
Shiller Says `Easy to Beat the Market' Long Term Bloomberg
What this covers
This Bloomberg Television "Market Makers" segment pairs Nobel laureate Bob Shiller with AQR co-founder Cliff Asness, with Stephanie Ruhle hosting. The conversation is organized around Eugene Fama's Efficient Market Hypothesis and where it falls short. Shiller calls Fama's theory half right: it is hard to make easy money in competitive markets, but event-study evidence exaggerated how perfect prices are. He also raises a paradox. If everyone believed markets were efficient, no one would do the speculating that keeps them so, and he says this free-riding contributed to the financial crisis. Asness adds a personal angle, recalling that he wrote his dissertation for Fama on price momentum, a result that is hard to square with efficiency, and that Fama supported the work anyway.
The range is wider than the theory dispute. They discuss value investing) as a long-run anomaly, and Asness and Shiller differ in emphasis over whether it reflects risk, irrationality, or both. The mechanism by which psychology and fads and fashions get into prices is acknowledged as imprecisely understood. Shiller argues for downweighting stocks that look overpriced because of fads. The talk then turns to high frequency trading), where Shiller is contested in saying it may help liquidity and execution and that Michael Lewis's "rigged" account is overblown. He also notes that transaction costs are lower than ever, and he links style drift to the troubles managers faced in the crisis.
The most useful turn comes near the end, where both guests describe common practical ground. A diversified world portfolio of stocks and bonds, low costs, a mostly passive stance, and a tilt toward cheap stocks is something Fama would likely accept as well. Shiller and Asness locate the real disagreement in whether psychology and sociology belong in market analysis, not in diversification. Shiller also defends occasional trading for rebalancing, and Asness says he would not put all his money with any one manager.
Shiller argues that markets are not perfectly efficient because psychology and behavioral factors drive stock prices, contrasting with Fama's efficient market hypothesis, though both scholars agree on practical investment approaches like diversification and value tilting.
- Markets are driven primarily by psychology and fads rather than just news about real fundamentals
- Value stocks historically outperform, contradicting perfect market efficiency
- Both scholars converge on practical investment strategy despite theoretical disagreement
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The ironic paradox of Fama's efficient markets hypothesis is that if everyone accepted it and believed markets were perfectly efficient, markets could not actually be efficient because there would be no one engaging in price-correcting speculation.
“The irony is that F's efficient markets hypothesis if it were accepted by everyone the markets couldn't be efficient anymore because there wouldn't be anyone enforcing efficiency”
Fama's theory is only half right because while it correctly identifies that it is not easy to make a lot of money trading in competitive markets with many smart people, his evidence from event studies gave an exaggerated sense of market perfection.
“I'm an admirer of Jean fama and I think that his theory of efficient markets is a Hal truth so he's half right it's the the fundamental thing is it's not easy to make a lot of money trading it's a competitive game and there's a lot of smarter people than you out there as well... what fama did is present some evidence that looked very favorable like these event studies that he did it looked amazing like markets are really perfect but I think they gave kind of an exaggerated sense of perfection of markets”
Eugene Fama's Efficient Market Theory holds that all information about a security is already priced in and it is all but impossible for an individual investor to beat the market.
“Eugene F he won the Nobel prize in economics last year for his Efficient Market Theory which basically holds that all information about a security is already priced in and it's all but impossible for an individual investor to beat the market”
Value stocks have historically outperformed the market over the long term, which is an anomaly that contradicts the efficient market hypothesis.
“it's easy to beat the market historically for example one can just go into a value stock over the long Hall value stocks have outperformed the market uh and there's a number of anomalies in the literature”
Price momentum—the tendency for winners to keep winning in the short run over 6 to 12 months—is very hard to justify within efficient markets theory.
“to justify why winners keep winning in the short run uh over 6 to 12 months is a hard one for the efficient market guys but but playing he would say”
Bob Shiller believes that the stock market is driven mostly by psychology rather than news about important real things, disagreeing with Fama's assumption that markets must be driven by real news.
“what's driving the whole stock market uh you f would say apparently that it must be news about important real things that really matter uh and I don't think so I think the stock market is the overall Market is probably driven mostly by psychology”
Cheap stocks being outperformers and expensive stocks being underperformers represents a combination of market risk and non-perfect rationality in markets, manifesting as fads and fashions.
“cheap stocks being expensive stocks uh is a combination of being somewhat riskier and not perfectly rational markets which are fads and Fashions if anything”
This paradox of efficient markets—that everyone cannot believe in them for them to work—was partly responsible for causing the financial crisis, as too many people assumed markets were right and became free riders.
“that is partly what actually caused this financial crisis too many people wanted to Be Free Riders is on everyone else and they just assumed that the markets were right and that let us into trouble”
Stock market movements are hard to forecast because of craziness and irrational behavior, and this is true across history and human endeavors, not just in finance.
“I think there are a lot of what happens it's just my view of world history it's not just in finance it's in politics we have these crazy Wars from time time what you go back and look at any one of them in history and you think what were they thinking you can't even imagine it in in future times and I think stock market movements are like that now they're still hard to forecast”
Transaction costs are lower today than they have ever been, making concerns about millisecond trading and trading costs less pressing than in the past.
“transaction costs are lower today than they have ever been right right yeah so I wouldn't worry too much about millisecond trading”
High frequency trading may actually be a positive force for the United States market by improving execution and liquidity, despite concerns about fairness.
