What this covers

This 2019 São Paulo "Global Citizen" conversation puts Yuval Harari and Jared Diamond on stage with moderator Ronaldo Lemos. It moves between Harari's focus on technology and politics and Diamond's field-based comparisons with traditional societies. Much of the first half concerns the AI revolution. Harari argues that jobs will change rather than vanish, but that rich countries can afford to retrain workers. Unemployment would therefore pile up in places like Guatemala, Indonesia and Bangladesh, whose main asset is cheap manual labor. He adds a political layer, data colonialism, in which a country's medical, financial and political data sit in San Francisco or Beijing and allow control without soldiers.

The conversation then turns to mental health. The moderator notes that physical health has improved while depression and anxiety have worsened among young people. Harari says minds evolved for the Stone Age and cannot absorb the pace of change, and he recommends meditation while allowing that sports may suit some people better. Diamond describes clinical specialists who treat electronic media addiction, and he complicates the nostalgia for traditional life. In New Guinea people age fast and child suicide is not rare, yet New Guineans know how to farm 79 sweet potato varieties and would be better placed than Americans if industrial systems collapsed. He puts the chance of a fall back to a Stone Age economy at roughly 49% if sustainable development fails.

The most contentious stretches concern truth and governance. Harari claims that large-scale cooperation often runs on flattering fictions rather than facts, even though a nuclear bomb needs both. Diamond cites National Geographic Society geography surveys, American disbelief in evolution, and the Trump administration's hurricane episode as signs of eroded respect for fact. Harari defends democracy for its ability to admit error, in contrast to authoritarian regimes that blame traitors and demand more power. He also urges Brazil to let rainforest hydrology shape policy. Education closes the discussion, including Japan's and California's opposite handling of teacher distribution.

Sharpest takeaway

Harari and Diamond argue that modern societies face interconnected crises—technological disruption, environmental collapse, and mental health decline—requiring fundamental shifts in education, technology use, and democratic governance to avoid catastrophic inequality and societal breakdown.

  • AI automation will concentrate wealth in rich countries while devastating developing economies through data colonialism, creating unprecedented global inequality
  • Mental health has deteriorated despite physical health improvements because human minds are maladapted to 21st-century technological acceleration and stress
  • Education systems must shift from teaching facts to teaching how to learn continuously and navigate uncertainty in a volatile future

The claims · ranked50 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.69

Extreme inequality from AI automation also leads to political domination through 'data colonialism'—controlling a country through gathered data rather than military force, where countries like Brazil will have personal medical, financial, and political data held by entities in San Francisco or Beijing, enabling remote control without soldiers.

causalhigh valuefringenovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“this also leads to political domination we are likely to see we are beginning to see what could be called data colonialism when to control a country you don't need to send in the armies you just need to gather the data from the country just imagine say Brazil in 20 years or 30 years when the entire personal medical financial history of every journalist every politician every judge every mirror in Brazil is held by somebody in San Francisco Beijing everything every little sexual escapade you had at age 20 somebody there knows it because they have the data they don't need to send in soldiers the data is enough to control these countries from afar”

0.69

Modern society faces emerging clinical psychology specialty dedicated to treating electronic media addiction, where patients literally experience withdrawal similar to heroin addiction when devices are removed, requiring professional psychological intervention.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jared Diamond

“there is now a specialty of clinical psychology which consists of detoxifying people who are addicted to their electronic media... there are psychologists who specialized in this and so someone who recognizes that they are checking their cell phone every two minutes and they're checking in in the in the in the evening and their the cell phone is next to them while they're making love in the evening they recognize that they've got a problem so there are psychologists who take away such a debts for the weekend the addict leaves all the electronic devices in the pile of the door and for the first couple of hours they are undergoing withdrawal literally withdrawal like a heroin addict”

0.69

Technology use without being used by technology requires a balanced approach where engineers emphasize potential while historians and philosophers must speak about dangers, as both perspectives are necessary for society.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“I try to use technology without being used by it so to use it smartly I I'm not against technology... there is kind of a division of labor between you know engineers and interpreter and tempra NORs while developing the new technologies they for obvious reasons tend to emphasize all the wonderful promises and the positive potential and then it becomes the tasks of historians and philosophers and social critics to speak mainly about the dangers because somebody has to do it but I think we need overall a balanced approach”

