YouTube35m· Oct 2024· cataloged

The view from Tehran: Iran's VP Zarif on Israel, Gaza & US complicity in ongoing conflicts


What this covers

This is a GZERO World interview in which Ian Bremer questions Javad Zarif, Iran's Vice President for Strategic Affairs, a year after the Hamas attacks. It was recorded just before the news of Hassan Nasrallah's killing and Israel's limited ground entry into Lebanon, and Bremer frames those events alongside earlier Israeli strikes, including the one on Iran's embassy compound in Syria. Zarif is the one making the case. He argues that Israel's regional posture rested on invincibility and victimhood, and he treats the Iron Dome as another myth that Iran's missile salvo undermined. His figures are contested: he says 300-400 ballistic missiles were aimed at unpopulated military areas, and that about 10-11 got through.

The conversation then widens to Lebanon and Gaza. Zarif says Hezbollah is far more capable than [Hamas] and has shown restraint, so an all-out war would be of a different order than Gaza. He also says Hamas is still militarily effective despite roughly 41,000 Palestinian deaths. He calls the US complicit in Gaza because it could end the war and does not, and he describes the pre-attack erasure of Palestinians from regional diplomacy, citing Netanyahu's UN map. On the nuclear file, he claims Netanyahu set out to kill the JCPOA and that Iran is closer to a weapons capability because Donald Trump withdrew from it.

The remaining ground is more contentious still. Zarif holds that the US bears as much responsibility as Russia, or more, for Ukraine because of NATO expansion. He defends Iranian drone sales to Russia as lawful trade, dismisses the alleged plot against Trump as a campaign ploy, and explains why Iran has so few trading partners under sanctions. He also speculates on whether Kamala Harris or Trump would suit Iran better, and discusses the new president's overtures to the West, which he says Israel keeps trying to block.

Sharpest takeaway

Zarif argues that Israel has lost two foundational pillars of its regional power—the myth of military invincibility (shattered by October 7th) and victimhood narrative (undermined by civilian casualties)—forcing it into escalatory violence that will ultimately fail to restore its strategic position, while Iran has exercised strategic restraint despite provocation to avoid being drawn into a broader conflict on Israel's terms.

  • October 7th demonstrated that formal armies and irregular forces can inflict sustained damage on Israeli military, contradicting decades of perceived invincibility
  • Massive civilian casualties in Gaza have destroyed Israel's victim narrative and international sympathy, shifting global perception of the conflict
  • Iran's calibrated responses (warning channels, military targets only, allowing missiles through despite low penetration rate) reflect strategic choice to avoid escalation spiral that serves Israeli interests

The claims · ranked38 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.74

Hacking and cyber interference operate across all countries without respect to territorial boundaries, and as a result no government can completely prevent hacking operations originating from its territory, making attribution difficult and collective responsibility inappropriate.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Javad Zarif

“hacking doesn't recognize territory doesn't recognize borders exactly has the information so is the is the Iranian government position that there may well have been the operating from Iran from Iran but not on behalf not on behalf of the Iranian government exactly”

0.74

Netanyahu came to the US Congress and explicitly said he wanted to kill the JCPOA nuclear deal, with Netanyahu having stated in his book that his first priority was to kill the deal.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Javad Zarif

“Netanyahu has said in his book that his first priority was to kill the deal uh a deal that would have you know he came to Congress and said that absolutely he said that I mean said that all along”

0.72

International relations is fundamentally about solving issues rather than placing blame, and resolving the Ukraine crisis requires understanding what gave rise to it, with the core solution being a US commitment to halt NATO expansion.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Javad Zarif

“international relations is not about placing blame is about solving issues and if you want to resolve the current unfortunate crisis in Ukraine you have to understand what gave rise to it the minute the United States commits itself not to expand to I think the war in Ukraine will end”