“it might be a good thing yeah I think for people to trade occasionally... I think the United States isn't that a positive for hft”
Style drift—when portfolio managers or investors move into investments outside their area of expertise—was a major problem in the financial crisis when managers became frozen and unable to exit from unfamiliar asset classes.
“my fear is style drift because when I think about just before the financial crisis when all these managers started getting to products that weren't their expertise and then the market turned for them they were frozen and couldn't get out”
Behaviorists are good at telling stories about market behavior, and Fama believes these stories even though he doesn't fully explain the mechanism of how psychological factors actually get priced into markets.
“he would say and I've heard him say things like this I won't get the exact wording right the behavioralists are great at telling stories about behavior and he believes them he doesn't think humans are robots are perfect but they're not as good at saying how they get into prices”
Despite theoretical differences, both Fama and Shiller converge on practical investment advice: stay relatively passive, keep costs low, and tilt towards known market anomalies like value investing and momentum investing.
“I started this and I don't know if Stephanie believed me when I said we were going to get two people uh somewhat known for disagreeing who just split the Nobel Prize who would end up advising us on how to invest in a in a fairly similar way... staying relatively passive keeping costs low and then tilting towards some known what what the academics call anomalies uh in English stuff that beats the market uh value investing being the most premier one I would also mention momentum investing lowrisk investing from from fiser black”
Eugene Fama told his students in class during the 1980s that markets are 'almost assuredly not perfectly efficient' because of information costs and the need for someone to enforce market efficiency.
“I don't think you you mentioned Gene believes in perfect efficient markets uh sometimes he gets pigeon hole that way he told us in class this was in the 1980s um that markets are I think the quote was almost assuredly not perfectly efficient um because of exactly what you're saying there's information costs and and and and reasons like that uh someone has to make them efficient”
The real fundamental difference between Shiller and Eugene Fama is not about portfolio diversification but about whether one incorporates psychology, sociology, fads, and fashions into market analysis.
“the real big difference between me and Eugene F uh having spent a week with him is not any concrete difference about portfolio diversification it's what jean doesn't maybe he has but he doesn't refer to psychology he doesn't refer to Sociology he doesn't think there are fads and fashion or maybe he thinks there are fads and Fashions but he doesn't bring it up it's not in his genetic profile to ever bring up something like that”
Shiller wants to downweight stocks when they are related to fads and fashions and are overpriced relative to traditional valuation measures, incorporating behavioral skepticism into portfolio construction.
“when I look at markets in the real world I see fads and Fashions and I feel feel skeptical about them especially if they're related to traditional measures of overpricing and I want to downweight those things in my portfolio”
Michael Lewis's narrative about high frequency trading being rigged against individual investors is somewhat sensationalist and overblown.
“I don't like this uh rigged story that Michael Lewis is telling it's uh that's being a little sensationalist I think”
Asness wrote his dissertation on the success of the price momentum strategy for Eugene Fama, who was open-minded and supportive of the research despite momentum being difficult to justify within efficient markets theory.
“I I I think uh for instance cheap stocks being expensive stocks uh is a combination of being somewhat riskier and not perfectly rational markets which are fads and Fashions if anything I wrote my dissertation for Jean on the success of the price momentum strategy which he was very open-minded and kind about by the way good Mentor”
A baseline investment strategy that both value investors (like Shiller and Asness) and efficient market advocates (like Fama) would likely agree on is a diversified world portfolio of stocks and bonds with a tilt towards cheap stocks.
“Bob Bob I and Jee all seem to agree on the value effect so let's focus the let's it's like all good negotiations you start out with what you all agree on we'd probably all start with a pretty Diversified World portfolio of stocks and bonds and tilt still own a lot of different things not own one cheap stock tilt towards cheap stocks”
DFA (Dimensional Fund Advisors) represents a largely value-tilted investment approach that both supporters of efficient markets (like Fama advises) and behavioral economists could agree on.
“it's it's largely a difference of interpretation Jee f doesn't seem to think that we should all just be completely Diversified... it's it's largely a difference of interpretation... so it's largely a difference of interpretation Jean f doesn't seem to think that we should all just be completely Diversified so are you saying people can beat the market”
There is no one person on earth that Cliff Asness would put all his money with; instead, he spreads his wealth across many managers to avoid concentration risk.
“there's no one on earth I put all my money with in fact I spread it out over many people”
Occasionally trading one's portfolio is acceptable and can even be beneficial for maintaining position sizing and rebalancing, particularly when the market is looking crazy.
“it's a good thing yeah I think for people to trade occasionally you don't want to trade too often because you'll lose in transactions costs so occasional trading but you know I think the United States isn't that a positive for hft when we talk about losing in transaction costs transaction costs are lower today than they have ever been right right yeah so I wouldn't worry too much about millisecond trading I I and I think that from time to time uh one should trade one's portfolio at least to rebalance but more generally when the market is looking crazy I think we have to have people willing to get out of the market”
If an executive at an automobile company invests in the stock market, they should be short (not long) automobile stocks as a hedge against their existing employment risk in that industry.
“if you are an executive at an automobile company you should be short not long the automobile stocks as a way of hedging yourself”
Behavioral factors get into prices, particularly when extreme, though the precise mechanism of how that process works remains imprecisely understood.
“but playing he would say and I've heard him say things like this I won't get the exact wording right the behavioralists are great at telling stories about behavior and he believes them he doesn't think humans are robots are perfect but they're not as good at saying how they get into prices when there is a Fed out there um and I would have to say my sense is they do get into prices particularly when extreme but we are still fairly imprecise in how we we we in our knowledge of how that process works works”