What this covers

Preet Bharara talks with Anne Applebaum, the historian and Atlantic writer, about the Trump administration's second term. The conversation starts with the administration's attitude toward the rule of law and moves to the ICE crackdown in Minneapolis, which Applebaum says shifted public opinion. She notes that Donald Trump went from strong polling on immigration to being underwater on it after sweeps that caught daycare workers, people with legal status, and more than 150 U.S. citizens. The talk then widens to the international order, using Mark Carney's Davos speech as its anchor.

Much of the argument is about what kind of government this is. Applebaum calls it radical rather than conservative, closer in mentality to the Bolsheviks than to a Burkean who wants to conserve institutions, and she is blunt about Stephen Miller's use of fascist and communist language. She treats the first term as rehearsal: Trump got away with everything, January 6th included, and the second-term staff sympathize with it. Her claim that a "decency" appeal no longer works, as it did against Joseph McCarthy, is contested, as is her broader reading of why democracies are fragile. She also draws on Hungary, Turkey, and Venezuela for how rights get chipped away.

On foreign policy, she defines rupture through Rome after Julius Caesar, which never returned to being a republic. She argues that Trump's complaints about NATO burden-sharing are factually shaky and are pushing Europeans toward defense and intelligence independence. She also forecasts that economic consequences will arrive gradually, through countless decisions not to invest, rather than in one break. Other threads include the failed hope that trade would democratize autocracies, the Navalny corruption playbook as a model for opposition messaging, and Poland's 2023 election as evidence that rule-of-law issues can be tied to everyday concerns.

Sharpest takeaway

The Trump administration is a radical, not conservative, force pursuing institutional destruction aligned with autocratic methods, having abandoned rule of law restraints after January 6th, while this rupture in American democracy and international alliances will have profound but delayed economic and geopolitical consequences.

  • The administration is populated by people who sympathize with January 6th and the assault on democracy, and are dedicated to continuing that destruction rather than preserving institutions
  • American disregard for rule of law in ICE operations, conflicts of interest, and unilateral executive changes mirrors the brutality-normalization tactics of modern autocracies like Russia and China
  • The rupture with NATO and allies will not break overnight but will cause gradual divestment, slower economic growth, and loss of American leadership advantages built after WWII

The claims · ranked43 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.79

Alexei Navalny, the most successful Russian opposition leader, used corruption messaging about the regime's palatial luxury and gold bathroom taps (their money) to explain why ordinary Russians had bad hospitals, making corruption comprehensible and actionable for people, a tactic that is available and true for American political opponents to use.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“this is what the Russian opposition the most successful Russian opposition leader um Alexi Noni did was he talked about corruption, but you know their corruption, their palaces, you know, their gold taps in the bathrooms, that's your money. That that's why you have bad hospitals. And that made sense to people. And I think that's an argument that's there for the taking, not least because it's true.”

0.76

Historically, autocratic regimes' mistakes that cause people to finally recoil include violent overreach (as in Ukrainian Maidan 2014 drawing ordinary people to streets), contrast between regime claims and observable truth (especially when lies are easily countered by video evidence), and when people become desperate and think they have no other choice, they will defy death and protest despite consequences.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“it it's very hard to be general because it depends on the specific country but it can be violent overreach. I mean it was the use of violence for example in the Ukrainian Maidan in 2014 that brought a lot of ordinary people who weren't normally protesters onto the street...sometimes it's the contrast between what the regime says and what people know to be true. And there's an element of that here too as well...When they when they lie and when their lies are very obvious and easily countered. I mean, in the case of these two murders, as they were by the tapes of the murders...there's a point at which, you know, when people become very desperate or when they think they have no other choice anymore, then they will then they'll protest and defy death”

0.73

Instead of democracies spreading ideas to trading partners, what happened was that autocracies like Russia and China began seeking to spread different ideas back, including building up far right and far left movements across Europe and using bribery to affect politics in different countries.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“And instead, what happened was that those ideas began to threaten our trading partners. And they um you know, and they began seeking to spread different ideas back to us. So, this is where you've got um you know, the Russians seeking to um you know, build up the far right or sometimes the far left and all over Europe and elsewhere. and and you saw you see both Russia and China using bribery in some cases in different countries to try to to try to affect politics.”

