What this covers

This is a conversation between Ezra Klein and David Remnick, the editor of The New Yorker, recorded almost a year after October 7. Both men had recently been in Israel and the West Bank, and Remnick has reported on the region for decades. His recent profiles of Yahya Sinwar, Netanyahu and Naftali Bennett give the talk its structure. It opens with Sinwar: his family's flight from Ashkelon in 1948, his rise under Sheikh Yassin, and his run of the Hamas morality police, the Majed, where he was known for ruthlessness toward suspected collaborators. It also covers his two decades in Israeli prisons, where he mastered Hebrew and read Israeli memoirs, and the novel he smuggled out. The conversation includes a foiled hostage-taking plot, his role in the Gilad Shalit negotiations, and his remark to the dentist Boaz Biton about sacrificing Palestinian lives.

The middle of the episode turns to the fronts beyond Gaza. They discuss Israel's northern border and the prospect of war with Hezbollah, and the Israeli conviction that Iran is the real adversary behind every other one. Remnick then traces Netanyahu's worldview to his father's revisionist Zionism and to the death of his brother Yoni at Entebbe, and recounts the cynicism American presidents have met from him. The West Bank section is among the most pointed. Remnick describes a systematic architecture of control that makes reversal harder to imagine each year, and Klein raises Smotrich's withholding of tax revenue from the Palestinian Authority.

The closing stretch covers Israeli politics and American opinion. Remnick draws the line between Religious Zionism, for which Hebron is the soul of the country, and the older Labor Zionism. The two also discuss why Israelis fear a "Gaza in the West Bank," and why Remnick rejects a one-state solution as likely to be more violent than the status quo. Klein contrasts how Israelis and Americans see the conflict, notes the generational shift among American Jews, and asks why many Israelis prefer Trump to Harris.

Sharpest takeaway

Remnick argues that the Israeli-Palestinian conflict has reached a state of intractable tragedy driven by ideological entrenchment on both sides, the collapse of moderate Palestinian leadership, and Israel's shift toward religious nationalism and settlement expansion, making a two-state solution practically impossible despite its theoretical necessity.

  • Netanyahu's long political dominance has systematically prevented Palestinian state-building while empowering settlers and religious nationalists like Bennett
  • Hamas's October 7th attack succeeded strategically in shattering Israel's security myth and radicalizing both Israeli and Palestinian politics further rightward
  • Israel's settlement architecture in the West Bank is now so comprehensive and systematic that reversal appears impossible without political transformation unlikely in the foreseeable future

The claims · ranked83 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.86

During his imprisonment, Sinwar was pivotal in discovering that taking hostages was tactically effective, evidenced by a document in his police file showing he and a cellmate tried to engineer the taking of Israeli military hostages from jail through his brother and the other cellmate's brother, though the plot was discovered and foiled.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· David Remnick

“in jail the most important thing that happened to him that helped shape events was the increasing Awareness on a tactical level that the taking of hostages was effective in fact I discovered a document thanks to the help of my colleague Ruth Margy in his police file that showed that he and one of his uh cellmates try to engineer The Taking of Israeli military hostages from their jail cells through the use of his brother the other guy's brother and the plot was foiled and found out um so that was step one”

0.80

Sinwar was arrested by Israelis in the late 1980s and remained in Israeli jails for the better part of a couple of decades, during which he learned Hebrew perfectly, read Israeli newspapers, watched Israeli television, became fluent in Israeli society and politics, and read memoirs of security chiefs and prime ministers.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· David Remnick

“sinir was arrested by the Israelis and put in jail in the late 80s and there he remained for the better part of a couple of decades and in Israeli jails he decided with a great sense of determination because he wanted to be a leader of Hamas and was committed to to Arms struggle he learned Hebrew and he learned it perfectly he read Israeli papers he watched Israeli television he became incredibly familiar with and and fluent in Israeli Society language politicians he read Memoirs of uh security Chiefs Prime Ministers and all the rest”

0.80

Sinwar wrote a novel called 'The Thorn in the Carnation' about his prison experiences, which he smuggled out bit by bit while incarcerated, and which portrays his self-justifying narrative of becoming a political and military leader.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· David Remnick

“he wrote a novel too by the way he wrote a novel about his experiences called The Thorn in the Carnation obviously it's a very self-justifying uh novel it's not a particularly brilliant novel but it's an extremely interesting no he in prison and has it smuggled out while he's in B by bit yeah we know that this novel exists because it was it was on Amazon for a while and um after October 7th there were loud protests uh against Amazon by the an employee of Amazon was one of the hostages”

0.75

The locus of internal conflict in Israel has shifted from whether there should be a peace plan with Palestinians to whether Israel will remain a democracy, with fights over the Supreme Court, whether the Orthodox military service requirement, and the treatment of Arab Israelis.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ezra Klein

“there are fights over the Supreme Court there are fights over whether or not the Orthodox the her will serve in the military the the locus of internal conflict in Israel seems to me to have changed quite dramatically”

0.75

Sinwar told an Israeli dentist named Boaz Biton that he was ready to sacrifice 20,000, 30,000, or even 100,000 Palestinians in order to achieve liberation and the elimination of Israel.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ezra Klein

“he says to this dentist at some point that he's ready to sacrifice 20,000 30,000 100,000 Palestinians in order to that's right you're referring to a dentist named Bon b t t n who lives on kibuts and was a dentist in the Israeli prison system and biton struck up a relationship or vice versa with sinir and he had lots and lots of conversations with sinir”

0.75

American support for Israel is generationally shifting, particularly among American Jews; the generation that grew up with the 1967 war and liberal Zionism that they could relate to is different from younger generations whose views are radically different, though this shift is not uniform across religious communities.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ezra Klein

“American support for Israel is Shifting generationally particularly among American Jews you know the generation that grew up with the 67 war and a kind of liberal Zionism that they could relate to and traveling back and forth and feeling a sense of profound kinship that is Chang changed not for the religious community and I straddle both in my own life right I I'm a secular Jew with a deep interest in this and I watch and listen to the younger people around me how they view this and I also you know I have religious conservative relatives as well and I hear how they talk about it it is radically different”

0.74

Sinwar was appointed to lead the Majed, Hamas's morality police and the organization that would root out, prosecute, torture, and kill people who dared to collaborate with Israelis in Gaza, and he was known to be particularly ruthless in this role in southern Gaza.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· David Remnick

“sinir found himself appointed to be one of the leaders of something called the Majed the Majed would be hamas's morality police and also most most importantly the organization that would root out prosecute torture and kill people who Dar to collaborate with the Israelis in Gaza and since war was known to be a particularly ruthless uh head of the Majed in Southern Southern Gaza”