0.68

Brazil should be honest in its governance and take perspective beyond a couple of years rather than short-term thinking; basic facts about tropical rainforest hydrology must drive policy—cutting down forests converts them to soybean/cattle operations initially increasing production but then reducing rainfall, eventually decreasing soybean and cattle production.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“my advice would be to be honest and to take a perspective beyond a couple of years my concern without knowing Brazil well is that the United States has no monopoly on dishonesty there are some very basic things about how to how to operate in the area like Brazil a tropical rainforest tropical rainforests have their own hydrological cycle and if you cut down the forest you end up with drought so if you cut down forests and convert the forest to soybean plantations initially you get you get a lot more soybeans you get more cattle ranches but then you get less rain and you're gonna get less soybean production less cattle productions well it's my concern is that the is that a short term perspective is being taken at the highest levels of and that in a relatively short runners can be very bad for Brazil”

0.68

Despite its difficulties, maintaining democracy is important because its core advantage—ability to acknowledge mistakes and change course—is essential for long-term survival, making it preferable to apparently faster but ultimately self-defeating authoritarianism.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“so no matter what the difficulties are it's very important to remove to remember this crucial advantage of democracy that it is better in acknowledging its mistakes and trying something else and that usually is worth all the downsides of the democratic regimes”

0.68

Authoritarian regimes, when facing policy failure, must attribute blame to enemies or traitors (never to regime error), concluding they need more power, leading to escalating power consolidation and authoritarianism—history shows where this path leads.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“for eternal regimes usually when the regime makes a mistake it never acknowledges it it blames it either own enemies outside or traitors within and the conclusion the regime reaches is that it meets even more power because yes things are we promised wonderful things we didn't accomplish them not because we made a mistake but because there was traitors and enemies so the solution is to give us even more power and if again that things still don't improve again they will say it's because the traitors are really really powerful so we need even more power and we know from history where this is leading”

0.66

Democracy's huge long-term advantage is flexibility—when mistakes are made (which all regimes do), democracies can acknowledge them and change course through citizen voting, whereas authoritarian regimes must blame enemies or traitors and demand more power, leading to escalating authoritarianism.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“I would emphasize the importance of keeping Brazilian democracy well functioning you know s all over the world there is now a growing disbelief or less faith in democracy but in the long run the huge advantage of democracy is its flexibility that sometimes authoritarian regimes they can make quicker decisions because you need to compromise less you need to consult less with different groups and different people so it seems that they can make things work faster but the big problem of authoritarian regimes is that when they make mistakes and everybody make mistakes all regimes all people all parties make mistakes in a democracy when you make a mistake it's easier to acknowledge it even if the ruling party doesn't acknowledge it their citizenry can replace them so you can change course you know for eternal regimes usually when the regime makes a mistake it never acknowledges it it blames it either own enemies outside or traitors within and the conclusion the regime reaches is that it meets even more power because yes things are we promised wonderful things we didn't accomplish them not because we made a mistake but because there was traitors and enemies so the solution is to give us even more power and if again that things still don't improve again they will say it's because the traitors are really really powerful so we need even more power and we know from history where this is leading”

0.63

Traditional New Guinea societies have shorter lifespans with people aging rapidly due to hard living conditions; few people live past 50, and those who do are in worse physical condition than their Western counterparts aged 70-80.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Jared Diamond

“the most obvious thing in traditional New Guinea societies is the shorter life spans not just the shorter life spans that that people whose age you can figure out by reference to some dateable events even if they didn't have a birth register people just age much more rapidly because they have a much harder life when I go into a New Guinea village and they ask they ask how old you last time I was there I said eighty-one and I remember in in one Indonesian village when when I said my sets in my age they said responded certain Gomati which an Indonesian means half-dead so the fact is that that in New Guinea villages a few people live into their seventies or eighties they are the repository of knowledge but most relatively few people live past 50 and they are in much worse condition physically”

