
Tavi Costa: Gold's Revaluation - This Could Be History in the Making
What this covers
Tom Bodger of Palisade Radio talks with Tavi Costa, a portfolio manager at Crescat Capital, about gold, silver, mining equities and the dollar, starting from the question of whether technical overbought signals in gold should worry anyone. Costa's answer is that debt imbalances, not chart positioning, are driving the move. He treats the bearish calls as a chance to act. The conversation then moves from the mechanics of Treasury financing to portfolio positioning.
The policy section is the most distinctive. Costa links gold revaluation to the TGA (Treasury General Account)) and Treasury buybacks, and cites Scott Bessent saying the Treasury has tools of its own if the Fed does not cooperate. He compares the current approach to 1940s rate suppression, including changes to the SLR (Supplementary Leverage Ratio)) to push banks toward buying Treasuries. He also argues that the market watches the wrong part of the curve, since 10- and 30-year bonds are a small share of total debt. A notable personal turn is his abandonment of the dollar milkshake theory. He now argues that US interest burdens relative to GDP will force deeper cuts than elsewhere. Europe's burden is higher still, which he concedes, and he compares today's dollar valuation to the Plaza Accord era. He also separates a structural dollar downtrend from loss of reserve status.
The remaining ground is the investment case. Costa says miners have beaten US equities over ten years yet lag gold badly, and he recalls their divergence from the NASDAQ collapse in the early 2000s. He notes mining's fall from about 20% of US GDP in the 1960s to 0.4%. Other threads include onshoring, copper's role in AI infrastructure, central bank buying by China, Russia and Turkey, and the Gold-to-silver ratio as an argument for silver. He rejects precise market timing and ends with a rotation toward energy.
Costa argues that gold revaluation is a strategic necessity for the US government to manage debt through Treasury buybacks and collateral expansion, representing the beginning of a structural dollar downtrend and creating exceptional opportunities in gold, miners, silver, and emerging markets.
- Gold revaluation increases TGA collateral to enable Treasury buybacks without explicit QE, allowing debt yield suppression
- US interest payment to GDP forces rate cuts beyond other economies, structurally weakening the dollar long-term
- Mining stocks are at 2001 valuation levels despite gold at record highs, with margins supporting prices even at $2,500/oz
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Mining represented approximately 20% of US GDP in the 1960s but now represents only 0.4% of GDP, indicating a dramatic decline in economic importance that must change as the world rebalances and onshores production.
“back in the 1960s or so, uh it used to be close to 20% of GDP mining alone and now it's 0.4% of GDP.”
Large central banks including China, Russia, Turkey, and South Asian emerging markets have been substantial buyers of gold, benefiting from higher gold prices.
“I have my own suspicion of who is probably buying and large central banks we've seen China Russia Turkey all sorts of places that have been um in other South Asian economies and even the emerging markets in general have been large buyers of gold itself.”
Gold miners have outperformed US equities on a total return basis (including dividends) over the last 10 years, but have not outperformed gold itself, demonstrating they remain deeply undervalued relative to their underlying asset base.
“the gold miners have outperformed US equities, dividends included, in the last 10 years. Did you know that? That's insane. Not a lot of people know this. Everyone likes to buy the US equity markets, but miners have actually outperformed them. What they have not outperformed is gold. And that just means how cheap they still are.”
The 1940s playbook used similar policies to the current administration's approach, including changes to bank capital requirements (SLRs) and influencing banks to become Treasury buyers, establishing historical precedent for current policy direction.
“You know, if you look at the 1940s playbook, uh we did see a lot of policies uh that are very similar to the attempt today. you know, the you know, this change of the uh supplementary uh um uh the SLRs on the banks and allowing the banks or really not allowing influencing the banks to become buyers of treasuries. Again, this this is all stuff that we saw in the 1940s”
Nobody knows how to time the market perfectly, and trying to do so causes people to lose big opportunities—this is not how wealth builders like Warren Buffett operate, they focus on buying cheap and building value.
“Nobody knows how to time the market perfectly like that. You don't have to. I think that's a that's a that's overdoing. Um, I think you're going to lose a lot of big opportunities by doing that. I don't think Warren Buffett built his wealth by trying to figure those things out... just look at the people that have done anything important with money in the past. tell you that there's it's not it's not about breakouts and breakdowns. It's about owning something cheap and building value”
Europe faces higher interest payment to GDP costs than the US (double or more), and some countries face triple or quadruple US rates, meaning Europe has less capacity to lower rates, making this comparison a critical lens for understanding dollar weakness.
“All I'm saying is is that when you look at how much it's costing European countries to pay their debt versus the US, we're talking double. We're talking maybe even higher than that depending on the country. Some countries is triple, quadruple.”
The US is heavily reliant on imports of metals and has outsourced smelters and refineries to China, creating strategic vulnerability that policy makers will address through onshoring and domestic mining capacity development.
“we're so reliant on imports of metals import of uh even you know the situation when you talk about uh smelters and refineries that come from China uh and the fact that we're so reliant on those things know these conversations are just getting started and and I believe we're going to see some big changes along those lines”
Copper benefits tremendously from AI infrastructure development, as copper is at the core of electrical systems required for data centers, making copper a key AI infrastructure play.
“we know the case for copper in a world where u there's so much push towards an AI arms race. um you know how do you do that without also having um a place where uh you know copper really really benefits tremendously and so it's right at the core of all these developments”
The dollar milkshake theory has played out beautifully, attracting too much capital into US equities and dollar-based assets, with MSCI World now 70% weighted to US and central banks holding US equities including technology companies on their balance sheets, creating an unsustainable concentration.
“The dollar milkshake theory has played out beautifully. Uh it has attracted too much capital into the US US equities or US-based equities, US dollar-based equities and and and and bonds and corporate bonds and treasuries have done extremely well over the last few years because of that influx of capital from outside. You look at the MCI world where 70% weight on the US. Uh you look at uh most central banks even have uh holdings of US equities in their in their balance sheet, you know, including uh technology companies and so forth.”
In the early 2000s, while NASDAQ fell nearly 90%, gold miners diverged sharply and went up substantially, providing alpha and showing miners' negative correlation to tech in equity downturns.
