
Is a new world economic order emerging? | Counting the Cost
What this covers
This Al Jazeera "Counting the Cost" episode is a 28-minute panel discussion with reported segments, narrated by Adrian Finigan. The guests include Danny Quah, Philip Lron and Arena Miran, with Arena Muriisan and a reporter's field pieces also in the mix. The inquiry is whether the Rules-Based International Order built after World War II is giving way to something else, and who would write the next rules. Lron frames the shift as a change in decision logic, from asking whether a policy makes a country richer to asking whether it makes the country more secure. He lists what has eroded: Western economic dominance, US stability, open markets and great-power acceptance of constraints.
The middle of the episode looks at institutions. The World Trade Organization (WTO)) is described as once highly successful, with China's 2001 entry as its high point, and now stalled, with a dispute settlement mechanism that barely functions. Miran ties this to a trust deficit among developing countries. On BRICS, the narration gives the 2009 founding aims and the group's weight in GDP and population. Another speaker notes the label began as a Goldman Sachs slogan and questions whether the members share enough to displace Western institutions. Miran adds a concrete detail: Chinese loans carry grace periods that suit electoral cycles. Reporting touches on China's turn toward developing markets, its ties with Serbia, and Ukraine's effects on energy and Russia's partnerships.
The sharpest disagreement concerns framing. Quah rejects the "Cold War" label for US-China rivalry, arguing the contest is over productivity, technology and industrial capacity rather than ideology as it was with the Soviet Union, and that the answer is domestic competitiveness rather than sabre-rattling. He also argues for reforming the old order rather than discarding it, and says the dollar's future rests on confidence more than fundamentals. Lron, by contrast, raises the risk of hot war over Taiwan.
The post-WWII rules-based global economic order is fragmenting under geopolitical tension and the rise of competing power blocs like BRICS, forcing a reckoning between those advocating for reformed multilateralism and those pursuing national security-driven economic competition.
- Four pillars of the old order (Western dominance, US political stability, open markets, rules adherence) have crumbled, replaced by multi-polarity and national security concerns
- BRICS and alternative institutions represent desire for fairer order but lack coherence and deep integration to genuinely displace existing institutions
- The real competition is economic (productivity, technology, industrial capacity) not ideological, yet framing it as security-driven Cold War risks obscuring the actual mechanisms of advantage
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
China's loans through its alternative finance mechanisms come with grace periods of 5-7 years before repayment begins, making them politically attractive to sitting governments even if long-term interest rates are higher than IMF/World Bank loans, because repayment timing aligns with government electoral cycles.
“if we were just to to look at at uh Chinese loans as an example or India's loans as an example um it's it's interesting to note that in the long run maybe they're not as cheap as as your IMF and World Bank but they're attractive because I mean especially with the Chinese lo they come with a grace period of 5 to seven years where countries can start repaying then uh politically this is where it's highly practical for a sitting government uh since repayment doesn't begin until the end of the term possibly”
The old question policymakers asked under the rules-based order was 'is it going to make us richer' but the key priority now is 'is it going to make us more secure', marking a fundamental shift in decision logic.
“in the old IC order the big question policy makers asked was is it going to make us richer and now the key priority is is it going to make us more secure”
Framing the US-China competition as a 'Cold War' based on security concerns obscures the real economic competition rooted in industrial capacity, technological control, and productivity, echoing language used during US-Japan economic competition in the 1980s rather than genuine ideological conflict.
“the language about it's being now a security competition unfortunately uh Rings a lot of early era not of competition with the Soviet Union for which the competition was not economic but of us competition with Japan a lot of the language about you know Japan's uh economic superiority threatening undermining US security uh is echoed today and the peculiar thing in all of that is that Japan in all of that time was firmly a liberal democracy Japan in all of that time was a strong partner of America in America's uh strategic Alliance in the Pacific so my own sense is that you know when we give in to talk about security talk about the Cold War we might be taking our eye off of the real competition okay which is an economic one”
The world is in a constant state of stable anarchy where larger powers pursue strategic interests, and institutions like the WTO should establish relevant boundaries to mitigate these interests.
“the criticism is that the world is in a constant state of stable Anarchy and the institutions like your WTO should be instilling these relevant boundaries to mitigate GE strategic interests”
The future of the US dollar as the dominant world reserve currency depends on sentiment and confidence, which do not necessarily track with factual economic conditions or comparative geopolitical strength.