0.62

Once textile production becomes cheaper in New York than Guatemala, unemployment will concentrate in Guatemala not New York, because employment in rich areas will increase due to higher income and demand for service jobs like yoga teachers for software engineers.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“just think what happens to the textile industry in Central America or in Southeast Asia once it becomes cheaper to produce a shirt in New York than in Guatemala we're quite close to that point you won't see unemployment in New York actually employment in New York or San Francisco will even go higher because there is more money there is more demand for software engineers there is more demand for yoga teachers to teach the software engineers yoga the unemployment will be in Guatemala it will be in Bangladesh”

0.62

The AI revolution will result in extreme global inequality between countries dominating the AI economy and countries that collapse because their main economic asset—cheap manual labor—becomes irrelevant.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“the danger is that the AI revolution will result in something like the Industrial Revolution of the 19th century extreme inequality between some countries which are dominate the global economy and other countries which completely collapse because their main asset of cheap manual labor becomes irrelevant”

0.62

Human minds are not adapted to 21st century; they evolved for Stone Age conditions and accelerating rate of technological, social, and economic change creates immense psychological stress that humans lack capacity to handle.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“our minds are not adapted to the 21st century they are much more adapted to the Stone Age and the accelerating rate of technological and social and economic change create immense stress for the mind”

0.62

Many traditional societies are severely repressive to children; child suicide is surprisingly common in some societies, whereas child suicide is virtually unknown in Western society—suggesting traditional societies may have mental health disadvantages Western societies don't.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jared Diamond

“many traditional societies are severely repressive to children a child suicide isn't surprisingly common in some societies whereas child's child suicide is virtually unknown in Western society all which means that we we just don't have the daughter I'm tempted to say that mental health is much better in traditional societies but that may not”

0.62

Jobs will not be completely eliminated but will rather change, with some disappearing and new ones emerging; the key challenge is retraining workers for new jobs, and rich countries leading automation will have huge advantage because they have resources to retrain workforce, so huge unemployment will concentrate in developing countries like Guatemala, Indonesia, Bangladesh.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“it's not that jobs will be completely eliminated some jobs will disappear some jobs will change and some new jobs will emerge and the big issue will not will actually be retraining people to fill the new jobs and here the rich countries which are leading the automation revolution they have a huge advantage because they will reap most of the benefits from the AI revolution and they already reach anyway so they will have the resources to retrain their workforce so I don't think we'll see huge unemployment in the United States or in Germany or Japan the huge unemployment will be in Guatemala and Indonesia and Bangladesh”

0.61

New Guineans retain knowledge of farming 79 varieties of sweet potatoes, and until recently 100% of New Guinean population were farmers; in contrast, only 2% of Americans are farmers, making New Guineans better positioned for subsistence economy than Americans if industrial system collapses.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jared Diamond

“my New Guinea friends still know how to farm the 79 varieties of sweet potatoes I don't have the faintest idea how to farm sweet potatoes in the United States 98% of Americans are not farmers 2% of Americans are farmers but in New Guinea until recently 100 percent of people were farmers”

0.61

Human power and large-scale cooperation do not depend on knowing the truth in many cases; instead, fictional stories are often more effective at achieving cooperation than truth because fictional stories are easier to grasp and more flattering, whereas truth is often complicated and unflattering.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“human power does not really depend on knowing the truth in many many cases the real UN power depends on cooperation on large-scale cooperation and unfortunately or not it is often easy to make people cooperate based on a fictional story then based on the truth because the truth and this goes back to the issue of crisis the truth is often complicated unflattering difficult to deal with whether as fictional stories tend to be easier to grasp and tend also often to flatter us like blaming somebody else for our problems”

0.60

If sustainable economy development fails in next decades and complex first-world society cannot be sustained, there is ~49% chance humanity lapses to Stone Age economy, and the people who survive best would be those with recent experience in pre-industrial living—New Guineans and Amazonian Native Americans—not developed-world populations.

forecasthigh valuefringenovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jared Diamond

“there's another scenario which is quite possible I would say the chances are 49% that the scenario that I'm about to tell you will happen and that is that suppose we don't get on to a sustainable economy in the next several decades we failed and we're no longer able to support a first world society and we would lapse we have to relapse to the Stone Age who is going to be able to master the art of living in the Stone Age not Americans not Europeans not Japanese the people who will master life in the Stone Age of the people who who have experience of it within their lifetimes with a grandparents lifetime New Guineans and here in Brazil on Amazonian Native Americans”