0.74

Religious Zionism is not uniform but immensely powerful and has a very different perspective on the land: what is outside the green line (the West Bank) is not religiously significant in the same way as what is within it; Tel Aviv is nice but secular and not the soul of Israel, whereas Hebron is the soul of Israel—the heart and soul resides in places like Hebron, not in secular Tel Aviv.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· David Remnick

“it's not uniform but it is immensely powerful and it has a very different perspective on on the land the what is in the green line is not religiously what is in in Israel yeah Tel Aviv is nice but Kevon is the soul of why we're here you would hear that from a lot of religious nationalists Tel Aviv is you know it's not Sodom and Gomorrah but it's this kind of secular modern aspect of Israel but the heart and soul of Israel is Jewish not um this other thing and that resides in places like Kon”

0.74

Sinwar's parents fled from what is now called Ashalon, a Palestinian village on the coast, to the Gaza Strip in 1948, and he grew up in a particularly religious family and attached himself to Sheikh Yassin, the founder of Hamas, while a university student at the Islamic University.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· David Remnick

“Yayos and yayos and's parents were from what is now called ashalon which was a Palestinian Village up the coast from Gaza and in 19 48 they fled to what is Gaza Strip and they settled there and Sinar was a a a religious kid you know he grew up in a in a particularly religious family um and when he was a university student at the Islamic University he attached himself to Sheik Yasin who was sheikin sheikin was the founder of Hamas”

0.74

Sinwar was part of the negotiations over Gilad Shalit's release and was the hardline negotiator holding out for much more than a thousand prisoners, so much so that Netanyahu (who did the deal under political pressure) put him in solitary confinement to isolate him from negotiations to finalize the agreement.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· David Remnick

“and Sinar is part of the negotiations over this he was and he was the most hard line of the negotiators in fact I he was holding out for much more than a thousand they put him in solitary confinement to isolate him from the negotiations to do the deal by the way Netanyahu is the politician that's what I'm saying who released a thousand prisoners under tremendous political pressure”

0.74

Every Israeli believes the real enemy is Iran, and this view is functional in how they perceive threats from Hamas, Hezbollah, and Houthis, not because of imagination but because Iran's leadership has made plain through rhetoric and actions that the elimination of the State of Israel is part of the national project.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· David Remnick

“this gets also to I think a deeper ideological Dimension every single Israeli I spoke to believes the Real Enemy for them is Iran and functionally every threat they face from Hamas even more so Hezbollah hoties in a smaller but unexpected and significant way and they don't think it because they have U uh a rich imagination they think it because for years and years the leadership of of Iran has made it absolutely plain in its rhetoric and in its actions that it its intentions it's it it the reason for being for the state to some degree is the future elimination of the state of Israel it's it's part of the national project”

0.74

Netanyahu's brother Yoni was the only Israeli killed in the heroic 1976 military operation to Uganda that brought back Israeli hostages from PLO captors, a family tragedy that shapes Netanyahu's entire worldview and contributes to his sense of being in an existential struggle.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· David Remnick

“bib netanyahu's brother y only was the one Israeli killed at the heroic uh 1976 uh military operation that went to Uganda and brought back Israeli hostages from from their PLO captors this family history weighs an Netanyahu and shapes him I think entirely without becoming an absurd psychohistorian of it's it's just obvious”

0.74

Palestinians in the West Bank view what is happening not as mistakes but as a deliberate policy project—the spirit of Labor Zionism that dominated post-1948 Israel has given way to the spirit of the settlers as the dominant ethos even though they are a minority, paralleling how the character of the country changes.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Ezra Klein

“when I talk to Palestinians there what they felt was happening was not mistakes but a a policy project and what they believe the polic a policy project and the politics and as the politics of Israel are being led by the the just as the kind of pioneers post 1948 what was then called Labor Zionism was the dominant spirit and political ethos of the country for all its uh mistakes and worse right now the in many quarters the dominant e ethos even though they are far from they a distinct minority in the country is the eth those Spirit of the of the settlers”

0.74

Remnick does not think a one-state solution with equal rights and political participation is plausible, describing it as 'the elimination of Israel for something else that is potentially even more violent' and 'make Yugoslavia look like a picnic'.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· David Remnick

“I think to some people the more satisfying notion of well it it'll be from the Mediterranean to the Jordan one state I don't see that as anything other than the elimination of Israel for something else that is potentially even more violent and leading to a history of constant War I just right now myself just try not to think about the the end points at all make Yugoslavia look like and you hear that a lot”

0.74

Israelis see themselves as locked in an ongoing multi-generational war against a patient adversary who strikes from all directions using various clients and may soon have nuclear weapons, whereas Americans see Israel as Goliath against a Palestinian David, representing a fundamental difference in how the two countries perceive the conflict.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Ezra Klein

“this to me was what Israelis felt we most did not understand about them because it looked to us in America like they are Goliath against the Palestinian David and they see themselves as locked in a you know ongoing multigenerational war against a patient adversary who strikes at them from all directions using all kinds of different clients and may one day in fact one day soon have nuclear weapons”

0.73

Netanyahu's father, Benzion Netanyahu, was a scholar of the Spanish Inquisition and follower of revisionist Zionism developed by Jabotinsky, which believed the state of Israel should extend beyond the West Bank to the East Bank of the Jordan River and viewed any compromise as a betrayal of Jews in history, informing Netanyahu's worldview about any compromise being weakness.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· David Remnick

“BBE netanyahu's father benzon Netanyahu was a was a scholar in some ways felt himself to be a scorn scholar of the Spanish Inquisition he was a follower not of mainstream um labor Zionism but rather a follower of what's called revisionist sist and much more conservative uh an ideology developed by jabotinsky as opposed to Boran and and so on long story so when you say revisionist Zionism what was it revising revising it was revising in a sense um what was considered mainstream Zionism the revisionist Zionist led by jabotinsky felt that they were too compromising they felt that the state of Israel should be not only in the West Bank of the Jordan River but the East Bank they were essentially looking for as much territory as possible not because they were unaware of the presence of Arabs in erit Israel in the land of Israel but because they felt that that was a menace and they needed as much land as possible and there in lay the most essential difference at every turn the ideology of the old man benzio Netanyahu was that the worst thing you can be is a frier a frier in in Hebrew means a sucker Oslo was the ultimate in being a sucker uh any he he didn't believe in even the partition plan of 1947”

0.70

Netanyahu has treated American partners with astonishing cynicism and lies for years; Bill Clinton left a meeting with Netanyahu and said aloud 'wait a minute, who's the superpower here', and Obama extended himself on negotiations, to which Netanyahu gave the Bar-Ilan speech hinting at Palestinian statehood but it was all a sham.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· David Remnick