“you can look at for instance the early 2000s the very beginning of the early 2000s the miners got caught up on that selloff and then immediately diverged from the equity markets of which NASDAQ and some other technology companies went down close to 90 plus%. And equity markets in mining companies actually went up substantially from that. So, talk about divergence. Talk about alpha.”
Central banks including China, Russia, Turkey, South Asian economies, and emerging markets generally have been large buyers of gold, suggesting they understand the strategic value of accumulation that the market may be underappreciating.
“large central banks we've seen China Russia Turkey all sorts of places that have been um in other South Asian economies and even the emerging markets in general have been large buyers of of gold itself.”
Mining stocks have not outperformed gold over the long term; they have underperformed gold significantly, which demonstrates how undervalued miners remain even after outperforming US equities over the past decade.
“the gold miners have outperformed US equities, dividends included, in the last 10 years. Did you know that? That's insane. Not a lot of people know this. Everyone likes to buy the US equity markets, but miners have actually outperformed them. What they have not outperformed is gold. And that just means how cheap they still are.”
The US government changed the Supplementary Leverage Ratio (SLR) on banks and is influencing them to become buyers of Treasuries, a policy similar to those employed in the 1940s, representing a shift toward Treasury-directed bank policy reminiscent of post-WWII interest rate suppression.
“If you look at the 1940s playbook, uh we did see a lot of policies uh that are very similar to the attempt today. you know, the you know, this change of the uh supplementary uh um uh the SLRs on the banks and allowing the banks or really not allowing influencing the banks to become buyers of treasuries. Again, this this is all stuff that we saw in the 1940s”
The post-WWII US gold sales were insane policy, and the subsequent reduction in gold backing ratio was caused by increase in money supply and government debt growth, not necessarily depletion of reserves.
“after World War II the US actually sold a bunch of their gold reserves uh which was insane policy uh that happened. Uh but also you did see the fact that the money supply or the government that increased substantially as shown in the white on the white line of that chart and so that was actually what caused uh the reduction.”
Costa previously believed the 'dollar milkshake theory' but has changed his view because US interest payments to GDP are substantially higher than other economies, forcing the US to lower rates more than other central banks, which will weaken the dollar relative to peers.
“I've changed my view on this and the main reason why I changed my view is because uh the interest payment to GDP on the US versus these other economies is substantially higher and I think that the US is going to be forced to lower rates a lot more than other economies and as we see that that's going to have a reflection on the dollar.”
Current bearish signals from technical and macro analysts should not be treated with caution; instead, this is a time to be active and capitalize on the validation of a long-term thesis that debt imbalances, not technical positioning, are driving gold prices.
“No, I don't think this is a time to be cautious. It's a time to be busy and it's we're seeing the validation of a long-term thesis playing right in front of us.”
The US government faces a dilemma requiring it to lower rates at all costs, and market focus on 10-year and 30-year yields is misguided because these bonds represent only 13-15% of total debt; the real pressure point is the short end (2-year, 5-year, 7-year yields).
“the US government is in a situation almost a major dilemma of which it has to lower rates at all costs there is this kind of obsession from markets about the 10year the 30-year yield which are completely meaningless in in the sense of where the debt is right that that only represents 13 to 15% of the debt, right? So, where is the big thick moment here of the debt situation is is really on the notes and and the T bills. And so, we need to lower the 2-year yield, the 5-year yield, the seven-year yield.”
Scott Bessent indicated in a Bloomberg interview that if the Fed does not cooperate, the Treasury has its own toolkit including treasury buybacks and instructing banks to buy treasuries, implying Treasury-directed policy independent of Fed action.
“Scott Basson was in an interview with a Bloomberg uh reporter in Argentina and where he talked about this. He talked about look if the Fed doesn't play ball if don't see much of a cooperation from JPAL of which Trump has said he might even fire him and if that happens accelerates all this process but let's just assume that there's some stubbornness and some issues about uh firing him for the next couple months and so um how is that going to play out? Well, he said we have our own toolkit. we have our own things that we can do. He's referring to specifically about treasury buybacks. He's referring to instructing the banks to buy treasuries and all these other things.”
A structural downtrend for the dollar does not mean the dollar loses reserve currency status; rather, the dollar is simply too overvalued and has been going up for too long, making rebalancing inevitable but not terminal.
“the discussion that usually gets to is the extreme things that when you start talking about the dollar of the will the dollar lose its reserve currency status and all sorts of things and that's completely uh in my view meaningless relative to the opportunity and the trend that we likely to see. There have been several multiple uh downward trends on the dollar that did not cause it to lose its reserve currency status. Uh the dollar is simply too overvalued. That's it. You know, it's way too overvalued. Has been going up for too long.”
Technical analysts suggesting the gold-to-silver ratio will go from 110 to 115 rather than mean reverting to historical levels like 70-50 are trying to time the market perfectly, which is impossible and causes investors to miss major opportunities like the silver mine acquisition at $16 per ounce.
“Nobody knows how to time the market perfectly like that. You don't have to. I think that's a that's a that's overdoing. Um, I think you're going to lose a lot of big opportunities by doing that. I don't think Warren Buffett built his wealth by trying to figure those things out. And uh it it kind of annoys me because I I do think that it unfortunately messes with the crowd. It messes with majority of the retail investors that can end up getting caught up into those narratives that are just completely meaningless.”
The greatest way to build wealth is owning something cheap and building value over time, as demonstrated by successful investors, rather than trying to time market breakouts and breakdowns.
“there's it's not it's not about breakouts and breakdowns. It's about owning something cheap and building value and you know to me that's what comes down to.”
Gold revaluation is critical to allow the Treasury to conduct treasury buybacks and suppress interest rates by increasing collateral value in the Treasury General Account (TGA), effectively creating non-QE liquidity.
“Why am I saying this with gold? Because the revaluation of gold topic is absolutely critical to allow the Treasury to do a few things to help uh lower yields.”
Gold revaluation is critical to allowing the Treasury to lower yields because higher gold prices increase collateral value in the TGA account, enabling Treasury buybacks to suppress interest rates without explicit QE.