0.59

Meditation—practiced daily (two hours) with annual 30-60 day retreats—helps people cope with modern stress; many meditation traditions spanning thousands of years have developed techniques for managing psychological stress that remain relevant.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“it goes all the way to relying on things like meditation yeah that we have thousands of years of traditions of helping people cope with with these things... I try to meditate two hours every day and go every year for a long retreat of between 30 and 60 days of the personal meditation... I know most people can't afford it but I think every person does that help you to me it helps very much”

0.57

Most Americans do not believe in evolution, despite it being the foundational framework for understanding biology, yet more shocking is that the majority of American biology teachers do not believe in evolution.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Jared Diamond

“there are lots of Americans more than in Europe who do not believe in evolution although the major factor biology is evolution you can no more understand biology if you don't accept the fact of evolution then you can understand physics if you don't believe in atoms and yet it's not just that a majority of Americans don't believe in evolution is that the majority of American biology teachers do not believe in evolution which is shocking”

0.57

The Trump administration's denial of hurricane threat to Alabama (a state ~1000 km from east coast) and subsequent government suppression of National Weather Bureau correction demonstrates political denial of elementary scientific facts and government suppression of scientists working for government.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Jared Diamond

“we recently had a hurricane a bad hurricane which came up the east coast of the United States and threatened Florida in the Carolinas for some reason president Trump believed that that hurricane was also going to threaten the state of Alabama which is about a thousand kilometers from the East Coast and so Trump announced that the hurricane was a threat to Alabama and this had various consequences the u.s. weather bureau then was was obliged to to announce that for fear that Alabamans would run out of that houses enclosed in the house the weather bureau chief in alabama announced no there's no threat to to Alabama from the hurricane but then the national government told the head of the weather bureau to shut up and to retract that statement”

0.57

Physical health of humans has improved dramatically through vaccination and medical advances, but mental health has not improved and has actually worsened, with epidemics of depression and anxiety especially among college-aged young people.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Moderator

“the overall health of humans have improved dramatically so vaccination and everything that we have accomplished to expand the perspective of human life and to keep a good health that's all truth and I think we can see that but there is one area in human life that I don't think we have improved and that's precisely mental health actually I think this situation is pretty much decreasing I think you all teach and you give talks and when you speak to younger people today especially people going to college at right now there's an epidemics of depression anxiety and so on”

0.57

National Geographic Society surveys of geographic knowledge in 12 countries (including US) repeatedly show Americans score lowest or second-lowest; Americans cannot locate Afghanistan, Somalia, New York City on maps; majority of Americans cannot identify the Pacific Ocean despite it being the globe's largest geographic feature.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Jared Diamond

“the National Geographic Society every year or two carries out surveys around the world of people's knowledge of geography and there are 12 countries test is one of which is always the United States then there's Mexico and Iceland various other countries year after year Americans score the lowest one next to the lowest in the knowledge of geography but the examples of how poor our knowledge of geography is I think will shock you most Americans of course most Americans cannot locate Afghanistan or Somalia on a map although American troops have gone into Afghanistan and Somalia but whose us to know we are Afghanistan and Somalia are worst yet most Americans cannot locate New York City on the map and worst of all the biggest geographic feature of the globe is the Pacific Ocean if you close your eyes and throw darts at random you you're more likely to hit the Pacific Ocean than anything else but the majority of Americans cannot identify the Pacific Ocean”

0.56

Building a nuclear bomb requires both scientific truth (e.g., accurate physics like E=mc²) and massive social cooperation through shared narratives; the scientific truth is necessary but insufficient—millions must cooperate, which fictional stories achieve more effectively than explaining relativity theory.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“take an example say of an atom bomb what do you need in order to build an atom bomb on the one hand you need truth scientific truths if you are working on the basis of a wrong theory of physics you think e equals mc2 the third you won't be able to build an atom bomb yeah so on the one hand you need the truth and even the most dictatorial and lunatic regimes in the world but it comes to building nuclear weapons they suddenly want the scientific truth but it's not enough to have a true physical theory to build an atom bomb you also need millions of people cooperating you need notice the physicists you need the miners and the engineers and the peasants and farmers who grow the food that the workers are in millions of people now how do you get millions of people to cooperate not by explaining to them the theory of relativity it's a very bad not bad but it's it's it's not going to work you won't get millions of people cooperating by trying to explain to them the theory of relativity here fictional stories tend to be far far more effective”

