
Simple Things You Can Do to Become a Better Listener | Carolyn Coughlin | Knowledge Project Podcast
What this covers
Shane Parrish talks with executive coach Carolyn Coughlin about listening as a developmental practice rather than a set of techniques. She grounds it in Adult Development Theory, the idea that sense-making keeps changing well past physical adulthood. She also draws on Robert Kegan's Subject-Object Theory, which separates what we are fused with from what we can hold out and examine. Listening below the surface means asking what a speaker actually means by their words. The talk contrasts listening to learn with listening to fix, maps the two loosely onto gender socialization, and argues that listening is contagious. It also covers coaching children to listen.
The middle of the conversation is about language. Coughlin looks at how "have to" versus "want to" changes our felt relationship to obligations, and how identity statements and monolithic narratives ("I never get heard") harden into fixed self-concepts. She argues that "I would never do that" quietly builds hierarchies between people. Her claim that speaking "as if" we hold a quality eventually makes it real is flagged as contested. Other threads include work-life balance as an unreachable equilibrium versus a shifting mosaic, listening to bodily sensation, and building tolerance for discomfort in safe settings.
The conversation then widens to complexity: distinguishing obvious, complicated, complex, and chaotic problems, treating polarities as pairs to be managed rather than choices, and Seeing the World as It Is (vs. as Wished)). Changing a complex system starts with understanding how it currently self-organizes. The remote-work segment is the most debatable. It claims remote work encourages echo chambers and uneven commute burdens, and says trust can still be built through structured check-ins. It closes with book recommendations, including Jennifer Garvey Berger's Changing on the Job, and Coughlin's definition of success as helping someone else be more fully themselves.
A speaker trained in adult development theory argues that transforming how we listen, use language, and make meaning—particularly by developing curiosity about other perspectives and recognizing complexity—is essential for both personal development and effective leadership in modern organizations.
- Listening below the surface to understand meaning rather than just words enables deeper connection and perspective-taking, which is foundational to solving complex problems
- Language is not merely expressive but constitutive—the words we use actively shape how we see ourselves and our possibilities, making deliberate language choice a developmental lever
- Most complex problems require embracing nuance and interconnection (polarities) rather than either-or thinking, which demands seeing the world as it is rather than as we wish it to be
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Creating the conditions for change in a complex system (like a person or organization) requires first understanding how the system currently self-organizes—its patterns and dynamics—rather than attempting direct intervention, because the system will push back against imposed change.
“creating the conditions is an idea that is one of the core ideas Moves In in complexity right so if you're wanting to make a change in a complex system which since each of us as human beings is a complex system you know creating the change of becoming a person to go that goes to the gym that that's a that's a complex that's a change to a complex system right if I want my team to behave differently um I'm also dealing with complexity there because people are complex and human systems are complex so the idea is that in a complex system you can't make change happen because the first thing that you need to do is understand how the complex adaptive system currently self-organizes so what are its current patterns um so if you look at a family is one of the easiest ways to see this right families have patterns they have Dynamics people play roles and if you want to um we've probably all heard stories or been part of a story where one person in a family suddenly changes and um it's the the family tries to reject the change right they want to continue acting the same even when one person changes”
Subject-Object Theory (developed by Robert Kegan) is a framework for understanding developmental stages based on what is 'subject' (fused with, invisible, the lens you see through) versus 'object' (held out, examined, can be reflected upon); understanding this distinction is central to listening well because it reveals what developmental stage a person operates from.
“there are very particular techniques that help people listen well for me the most important one has been really the training and under in and understanding of adult development theory particularly the one that um my colleagues and I are most um have most depth in which is the the subject object Theory um that it was developed by Bob Keegan and others and in the subject object Theory you're what you're listening for the stage of development is defined by what is subject and what is object and when I when I say subject what I mean is like what you're fused with it's like the water you're swimming in the lens through which you see things but you don't actually even know you have a lens um and what is object is what can be held out and examined and talked about um like a value is object if you can see how it's shaping um what you do and don't do a value is subject if it's invisibly shaping what you do and don't do for example”
Understanding complexity (via frameworks like Cynefin) helps people see the world as it is rather than as they wish it to be, by distinguishing obvious, complicated, complex, and chaotic domains; this is both immediately useful for problem-solving and developmental in transforming worldview.