“Why am I saying this with gold? Because the revaluation of gold topic is absolutely critical to allow the Treasury to do a few things to help uh lower yields.”
The Fed Traded Weighted Dollar Index is now as overvalued as it was during the Plaza Accord, a coordinated international effort to weaken the dollar, raising the question of whether the Mara Lago Accord represents a modern equivalent currency coordination.
“we're almost as overvalued or in some cases depending on how you look at if you look at the Fed traded weighted uh index of the dollar we're now as overvalued as we were back in the Plaza accord that was a coordinated act we saw countries coming along and saying well let's reduce the value of the dollar what if this is part of the Mara Lago accord”
This is not a time to be cautious but rather a time to be active, as we are seeing validation of a long-term thesis playing out in real time with gold's big move reflecting debt imbalances rather than technical overbought conditions or crowding.
“No, I don't think this is a time to be cautious. It's a time to be busy and we're seeing the validation of a long-term thesis playing right in front of us. There is an inclination that is natural of a lot of investors to see this big move in gold and think that this is a correction ahead of us or saying things are overbought that it's a very crowded position. And all those things are probably true. But there are moments in history where we see these moves in gold that we've seen in other times that have nothing to do with technical reasons that have nothing to do with positioning has everything to do with the magnitude of the debt imbalances we have.”
Mining is critically important for functioning global economy through onshoring, addressing housing affordability through construction, building industrial capabilities to avoid China dependency, and handling the tripling/doubling of electricity consumption from AI.
“these are industries that you know take um have been have been in in uh part of our economy globally for a very long time. They're critically important for uh to function uh the the world and uh we're talking about onshoring uh and uh we're talking about uh the the you know issues with with uh even affordability of housing. uh there's clearly a need for a lot of construction to happen in the world. Uh a world that is trying to avoid dependency with China... electricity consumption about to double triple depending uh the situation with artificial intelligence”
Investment banks and sell-side analysts play a critical role as the front door for larger capital allocators, but they tend to underestimate mining industry potential because the industry uses ultra-conservative metrics for modeling future cash flows.
“the analysts play a very important role especially investment banks because they are the ones that are the kind of the front door of the bigger allocators that don't understand the industry and are first looking for those guys to be presenting to them some ideas and how they view the market and I think that they underestimate a lot of times uh because of the how the industry has been built and because of the how the industry has been forced to use ultra-conservative metrics to uh look at future cash flows and so forth and it hurts those industry uh this industry because it's you know essentially we are sandbagging in a big way in my view a lot of the the the fundamental change that is likely to come in this industry.”
Energy has been suffering from commentary around Trump's 'drill baby drill' rhetoric, but energy is equally strategically and geopolitically important as gold, and oil has not reflected those geopolitical concerns as much as gold has.
“the energy space uh to me has been uh suffering tremendously from uh you know, commentaries from Trump and uh and the situation of uh drill baby drill and so forth. And uh look, I I am of the view that there's nothing more is strategically uh geopolitically than oil and gold. And gold has been reflecting a lot of those those issues of deglobalization but oil is not”
At current gold prices already marked to market, US gold reserves back only approximately 2% of total US Treasury debt outstanding, compared to 17% in the 1970s and 40% pre-World War II, suggesting historical gold prices of $20,000-$50,000 per ounce if reserves achieved historical backing ratios.
“this chart is actually already marked to market. In other words, it's already using the current gold price and it's just putting into perspective because it's ridiculous marking at $40 an ounce. So, um I guess this is just showing you even if we mark the market, we only own about 2% of the total amount of debt outstanding.”
The administration's objectives are to fix both the trade balance deficit (through dollar weakening) and fiscal deficit (through rate lowering), and these two goals are combined to create conditions for investment reallocation to emerging markets.
“clearly the administration has a goal which is which is to um fix the deficits. Two things, the trade balance and and the fiscal. And the trade balance needed to be fixed by uh weakening the dollar. And the the fiscal side needs to be fixed by uh lowering rates. And they're, you know, they're combined. Those two things are are are basically what's going to create the green light uh to invest in emerging markets and all sorts of things in my opinion.”
The US has opted out of the gold buying spree and will probably be coming back either quietly or more openly; this is inevitable.
“my point is, uh, I do think that the US is has been opting out of the buying spree of gold and it's probably going to be, uh, coming back either either quietly or, uh, or more openly. And, uh, and I think that's inevitable.”
Mining stocks are extremely underowned currently, and the industry is critically important for functioning of the world, with onshoring efforts, housing affordability issues, and electricity consumption doubling or tripling making mining essential.
“I think it's extremely underowned...These are industries that you know take um have been have been in uh part of our economy globally for a very long time. They're critically important for uh to function uh the the world and uh we're talking about onshoring uh and uh we're talking about uh the the you know issues with with uh even affordability of housing. uh there's clearly a need for a lot of construction to happen in the world. Uh a world that is trying to avoid dependency with China and other economies and uh industrial cap you know capabilities need to be built up. We have electricity consumption about to double triple depending on uh the situation with artificial intelligence and you know we're not ready for that. So mining is going to be a critical part of the economy.”
NASDAQ has recently declined while copper has risen, which is historically associated with inflationary regimes where countries secure commodities geopolitically regardless of spot prices, and copper benefits from AI electricity demand.
“have you noticed the fact that NASDAQ has been coming down recently and copper has been going up? And how would anybody explain that outside of going back to other periods and saying, "Whoa, hold on a second. In inflationary regimes, you can see metals rise as markets fall. And that's that's because countries are securing metals or they don't care about, you know, that, you know, price that is on the screen right now. They just want to secure things uh from a geopolitical standpoint. And we know the case for copper in a world where u there's so much push towards an AI arms race. um you know how do you do that without also having um a place where uh you know copper really really benefits tremendously”
A structural downtrend for the dollar does not mean the dollar loses reserve currency status—this is meaningless relative to the real opportunity, which is that the dollar is simply too overvalued and has been going up for too long.
“the discussion that usually gets to is the extreme things that when you start talking about the dollar of the will the dollar lose its reserve currency status and all sorts of things and that's completely uh in my view meaningless relative to the opportunity and the trend that we likely to see... The dollar is simply too overvalued. That's it. You know, it's way too overvalued. Has been going up for too long.”