0.55

Japan and United States handle regional educational inequality differently: Japan provides more teachers to rural low-performing areas to equalize achievement; US California provides fewer teachers to poor areas, making poor/uneducated become more uneducated.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Jared Diamond

“let me contrast the educational systems in the United States and in Japan particularly as regards what to do about areas where educational performance is poor both in the United States and in Japan rural areas with low population density the students tend to be poorer students Japan and the United States deal with that in opposite ways Japan has a higher teacher to student ratio in rural areas that's the say in areas where the students are doing poorly the Japanese provide more teachers in order to try to equalize academic performance within Japan in the United States instead for example in California the United States sends fewer teachers to areas with poor academic performance which means that the poor the uneducated become even more uneducated which is bad sign for the United States”

0.55

Different people benefit from different mental health interventions; what works for one person (meditation) might not work for another; some people benefit more from sports than meditation, so solutions should be individualized rather than universal.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“I wouldn't comment anything as a kind of panacea that oh this is the solution to all the world problem many people are different different things work that different for work for different people if somebody finds that meditation doesn't help but sports works much better then invest in that”

0.55

Comparative mental health claims between traditional and modern societies lack solid data because we don't have rigorous measurement tools for either population—therefore the temptation to claim traditional societies have better mental health may not be supported.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Jared Diamond

“all which means that we we just don't have the daughter I'm tempted to say that mental health is much better in traditional societies but that may not”

0.55

Mental health measurement in traditional New Guinea is difficult due to lack of standardized assessment tools and interview scales; physicians cannot rigorously measure mental health conditions; therefore claims about comparative mental health between traditional and modern societies lack solid data foundation.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Jared Diamond

“so I asked physicians out there what is mental health why in New Guinea we don't don't know rigorously what mental health is life because we don't have the the tools for interviewing New Guineans about mental health scales”

0.52

New Guineans, who had no writing or cell phones and relied on face-to-face communication exclusively, developed superior social skills and negotiation ability—five-year-old New Guineans are skilled at bargaining, and untraveled village negotiators regularly outbargain international oil company lawyers.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Jared Diamond

“all communication in New Guinea is face-to-face its most communication for us here is not face to face it's words on a screen but New Guineans communicate with each other always face to face and the result is that they're very good at understanding other people five year old New Guineans are good at bargaining New Guinea villagers who've never been out of their village can out bog and oil company lawyers who come in from around the world”

0.52

Major crises accelerate dangerous technological development (as seen in World Wars) because during crises people are willing to take risks with extreme technologies; climate crisis will likely accelerate rather than slow AI and biotechnology development and reduce precautions because elites view crisis as requiring extreme solutions.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“a major crisis will only accelerate dangerous technological developments like we saw in the two world wars that as long as things are relatively calm people don't like to take risks with extreme technologies but if say a major that we don't get a handle over the climate crisis and thinks that TV right rapidly this will cause people to look for extreme solutions and therefore I think that a climate crisis will not slow down developments in AI and biotechnology it is likely only to accelerate them and to cause people to not take to give up the precautions oh we are facing existential crisis anyway so yes it's very dangerous to start experimenting in genetic engineering it's very dangerous to develop these new super AI but we are in a crisis so we have to do it”

0.52

Lack of smartphone ownership functions as a status symbol in modern society because it signals the person is important enough to be unreachable, whereas smartphone ownership indicates one has a boss (professional or family) who needs constant access to you.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“in a way not having a smartphone is kind of the new status symbol I mean I don't have a smartphone and you know if you if you don't have a smartphone you're really important somebody else is carrying of course the smartphone for you... it means that you are unreachable which was always the ultimate status symbol in a way if you have a smartphone it means that you have a boss either a professional boss at work or maybe a family boss like your children or your parents whoever needs to know where you are all the time”