“he has lied to and Betrayed at certain instances for years American presidents and it's it's unbelievable Bill Clinton remember him leaving a meeting with uh Netanyahu and he and he said out loud wait a minute who's the superpower here he wasn't kidding around Obama who whom the Netanyahu loathed you know extended himself and to to such a degree that Netanyahu made his iCal speech at barlon University hinting that he might be for a Palestinian state it was all a sham it was all a sham”

0.69

In the West Bank, there is a comprehensive and systematic architecture of isolation and oppression that has been building over decades; if you take a varied ride through Janine, Nablus, and villages in Ramallah, you see this architecture everywhere, and with each passing year it becomes harder to believe it is reversible.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Remnick

“if you take a much more um varied ride and you go to Janine and to nablas and you go to The outskirt Villages of rala and you see how there is an architecture of isolation and oppression that has been building and building and building over the decades in the West Bank what you see is something so comprehensive and systematic that with each passing year it becomes harder to believe especially if you're Palestinian but I think for everybody that this is reversible”

0.69

A prevalent Israeli view is that the Gaza withdrawal in the 1990s was a mistake because Gaza then created and empowered Hamas, so if Israel withdrew from the West Bank, they would get 'Gaza in the West Bank'—a psychological blocking of any separation or dismantling of settlements even though such a transformation would require a political and psychological shift in Israeli society that doesn't currently exist.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Remnick

“the Israeli view of this a predominant Israeli view of this now in the rearview mirror is that Gaza and gazin just went ahead and created and empowered Hamas and things were terrible so and if we do that in the West Bank we will get Gaza in the West Bank that's the common psychology to imagine a dismantling of the settlement project in the West Bank would require a political transformation in Israel a psychological uh sense of uh the future and assurance and security that just doesn't exist”

0.69

Israelis have processed American demonstrations against Israeli policy as uniformly pro-Hamas despite the actual diversity of perspectives; there is both a fear and a willful misunderstanding that conflates criticism of Israel with antisemitism or support for Hamas, when in fact many American critics have deep revulsion for Hamas while also criticizing Israeli actions.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ezra Klein

“I've watched how and listen to how Israelis have processed the demonstrations in this country and sometimes hearing that they're all pramas across the board and there's a a a kind of both a fear and a profound un misunderstanding a willful misunderstanding that no in fact that there's there's deep revulsion for what's happened in Gaza and it's possible to have that at the same time not in any any way sympathize with um hamas's attack on Israel it's possible to have both things in your mind”

0.69

Palestinian moderates who wanted a Palestinian state and fought for years for it and never liked Hamas have now grudgingly come to admire Sinwar because of the failures of the Palestinian Authority, the weakness of Palestinian moderation, and the long years of settlement expansion that have made a two-state solution feel even remotely real or achievable.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Remnick

“and have never really liked Hamas have now reached the point where they grudgingly and I it's it's a bitter thing to say admire sinir because of the failures the weakness of the Palestinian Authority and because of the long years that have passed in which the settlement movement has grown and grown and grown and the thought of a two-state solution spoken about so ardently in certain Corners still in Washington and and elsewhere it just doesn't feel even remotely real”

0.69

The Israeli left's decline is influenced by many factors: Russian immigration, religious birth rates, and it represents a political culture now in a moment of trauma, protectiveness, and deep existential concern, which is a recipe for being on the right.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Remnick

“and has been influenced by all any number of currents whether it's Russian immigration religious birth rates it's just not a political circumstance where the the left or even the center left I mean even yayer Leed who was I believe interviewed by the times not long ago he can't talk about Palestinian State it's a political culture that it's in in a moment of trauma protectiveness and deep existential concern and that that's a recipe for being on the right”

0.69

Before his imprisonment, Sinwar's primary experience in violence was in killing Palestinians through his work with the Majed, not Israelis, though he had no compunction about killing Israelis either.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Remnick

“you might imagine the leader of Hamas is somebody whose experience is Waging War against Israelis killing Israelis but his experience is at least before prison appears to be in killing Palestinians I don't think he had any compunction about killing Israelis too”

0.69

In the first week after October 7th, Biden warned Israel not to act out of rage, explicitly referencing the Iraq and Afghanistan wars as cautionary examples of mistakes made when seeking justice while consumed by rage.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Remnick

“you can't look at what has happened here to your mothers your fathers your grandparents Sons daughters children even babies and not scream out for justice justice must be done but I caution this while you feel that rage don't be consumed by it after 9/11 we were in raged in the United States while we sought Justice and got Justice we also made mistakes a very clear reference to the misbegotten Iraq War and to some extent Afghanistan don't do that don't act out of a sense of Rage that was very carefully said in the first week”

0.69

Smotrich cut the amount of tax revenues that Israel was passing on to the Palestinian Authority from its own taxation, preventing the Palestinian Authority from paying its employees, despite the PA being the largest employer in the West Bank, creating a squeezed situation that contradicts security rationales for the occupation.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ezra Klein

“smich had cut the amount of revenues that Israel was passing on of the Palestinian Authority's own taxation so they weren't being able to pay the people they employ they're the largest employer the place was being squeezed right and I went around the West Bank and I thought if what I cared about was security this is not what I would do right I would not want people unpaid I would not want people angry about water Israel is a desel nation superpower they have the capacity to move water around and they do for their own settlers”

0.68

Hezbollah, a Shiite group heavily militarized and infinitely more sophisticated and better armed than Hamas, began attacking northern Israel on October 8th, the day after the October 7th attack.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· David Remnick

“remember October 7th was October 7 7 that was an attack from Hamas something happened the next day on October 8th which is that Hezbollah began to attack Northern Israel Hezbollah is a Shiite group heavily militarized infinitely more sophisticated then Hamas infinitely better armed”

0.68

The situation is not an easy problem with an easy solution but a set of interlocking tragic circumstances, a history of folly, cruelty, and missed opportunities that must be understood thoroughly but should not lead to throwing up one's hands and abandoning hope for a two-state solution despite how naive it may sound.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· David Remnick

“what we're describing Ezra is not an easy solution but a set of interlocking tragic circumstances in a history of folly and cruelty and misted opportunities and it's important to understand that history thoroughly but not throw up your hands and so there I sympathize with the talk of two-state solution no matter how naive it may sound coming out of my mouth or an American politician's mouth”

0.68

Hezbollah has a long history of threatening Israel, including the killing of hundreds of Marines during the Reagan Administration, and has immense power and operational capacity in Lebanon, where it operates in a relatively failed state.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· David Remnick

“it is it is a real threat but what you have right now is a depopulated northern Israel and a constant uh back and forth which is again an absurdly uh bloodless word to describe what's going on but a back and forth that's limited somewhat controlled between Hezbollah in southern Lebanon and and Northern Israel and if you and I know you've been there as have I Hezbollah is a Shiite group heavily militarized infinitely more sophisticated then Hamas infinitely better armed uh and obviously doesn't have the have the sense of isolation and in in fact uh in a relatively failed state of Lebanon its power there is is immense its ability to operate is immense so this has been going on for years Americans old enough to remember even during the Reagan Administration that Hezbollah killed hundreds of Marines it is it is a real threat”

0.68

The only solution for the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is real partition that is secure, just, and lends dignity and possibility to both peoples, but it sounds like the greatest fairy tale of all time and is almost never heard in political conversation in Israel.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· David Remnick

“the only solution again I I don't see it in the offing the only solution is a real partition that is secure just and lent dignity and possibility to both peoples and right now that sounds like the greatest fairy tale mistakes of all time and you don't hear it very very often at at all in in the political conversation in Israel”

0.68

Religious Zionism was discouraged in the early days of the Israeli state; the religious did not see themselves as Zionists initially and wanted to live their own lives and study Torah; but demographic factors and political developments, especially after 1967, made religious Zionism a powerful political force, becoming almost Messianic around the 1967 war and Rabbi Kook's influence and the development of Gush Emunim (the block of the faithful).