0.71

Israel's core regional narrative rested on two foundational pillars: invincibility (demonstrated through military superiority in every conflict over decades) and victimhood (Holocaust, Arab terrorism, growing anti-Semitism), and the October 7th Hamas attack shattered the first pillar by proving that Israel could be seriously challenged and unable to achieve stated objectives of destroying Hamas.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Javad Zarif

“the Israel narrative uh in our region was that Israeli Army is Invincible uh and it has proven itself to be Invincible in every fight that it had with formal armies 7 Days 20 days it won the various Wars over the past decades decades Egypt Lebanon you name it y this time was different”

0.69

Hezbollah has military capabilities significantly greater than Hamas and has exercised considerable restraint, meaning that if Hezbollah stops exercising restraint, an all-out war would result that would be substantially different and more dangerous than the Gaza conflict.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Javad Zarif

“in Lebanon uh I think it's it's even more dangerous because because hasah has much greater military capabilities much greater military capability and it has exercised a lot of restraint and once it stop exercising restraint then you can have an allout War which would be much different than the war in Gaza”

0.68

The Israeli government is concerned less with genuine security threats and more with maintaining a narrative of threat for political purposes, as demonstrated by Netanyahu's opposition to the JCPOA despite it being the most effective constraint on Iranian nuclear capability possible.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Javad Zarif

“and Israel was worried about the end of that narrative the end of Iran being a security threat to the International Community”

0.68

The United States bears as much responsibility or more for the Ukraine invasion than Russia because US NATO expansion decisions created the underlying conditions that led to the invasion, even though Russia bears direct responsibility for the invasion itself.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Javad Zarif

“the United States is as much to believe to to blame if not more than Russia”

0.63

Israel assassinated a senior Iranian official in Syria and struck Iran's embassy in Syria, which caused major concern that this would trigger a full-scale Israel-Iran war.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Ian Bremer

“when Israel um targeted killed a senior Iranian official in Syria the a lot of people were concerned this was going to lead to an allout war between Israel and Iran”

0.63

Hassan Nasrallah, Hezbollah's iconic leader, was killed by Israel in a Beirut bombing, and Israeli troops entered Lebanon for the first time since 2006 in limited ground operations.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Ian Bremer

“Israel's government shocked the World by announcing that it had killed hezbollah's iconic leader Hassan nasrala in a Beirut bombing and earlier this week Israeli troops entered Lebanon for the first time since 2006 in what the government is calling limited ground offensives”

0.63

Russia is a neighbor of Iran with shared Caspian borders (historically including land borders with the Soviet Union), and Russia has not been hostile to Iran in the way the United States and the West have, specifically by continuing trade with Iran following the US withdrawal from the JCPOA while China also maintained trade relationships.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Javad Zarif

“Russia is a neighbor don't forget that Iran and Russia have been on the Caspian in the Caspian I mean in the past when when you had the Soviet Union we had land borders with Russia we've had we we've had a long history not a not always very positive but we have a long history with with Russia uh and uh Russia has been uh has not been hostile to Iran like the United States in the west uh Russia did not cut its trade with Iran following us withdrawal from the jcpa neither did China uh and that is why they're friends of our difficult times”

0.62

The myth of Iron Dome has been shattered because despite massive expenditure on air defense, Iranian missiles got through, whereas Iran spent much less money sending missiles than Israel spent preventing them.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Javad Zarif

“the myth about Iron Dome is over... you see with those missiles yes we spend much less time much much money in sending those missiles that Israel spent oh clearly in preventing them I mean the houthis are sending very inexpensive missiles against very expensive yes it's true I mean look because if you have to spend more money you're in serious trouble right”

0.62

Iran never wanted to build a nuclear weapon, and Iran is closer to nuclear weapons capability today because Trump withdrew from the JCPOA than it would have been if the deal had remained in place, as the deal would have kept Iran further from weapons capability for 15 years.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Javad Zarif