0.52

The AI revolution is approximately 4-5 years old and will unfold gradually over time; it takes considerable time for breakthroughs in laboratories to impact factories and offices, so job automation will be a cascade of ever-bigger disruptions as AI improves rather than a single discrete event.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“of course nobody knows exactly the timetable but the key elements to consider is first of all the AI revolution is something like four or five years old it takes time it's not that within it one of the other that the distance from the laboratory were the breakthrough are being made till it impacts the factory of the office it takes time... so we will see it unfolding and not just in one year it will be a cascade of ever bigger disruptions because AI is nowhere near its full potential so it's not like we'll have a big AI revolution say in 2020 or 2025 and then we have a couple of rough years and then everything settles down no we are about to eat a slope which is will get worse and worse as AI becomes better and better”

0.50

PISA test results show China's 10% worst students score as high as Brazil's 10% best students, indicating vast educational inequality and advantage created by China's system that has lifted 750 million people out of poverty.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Moderator

“I was in China until two days ago I spent four months in China this year and I was really shocked to see the Pisa results for shine China Pisa is the global exam that measures the grades and the 10% worst students in China are equal to the 10% best students in Brazil for instance and this is really shocking and China as you guys know has lifted 750 million people out of poverty which is the largest emergence of a population in history and education played a really important role on that”

0.48

Global elites are not sufficiently alarmed about climate and ecological crises (either consciously or subconsciously) because they believe they will have resources and technological expertise to protect themselves from worst outcomes, so they can afford to not act urgently.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“I think part of the reason why elites in the world today are not doing enough to combat the climate crisis the ecological crisis is that either consciously or at least subconsciously in the back of their mind they say yes that's a big problem but not when the flood comes we will build a technological arc yes the poor people in the favelas they will suffer but not us we will probably have the resources and the technological expertise to protect ourselves from the worst outcomes and this is why the elite are not as alarmed as they should be”

0.48

Jared Diamond's MacArthur Fellowship (1985), which provided 5 years of unrestricted funding, initially triggered serious depression because it communicated that the foundation believed he was capable of more than gallbladder research and was not living up to his potential.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jared Diamond

“I received a fellowship called the MacArthur Fellowship MacArthur fellowships are batch of fellowships for which you don't apply and they they give you five years of support to do anything that you want I got a phone call from the head of the McArthur fellowship program... and at first I was highly excited because there was lots of money and the result then surprised that paradoxically was that for one of only two times in my adult life I've got seriously depressed really depressed but one of the those few times was after I got the announcement of MacArthur award because of when what it meant to me was that the foundation thought that I was capable of doing more than gallbladder research that I had not been living up to my potential”

0.48

Educational systems must teach what world will look like 20 years from now, not what the world looks like today; six-year-old students in school today should learn what's relevant to 2040, not 2020, requiring serious thinking about future state.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“when we talk about Christ's developing crisis which will hit in ten years twenty years thirty years the educational system is really the forefront of all that because what you teach kids today in school should be relevant to the world of twenty years from now not to today if you're a six-year-old students in a school what you learn should be relevant to 2040 not to 2020 so this is maybe the first arena or front when we have to take very seriously the question how would the world look like in 2014”

0.48

During 1993 Los Angeles Rodney King riots, police placed yellow plastic tape across main Beverly Hills boulevards; this tape would not have stopped rioters if they reached Beverly Hills, but riots petered out before reaching wealthy areas; conditions that spawned riots have worsened, so next riots are likely to reach Beverly Hills and wake rich residents to consequences.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jared Diamond

“in 1993 Los Angeles is a city with unequal distribution of wealth they are the rich areas like Beverly Hills and there are poor areas like downtown and when Marie and I... we arrived in Chicago... we turned on the telly what had happened was the the Rodney King riots... the Rodney King riots were riding that broke out in the downtown area of Los Angeles... there was concern that the riots would spread to devily hills what could the police do to protect the rich people in Beverly Hills if the riot has started rampaging at the Beverly Hills there was absolutely nothing that the police could do... the police actually did do was... if the police want to pose on the street they put a yellow band a plastic police tape across the street and so the police put yellow bands a plastic police police tape across the main boulevards and Beverly Hills... naturally if the rioters that spilled out into Beverly Hills the police state would not have held them up in fact the Rodney King riots petered out without reaching Beverly Hills but the conditions that spewed the rather Rodney King riots have gotten worse in Los Angeles and my expectation is that it's just a matter of time before there are more riots and the next time there are big riots and Los Angeles the rioters will come to Beverly Hills”

