What this covers

This is a conversation between historian Gary Gerstel, author of the FT Business Book of the Year winner, and FT columnist Rana Foroohar. It starts by defining a political order as something that lasts decades, resting on reliable constituencies, animating ideas, and a vision of the good life. The New Deal order is the first example: it held that states should manage markets democratically, and it was confirmed when Eisenhower preserved it in 1953. The 1970s crisis, when Keynesian techniques stopped working, let once-marginal thinkers like Milton Friedman move into the mainstream. Gerstel also separates neoliberalism from 18th-century classical liberalism, since neoliberals treat markets as human constructions that need law and contracts.

The middle of the discussion is about how both parties took up the new order. Foroohar presses the claim that Ronald Reagan and Bill Clinton differed little in practice on financial deregulation and trade. Gerstel traces Clinton's turn after the failed health plan and the 1994 midterm losses. He also covers Alan Greenspan's reappointment under successive presidents, the 1990s techno-utopianism that promised perfect information would make government superfluous, and the collapse of the Soviet alternative, which unsettled the left.

The later sections turn contentious. Gerstel describes the Lehman moment as an "extinction level event" and argues that Obama had other options: jailing bankers, temporarily nationalizing banks, and spending heavily on infrastructure while borrowing was cheap. He also argues that in the early 2000s fiscal policy to raise wages and strengthen unions would have served better than monetary stimulus. The talk then moves to the political aftershocks, including Donald Trump, Brexit, and Bernie Sanders, and to Joe Biden's surprising embrace of industrial policy through the infrastructure, chips, and inflation reduction acts. Gerstel and Foroohar consider a possible left-right overlap on labor, resilience, and security. They also ask how a post-neoliberal order can reconcile national and global interests in a world of four regional hegemons, a setting in which Putin's invasion of Ukraine looks like an overreach.

Sharpest takeaway

Gerstel argues that neoliberalism—a political order based on freeing capitalism from state regulation—emerged from the 1970s crisis as a dominant organizing principle for both American political parties, but is now breaking down as policymakers recognize that markets alone cannot solve fundamental problems of inequality, economic security, and worker prosperity, requiring a return to deliberate state intervention and industrial policy.

  • Neoliberalism succeeded the New Deal order when the 1970s economic crisis discredited Keynesian management and made previously marginal figures like Reagan and Hayek mainstream
  • Both Reagan Republicans and Clinton Democrats embraced neoliberal deregulation and financialization despite different rhetorical positions, showing the order's cross-party capture
  • The 2008 financial crisis and subsequent political volatility (Trump, Brexit, Sanders) signaled neoliberalism's collapse, and Biden's infrastructure, chips, and climate legislation represent an emerging industrial policy order based on stakeholder capitalism and state-guided markets

The claims · ranked35 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.84

The fall of the Soviet Union in 1991 and collapse of the notion that there was an alternative way to organize politics and society to capitalism caused a crisis among left-oriented people because even though they weren't Communists, they had clung to a socialist ideal and planning ideal, and this loss was devastating for organizing left politics.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Gary Gerstel

“one is the fall of the Soviet Union in 1991 and not just to follow the Soviet Union but the the collapse of the notion that there was an alternative way of organizing politics and Society to what the capitalist world offered... this caused a crisis among a lot of left-oriented people because even though they were not Communists and even though there was an understanding that there was a tremendous amount of tyranny within the Soviet system they had clung in some respect to a socialist ideal a planning ideal... and the collapse of the Soviet Union and the dream and bought that it had once embodied of doing that to a spectacular degree was just devastating for people who had believed this”

0.84

The IT Revolution and techno-utopianism of the 1990s promised that perfect information would lead to perfect markets and make government superfluous, because information would travel instantaneously to anyone in the world and eliminate the risk and imperfect information that had once justified state intervention.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Gary Gerstel

“the techno-utopianism of the period the I.T Revolution comes into full flower and um and a part of that Revolution was that we now speaking as a 1990s person have the ability to eliminate risk that there were problems with markets in the past because of imperfect information traveled too slow uh or didn't travel at all... what if you did have perfect information then perhaps markets could be perfected... the I.T Revolution is promising in the 1990s is an extraordinary amount of information available instantaneously to anyone in the world at any time of the day and night... markets could be perfected and thus while there had once been a need for government there no longer was”

0.80

Finance and the real economy have become unmoored from each other following Lehman Brothers' collapse, and the challenge since 2008 has been trying to reconnect them.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Rana Foroohar