“a deal that would have you know he came to Congress and said that absolutely he said that I mean said that all along and that deal ostensively prevented Iran from building a nuclear weapon that he's screaming about uh we never wanted to build a nuclear weapon and that is why I argue uh that and the Iranians are much closer to that weapon today because of trump because heally pulled out of the to build a nuclear weapon we would be very close to it today”

0.62

During the Bush and Clinton administrations, the United States committed to take into account Russian security with regard to NATO expansion in G-7 Sheridan conversations, but the United States subsequently failed to honor these commitments through continued NATO expansion.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Javad Zarif

“during Bush and Clinton the United States I mean in the G Sherin uh conversations uh the United States committed itself to take into account Russian Security in in with regard to Nato and it didn't”

0.62

The United States is complicit in atrocities being committed in Gaza because it has the capability to end the war in Gaza and chooses not to, making the US morally culpable for the violence in a way Iran is not culpable for Ukraine because Iran has no comparable capability to end that conflict.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Javad Zarif

“we say the United States is complicit in the atrocities being committed in Gaza because the United States has the capability to end the war in Gaza and it doesn't whereas Iran has said time and again that we are prepared to use whatever influence which is limited in order to end the war in Ukraine so these are two different situation”

0.57

Netanyahu presented a map at the UN General Assembly just days before October 7th showing no Palestine on it, publicly stating that Israel's relations with 98% of the Arab world would be good while 2% (Palestinians) could 'do whatever they want,' revealing that the Palestinian issue was being deliberately written out of regional diplomacy.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Javad Zarif

“you remember Netanyahu came before the general assembly of the United Nations last year just a few days before October 7th and showed a map in which there was no Palestine and and he said uh our relations with the rest of the Arab world 98% of the Arab world is going to be good and 2% meaning Palestinians can do whatever they want that was the that was the perception that he had at that time”

0.57

Iran's provision of drones to Russia for use in the Ukraine war does not constitute military participation in the war effort but rather legitimate economic business relations, and Iran's cooperation with Russia is 'totally legal' as opposed to US provision of weapons to Ukraine which actively enables war fighting.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Javad Zarif

“we're not participating in the war we're simply conducting business our cooperation with Russia is totally legal we have not participated in the war effort in Ukraine building drone factories that Russians are using in Russia you see we have limited options in foreign trade”

0.57

For Palestinians, the pre-October 7th situation where they were being forgotten by international diplomacy and contained in Gaza as a 'big open prison' was a matter of life and death, justifying the attacks as a response to existential erasure from regional politics.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Javad Zarif

“for for the Palestinians it was a matter of life and death and that is why anybody who says is the uh is the cost of so many cash is worth it I tell them that this is up to the Palestinians to decide but you got to put them yourself in their shoes and see the the situation they were living under a big open prison in Gaza and the fact that they were being forgotten”

0.57

Iran's missile response to Israeli operations involved 300-400 ballistic missiles, deliberately targeted unpopulated military areas rather than civilian centers despite having the precision capability to do so, resulting in approximately 10-11 missiles penetrating Israeli defenses, demonstrating that the Iron Dome's 90% interception rate masks the strategic choice to limit casualties.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Javad Zarif

“when I go back to the 300 400 missiles that were sent back towards Israel I mean again I remember that in advance of that um there were back channels to Turkey to Iraq saying here is what Iran is planning it's seemed to me at the time that the Iranians were doing what they could saying yes we're going to respond militarily but we really don't want this to go and we didn't hit civilian targets and you only hit military targets only hit military targets only hit unpopulated areas”

0.55

Iran has limited options in foreign trade due to illegal US sanctions in violation of UN Security Council resolutions, which constrains Iran's international partnerships and forces reliance on available partners.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Javad Zarif

“the reason we have limited options in foreign trade is because the United States has illegally imposed sanctions against us in violation of un Security Council resolution that's it”

0.53

Hamas remains militarily capable of inflicting heavy damage on Israel despite 41,000 Palestinians killed and widespread destruction in Gaza, maintaining operational effectiveness contrary to Israeli claims of near-total military destruction.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Javad Zarif

