What this covers

Arnold Kling and Russ Roberts discuss Arnold Kling's alternative framework for understanding recessions and labor-market dynamics. Rather than the standard aggregate-supply and aggregate-demand model taught in most macroeconomics courses, Kling proposes thinking about the economy as a system of interconnected patterns of specialization and trade—what he calls PSST. The conversation centers on why this reframing matters: the conventional aggregate-demand story, Kling argues, obscures what actually happens during economic downturns by treating the economy as if it were a single "GDP factory" rather than a web of distinct sectors, skills, and comparative advantages. When demand collapses in the standard model, we are left with the unsatisfying claim that people have simply stopped wanting things. PSST offers a different diagnosis: recessions occur when previously viable arrangements—which workers and employers have organized around—become unsustainable, and the economy must discover new patterns before employment can recover.

The discussion ranges across concrete historical and contemporary examples: how tractors displaced farm labor in the 1930s, how Amazon and e-readers eroded the comparative advantage of Borders bookstores, and why carpenters and computer workers face radically different employment prospects after 2008. Kling identifies specific obstacles to reallocation—credentialization in healthcare and education, the rising cost of employee benefits, and what he calls the "Garrett Jones effect," where modern work resembles a capital investment rather than simple production. Roberts presses a central puzzle: if creative destruction happens constantly without causing mass unemployment, what makes the current disruption different? The two also touch on theoretical disagreements—sticky prices, wage rigidity, the role of demand stimulus—and reflect on how economists trained in different traditions (Keynesian versus monetarist schools) have gradually migrated toward more micro-grounded, Austrian-leaning perspectives on how economies actually work.

Sharpest takeaway

Kling argues that macroeconomic fluctuations are better understood as disruptions in 'patterns of sustainable specialization and trade' (comparative advantage) than through the aggregate-supply/aggregate-demand paradigm, which lacks micro foundations and fails to explain recessions intuitively.

  • Aggregate demand/supply models rely on a 'GDP factory' representative agent that obscures the real economy of diverse specialized roles
  • Recessions occur when previously profitable comparative-advantage patterns become unsustainable and entrepreneurs struggle to discover new ones
  • Demand-side stimulus cannot help entrepreneurs find new viable specialization patterns; it is like pouring gas over a car hoping it seeps in

The claims · ranked35 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.86

Long-term employment growth in a sector depends on how demand grows relative to productivity: manufacturing productivity has long outpaced demand (shedding workers) while health care and education demand has outpaced productivity (adding workers), so workers will inevitably shift from manufacturing into health and education regardless of political protests.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Arnold Kling

“long term growth in employment depends on how demand grows relative to productivity and for a long time certainly in manufacturing productivity has been increasing faster than demand whereas in things like health care and education demand has been increasing faster than productivity”

0.80

Measured economic activity reflects the degree of true specialization: cooking your own dinner or mowing your own lawn isn't measured activity, but cooking in a restaurant or paying someone to mow is—and this is right, because doing everything oneself (building one's own computer, car, gasoline, pencil) would be impossibly wasteful.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Arnold Kling

“if a surgeon knows her own lawn that doesn't count as economic activity but if she does another surgery and then pays somebody to mow her lawn that is economic activity... it would be a tremendous waste if we were to do everything ourselves”

0.77

The 1930s depression can be read as a comparative-advantage dislocation: tractors let far fewer farm workers produce all needed food, dumping masses of manual laborers the economy couldn't reabsorb until the 1950s, when those workers retired, WWII uprooted and relocated potential workers, and a very different economy (services, suburbs, clerical work, more women in the labor force) emerged.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Arnold Kling

“in the 1930s I would tell you that what happened is... tractors really took hold on the farm and we could basically produce all the food that we needed with way fewer farm workers so that creates this just massive dislocation of lots of people whose skill is manual labor”

0.75

Borders bookstores are failing not from a lack of aggregate demand but because the comparative advantage of holding physical book inventory in many locations has been eroded by Amazon's centralized-inventory model and the rise of e-readers like the Kindle—an instance of creative destruction.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Arnold Kling

“I suspect that the comparative advantage of having a physical inventory of books in many locations has gone away relative to the Amazon model of having the inventory located in a single place... that's probably why Borders is going out of business not because of a lack of aggregate demand”

0.75

Creative destruction occurs continuously in good times without causing mass unemployment, so the puzzle is what is different now—Roberts challenges Kling that PSST disruptions happen always, yet reallocation usually works, implying something distinct must explain the current high unemployment.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“in quote good times meaning not a recession this creative destruction is taking place every all the time it's ongoing and we don't have a lot of problems... so something is different”

