
Chairman of the Council of Economic Advisers Stephen Miran on the Trump Admin’s Economic Agenda
What this covers
This is a Hudson Institute event in which Stephen Myron, chairman of the Council of Economic Advisers (the speaker's name appears as "Myron" in the transcript), gives remarks and then talks with senior fellow Tom Duesterberg, followed by questions from the audience and the press. The argument starts from the Global Public Goods Framework: the US supplies a security umbrella and the dollar and Treasuries as reserve currency assets. Myron says these underpin an unprecedented era of peace and prosperity. He also says they produce persistent trade deficits, because foreign trade between third countries is denominated in dollars and foreign savings are held in Treasuries.
The middle of the conversation turns to economics. Myron says most economists dismiss tariffs because their models assume deficits are absent or quickly self-correct through currency moves. He rests his case on incidence analysis. He uses a property-tax analogy: the inflexible party, whose houses cannot move, absorbs the burden. By this logic, China bears the cost of tariffs and the revenue accrues to the US Treasury. That claim is flagged as contested. He also cites the loss of more than a third of US manufacturing employment from its peak, and COVID-era supply chain exposure.
The conversation then widens. Duesterberg describes China as a mercantilist state that subsidizes, steals intellectual property, overproduces, and shuts its own market. He says China may use rare earths to drive out competitors and extract monopoly rents, and he calls the WTO effectively dead. Myron describes China's growth engine as rotating among exports to America, housing bubbles, and exports elsewhere. Other topics include the Biden administration's tilt of Treasury issuance toward bills, which Myron and Nouriel Roubini criticized in a paper and which Duesterberg calls stealth quantitative easing. They also take up the underappreciated role of regulation in supply-side growth, private-sector worker training, and deficit reduction as a route to lower mortgage and credit card rates.
The United States should restructure global trade and financial relationships to achieve fairer burden-sharing, where other nations pay for the security and financial stability the US provides rather than free-riding on American military and reserve currency dominance, using tariffs as a primary mechanism to rebalance trade deficits and reinvigorate US manufacturing.
- US provision of security umbrella and reserve currency function creates persistent trade deficits that hollowed out American manufacturing, with costs borne entirely by American workers and taxpayers
- Persistent trade deficits do not self-correct through currency adjustment as standard economic models assume, because demand for dollar reserves is insatiable, requiring tariff intervention
- Tariff incidence falls on exporting countries with inflexible supply (factories cannot move), not on US consumers, allowing tariffs to fund US public goods provision while improving trade balance
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
When private agents in two separate foreign countries trade with each other, the transaction is typically denominated in dollars because of American status as reserve currency provider, and the trade entails savings housed in dollar securities, often Treasuries.
“I've often used the example that when private agents in two separate foreign countries trade with each other, it's typically denominated in dollars because of American status as the reserve provider. That trade entails savings housed in dollar securities, often Treasuries.”
When private agents in two separate foreign countries trade with each other, it is typically denominated in dollars because of American status as the reserve provider, and that trade entails savings housed in dollar securities, often Treasuries
“I've often used the example that when private agents in two separate foreign countries trade with each other, it's typically denominated in dollars because of American status as the reserve provider. That trade entails savings housed in dollar securities, often Treasuries.”
The United States provides two critical global public goods: a security umbrella that has created the greatest era of peace in mankind's history, and the dollar and Treasury securities as reserve assets that enable the global trading and financial system responsible for the greatest era of prosperity mankind has ever known.
“First, the United States provides a security umbrella, which has created the greatest era of mankind's the greatest era of peace mankind has ever known. Second, the US provides the dollar and Treasury securities, reserve assets which make possible the global trading and financial system, which has supported the greater era of prosperity mankind has ever known.”
Treasury debt issuance policy in the Biden administration involved skewing Treasury debt toward bills instead of bonds and had the effect of lowering interest rates on huge US debt, which Myron and Nouriel Roubini argued in a paper was not healthy for the country's finances in the long term.
“the Biden administration had engaged in a form of stealth quantitative easing to partially offset the tightening of the Fed and contributing to the stubborn persistence of inflation. This tactic involves skewing Treasury debt issuance towards bills instead of bonds. Um it also had the effect of lowering interest rates on the huge US debt.”
Companies in the US spend nearly five times as many dollars on their own training programs as all state, local, and federal government combined, showing private sector commitment to worker training.
