
What this covers
This is the third episode of Existential Basics, a short series from The Modern Existentialist, narrated by Mark. It begins with groundwork: the terms subject and object, where a subject is a conscious agent able to act on the world and an object is something within the world that agents act on. From there it separates the subjective, which arises from individual agency, from the objective, which is an effect of the world itself. The principle of fundamental subjectivity follows. Reality appears to us only as we perceive it, so no piece of information can be confirmed as an undeniable metaphysical fact. That principle is the lens for the rest of the video.
The middle section lays out nihilism and absurdism, which Mark ties to Schopenhauer and Camus. Nihilism is described as the view of a cold, barren world without meaning, and the nihilist either sinks into despair or settles into stoic silence. The absurdist agrees that existence is meaningless but notes that biology still compels humans to look for meaning. The absurdist answers with revolt and treats meaninglessness as a kind of freedom: with no consequences and nothing at stake, one can live fully. Mark treats the two as opposites in one respect, since one gives up agency and the other embraces it, and as the same in another, since both start by rejecting inherent meaning.
The last stretch is the rebuttal. Mark argues that both positions swap one dogma for another, and that "inherently meaningless" is as unverifiable a claim as "inherently meaningful." He also makes a self-undermining argument: if nothing could be meaningful, words could not carry meaning and the conversation could not happen. His constructive turn holds that meaning is a value people create, which makes it real to them rather than fake. He presents existentialism as a discipline that deconstructs and tests every belief, its own included, because it values truth that can be known.
Nihilism and absurdism both make an empirical error by claiming existence is inherently meaningless, when in fact meaning is a value humans create; existentialism instead empirically tests all claims and rejects dogmatism itself rather than replacing one dogma with another.
- Nihilists and absurdists reject the dogma that existence is inherently meaningful but replace it with the dogma that existence is inherently meaningless—both are unfalsifiable metaphysical claims, not empirical conclusions
- Meaning and truth are values we create, not objective facts; the fact that we create meaning makes it entirely real to us, not fake
- Existentialism is empirical philosophy that tests every belief through systematic deconstruction and elimination, refusing to accept any dogma including its own
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
If nothing could be meaningful, then words themselves could not have meaning, and we could not have a conversation about meaning in the first place.
“if it were the case that nothing could be meaningful then words themselves can have meaning meaning that you and i couldn't in the first place be having a conversation about meaning”
The absurdist rejects the nihilist's claim to impotence; instead, because everything is meaningless and nothing will amount to anything, the absurdist believes he is therefore perfectly free and perfectly his own man, completely a subject.
“where the nihilist is content to just let go to deny his own agency and let himself sink into the futility of his meaningless condition the absurdist chooses to rebel instead embracing his fundamental subjectivity where the nihilist believes that he is impotent that nothing he can ever do will ever amount to anything the absurdist instead believes that because everything is meaningless because nothing will ever amount to anything he is therefore perfectly free and perfectly and completely his own man completely and totally a subject”
According to the principle of fundamental subjectivity, our reality appears to us only as we perceive it, and we cannot confirm that any information is strictly real or an undeniable metaphysical fact of the world.
“we established last time though that according to our principle of fundamental subjectivity that to the best of our knowledge our reality appears to us only how we perceive it we can't know any information to be strictly real strictly objective in its nature we can't know that something is an undeniable metaphysical fact of the world because we can never confirm it”
Existence is absurd in the sense that even though existence is fundamentally meaningless, human beings are still compelled by their biology to seek meaning within the world.
“the absurdist believes that existence is well absurd that even though existence is fundamentally meaningless even though it's an objective fact of reality that our reality is fake we as human beings are still somehow compelled by our biology to seek meaning within the world that's what it means to say that existence is absurd that we feel that we must seek even though we know that we will never find meaning in our lives”
The absurdist walks a path of revolt: rejecting the ideas that there is no meaning, no such thing as value or truth, and affirming that this meaninglessness is okay and good because it means we are truly free.