Currently, US gold reserves back only about 2% of total Treasury debt outstanding, compared to 17% in the 1970s and 40% before WWII, suggesting potential for gold prices of $20,000-$50,000 per ounce if revaluation approaches historical backing ratios.
“marking at $40 an ounce. So, um I guess this is just showing you even if we mark the market, we only own about 2% of the total amount of debt outstanding... back in the 70s we saw somewhere close to 17% of the treasury outstanding was backed by gold and back in the 40s before the World War II was actually close to 40%... you start seeing numbers like 20,000 $50,000 an ounce.”
Costa has changed his view on the dollar milkshake theory because the US interest payment to GDP ratio is substantially higher than other economies, forcing the US to lower rates much more than other countries, which will pressure the dollar.
“I've changed my view on this and the main reason why I changed my view is because uh the interest payment to GDP on the US versus these other economies is substantially higher and I think that the US is going to be forced to lower rates a lot more than other economies and as we see that that's going to have a reflection on the dollar.”
Japan's experience shows that when a country lowers its interest payment relative to GDP through rate cuts, its currency collapses—and if the US has to do the same thing, that is the lens through which people should be analyzing current events.
“Some countries is triple, quadruple. Japan is quadruple, right? I mean, Japan is is is paying less than 1% of its GDP. So and and think about the Japan case you know what caused their currency during that process of lowering their interest payment relative to GDP collapse their currency their currency is is you know is in the toilet because of that what happens if the US has to do that that's the lenses I think people need to be looking into this uh right now”
The US government faces a major dilemma requiring it to lower rates at all costs, and the obsession with 10-year and 30-year yields is misplaced because they represent only 13-15% of total debt, while the real debt pressure is on the 2-year, 5-year, and 7-year notes and T-bills.
“the US government is in a situation almost a major dilemma of which it has to lower rates at all costs there is this kind of obsession from markets about the 10year the 30-year yield which are completely meaningless in in the sense of where the debt is right that that only represents 13 to 15% of the debt, right? So, where is the big thick moment here of the debt situation is is really on the notes and and the T bills. And so, we need to lower the 2-year yield, the 5-year yield, the seven-year yield.”
There is room for a hybrid venture capital approach in the mining space that can combine the discipline of venture investing with mining opportunities where companies have strong results but haven't been rewarded by markets.
“I think there's room for somebody to build something like a hybrid um venture capital approach in the mining space. There's companies that put out great results and and have just not been rewarded for that”
Sovereign wealth fund development, potential state ownership of strategic industries like US Steel and TikTok, and unlocking value from underdeveloped US natural resources represent alternative or complementary forms of asset monetization.
“one side of it is the the sovereign wealth fund which is the monetizing um quote that he said was referring to that first and foremost. Uh and you've got Tik Tok and all US steel producers. you know, they just block US steel from being purchased by uh a Japanese firm and and and uh because they don't want a foreign owner of this uh you know, such a protected industry that we need to.”
The mining industry is complex and was not considered sexy, but complexity doesn't prevent sectors from becoming popular again—the best marketing is making money, as demonstrated by crypto becoming "interesting" despite most people not understanding it.
“for those who think that a complex industry can never become uh you know you know uh quote unquote sexy again I disagree you know I disagree because there's nothing better for marketing than making money. when people start making money everything looks sexy and you know hence the crypto industry know a lot of people say they understand cryp I still don't understand a lot of things in the crypto market I I still think that a lot of people that say they understand it they don't but because people have made money in that they think they you know it's it's really interesting”
The gold-to-silver ratio recently hit 110, representing an extreme undervaluation of silver compared to historical patterns, with only a few periods in history where it reached such extremes.
“the gold to silver ratio recently hit 110. There's only a few other examples in history where it got that high.”
The gold-to-oil ratio is at the second highest level in history, demonstrating that mining margins have expanded significantly.
“The gold to oil ratio is at the second high highest level in history. So margins are have really expanded.”
Tariffs will likely stay but at substantially lower levels than currently presented, and markets may view tariff reductions as positive news clarifying uncertainty rather than as policy failure.
“I do think the tariffs will stay, but also are a huge part of it is um you know certainly a strategy of of of uh of trying to fix this chronic debt or I should say chronic uh deficit on the trade balance aspect uh in a big way and trying to uh perhaps create some level of agreement with these countries the so-called Mara Lagua accord and so forth uh which would be another way of restructuring the debt uh by pressuring these countries through the tariffs and uh by no means I'm saying the tariffs are going to go away but I also think that the levels have been presented are also going to be potentially substantially lower than what's being shown and the market might even see this as positive uh news and and uh more clarity on uh this uncertainty that that people are seeing in in equity markets in the US.”
Brazilian government bonds currently yield approximately 20% with a capped strong dollar and capped interest rate environment, creating positive carry in emerging market assets that people are ignoring due to historical risk perceptions that are likely to be removed.
“If you look at government bonds in Brazil now they're paying you know almost 20% yields right now. Um so there is a positive carry in most of these assets that people are completely ignoring because of the the the risk historical risk when when you look ahead those risks have been are likely to be removed. we're likely to be a cap dollar and a cap yield environment and getting paid for it.”
Costa suspects the US may actually be accumulating gold while everyone is bearish due to technical signals and positioning, and this would not shock him given the policy necessity.
“it wouldn't shock me at all if the US is actually being accumulating gold while everyone is being bearish here and uh because of the positioning, because of the overbought signals.”
Tariffs are part of a strategy to fix the chronic trade deficit through potentially creating agreements like the Mara Lago accord to restructure debt with trading partners, and while tariff levels may be lower than initially proposed, they will remain and ultimately benefit by providing clarity to markets.
“Well, I do think the tariffs will stay, but also are a huge part of it is um you know certainly a strategy of of of uh of trying to fix this chronic debt or I should say chronic uh deficit on the trade balance aspect uh in a big way and trying to uh perhaps create some level of agreement with these countries the so-called Mara Lagua accord and so forth uh which would be another way of restructuring the debt uh by pressuring these countries through the tariffs and uh by no means I'm saying the tariffs are going to go away but I also think that the levels have been presented are also going to be potentially substantially lower than what's being shown”
A stubborn Fed that refuses to cut rates could cause short-end T-bills and 3-month rates to be too high, potentially causing a recession that would result in 2-year yield collapse.