“I called Steve roach um who's now professor at Yale but at the time of the crisis was in charge of Morgan Stanley Asia and I said after Lehman Brothers fell and I said what just happened and he said finance and the real economy have become unmoored from each other which I think was a a very profound insight and we're still trying to reconnect those things”

0.74

The New Deal political order was centered on the core idea that states ought to manage markets in the public interest in a democratic way, gained such prestige that it influenced American politics from the 1930s through the early 1970s, and was tested when Republican Eisenhower came to office in 1953 and chose to preserve rather than dismantle it, indicating the Democratic order had truly established itself.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Gary Gerstel

“the New Deal was a movement to manage capitalism in the public interest using Keynesian tools coming out of the crisis of the Great Depression uh and we thought there was a core idea of the New Deal which was simply that states ought to manage markets in the public interest in a democratic way that gained so much prestige in the United States that it influenced not just the 30s and 40s but went on to influence the 1950s 60s into the early 70s... when Dwight D Eisenhower the first Republican president in 20 years comes into office in early 53 the big question is will he dismantle the New Deal or will he preserve it and he preserved the New Deal”

0.71

Despite the severity of the 2008 crisis justifying emergency responses, Obama had other alternatives available: he could have jailed bankers, required bankers to run the gauntlet before Congress, temporarily nationalized several banks as warning signs, and invested his political energy in massive infrastructure spending during quantitative easing when borrowing costs were lowest.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Gary Gerstel

“Obama had other Alternatives open to him he a note Banker was sent to jail no Banker was made to run the gauntlet going before Congress he could have nationalized several Banks uh as a as as as a warning sign at least temporarily... if he had put a lot more of his energy into um using that moment of quantitative easing for a huge infrastructural plan to rebuild American Society at a time when there was no interest on any loans it would have been the cheapest time and and it'll in almost the last hundred years to rebuild American infrastructure”

0.69

The economic crisis of the 1970s—including the Great Recession, rebalancing of power between the Global North and Global South over petroleum, and the resurgence of Europe and Japan as competitors—disrupted the New Deal political order because Keynesian techniques suddenly stopped working.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Gary Gerstel

“the major economic crisis that disrupted the New Deal order was the economic crisis of the 70s the Great Recession the rebalancing of relations between Global North and Global south over the issue of petroleum the Resurgence of Europe and Japan to become competitors of the U.S after World War II suddenly Keynesian techniques were no longer working there was a lot of distress in the American economy and the New Deal order began to break up”

0.69

Neoliberals like Hayek and Friedman, who had been marginal and regarded as heterodox and unworkable in the 1940s, 1950s, and early 1960s, became mainstream and 'all the rage' in the 1970s when the economic crisis created openings for previously excluded ideas to be conscripted into mainstream politics.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Gary Gerstel

“neoliberals like Hayek and Friedman and one of their tribunes Ronald Reagan all of whom have been working for a neoliberal world since the late 40s and early 50s they were largely Irrelevant in American politics in the 40s 50s and and early 60s and and suddenly in the 70s they become all the rage this is an example of ideas that were regarded as heterodox unworkable marginal sliding into the mainstream”

0.69

Clinton's health care plan failed in his first year and a half, he lost both houses of Congress to Republicans in 1994, and subsequently shifted to embrace Bob Rubin's neoliberal group, Alan Greenspan at the Fed, and full deregulation—a moment of transition when neoliberalism became ascendant within the Democratic Party.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Gary Gerstel

“Clinton when he came into office had some other ideas but his first year and a half or so were disastrous with his health care plan and then he becomes the first Democratic president since Harry Truman in the late 40s to lose both houses of Congress in 1994 to Republicans and he completely changes and he wants to get reelected and this is the moment of transition when Bob Rubin and his group Ascend along with Alan Greenspan at the Federal Reserve”

0.69

Alan Greenspan's monetary policy focused solely on managing the economy through monetary means and was perfectly comfortable with financialization and financial asset performance, measuring economic success primarily by how well financial assets were performing.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Gary Gerstel

“he believed that monetary policy uh was the only tool that should be used to manage the manage the economy and he was perfectly comfortable with Financial assets and uh financialization and he was very concerned about the [Music] the maintaining Financial assets and having them perform well for him that was the uh truest measure of economic success”

0.69

In September-October 2008, policy makers facing the possibility of Lehman Brothers' collapse and subsequent financial system collapse confronted an 'extinction level event' for the global financial system, an unprecedented moment in modern history analogous only to the Cuban Missile Crisis of 1962 as a moment of existential fright.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Gary Gerstel