“so the absurdist walks his path of revolt to rebel against the absurd and say this there is no meaning no such thing as value or truth and that's okay that's good because that means we're truly free”
Both nihilists and absurdists correctly recognize that existence is not inherently meaningful, but they then make a logical error by assuming that because the world is not inherently meaningful, it must therefore be inherently meaningless.
“the nihilist and the absurdist both after all base their theory on the idea that the dogma of the world is wrong that existence is not inherently meaningful as the majority of people might claim and in this they're correct after all existence is not inherently meaningful where they go wrong though is in this next step of their reasoning that they assume that because the world is not inherently meaningful it must therefore be inherently meaningless in formulating their rejection of dogma they took a logical leap and then immediately tripped falling flat on their faces”
By rejecting the dogma that existence is inherently meaningful and replacing it with the dogma that existence is inherently meaningless, nihilists and absurdists failed to reject dogmatism as a whole; they simply replaced one dogma with another.
“they believe that they've rejected dogma but in reality all they did was reject a dogma the dogma that everybody else believes and then they replaced it with their own the fundamental problem with nihilist absurd this theory is that they failed to reject inheritance to reject dogmatism as a whole what they've done instead is just embrace a different dogma a dogma that rejects meaning”
The fact that we create meaning does not make that meaning fake; the fact that we have created it makes it entirely real to us, and our reality is a fiction therefore our fiction is our reality.
“the fact that we create meaning doesn't make that meaning fake because the fact that we have created it makes it entirely real to us our reality is a fiction therefore our fiction is our reality”
Using the principle of fundamental subjectivity, we can demonstrate that existence cannot be inherently meaningful (because meaning is value we assign), cannot be inherently meaningless (because meaning is value we assign), and therefore is not inherently anything at all.
“using our principle of fundamental subjectivity we can demonstrate that existence both can't be inherently meaningful because meaning is value that we assign and also can't be inherently meaningless because meaning is value that we assign existence just isn't inherently anything at all”
The empirical evidence does not lead us to conclude that there is no meaning in existence; rather, because meaning like truth is a value that we create, the existence of meaning is evident in the fact that things mean things to us.
“the empirical evidence after all doesn't lead us to conclude that there's no meaning or value in existence because meaning like truth is a value that we create it should be obvious after all that there is meaning in the world because things mean things to you”
The claim that meaning is inherently absent is itself a claim to metaphysical knowledge—a claim to know something to be absolutely true even though we can never observe or confirm it, which violates the principle of empiricism.
“we can't claim as the nihilist and absurdists do that we know that meaning is inherently absent because that's a claim to metaphysical knowledge a claim to know something to be absolutely true even though we can never observe or confirm it the best we can say is that we know that there is no inherent meaning because that is what we can confirm empirically”
In one sense, nihilism and absurdism are opposites: nihilists reject their agency while absurdists embrace it; in another sense, they are the same because both base their theory on rejecting the claim that existence is inherently meaningful.
“so there's a sense in which nihilism and absurdism are opposites that is in the sense that nihilists are just the sad ones and absurdists are just the happy ones the sense in which nihilists reject their agency and absurdists choose to embrace it in the other sense though the sense in which they're the same”
The fundamental flaw in nihilist and absurdist theory is that these philosophers believe they are empirically correct, but in reality they are actually all empirically wrong.
“the fundamental flaw in nihilist absurdist theory is that the philosophers of their tradition believe that they're empirically correct but that in reality they're actually all empirically wrong”
Existentialists deconstruct every claim to knowledge or truth and test its empirical validity before deciding whether to believe it, attacking and questioning every belief system including their own.
“we as existentialists have to deconstruct every claim to knowledge or truth and test its empirical validity before we can decide whether or not we'll believe it that's why we attack question and try to destroy every belief system that we find including our own”
Existentialists attack and question belief systems not out of malice, arrogance, or spite, but because they choose to value truth that can be known.