“companies in the US spend nearly five times as many dollars on their own training programs as all state and and local and federal government combined. It's a five to one ratio.”
China may still have leverage through rare earth production and can manipulate competitors to run them out of business, establishing itself as the sole producer and then extracting monopoly rents.
“And there has been some criticism of the across-the-board tariff approach that that actually uh moves us in the wrong direction because the negative reaction uh especially from uh from the Europeans from uh from others. Should we do take that into consideration more the need for having allies in pushing back against China as we calibrate these uh this bevy of tariffs that we put into place? ... And there's some areas um and I want to cite rare earths as one where the Chinese um uh strategy is not only to be a low-cost producer, but to run everybody else that might compete with them out of business. And they've done that effectively with rare earths.”
Most economists and some investors dismiss tariffs as counterproductive at best and devastatingly harmful at worst, but they are very wrong because their models assume either no trade deficits or assume they are short-lived and quickly self-correct through currency adjustments.
“Most economists and some investors dismiss tariffs as counterproductive at best and devastatingly harmful at worst. They're very wrong. One reason the economic consensus on tariffs is so wrong is because nearly all of the models that economists use to study international trade assume either no trade deficits at all or they assume that deficits are short-lived and quickly self-correct through currency adjustments.”
The reserve currency function of the dollar has caused persistent currency distortions and contributed, along with other countries' unfair barriers, to unsustainable trade deficits that have decimated American manufacturing and working-class families' communities by facilitating non-Americans trading with each other using dollars.
“On the financial side, the reserve function of the dollar has caused persistent currency distortions and contributed, along with other countries unfair barriers to trade, to unsustainable trade deficits. These trade deficits have decimated our manufacturing sector and many working-class families in their communities to facilitate non-Americans trading with each other.”
The WTO (World Trade Organization) is effectively dead due to the inflexibility of its rules in the face of mercantilist major trading countries, and a new rules-based trading system may need to be developed.
“the inflexibility of the World Trade Organization rules um system changing the rules of um that organization that the WTO is effectively uh almost dead.”
The regulation-side of the economy is one of the most important determinants of the supply side of the economy for both potential GDP growth and prices, but is severely underappreciated by economists because it is difficult to study.
“I mean, I do. I I think that the regulatory side of the economy is one of the most important determinants of the supply side of the economy in general um for both potential GDP growth, but also for prices. And economists, I think, under appreciated because it's difficult to study.”
The reserve currency function of the dollar has caused persistent currency distortions and contributed, along with other countries' unfair barriers to trade, to unsustainable trade deficits that have decimated the US manufacturing sector and working-class families.
“On the financial side, the reserve function of the dollar has caused persistent currency distortions and contributed, along with other countries unfair barriers to trade, to unsustainable trade deficits. These trade deficits have decimated our manufacturing sector and many working-class families in their communities”
Foreign central banks and financial institutions can buy US assets to manipulate their own currencies and keep their exports cheap, pumping money into the US economy and fueling economic vulnerabilities and crises.
“Others may buy our assets to manipulate their own currency to keep their exports cheap. In doing so, they end up pumping so much money into the US economy that it fuels economic vulnerabilities and crises.”
Taxes are straightforward for economists to study (one marginal rate vs another), but regulatory environment is complex, multi-dimensional, incredibly detailed, and non-numerical, varying by firm type, age, size, employee count, jurisdiction, and quality of regulatory relationships.
“Taxes are pretty straightforward to study. You know, someone has a 28% marginal tax rate or a 34% marginal tax rate and it's pretty you know, it's pretty straightforward like how to think about that. But you face a different regulatory environment based on what type of firm you have, how old your firm is, how big your firm is, how many employees you have, uh what jurisdiction you operate in, um how you know, how friendly are you with your local regulators, um your national regulators. The the regulatory environment uh firms face is complex, multi-dimensional, and uh incredibly detail-oriented and incredibly non-numerical.”
Companies should invest in training workers because human capital matters and American people are the future and should be invested in.
“investing in Americans is one of the most beneficial investments you could make. Human capital matters. Our people are our future and we need to invest in them and I agree I agree with that entirely.”
When property taxes increase significantly, buyers (who are flexible and can move to neighboring towns) avoid the burden by relocating their demand, while sellers (who are inflexible because houses cannot move) must absorb the burden through lower prices, demonstrating how incidence falls on the inflexible party.