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· David Remnick

“religious Zionism was discouraged in the early days of the state the religious were not big zionists to begin with they wanted to live their own lives study Torah and exist birth rates were such political developments were such they became much more powerful and around the time of 1967 religious Zionism became this kind of almost Messianic current in life uh in Israeli life thanks to the after the war uh Rabbi cook and the development of gush emunim the block of the of the faithful the the rise of settlements politics changed and this current grew and grew and grew”

0.66

The Gilad Shalit kidnapping occurred 20 years ago when members of Hamas crossed the border, raided, and kidnapped a young Israeli soldier, bringing him into Gaza, where for the next five years Israeli society was obsessed with the case, with demonstrations on the streets, until he was finally released in exchange for 1,000 Palestinian prisoners.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· David Remnick

“then came the really pivotal gillad Shalit kidnapping 20 years ago you had a situation where members of Hamas came across uh uh the border the fence and kidnapped in a in a raid uh a young Israeli soldier gilad chalit one one brought him into Gaza and for the next five years while Shalit was in the hands of Hamas Israeli Society was obsessed with this case there were demonstrations on the street not entirely dissimilar not in the same scale as that you're seeing now and finally he was released for a thousand Palestinian prisoners”

0.65

American presidents will increasingly feel they can express criticism of Israel without being accused of antisemitism, and this will become more necessary as American investment in Israel—political, military, and in terms of intelligence—comes under fire and must be rationalized.

forecasthigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Remnick

“I mean you hear this I used to hear this about Obama all the time he's an anti-semite but it's important for friends to speak firmly and directly to one another in moments of Crisis and I think you're going to see that more and more whether it's kamla Harris or any number of other politicians in the future it's a necessity and because our investment in politically uh militarily in terms of intelligence is immense and it's going to come under Fire and it has to be uh those politicians are going to have to rationalize that”

0.65

There is no evidence that Netanyahu really wanted substantive negotiations—he wanted only to 'tread water' and show Americans that he was negotiating, with no genuine political impulse to create a politics or constituency for Palestinian statehood.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Remnick

“there's no evidence that Netanyahu really wanted negotiations for anything other than to tread water and to show The Americans that he was doing so there was no political impulse in him and in his and we shouldn't blame everything on one guy that's that's ridiculous but he had no interest in creating a a politics or a constituency for the creation of a Palestinian state”

0.65

Area A of the West Bank is run by the Palestinian Authority, Area B is shared in a complicated way, and Area C comprises 60% of the land mass and is governed by Israel with no Palestinian Authority governance, creating a system where water access, trash collection, and basic services are visibly different based on whether Israelis or Palestinians live in an area.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ezra Klein

“West Bank is run by the Palestinian Authority there's actually areas ABN C area a is run by the Palestinian Authority to a large extent B is in a complicated way shared C which is 60% of the land mass roughly of the West Bank is just governed by Israel uh the Palestinian Authority cannot govern there and what one of the things I noticed often in in SE was trash in the areas of sea where Israelis live trash is picked up it looks great in the areas where Palestinians live or move trashes everywhere”

0.65

Boaz Biton, a dentist from Kibbutz who worked in the Israeli prison system, had numerous conversations with Sinwar and there have been many other Israeli visitors to the jails and numerous semi-recent interviews with Sinwar, meaning he is not a figure of extraordinary mystery.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Remnick

“you're referring to a dentist named Bon b t t n who lives on kibuts and was a dentist in the Israeli prison system and biton struck up a relationship or vice versa with sinir and he had lots and lots of conversations with sinir by the way and so have many other Israeli visitors to those jails and there have been numerous interviews even semi-recent interviews with senoir he is not a figure who's one of extraordinary mystery”

0.65

Salam Fayyad, the former Palestinian Authority prime minister, was as good a partner for Israeli negotiations as Israel could have hoped for, but Israel under Netanyahu systematically undermined rather than strengthened the Palestinian Authority, suggesting that Netanyahu did not actually want a successful Palestinian governing partner.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Remnick

“we we Salam fad was as good a partner as Israel could have hoped for if your intention was to make actual progress rather than to stifle it why did Israel over this period which was let's call the period of netanyahu's long Reign not want a stronger Palestinian Authority why did they not want the more moderate of the factions vying for leadership of the Palestinians to become stronger because they didn't want to State ultimately they didn't really want there's no evidence that Netanyahu really wanted negotiations for anything other than to tread water and to show The Americans that he was doing so”

0.65

Smotrich, the Finance Minister, has argued that the mistake Israel has made is giving Palestinians hope of a state, and that instead Israel should break that hope by making clear Palestinians will never get a state and forcing them to live with either better behavior receiving better quality of life or harassment driving them eastward into Jordan.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ezra Klein

“there's a famous document from smotrich the the Finance Minister who says something like this in 2017 I believe but there's an argument that the mistake Israelis have made is to give Palestinians a hope of a state what they need to do is break that hope what they need to do is make sure Palestinians know they will never get a state and if they live there with better Behaviour they get a better quality of life or they get harassed out into Jordan”

0.65

Netanyahu's entire political strategy has been to align Israel with the American right, and this has come to fruition in a damaging way for Israel; Joe Biden tried to reverse this alignment but ultimately failed, and now many Israelis rationally understand their long-term security lies in an alliance with the American right rather than the Democratic party.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ezra Klein

“this is something that has been a through line of netanyahu's entire career of his entire political strategy you can say that it has come to fruition in a damaging way for them I think Joe Biden was trying to reverse it and I think ultimately has failed but I think that for many Israelis they now maybe rationally understand their longterm security is an alliance with the American right that in the end there practically is the Democratic party's generational changes happen that there's going to be too much pressure from democratic politicians to be an Israel they don't want to be or don't believe it is safe for them to be or don't believe they should be and that there is potentially space on the right for a more partis which is dangerous because sometimes your people are not in power but also less demanding relationship”