“you have a stubborn Fed that is not lowering rates therefore the short end the three month and the the T bills itself uh themselves are are actually too too high and and are you know could be the cause of a recession that would cause the 2-year yields to collapse”
NASDAQ has been coming down recently while copper has been going up, which is anomalous and reflects an inflationary regime where metals rise as markets fall as countries prioritize securing metals from geopolitical standpoint.
“Have you noticed the fact that NASDAQ has been coming down recently and copper has been going up? And how would anybody explain that outside of going back to other periods and saying, "Whoa, hold on a second. In inflationary regimes, you can see metals rise as markets fall. And that's that's just because countries are securing metals or they don't care about... that, you know, price that is on the screen right now. They just want to secure things uh from a geopolitical standpoint.”
Scott Bessent indicated in a Bloomberg interview that if the Fed doesn't cooperate, the Treasury has its own toolkit including buybacks and instructions to banks to buy treasuries, and specifically mentioned revaluing gold as part of this strategy.
“Scott Basson was in an interview with a Bloomberg uh reporter in Argentina and where he talked about this. He talked about look if the Fed doesn't play ball if don't see much of a cooperation from JPAL of which Trump has said he might even fire him and if that happens accelerates all this process but let's just assume that there's some stubbornness and some issues about uh firing him for the next couple months and so um how is that going to play out? Well, he said we have our own toolkit. we have our own things that we can do. He's referring to specifically about treasury buybacks. He's referring to instructing the banks to buy treasuries and all these other things.”
Complex industries never become sexy again if people believe that narrative, but history shows that nothing markets an industry better than making money, as evidenced by crypto's popularity despite many investors not understanding it.
“for those who think that a complex industry can never become uh you know you know uh quote unquote sexy again I disagree you know I disagree because there's nothing better for marketing than making money. when people start making money everything looks sexy and you know hence the crypto industry know a lot of people say they understand cryp I still don't understand a lot of things in the crypto market I I still think that a lot of people that say they understand it they don't but because people have made money in that they think they you know it's it's really interesting”
A history lesson is currently occurring about gold, with many having believed it was a useless pet rock, and the same education process will happen in the mining industry and for silver and other commodities.
“Right now we're having a history lesson about gold. Now, how many people said gold is a pet uh rock and it's it's not used for anything. I mean, how wrong has that been? I mean, you know, how many, you know, people on the technology front learn a lesson about about gold? And um you know, the same is going to happen with the mining industry and silver and others.”
Official US gold reserves may not reflect actual holdings, and unofficial reserves held by countries like China are unknown, making it impossible to determine whether the US actually owns more gold than other countries today.
“I do think that the US does think it owns more gold than other countries and I don't think it does as of now. Perhaps it does, but it it's a tough it's a tough call to to to be making, you know, especially given the fact that...we also are at 90-year lows in terms of ownership of gold relative to the rest of the world, which is in a 60-year highs or 50-year highs. So, this is all officially, you know, reported reserves. We don't know what's unofficially held by these countries, China and others.”
For the first time since 2001, mining stocks appear this attractive compared to US equities from a free cash flow yield perspective, and that 2001 period marked the beginning of the strongest decade for the mining industry, suggesting current valuations portend significant outperformance.
“I'd like to turn to talking about gold and and gold miners. This is the first time since 2001 that mining stocks have appeared this attractive as compared to US equities from a free cash flow yield. So that period marked the beginning of of the the industry's strongest one of the strongest decades for that industry.”
There is a significant lack of money managers in the mining industry, and it would be beneficial for the industry to see more investment vehicles created to attract capital.
“there's just a lack of money managers in the industry. I mean I we know you know personally all of them and uh which is or I should say I I think most of them um and uh you know it would be great to see more uh more vehicles being created to bring more capital and attract more money into this industry.”
Most billionaires in the mining industry have made their money through exploration first, then switched to production and development at later stages as it became less risky, with most of their wealth made in exploration.
“most of the billionaires in this industry I think all of them have made their money in exploration and then switch to production and development at later stages as it makes sense. it becomes less risky. You already made most of your money and uh but the the big chunk of their money was made in that side of the market.”
Investment bank analysts underestimate the mining industry because it's been forced to use ultra-conservative metrics for future cash flows, which sandbagging creates a structural lag between fundamental improvements and analyst recognition.
“the analysts play a very important role especially investment banks because they are the ones that are the kind of the front door of the bigger allocators that don't understand the industry... they underestimate a lot of times uh because of the how the industry has been built and because of the how the industry has been forced to use ultra-conservative metrics to uh look at future cash flows and so forth and it hurts those industry uh this industry because it's you know essentially we are sandbagging in a big way”
In the 1960s, mining was close to 20% of US GDP, while currently it is only 0.4% of GDP in the US—this will change globally but this particular statistic comes from the US.
“back in the 1960s or so, uh it used to be close to 20% of GDP mining alone and now it's 0.4% of GDP. So that's going to change in my view. uh and I'm talking about the US by the way and that's going to change globally but that stat came from the US”
Mining stocks have not appeared this attractive compared to US equities on free cash flow yield basis since 2001, which marked the beginning of one of the strongest decades for the mining industry.
“This is the first time since 2001 that mining stocks have appeared this attractive as compared to US equities from a free cash flow yield. So that period marked the beginning of of the the industry's strongest one of the strongest decades for that industry.”
There is a lack of money managers in the mining industry and it would be great to see more vehicles created to bring more capital and attract more money into the industry, making this inevitable.
“there's just a lack of money managers in the industry. I mean I we know you know personally all of them and uh which is or I should say I I think most of them um and uh you know it would be great to see more uh more vehicles being created to bring more capital and attract more money into this industry. So you know I think that's also inevitable.”
The dollar milkshake theory has played out beautifully, attracting too much capital into US-based equities, bonds, and corporate bonds, making the current situation completely unsustainable and requiring rebalancing away from the US.