0.69

Democracy was also a product of an expectation of decency—the founding fathers believed the president would be a good person and nobody would vote for a bad person, an assumption that has proven wrong.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“it was also the product of a certain expectation of decency. I mean the you know the founding fathers believed that the person who would be president would be a good person you know and that nobody would vote for a bad person. Um, and you know, obviously that was that that was wrong.”

0.69

A 'rupture' means some things will not be repaired in the same way—the example being Rome after Julius Caesar, which never went back to having a republic, suggesting that even if NATO is reinvented by a future president or Europeans find new answers, fundamental change has occurred that cannot be undone.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“look, I mean after Julius Caesar, Rome never went back to having a republic. So I I you know I think some things have changed that will not be repaired...it may be that it can be reinvented it may be that um a future American president can you know find ways to to you know heal or or fix some of the problems it may be that uh the Europeans are um you know are going to are going to find new answers...So things will things are going to change and are changing already.”

0.68

When the US was attacked on 9/11, NATO Article 5 was invoked and European countries, sometimes at great political and military cost, sent troops to Iraq and Afghanistan—wars that were not especially popular in Europe but which the US requested NATO to support.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Anne Applebaum

“The one moment when they were when they when the US was attacked and they were asked to do something absolutely stood up, you know, after 9/11, you know, article 5 was declared and you know, European countries sometimes at great political cost to themselves as well as you know, as as well as the lives of their soldiers sent soldiers to Iraq and to Afghanistan. um wars that were not especially popular or necessary in Europe, but the United States had asked uh had asked NATO to contribute and so they did.”

0.65

This administration is a radical administration, not a conservative one, because conservatives believe in conserving things, moving slowly, and taking care not to smash up institutions because they know institutions are hard to rebuild, whereas this group of people does not care about any of that, exhibiting a mentality much closer to the Bolsheviks than to Burkian conservatism.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“It is really important to understand that this is a radical administration. It is not a conservative administration...conservatives believe in conserving things and in moving slowly and in taking care not to smash things up because conservatives know that it can be hard to rebuild them institutions again. And this is a group of people who don't care about any of that. You know, this is some a mentality much closer to the Bolsheviks, I would say, than to I don't know, Burkian conservatism of the past.”

0.62

A significant portion of the population either did not care that Donald Trump attacked the Congress and Capitol on January 6, 2021, or thought it was good, but the greater concern is Republican politicians in Congress who are unwilling to hold him to account or defend Congress's traditional constitutional rights and abilities.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“Clearly, there is a percentage of the population that either didn't care that Donald Trump had attacked uh the Congress and the capital on January the 6 in in 2021. Either they didn't care or they thought it was good. Um I think right now the greater concern is the Republican politicians in Congress who are not willing to hold him to account or even to stand up for what are traditional rights of Congress.”

0.61

Democracies are fragile not because of their form but because they are unusual in human history—most people over thousands of years lived in autocracy, monarchy, tribalism, or warlordism, and democracies were made possible by Enlightenment thinking, popular information, and basic education, so the question is whether democracies can survive new forms of communication and technology.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“It's not about democracy being fragile. Democracies are unusual. If you look back on human history, there haven't been very many. And most humanity, you know, over over thousands of years have lived in what we would describe as an autocracy, a monarchy or a tribal system or some kind of warlordism. That was normal for most people over time. in democracies um have were made possible by the thinking of the enlightenment by um the existence of popular information by some kind of basic level of education. I mean there were a lot of things that made democracy be possible in the 18th and 19th centuries that where it wasn't before. Um the question is whether it can survive the new forms of communication and new kinds of technology whether surveillance technology or AI or um you know or as I said the the this the the superficiality and the speed of information that most of us now receive.”