0.64

The return of evacuated residents to northern Israel has recently been announced as an official Israeli war goal, and 67% of Israelis in a September poll said the government should intensify its response to Hezbollah.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· David Remnick

“one thing is that it is just been announced recently that the return of evacuated residents to the north which means the safety of the north is now an official War goal members of the Israeli military political class are speaking much more of going into Lebanon now um 67% of Israelis in September poll say the government should intensify its response to Hezbollah”

0.64

Haaretz is publishing significant coverage of Gaza in Hebrew every day, but it has a modest readership in Israel, mostly reaching liberal readers and English-speaking readers outside Israel.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· David Remnick

“the one Outlet that's publishing a lot about Gaza in Hebrew every day is harits but that's a newspaper that now reaches a lot of people here uh probably a lot of Lial readers in the united states and englishspeaking countries but it's a modest readership Isel”

0.64

Northern Israel has become a depopulated region, with towns like Kirat Shona and small kibbutzim completely empty as 60,000 to 80,000 Israeli residents have been displaced from the north and are living in temporary accommodations elsewhere in Israel.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ezra Klein

“they're empty they're empty just as a lot of places in Southern Israel have now been transformed Israel has shrunk in strategic Geographic sense Israel already a tiny state has shrunk this to me was the the the piece of it that is most potent in the politics there that you hear the least about here I was up in kirat Shona it was on fire when I was there um as you say everything is Ghost Town you're dealing with tens of thousands I think the number I heard then was 60 to 80,000 interal Israel refugees”

0.64

Yahya Sinwar is the most powerful person in Gaza and the decider for Hamas, has been since before October 7th, and communicates with the outside world by runner and written message because he does not trust electronic communications.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· David Remnick

“Yaya senoir is for all intents and purposes the leader of Hamas in Gaza and has been for some time at this point the most powerful person in Gaza and the decider for Hamas and has been for quite a while he's now so far as we know underground and has been since October 7th and communicates with the outside world and his Hamas colleagues by Runner and by by uh written message because he doesn't trust electronic communications”

0.64

A Channel 12 poll found that 50% of Israelis would vote for Donald Trump in the American election, 25% would vote for Kamala Harris, and the remainder didn't know, with Trump even beating Biden despite Israeli gratitude for his early war support.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ezra Klein

“pulled Israeli views on the American election just came out a couple days ago and it found that 50% of Israelis would vote for Donald Trump found that 25% of Israelis would vote for K har the remainder didn't know I think Trump even beat Biden despite the fact that a lot of Israelis were incredibly grateful at least in the first months of the war for his support”

0.63

Netanyahu could not have built a coalition to his left and couldn't have even if he wanted to; the center-left is vastly diminished, and Labor Zionism of the early kibbutz-building era is no longer politically salient; the entire political culture has shifted.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· David Remnick

“it it's not like BB made any effort to or or necessarily could have built a coalition to his left it it's very important to tell ourselves the sad truth the center Center left is vastly diminished it's not just that the Labor's Zionism of khaki shirts and you know good liberals and amas O novel reading uh public has has has diminished a lot this is a very different uh political culture”

0.62

Israeli settlers tell Klein that their presence in the West Bank is necessary for security because if the West Bank was a Palestinian state under the PA, it would raise up an army, make common cause with neighbors, and eventually commit a slaughter that October 7th couldn't match, citing the ability to see Ben Gurion Airport from Hilltops as proof.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ezra Klein

“every settler I spoke to every person who lived in a settlement describe themselves now as a centy right that their presence was necessary here because if they were not there if the West Bank was a Palestinian State under the PA it would raise up an army it would make common cause with neighbors and it would eventually come and commit a Slaughter on a scale that October 7th couldn't match look you can see benan Airport from this Hilltop Etc all of it true”

0.61

In Remnick's 2013 profile of Naftali Bennett, Bennett's endgame theory for the conflict was virtual annexation of the West Bank followed by a potential exodus of Palestinians eastward into Jordan, where Palestinians are already a majority—a position that has become commonplace on the Israeli right.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ezra Klein

“Bennett solution has become a common place on the right virtual annexation followed by a potential Exodus of dispirited Palestinians Eastward into Jordan where Palestinians are already a majority”

0.61

Israeli media does not adequately report on what is happening in Gaza; Israelis are not seeing the destruction and scale of death happening every night, seeing instead primarily military operations, military spokes, embeds in the Philadelphia Corridor, and coverage focused on hostages and political battles.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· David Remnick

“if you're an Israeli you are not seeing what's going on in Gaza every night not on channel 12 not on 13 and certainly not on 14 which is the kind of Fox news station you seeing military operations you're seeing the military spokes taking an embed of some correspondence into the Philadelphia Corridor near Rafa you're much more you're seeing lots and lots understandably about the hostages about interesing political battles Street demonstrations”

0.60

Prior to October 7th, there was acceleration of settlement construction; after October 7th, there has been both continued acceleration of settlements and a real rise in settler violence with almost 700 Palestinians killed, and now there is talk of a third Intifada.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ezra Klein

“one thing that has just been true prior to October 7th you were seeing an acceleration of settlement construction after October 7th You've have both seen that but you have also seen a real rise in settler violence around or almost 700 Palestinians have been killed and there is talk you hear talk now of a third inata right”

0.59

Bennett was prime minister for a year and there were claims he moderated somewhat on issues like LGBTQ rights (he is supportive), though his rhetoric on other topics has remained or become more extreme; he was a critic of Netanyahu's prosecution of the Gaza war, believing it was too slow and hesitant and that Israeli leadership was too influenced by American pressure to slow operations.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· David Remnick

“he was prime minister for a year and there were people that would say that he moderated himself to some extent on the one hand when asked about gay marriage he made some crack that is better not repeated it was quite disgusting but on the other hand he was for lgbtq rights so there was in some way some softening of rhetoric but he is extremely conservative and if anything he was a Critic of Netanyahu on the prosecution of the war in Gaza he thought it was too slow too hesitant that that the Israeli leadership was guilty of listening to the Americans too much”

0.59

Netanyahu is reportedly considering firing his defense minister Galant, with the pretext or reason being Galant's opposition to a full-on invasion of Lebanon.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· David Remnick

“there's talk of Netanyahu firing his defense minister Galant with it's not clear if the reason or the pretext being that Gant has been in opposition to to a fullon invasion of Lebanon”

0.59

Bezalel Smotrich and Ben-Gvir are vile creatures, thugs, extremists, and religious nationalists with backgrounds in trouble with the law; Ben-Gvir couldn't serve in the military and was in so much trouble that he could only work for the police, where he now runs the police forces that control much of how the West Bank is run day-to-day, while Smotrich controls much of the finances in the West Bank—a horrible bargain Netanyahu has made with the devil that is corrosive to Israeli society.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Remnick