“another one that I find really really helpful um is um well actually the idea of complexity itself right so helping people to see the world as a friend of mine used to say to see the world as it is rather than as you want it to be so there's a you know we teach about complexity through a particular framework called the kinevin framework that I think is pretty widely known these days um and so it's a framework that can help immediately to sort out if I'm facing some sort of a challenge like again as a team to sort out which bits of the challenge are are obvious so I can just like automate them don't have to worry about them don't waste time on them which parts are complicated we need to figure them out and which parts are complex and then so we deal with those things differently”
Polarity thinking (based on Barry Johnson's work) is the recognition that many problems are not either-or choices but interconnected pairs that both require management over time; this shifts worldview from trying to optimize one side to dynamically balancing opposites.
“a polarity is um it it's it's two things that are interconnected and that over time you need them both so it's like a an example in organizations is centralized decentralized right if the question is do we need to be decentralized or centralized the answer is most likely both right yes sometimes we need to be decentralized sometimes we need to be centralized in some places we need it's it's in its Dynamic over time right”
Taking multiple perspectives requires deliberately seeking perspectives that are not only different from one's own but are also threatening or challenging to one's identity; this is harder when not forced into such encounters by being physically in shared spaces.
“we have to often work to find the perspectives that are not only different from our own but are maybe even threatening to our own and it's hard enough work when we're showing up at the office every day and going out into a world where we see differences because let's face it we can shut those things out even even more around the world it's just so much easier when we're not interacting with um with people who are unlike us”
Work-from-home and remote-first arrangements make it easier to create echo chambers where one's environment (digital feeds, delivery services, interactions) increasingly reflects one's own views and demographics, reducing unplanned exposure to different perspectives that in-person work previously forced.
“when we work from home it's much easier to create our own Echo Chambers either on purpose or inadvertently and because we have so much more control over what we let in and what we don't let in right whereas if we go yeah you're surrounded by a world that looks like you right so you hop on Zoom you have this interaction with somebody you get off of it you hang it with your friends you get delivery of food groceries whatever and the world just tends to look like you and the socioeconomic world looks like you the political world looks like you and my hunch and I hope I'm wrong is that this starts to lead to political extremes”
Adult development theory shows that even after we reach physical adulthood, our sense-making—how we construct meaning of ourselves and the world—continues to change and develop throughout our lives, contrary to the assumption that adults are fully formed.
“adult development theory is a I sort of think of it as a map it gives us it's a there are several different adult development theories I won't go into detail about them but um but they are each of them is a theory that describes how once we get to the adults so once we look like adults what happens to how does our sense making change and the big news of adult development theory really when it when it first was introduced about 50 close to 60 years ago was this idea that even when we look like adults we are actually um like what's not this so easily visible uh can but doesn't always continue to change”
Listening patterns map roughly to gender socialization—women typically socialized toward 'listening to learn,' men typically toward 'listening to fix'—and this creates communication divides, though the issue is more about mismatched listening approaches than biological difference.
“this sort of comes back to to um matter for Mars Women Are from Venus in a way right which is women typically listen to learn men typically listen to fix problem solve and this creates a divide between us”
Speaking and acting 'as if' we have a quality we wish to cultivate (e.g., speaking as if we're choosing something) eventually translates into actually seeing and experiencing that quality as real, not pretend.
“it isn't just a pretend thing you know they this whole idea of acting as if it's talking as if speaking as if I were choosing after a while that translates into um you're actually seeing it as a choice”
Success means that one's presence mattered to another person—that through one's presence in a room, workshop, friendship, or relationship, the other person was able to be more fully themselves; this is success independent of ideas, intelligence, or accomplishment.
“I just want to look back on my life and know that um that my presence mattered to somebody else like that by me being in whether it's in a room you know running a workshop or whether it's in a friendship whether it's with my children or my partner or anyone else that my presence mattered and not because I had great ideas um not because I was so smart but that in my presence um another person could be more fully themselves”
Practicing being uncomfortable in safe, supportive environments gradually expands capacity to stay present with discomfort rather than immediately acting to eliminate it; like physical exercise, somatic adaptation to discomfort is trainable through incremental practice.