“And just imagine that you're buying a house and suddenly the town that you're looking to buy a house in says, "Okay, we're raising property taxes uh by 300% and your property tax bill isn't going to be $10,000 a year, it's going to be $30,000 a year." That's a big jump, right? And so if you're very flexible, an economist would say elastic, uh if you're very flexible, you might decide, "Hey, I'm going to look at the next town over instead." because, you know, like I could just live, you know, 3 miles down the road... Um you can move your demand across a border. The person who's selling the house can't move his house across the border. The house is stuck in that town, right? So, because you were flexible, you can adjust your behavior to avoid the burden of the tax, the person selling the house can't adjust his behavior. He's stuck The house is stuck where the house is stuck. So, he has to drop his selling price because demand for that house disappeared, right? And so that lower selling price is now cleared the market. Economists would say the incidence of the property tax fell on the owner of the home, not the buyer of the home.”
China has run a strategy not only to be a low-cost producer in rare earths but to run everybody else that might compete with them out of business, and they've done that effectively with rare earths
“And there's some areas um and and I want to cite rare earths as one where the Chinese um uh strategy is not only to be a low-cost producer, but to run everybody else that might compete with them out of business. And they've done that effectively with rare earths.”
Deficit reduction will help lower Treasury rates, and with them mortgage rates and consumer credit card rates, stimulating an economic boom
“Deficit reduction will help lower Treasury rates, and with them mortgage rates and consumer credit card rates, stimulating an economic boom.”
By imposing tariffs against exporting countries, the US can improve economic outcomes, raise revenues, and impose huge losses for tariffed nations even with full retaliation, as shown by economic analyses of tariff incidence.
“They show that by imposing tariffs against exporting countries, the US can improve economic outcomes, raise revenues, and impose huge losses for the tariffed nation even with full retaliation. In this sense, analysis of what economists call the incidence of tariffs indicates that a large share and burden of the tariffs are paid for by the country on which we are applying the tariffs.”
Because China cannot substitute for American demand and bears the incidence of tariffs through inelasticity, tariffs represent revenue to the United States Treasury that is financed by the countries that are tariffed, not by American consumers.
“they are inflexibly supplying to the world market, and that inflexibility, as economists would say, inelasticity means that they bear the burden, they bear the incidence of the tariffs. And that is why the tariffs represent revenue to the United States Treasury that is financed by the countries that we are tariffing.”
Most economists and investors dismiss tariffs as counterproductive or devastatingly harmful, and they are very wrong about this assessment.
“Most economists and some investors dismiss tariffs as counterproductive at best and devastatingly harmful at worst. They're very wrong.”
China's growth engine alternates between different drivers (exporting to America, housing bubbles, exporting to other countries) based on what policies the government feels it can stomach at any moment, using top-down GDP targets to guide policy selection.
“you see from China is they tend to alternate between um different drivers of their growth engine based on what they feel they can they can stomach at any at any moment. Um and they they you know, they tend to have these top-down um GDP targets and then okay, what can we do to achieve that GDP target? Um and you know, one moment it's exporting to America, the next moment it's inflate a housing bubble, um then it's you know, exporting to others.”
Stealth quantitative easing via skewing Treasury debt issuance toward bills instead of bonds, lowering interest rates on huge US debt, was pursued by the Biden administration to partially offset Fed tightening and contribute to persistent inflation.
“the Biden administration had engaged in a form of stealth quantitative easing to partially offset the tightening of the Fed and contributing to the stubborn persistence of inflation. This tactic involves skewing Treasury debt issuance towards bills instead of bonds. Um it also had the effect of lowering interest rates on the huge US debt.”
US manufacturing employment has declined by over a third since its peak and the US share of world manufacturing has declined by 40%, forcing unsustainable trade deficits and vulnerability to supply chain disruptions, as demonstrated during COVID when many supply chains relied on China.
“forcing a decline in our manufacturing workforce by over a third since its peak, and a reduction in our share of world manufacturing 40%. We need to be able to make things in this country as we saw during COVID when many of our supply chains could not survive without being reliant on our biggest adversary, China.”
This is part of why the United States has leverage and other countries don't in trade negotiations.
“And this is part of why uh the United States has leverage and uh and and other countries don't.”