0.61

The assumption that decency appeals ('Have you no sense of decency, sir?') would break Trump's support (as McCarthy faced) is no longer valid because the category of decency itself is not felt by everybody anymore, reflecting cultural change from the 1950s driven by internet information dynamics, hardening of hearts from exposure to constant violence/tragedy/murder imagery, and possible influences from Hollywood and video games.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“I am not sure that this category of decency is felt by everybody anymore...I think it's a change. I mean, certainly from the 1950s. Um and I am, you know, the the the cultural forces that created this moment are too great for me to pick on one thing. I mean, it's clearly something to do with the way people now get information on the internet. The the the hardening of hearts of people who see millions of images every day and you see images of, you know, death and murder and violence and and and and tragedy and you just click and move on, right? And so, we've all got used to doing that. And that's clearly affecting people. I mean, maybe there's some blame for Hollywood. I don't know. I mean, maybe there's some blame for video games. I don't I mean there's a there there's a lot there's a lot to go around. I mean but there is some profound coarsening of the culture that both made Trump possible and he in turn has accelerated that coarsening.”

0.61

Stephen Miller knowingly uses radical language from fascist and communist traditions, willing to call for a non-citizen non-immigrant population (whether implying slavery or underclass creation), is interested in breaking conventions, and appeals to Trump's similar interest in smashing things and saying the unsayable, alongside Nick Fuentes and pro-Nazi figures in the administration's orbit.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Anne Applebaum

“he is somebody who knowingly uses the most radical language he can find. Some of it comes from the fascist world. Some of it comes almost from the communist world. You know, he's very willing to say the more or less we need, you know, we need a foreignb born population that is that are not citizens. Whether that means he wants slavery back or whether he wants some kind of underclass uh to be created. I mean, he's willing to he's somebody who's interested in breaking and defying conventions of all kinds...Trump also likes this idea of smashing things and breaking convention and, you know, saying the unsayable, you know, you know, whether it's and there's a there there's a group of people around this administration or in its orbit like Nick Fuentes who's openly pro-Nazi and others um who who are finding that that um that breaking those taboos is”

0.58

The process by which people elected to leadership have historically undermined democracy—exemplified in Hungary, Turkey, and Venezuela—involves slow chipping away at rights, convincing voters that only their political enemies or disfavored ethnic/minority groups will suffer, and Trump has done this much faster than previous leaders, suggesting part of the population was already primed to accept the erosion of rights.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“if you look at Hungary or if you look at Turkey or if you look at um you know you Venezuela actually any any one of those countries where you had somebody who was elected to office legitimately then taking power and seeking to undermine the state. It almost always happened through a process of slow chipping away of um you know of of of saying to people that they weren't really losing anything or convincing their voters that it was only other people who were losing something...Trump has done it much faster than any of those any of those previous leaders, which leads me to believe that some part of the population was primed already to accept it”

0.57

Trump went from being 'way way way up politically and poll-wise on the issue of immigration and the border' to being underwater on it because ICE overreach in Minneapolis arrested daycare workers and children, people with legal status, people renewing immigration papers, and over 150 US citizens, revealing the gap between promised immigration enforcement and actual indiscriminate sweeps.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Anne Applebaum

“How do you go from being way way way up politically and poll-wise on the issue of immigration and the border to being underwater on it? Um, I guess the answer is because of, you know, the overreach in Minneapolis. I mean, you know, also, you know, Trump told people, 'Oh, we're going to we're arresting these criminals and thieves and rapists who are among us.' And then it turned out that's not what they were doing. They were rounding up, you know, people who worked in daycare centers and children and, you know, the guy who mows your lawn. Um, and not only were they doing that, they were also rounding up people who had legal status in the United States. They were arresting people who went to have their immigration papers renewed or their cases examined...I mean the running tab keeps changing, but it's it's certainly over 150. I mean there have been US citizens who've been locked up um for no reason”