“it's not out of malice not because of arrogance or spite but because we choose to value the truth that we can know”
If meaning, value, and truth are subjective values we create rather than objective truths, then the question arises: what does meaning mean if our values do not hold inherent value and we cannot consider them objective?
“if our ideas of meaning value and truth concepts that we might have originally assumed to be immovable objective truths are actually just subjective values then what does meaning mean if our values don't hold inherent value if we can't consider them objective then what can truth even be”
If someone believes something is the truth, they should be able to defend their position and demonstrate why they believe it is true; if they can, we have a reason to believe it is true too.
“if someone believes that something is the truth then they should be able to defend their position and demonstrate why they believe it's the truth and if they can then maybe we'd have a reason to believe it's true too”
Because the world is fake and our reality is just a simulation, there are no restrictions to hold us back, and because we will die, there can never be any consequences; therefore, while still alive, we are free to live our fullest lives.
“if nothing means anything if the world we live in is just a simulation then that means that there are no restrictions nothing to ever hold you back again if the world is fake just a fantasy born from our imaginations then that means that there can never be any consequences when we die it's all over so while we're still here and still alive we're free to live our fullest lives”
The nihilist either lays down and wallows in despair or comes to terms with his realization and sits in stoic silence; the absurdist instead chooses to rebel against this futility.
“this next step here where the nihilist chooses either to lay down and wallow in his despair or to come to terms with his realization and just sit there forever staring at nothing in stoic silence this is where the absurdist first takes to the stage”
An object is something within the world that can be acted on by agents, by us as subjects.
“an object on the other hand is well it's literally an object it's something within the world that can be acted on by agents by us as subjects”
Something is subjective when it arises from individual agency—what you think or believe; something is objective when it is an effect of the world or reality itself.
“what it means for something to be subjective then is that it's something that you think or that you believe something that arises from our individual agency and what it means for something to be objective then is for it to be effect of the world or of reality”
Nihilism is the philosophical position that existence is fundamentally and objectively meaningless, and the world is a cold, uncaring, bleak barren wasteland completely devoid of any real true meaning.
“the world is cold and uncaring a bleak barren wasteland completely devoid of any real true meaning we come and go as ash and soil in between we are nothing but sacks of flesh and bile that is what the nihilist believes”
Nihilism and absurdism are philosophical traditions in the Western tradition usually attributed to Schopenhauer and Camus.
“welcome to a brief summary of nihilist absurdist theory a pair of philosophies which in the western tradition are usually attributed to schopenhauer and kamu”
A subject is an actor or agent—someone who has the power or agency to act on the world; you, me, or anyone else who is a conscious individual.
“a subject is what we call an actor or an agent someone who has the power or agency to act on the world in other words you or me or anyone else who's a conscious individual”
Nihilists believe that because we are nothing more than a brain and body, because we live in a fiction and cannot access objective reality, our existence is therefore fake, a lie, and a sham, and the real true objective nature of existence is just meaningless nothing.
“they believe that because we're nothing more than just a brain and a body because we live a fiction and can't access an objective reality our existence is therefore fake a lie and a sham and that the real true objective nature of existence is just a meaningless nothing”
Nihilists typically do not think of themselves as dark or depressive people; they style themselves as tragic pragmatists or realists who have come to terms with a fundamental objective truth that nothing is really real and everything moves inevitably toward a meaningless end.
“everything is meaningless is the mantra of the nihilist though typically they don't think of themselves as such dark or depressive people usually they'll style themselves as tragic pragmatists or realists or something to that effect just people that have come to terms with a fundamental objective truth of the world they believe that they've arrived at this kind of transcendent metaphysical wisdom the knowledge that nothing is really real and that everything moves inevitably toward a final meaningless end”
Existentialism is an empirical philosophy that reaches rational conclusions by working slowly and methodically through process of elimination.
“existentialism is an empirical philosophy what that means is that in order to reach a rational conclusion we have to work slowly and methodically by process of elimination”