There are plenty of markets where American products either aren't allowed by fiat or are blocked by flimsy regulations designed to protect local incumbents, including bizarre health requirements, environmental requirements, or tariff rates, subsidies, and intellectual property protections, that keep American products out and represent barriers to American exports.
“There are plenty of markets where American products just either aren't allowed by fiat or there's, you know, uh you know, sort of flimsy regulations designed to protect local incumbents. And those regulations can be, you know, related to you know, sort of you know, bizarre health requirements that, you know, are very different than we have here environmental requirements or or you know, whatever that sort of keep our products out.”
Mercantilist countries like China break nearly every rule in the economic playbook through subsidization, intellectual property theft, overproduction, and closing off their own market while relying on access to foreign markets as consumption-oriented advanced economies like the US.
“mercantilist countries like China um which break every almost every rule in the economic playbook of free markets, subsidization, theft of intellectual property, overproduction, uh closing off their own market.”
With competition for great jobs in the economy, manufacturing jobs are less attractive to American workers than very high-skilled jobs like semiconductor factory work, which receives many applicants, whereas assembly work is less attractive to American workers.
“there's a lot of competition for great jobs in our economy and so the very manufacturing jobs that we want to bring back, many of those are less attractive to American workers than the other really high-skilled jobs like perhaps working at a semiconductor factory which is a very attractive job and they get lots of applicants. But, some of the other things like assembly work for instance is less attractive to American workers.”
According to standard economic models, trade deficits cause the dollar to weaken, which reduces imports and boosts exports, eventually wiping out the trade deficit, and therefore tariffs may be unnecessary because trade balances itself over time.
“According to standard models, trade deficits will cause the dollar to weaken, which reduces imports and boosts exports, eventually wiping out the trade deficit. If that happens, tariffs may be unnecessary because trade will balance itself over time and in this view, intervening with tariffs can only make things worse.”
Countries could stop unfair and harmful trading practices by opening their markets and buying more from America, boosting US exports.
“Second, they could stop unfair and harmful trading practices by opening their markets and buying more from America.”
Foreign countries could invest in and install factories in America; they won't face tariffs if they make their products in this country.
“Fourth, they can invest in and install factories in America. They won't face tariffs if they make their if they make their products in this country.”
Foreign countries may buy American assets to manipulate their own currency to keep exports cheap; by pumping money into the US economy, they fuel economic vulnerabilities and crises, as China did with mortgage debt purchases in the years leading up to the 2008 crash.
“Others may buy our assets to manipulate their own currency to keep their exports cheap. In doing so, they end up pumping so much money into the US economy that it fuels economic vulnerabilities and crises. For example, in the years running up to the 2008 crash, China, along with many foreign financial institutions, increased their holdings of US mortgage debt, which helped fuel the housing bubble, forcing hundreds of billions of dollars of credit into the housing sector without regard as to whether the investments made any sense.”
Standard macroeconomic theory and models assume trade deficits away through a 'transversality condition' rather than addressing them as a real problem.
“classical economic theory just assumes away uh they call it a transversality condition, but really what they do is they assume away the problem.”
There is no substitute for American demand for Chinese exports; Chinese attempts to find alternative markets for their excess capacity and exports to other countries will not be successful in replacing US demand.
“at the end of the day, there's just there's no substitute for American demand. Um and so, I I don't know that they'll be you know, that they'll be so successful at trying to avoid trying to find an alternative.”
China, as a mercantilist country, breaks almost every rule in the economic playbook of free markets, including subsidization, intellectual property theft, overproduction, and closing off its own market.
“many analysts have argued that China's weak economy in recent years is only held up by overinvestment in production capacity and the exports which result from the goods production from their overinvestment. Uh this has been seen again and again in industries like steel, solar panels, critical minerals, electric vehicles, among others. Um and they depend on their access to foreign markets as of advanced economies like ours which are more consumption-oriented. Um but question is if China is really has a weak and weakening economy and it's dependent on exports, the tariff policy that the administration has adopted and the first Trump administration adopted uh should be especially effective against China. So, my question is is your analysis of where the Chinese economy is headed uh agree with the idea that they're really weakening and they are especially vulnerable to the actions that your administration is taking”
The US should not rely on its biggest adversary, China, for equipment essential to keeping the population safe and secure, nor should China be allowed to benefit from an international security and financial architecture the US finances.
