
A History of Philosophy | 18 Middle and Neo-Platonism
What this covers
This lecture from a college history-of-philosophy course follows Middle Platonism in the first two centuries AD and then Neoplatonism. The instructor treats Middle Platonism as an amalgam of Plato with Stoic logos and the Neo-Pythagorean idea of emanation. The Stoic logos is a divine reason that permeates the world through "seeds" in each thing, and emanation supplies the outflowing of being. The lecture then moves to the three principles of Plotinus: the One, the Nous, and the World Soul. It reads them through Plato's Divided Line and assigns them roles as final and material cause, formal cause, and efficient cause.
The range is wide. On the One, the lecture argues that it cannot be defined, since definition marks something off from something else and the all-inclusive One has no "something else." That leads to Negative Theology (Via Negativa)), which the lecture ties back to Anaximander's apeiron and forward to Christian words like "immortal" and "invisible." Other threads include the Hierarchy of Being and the Principle of Plenitude, which the instructor says shaped medieval church, society, and literature. Evil as Privation is presented as a shortfall relative to one's place in that hierarchy. Philo of Alexandria appears as a Jewish Middle Platonist, and Justinian is credited with using the system to save pagan religion by recasting the gods as intermediary beings.
The most contentious and consequential turn is theological. The lecture separates three accounts of creation: dualism (out of eternal matter), pantheism (out of God), and theism (out of nothing). It says the first centuries of Christian thought were largely spent sorting these out. It then argues that Middle Platonist solutions to the one and the many prepared the ground for trinitarian doctrine, and that Plotinus's term hypostasis passed into the Chalcedonian formula, later becoming "person." The lecture closes on Neoplatonism's long afterlife, from medieval thought through the Renaissance and nineteenth-century revival, with John Milton as one example.
Middle Platonism and Neoplatonism represent a crucial philosophical development from dualism toward monism through the concept of emanation, creating a hierarchical cosmos that profoundly shaped Christian theology, particularly the formulation of the Trinity and the relationship between God's transcendence and immanence.
- Middle Platonism synthesized Platonic, Stoic, and Neo-Pythagorean thought to move away from dualism toward monism through hierarchical emanation
- The doctrine of the logos and the hierarchy of being (God, Logos/Divine Intellect, World Soul) provided conceptual tools for Christian trinitarian formulation
- Neoplatonism's three hypostases (one, nous, world soul) directly influenced the Calcedonian formulation of the Christian Trinity and concepts of divine transcendence balanced with immanence
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Questions about the One are problematic but necessarily asked; the One is known immediately (in the sense of direct apprehension) rather than through discursive reasoning or description, even though one cannot describe what is known.
“now how then can you ask questions about the one I'm not putting you down for asking questions”
Emanation means an outflowing of being; natural analogies are water streaming from a fountain or light streaming from the sun—if the natural world is an emanation of the Divine being, it is of the very stuff of which the Divine being is made, so nature comes out of God (ex Deo) rather than out of nothing (ex nihilo).
“what is emanation well the word itself means an outflowing an outflowing of being anal IES used are of water streaming from a fountain light streaming from the Sun you see so if the natural world is an imination of the Divine being it's of the very stuff of which the Divine being is nature comes X Deo out of the Divine being rather than x NE so”
Middle Platonism decisively moved philosophy from dualism to monism—not two ultimate realities or two irreconcilable aspects but one inclusive reality from which variety is derived and to which it returns—by means of the Neo-Pythagorean emphasis on emanations.
“what middle platonism does decisively for the future of Plato ISM decisively is to push from dualism in a monistic direction not two ultimate realities or two irreconcilable aspects to reality but one inclusive reality from which variety is derived and to which it returns moving from dualism then to monism how did they do it they did it by means of the neop Pythagorean emphasis on emanations”
The One is beyond definition because to define something is to mark it off from something else, but if the One is the all-inclusive one, there is no 'something else' to define it against; therefore, one cannot define the One by distinguishing it from other things, and all predicates applied to God are drawn from knowledge of finite things and cannot apply to the all-inclusive One.