0.48

In history, the rich typically cause crises that poor people pay for most heavily, as seen in 2008 financial crisis where bankers were least hurt and people in distant unrelated places paid most; in catastrophic scenarios, the vast majority of poor people are not tribal societies with survival skills but factory workers in cities who will suffer more than wealthy people in San Francisco or London.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“one of the features of history is often that Easter is terribly unfair and it often happens in history that the rich caused problems that then the poor pay for and the rich are maybe hurt a little but they are in the position to survive it better like we saw in the financial crisis that the bankers who caused much of the crisis they were least hurt by it and people in far-off places that had nothing to do with the responsibility they pay the most now I think that in a catastrophic scenario like that the kneestr will be a huge advantage to people who are in a way closest to the Stone Age but the vast majority of poor people in developing country are not these tribal societies which still have the survival skills they are the people who work saying the textile mills and they never found they don't know how to produce texture they don't know how to produce stone - they know how to drive two hours in a bus to some polluted factory and work there for 10-12 hours and then take the bus back home and in case of a major crisis they are likely to suffer even more than the rich people say in San Francisco or in London”

0.48

Creating sanctuaries—times and places where people (especially teenagers) are completely unreachable and cannot be contacted—is necessary for mental health; bullying and stress that previously ended at home now continue 24/7 via smartphones, eliminating refuge.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“creating like we mentioned before sanctuaries that you have these times and places when you can really relax I mean again if you're a kid in school so previously something happened in school which was very stressful like other kids bullying you when you went back home at least you had sanctuary in your home now you don't have sanctuary the bullying can continue 24 hours a day VR all the screens and smartphones and so forth”

0.47

Brazil has higher unemployment (12%) than the US (3.7%) despite being ranked low on automation readiness, suggesting automation is not currently the main driver of unemployment and high-automation countries show rising labor costs, contradicting the view that automation is replacing human work.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Moderator

“right now we don't really see it happening so if you look at the United States which has one of the highest levels of automation employment rate is unemployment rate is actually three point seven percent now while Brazil that ranks really low in the automation readiness index by the economist has a twelve percent unemployment rate right now so is it really happening is this something that is going to happen in the future because what I'm afraid is that I we don't see right now any signs that automation is actually replacing human work and actually these most automated countries the cost of labor is actually going up”

0.45

Reinventing oneself at age 20 is already difficult; having to reinvent at 30, 40, 50 across multiple career cycles requires psychological stamina that many people do not currently possess, so mental dysfunction burden is likely to increase unless countermeasures are taken.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“gun box is a job market change is always stressful and as you get older it usually becomes more difficult so inventing yourself at age 20 is very difficult but to reinvent yourself again at age 30 again at age 40 again at age 50 this is something that many people just at present don't have the psychological stamina to do so there are the burden of stress and mental dysfunction is likely only to increase unless we take countermeasures”

0.45

Tests in school teach students that every answer is right or wrong and every question has a right answer, which frames reality as having predetermined correct answers; 21st century key skill should instead be how to deal with unknown by gathering reliable information and understanding one's method, not retrieving pre-learned answers.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“tests in school so you learn throughout the year certain things and you have the impression that every answer has a right and every question has a right answer in the test at the end of the year asked you and you need to give the right answers and this gets you in in the frame of mind that yes there are these right answers out there and I just need to learn them whereas especially for the 21st century the key is how to deal with the unknown so the best test at the end of the you you learn something during the geography the test at the end of the you shouldn't be about something you already know it should be or given a new question in geography and the issue is how do I go about gathering information distinguishing reliable from unreliable information what is the method that I'm using this would be the most important skill for the 21st century”

0.45

Most people in traditional New Guinea appear happier than Western populations; loneliness endemic to Western society doesn't exist in New Guinea where people spend lives with those they grew up with.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Jared Diamond

“my first impression is that most people are happier certainly there the loneliness that is endemic in epidemic in our society doesn't exist in New Guinea where you spend your life with the people that that you grew up with”

0.44

The birth of Jared Diamond's twin sons (1987) triggered recognition that their future world in 2050 would depend on history and geography, not gallbladder physiology, motivating his shift to writing books for general audiences.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Jared Diamond