0.55

It is possible to connect rule of law and rights issues to things ordinary people understand, as demonstrated by Polish pro-rule of law parties in the 2023 election, which connected illegal undermining of courts to concrete incidents people understood, and this shows Democrats do not need to choose between democracy and economic ('kitchen table') messaging.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“So I think it is very possible to connect the democracy issues or however you want to describe them the issues of rule of law, the issues of rights. It is perfectly possible to connect those to things that that ordinary people understand. Um this is I mean this is um you know this is a it's a it's a site issue and this was we had an election here in Poland in 2023 where there were also democracy issues at stake and one of the reasons that a coalition of um I'd say pro- rule of law parties finally won was because they were able to connect here it was a question of the the an illegal illegal undermining of the courts and they were able to connect that issue to things that ordinary people understood or to incidents that had recently happened. So I think it's I think it's very possible to do both. I'm not sure why there has to be a choice.”

0.55

The world after WWII that brought American prosperity was built on allies, trading partners, international laws of the sea and aviation, making travel and transport possible, and giving the US benefits because people wanted a special relationship with the U.S. as the protector country, and all of this will fall away if the U.S. alienates allies.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“the world that we created after the Second World War and that brought us prosperity and made us for better and for worse the richest and most powerful country in the world was a world where we had allies and we had trading partners and we built, you know, the laws of the sea and the laws of international aviation and we made travel and transport possible and we made um and we and we also created a world in which we were um the recipient of all kinds of laress that we never acknowledged. I mean, why did people buy our airplanes or our um our infrastructure? They did it not just because it was really good, but also because, you know, we were the protector country and so people wanted a special relationship with the United States. And all that will fall away. Um and the United States won't be automatically able to count on friends, whether it's in financial markets or in business or in trade um or in politics.”

0.55

NATO burden-sharing criticism is factually wrong because the US spending percentage includes global operations outside NATO (Pacific, Middle East, Africa), whereas Europe's NATO spending doesn't include global operations, so if you count only Europe's defense spending versus all U.S. military spending, Europeans are ahead of the United States.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“Um that's not how NATO works. This has been said so many times. It's incredible that we have to continue well not not paying the not paying the u aspirational percentage of GDP. people. Well, the US's percentage of GDP was was first of all for US operations around the world. It's true NATO doesn't have operations in the Pacific and we don't and they you know the British have an aircraft carrier one or two others have some assets in the Pacific but no they don't have that and it was the US that has bases in the Middle East and in Africa and and around the world and no Europeans don't have that...if you look at the percentage of spending in Europe as opposed to all over the world then as you know I believe Europeans are well ahead of the United States.”

0.55

American decisions about military leadership (satellite intelligence, global bases, Middle East operations) were made by Americans for American advantage, not imposed on reluctant Europeans, and the U.S. got benefits and concessions from this arrangement as the protector country.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“a lot of these you know decisions about American leadership were I mean Americans wanted to do these things. They wanted to be the leaders. they wanted to create the systems of you know you know this the satellite intelligence systems and so on um and they got advantages from doing so as I've just said you know the United States got benefits and it got concessions and it got you know good economic treatment”

0.55

Trump's publicly stating that European NATO members don't do much has backfired by accelerating new European defense and intelligence projects designed to replace the United States, making Trump's criticism self-fulfilling by spurring European independence.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“do you think I mean there's some there is some use to him saying it out loud if that's what he thinks because then you're now getting this really hyper new European defense projects including some tech projects and including intelligence projects that are now designed to replace the United States. And so that will that's beginning to happen probably faster than it would have done if he hadn't said those things. But that doesn't make them true. And it and it doesn't mean that it's going to be good for America that he's said that.”

0.55

The belief that engaging in trade with autocratic regimes would create democracy has failed, and trade with autocracies does not necessarily create democracy or peace, contrary to 1990s expectations based on post-WWII European integration.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“You've also suggested that another thing that has changed is the view that engaging in trade with autocratic regimes fails and some don't always fail that it doesn't it doesn't create democracy. Yeah. From my civilian seats um it seems that and I think that's a reasonable observation that economic engagement fails...economic engagement the idea starting in the '9s and I have a lot of sympathy with the people of the 1990s because at that time they had the experience of the you know the reintegration of Europe after World War II and they had experiences that led them to believe that you know economic ties would lead to better political ties and and they thought that if you connected the world economically then you would have a peaceful world because nobody would want to go to war with their trading partners.”