“beyond anything in particular that we can say about it Beyond definition now why Beyond definition because to define something is to mark it off from something else but if the one is the allinclusive one there isn't a something else to Define It Off from do you get it and so you have to think of the one is beyond anything we can predicate of God in addition all of the predicates we might come up with all of the attributes are attributes we draw from our knowledge of finite things and apply them to God they are distinguishing marks of things applied to God but God isn't distinguished from anything else God is the all-inclusive one so in that sense God is beyond all predication”
Evil can be understood as dependent on one stage in the hierarchy of being—a dog lacks the degree of perfection appropriate to a human, and a human lacks the degree of perfection appropriate to higher beings, but among humans those who do not live according to the logos and do not conform to the form of their human existence fail to achieve the actuality of that inherent capacity, so evil is a privation of good, a privation of the intended good of the form in actualization.
“and consequently evil can now be seen as dependent on one stage in the whole hierarchy of being that is to say down here a dog simply doesn't have the degree of perfection which is appropriate to the human being nor does the human being have the degree of perfection appropriate to higher beings but by the same token among human beings there are some who who do not um live in accordance with that logos as according to the stoic ethic we are to live human beings who do not putting it in platonic language conform to the form of their human existence they don't achieve the actuality of that inherent capacity and evil then is a privation a privation of good it's a privation of the intended good of the form in actualization”
Neoplatonism provided the philosophical framework that dominated medieval thought until the eleventh to twelfth century, continued to be powerful influence after the Reformation in Renaissance and Enlightenment, underwent resurgence in nineteenth-century Europe, and has proven tremendously influential through the twentieth century.
“the importance of neoplatonism is that it provided the philosophical framework that dominated medieval thought until the 11th 12th century continue to be a powerful influence after the Reformation both in the Renaissance and during the Enlightenment went through another Resurgence in 19th century Europe okay so the history of platonism and history continuing really into the 20th century trend tremendously influential”
Neo-Pythagoreans conceived of a hierarchy of beings with varying degrees of being and perfection from God down to non-being, with all sorts of intermediary beings between the human realm and the Divine realm, including various kinds of powers with varying degrees of perfection and imperfection, with no gaps in the hierarchy.
“what the pythagoreans did was to conceive of a um hierarchy of beings with varying degrees of being and Perfection from God all the way down to the Other Extreme non-being a hierarchy with all sorts of intermediary beings in fact even between shall we say the human realm and the Divine realm intermediary beings various kinds of powers with various degrees of perfection and imperfection”
The Neoplatonic system can be understood through the overlay of Plato's Divided Line: the upper half represents what is eternal and universal (the intelligible realm of forms and Nous), while the lower half represents what is temporal, particular, and changing (the sensible realm), with epistemological questions arising about how we can have knowledge across this divided ontological structure.
“you can anticipate what that is going to be like by recognizing here the divided line Plato's divided line you see superimpose it because here in the upper half you have what is um what is eternal Universal here you have what is temporal particular changing okay and if you want to raise the epistemological questions then you have to range um raise them in terms of a platonic kind of epistemology”
The Nous (Divine Intellect/Intelligence) is the highest definable emanation from the One, flowing out from God as the Mind; in this realm, the Divine being can be spoken of as wise, good, and beautiful because it is the realm of ideals and forms differentiated in the mind of God.
“what about the Noose uh reason intelligence the intelligible principle well you see this is as it were the Mind flowing out from God from the one no in in this this emanation reason thought you can speak as if the Divine being is thinking thinking its own thoughts like Aristotle's unmoved mover thinking on its own thoughts because the forms are in the mind of the lers in the mind of the Noose Divine intelligence this is the uh this is the highest definable emanation of the Divine being it's here that we are able to speak of the Divine being as all together wise allog together good allog together beautiful because it's the realm of ideals the forms differentiated in the mind of God”
Middle Platonism represents the first two centuries AD and is an amalgam of Platonism with Stoicism (particularly its emphasis on logos as Divine Law ordering the natural world) and Neo-Pythagoreanism (particularly its concept of emanation).