“the second thing I think is um is practicing being in discomfort so um nudging ourselves just a little bit a little bit a little bit in safe circumstances to feel discomfort and stay in it our urge is like going back to the body um often there's this thing called what I call an action urge that when we feel uncomfortable there's something in our bodies that is saying get out of the discomfort so we act or react to remove the discomfort somehow um part of of seeing the world as it is um not just kind of conceptually but actually being in the world as it is requires us to practice being uncomfortable and um our bodies are so and and all parts of us are really adaptable if we if we um put ourselves in uncomfortable situations where there's a safe and supportive environment um it's like going to the gym if you want to build your muscles you just have to go every day and you do it”
Creating identity hierarchies through statements like 'I would never do that' (as distinct from 'that person would') creates subtle separation between us and others, which severs connections that might be important for solving complex problems and building trust.
“I think that's fascinating because one of the things I think about for biological creatures which humans are is that we have an innate sense of hierarchy in the world and hierarchy doesn't doesn't just mean status it can be an identity based hierarchy and when you construct a world and this can be completely wrong so push back but when you construct a world which is like I'm not the type of person who would do that you immediately put yourself higher than that person in this arbitrary hierarchy that you've created which is like no matter what I would never do that to somebody and you might be right you might be wrong but that that sort of like is not the point of this it's just you're placing yourself sort of in and you're not doing it consciously like you're not trying to organize the world in this way where you're better than somebody else”
Remote work enables different groups (e.g., administrative staff vs. professionals) to experience very different commute impacts and quality-of-life trade-offs, suggesting that 'get people back to the office' mandates may mask or ignore these systemic inequities.
“what he discovered was that these people tend to live further from the office so their commute time is really long like over an hour each way and the professionals did what they would call the professional staff tend to live much closer to the office and so their commute time is in their when they're commuting they're like in an Uber or something going from one side of Manhattan to the other side of Manhattan and they're working while they're in the Uber too”
'Changing on the Job' by Jennifer Garvey Berger is the best book written about adult development, particularly in terms of what it means to create conditions for humans to be fully human, and it's highly accessible.
“if you want to know more about adult development um Jennifer my colleague and friend Jennifer Garvey Berger's Book Changing on the job was Far and Away in my opinion the best book that's been written about about adult development not so much the theoretical part although she it's really good on that but essentially like what does it mean what does it mean in terms of creating conditions for humans to be fully human um so that was and it's super accessible I would highly recommend it”
Listening tends to be contagious—how each of us listens wears off on other people, shaping their capacity to listen well or poorly in return.
“listening tends to be contagious so how each of us listens does tend to wear off on other people”
Feeling truly seen and heard through deep listening is one of the most extraordinary experiences a person can have and itself becomes a condition for others to learn to listen well.
“find that when people feel really really truly seen and heard it's one of the most extraordinary experiences that a person can have and so um just being around that and having the experience of being on the receiving end that sort of deep listening where you feel truly seen and fully seen is itself a condition right for for learning to listen well”
Language patterns of necessity ('I have to', 'I need to') versus choice ('I want to') shape how we construct meaning about our responsibilities and commitments; changing habitual language patterns from necessity to agency can shift our embodied experience and sense of relationship to our obligations.
“um that story happened about you know 10 years ago when my children were younger and I was um I was really torn a lot of the time because I was traveling around the world I was really feeling like I was experiencing the most exciting period up until then of my professional career and all parts of my life and and I had these three children at home and a husband who was there with them most of the time because he's a teacher so he didn't travel he was around more and I felt torn you know between these two parts of my life and a good friend of mine noticed that I often when talking about my kids and my family just as you said um used the term have to get home I need to check on them I need to call and um so this I already had had this idea that our language is not just an expression of our meaning making but it also shapes our meaning making so when this friend of mine noticed my that language pattern I began to ask a question like what could I what words could I use um that might actually change the way I make sense make me help support me to be less torn about this kind of kids and family and the rest of my life thing”
Work-life balance is experienced as a perpetual state of failure because the metaphor assumes a static equilibrium that breaks as soon as it is achieved, whereas seeing life as a mosaic allows for dynamic rebalancing where different elements take different prominence at different times.