“the future of the the world Reserve currency uh the US dollar in this case is going to depend on a whole range of factors but likely high on that list is sentiment and confidence and often that does not run parallel with or hand inand with you know facts on the ground”
The WTO faces a trust deficit because the system is not working for all countries equally, especially in terms of development outcomes, driving desire for global reform while simultaneously attempting to preserve institutions that mitigate existing power imbalances.
“the system suffers from this trust deficit we've been talking about but this really drives home the desire for Global reform while trying to really hang on to institutions that mitigate existing formats and existing platforms”
The WTO, once the most successful institution of the old world order through multilateral liberalization and successful integration of China in 2001, has ground to a standstill since then and is increasingly ignored by the US and China, with its dispute settlement mechanism largely non-functional, representing a tragedy that will not lead to a fairer world.
“the WTO um is probably the was the most successful institution of um the old world order it was created on a wave of multilateral liberalization there was the huge success of bringing China in in 2001 and since then basically its ground to a standstill it's increasingly ignored by um the US and China who go their own way the dispute settlement mechanism uh which resolved international disputes is largely uh in abeyance and I think that's a tragedy”
BRICS was originally a Goldman Sachs marketing slogan that was then adopted by the leaders of those countries, but it is unclear how much the member nations actually have in common given they have divergent interests, economic structures, and geopolitical alignments.
“the bricks remember started off as a Goldman Sachs marketing slogan it was then adopted by the leaders of those countries it's not clear to me that they have a hell of a lot in common um you know India and China are geopolitical Rivals um some are commodity exporters and some a commodity importers some as Arena said um uh have closer ties to the West as well as ties to China others are are clearly in an anti-western Camp economically the ties between them aren't that significant”
The post-Cold War international economic order based on Western economic dominance, US geopolitical stability, open markets, and US willingness to abide by international rules has fundamentally eroded as a result of Western economic decline, rising multipolarity, security concerns displacing market liberalism, and great powers no longer accepting constraints on economic policymaking.
“the old order which is the one that prevailed since the end of the Cold War uh in the early 90s was based on four pillars four pillars that have now crumbled the first uh is Western economic dominance and as Danny has said um the West has declined and the rest um have risen uh the second was an exceptional period of us GE political Agony and and we now live in an increasingly multi-polar World which is characterized between by geopolitical conflict between a still dominant us and a rising uh China thirdly as Danny also noted um before there was a belief in open markets which Trump pretty much everything and now increasingly that is usurped um by National Security concerns and indeed industrial policy uh priorities not just in the west also in China indeed has always been the case and last but not least um a US willingness to support uh International uh rules and to abide by them most of the time and that's exceptional for he hegemonic power and now now that is no longer the case”
BRICS' strategic intention is to use partnership to create windows for changing the global system, with success dependent on strength of bilateral relationships and individual national power, sustained by accelerated cooperation through approximately 200 meetings per year.
“the success of bricks is really dependent on the strength of bilateral relationships as well as the the country as an individual power of course but as we've seen bricks host something like 200 meetings a year and so you have an accelerated growth in political and economic cooperation this constant meeting which is definitely contributing to their success”
China is capitalizing on divisions in the international system by establishing stronger ties with Eastern European nations like Serbia that are waiting for EU membership, offering alternative partnerships.
“China is capitalizing on divisions in a recent visit to Serbia president Chi Jinping established stronger ties with the Eastern European country which has been waiting for EU membership for over a decade with the joint efforts of both countries the China Serbia free Trade Agreement formally begins in July”
Advanced wealthy economies are now joining emerging and developing economies in criticizing the international economic order, marking a shift where opposition to the system is no longer confined to the Global South.
“one of the interesting turnarounds is that today the advanced economies the rich economies are also critical of the international economic order and how this comes out is going to be really interesting going forwards”
The US-China trade war and competitive pressures are causing China to redirect significant portions of its economy away from Western markets toward developing world trade and investment.
“China is redirecting large parts of its economy away from the West toward the developing World”
The war in Ukraine has disrupted energy supplies across Europe, weakened Russia-West ties, but strengthened Russia's relationships with other regions including parts of Africa.