“Hamas is still capable of INF inflicting heavy uh damage on isra do you believe in terms of the broader Palestinian cause which of course is getting a lot more attention today than it was before October 7th from everywhere I mean in my country in your country in the Gulf everywhere you remember you remember Netanyahu came before the general assembly of the United Nations last year just a few days before October 7th and showed a map in which there was no Palestine and and he said uh our relations with the rest of the Arab world 98% of the Arab world is going to be good and 2% meaning Palestinians can do whatever they want that was the that was the perception that he had at that time and I think for for the Palestinians it was a matter of life and death and that is why anybody who says is the uh is the cost of so many cash is worth it I tell them that this is up to the Palestinians to decide but you got to put them yourself in their shoes and see the the situation they were living under a big open prison in Gaza and the fact that they were being forgotten now as you say and rightly so Palestinian issue is top on the agenda of the International Community once again after so many years”

0.53

Iran's new president, a former cardiac surgeon, was elected by defeating hardliners and has explicitly stated desire to find common ground with the West and specifically to de-escalate tensions with the United States, representing a significant diplomatic opening.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Ian Bremer / Javad Zarif

“Iran's new president a former cardiac surgeon who beat out a field of hardliners in the election has vowed to find common ground with the west and is clearly uneasy about escalating things”

0.52

Israel's strategic objective has been to prevent Iran from engaging with the international community and finding common ground with the West, systematically blocking diplomatic opportunities including the JCPOA nuclear deal, and now the assassination of Haniyeh during Iran's presidential inauguration follows this pattern of Israeli interference in Iranian diplomatic initiatives.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Javad Zarif

“anytime Iran had an opportunity to engage with the International Community Israel made sure to block it whether it was jcpoa whether it was Irani nuclear deal you remember Israelis I mean Netanyahu has said in his book that his first priority was to kill the deal”

0.49

A student of Zarif's research demonstrated that Trump failed to re-securitize Iran during his administration while inflicting heavy economic damage, whereas Harris would be more capable of re-securitizing Iran because the global audience would be more aligned with that narrative, suggesting different electoral outcomes would have asymmetric effects on Iranian security interests.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Javad Zarif

“I have a student uh who wrote a master thesis uh with me uh proving that Trump failed to re securitize Iran during his administration while he inflicted heavy economic damage Harris is more capable of doing that because the audience the global audience would L be more aligned with it”

0.48

The International Community must take immediate serious action to prevent escalation in Lebanon because the region faces a shift from a humanitarian catastrophe (Gaza) to a security catastrophe (potential regional war), and the West is less concerned with humanitarian catastrophes than security catastrophes.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Javad Zarif

“that is why it would be prudent for the International Community to take Serious action the action that it has failed to take over the past 11 months in Gaza in Gaza in order to end this now Gaza was a humanitarian catastrophe is a is it continues to be a humanitarian catastrophe this can be a security catastrophe and I think the West unfortunately unfortunately uh is less concerned about the humanitarian catastrophe than about a security catastrophe”

0.48

Iran developed drone and weapons manufacturing capabilities specifically because when Iran fought Iraq, everyone provided sophisticated weapons to Iraq while Iran received nothing for self-defense, establishing a precedent that Iran cannot rely on international legal constraints and must be self-sufficient in defense.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Javad Zarif

“we didn't want to build weapons why did we because nobody gave it to us when we were fighting the Iraqis everybody was providing with the Iraqis with all sophisticated weapons and we didn't get anything to defend ourselves they were the aggressor so”

0.45

Nobody in Iran has affection for Trump or his company, though some may politically prefer him for strategic reasons despite this personal animosity.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Javad Zarif

“nobody in Iran has any affection uh for president Trump or his company but coming to politics politics is is a nasty game and some may prefer I certainly don't I don't have any preference but some may prefer him”

