YouTube19m· Oct 2024· cataloged

Dividend Cafe - A Consideration Being Missed


What this covers

This Dividend Cafe episode is a solo commentary from David Bonson, built around notes from a week of meetings with portfolio managers in New York. It starts with the macro backdrop and moves into private markets. Inflation and growth come first. Goods inflation is already at zero or below, and the remaining stickiness sits in housing, which he describes as frozen until the Fed lets buyers and sellers transact again. His long-term growth view is subdued, a "japanification" he blames on government debt and the policy response to it. He treats the short and medium term as harder to read. Onshoring and other capex could lift productivity for a time, but post-election fiscal and regulatory uncertainty and a shortage of labor could stop it.

The middle of the episode covers valuations and China. He calls equity valuations objectively rich but says the timing of when that matters can only be seen in hindsight. His team avoids Chinese equities because it sees the country's problems as structural rather than cyclical, a position the episode flags as contestable.

The main section turns to private equity. Sponsors bought companies in 2020-2022 at low rates and now face a worse exit multiple than they penciled in. Secondary sales to larger sponsors are impractical because borrowing costs are high, and IPO appetite has faded. That leaves the strategic acquisition of private companies by public ones as the residual exit. He expects elevated activity, especially from public companies with constrained organic growth. For dividend growth investors he points to investment banks, M&A lenders and asset managers, and he cautions that shareholders must judge good acquisitions from bad ones rather than accept them passively.

The closing stretch covers private credit. He explains how its non-callable capital differs from callable bank deposits and why some borrowers prefer it to bond markets. He rejects the idea that it is a systemic risk, arguing it keeps risk out of the banking system. He also says that the abundance of lending opportunity still demands careful underwriting and diversification.

Sharpest takeaway

David Bonson argues that private equity deal backlog will drive a substantial increase in strategic acquisitions of private companies by public companies over the next several years, creating both investment opportunities and risks across multiple sectors.

  • Low interest rates enabled heavy private equity deal activity in 2020-2022, but rising rates and exit multiple pressure have created a backlog of companies needing to be sold
  • Traditional exit channels (secondary sales to larger PE firms and IPOs) are largely unavailable, making strategic acquisitions by public companies the primary remaining exit mechanism
  • This M&A wave will create opportunities in financial services (investment banks, lenders, asset managers) while also presenting risks as public companies execute acquisitions with varying quality

The claims · ranked35 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.74

Private credit lending differs from bank lending because the funding comes from investors without a timeline for return of capital and is not callable, whereas bank deposits are callable at any moment.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· David Bonson

“the money comes from investors and investors that don't have a a timeline for return of capital it's not callable and that's where of course diff differ in the bank Market where deposits the funding mechanism are always you know callable at any moment”

0.69

Most private equity deals are funded with borrowed money, and private credit has largely replaced bank loans and high-yield bonds as the funding mechanism, with lenders providing non-traded debt without callable terms.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Bonson

“most of these uh deals get done with borrowed money and and I've talked nauseum over the last couple years about how private credit uh has really out competed a lot of the bank loan market and the high yield bond market to underwrite a lot of these deals they're lending the private Equity sponsors through private channels and what I mean by that is it's debt that doesn't trade and isn't held on a bank balance sheet”

0.69

Anyone invested in public equity will have to manage the risk that companies they own will make both good and bad acquisitions as they pursue M&A-driven growth, requiring active adjudication and discernment rather than passive acceptance.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Bonson

“anyone invested in public Equity is likely going to end up having to deal with the possibility of their of companies they own making bad deals and then making good deals and so it is not something you bring up to say this is a risk or this is a good thing it is both at once it requires adjudication and discernment”

0.69

Some borrowers prefer private credit to the bond market because of speed, execution quality, value creation, and other strategic benefits that outweigh the trade-offs in transparency and disclosure.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Bonson

“why would someone prefer this to the bond market there's uh speed there's execution there's value creation there's a number of arguments as to why some would go private credit versus the bond market um transparency disclosures you know that there's a lot of issues that play there but those are strategic things for the borrowers and the lenders to think about”

0.69

Rising interest rates have made the exit multiple for private equity deals unattractive compared to what sponsors penciled in at the time of purchase, because higher borrowing costs reduce the valuation multiple at exit.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Bonson

“they bought at a certain rate when they bought but now it's a higher borrowing rate and so the exit multiple may not be what they kind of penciled a deal to”

0.69

Private equity sponsors bought companies at certain valuations and earnings levels during the low-interest-rate period of 2020-2022, and now need to exit these deals at higher valuations and earnings levels to satisfy their investors.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Bonson

“a lot of companies were bought and the sponsors the private Equity folks buying these companies you're now in the third fourth soon to be fifth year of some of these deals you know their investors want money back and they bought at a certain valuation and they would like it to be at a higher valuation when they sell they bought at a certain earnings level they like it to be at a higher earnings level in they sell”

0.68

The richness of opportunity in lending markets requires maintaining high-quality underwriting, diversification, attractive terms, and suitability for the particular lender, not just deploying capital into new lenders regardless of quality.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· David Bonson