“the followers of of of mar Kahana and I'm talking now about benir and smotrich benav and smotrich are vile creatures they're they're thugs they're not just annexationists and extremists they their their background they were in trouble with the law they benir couldn't serve in the military was in so much trouble with the law that's who net police forces just to be clear yeah he runs the police forces that have a lot to do with how the West Bank is run day today smch controls a lot of the finances in the West Bank it's it's horrific and this is netanyahu's latest bargain with the devil and it's corrosive to Israeli Society corrosive is not nearly a strong enough word”

0.57

There may well be soon a war in Lebanon as tensions between Israel and Hezbollah escalate, and there is no vision for the day after—no theory of what comes next after the current conflict.

forecasthigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Ezra Klein

“there may well be soon a war in Lebanon there is no vision for the day after there is no theory of what comes next”

0.56

Naftali Bennett, though he does not live in a settlement (he lives in Raanana on the Mediterranean coast north of Tel Aviv, a town filled with tech people), is a pro-settler and pro-settlement figure whose political ethos aligns with religious nationalism rather than Tel Aviv liberalism.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· David Remnick

“naali Bennett who is quite likely to be the main Challenger to uh bib Netanyahu is to say the least Pro settler and pro settlement project he doesn't live there he lives in ranana on the on the Mediterranean Coast north of Tel Aviv he's Town filled with kind of tech people but his political ethos his political ideas his Spirit doesn't resolve with Tel Aviv liberals it resides elsewhere”

0.56

In his novel, Sinwar rhetorically asks 'Who will be our great Saladin?' in reference to the Muslim leader who defeated the Crusaders, which can be read as Sinwar posing himself, at least at some level, as a possible answer to that question.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· David Remnick

“he asks at one point rhetorically in this novel who will be our great saladine clearly at some level at least how I'm reading it posing himself as a possible answer to that question”

0.55

Nachum Barnea, an Israeli columnist, has been writing for years and has said that he attends funerals of politicians to make sure they're dead, but when Remnick interviewed him after October 7th, Barnea acknowledged that Netanyahu remains the shrewdest raw political actor on the Israeli stage despite lacking affection for him.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· David Remnick

“nak Bara who has been writing a column for yo for God knows how many years when I interviewed him on my first trip after October 7th he said look I go to the funerals of politicians to make sure they're in the ground and BB Netanyahu is and I he has no affection for Netanyahu is Remains The shrewdest Raw political actor on the stage”

0.54

The politician thought to be the great Netanyahu challenger was General Benny Gantz, who led in polls by 30 points, but Gantz is not a skilled politician and is simply 'the not-Netanyahu'; he looked good in uniform and had a military record, but he lacks political ability, and his support has now collapsed; Netanyahu is now behind Bennett in polls.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· David Remnick

“the person was thought to be the the great Pretender that would somehow displace Netanyahu was a military General who had no political skill whatsoever Benny G Benny G Benny G is just not a skilled politician he was just the not Netanyahu and he was in the war counil and he looked great in a uniform and he had I suppose a a a storyed military career but he's that wasn't going to happen and slowly after leading in the polls I think he had was leading by 30 points he's now behind Netanyahu”

0.54

A Channel 12 poll shows Bennett is currently leading Netanyahu as the politician most Israeli voters believe is suited to be prime minister; Israelis prefer Bennett because both he and Netanyahu shift the conversation to the right, but voters believe Bennett is more authentically rightist and thus more suitable.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· David Remnick

“he is the person when right now you pull Israelis there there Channel 12 poll he is the one who leads Netanyahu by the most who is considered to be more suited to be prime minister than Netanyahu somebody said to me that to understand Israeli politics where it was going you had to understand that both there was going to be a rejection of Netanyahu but was going to the right and Bennett reflects that absolutely”

0.54

In early days after October 7th, there was near-universal prediction among Israelis that Netanyahu was done politically and would phase out; however, this has not happened, and Netanyahu has maintained power.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Ezra Klein

“when I talk to Israelis in the the days the weeks the months after October 7th there was uncertainty on every Point except one point was that which is Netanyahu was done he would phase out of Israeli politics and infamy he would try to hang on but I mean the the street and he'd be gone people don't seem to believe that now”

0.53

More than 40,000 Palestinians in Gaza are dead one year after October 7th, there is no viable ceasefire deal, and there is no political vision for what comes after the war.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Ezra Klein

“we are now almost a year from October 7th and where are we more than 40,000 Palestinians in Gaza are dead the hostages are not home does not look like there will be a ceasefire deal that brings them home anytime soon”

0.52

There is a deep historical irony in Netanyahu releasing a thousand prisoners (including Sinwar) for one soldier, which demonstrated the devaluing of Palestinian life becoming a devaluing of Israeli life, essentially confirming the value of hostage-taking as a strategic tool.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ezra Klein

“and I feel like there's a deep historical irony in this the sort of devaluing of Palestinian life becoming a devaluing of of Israeli life he's released because he's not killed Israelis he's killed Palestinians correct correct but many many of the people who were released many of the Palestinian prisoners who were released were in prison for planning or the blowing up of buses or cafes uh um all kinds of uh horrific crimes”

0.52

When Sinwar unleashed his soldiers on October 7th, he was likely hoping for deeper penetration into Israel, but the operation was essentially a suicide mission designed to spark something larger, operating from the sense that the status quo was unacceptable and needed to be exploded.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· David Remnick

“when he Unleashed his soldiers on October 7th that he might have hoped for any number of things even deeper penetration into Israel but it was basically a suicide mission to spark something even larger if possible what he was operating from was a sense that nothing is happening we are still here in Gaza living the life of the oppressed um Palestine is not free the West Bank is in the circumstances it's in meanwhile the israelies are negotiating uh through the good offices of the United States with Saudi Arabia the Abraham Accords and it's ignoring us we need to blow this up”

0.52

When Klein was there in June, spending about half his time in the West Bank, his strongest and unchanging thought was that it resembled what the American South would have felt like in the 1940s or 1950s—a comparison rooted in the visual immediacy of racial segregation and hierarchy.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ezra Klein

“when I was there in June I spent about half of my time in the West Bank and my strongest thought in my first day in the West Bank which never changed and I spent time in the big cities and I spent time in settlements and I spent time in all kinds of places plac was oh this is what the American South would have felt like in the 1940s or 50s”

0.52

The question of how much pressure Israel can apply before an uprising occurs is crucial; withholding tax revenues from the Palestinian Authority and other squeeze tactics feel to Klein like they are 'letting matches around dry tinder' for those annexationists who view a third Intifada as potentially useful for their ends.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ezra Klein