“you can think of middle platonism as um representing the first two centuries ad the first two centuries and think of it as an amalgam of platonism with two other strains of thought that time stoicism particularly with its emphasis on the logos logos in the sense of the Divine Law that orders the natural world um also neop pythagoreanism”
For the Stoics, the logos was divine reason—probably impersonal but an unchanging rational principle that embraces and permeates everything in existence, with seeds of the logos (logoi spermatikoi) distributed in every particular thing, making the Divine being immanent in every natural thing and Earthly process by virtue of these seeds of the logos being equated with the immanent forms.
“for the stoics the logos was divine reason probably impersonal but some rational unchanging rational principle that Embraces and permeates everything in existence so that there are seeds of the logos log o spao seeds of the logos in every particular thing now if that's the case then you see there are these seeds of the logos running all the way down everywhere It Is by virtue of the logos that the Divine being is imminent in in every natural thing and every Earthly process imminent in so far as these logo spao logos spoy are equated with the imminent forms”
The finite soul is a seed (emanation) of the World Soul itself, and thus possesses the possibility of innate knowledge by virtue of this emanative relationship; the importance of dialectic lies in bringing this innate knowledge out into the open through philosophical inquiry and discussion.
“How can there be innate knowledge well by virtue of the fact that the finite soul is a seed of the world Soul itself an emanation from the uh all intelligent news see hence the possibility of innate knowledge hence the importance of dialectic to getting it out in the open”
When reading about platonism in later history, sometimes 'platonism' refers to Plato and sometimes to Neoplatonism, and the reader must examine context to determine which is meant; figures influenced by Neoplatonism are innumerable, including John Milton, whose theology displays neoplatonist language and appears to be neoplatonic in his kind of Christianity.
“when you read of platonism in later history sometimes it's Plato sometimes it's neoplatonism okay and you always have to read the context to see which it is sometimes it's Plato sometimes it's neoplatonism and um the figures influenced by it are innumerable if you read John Milton you don't read long in his theology before you discover that he's talking neoplatonist language it seems to be neoplatonic in his kind of Christianity”
The World Soul is the dynamic, life-giving, energizing force that permeates finite things, orders them, conserves them, and guides them; it functions as the efficient cause in the Divine being (the cause that brings about change), while the Nous functions as the formal cause (the principle of form and essence) and the One functions as both the final cause (the end toward which all things move) and the material cause (the stuff of which all things are made).
“the world Soul this is the dynamic lifegiving energizing force that permeates finite things orders them conserves them guides them if you like to speak more precisely the uh the efficient cause in the Divine being the efficient cause of nature is the world Soul the formal cause is the Noose the final cause and the material cause but both the one but because World soul is the dynamic agent in the process this comes closest to efficient C”
The philosophical basis for some sort of trinitarian view emerged before Christian debate on the Trinity because Middle Platonists solved the problem of the one and the many in the Godhead through the doctrine of Deuteros Theos (the logos) that immediatizes the good within nature, a solution adopted by the early Church in formulating trinitarian doctrine.
“if you want to overcome the gap between Plato's good objective value personified as God you see and this world of time space how you going to do it and the middle platonist saw that this could be done most effectively in um having yeah dudos Theos that um imminent tizes the good within nature and this was picked up by the early Church in the debate on the Trinity as we'll see and so the the philosophical basis for some sort of trinitarian view emerged before the Christian debate on the Trinity which is very interesting”
Three metaphysically distinct worldviews emerge from different creation theories: dualism (things formed out of eternal matter, ex materia), pantheism (things formed out of the very substance of God, ex Deo), and theism (creation ex nihilo—out of nothing), with the history of the first five to six centuries of Christian thought being the history of making these distinctions clearly.
“what begins to take shape on the horizon now and it's on the horizon still is a distinction between dualism okay dualism as in the gnostics pantheism as in the neoplatonists and theism as in Christian thought dualism where things are formed out of Eternal matter ex Materia pantheism with things formed X Deo out of the very substance of God and theism with creation ex neolo out of nothing at all giving rise to three very different World Views and in a real way the history of the first five six centuries of Christian thought is the history of trying to make those distinctions clearly”
Roman Emperor Justinian in the third century attempted to popularize Middle Platonism in order to save pagan religion by making room for the pagan gods as intermediary beings—beyond Proto Theos and logos, all sorts of other intermediary beings superior to humans could be identified as the pagan deities, allowing pagan religion to be articulated as an allegorical way of talking about these intermediary beings.