“The dollar milkshake theory has played out beautifully. Uh it has attracted too much capital into the US US equities or US-based equities, US dollar-based equities and and and and bonds and corporate bonds and treasuries have done extremely well over the last few years because of that influx of capital from outside. You look at the MCI world where 70% weight on the US... And so that is completely unsustainable. You know, we've seen too much of that. We need to see a rebalancing”
When Costa's team was considering buying the San Cristobal silver mine in Bolivia, technical analysts warned that silver could fall to $15 before going higher, but it went to $15 and then recovered to $30, validating ignoring perfect timing attempts.
“This reminds me when we were about to buy S crystal ball mine in Bolivia. Uh silver was trading at $16 an ounce. I remember this very well. and technical guys came up to me and said, "Well, Tavi, be very careful because, you know, we think silver is going to go down first before it goes up. It could and it actually went down to 15, but it doesn't matter." You know, in their mindset, they wouldn't have done what we did because of this technicality of saying we could see two $3 lower before seeing 30. Here we are at $30 an ounce now”
Technical analysis and focus on breakouts/breakdowns messes with the retail investment crowd and causes them to miss major opportunities through narratives that are meaningless.
“I think that's a that's overdoing. Um, I think you're going to lose a lot of big opportunities by doing that... I do think that it unfortunately messes with the crowd. It messes with majority of the retail investors that can end up getting caught up into those narratives that are just completely meaningless.”
When Costa considered buying San Cristobal silver mine in Bolivia at $16 silver, technical analysts warned it could go to $15 first; he proceeded anyway and now silver is at $30+, validating the approach of owning cheap assets rather than timing perfectly.
“Here we are at $30 an ounce now, you know, and the gold to silver ratio is extremely attractive.”
Technical analysts have not performed well over the long term compared to fundamental investors like Pierre Lassonde, Eric Sprott, and Tom Kaplan, who do not rely on technical indicators like the RSI.
“I I just don't know too many actually I don't know any technical analyst who's done very well in the markets over the long term. So relative to guys like Pierre Lassan and Eric Broad and Tom Kaplan and all these guys I I guarantee you these guys are not looking at the RSI of gold or anything along those lines.”
When gold prices surge as they have recently, some investors see a chronic problem and avoid the industry, while others see the lag between metal prices and miner valuations as an opportunity, with Costa observing unprecedented margin attractiveness in private mining vehicles.
“So those two investors are one of them are the ones that look at it and say, "There's a chronic problem. There's there's an issue. I don't want to touch this." And the others that will see this, the lag is your friend and and and there's clearly an opportunity. I can tell you from an insider of owning a private mining vehicle as well that I've never seen margins being so attractive as they have been today.”
Large technology investors are beginning to enter the mining space, representing the start of a broader capital reallocation from tech into mining.
“I think we're going to see a lot more of that. And uh so for those who have been in this nichy environment uh you know and and they're shying away from it, I I don't know. I don't know what to say. I mean this is your moment to shine right now. So, uh, I I love it.”
Within US markets, there are industries that have not benefited from recent changes and are positioned for rebalancing away from mega cap names, particularly energy, which Costa views as timely to examine.
“within the markets in the US markets there are some industries that have been very um you know uh that have not benefited from from uh from the changes we've seen recently. I'm going to point out one that I think uh today looks very timely to be looking at which is the energy space.”
Miners have been outperformed until they start showing real earnings improvements, at which point market perception changes and capital flows accelerate; this is likely what will happen with mining industry.
“miners tend to lag until they actually show uh you know show you know real numbers or reported numbers that they're improving fundamentally and and maybe that's going to be the case here. Now we're going to have to see the uh the actual reported improvement before people really get into uh you know starting to to get more bullish about this whole industry.”
The 2-year yield hovering around 4% is nearly insane given increased recession probability, an administration focused on lowering debt costs, and a stubborn Fed, making short-end yields too high and potentially causative of recession that would force them lower.
“I don't think it's it's almost like it's insane that we're still hovering around 4% on a 2-year yield. uh when you know when probability of recession has has increased when you have an administration that is solely focused on lowering the cost of the debt which you know they could have full control over if they fire JPAL and and fix the issue um you have a stubborn Fed that is not lowering rates therefore the short end the three month and the the T bills itself uh themselves are are actually too too high and and are you know could be the cause of a recession that would cause the 2-year yields to collapse”
Costa is extremely bullish on emerging markets and the rest of the world, with particular emphasis on South America as a very underweighted region likely to be a big winner over the next 2-3 years.
“I'm extremely bullish the rest of the world. I'm extremely bullish emerging markets because they have also underperformed the rest of the world. So there's so many rebalancies that could happen not only out of the US into the rest of the world but also within the rest of the world. It needs to come back into emerging markets in a large way. Uh and and I don't mean this specifically talking about China. I mean this in South America specifically. I think that that's a very underweighted part of the world right now and that's likely to be a big winner for the next you know two to three years.”
Even if gold prices corrected to $2,500 per ounce, most miners with all-in sustaining costs of $1,500 or lower would remain profitable, and the gold-to-oil ratio at historically high levels provides margin protection against commodity downside.
“Uh, and I don't mean this specifically talking about China. I mean this in South America specifically...Let's just say we'd see a correction back to $2,500, which would be insane. $2,500. These miners majority of them are currently with all sustaining costs of 1500 or even lower depending on the case. Um the gold to oil ratio is at the second high highest level in history. So margins are have really expanded. It won't damage their their bottom line.”
The gold-to-silver ratio recently hit 110, one of the few examples in history of such extreme ratios, making silver extremely undervalued relative to history and suggesting silver can appreciate to double or triple current prices and remain plausible given historical ratios.
“the gold to silver ratio recently hit 110. There's only a few other examples in history where it got that high...we could see silver prices, you know, please don't quote me on this, but we could see silver prices at, you know, double triple uh levels that we're seeing now and would still be very plausible because of the gold to silver ratio.”
There will be a rebalancing in US markets from mega cap names into other industries that have not benefited from recent changes.