0.75

Macroeconomists trained at saltwater (e.g., MIT, Keynesian) versus freshwater (e.g., Chicago, monetarist) schools largely stayed within their silos through their careers, whereas Roberts and Kling have migrated toward each other—away from aggregation and elegant mathematical models—into a more Austrian-leaning, micro-grounded position.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“you went to what is called a saltwater school meaning near the coast which is MIT which was more prone to be a Keynesian place I was I went to what's called a freshwater school University of Chicago which is a monetarist place... you and I have both sort of migrated together and in that direction we were less comfortable with aggregation”

0.74

Job creation and full employment are the process by which entrepreneurs invent ways to create and exploit comparative advantage and workers find those opportunities; recessions happen when comparative-advantage relationships change so that livelihoods possible a few years ago are no longer viable (e.g., home building, mortgage securitization).

causalhigh valuefringenovelty 4/4durability 4/4· Arnold Kling

“it's a case of entrepreneurs coming up with ways to create an exploit comparative advantage and then workers finding those opportunities that's what job creation is... the comparative advantage relationships in the economy have changed and so ways that you could have made a living a few years ago you cannot make a living now”

0.73

Credentialization is a major impediment to reorganizing the very sectors with the greatest growth potential—education and health care—because legal requirements (medical licensing, school accreditation, teacher certification) prevent redesigning clinics or schools and so slow the adjustment of comparative-advantage patterns during recession.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Arnold Kling

“a lot of what I call credential ization... you cannot redesign a healthcare clinic so that someone other than a doctor performs a function without running into legal problems and you cannot organize a school and get that school accredited... the sectors are their most rigidly held by these credentials regulations”

0.73

If the 1970s didn't wreck the aggregate-supply-demand paradigm, the current crisis won't either, because the language is flexible enough that practitioners can always tell a story (e.g., high risk premia plus the zero nominal interest-rate bound implying high real rates) even when nominal rates didn't rise, government spending didn't fall, and the money supply didn't fall.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Arnold Kling

“if the 1970s didn't you know wreck the aggregate supply demand paradigm that's and what will... you can tell a great aggregate demand story if you want if you again if you push on it a little harder it's troubling... the nominal interest rate it didn't go up the government spending didn't go down the money supply didn't go down”

0.73

A macroeconomic paradigm functions like a language rather than a falsifiable theory; you cannot choose between paradigms with a decisive experiment any more than you could call English true and French false.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Arnold Kling

“a paradigm is kind of like a language... you wouldn't say that you know English is true or French is false or whatever and that that's kind of the level at which a paradigm functions”

0.73

The aggregate demand story is intuitively unsatisfying because it amounts to claiming that 'all of a sudden people have stopped wanting stuff,' and it is typically told without reference to prices, which is the same way non-economists reason about perpetual shortages or excess supply.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Arnold Kling

“I just don't agree that the problem is some all of a sudden people have stopped wanting stuff... the whole aggregate demand aggregate supply story is a story that mostly gets told without prices and is in line with that of non-economic thinking”

0.73

The 'Garrett Jones effect' holds that modern workers no longer produce widgets but produce organizational capital—building firms' capabilities, connections, and process-tracking—so hiring them resembles a capital investment with high fixed costs that firms postpone when other firms retrench, contributing to recessions and slow recoveries.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Arnold Kling

“I call that the Garrett Jones effective he says that workers no longer produce widgets they produce organizational capital... it's a worker that that you hire the way you would invest in capital you make a very careful decision... there are a lot of fixed costs involved in that hiring process”

0.73

The carpenter-vs-computer-worker contrast explains differential recovery: an unemployed computer worker in 2001 was in a long-term growing industry and only faced a temporary supply-demand blip, whereas an unemployed carpenter today faces a sector with ~200,000 surplus workers and a long downward labor-intensity trend, so those jobs won't return for a long time.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“in 1999 2001 we still had to use for people who are Computers... but we've got way too many carpenters in America right now we there were 200,000 more carpenters a few years ago then they're employed”

0.71

In the Keynesian model, recession arises when people switch demand from produced goods (cars, bread) to a non-produced good—money—through hoarding, so producers can't sell and must lay off workers; saving toward future consumption via investment goods would not cause unemployment, but Keynes treated the animal-spirits investment motive and the hoarding savings motive as separate.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Arnold Kling

“when you switch from wanting to produce good to a non produce good you no longer ask for production you no longer want stuff and so that's kind of the aggregate demand story”