0.52

The first Trump term was preparation for the second term because he got away with an enormous amount, surrounded by people cautious about boundaries (both domestically and in foreign policy), but he got away with everything including January 6th, and now the second-term administration is populated by people who sympathize with January 6th and are dedicated to continuing destruction.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“I think the you know the first term was preparation for the second term in this sense. You know in the first term they got away with an enormous amount. I mean Trump was still surrounded by people who were cautious who wanted him to um you know this is true domestically and in foreign policy as well who wanted him to keep within some kind of normal boundaries. Uh and they were all everybody around him was dedicated to doing that. But the fact is that he got away with everything he got away with and then more importantly he got away with January the 6th...anybody who sympathized with that assault, whether because they dislike democracy...or because they feel so much disgust for the country...all of those people who agreed with the sympathy behind that then went to work for Donald Trump in the second term. Um and so the administration is now populated by people who know he got away with it, who agree with what he did, and who are anxious to continue whatever. I mean, I think they some of them have different goals and so they're I wouldn't say they're all the same, but whatever whatever version of of destruction or rebellion or transformation they think is happening, they want to continue.”

0.52

The decline of the UN system and perceptions by Russia and China that international human rights and rule of law language weren't good for them and Putin and Xi personally led them to retreat from those forums or change how people talk about them.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“So why is hard to say. I mean it's to do with decline of the UN system. It's to do with um the perceptions especially in Russia and China that um the language of international human rights and rule of law wasn't good for them for the well for Putin and she personally um and so they decided to retreat from those fora or to try to change the way people talk in them.”

0.52

The administration's profound disregard for the rule of law is demonstrated in federal agents working with ICE having impunity to attack and kill people with no responsibility or possibility of investigation, Trump and his family accepting conflicts of interest and direct payments to Trump companies, DOGE and cabinet secretaries changing rules without Congressional authorization or legal basis, and undermining science and health.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Anne Applebaum

“I think the thing that worries me the most is this administration's profound disregard for the rule of law. And whether that's in allowing federal agents working for or with ICE to have impunity to be able to attack people and kill people with apparently not no no responsibility, no no possibility of investigating them...Trump and his family's willingness to accept all kinds of conflicts of interest and even direct payments into Trump companies...whether it's whether it's Doge or whether it's individual um uh cabinet secretaries to change the rules of their organizations or destroy their programs without asking Congress or without um uh without without having a legal basis for doing so. All of that is profoundly disturbing”

0.52

Now the de-risking conversation has shifted to include the United States, as Mark Carney said the U.S. was weaponizing economic engagement and interdependence, so people are asking whether they want to be too dependent on America.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Anne Applebaum

“Um, now unfortunately, the conversation about de-risking is also about the United States. like do you want to have these dependencies on the United States was also what Mark Cardi said that um that the United States was weaponizing economic engagement and interdependence and so now people are asking do we want to be too dependent on America um and so the question is is moving the other way”

0.51

Minnesota protesters have been extraordinarily brave, well-organized without formal leaders, flexible in tactics, focused on recording and documenting violence, largely non-violent, and this organization and restraint has played an important role in showing the contrast between administration actions and what Americans recognize as normal.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“there's an important conversation to be had about what the what the Minnesota protesters have done, right? I mean, they've been extraordinarily brave, but also very wellorganized kind of it's not a leader. It's not this is also a thing I recognize from other countries. You know, a movement that doesn't have a a leader but has um has been very flexible in what it does, has focused on recording and and documenting um you know, has for the most part stayed away from violence or tried to. And you know that I think you know that's that's also played a really important role in showing up the contrast between what the administration is doing and what most Americans would recognize as as something normal.”