“there is still a principle at play maintaining high quality underwriting diversification um attractive terms you know uh suitability for who exactly is doing it”

0.68

Bonson does not believe private credit itself represents a systemic risk; instead, he sees it as a huge growth story with investment opportunity.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· David Bonson

“I would be none of the above but but one of the takeaways from this last week that Brian Kenny and I really shared was appreciation for the opportunity and structured Credit in asset-based lending private credit and the fact that there are perhaps bad uh lenders coming into Frey is somewhat immaterial um there's always bad deals uh but we want to avoid those we want to avoid the bad players stick with the The Operators that are worthy of our investment and and that's what we think we're doing but don't see it as a systemic story in fact see it as a huge growth story”

0.68

Private credit represents a great victory for US capital markets and an enhancement to systemic safety because productive deals can be done without holding risk inside the banking system.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· David Bonson

“I consider to be a great victory for Capital markets in America and an enhancement to the systemic safety of our banking system when a lot of deals can be done that are productive and and yet not held from a risk profile inside the banking system”

0.65

Short and medium-term growth outlooks are much more complex and tricky than the long-term, with possible catalysts from capex but multiple potential headwinds.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Bonson

“but the short and medium-term Outlook is much more um tricky there are people who believe that there is the possibility of a boost in growth in in a short or intermediate term that could be catalyzed by capex”

0.64

Multiple headwinds could prevent onshoring/reshoring capex from materializing, including fiscal issues around tax and regulatory policy after elections and a shortage of labor.

forecasthigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· David Bonson

“there are plenty of things that could prevent such from happening um a fiscal uh issue around tax and Regulatory policy after the election um and not to mention a shortage of Labor”

0.64

IPO appetite has declined significantly, further constraining traditional exit channels for private equity and making strategic acquisitions by public companies the remaining major exit mechanism.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· David Bonson

“and then IPOs uh there I've I've talked about written about lately that there's a much lower appetite for IPOs what what that leaves you is an option that I had not considered enough that I think is going to be a really substantial part of capital markets activity”

0.61

Stock market valuations are objectively rich but the timing of when that matters is highly uncertain and can only be identified with hindsight.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Bonson

“there's not a question that valuations are rich there is plenty of question as to when that will matter um it is simply untimely by definition until it can be identified with the vantage point of the rear room year”

0.61

The housing market is frozen and cannot disinflate until the Fed is successful in detha-ing that market and allowing buyers and sellers to start transacting again.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Bonson

“the housing market is Frozen and and will but can't will disinflate but can't disinflate until uh the FED is successful in sort of detha that market and allowing buyers and sellers to start transacting again”

0.61

Bonson's long-term growth expectations are subdued because he believes the US is in a japanification period caused by excessive government debt and the policy response to it.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· David Bonson

“our long-term growth expectations are subdued because we are of the belief that we are in a japanification period uh bought brought about by both excessive government debt and the policy response to such”

0.60

Some form of business investment that boosts productivity for a time is entirely possible, catalyzed potentially by onshoring, reshoring, and other changes in manufacturing activity.

forecasthigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· David Bonson

“I think that some form of business investment that juices productivity for a time is entirely possible um a catalyst to the cap the Catalyst of capex could very well be um onshoring uh reshoring and and other change in manufacturing activity”

0.57

Strategic acquisitions of private companies by public companies will become a substantial and lasting part of US capital markets activity for several years because they are the residual exit mechanism once secondary PE sales and IPOs are constrained.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· David Bonson

“that's strategic Acquisitions of private companies by public companies and I think that you may see a little bit of give in in the exit multiple for the seller because buyers in public markets don't like to pay a multiple for a company they're buying higher than the multiple they already trade at and public multiples are high but in some sectors they're not as high as where private deals are you're going to see some good deals you're going to see some bad deals”

0.56

The inflationary backup is concentrated in housing in the data, which is where residual inflation persists after goods inflation has already reached zero.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· David Bonson

“that's really where I see the inflationary backup is just in housing in the data”

0.56

Goods inflation is already effectively at 0% or lower, representing a significant disinflation in that category.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· David Bonson

“effectively I think the um uh you know goods and inflation producer price inflation is already effectively at 0% if not lower”

0.56

Bonson does not believe times are truly calm; rather, various underlying challenges are always occurring and take different shapes or manifestations from period to period.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· David Bonson

“I have talked about over and over again over the years I don't really believe there are times when everything's kind of calm and cool when people will say like oh wow things are a little crazy right now um it's usually describing something that is always happening just taking on a different shape or size or manifestation”

0.55

Bonson and his team believe China is going through structural rather than cyclical challenges, which is why they are very avoidant of Chinese equity opportunities.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Bonson

“we do not consider them to be going through cyclical challenges that therefore have cyclical exciting opportunity we believe they're going through structural challenges and and that's why we essentially consider ourselves to be very um avoidant of of the Chinese Equity story in particular”

0.52

For dividend growth investors in public equity, exposure to companies in financial services (investment banks, M&A lenders, asset managers) provides a play on increased M&A activity driven by the private equity deal backlog.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· David Bonson