“I've studied September and October 2008 quite closely and the policy makers who were involved in about 18 days uh beginning with the failure of Lehman Brothers... they are looking at the perhaps the entire the collapse of the entire Global Financial system an unprecedented event in modern history and one economic person on Wall Street refers to it as an extinction level event... the only analogous moment of fright and fear... the only inaug analogous event that I can think of in modern American history is the Cuban Missile Crisis of 1962 13 days in October where the world was facing nuclear Annihilation”

0.69

The 2008 financial crisis became a major political shift point, with effects delayed into the 2010s through political volatility including Trump, Brexit, near-collapse of the EU over Greece, rise of authoritarianism, Bernie Sanders becoming the second most successful socialist in American history, and Trump and Sanders emerging as the two most dynamic players in the 2016 election.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Gary Gerstel

“I think uh in political terms it does become a major shift Point although the effects are somewhat delayed if we think of the political volatility of the 20 teens and all the shocks Trump yeah brexit the EU almost falling apart over over Greece uh the rise of authoritarianism in the world um an unknown Vermont socialist becoming the second most successful socialist in American history a man by the name of Bernie Sanders uh and he and Trump becoming the most the two most dynamic players in the 2016 election”

0.69

Governments are now worried about having access to vital materials the economy needs and can't get them, and can't rely on supply chains stretching around the world, so a different way of thinking about economic security and resilience has re-emerged as a result of the pandemic and the war in Ukraine.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Gary Gerstel

“government has to provide for the security of the American people understood as both Economic Security and Military security these Tendencies have been accentuated as a result of the pandemic and the war in Ukraine suddenly governments are worried about having access to vital materials that the economy needs and it can't get them anymore and it realizes it can't rely on uh supply chain stretching halfway around the world so a whole different way of thinking has has re-emerged”

0.69

Neoliberalism is fundamentally a philosophy that desires to free capitalism from regulation, emerging after the state-managed economies of the 1930s and 1940s, premised on the belief that releasing capitalism's animal spirits will generate prosperity and innovation, with the caveat that inequality generated by this process is acceptable because all boats will rise.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Gary Gerstel

“it's a philosophy that desires to free capitalism from its Fetters it emerges after a period of the heavily State managed economies of the 1930s and 40s... it preaches that economic growth will be best Prosperity will be best if the animal spirits of capitalism are released from regulation... there is acknowledgment among neoliberals that allowing capitalism to do what it will relatively unrestrained will generate increased inequality... but this is deemed acceptable because of the motto All votes will rise”

0.68

What should have been done in the early 2000s, instead of relying on monetary stimulus, was fiscal policy to raise wages through progressive taxation and strengthening labor unions' bargaining power, which would have provided sustainable consumer demand and potentially averted the financial crisis.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Gary Gerstel

“what was needed in the early years of the 2000s is the is what Elizabeth Warren was arguing for against Jerome Powell... it's not enough simply to ease monetary policy to create conditions in which people can borrow money at low interest rates what you really needed to do to sustain better consuming power was to transfer higher wages into the hands of ordinary people... a policy that was oriented toward raising wages in the early years of the 2000s might have been a much healthier road for the economy to travel and they have averted the great financial crisis... and so this is an argument perhaps for uh adopting fiscal policies rather than simply relying on monetary means... progressive taxation uh strengthening the hand of labor unions so they can bargain more effectively with their employers”

0.63

Subprime mortgages became central to first national and then global economics in the late 1990s and first decade of the 21st century, and were the most proximate cause of the great financial crisis of 2008-2009.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Gary Gerstel

“the prime example of this is the subprime mortgage which becomes so Central to First National and then Global economics in the in the late 1990s and first decade of the 21st century and that's going to be the most proximate cause of the great financial crash of 2008-2009”

0.63

Greenspan was reappointed as Fed chairman under every successive president (George H.W. Bush, Clinton, and George W. Bush), which is a sign of the deep neoliberal consensus across both parties.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Gary Gerstel

“it's a sign of the neoliberal consensus that he was he kept on getting reappointed as chairman of the Federal Reserve first appointed by George H.W bush and then reappointed by um Clinton and then reappointed by uh by Bush”

0.62

Both Reagan and Bush (conservatives) and Clinton and Obama (liberals) were all neoliberals, with very little practical difference between Reagan's deregulation of finance and Clinton's Bob Rubin-driven deregulation, and between Reagan's trade policies and Clinton's NAFTA and WTO commitments.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Rana Foroohar