0.51

A rupture between the United States and its allies (European, Asian, Latin American) will not have immediate economic effect for most Americans in their pocketbooks but will be quite profound over time, as seen after Brexit where after a decade the UK lost momentum to Europe in many fields and now experiences a sense of malaise.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“a rupture between the United States and its allies whether it's European allies or its Asian allies or even you know its its friends in Latin America and elsewhere um won't have an immediate effect for most Americans. So you won't immediately feel it in your pocketbook or you won't see it in an immediate way. Yeah. Um but over time it will be quite profound. Um I mean this is what we discovered after the Brexit vote in the UK. You know there wasn't a immediate moment where I don't know everybody lost all their money because of Brexit. But over time you know after a decade we can see that the country has changed not for the better. We can see that a lot of businesses lost out. We can see that the UK lost momentum to Europe in all kinds of fields. And we can see that there's a sense of malaise in the country.”

0.51

Economic interdependence is now tightly locked in but may be unraveling due to tariffs, as people who would have invested in the U.S. are now afraid due to tariffs and instability, and this is happening gradually through millions of decisions not to invest rather than dramatic sudden breaks.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“Economic interdependence has never been so tightly locked in as now. And is that going anywhere? Maybe because of tariffs. Um I mean I think I people have said this to me too. You know people who would have invested in the United States until recently are now afraid because of tariffs because of instability...you'll see millions of decisions being made, um, where people decide not to invest or they don't want a US partner or they're worried about sending staff to the United States because people are freaked out about visas...you'll see a slow shift and people will look for other options”

0.47

There is space open for someone to articulate a liberal patriotism based on what America stands for, why the country is great, what institutions built in the past should be carried forward, and how that benefits families and American prosperity, which could galvanize political opposition.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Anne Applebaum

“I also think that there is a space open for someone to begin to articulate a kind of liberal patriotism. You know, here's what we stand for. Here's why our country is great. Uh here's why the things that we built in the past um need some elements from the past need to be taken into the future. and here's why that will be beneficial for you and your family”

0.45

At the top, the president is insulting Europeans and talking about invading Denmark, but three levels down, American-European relations remain the same with military exercises, intelligence operations, and joint planning all shared between allies, creating a weird disconnect.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Anne Applebaum

“at another level, you know, kind of three levels down from the presidency, American European relations are the same as they ever were. You know, so if you met an American general or an admiral, you know, they would say all of our plans still depend on allies and there are military exercises and, you know, intelligence operations going on all the time that are still shared by allies. And so there's this, you know, there's a kind of weird disconnect where at the top the president is insulting Europeans. He's um, you know, talking about invading Denmark. Um, and at another level, you know, everybody's preparing to do joint operations.”

0.45

Trump's foreign policy is not guided by a broader strategy but is fundamentally about Trump being perceived as the winner, the victor, and the dominant person in each circumstance, as exemplified by his threats to Greenland and then changing his mind when he saw he wasn't winning the argument or when the stock market crashed.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Anne Applebaum

“To understand Trump's foreign policy, you really have to understand that this is all about him. You know, in each circumstance, it's about him being perceived as the winner, about him being perceived as the victor or as the dominant person. You know, there isn't a broader strategy. I don't think there is one in Europe either. You know, I mean, as we saw, he made all these threats to Greenland. He, you know, made the Danes get ready for a US invasion. Uh, and then he changed his mind because he saw that he wasn't winning that argument or, you know, or because the stock market crashed. I don't know. Um, but but he but he's there there isn't a consistent strategy.”

0.45

Brutality is no longer considered embarrassing by modern autocrats; China bragged about destroying Hong Kong's democracy movement, and Russia's 2022 invasion of Ukraine was partly intended to show Europe and the world that Russia doesn't care about international rules, borders, UN charter, sovereignty, genocide laws, children protection, or Geneva Conventions.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Anne Applebaum

“There is a phenomenon whereby the use of brutality um is no longer considered embarrassing. You know the Chinese bragged about destroying the Hong Kong democracy movement. Um I you know actually I believe that one of the reasons why the Russians launched their full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022 was precisely to show especially Europeans but also the world that they don't care about the rules. They don't care about borders, about the UN charter, which recognizes borders. They don't care about other countries sovereignty. They don't care about laws on genocide. They don't care about laws on the protection of children. They don't care about Geneva Conventions on warfare.”