“I personally find the work-life balance thing uh really hard because you're never in balance and the moment you are in Balance it's out of balance right like you almost have to be actively uh balancing at every moment and therefore you're always sort of failing to achieve a work-life balance because just the second you have it figured out you get an extra email or the kids need to be go to the doctors or something something just like tweaks it and then you're always just you're you're dissatisfied unconsciously with yourself because you're you're trying so hard to achieve this perfect sort of balance that is um a Pursuit and can never actually be realized”
Deep listening means listening below the surface for meaning—noticing not just what words are said but what the speaker actually means by those words, which requires holding curiosity about how one's own assumptions might differ from the speaker's actual meaning.
“so this friend is a developmental coach and she so she's kind of in the practice of wondering um what does when when she hears uh a somebody use a word or a phrase um that doesn't like she notices the dissonance between what she would mean by that and what she notices I might be meaning by that right so this is the the listening below the surface this is listening for meaning um and so it's getting below underneath the story or the words and wondering wow what does that person actually mean by that”
Language that limits people often takes the form of identity statements ('I am this way', 'I am the sort of person who...') and monolithic narratives ('X is always this way', 'I never get my voice heard'), which create fixed self-concepts resistant to change.
“language that is limiting for people is often as simple as what I you know described to you the have to's and the and the need to's it often shows up as like I am just this way um or I am the sort of person who has to respond when somebody emails me right away I have to respond within five minutes um so these are I think I think of these as identity habits languages of habit sorry habits of language around identity I am this way I am that way um kind of language other limit limiting language you can hear in what I sometimes call monolithic narratives um so and so is always this way at work I never seem to get my voice heard there's so many of them if you start to listen to people's language patterns um you'll start to notice all the ways that they can be limiting”
Remote-first organizations can still build strong trust and connection if they establish structured mechanisms for regular, deep connection (e.g., check-ins at the start of meetings) and are intentional about creating conditions for people to know each other as whole persons, not just functional collaborators.
“I mean I don't know you know I we've been a um our firm has been remote since we founded in 2011 and I'd say we have a lot of trust a lot of trusting but we've developed mechanisms to be sure that we connect that like create the conditions for us to connect frequently and deeply um both in the sorts of connections that we set up regularly as part of our systems and the way that we are together when we connect um so that so it really trust really can happen remotely”
We can learn to listen to our own bodies—emotions, sensations, tensions—by asking ourselves 'Where do I feel this?' and scanning inward to notice connections between mental/emotional states and bodily sensations; this requires no external facilitation and can become a habitual self-awareness practice.
“so you don't need another person it can become a habit a habitual question that we ask ourselves and um and over time people I'm a case in point you know I would 15 years ago if you had asked me to notice where do I feel something in my body I would say I don't know like I I would say okay I can make something up you know let me just make something up I'll just tell you I tend to notice this if I feel it in my jaw that means that there's like a little bit of stress element involved in it for me or something I'm not looking forward to doing”
The habitual question 'Why do I do this?' directs attention to finding fault with oneself but often leads to dead ends and doesn't result in behavior change; other questions can be more productive for actual change.
“I habitually asked the question why do I do this why do I do this and there's this idea that our questions direct our attention so you are alluding to this a minute ago so the question that I asked then becomes where I look so my attention because of this question um I would get sort of intensely focused on trying to figure out um what was wrong with me or what was you know what what led me to do certain things and that turns out to be helpful in some ways but often you know like most of us we hit a dead end with that question um and so even if I got to the Y I do this it didn't always result in me changing Behaviour”
Sense-making is fundamentally about how we construct meaning of what we perceive—how we determine what things mean. Early in life, we make sense of the world primarily through how it affects our own physical well-being, but this shifts over time to more complex, other-aware interpretations.
“so sense making is um is basically how how do I even know what what I'm seeing means right so earlier in our lives when young people look out at the world what they see makes sense to them in relationship to their own kind of physical well-being mostly”
Trying to be on top of everything is unconsciously driven by the belief that if you achieve it your life will feel calm and settled, or that being reliable and responsive equals being a good person; both are limiting identities that create suffering when pursued as absolutes.