“it um should be be said that the motivation behind the spread of middle platonism was thoroughly Pagan in fact the Roman Emperor Justinian in the 3 Century attempted to popularize middle platonism in order to save Pagan religion because it made room for the pagan gods as other intermediary beings you see in addition to God Proto Theos logos you have all sorts of other intermediary being Superior to human beings these are the Pagan deities so you've got all the room for Pagan religion to be a popularized allegorical way of talking about these intermediary beings”
The three principles of Neoplatonism are called hypostases by Plotinus, a term later adopted in the Calcedonian formulation of the Christian Trinity (fifth century) where there are three hypostases (Father, Son, Holy Spirit) in one ousia (being/essence), with the term hypostasis later translated into Latin as persona (mask/role worn by an actor), and then into English as 'person,' creating the formula of three persons in one being.
“these three um three hypostases is what plonus calls them who posesses any of you familiar enough with the theological formulation of the doctrine of the Trinity to recognize the word hupostasis you see because in the calcedonian formulation of the Trinity later on in the fifth century we're told there three hypostases singular hypostasis Father Son and Holy Spirit to call them three hypostases is the language of neoplatonism three hypostases in one um usia what's usia being Essence three hypostasis with one Essence it's the language of neoplatonism hupostasis gets translated in uh process of translation in the Latin versions Persona hence the English person but the Latin Persona was more of a a role a mask that the actor wore to identify his role who he was you'll see but in Translation it's become three persons in one being”
Neoplatonic language of emanation and return is evident in mysticism and in phrases like 'the myth of the eternal return,' showing how Neoplatonism shaped mystical and spiritual language.
“that neoplatonic language is very evident in the language of certain kinds of mysticism to this day the myth of the eternal return phrases of that sort you'll see neoplatonic”
The notion of a hierarchy of being with no gaps—governed by the principle of plenitude where every possible degree of being is occupied by something that exists—became the conceptual model that governed the Middle Ages, finding expression in the structure of the church, society, literature, and philosophy, and has carried over into some Christian thinking to the present day.
“this notion of a hierarchy of being becomes in fact the conceptual model that governs the Middle Ages this is where it comes from that hierarchical notion which uh found expression in the structure of the church and of society as well as in philosophy and literature and so on and so forth and has carried over into some Christian thinking to this day um it's a hierarchy of being in which there are no gaps and so um we talk of the principle of plenitude the hierarchy is filled up there are no places to let there are no vacancies every possible degree of being is taken by something that exists”
The Neoplatonic One is characterized by perfect unity and absolute simplicity, and in stressing the One's unity, Plotinus emphasizes that unity and identity are identical—to have identity one must have absolute unity without internal distinction or multiplicity.
“yes um in uh in in a certain sense um the one uh is perfect Unity now Aristotle stressed perfect actuality plotinus stresses perfect Unity influence of Parmenides why Unity because unity and identity are one and the same thing you only have identity if you have Unity you see if you are multiple schizophrenic with six different personalities you see if there is an i and a thou within you in some sense then you don't have Unity absolute Unity”
Philo of Alexandria, a Jewish philosopher, is often said to be a Platonist and was specifically a Middle Platonist who conceived of logos and World Soul in precisely Middle Platonist terms, showing the influence of Middle Platonism extended beyond pagan and Christian communities to Jewish philosophical circles.
“the pagans weren't the only ones uh we'll be reading next week about Philo of Alexandria the Jewish philosopher who it often said was a platonist yes he was a middle platonist and he too conceived of logos World soul in precisely these middle platonist terms okay so the influence of it is significant”
Traditional Christian vocabulary about God includes the via negativa, including terms like 'Immortal,' 'Invisible,' and 'Immaterial,' which reflect the negative theological tradition and show Christian influence from Neoplatonic apophaticism.