“the second wakeup was the birth of my twin sons in 1987 recognizing that that the year 2050 when I certainly will be dead my son's own can be alive in 2050 and their world their future is not going to depend upon gallbladders but it's going to depend upon history and geography so that those two things were the stimulus for my starting to write the book for the general public to convey the excitement of science and what we can do about it to the general public”

0.44

Reading 'Guns, Germs, and Steel' revealed to a PhD student doing medieval military history that one could write scientific, macro-perspective books for general audiences—that science is not limited to either popular fiction or narrow academic monographs but can bridge both.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“I was doing my PhD in Oxford on you know a typical peach the history subject which was the memoirs of soldiers from the late Middle Ages and early modern period not the stuff of bestsellers and in my spare time I read Guns Germs and Steel and I said to myself hey you can actually write such books and it can be scientific books it's not like the world is divided into these I don't know science fiction and and thrillers and things like that and then these tiny professional scientific monographs about very very limited subject you can actually be scientists who writes from a macro perspective”

0.44

Rich people in the US perceive they can currently escape consequences of global crises and other people will suffer; they take problems seriously only when they perceive personal safety threat, as demonstrated by 1993 Los Angeles Rodney King riots spreading from downtown to wealthy Beverly Hills.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Jared Diamond

“it is true flagrantly in the United States that lots of rich people perceive correctly that at present and for the foreseeable future they can escape the consequences of bad things going on in the world and other people are going to to suffer there's a question when will rich people in the United States start taking problems seriously and a bitter answer is they will start taking problems seriously when they see that their own personal safety is a threat”

0.44

Shutting down phone is not adequate solution to FOMO (fear of missing out) because the fear remains; important friends' events are happening among your peer group and not being present increases danger for social acceptance.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“just shutting down the phone is not even that is hardly a solution because then you have the form or the fear of missing out you know that so many important things are happening among your friends and if you are not there it increases the danger for you”

0.43

Key educational challenge for the 21st century is teaching people how to keep learning and changing throughout their lifetime as job markets become volatile and jobs appear, disappear, and change; current educational systems aren't built for this and instead teach students that every question has one right answer.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Yuval Noah Harari

“as the job mark is going to be more and more volatile that jobs appear disappear change and people will have to basically reinvent themselves several times during their lifetime the old model that you'll most as a young person you mostly learn and then as an older person you mostly rely on the skills and knowledge you acquired in your early years this is going to be an obsolete model you'll have to retrain yourself reinvent yourself repeatedly and and our educational systems in most of the world are not built for that the key skill is not learning any particular historical fact or geographical fact of physical equation the key skill is how to keep learning and changing throughout your life”

0.41

The situation regarding acceptance of facts in the current US administration is getting worse rather than better, characterized by official language of 'alternative facts' and political living made from denying reality.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Jared Diamond

“the trend at present under the current administration in acceptance of fat facts is is backwards the the current administration talks about alternative facts or fake facts it's making a political living out of denying reality”

0.37

Lego/Harris Group research comparing US and Chinese children (ages 8-12) on career aspirations found Chinese children want to be astronauts while US children want to be YouTubers, illustrating different cultural ambitions and expectations.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Moderator

“I also saw recently a research done on behalf of Lego by the Harris group they asked United States Kids and Chinese kids from 8 to 12 years what they wanted to be when they grew up and the answer of the Chinese kids were astronauts in the answer of the us kids were youtubers”

0.29

Jared Diamond experienced depression and identifies it as important challenge most people face at some point; his experience with mental health is relevant to understanding broader patterns of depression in society.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Moderator

“Jared you mentioned that you had to cope with depression and I think many people actually most people will have to deal with that at any point in their lives”

0.19

Survey by data polling company in Brazil (July of current year) found 7% of Brazilians believe the earth is flat and 4% are unsure, meaning approximately 22 million Brazilians either disbelieve or question the roundness of the earth.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — Yuval Noah Harari and Jared Diamond in conversation [VLXHnGVp7ZU]

“there is a Brazilian Paul company called data folia and they asked Brazilians whether they think the earth is flat or round and it's funny because seven percent of Brazilians as July of this year think that the earth is flat and four percent I'm not sure so we are talking here about twenty two million people actually believe in in Brazil that the earth is either flat or they don't really know how it is”