“I and certain things that were being done like the withholding of of tax revenues felt to me like they were they were sort of letting matches around dry tnder for those who do see annexation as an end right and they are there and they have political power is violence a something to be warted off or or invited in which is to say that if you wanted to Annex and hold more of the West Bank a third in uh may not be I mean use that presumption as a means to an end”

0.52

Reading Remnick's 1998 profile of Netanyahu alongside observing him now reveals not so much change but rather a confirmation of who he always was—his ideological commitments have remained consistent, but he has become more fully himself, with his anti-democratic aspects and lust for power allowing him to make common cause with the worst current of religious nationalism.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· David Remnick

“what do you think Netanyahu believes of the situation itself BBE netanyahu's father benzon Netanyahu was a was a scholar in some ways felt himself to be a scorn scholar of the Spanish Inquisition he was a follower not of mainstream um labor Zionism but rather a follower of what's called revisionist sist and much more conservative uh an ideology developed by jabotinsky put aside the corruption I'm I'm not saying that's not a part of his motivations put aside his own politics we'll talk about that in second what do you think Netanyahu believes of the situation itself I think ideologically he's the same guy but I think he became himself as they say about aging you become yourself only more so and the anti-democratic aspect of him and the lust for power allowed himself to make common political cause with followers of the worst and most extreme current of religious nationalism”

0.51

In his novel, Sinwar describes witnessing the 1967 war, which he and his schoolmates expected to be a great victory but turned out to be a humiliation, and a similar experience in 1973, rooting his political fury in his family's exile and these formative national defeats.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· David Remnick

“in the rearview mirror of visiting uh the AL AXA mosque and also the where saladine the Great uh Muslim military leader and political leader who defeated who had victories against the Crusaders and he asks at one point rhetorically in this novel who will be our great saladine clearly at some level at least how I'm reading it posing himself as a possible answer to that question”

0.50

Hussein Agha, a PLO negotiator from the Oslo era, told Klein that in pure terms of consequence, Sinwar won his hoped-for victory by shattering Israeli sense of security, exposing IDF weaknesses and overextension, arousing Fury in the West Bank rather than resignation, and triggering events in which Iran directly fired missiles at Israel, making Sinwar in his own mind—whether he survives or not—a success comparable to Saladin.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Ezra Klein

“I was speaking to um somebody named Hussein AA who was a negotiator for the PLO back when in the sort of better days very sophisticated guy and he said look to some extent sinir and it's a horrible thing to say but on a pure level of consequence that sinir won this great victory that he had hop hope for immediately what do I mean by that and I say this with whatever the opposite of relishes disgust despair that by shattering Israeli sense of security by exposing the weaknesses of the Israeli military or it's the degree to which it's overextended that it's not some mythological institution that could fight on infinite fronts by arousing The Fury that you see in the West Bank rather than a kind of terrible resignation by arousing Hezbollah by tripping off a set of events in which Iran for the first time directly sets missiles off toward Israel well in sino's mind that's an enormous Victory”

0.49

Despite Iran being characterized as an implacable hyper-ideological adversary, what has been surprising is the caution on both sides regarding escalation with each other; there was an Israeli assassination on Iranian diplomatic soil, Iran launched drones that were knocked out of the sky, and both sides stopped, showing a pattern of tit-for-tat that has not exploded.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Ezra Klein

“the thing that has been surprising to me on the other side of this and I think militates against the view of Iran as an implacable hyper ideological adversary is been the sort of caution on both sides of that escalation that includes with Hezbollah which has rockets that could go much deeper into Israel and has not been trying to do primarily civilian targeting there was a sort of exchange between um Iran and Israel Israel uh committed an assassination on sort of Iranian diplomatic soil Iran launched drones that were knocked out of the sky and both sides stopped more or less”

0.48

Galant recognizes that the IDF proved deeply flawed on October 7th, is now exhausted, has suffered losses, and is in no condition to wage war in Lebanon, which is a basis for his objection to invasion plans.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Remnick

“I think Gant also recognizes that the vaunted IDF proved that it was deeply flawed on October 7th and that it is now exhausted it's suffered losses it's um forget the criticism from abroad that the idea that they're now going to wage war in Lebanon is something that Galant objects to”

0.48

Alex Gibney's new film about Netanyahu reveals Netanyahu's personal motivations for his behavior—to keep himself in power and escape corruption charges—showing his dismissiveness, arrogance, wornness, and his wife Sara's sense of entitlement and embattlement, plus their son Yair's inflammatory rhetoric on social media, demonstrating how staying in power too long corrupts a leader until he becomes his worst version of himself.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Remnick

“I really recommend there's a new film about Netanyahu that Alex gibney's jigsaw Productions just just did and at the heart of it is a subject we haven't discussed which is netanyahu's motivations his political personal motivations for the way he's behaving to keep himself in power and behind it to some extent are the corruption Chargers that are leveled against him and he knows that the longer he stays in power the more attenuated those charges get and the more he can escape them and you see in this film so vividly the dismissiveness and the arrogance the worn outness of Netanyahu and the outlandish sense of entitlement and embattlement of SAR Netanyahu and the magal likee rhetoric of yayer Netanyahu the son who sounds like somebody who's just never off of Truth social going on and on about how the Israeli people and the particularly the media are ungrateful”

0.48

There is a binary choice being forced on observers: either check your liberalism or your support for Israel, because Israel is becoming illiberal and has no pathway or intention of becoming other than that unless forced by external pressure to change its politics.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ezra Klein

“speaking here specifically though of America that it's a point that others have made but this question where you will have to check your liberalism or your support for Israel because Israel is becoming illiberal arguably already has no pathway or intention of becoming other than that”

0.48

The Trump administration from 2016-2020 felt endless while it was occurring but was not inscribed in American politics as ineradicable, suggesting that political change is possible even after seeming permanent damage, offering some hope that Israeli democratic change might also be possible.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ezra Klein

“look we had the mostal president imaginable from 2016 to 2020 and while we were living it it felt endless but it was not necessarily yet inscribed in our politics that it was ineradicable I mean this to me is one of when you think about divisions in Israeli Society I think some people here still think of you know there once were these big divisions about should there be a peace plan or not now about whether or not Israel will be a democracy”

0.48

If Klein thought he was facing an existential threat from a soon-to-be nuclear regional power with imperialistic ambitions, deep ties to Russia and China, his international alliances would be extremely important, his alliance with America would be paramount, and Europe would be significant—yet Israel at the same time emphasizes long-term multi-pronged threats from Iran but shows recklessness in how it is seen internationally and how it treats partners like America.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ezra Klein