0.70

Kling's dissertation proposed a search-cost mechanism for price stickiness: sellers are reluctant to raise prices because raising prices motivates buyers to search, while a competitor cutting prices goes unnoticed unless buyers are searching, giving sellers less incentive to cut—a mechanism others have repeatedly rediscovered.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Arnold Kling

“there are search costs and that people only there people are more motivated to search when you raise your price so you're you're reluctant to raise your price but when somebody else is lowering the price unless I'm searching I don't realize that they lowered the price so they have less motivation to cut their price”

0.70

Aggregate demand stimulus cannot help entrepreneurs discover comparative-advantage opportunities; it is like the Bill Cosby joke of pouring gasoline all over a car hoping it seeps into the tank—pouring on spending while hoping it seeps into the right patterns of specialization and trade.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“to me that's what aggregate demand policy is trying to do relative to this finding patterns of sustainable specialization and trade it's not helping you find those patterns it's just pouring on some gasoline and hoping it seeps in somewhere”

0.69

The puzzle of high unemployment is why entrepreneurs aren't hiring cheaply available unemployed workers; a key answer is that secular cost increases—especially healthcare benefits that have doubled—reduce the proportion of people who can be profitably employed going forward.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Arnold Kling

“why aren't there entrepreneurs looking around saying gosh there are all these people who could conceivably come to work cheaply... when you have to pay health care benefits and that the cost of those healthcare benefits has doubled that... becomes a real issue... reduce the proportion of people who can be profitably employed going forward”

0.68

Economic activity should be understood not as spending but as patterns of comparative advantage (specialization and trade): a booming economy is one where people have found many ways to exploit comparative advantage, and a recession is when those patterns break down.

definitionhigh valuefringenovelty 4/4durability 4/4· Arnold Kling

“instead of describing economic activity is spending I want to try to describe it in terms of comparative advantage so I use this acronym psst patterns of sustainable specialization and trade”

0.68

Work is not intrinsically good; in traditional economics work is a cost, and most economic progress consists of eliminating jobs and making work less onerous—so macroeconomics' treatment of 'creating jobs' as a goal is a peculiarity, since you are never unemployed when self-sufficient but also impoverished.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Arnold Kling

“a job in some sense it's a bad thing and you spend most of our time doing is trying to eliminate jobs and eliminate work and make work less onerous less risky less painful and so on so that in some sense that's what economy is all about”

0.68

Wage stickiness is better understood not as irrational rigidity but as workers rationally resisting large pay cuts because switching jobs is costly, a low wage is a bad signal that can brand a worker as low quality, and a better non-pay-cut job might arrive.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Arnold Kling

“a worker is hesitant to take a giant pay cut for a whole bunch of reasons one being it'd be nice if another job came along that didn't require a giant pay cut... it's a bad signal to send to employers future employers... it may brand you as a low quality worker if you take a lower wage”

0.68

The labor market constantly destroys and creates millions of jobs every quarter (JOLTS data) in both good and bad times; bad times are simply when fewer jobs are created than destroyed and good times when slightly more are created than destroyed.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“the jolt stated that the Bureau of Labor Statistics collects millions of jobs being destroyed and there's millions of jobs being created every quarter in America in good times and bad times but what are called bad times are when the numbers that get created are not quite as many as the numbers to get destroyed”

0.66

The textbook model assumes only nominal wages are sticky while firm prices are flexible, which predicts strongly counter-cyclical real wages (high real wages during low employment); but this pronounced counter-cyclicality is very hard to find in the data, undermining the model.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Arnold Kling

“the cyclical behavior of real wages is not as pronounced as that model would suggest... you would expect to see that when... you see low employment you'll see high real wages and vice-versa and i that skypes very hard to tease out of the data”

0.66

The 'GDP factory' or representative-agent model—where everyone makes one good in one labor market—is flawed because if the plant manager simply paid workers in output rather than money, the recession would disappear entirely; the resulting claim that a barter economy couldn't have recessions is exactly backwards, since recessions would be easier in a barter economy.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Arnold Kling

“if the if the plant manager were all of a sudden to pay workers in terms of output rather than paying a money wage just say here have some of your GDP that you produce as output all of the recession breaks down it just disappears completely which is bizarre... I think in a barter economy it would be much easier to have recessions”

0.64

Sticky-price and sticky-wage explanations of why falling demand doesn't simply lower prices are hard to credit, because it is difficult to understand why sellers facing extreme duress with excess inventory would refuse to cut prices, and the model implausibly assumes price changes are costly downward but not upward.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Arnold Kling

“the aggregate supply story becomes one of sticky prices and sticky wage the idea that which I've never understood the idea that producers are loath to lower their prices... it's hard to understand how that works in a time when people have all this excess production excess output sitting on their shelf”