“I'm gonna just start for a second with why it's hard um it's hard because sometimes very often the world as it is can feel overwhelming it can feel too messy to solve it can feel unpredictable and in many ways as human beings we don't like unpredictability um although interestingly we do like unpredictability when it comes to things like athletic events um but there's some element of if I'm on top of everything my life will feel calm and settled like there's some sort of a destination in mind it's like when you finish that last um when I was in university you know I'd finished my last exam of the semester there was this momentary feeling of ah I'm done so I think I was in search of that oh I'm done feeling um I think that but there are also a couple other things one is um the the it was sort of a I think I was conflating respect for other people with being on top of everything so particularly with regard to answering all my emails I thought if I don't attend to things I will be being disrespectful of other people I will not be I mean if you get down to the core of it I will not good people do not ignore things that need to be done especially when they affect other people”
The questions we habitually ask ourselves and others direct our attention and constrain what we can see; changing questions is a powerful way to access different information and perspectives, and the best new questions often come from other people rather than from our own habitual question set.
“there's a saying in Psychology that if you could see the world the way that I see it you'd understand why I behaved the way that I do so a large part of the way we see the world is through the information that we have a lot of times the information comes from the questions we ask how do we go about the process of asking different or better questions of ourselves and others in order to get better or different information the first thing is to notice the questions that you currently ask so each of us has habitual questions that we ask as well of ourselves of others of the world”
When overwhelmed or pressed, it becomes harder to step back and see life as a mosaic because the pressing demands keep one 'stuck in' the mosaic rather than able to view it; this requires deliberate perspective-taking practices like visualizing a future timeline to create distance.
“the the the the Mosaic um requires actually that we'd be able to like for the for the Mosaic to to for us to feel satisfied with the Mosaic on any given day in some ways we have to be able to step back and look at it and see how beautiful it is but when you're stuck in the Mosaic because things are so pressing um really can't see the beauty of it all you kind of can see is the mess”
'Listening to fix' (also 'listening to solve') is probably the most common listening pattern; it means immediately trying to solve the other person's problem rather than first understanding their experience.
“called we call it listening to fix um and this is probably the by far the most common one so listening to win is let me make the problem go away by telling you you don't have a problem listening to learn or listening to see is you know getting underneath really getting underneath the what's being said and reflecting back to the person um and listening to fix is let me take your problem and solve it for you”
The listener has realized that guilt about not responding to unsolicited emails is self-imposed; he never asked for the emails, so taking responsibility for responding is putting other people's expectations on himself without their consent.
“I feel guilty if I don't respond to people and I'm like but I never asked for this email I never wanted this email like why am I the one who's on the receiving end of this sort of like guilt and I'm putting it on myself obviously and not other people is that what happens with you too or um it never actually occurred to me Shane to wonder to think wow I didn't ask for this um why do I feel like I have to uh respond”
In remote/video meetings, it is harder to pick up on body language and micro-expressions than in person, which reduces (but does not eliminate) the data available for reading unspoken communication, though most people don't pay close attention to body language even in person.
“I mean the truth is we can't right you know you you can't see as much on video as you said um I would argue that most people don't pay that close attention to body language even when they're in person so that's that's a separate topic but learning to like making the helping inviting the body in to be part of the conversation for everybody is is a um a really I think a helpful move”
Identity (small 'i') is how I see myself and how I want others to see me in the world—something we develop throughout our lives by learning what works and amplifying successful patterns while (ideally) discontinuing unsuccessful ones.
“I sometimes call it identity with a with a small I rather than a capital I because it's I don't mean um like my social identity or my racial Identity or my gender identity or anything anything like that what I mean is how I see myself and I often talk about um that our identity how I see myself um and how I want to be in the world how I want you to see me in the world um is is um it's something we've been developing all of our Lives each of us right it's um we adapt as kids we learn what works we learn what doesn't work we amplify the things we keep doing the things that work and we can hopefully stop doing the things that don't work”
Connection between people—characterized by mutual awareness of impact, trust, and recognition of interdependence—is probably the most important element of leadership, though leaders often don't think of it as a core part of leadership.
“I am really one of the things that I care about a lot these days is connection and how important that is and leaders don't think of that necessarily as a core part of leadership or at least they haven't um you know and it is I think it's probably the most important thing”
Stopping a meeting to ask 'What's not being said here?' is uncommon in business meetings, though it could surface important unspoken concerns; this is often avoided because it threatens the efficiency-focused identity of meeting leaders who see it as a distraction from 'getting things done.'
“how often have you been in a meeting I'm curious for listeners too like how often have you been in a meeting especially a business meeting where um the facilitator or somebody stops to actually ask the question what's not being said here and then makes time for people to explore that just doesn't happen very often”
Environmental modifications are powerful condition-creating levers: removing tempting foods from the refrigerator to support weight loss, placing hand weights by your computer to encourage strength work, or joining communities of people already embodying desired behavior all create conditions where desired outcomes become more likely without requiring willpower.