“for us as dividend growth investors in public Equity we happen to own quite a few companies that would be either directly or tangentially connected to the deal side of this investment Banks m&a lenders lenders on on these transactions asset managers So within Financial the financial services sector there is a play here on just increase activity m&a has been very subdued the last couple years”

0.52

Secondary sales to larger private equity companies, a historically common exit channel, have been taken off the table as a significant option because high borrowing costs make acquiring companies at better multiples unattractive for larger PE sponsors.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· David Bonson

“one of the common exits of uh private Equity transactions has been off the table selling to a bigger private Equity company because of high borrowing cost and the desire to get a better multiple buying than what the exit multiple would be to sell so a difficulty matching buyers and sellers there”

0.52

There is no way to remove the backlog of companies that need to be sold apart from public companies making strategic acquisitions, implying this outcome is economically necessary rather than optional.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· David Bonson

“I think that there is no way to kind of remove this backlog address the backlog of companies that have been bought that need to be sold apart from public companies making strategic Acquisitions”

0.52

Strategic acquisitions of private companies by public companies will be elevated compared to historical norms and will impact particularly those organic earnings growth-constrained companies that want to use M&A as a means of buying growth inorganically.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· David Bonson

“I think you're going to see it elevated I think you're going to see it impact um especially uh organic earnings growth constrained companies that want to use m&a as a means of buying growth inorganically and that can be done very very well but it often is not”

0.49

There is an absolute backup of exit transactions in the private market space, but no panic or big deterioration of value—deals are still happening at good marks where companies had been priced, suggesting orderly but constrained exit activity rather than distress sales.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· David Bonson

“you see a absolute backup of exit transactions for the private Market space you don't see a big deterioration of value where deals are happening they're largely happening at good marks at at uh where companies had priced them to be or even better but there um isn't a panic sale to get out people are not desperate but we're at a very abnormal level of deals that need to kind of be brought to fruition”

0.48

A trillion and a half dollars has gone into underwriting leverage buyouts and private equity deals through private credit, but this does not exhaust the opportunity set because there are many trillions of dollars in lending opportunities against various assets and collateral types.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Bonson

“the question that comes up a lot is well are we at the end of the opportunity set here a trillion and a half dollars has gone into underwriting leverage buyouts private credit funding private Equity deals aren't we kind of into the thin part of the of the opportunity set now and I think it underestimates the many many many many trillions of uh dollars of lending opportunities that exist against assets against different types of collateral”

0.47

Excess valuations are very concentrated in a couple of particular sectors and spaces, but are broadly diffused in impact through massive increase in cap-weighted index investing since the last valuation bubble.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· David Bonson

“right now the excess evaluations are very concentrated in a couple of particular sectors and spaces and yet and then and then uh perhaps more democratized in their impact because of the massive increase in cap weighted index investing that's taken place since the last time we had a valuation uh bubble like this”

0.45

The entry of bad lenders into the private credit space is somewhat immaterial to systemic risk because bad deals are always happening and the important thing is to identify and avoid them while sticking with worthy operators.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· David Bonson

“the fact that there are perhaps bad uh lenders coming into Frey is somewhat immaterial um there's always bad deals uh but we want to avoid those we want to avoid the bad players stick with the The Operators that are worthy of our investment”

0.37

The quarterly meetings with portfolio managers, asset managers, and lenders allow for intensive portfolio introspection, debate, and critical evaluation of investment theses.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· David Bonson

“it allows us the ability as an investment committee to not only have a lot of time together in discussion and debate in consideration but also to have this time with others where we can bounce ideas off them hear their perspective critique what they're doing and just really force ourselves to kind of do a whole week of real um portfolio introspection”

0.37

Private markets exposure carries trade-offs between illiquidity and return potential, with tolerance for illiquidity varying significantly across clients.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· David Bonson

“private markets are something that many of our clients have exposure to some do not there is tolerance for illiquidity for some people and and not for others there's a lot of considerations that go into the risk profile and suitability of one being engaged in private markets”

0.34

Dividend growth investing is a core investment philosophy for Bonson's firm and represents the majority of their public equity exposure in the US.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· David Bonson

“for us our exposure to public equities in the US is largely um the mass majority of that exposure is through dividend growth investing which is what we believe in as a almost religious principle in our investment philosophy”

0.29

Common topics for portfolio discussion at investment meetings include inflation, growth, stock valuations, and China, representing ongoing potential headwinds, tail risks, vulnerabilities, and opportunities that vary in their specific manifestation year to year.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· David Bonson

“it isn't so much that oh well you know this year we had to go talk about inflation or this year we had to talk about subdued growth or this year we'd talk about the election or about uh China there's various things that have to be discussed every year that represent um potential headwinds that represent uh tail risk and sometimes it represent opportunities or or questions you know it's vulnerabilities but also you know the the untapped opportunity”

0.24

Getting transactions to happen in the housing market is simply a matter of policy allowing the market to clear, implying the solution is essentially mechanical once policy moves appropriately.

causalestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· David Bonson

“I think that that's just simply matter of getting transactions to happen”

0.19

M&A has been very subdued over the last couple of years following a hot period in earlier years.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· David Bonson

“m&a has been very subdued the last couple years it had been really hot couple before then”