0.63

Generous 99-week unemployment benefits, while not lavish, make some people less willing to take a chance on a new job, profession, or opportunity, thereby slowing reallocation.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Russ Roberts

“when you extend unemployment for ninety nine weeks which is two years it's that does not sharpen the mind... it certainly makes people less willing some people less willing to take a chance on a new job a new profession a new opportunity”

0.61

The current recession can be read as an acceleration of ongoing sectoral shifts: when companies in 2008 examined their balance sheets and feared for survival, they suddenly discovered they had workers they didn't need, speeding up an adjustment that would otherwise have been gradual.

causalhigh valuefringenovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Arnold Kling

“as of 2008 when a lot of companies looked at their balance sheets and said oh my goodness we're not sure we could you know whether we'll survive we have to really cut back to the bare bones... they suddenly discovered that they had workers who they didn't necessarily need and so this this adjustment process has sped up all of a sudden”

0.56

From December 2007 to October 2009, employment fell by 7.2 million, of which 3.6 million (half) was in construction and manufacturing (1.5 million construction, 2.1 million manufacturing), with the gains concentrated in health, education, and government.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Russ Roberts

“from December o 7 which is the start of the recession... to October of oh 9... employment was down 7.2 million and 3.6 million of that was I was from construction and manufacturing... 1.5 in construction and 2.1 in in manufacturing”

0.56

The aggregate demand / aggregate supply paradigm is troubling because there are very few instances where aggregate demand policies succeeded and many failures, including post-2008 policies, decades of Japanese demand policy, and the surprising absence of a predicted depression after the massive post-WWII reduction in government spending.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Arnold Kling

“there are very few instances where aggregate demand policies were successful... there are many instances of failures... the period after World War 2 there was this massive reduction in government spending but without a sort of recession or depression that would have been predicted”

0.56

Unemployment in this recession is highest among low-education workers and is geographically concentrated in states (Florida, Arizona, Nevada, Michigan) that had the largest home-construction booms, while high-skill knowledge workers ('Garrett Jones types') face much lower unemployment and can find work fairly quickly.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Russ Roberts

“the people who are not finding work quickly have two characteristics they have low education... it's very geographically varied... the highest unemployment rates aren't in California they're in Florida they're in Arizona they're in Michigan they're in Nevada”

0.51

'Sustainable' in PSST means profitable and ongoing, not environmental—government can create employment, but if those opportunities are unprofitable (like a product people stop wanting, or the housing bubble) they cannot be sustained.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Arnold Kling

“what I mean by that is profitable because... the government can certainly create can create employment opportunities but if they're not profitable opportunities ultimately the question is how do you sustain them”

0.44

The PSST paradigm aligns with classical (pre-Keynes) economics in emphasizing production rather than consumption as the right way to think about the economy at large.

normativecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Arnold Kling

“another sense by the way in which this paradigm is goes back to the classics and by classics I mean before Keynes is the emphasis on production rather than consumption which is a very classical idea and I think the right way to think about economies at large”

0.44

Patterns of specialization and trade have grown so complex that a shirt company now hires web designers, business development managers, customer service reps, and social media marketers—jobs unimaginable for a shirt maker 50 or 500 years ago, illustrating how comparative advantage now produces oddly specialized roles.

factualestablishednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Arnold Kling

“it's a really strange economy that somebody's comparative advantage could be a social media marketing for a shirt company it just shows how complex the patterns of specialization trade has become”

0.37

Economics and environmentalism are not strongly opposed; both are fundamentally about achieving desired goods and services using as few resources as possible, approached from slightly different angles.

normativecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Arnold Kling

“I don't think economics and environmentalism are that opposed I mean in some sense you're worried about using as few resources as possible... the economy is trying to figure out that problem environmentalists are trying to figure out that problem but they come at it from sometimes from a slightly different angle”

0.23

Today's situation resembles the Keynesian hoarding story in that banks are sitting on reserves rather than lending to investors and entrepreneurs because both banks and entrepreneurs are anxious about the future.

factualcontestednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Arnold Kling

“right now banks are sitting on those reserves they're anxious about the future as are the impossible entrepreneurs”

0.12

Macroeconomics is uniquely hard because many markets (credit, money, goods) interact simultaneously, which is why economists write simplified mathematical models to grasp the interactions.

factual· Arnold Kling

“one of the challenges of macroeconomics is the fact that you've got so much stuff going on at the same time... how they interact of course is hard to keep in your head at the same time which is why people write down simplified models of these things in mathematical equation”