positive real rates in the US.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“gold prices in dollars have completely separated from inverted us re rates uh ultimately that's a phenomenon we see all the time in Emerging Markets rates go up and gold goes up in that currency it's been a long time since it's happened in dollars but it's happened since 2022 and that's the message of why gold is rising despite us real rates having risen is that the US government can't afford real positive re rates and so that will end”

0.49

Gold miners are mispriced relative to gold bullion because some of the capital allocation that historically went to gold miners (as leveraged gold exposure) has shifted to Bitcoin as an alternative leveraged position, and because markets have not yet fully absorbed the implications of BRICS gold-settlement behavior.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“I think ultimately miners uh have probably lost some share to bitcoin right some portion of people that buy gold miners have historically been well I want to own gold but I want to own gold with a ticker right I want to own something if I think Gold's going to go up but I want I want leverage I buy the miners uh I would argue that this cycle um and certainly over the last couple years that that some of that money when you say I want to own gold but I want to own it with leverage uh they might buy Bitcoin”

0.49

Gold is likely to reach $3,000 in the near-to-medium term, driven by two factors: (1) economic—gold is the effective BRICS currency with net settlement in gold at central bank level, and global oil markets (12-15x the size of annual gold production in dollar terms) create potential demand if trade increasingly settles in gold, and (2) geopolitical—after the US seized Russian FX reserves in 2022, central banks accelerated gold purchases to record pace (~1,100 tons/year), representing 55-60% of global non-Russian, non-Chinese mine production.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“I think it's going to 3,000 um you know then we'll see from there but ultimately well you've got both a u an economic and you've got a geopolitical uh driver to it uh the economic is that you know for all of the talk about the bricks currency gold effectively is the bricks currency uh they are trading in$ doll and they are settling on a net basis in gold at the Central Bank level”

0.49

Global central banks have not grown their Treasury holdings on net over the past 10 years; instead they have sold approximately $300-400 billion of Treasury bonds and purchased approximately $500 billion of gold bullion, signaling a structural shift away from storing value in Treasury bonds and toward gold.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“Global central banks have sold around3 to 400 billion dollar worth of Treasury Bonds on net in the last 10 years they have bought about $500 billion worth of gold bullion uh on net and so you're seeing this shift away from storing treasury bonds storing dollars as treasury bonds uh towards gold over the last 10 years”

0.48

Gold and Bitcoin are both very well positioned because when the most powerful, most indebted nation in the world and the reserve currency issuer cannot afford debt unless real rates are negative over a sustained period, this creates ideal conditions for both hard assets and alternative stores of value.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“I think gold and Bitcoin are both very well positioned uh when when you're in a regime uh where the most powerful nation in the world the most indebted nation in the world the reserve currency issuer of the world cannot afford their debt unless real rates are negative over a some sustained period of time over the cycle uh that's a really good setup for gold it's a really good setup for Bitcoin”

0.48

US industrial stocks are favorable investments because: (1) inflation provides nominal GDP growth support, and (2) there is bipartisan agreement on industrial policy, reshoring, and infrastructure buildout across Biden, Harris, and Trump administrations, which is particularly beneficial for companies exposed to electrical grid infrastructure needed for EVs, data centers, and AI.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“I continue to like us Industrials both from an inflationary sort of you know nominal GDP perspective but also when you're seeing bipartisan agreement on U industrial policy reshoring Etc both Biden and Trump uh Harris and Trump uh I think that's good for us industrial stocks and especially those exposed to electrical infrastructure uh type uh equipment uh there continues to be build out for the grid um which is desperately needed not just for EVS but for data centers AI stuff like that”

0.47

When China's commodity imports are priced in Yuan instead of dollars, it preserves China's dollar reserves and prevents the need to devalue or call in the IMF during commodity price spikes, addressing a fundamental constraint on China's ability to maintain sovereignty without implementing Southeast Asian-style capital controls.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Luke Groman

“the way you get around that is you get you switch the invoicing of your biggest import item your biggest dollar outflow which for the Chinese is Commodities and oil in particular you start switching it to you want you start getting trade deals with your partners that will sell to you in your currency um instead of in dollars and what that does is it basically preserves the dollar reserves of the Chinese”

0.45

Maintaining overweight Treasury bill positions at 5% yields provides clients with positive carry (payment for waiting) and optionality, because when the Fed doesn't cut rates aggressively enough to keep long rates down, investors can trade the volatility (dollar up, long rates up, gold flat/up, equities down as in Q3 2022 and Q3 2023).

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“maintain an overweight position in treasury T bills at 5% because you're getting paid and it gives you you know getting paid to wait and it gives you some ballast and it gives you some optionality with because anytime the FED doesn't play ball um you're going to get what we had in the third quarter of 2022 and in the third quarter of 2023 which was dollar up long rates up Gold Flat to up and everything else down”

0.45

Over the last 10-12 years, the invoicing of global commodity markets has shifted such that the marginal ton of commodities is now priced in Chinese Yuan, Indian Rupees, and other non-dollar currencies rather than exclusively in dollars as was historically the case, driven primarily by China and Russia.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“there is a dollarization of usage in global commodity markets uh particularly led by China as well as Russia some others as well where historically Commodities were only priced in dollars over the last 10 to 12 years that has shifted so that the marginal ton of Commodities is now priced in US um little bit in Indian rupes some other currencies but primarily in Chinese Yuan”

0.41

Recession is not imminent because US Federal receipts are running up 10% on a trailing 12-month basis and 6% on a trailing 3-month basis, which are not recessionary indicators; a recession would require both a big decline in receipts and a big increase in unemployment, and these would be triggered primarily by a sharp fall in stock prices that stays down.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Luke Groman

“I would be looking for um probably a the combination of a big decline in receipts uh and a a big increase in unemployment unemployment's a bit of a lag but uh the reality is US Federal receipts are running up 10% on a trailing 12mon basis right now they're up 6% on a trailing three-month basis um it's not recessionary uh at all it's it's actually very strong”

0.34

The US will never default on Treasury bonds in nominal terms because the US government has a printing press and can always print money to pay nominal debt obligations.

forecastestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Luke Groman

“can you imagine a scenario in which the US Treasury defaults on its sovereign debt no not not not in nominal terms no they will always print the money in my opinion”

0.21

There is persistent tension in Wall Street analysis between traditional monetary policy analysis (which focuses on economic indicators) and fiscal reality analysis (which focuses on deficit financing), and Wall Street has been increasingly split between those thinking the Fed will hold rates higher-for-longer and those realizing the Fed cannot afford to due to fiscal constraints.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Luke Groman

“I think this chop we've seen in the dollar has been sort of this fight of I would say traditional Wall Street and markets who are increasingly thinking the US is has a fiscal problem that basically hey the fed's going to go higher for longer because they can and then markets say no no no they they can't because they're not going to be able to cover their inter true interest expense with receipts and so there's this back and forth”

0.13

Trump's MO is to ask for a supercharged Ferrari at Christmas hoping to get a pet hamster; the 100% tariff is his opening negotiating position, not his actual policy expectation.

normativespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Luke Groman

“so it's a little bit of six of one half dozen of the other so I I I tend to think Trump saying those tariffs I think that was you know Trump being Trump which is he throws out you know if you Trump's Trump's MO is you know if you want a dog for Christmas ask for a supercharged Ferrari right and and so like you know I think the 100% tariff comment was you know I want a you know I want a supercharge Ferrari for Christmas because I'm hoping to get a pet hamster”