
Sir Roger Penrose: Are Animals Conscious Like We Are?
What this covers
This is a six-minute clip from Joe Rogan Experience #1216. A single speaker, credited in the title to Sir Roger Penrose but not identified in the material itself, works through animal examples to argue that the gap between human and animal minds is one of degree. On this account, humans differ mainly in how sophisticated their language and abstract thinking are. Chimps, dolphins and humans are named as clear cases of consciousness, and the speaker suspects it extends further down the evolutionary scale.
The evidence is anecdotal and organized around three animals. Elephant herds are said to detour to the place where a relative died, handle the bones and tusks, and appear to mourn before moving on. African hunting dogs and wolves come up as coordinated hunters. In the example given, the pack splits, one group hides at a river crossing, and the other drives the prey toward them. The speaker reads this as non-verbal communication and as an understanding of both the shared goal and each animal's place in the hierarchy. Both the hierarchy claim and the continuum claim are flagged as contested.
Octopuses get the most space. The speaker describes them changing skin texture instantly for camouflage, apparently responding to what lies beneath them, a mechanism the speaker says science doesn't understand well. Other examples include opening jars, escaping tanks, and crossing a floor to reach a neighboring tank. The most vivid story is of an octopus that broke a chain it was supposed to pull and then squirted people, which the speaker takes as protest. The clip ends without settling what consciousness is, floating the possibilities of self-preservation tied to reproduction, something mystical, or something more complex than anyone currently grasps.
Consciousness and intelligence exist on a continuous spectrum across species rather than as a binary human/non-human distinction, with evidence from animal behavior demonstrating planning, communication, emotional cognition, and problem-solving abilities that suggest no clean dividing line between human and animal consciousness.
- Elephants demonstrate grief and memory by revisiting sites where herd members died, showing emotional and abstract awareness beyond mechanical behavior
- African hunting dogs and wolves coordinate complex multi-stage hunts requiring non-verbal communication, role awareness, and group objective understanding
- Octopi display intelligence through tool use, environmental adaptation, and deliberate problem-solving (jar opening, tank escapes, chain-yanking protest)
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
There is no clear distinction in kind between human and animal intelligence; rather, the difference is primarily one of degree, particularly in the sophistication of language use and abstract thinking.
“I mean okay we you know we use language to a degree I mean some animals use language to some kind of degree hmm there's a huge difference in degree i'd agree with that but whether it's a difference in kind I'm not at all sure”
Octopi possess adaptive intelligence that allows them to change the texture and appearance of their skin instantaneously to match their environment, and they demonstrate understanding of what is below them that allows them to determine what to copy for camouflage, though the mechanism of this ability is not well understood by science.
“I think they're they're highly intelligent yes yes yeah I'm going really paying attention to them for a few years I'm a good friend my friend Remy Warren was doing a television show called apex predator we studied the way different animals hunted and he started studying the way octopus and cuttlefish and all these different yeah the different octopi and what the way they could adapt to their environment by changing their actual not just to look but the texture of their skin instantaneously and how this is not really understood how they not only how they do it but how they know what they're what's below them what they're copying yes that they somehow or another can figure out how to blend in almost perfectly with their environment it's amazing isn't it”
Elephants exhibit emotional cognition and memory of deceased herd members, as evidenced by deliberate group behavior where elephant herds make detours to visit locations where deceased relatives died, handle their bones and tusks, and appear to caress and mourn them before resuming their journey.
“they thought there's a whole herd of them they'll be doing that but then at a certain point they did made a detour and they went off to a place where the leader of the elephant herd her sister had died and there the bones and the tusks I suppose were their bones anyway we're there and the elephant's picked them up handed them around and and seemed to caress them and move them around and then they went back enjoined to the the route that they were now what does that tell us there's something going on which is not just some machine behaving yes like a robot there's some some feelings that I can appreciate”
African hunting dogs coordinate complex multi-stage hunting strategies through non-verbal communication, where the pack strategically splits into two groups—one to hide at the river crossing point while the other chases prey toward the concealed hunters—demonstrating planning, role awareness, and mutual understanding of the hunt objective.
“I remember was one with these African hunting dogs and the dogs you see there's a road where some antelopes would tend to go and they're to go across the river and when they got to the point where the cross or it might slow down and make their way to get across now these hunting dogs you could see them that I think it was taken from the air and they would go along towards this place where the river was and then they would break into two so half of them would go one way towards thick and they were hide just where the river starts and the other half would go and chase the antelopes they'd go and bark and make an awful noise chase them right there and then the other ones would pounce on them”
Consciousness and subjective awareness exist on a continuous spectrum across animal species rather than as a binary distinction between humans and other animals, with no clean dividing line between human understanding and more primitive forms of animal cognition.
“and I think there is what will you call understanding okay at a more primitive level and then human understanding but nevertheless there is something there's no sort of clean dividing line in my view it's it's it's pretty continuous”
Wolves and African hunting dogs display evidence of conscious awareness through hierarchical understanding, group coordination, and non-verbal communication that demonstrates they understand both their position in the pack hierarchy and their collective objective.
“and this exists in wolves as well so very very similar behavior and they do seem to have not just verbal but nonverbal communication they seem to have some understanding of what the task is uh-huh and what their roles are in the task and even though there's not as many variables maybe it's human life there there definitely seems to be a conscious awareness of first of all their their position in the hierarchy of the tribe yeah of the the pack round the things but also their what their objective is is this is not a selfish objective it's a group objective and they operate as a group”
Octopi display high-level intelligence through capabilities including opening jars, escaping from tanks, climbing across floors to reach adjacent tanks, and problem-solving behavior demonstrating deliberate choice and agency.
“they also can open jars and they cannot climb out of tanks there was one guy had a he had a camera on his tank because he had two tanks yes and one of them had very expensive tropical fish and the other one had his octopus and he was trying to figure out what was happening to his expensive tropical fish so they put a camera on it and the octopus was climbing out of the tank walking across the ground climbing into the other tank killing one of the fish eating it and then going back into his tank”
Consciousness and intelligence exist across a wide range of animal species including chimps, humans, dolphins, and likely extends further down the evolutionary scale.
“and there's a lot of indication that we're certainly chimps and humans and things and dolphins you we know about them but ice imagine it goes quite far down I should think”
Octopi demonstrate deliberate agency and emotional response by refusing to cooperate with unintuitive puzzle tasks, as evidenced by an octopus that deliberately broke a chain mechanism it was supposed to pull, then deliberately squirted people as apparent protest behavior.
“there's some experiments on testing the intelligence of octopuses oh and they had a little thing they had to pull a chain and then open a door and get food out and this octopus was thinking that I'm gonna fed up with this thing and so you yank the chain it came right off and then it rose to the top and started squirting all the people in their white coats I know it was pretty good you know there's something else going on than just there is something going on absolutely”
The nature and definition of consciousness cannot be easily resolved—it may be biological self-preservation with reproductive drive, something mystical, or something far more complex than currently understood by humans.
“this is something that everyone contemplates like what makes you conscious what is the soul is it a real thing what is what is your consciousness is it simply just your own biology trying to calculate your environment and looking out for its best interest in trying to procreate and move forward with the the the genes that it has or is it something almost mystical or far more complicated maybe even instead of the word mystical might be tainted man something far more complex than we're currently able to understand”
Octopi are highly intelligent animals that warrant careful study to understand their cognitive capabilities.
“how much have you studied octopi they're fascinating oh yeah yes no I haven't there's a new book about them which I haven't gotten the chance to read yet I want to read it I think they're they're highly intelligent yes yes yeah I'm going really paying attention to them for a few years”