“we always have the opportunity to change our environment right as a way to help us let's take the gym example go to the gym more or let's say we want to get fit or lose weight right but let's take losing weight one condition um that we could create is to take all the stuff out of our refrigerator that we're super tempted by that is not that doesn't contribute to our losing weight another way to create conditions if you want to get more if you want to get stronger because you could buy some like light hand weights and keep them next to your computer so that it's you don't have to do much in order to lift weights and get your muscles stronger”
We cannot guarantee that surrounding ourselves with people who embody desired traits will produce change, but it creates conditions where such change becomes more likely; the mindset should be intentional selection of communities aligned with desired development, not orchestration of perfect conditions.
“so I think the last lesson there is there are yes of course the people that we hang out with um I think can make a huge difference in shaping and creating the conditions for us to grow in particular grow and change in particular ways and as I you know found out with my children it's not a guarantee right so um trying to orchestrate things just right so that you know you're hanging out with exactly the right people who will get you the exact right result is probably the wrong mindset um the a more helpful mindset is that people communities do create the conditions for particular things and we can be intentional about which people and communities we spend time with in service of moving ourselves in a particular direction and it's no guarantee which is the way it is in complexity always there's no guarantees ever”
'Listening to win' is listening that aims to make the other person wrong or fix their problem for them without hearing them; it creates non-connection and fails to create conditions for the other person to feel seen or develop their own listening capacity.
“what we call I often call listening to win which is to just make them wrong or like when I say well that's not true you you look great or don't worry about that you you know you'll be fine”
Trying to be on top of everything (all emails answered, house clean, all knowledge current) is ultimately impossible and counterproductive because it directs attention away from the present moment and prevents full presence; letting go of this pursuit frees attention for what matters.
“the first thing that comes to mind is trying to be on top of everything so I used to spend an inordinate amount of time trying to attend to everything from answering every email you know within a certain amount of time to having um so having a clean inbox you know where I could actually see the bottom of the inbox on the first page um uh attending to making sure my house was clean this is one that I I just had to give up when I had three young kids um and so just you know knowing the latest um like research on everything you know and making sure that I knew every last um possible question that someone could ask me before I walk into a situation so that I have an answer for everything um these just don't seem they first became impossible so it was through realizing that I was in too much pain trying to get it trying to get these things be on top of everything um and now I see that trying to be on top of everything actually takes away my attention from the present moment from being fully present um so I I see the temptation of it and um I just I'm really really grateful to be in this place in my life where I don't feel I need to do that anymore”
Different leadership books create paradigm shifts: 'Leadership Without Easy Answers' (Heifetz & Linsky) disrupted the assumption that things are clear/knowable; Laloux's work showed how organizations themselves have stages of development; 'Changing on the Job' (Garvey Berger) made adult development theory accessible and practical.
“the first book that ever really that I can remember ever really shifted my perspective um uh was um I I think it's hot it's Heifetz and Linsky I think um leadership without easy answers um I'm sorry if I've got that co-author wrong because they're he's a co-author of one of heifetz's book um and it just it really sh was the first time I I got the sense of complexity actually it really disrupted my sense that um that things are clear and um so that was a that was it that's an old one that's probably 28 years old at this point um another one that really um impacted I would say the the way we the way I've put um complexity into practice into leadership practice of our firm was um oh you're testing my memory here shoot it's um Lalu um yeah I can't remember the name of it I'm sorry it's so popular and it's the idea that organizations also have um like operating in complexity organizations like show up differently and so it had a lot of lessons in it for us as an organization about how we wanted to be um and how we wanted to create the conditions for ourselves to be um to be embracing the complexity of the world embracing in the way we run ourselves um so that was another one and uh if you want to know more about adult development um Jennifer my colleague and friend Jennifer Garvey Berger's Book Changing on the job was Far and Away in my opinion the best book that's been written about about adult development not so much the theoretical part although she it's really good on that but essentially like what does it mean what does it mean in terms of creating conditions for humans to be fully human um so that was and it's super accessible I would highly recommend it”
Developmental coaching is about taking everyday experiences and using them to intentionally develop one's sense-making when facing situations where current sense-making is not well-suited ('in over one's head') to the demands of the context.