“here's the piece of this that I found perplexing I understand a lot of the argument and and believe it that Israelites make about Iran at the same time if I thought I was facing existential threat from a soon to be nuclear Regional power with an imperialistic past and Grand strategic Ambitions and deep ties to Russia and China my International alliances would be extremely important to me my alliance with America would be extremely important to me um Europe would be significant to me and at the same time that there's this emphasis on the long-term multi-pronged multilateral threat of Iran there is this recklessness I see in Israel in terms of how it is seen internationally”

0.48

Israeli claims about being a functioning democracy are defended by referencing the free press and freedoms that don't exist elsewhere in the Middle East, but the comparison is problematic given that America itself has become minoritarian in its presidential outcomes and its own democratic commitments are peculiar.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Ezra Klein

“let me be the ventriloquist for what some Israelis would then say to you although I I I see the sense in what you're saying they would say hey wait a minute we still have a free press we have all kind of freedoms here that don't exist elsewhere in the Middle East the United States's commitment to democratic Norms is rather peculiar when you can win a majority of the vote for presidency and then lose the presidency what's that about you know our politics in some ways are minoritarian arguably so that gets played back against us in some in some corns”

0.47

Political actors on both the Israeli and Palestinian sides are 'fantasists with guns'—people with ideological visions but no realistic pathway to achieving their goals, as evidenced by a Hamas conference before October 7th about what taking over would look like, where speakers debated whether to expel, kill, or retain the Jewish population based on their economic value.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· David Remnick

“I think part of what distinguishes this part of the world is that there are political actors on both sides who are fantasists fantasists with guns and in Gaza not that long before October 7th a couple years before I forget the date there was a conference sponsored by Hamas sponsored by sinir about what taking over would look like and there were all kinds of speeches and very specific plans about what would happen on the day after Israel was eliminated and Palestine was liberated in their terms what should we do about the Jews should we kick out everybody out or or kill them or should we keep the ones that are really valuable who are doctors or Advanced Computer programmers that conference of the Hereafter took place that was on a level of fantasy I think it's fair to say”

0.45

Sinwar now lives underground and communicates by messenger, and while he had an extraordinarily successful lethal attack on October 7th, Gaza is destroyed, tens of thousands of people are dead, and Remnick does not believe, based on reviewing all his collected speeches and interviews, that Sinwar still believes there is a viable path to immediate success, but rather that he sees himself as a great actor in a great historical struggle.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Remnick

“he might be fine D Hamas is Rule let's be clear yoir is unavailable for comment I certainly have not talked to him for this piece or or anything else but if we accumulate all his collected speeches and interviews and look at them and review them it's very clear that he sees himself as a great actor in a great historical struggle”

0.45

Many of the Palestinian prisoners released in the Gilad Shalit exchange were in prison for planning or carrying out bombings of buses or cafes and other horrific crimes, yet Netanyahu has somehow survived politically despite being the one who released the mastermind of the October 7th massacre.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ezra Klein

“but many many of the people who were released many of the Palestinian prisoners who were released were in prison for planning or the blowing up of buses or cafes uh um all kinds of uh horrific crimes this is one of the bits of this that I am surprised Netanyahu has survived this whole moment goes back to a deal that confirms the value of Hostage taking in a incredibly lopsided negotiation and releases The Mastermind of the October 7th Massacre”

0.45

Neither a two-state nor one-state solution is plausible right now; no preconditions exist for either, and the question is what American policy should be given that Israel has no genuine interest in a political horizon with Palestinians.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ezra Klein

“I don't think any solutions are plausible right now I don't think that a two- State solution is in any way plausible or realistic that any of the preconditions exist we agree I don't think a one state a one state reality is sort of there in a way but a one state solution when people are talking about equal rights and political participation or Confederation and yet it's a very bitter thing to hear particularly if you're sitting in a in a in the West Bank yes and living the life of of a Palestinian today”

0.45

The Israeli refugees from the north reported feeling profound fury and asked what would make them feel safe enough to return, understanding that October 7th now looks like a 'Coming Attractions preview' of what Hezbollah capabilities suggest could be possible.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ezra Klein

“some of the interviews I did with people who had lived up there whose family had now been living you know in a one-bedroom hotel room right you know somewhere else now for you know seven months like their Fury was palpable and and their question which they they kept posing to me and and I don't have an answer for but but seems to me to becoming more Central in Israeli politics is what is supposed to make them feel safe enough to to go back I mean some of these people on the border they say look I can see Hezbollah and and to me October 7th now feels like a Coming Attractions preview right they can see them”

0.42

Biden has an emotional, generational feel for Israel and a vocabulary that Israelis can relate to; his administration's reporting suggests he has a deep emotional connection to Israel, which is different from Trump's apparent indifference to whether Israel exists or not.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· David Remnick

“I mean Biden I will say this has a feel for Israel and I think something I see in that poll well he also has a generational feel and a vocabulary that is the Israelis particularly Israelis of a certain age can understand his connection Israel is emotional uh like I believe that about him very deeply all my reporting on the administration suggest that to be true”

0.39

There is potentially space on the right for a less demanding relationship with Israel compared to the Democratic party, but with emphasis on 'less demanding'—because Trump cares little about Israel policy either way and may simply be transactional.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ezra Klein

“and that there is potentially space on the right for a more partis which is dangerous because sometimes your people are not in power but also less demanding relationship I think emphasis on the less demanding if they only knew how little Donald Trump cared one way or the other”

0.34

Bennett eventually became Chief of Staff to Netanyahu, which is described as a thankless job, and the two fell out, partly over Sarah Netanyahu's difficult temperament and management of staff.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· David Remnick

“he became eventually Chief of Staff to Netanyahu a more thankless job one could not imagine and they fell out over Sarah Netanyahu who apparently was not a wonderful to work with or around but they come from different streams”

0.20

Remnick recommends three books for audiences in the context of an election about the future of democracy: 'Hope Against Hope' by Nadezhda Mandelstam (about surviving Stalinism), Jill Lepore's survey of American history, and Kwame Anthony Appiah's 'Cosmopolitanism' (about multiple identities and world citizenship).

normativespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· David Remnick

“the first is a book called hope against hope which is a memoir by nes dandam who was the wife of then the Widow of the great poet OIP mandam and it's a memoir in which the ferocity of spirit and facing up to the worst uh that the world has to offer particularly during the Stalin period is is is exemplified in the most heroic way I love that book hope against hope that's one just as a pure American history I think Jill Lor's survey is is these truth it's just so moving brilliantly written and I'm not picking it because she's my colleague at the New Yorker much the third is kwami Anthony apia's book cosmopolitanism”

0.20

The observation that one is speaking from a podcast studio in New York to a comfortable audience must be accepted as a limitation on the moral authority of criticism of Israeli policy, though this does not invalidate the observation about the reality of the occupation.

normativespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Ezra Klein

“I think this is and the point that it's all easy to say from a podcast studio in in New York is true like you have to accept that that is true this is simply an observation about the reality of it”