0.45

Not all things are irreparable after rupture; at 'three levels down from the presidency' American-European relations remain the same as ever, suggesting that while some damage is permanent, other relationships can be rescued.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Anne Applebaum

“It's not all irreparable. And I, you know, one of the strange things I I also say in and I hear traveling around Europe is that at another level, you know, kind of three levels down from the presidency, American European relations are the same as they ever were.”

0.45

People will be freaked out about sending staff to the US because of visa/customs concerns and will prefer opening offices in other cities/countries rather than risk difficulties for their employees.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Anne Applebaum

“So you know you'll you'll see this you'll see a slowdown that will be inevitably the result of this and again I say that because it's what happened in the UK. And so you know you'll see this you'll see a slowdown that will be inevitably the result of this and again I say that because it's what happened in the UK.”

0.44

Polling data shows that an argument that moves people is that money being spent on ICE and creating Trump's private military should have gone to healthcare, education, or repairing roads in their congressional district, and this type of argumentation showing what people's taxes pay for has been used by Elizabeth Warren, AOC, and others.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Anne Applebaum

“I mean, one of the one piece of polling that drifted by me, I mean, I I I I almost had hesitate to mention it because um I'm not sure I can tell you right now off the top of my head where it's from, but you know, I did see a statistic that said that one argument that moved a lot of people was the argument that this abusive use of ICE, this huge amount of money that's going to creating President Trump's private military, that that money was was money that should have gone to your healthcare or to your educational system or to repair the roads in your congressional district...I've seen Elizabeth Warren say that. I've seen AOC say that. I've seen a se several other people say that.”

0.44

The administration's lies about ICE victims (claiming they are domestic terrorists, gun wielders, or attempting to massacre law enforcement) have upset people more than other lies, partly because the victims died obviously innocently and in shocking fashion, and the lies were deployed immediately before evidence could be gathered, violating basic decency norms about mourning rather than slandering the dead.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Anne Applebaum

“but I but I welcome what seems like a a shift in the in the in the vibe...the lying about these victims of ICE shootings as domestic terrorists or as gun wielding or gun brandishing or arriving there to massacre law enforcement agents that has upset people more than other lies...Maybe because they, you know, they died and they died in such a No, I mean it because they died in in a in such an obviously innocent way in both cases. Um and and to lie about someone who's who died and they did it so fast, you know, actually it even shocked me, you know, that within particularly the the first one when Renee Good was murdered just within minutes they were slandering. I think before the video had even been observed...The normal reaction of normal people is to wait a beat. I mean, someone has died, an innocent person has been murdered by by agents of the federal government. I mean, don't you wait a day be to find out, you know, before before launching into a kind of, you know, propaganda invective. I mean, I think that was that was a, you know, they normally people we we mourn people who die in those circumstances. We don't insult them.”

0.43

Before Trump was elected, Europe was having conversations about 'de-risking'—deciding whether to sell China valuable chips that could be turned against democracies in conflict, reflecting a cautious approach to trade with strategic rivals.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“this was, by the way, this conversation was happening before Trump was elected. Yeah. There was a conversation in Europe about de-risking. So, you know, when trading with China, you know, should you should you sell them your most valuable chips, remembering that they could be turned against you at a time of conflict. That was the kind of conversation that we were having.”

0.43

Trump's foreign policy is similar to Putin and Xi's in that it's about preserving and spreading their personal power; this is similar to autocratic strategy generally

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“and that's very similar to Putin and she their their foreign policy is about preserving their own power and spreading it.”