“and of course you can't help but notice how traditional Christian vocabulary about God includes a lot of via negativa Immortal invisible Immortal invisible”
Anaximander called the basic nature of being the apeiron (the unlimited, the indefinable), an ancient pre-Socratic concept that anticipates the Neoplatonic notion of the One as indefinable and known only through the via negativa (the negative way), using negative terms like 'not finite,' 'not multiple,' 'not this, not that,' to gesture toward what is beyond all positive predication.
“remember back in anex amander um the basic nature of being was labeled as a Pyon what does a Pyon mean the unlimited the indefinable you see it sounds like that's feeding into the notion of the one the ayon the undefined um known only therefore by the Via negativa what's the V negativa the negative way yeah the negative way you use negative terms in speaking God is Not finite the one is not multiple it's not this it's not that it's not the other it's beyond anything we can say”
In the second and third centuries, Alexandria housed a Christian Academy devoted to educating both church people and pagans in theology, philosophy, and other subjects, representing one of the seats of learning in antiquity, where figures like Clement of Alexandria advocated for the liberal arts in the classical tradition.
“in second third Century Alexandria there was a um Christian Academy of sorts uh devoted to educating not only church people but others as well pagans who came for instruction instruction in theology instruction in philosophy instruction in other things uh Alexandria was one of the seats of learning in Antiquity Clement of Alexandria was early Church Father Was An Earnest advocate of what then they thought of as the liberal arts in that classic tradition”
Emanation represents an outflowing (downward movement) from the divine, while epistrophe (Greek term translated as 'conversion' or 'turning back') represents the return movement, so that everything flows out from and returns to the One in a parallel movement.
“the downward movement is emanation but we must mustn't let that give us the impression that the downward movement means that there is a gradually emptying out of the Divine being far from it what you have is a uh parallel movement um known as epistrophe return AO Greek term translated conversion turning back so emanation is an outflowing epistrophy is a turning back and that neoplatonic language is very evident in the language of certain kinds of mysticism to this day the myth of the eternal return phrases of that sort you'll see neoplatonic and in as much as everything flows out from and returns to the one”
Ammonius Saccas appears to have been at one time a student, perhaps a student at the same time as Origen, perhaps also a teacher in the Christian catechetical school in Alexandria; later he departed from both Alexandria and the Christian faith and continued his teaching which became the Neoplatonism of Porphyry and Plotinus, suggesting that Neoplatonism was in some ways a reversion to pre-Christian Middle Platonism.
“it seems that ammonia saus was at one time a student uh perhaps a student at the same time as Oren perhaps also a teacher in that school in any case at one time a Christian and that ammonia sacus later um departed from Alexandria and from the Christian face and continued his teaching which became the neoplatonism of poery and plotinus so in that sense neoplatonism uh was um a continuation of middle platonism as it had been filtered through the alexandrian school and been christianized in the process okay uh if you like neoplatonism was a Christian heresy it was a departure from Christianity but in some ways it was a reversion to pre-christian Middle platonism”
Arthur O. Lovejoy's book 'The Great Chain of Being' provides historical and intellectual context for understanding how the notion of a hierarchical universe played a significant role in Western thought, particularly relevant for those in history and literature.
“you may be interested sometime in looking up a book by AO love joy it's an older book about um oh 60 years 70 years old now uh AOL love joy a book called The Great chain of being the great chain of being and particularly those of you in um history and literature uh who want to have some sense of where this notion comes from that plays such a role in um in Western thought um may want to take note of that book for um sometime to read AOL Love Joy's great chain of being”
Plotinus wrote a series of treatises known as the Enneads (literally six sets of nine essays called 'the Nines'), which purport to report on Porphyry's teaching but are usually taken to be largely Plotinus's own, originating from Porphyry's teaching of Ammonius Saccas.
“he wrote um a series of treaties known as theads literally six sets of nine essays called The Nines in the way that they've been preserved the nads the nines sixads um purporting to report on poer his teaching though usually taken to be largely his own but Po's teaching which originated in amonia seus”
The roles of Nous and World Soul are easier to understand than the nature of the One because they have precedents in Platonic and Aristotelian philosophy; the nature of the One is the central problem that requires prolonged philosophical pondering.
“I I take it that the uh the role of newent world Soul are much easier to get a handle on we've met those in Plato and others it's the um nature of the one that's the teaser that you have to uh Ponder a while”