“you point out in your book uh that Reagan and Bush were conservatives Clinton and Barack Obama were liberals but they were all neo-liberals and that is certainly true I mean you know there's very little air between the deregulation of Finance under you know Bob Rubin and and some of the trade deals that were cut under Clinton and the the ethos in some ways of what the Reagan Thatcher Revolution was all about”

0.59

A political order is not defined by election cycles but by structures that persist across 20-30-40 year intervals, defined by reliable constituencies, core animating ideas, and a particular vision of the good life that can convince large populations to orient themselves toward it.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Gary Gerstel

“we gave political order a particular meeting as it applied to the United States... we were dissatisfied with the writing of political history in the U.S which focused so much on two four and six year election Cycles... we were interested in loggers stretches of time and understanding political developments that had to be understood in 20 30 40-year intervals... a political movement in other words became a political order what does that mean uh reliable constituencies who turn out for Democrats election after election core ideas that animate politics uh a particular vision of the good life”

0.56

Neoliberalism had natural cosmopolitanism and globalism that allowed it to square the circle between national and global interests, but a key challenge for the emerging post-neoliberal order is connecting national interests and global interests in ways that are mutually beneficial.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Rana Foroohar

“the nice thing about neoliberalism was that it had a kind of a natural cosmopolitanism a natural globalism that um squared those two circles at least in theory... there's a I know you know working in a British newspaper working with European colleagues I think in Europe in particular there's a sense of where do we fit in this new world... where do we go from here at a global level well great question I wish I could answer it the um yeah neoliberalism uh was had this this Global aspiration and the cosmopolitanism was a feature of it that I much admired”

0.56

In a world order with four regional hegemons where boundaries (both physical and power) are unclear, players can make costly mistakes by overstepping their bounds, as Putin appears to have done in invading Ukraine, leading to destabilization.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Gary Gerstel

“if I'm right about and I'll be interested to hear your ideas about whether we are passing to a new world order the passage is perilous because the different players are not certain of their boundaries and what I mean by that are both physical boundaries and the boundaries of their power and this is part of what Ukraine is about so Putin who I used to think of as being a very clever scheming strategist very successful at advancing the strategies that he wanted for his Nation you like them or not I felt you had to respect that he clearly made the biggest mistake of his life and and his regime in invading Ukraine and this is an example of how the rules of an of an emerging New World Order are not clear”

0.55

Biden's infrastructure bill, chips reshoring act, and inflation reduction act represent three pieces of coherent industrial policy showing that markets can no longer be allowed to make all critical economic decisions alone and must be guided by government to provide economic and military security.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Gary Gerstel

“I think there's coherence to the legislation that Biden has gotten through and here I'm thinking of the the trillion dollar infrastructure bill the um the massive chips reshoring act to begin producing semiconductors in a massive way in the U.S and also the 400 billion dollar program for green energy misnamed or or teasingly named the inflation reduction act yeah if we add these three pieces of legislation together we begin to discern that Biden has an industrial policy and what does this industrial policy it means that um markets can no longer be allowed to make all the critical economic decisions themselves they have to be guided by government that government has to provide for the security of the American people understood as both Economic Security and Military security these Tendencies have been accentuated as a result of the pandemic and the war in Ukraine suddenly governments are worried about having access to vital materials that the economy needs and it can't get them anymore and it realizes it can't rely on uh supply chain stretching halfway around the world so a whole different way of thinking has has re-emerged and Biden understands that this is his project”

0.55

Biden has been a surprising figure who has embraced post-neoliberal politics that contrast with his moderate career as a Delaware senator and vice president, suggesting his path to the presidency changed him and he perceived the US and world were at an inflection point requiring abandonment of neoliberalism and forging of new democratic politics.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Gary Gerstel

“Biden... has been a surprise he's he's been a revelation the kinds of politics that he has embraced hard to discern and have very long but only moderately distinguished career as senator from Delaware... Gary ellisman a fun man to be around but not someone who often stuck his head out or innovated um... I think when his path to the presidency and being elected president uh changed him and he was able to perceive that uh the U.S and the world much of the world was at an inflection point and that the politics that he had grown up with himself being part of the neoliberal world uh had to be abandoned uh and a new kind of democratic politics forged”