“The war in Ukraine is another factor it's disrupted energy supplies across Europe and it's also weakened ties between Russia and the west but is strengthened them elsewhere including parts of Africa”
Countries are trying to understand how to reconfigure global supply chains given China's major role and environmental concerns, and this reconfiguration will be both technically complex and influenced by sporadic geopolitical changes.
“countries are still trying to understand how to understand Global Supply chains China's major has a major role in this and how it's going to be reconfigured and how the future of global Commerce is also going to settle especially in the context of environmental concerns and uh sporadic geopolitical changes and challenges”
The WTO ruled that small countries have equal voice and guaranteed fairness under its dispute settlement mechanism, though this mechanism is now largely non-functional.
“the WTO rules which were not perfect but which were applied largely impartially guaranteed uh equal voice uh to small players they guaranteed fairness for pretty much everybody okay and going to a world of might might makes right and small clubs isn't going to make things better”
The old rules-based international order should not be hastily abandoned because countries like China successfully leveraged its grand ideas (comparative advantage, economic efficiency) to lift hundreds of millions from poverty, and these mechanisms could continue if the order were reformed rather than replaced.
“I think that we should be not so uh anxious to so quickly uh ditch the Old World Order of globalization and capitalism there were Grand ideas there that arguably the most successful of the brics Nations China leveraged and leveraged successfully the grand ideas included uh the notion of how you wanted to organize things in an economically efficient way you needed to leverage comparative advantage and countries like China and smaller Nations uh leverage these ideas powerfully in the process lifting hundreds of millions of their citizens out of poverty”
The original Cold War involved genuine American concern that the Soviet Union was building an alternative political and economic system designed to replace Western liberal democracy, making it fundamentally ideological.
“During the the original Cold War Americans were genuinely worried that the Soviets were building a political and economic system that would undermine their American way of life destroy the American way of government”
The appropriate response to economic competition from China is not security rhetoric and sabre-rattling, but for countries to raise their own productivity, train their people, and compete economically, addressing the real issue of China undermining industrial structure and stealing jobs through improved competitiveness.
“when we give in to talk about security talk about the Cold War we might be taking our eye off of the real competition okay which is an economic one which is that there are some countries in the world feeling that China is um undermining dismantling their industrial structure uh stealing their jobs engaging in um in a program that will lead to their uh taking control of Technologies of the future and in economics the right way to deal with that is not to okay shout wolf and then rattle a saber of security but to pick oneself up raise your own productivity train your people get to a point where you can compete”
If the United States persists in bullying behavior and market protectionism, China will take resolute and forceful measures to defend its sovereignty, security and development interests.
“China has repeatedly accused the US of bullying and of Market protectionism if the United States persists China will take Resolute and forceful measures to firmly defend its sovereignty security and development interests”
The possibility of full-blown hot war exists if developments in Taiwan degenerate, representing a qualitatively different risk than trade war or geopolitical competition.
“there a possibility of a full-blow um hot War if uh uh developments in in Taiwan um uh degenerate”
BRICS nations, while representing nearly one-third of global GDP and nearly half of global population, do not have sufficient internal coherence or deep economic ties to genuinely displace or replace the existing Western-led international economic order.
“the bricks remember started off as a Goldman Sachs marketing slogan it was then adopted by the leaders of those countries it's not clear to me that they have a hell of a lot in common um you know India and China are geopolitical Rivals um some are commodity exporters and some a commodity importers some as Arena said um uh have closer ties to the West as well as ties to China others are are clearly in an anti-western Camp economically the ties between them aren't that significant and in any case they're only um you know a small number of countries uh in a very large world”
BRICS nations now account for nearly a third of global GDP and nearly half of global population, with their total GDP in purchasing power parity terms exceeding that of the G7.
“bricks represent nearly a third of the global economy and nearly half of its population their total GDP in purchasing power parity terms is actually bigger than that of the GC 7”
The US has dominated the global economy for decades, but this dominance is now under challenge from geopolitical tensions and the emergence of alternative economic blocs.
“the US has dominated the global economy for decades but the world is fractured by geopolitical tensions”
BRICS was founded in 2009 with the intent to create a new global voice opposing unilateral approaches to geopolitics, explicitly designed to create alternative financial institutions and reduce reliance on the US dollar.