“what Bob Keegan called it in over our heads how can we what moves can we make to try to develop our meaning making to be more fit for the context it happens better with company it's a kind of a hard thing to do alone”
Language tends to be habitual and often invisible to us, so we don't recognize the power it has to shape meaning and identity until someone else reflects it back to us.
“our language tends to be habitual and so we often don't like I said earlier we often don't even notice the phrases we use right”
People are the raw material from which all work gets done in organizations, so the quality of the human system (attention to what people are bringing, their patterns, absences) matters more than rushing to task completion.
“when you bring a group of people together to do something it's the people themselves that matter the most right that's the raw material from which the work is getting done”
Shane's listening involves seeing the world through another person's eyes, not necessarily agreeing with them, but genuinely wanting to understand what they see and understand.
“I like the word curiosity because it sort of when I think of listening I think of seeing the world through the other person's eyes I don't have to agree with it I want to see what they see and I want to understand what they understand”
Children naturally ask great questions ('Why is the sky blue?') without the filters that adults develop (social comparison, looking smart, relevance gatekeeping), and re-cultivating this unfiltered curiosity is valuable for adult development.
“who in your life asks the the questions that are either most different from yours or the best questions and do you know what most people say why children ask great questions because they're not they don't have the overlay of what should I be asking they don't have the overlay of I need to look smart they don't have any filter they're just asking the question that come that occurs to them”
Metaphors are powerful tools in coaching because they capture and communicate meaning more effectively than abstract language; listening to the metaphors people naturally use and offering alternative metaphors can shift how they see a situation.
“I also have to find metaphors to be really helpful here with these sorts of things because often I will listen to the the metaphors that a client uses and try to tap into those um so um so for example um when somebody is talking about balance I will present to them like a scale a an old-fashioned balancing scale and I'll just ask them like how does that feel to you is that actually what you're going for here um and often they will come up with a new metaphor”
We often cannot see our own blind spots without external help; trustworthy company who can reflect back what we cannot see is a core condition for change and growth.
“we often cannot see what we're doing and this is why we need company and we need company with whom we have trust who will tell us things that we can't see in ourselves um this is this is one of the core conditions for being able to shift and change”
An intrapersonal polarity is focusing on one's own needs vs. focusing on others' needs; if you focus only on your needs, you become isolated and disconnected; if you focus only on others' needs, you lose your voice and burn out—requiring dynamic balance.
“in a very personal sense what I would call an intrapersonal polarity is um like is a question of do I focus on my needs or do I focus on others needs right well both because if I focus on only my needs um pretty soon I'm going to be able to get a lot of the negative aspects of that I'm going to be isolated I'm going to feel disconnected and I'm not going to be able to get my work done if I focus only on other people's needs I'm going to get the negative aspects of that because I will lose myself I won't have a voice um I'll probably get burnt out”
The world as it is can feel overwhelming and unpredictable, so humans prefer trying to control it to being open to uncertainty; however, seeing the world as it is requires accepting that we cannot control everything and will be okay anyway.
“it's hard because sometimes very often the world as it is can feel overwhelming it can feel too messy to solve it can feel unpredictable and in many ways as human beings we don't like unpredictability um although interestingly we do like unpredictability when it comes to things like athletic events you know like who would watch a a soccer match if you knew who was going to win and exactly what plays were going to happen first second third and fourth right we wouldn't do that that's what makes it fun who would go to a movie if you knew exactly how it was going to turn out but somehow in our own lives we don't like unpredictability because it leaves us feeling sort of out of control”
A parent can make a 'listening to learn' move by reflecting back what they hear a child saying with genuine understanding (e.g., 'It sounds like you're upset because you feel responsible for everything and don't think he should rely on you'), and this teaches better listening through modeling.
“what I would do is I would come in and make what I would call a listening to learn or a listening to see move where I would say to her it looks like you're really upset because um because he is relying on you for everything and you don't think he should have to be doing that and it's not your responsibility is that right and they could just literally see her whole body like breathe out”
The structured check-in process—where all participants answer a posed question and the group then observes patterns and outliers—functions as a systems-scanning exercise that reveals what is present and what is absent in a group's consciousness.