0.53

There is overlap emerging between left coalition concerns (labor, worker power) and right coalition concerns (national security, efficiency, resilience), suggesting potential bipartisan agreement that could establish a new political order.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Rana Foroohar

“there are some encouraging signs there you know Josh Hawley is also himself very Anti-Trust well and and Marco Rubio to a certain extent I mean I think there is a over overlap interestingly it's I think it started as you pointed out in the far right far left Trump and Sanders were different responses to a feeling of being um you know sold out by the center and now there's a left Coalition that cares about Labor there's a right uh Coalition that cares about National Security and maybe efficiency and resilience that are coming together”

0.52

Herbert Hoover was one of the most accomplished men to become president, but after the Great Depression made his approach irrelevant, he tried to reinvent himself as a neoliberal critic of Roosevelt by the mid-to-late 1930s, but remained politically irrelevant his entire life because the New Deal political order prevented him from gaining traction, until he founded the Hoover Institution which later became a key neoliberal think tank.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Gary Gerstel

“Hoover Uh was um one of the most accomplished men ever to hold the office the president of the United States... and then the Great Depression strikes he's unable to respond to the magnitude of the Calamity... he becomes within a few years one of the most reviled presidents... he tries to um Rebrand himself as the first of the American neoliberals uh and by the mid to late 30s and tries to become a Critic of Roosevelt... he remains Irrelevant for uh the entire rest of his life... with one exception he established the Hoover Institution... it will Rebrand itself in the 1960s and 70s as a think tank and it's got to become one of the leading Lights of the neoliberal Revolution”

0.52

A Clinton administration official told AFL-CIO head Richard Trumka that trade deals and globalization would hurt US labor but eventually lead to global wage equalization, requiring 3 to 5 generations, reflecting the hubris of neoliberal economic thinking in modeling complexity over such long timeframes based on algorithmic assumptions.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Rana Foroohar

“the former head of the AFL-CIO in America Richard tremka... I was asking what were the conversations that you were having with the Clinton administration at that point and he told me a fascinating story... a policy maker from the name frustration had come to him and said you know we know these trade deals and the sort of globalization thing is going to hurt U.S labor but don't worry eventually there's going to be a leveling out or a leveling up of wages and they're going to equalize globally and trumpka said well how long is that going to take and the policy maker said three to five generations”

0.52

When the dot-com bubble burst in the early 2000s, Greenspan followed with easy money policy to stimulate recovery, but employment and wages did not pick up as expected, and this failure was tied to a deeper problem: the global productive capacity his policies had generated was not being matched by sufficient consumer demand, particularly from American consumers who disproportionately drive global consumption.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Gary Gerstel

“there's a.com bubble that bursts in the early 2000s and he follows that with the easy money policy to stimulate that sector and other sectors back to full health uh but even though um monetary uh policy is very loose at the time he is surprised that employment is not picking up more than it had that wages are not picking up more than it had... the consuming power of the world's population in which Americans held a disproportionate influence because American consumers consume vastly disproportionate amount of the consumer goods in the world the the consumption was not reaching the levels that it needed to to satisfy the product the global productive capacities of the global economy”

0.52

It's not clear that Al Gore or Barack Obama would have chosen a different path than easy money, since they were also under the neoliberal spell, indicating that neoliberalism's influence went deep into Democratic Party thinking across multiple administrations.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Gary Gerstel

“it's not enough to say well if Gore had been president in fact looks like he did win the presidency in 2000 2001. it's not clear he would have made that move because he and like Clinton before him were under the neoliberal spell and either even Obama has trouble breaking the neoliberal spell”

0.52

Biden's executive order in summer 2021, crafted with Tim Wu, declared the end of shareholder value maximization (Milton Friedman's doctrine) and committed to stakeholder capitalism focused on stakeholders, communities, income growth, and businesses of all sizes, representing a major ideological shift away from neoliberalism.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Rana Foroohar

“the executive order that came out in um in the summer of 2021 that Tim Wu Columbia Scott legal scholar helped to craft and in it Biden said you know what shareholder value Milton Friedman that's all over we're in a new world now it's not all about stock prices going up consumer price is going down it's about stakeholders it's about communities it's about income growth it's about businesses of all sizes not just multinationals but small businesses entrepreneurship it's about diversity 72 different um parts of that asking every portion of government to look at concentration of power on the labor Capital balance”

0.52

Neoliberals distinguish themselves from 18th-century classical liberals by insisting that markets are human creations requiring law and contracts to be built and perfected, not natural spontaneous phenomena, meaning government activity is acceptable insofar as it strengthens markets rather than regulates other economic behavior.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Gary Gerstel