0.45

Iran has reserved the right to respond to the assassination of Hamas political leader Ismail Haniyeh and will choose the time of its response, but this reserved right is distinct from immediate action, reflecting a strategic decision to avoid falling into Israel's trap of expanding the war to drag the United States and Iran into direct conflict.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Javad Zarif

“Iran has reserved the right to respond at at the time of its choosing and uh we haven't given up that right it it is there and we will choose the time to respond because that's our right self-defense is the right that we have”

0.45

The Arab perception following October 7th is that they have achieved a new confidence that they can withstand Israeli military might, though this is more of a psychological condition than an actual change in military balance.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Javad Zarif

“the Arabs have a new confidence that they can withstand Israel military might and I think that's important that's a psychological uh condition not not a real condition on the ground”

0.40

Assassinating Qasem Soleimani was a heinous crime representing the murder of the most revered general in Iranian history, making the Trump administration's action deeply damaging to Iranian-American relations despite potentially creating some strategic calculations about electoral preferences within Iran.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Javad Zarif

“Trump obviously carried out a heinous crime of assassinating the most Revere General probably in Iranian history kasum suan good friend of mine uh and this is I mean nobody in Iran has any affection uh for president Trump or his company”

0.39

According to Bremer's assessment, Israel has thus far faced virtually no consequences for its escalations despite unprecedented scale of operations.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ian Bremer

“aside from a handful of Hezbollah and Iranian missiles sneaking through the Iron Dome Israel has thus far faced virtually no consequences for its escalations”

0.27

Netanyahu's polling improved for the first time since October 7th, contrary to what Zarif's claim would suggest about Israeli political vulnerability.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Ian Bremer

“Netanyahu's Likud party for the first time since October 7th is now polling ahead of the other parties”

0.26

Iran does not interfere in the internal affairs of other countries, specifically the US elections, and does not have a preference regarding the outcome, contrasting this with the United States which regularly intervenes in other countries' internal affairs.

normativespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Javad Zarif

“Iran doesn't have a preference in in this election we don't exercise uh intervention in the internal affairs of other countries unlike the United States which does that every so often uh but we don't do that uh we don't interfere in the in the US elections uh it's up to the American people to decide who will run their country”

0.24

Iran recognizes and accepts the territorial integrity of all of Ukraine including Crimea, which was a matter of principle for Iran in past positions on territorial acquisition by force.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Javad Zarif

“Iran is under record not to accept acquisition of territory by force by anybody that's our position of principle we have repeated so the Russian invasion was illegal in our view... so do we including Crimea”

0.22

The Iranian position is that there may have been hacking operations originating from Iran but not on behalf of the Iranian government, and Iran itself is a victim of hacking.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Ian Bremer and Javad Zarif

“is the Iranian government position that there may well have been the operating from Iran from Iran but not on behalf not on behalf of the Iranian government exactly um... we are ourselves victims of hacking and uh it it continues”

0.19

The Palestinian issue is once again at the top of the international community's agenda after many years of being marginalized, which is a positive development even if achieved through the devastating consequences of October 7th.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Javad Zarif

“Palestinian issue is top on the agenda of the International Community once again after so many years uh and I think that's important”

0.17

Everyone who has the capability and the need builds weapons; this is not unique to Iran, though not all countries have the capability to do so.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Javad Zarif

“everybody who has the capability and has the need... everybody with the capability and with the need”

0.13

Bremer hopes that in a year's time at the UN, whoever wins the US election will have improved the US-Iran relationship from its current state.

forecastspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Ian Bremer

“do you come back in a year's time at the United Nations do you believe whoever wins the US election do you believe that the US Iran relationship will be better will be in a better position than it is right now”

0.13

Iran officially refutes allegations that it has threatened to assassinate former President Trump, characterizing such claims as campaign tactics rather than evidence of genuine Iranian policy.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Javad Zarif

“the Iranian government has refuted that officially yes and I once again refute that we don't send people to assassinate people uh I think that's a campaign Ploy uh in order to uh get uh former president Trump out of the uh well not so favorable situation he's in uh in the elections”