0.39

The Minneapolis ICE operations striking a chord in the public consciousness is due to the visual contrast of militarily-dressed armed men in ordinary suburban neighborhoods targeting innocent people (documented via phone recordings), including white victims like Alex Prey who owned guns but was not carrying one, appealing to gun owners and making it obvious the administration is attacking normal Americans, not criminals.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Anne Applebaum

“Clearly the site of masked militarily armed men on the streets of a pretty ordinary city like Minneapolis...the all the pictures look like suburban neighborhoods that we see. and to have um guys dressed for Fallujah um you know or Gazny province um closing in on ordinary schools and daycare centers and threatening ordinary people uh who who who are who are committing the crime crime that's not a crime of holding up their phones...The fact that the the man who was most recently killed, Alex Prey, was carrying a gun, and there are a lot of gun owners out there, or he owned a gun. He wasn't carrying it at the time he was killed...he's a he's a more sympathetic figure for at least a part of Trump's electoral base”

0.39

Christians, Catholics, and moral upstanding Americans support Trump despite his cruelty and corruption on an astronomical scale, suggesting something profound has changed in the culture that allows button-down office workers and people nice to their families to align with brutality and corruption.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Anne Applebaum

“the the the Christians and Catholics who support him. Um uh the the people who think of themselves as moral upstanding Americans support him, you know, despite the cruelty, you know, the cruel language, despite the corruption, um which is on an just on an astronomic scale. and yet kind of I don't know people who wear button-down shirts and go to offices every day and are nice to their wives, you know, seem able to go along with this.”

0.39

Mark Carney, former Bank of England and Bank of Canada chairman, gave a significant speech at Davos saying 'what we are living through now is not a transition but a rupture,' reflecting what everyone in the room believed and what Europeans, Asians, and Australians now think—that we are living through a moment of radical change.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Anne Applebaum

“Mark Carney, Prime Minister of Canada, gave a speech for the ages at Davos...he articulated what a lot of other people were saying...the important thing was him saying that what we are living through now is not a transition but a rupture...That was the main word and that reflected what everyone in the room thought and it's what everybody, you know, it's what Europeans now think um and many others, not just Europeans, Asians, Australians I've spoken to recently. Um everybody believes we're now living through a moment of um radical change”

0.28

While Trump says things that shouldn't be said, some contain kernels of truth about NATO members not doing enough, with America providing the star power while Europeans contribute limited military assets and haven't fought close to the front lines, which Trump uses to argue for higher burden-sharing.

factualcontestednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — America is in Rupture Under Trump | Anne Applebaum & Preet … [UhQbEwQaoAc]

“Um, look, um, Trump says things that you shouldn't say and a lot of those things that we've discussed and as has been well documented are abject complete lies. But then there's some things he says that have a kernel of truth that you're not supposed to say...when Donald Trump says, 'You know what, these European countries, including Denmark and others um that are in NATO, they didn't do a whole hell of a lot. Yeah, they lost a few lives. Again, I'm channeling Trump. You know, they provide a couple of ships here and there, but really it's America all the way. We're the star, but for us, there's no world order.'”

0.22

The lies about ICE operations (Stephen Miller lies, Christine lies) are not different in character from administration lies over nine years, but rather the focus and subject matter has changed while the lying pattern remains constant.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Anne Applebaum

“the Steven Miller lies and the Christine lies are of a piece with what's been going on for nine years.”

0.22

This is not an argument for stopping all trade but for realism about how trade works, caution about what it does, and understanding that trading partners might use trade to their advantage.

normativespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Anne Applebaum

“I don't think it means that all trade needs to stop. Um you know on the contrary I just think we need a level of realism and understanding how it works and what it does and also some some um you know caution about you know what it is.”

0.13

Multiple Democratic figures (Gavin Newsom, Governor Pritzker, James Terico, Elizabeth Warren, AOC) are attempting some version of liberal patriotism messaging, but no single figure has clearly broken through except possibly Governor Newsom due to social media skill

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Anne Applebaum

“there are perhaps a dozen different people, you know, people whom people, you know, we have various feelings. I mean, there's Gavin Newsome in California, there's Governor Pritsker, there's a handful of um people in Congress. Um I don't know, there are people like James Terico who's running for the Senate in Texas, um who's who's very articulate about how Christianity is being abused. So, I mean, so there's a there there may be 20 25 senior people in politics who are who are trying some version of this. Um, I don't know that they that any one of them has broken through. Maybe maybe Governor Newsome the most. Um, because his he's very talented so at using social media.”