“one of the ways in which neoliberals distinguish themselves from classical liberals is to insist that markets need work they are human Creations they have to be managed to a certain extent so government activity is allowed and so far it's as it's going to strengthen markets rather than regulate too many other aspects of economic behavior”

0.51

Joe Stiglitz has admitted upon reflection that he himself got seduced by deregulatory principles in the 1990s Clinton Administration even though he was on the left of the administration and opposed Bob Rubin's views, showing how a political order 'orders your thinking' so that even trained economists with convictions become drawn into its framework.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Gary Gerstel

“stiglets may be even more interesting because uh he admits that he himself got seduced by certainly a liberal principles or deregulatory principles and reflecting back on his years working in the Clinton Administration as an economic advisor he quotes John F Kennedy visiting Berlin in the early 60s saying we are all berliners now... and then stiglitz goes on to say little did I know we were all deregulators in some respects in the 1990s he did not understand that at the time... as he reflected on it he said I too was taken in by this and um uh and this is how a political order works it it orders your thinking”

0.49

Are we phasing out of pax Americana and was neoliberalism the last gasp of pax Americana, facing a potential transition to a world order directed by four regional hegemons: America, Europe, China, and Russia, possibly joined by India or Brazil—a world order similar to the pre-1815 Congress of Vienna system that hasn't existed for 170 years.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Gary Gerstel

“are are we phasing out of pax Americana are we is is the neoliberal world was that a was that the last gasp of pax Americana... we may be moving to a different world order that's we will not be able to characterize as Pax Americana it may be a World Order uh directed by four Regional hegemons yeah America being one Europe being a second China being a third obviously um Russia probably a fourth although that's become harder to predict maybe a fifth in India or or Brazil... this may this may be what the world looks like in 2050 2060 and I actually think the world can live with that um we the world's had it before the problem for us is we haven't had it in like 170 years”

0.49

Tim Wu's manifesto about stakeholder capitalism and the Biden administration's post-neoliberal ideas may one day be seen as the beginning of a new progressive political order, but the ideas have not yet established themselves as a true order because they have not yet compelled people on the other side of the aisle to share those views.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Gary Gerstel

“Tim Wu is a one of a number of people who I would characterize as broadly left who have been brought into important positions in the Biden Administration... the question is can the policy achievements of the Biden Administration be translated into victories at the polls that are going to provide the basis for establishing a new Progressive political order... the ideas are there Tim Wu has written a Manifesto that may one day be hailed as the beginning of a new Progressive order but we are in the early days of that political movement it has not yet established itself as an order it we are it is not close to compelling people on the other side of the aisle to sharing in those views”

0.48

Tim Wu is one of several people characterized as broadly left who have been brought into important positions in the Biden administration, suggesting a deliberate strategy to bring progressive economic thinkers into power.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Gary Gerstel

“Tim Wu is a one of a number of people who I would characterize as broadly left who have been brought into important positions in the Biden Administration uh so um I like what I see in this regard”

0.46

The Democratic Party has been most successful in the 20th century when dialogue between the left and center of the party has been full, robust, ongoing, and effective, which was true under Wilson (Progressive Era), Roosevelt (New Deal), and Lyndon Johnson (Civil Rights), but hasn't happened since then until Biden.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Gary Gerstel

“with the Democratic party in it in the last hundred years has been most successful when that discussion between the left and the center of the democratic party is full robust ongoing effective... it's never an easy relationship because there are differences real differences between the center and the left but if those two wings of the democratic party are in dialogue this is when the Democratic Party in the 20th century has been most successful is true under Wilson in the Progressive Era Roosevelt during the New Deal Lyndon Johnson during the Civil Rights moment of the 1960s it really has not happened since then and it's happening again now”

0.20

Rana's book 'Homecoming' presents an inspiring vision of American and global future possibilities, and the rise and fall of the neoliberal order is required reading for understanding both historical conditions and future possibilities, making these two books complementary visions of post-neoliberal futures.

normativespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Rana Foroohar

“before before you conclude if I can just interject that you have written one of the most inspiring books about America in the future that I have read in some time called homecoming listeners look for it um it opens uh no payments going back and forth no it opens a world of possibility in America and for the world that um in this tough time uh was a real tonic and a real source of Hope well thank you Gary I would say right back at you the rise involved in neoliberal order is absolutely required reading um for the history of where we have been and where we might be going”