“I think that maybe what I would uh be something we didn't touch a lot on is uh this rebalancing that may occur in the US out of the mega cap names into other industries. Uh I would not underestimate that type of trend because I I do think um within the markets in the US markets there are some industries that have been very um you know uh that have not benefited from from uh from the changes we've seen recently.”
The energy space has been suffering tremendously from Trump commentary about drill baby drill but should be reconsidered, as oil is strategically as important geopolitically as gold.
“I'm going to point out one that I think uh today looks very timely to be looking at which is the energy space. you know, the energy space uh to me has been uh suffering tremendously from uh you know, commentaries from Trump and uh and the situation of uh drill baby drill and so forth. And uh look, I I am of the view that there's nothing more is strategically uh geopolitically than oil and gold.”
Silver prices could realistically double or triple from current levels without being implausible given the gold-to-silver ratio, and this catch-up trade is the most attractive opportunity.
“we could see silver prices, you know, please don't quote me on this, but we could see silver prices at, you know, double triple uh levels that we're seeing now and would still be very plausible because of the gold to silver ratio.”
Things that have lagged relative to gold, particularly miners, silver, and platinum, are now even more attractive than ever, with every commodity in the world basically cheap relative to gold.
“things that have lagged relative to the metal uh are even more attractive right now that they could ever been. uh you know we're talking about miners, we're talking about silver, gold to silver ratio at 100. Uh you have platin uh that also is extremely cheap. Every commodity in the world today is is basically cheap relative to gold.”
It is insane that 2-year yields are still hovering around 4% given that recession probability has increased and the administration is focused on lowering debt costs, making 2-year yields extremely overvalued from a yield perspective.
“I I don't think it's it's almost like it's insane that we're still hovering around 4% on a 2-year yield. uh when you know when probability of recession has has increased when you have an administration that is solely focused on lowering the cost of the debt... I am I am a very uh big firmly believer that the 2-year yield is is extremely uh overvalued as a from a yield uh perspective”
Costa has never seen mining margins as attractive as they are today from an insider perspective of owning private mining vehicles, and he doesn't believe this is unique to what they own but rather is industry-wide.
“I can tell you from an insider of owning a private mining vehicle as well that I've never seen margins being so attractive as they have been today. And I don't think this is unique to what we own. I think this is unique to the whole industry.”
This is the beginning of a "golden age of mining," and even if gold corrects to $2,500/oz, most miners with all-sustaining costs of $1,500 or lower will still be profitable and cash-generative.
“I've said this before. I think this is the golden age of mining. Um, and even if gold prices, well, let's just assume all the technical guys are right and we're, you know, we see a correction. Let's just say we'd see a correction back to $2,500, which would be insane. These miners majority of them are currently with all sustaining costs of 1500 or even lower”
Large technology investors are already moving into the mining space, representing the beginning of a broader rebalancing from tech into mining.
“We're seeing some large technology investors already coming into the space. I think that's just the beginning. I think we're going to see a lot more of that.”
Copper benefits tremendously from the AI arms race, as AI infrastructure requires significant copper inputs, positioning copper at the core of major developments.
“we know the case for copper in a world where u there's so much push towards an AI arms race. um you know how do you do that without also having um a place where uh you know copper really really benefits tremendously and so it's right at the core of all these developments”
Extremely bullish on rest of world and emerging markets, particularly underweighting on South America which is likely to be a big winner over the next 2-3 years due to underperformance and potential for significant rebalancing.
“I'm extremely bullish the rest of the world. I'm extremely bullish emerging markets because they have also underperformed the rest of the world... I think that that's a very underweighted part of the world right now and that's likely to be a big winner for the next you know two to three years.”
The US dollar is currently as overvalued on the Fed Traded Weighted index as it was at the Plaza Accord, which was a coordinated international effort to reduce the dollar's value.
“we're now as overvalued as we were back at the Plaza accord that was a coordinated act we saw countries coming along and saying well let's reduce the value of the dollar”
Gold has been reflecting deglobalization and geopolitical issues while oil has not, and it would not be shocking if oil goes back to triple-digit prices in the next year or two.
“Gold has been reflecting a lot of those those issues of deglobalization but oil is not and wouldn't shock me at all if we go back to uh you know know tripledigit numbers in oil in the next year or two”
Miners tend to lag until they show real reported numbers showing fundamental improvement, and that may be what's needed before people get bullish on the industry—positive earnings reports are likely coming.
“Hence why a lot of times the miners tend to lag until they actually show uh you know show you know real numbers or reported numbers that they're improving fundamentally and and maybe that's going to be the case here. Now we're going to have to see the uh the actual reported improvement before people really get into uh you know starting to to get more bullish about this whole industry.”
Trump's tweets opposing currency manipulation suggest he does not want foreign currencies to be too strong versus the dollar, which could indicate the Mara Lago accord includes coordination on currency values.
“what if this is part of the Mara Lago accord have we seen the tweet from Trump saying that non-tariff uh issues of people manipulating the currency what does that mean that means that he does not want these currencies to be too strong versus the dollar.”
Brazilian government bonds are currently paying nearly 20% yields, providing positive carry in emerging market assets that people are ignoring due to historical risk, but risks are likely to be removed in a capped dollar and capped yield environment.
“If you look at government bonds in Brazil now they're paying you know almost 20% yields right now. Um so there is a positive carry in most of these assets that people are completely ignoring because of the the risk historical risk when when you look ahead those risks have been are likely to be removed.”
Companies that are not drilling and not creating value should be avoided, but companies actively working on creating value exist in a highly inefficient market.
“as long as you're not in those markets where companies have been dormant uh they're not drilling they're not trying to create value um I think there is uh lots of things you could be doing in this part of the market as well and it's extremely inefficient which I like it a lot”
Costa has long-term conviction on dollar weakness, having doubled down on the view that the dollar peaked in September and December, believing this is a structural long-term trend despite not knowing the exact timing of reversals.
“back in July, uh uh actually September and also back in December, I doubled down on this view uh that the dollar was was at its peak. I I did not know the dollar was going to peak that day or the next day. Had no idea about that. And the same thing goes for commodities. when we came in and started buying commodities and got into mining, we had no idea commodities would turn the COVID was going to happen. But you can kind of see the foundation of a thesis happening here and I've been a believer of the milkshake theory”
Private markets for mining are extremely competitive in bidding for mines, and attractiveness of the space continues to grow as investors recognize the opportunity, suggesting continued capital inflows.