“the check-in um someone poses a question and every person in the room responds to the question and then we step back and get on the balcony and look at the patterns the question being what's in the room today what are the patterns we're seeing and particularly when you do a check-in um it's important not only to see the commonalities the themes but also pay attention to the outliers and also what wasn't said”
Using a mountain climbing metaphor: you can borrow from others' experience and start at a higher base camp rather than at the base of the mountain; this is not cheating but intelligent strategy, and once you reach a height, you can iterate and make the borrowed knowledge your own.
“I mean if you think of it sort of as climbing a mountain uh you can start at the bottom of the mountain where I can borrow from somebody else and start a base camp or I can borrow from somebody else and start out like camp three and if you get to the top of the mountain and I'm just using the the metaphor here it doesn't nobody really asks uh did you did you start a base camp right uh and so if you can imitate other people uh to the point where you can start at a higher level a higher position then that's awesome and then you can iterate after you imitate so it you can take something and I think it was montang who said you know I have to digest it and I have to make it my own so you can take something from somebody else and then you can reflect on it and digest it and put a little twist on it that is maybe more personal to you but I love the idea of uh mastering the best of what other people have figured out already”
Asking a child 'Did doing this help you get what you wanted in that moment?' after they've done something problematic is a coaching intervention that promotes reflection and self-correction, more effective than direct correction.
“when you did this did it help you get what you wanted in that moment right or is doing this going to get you what you want and that coaching after the fact is usually very helpful for him because he's like oh I didn't mean it that way or I shouldn't have done that or I wasn't thinking when I said something and so it prompts at least a little bit of reflection around it”
Lisa Feldman Barrett's 'How Emotions Are Made' provides deep understanding of the physiological bases of emotions and their relationship to bodily systems; understanding this connection is valuable for developing body awareness and emotional literacy.
“there's a I don't know why the names of the books are escaping me today Shane I'm sorry I've got the authors um there's a book by a guy named guy Claxton about about emotions it's not um uh Lisa Feldman Barrett wrote how emotions are made and that's really good too this one goes more deeply into um like the physiological components of um of not only our emotions but the relationship between our bodies and everything else um and it's really I would highly recommend it it's it it takes some getting through but it's it's quite good if you're curious about the relationship between um our bodies and um and everything else”
Giving language to a blind spot (e.g., 'you're listening to win') can function as an instant prompt that helps someone notice and correct their pattern, because the language creates a light that flashes each time the pattern occurs.
“it sounds like that's what you were doing so this is where the question I didn't I didn't intend for this to be like a longer question but yeah yeah um so your question is is language um giving language to something can that be a help um well it's sort of a broader question if we take an OTA of the context of me and my son it it's sort of can we learn to listen to ourselves better or does it take an outside person to sort of intervene and point out our blind spots”
Buying a gym membership is often ineffective at creating conditions for gym attendance because it is a direct intervention (you pay money expecting behavior change) rather than a genuine condition-creator; it works only if coupled with changes to patterns, environment, or identity—which is why gyms are profitable in January/February (memberships purchased, not used).
“buying a gym membership is an example of a kind of a direct intervention that often fails I mean it could be a condition creating thing but but if we think that buying a gym member is going to make us go to the gym anyone who's ever bought a gym membership or most people will at least have had one experience of doing that and finding that they just wasted their money that's why they sell 12-month memberships in November and December right exactly yeah they're creating their own conditions for profitability because they know the patterns of human beings”
Adults often believe they must figure everything out themselves, but the world is too complex for this and other people are often our greatest resource; borrowing ideas and frameworks from others and building on them is not failure but wisdom.
“I just want to say Shane that there's something that happens to us as adults um that we think we have to have it all figured out ourselves right I don't if if you don't have this idea this is great for those of you out there who don't who have never had that idea um you're way ahead of the game in my book um but we don't like the world is way too complex for that that sometimes our greatest resource is right there in front of us in the form of another person or someone else's idea”
The environment we create in our heads—our identity, the narratives we tell ourselves, and the people we choose to spend time with—is as important as physical environment in shaping our behavior and development over time.
“I often think about how environment we think of our environment most of the time when it comes to mind is physical but our environment is also our identity right we're creating an environment in our head an artificial environment if you will our environment is also who we hang around and there's their sort of habits and if we hang around people who are are sort of politically extreme we will eventually become politically extreme or we hang around people who are lazy we become lazy”