“The leaders of Brazil Russia India and China founded the group in 2009 South Africa joined a year later bricks is designed to be a new global voice opposing what it sees as a unilateral approach to geopolitics bricks nations want to change the imbalance by creating an alternative to us-led financial institutions in 2015 they founded the new development Bank to counter organizations such as the World Bank and the international monetary fund they also aimed to reduce their Alliance on the US dollar”
The UAE, Iran, Ethiopia and Egypt joined BRICS in 2024, and Saudi Arabia was invited with membership pending, with these additions amplifying BRICS ambition to become champion of the Global South.
“The Block is growing too the UAE Iran and Ethiopia and Egypt joined this year Saudi Arabia was invited to join its membership is pending but its addition will only amplify the bricks ambition to become the champion of the global South”
A contrasting group of nations may consist of those that historically had the upper hand but now face anemic growth, and the increasing confrontation will be between growth-oriented nations and declining wealthy powers.
“on the other side a group of no Nations that might have historically had the upper hand but for whom Now growth is anemic and so that it seems to me is the increasing confrontation”
Alternative creditors like India and China are now available to countries seeking development finance, offering an alternative to the IMF and World Bank, suggesting the IMF has a diminishing future.
“with um alternative creditors like India and China available right now what does the IMF have a future”
While 80% of the world lives outside great power competition, most smaller nations do not necessarily want to choose sides in a new bipolar order but rather prefer principles-based world order construction that prioritizes accountability and institutional boundaries over geopolitical alignment.
“80% of the world lives in countries that are not a great power and for many of us outside of that Circle what we want to see are principles that go into thinking about how World Order can be constructed rather than simply who is where in that Coalition”
The post-WWII multilateral institutions have been under sustained attack, and smaller and emerging middle-power countries must uphold institutional values and build critical mass around accountability to mitigate great power strategic interests.
“if you look at the institutions specifically from the post World War II order that we you know characterize the world order by multilateralism is and has been under attack and if you look at the bricks and their values and the sense that they advocate for a rules-based order governed by international law and celebration of multilateralism many take for granted that this may be interpreted for one's own value systems and so the criticism is that the world is in a constant state of stable Anarchy and the institutions like your WTO should be instilling these relevant boundaries to mitigate GE strategic interests and it's really the rest the smaller countries the emerging and middle powers that need to uphold institutional values to build this kind of critical mass”
Some global leaders express frustration that countries should not have to be tied to the US dollar for trade and should have the commitment to innovate in alternative systems.
“why should every country have to be tied to the dollar for trade why can't we trade in our own currency and why don't we have the commitment to innovate”
US President Biden has issued new tariffs on Chinese products including electric vehicles, batteries and semiconductors affecting approximately 18 billion dollars worth of Chinese goods, justified as promoting fair competition rather than conflict.
“US President Joe Biden recently issued a new round of tariffs on Beijing affecting about 18 billion dollar worth of Chinese products including electric vehicles batteries and semiconductors bottom line I want Fair competition with China not conflict”
Smaller powers leverage the moment of great power competition and institutional flux to find agency and extract favorable terms from competing providers of credit and development finance.
“and there the desire to have something different to have an alternative um and leverage that in terms of who is fighting whom I think that is that is an interesting time we find ourselves in and it is more about the smaller Powers finding a way to leverage this moment for themselves to find their agency in that”
Global leaders express the goal of expanding the global economic pie rather than moving the cheese, suggesting that the goal of BRICS and emerging nations is inclusive growth rather than zero-sum redistribution.
“the development of the emerging market and developing countries is not intended to move the cheese but to make the pie of the global economy bigger”
Brazil and India are able to leverage their relationship with both the old Western order and newer BRICS relationships, proving more flexible and adaptable powers in the international system due to their individual economic power and strategic positioning.
“Brazil and India are able to leverage their relationship with the old world order and they've also proven to be more flexible and adaptable powers in the International System”
Developing nations criticized by Global South leaders have experienced oppression and been excluded from fair treatment in global governance structures created more than six decades ago that have not evolved to reflect changing global realities.
“the poor countries have been and are being oppressed and terrorized by the rich countries naturally the poor are bitter and angry and have lost faith in Justice and honor Global political and economic governance created more than six decades ago have not kept PA with the changing realities of the world”