“the private markets are extremely competitive now to purchase mines and I think it's only going to go up from there in terms of attractiveness.”
It would not be shocking if oil returns to triple-digit prices within the next 1-2 years, and many equities in the energy space are extremely undervalued under this assumption.
“and oil is not wouldn't shock me at all if we go back to uh you know know tripledigit numbers in oil in the next year or two and uh I think if if you are of that view um a lot of equities are extremely undervalued under that assumption”
Costa doesn't know any technical analyst who has done very well in markets over the long term, contrasting this with successful investors like Pierre Lassonde, Eric Sprott, and Tom Kaplan who do not rely on technical indicators.
“I just don't know too many actually I don't know any technical analyst who's done very well in the markets over the long term. So relative to guys like Pierre Lassan and Eric Broad and Tom Kaplan and all these guys I I guarantee you these guys are not looking at the RSI of gold or anything along those lines.”
Crescat manages a fund with investments across many mining companies, with options to structure through development-phase and producing-phase companies, but lower market cap and earlier stage investments get more technical and complex.
“we do own obviously we manage a fund that has investments across many mining companies. Um I think there's a lot of ways to skin the cat um in this industry. Majority of people like to do it in the development phase and the producing phase because it's just easier to understand these companies. the lower you go in the market value and also the earlier stage you go the more technical the industry gets and extremely complex.”
Every commodity in the world is cheap relative to gold, making this an optimal period for relative-value trades into lagging assets (miners, silver, platinum) versus gold itself.
“we're talking about miners, we're talking about silver, gold to silver ratio at 100. Uh you have platin uh that also is extremely cheap. Every commodity in the world today is is basically cheap relative to gold.”
The asset side of the balance sheet that Treasury can monetize includes the sovereign wealth fund, TikTok, US Steel, and unexplored/underdeveloped natural resources that could unlock trillions of dollars in value.
“there's well there's lots of things. There's I guess two separate things. Um one side of it is the the sovereign wealth fund which is the monetizing um quote that he said was referring to that first and foremost. Uh and you've got Tik Tok and all US steel producers. you know, they just block US steel from being purchased by uh a Japanese firm... there's also a lot of resources in the US that um I believe Ludnik has has talked about extensively about how we can unlock a lot of value from resources we have in the US uh in terms of trillions and trillions of dollars”
There are two types of investors seeing gold prices at historic highs while miners remain cheap: those who see a chronic problem and avoid the sector, and those who see the lag as an opportunity—the latter view is correct based on historical patterns and margin attractiveness.
“there's two types of investors when they see these, you know, issues with um with uh the fact that we're not seeing uh we're seeing gold prices surge to levels we haven't seen any other time in history. At the same time, the miners continue to be so cheap. So those two investors are one of them are the ones that look at it and say, 'There's a chronic problem. There's there's an issue. I don't want to touch this.' And the others that will see this, the lag is your friend and and and there's clearly an opportunity.”
Technical analysts arguing that gold-to-silver ratios will go from 110 to 115 instead of mean-reverting to historical levels like 70, 60, or 50 are exhibiting asymmetry in risk-reward thinking and missing the opportunity.
“I'm seeing technical guys say well this time is going to be different we're going to see the gold to silver ratio go from you know 105, 110 to 115 and instead of going back to 80 first and can we think about asymmetry like what's the asymmetry of saying that something will go from 15, 105, 110 to 115 versus going back to 70 or 60 or 50.”
Gold is not a 'pet rock' with no utility, and people wrongly dismissed it as useless, but technology industries are now learning the importance of gold in semiconductor and electronics manufacturing, similar to how mining will become respected once profits materialize.
“how many people said gold is a pet uh rock and it's it's not used for anything. I mean, how wrong has that been? I mean, you know, how many, you know, people on the technology front learn a lesson about about gold? And um you know, the same is going to happen with the mining industry and silver and others.”
Kinton Henny is a key partner who understands the exploration side better than anybody else, providing Crescat with superior analytical ideas on where to invest in the mining space.
“I just happen to have a great relationship with one of our partners, Kinton Henny, uh who understand the the exploration side better than anybody else.”
We live in a fantasy world where reality has been destroyed, making this a critical time to pay attention to probabilities overwhelmingly favoring gold's value increase.
“We live in a fantasy world now. Reality has been destroyed. This is the time that you really need to pay attention. The probabilities are overwhelmingly on gold's side.”
The probabilities are overwhelmingly on gold's side in the current environment, making it the best environment to see gold increase its value.
“The probabilities are overwhelmingly on gold's side. That is the best environment to see gold increase its value.”
Trump's tweet about non-tariff issues and currency manipulation indicates his desire to prevent other currencies from strengthening versus the dollar, establishing policy intent around currency management.
“have we seen the tweet from Trump saying that non-tariff uh issues of people manipulating the currency what does that mean that means that he does not want these currencies to be too strong versus the dollar.”
This is an extremely important turning point for emerging markets right now, with both structural conditions and pricing positioning them for significant outperformance.
“So, I do think emerging markets are in the very important turning point right now.”
Costa doubled down on his view that the dollar peaked in July, September, and December, betting the dollar would enter a long-term downtrend without knowing the exact timing of the reversal.
“back in July, uh uh actually September and also back in December, I doubled down on this view uh that the dollar was was at its peak. I I did not know the dollar was going to peak that day or the next day. Had no idea about that.”
Crescat manages a fund with investments across many mining companies, and there are multiple ways to gain mining exposure through development, production, or exploration phases, each with different complexity and risk profiles.
“we do own obviously we manage a fund that has investments across many mining companies. Um I think there's a lot of ways to skin the cat um in this industry. Majority of people like to do it in the development phase and the producing phase because it's just easier to understand these companies.”
We are living in a fantasy world where reality has been destroyed, requiring careful attention to investment implications.
“We live in a fantasy world now. Reality has been destroyed. This is the time that you really need to pay attention.”