“We clearly should not rely on our biggest adversary for equipment essentially essential to keeping our population safe and secure. Nor should our biggest adversary be allowed to benefit so much from an international security and financial architecture we finance.”
Tariffs are not levied just to collect revenue but are designed to correct for multiple unfair trading practices: tariff barriers, non-tariff barriers, currency manipulation, dumping, and subsidies.
“the president's reciprocal tariffs are designed to address tariff and non-tariff barriers and other forms of cheating like currency manipulation, dumping, and subsidies to gain unfair advantage”
Americans have been paying for peace and prosperity, not just for themselves, but for non-Americans, through the costs of providing security and reserve currency function.
“As a result of all this, Americans have been paying for peace and prosperity, not just for themselves, but for non-Americans, too.”
Improving burden-sharing is critical for both fairness and capacity: the US will be unable to provide defense or reserve assets if its manufacturing capacity is hollowed out and it cannot pay its bills.
“Moreover, it is critical not just for fairness, but for capacity. We are under siege by hostile adversaries trying to erode our manufacturing and defense industrial base and disrupt our financial system. We will be able to provide neither defense nor reserve assets if our manufacturing capacity is hollowed out.”
Foreign countries can accept tariffs on their exports to the United States without retaliation, providing revenue to the US Treasury to finance global public goods provision, as retaliation would exacerbate rather than improve the distribution of burdens.
“First, other countries can accept tariffs on their exports to the United States without retaliation providing revenue to the US Treasury to finance global public goods provision. Critically, retaliation will exacerbate rather than improve the distribution of burdens. That might make it even more difficult for us to finance global public goods.”
China depends on access to foreign markets of advanced consumption-oriented economies like the US, and would be especially vulnerable to tariff policy that restricts that access.
“Um and they depend on their access to foreign markets as of advanced economies like ours which are more consumption-oriented.”
The United States provides two principal global public goods: a security umbrella that has created the greatest era of peace mankind has ever known, and the dollar and Treasury securities as reserve assets that enable the global trading and financial system supporting the greatest era of prosperity mankind has ever known.
“First, the United States provides a security umbrella, which has created the greatest era of mankind's the greatest era of peace mankind has ever known. Second, the US provides the dollar and Treasury securities, reserve assets which make possible the global trading and financial system, which has supported the greater era of prosperity mankind has ever known.”
If high prices result from insufficient supply to meet consumer demand, the solution is to produce more stuff by removing government regulatory barriers, allowing companies to adjust supply quickly rather than waiting 3+ years for permits.
“if you think high prices are due to not enough stuff to meet consumer demand, the easiest approach is just make more stuff. And the way to make more stuff is to get the government regulatory tape out of the way, let companies adjust their supply to changing demand patterns, let companies produce more, reduce the you know, it shouldn't take 3 years to get the permits or or longer to get the permits in place to build a factory uh or or to enter a particular market.”
Myron and Roubini were clear in their paper that adjusting Treasury debt issuance policy through bills vs bonds (stealth QE) was not a healthy policy for the country or its finances in the long term.
“Nouriel and I were were pretty clear in that paper that it this was not a policy that we thought was healthy um for the country or for the country's finances for the long term.”
The Treasury Department should return to orthodox Treasury debt issuance policy in the long run, but this does not mean the Treasury must immediately unwind past policy errors.
“And but to be clear, that doesn't mean that, you know, I that doesn't mean that I think that the Treasury is deter you know, is is obligated to um you know, immediately unwind uh the you know, sort of the the past in in my view errors of of of the previous Treasury Department.”
Manufacturing jobs are less attractive to American workers than other high-skilled jobs like semiconductor factory work, which gets lots of applicants, while assembly work is less attractive.
“the very manufacturing jobs that we want to bring back, many of those are less attractive to American workers than the other really high-skilled jobs like perhaps working at a semiconductor factory which is a very attractive job and they get lots of applicants. But, some of the other things like assembly work for instance is less attractive to American workers.”
China is attempting to build an alternative economic sphere excluding the US through multiple means including attempting to undermine the dollar, setting up its own financing system, the Belt and Road Initiative, the Made in China 2025 strategy, and the BRICS bloc, and this requires the US to think about the next stage in rebuilding a rules-based global trading system.
“the Chinese through various means such as trying to undermine the dollar, setting up their own financing system, the Belt and Road system, the Made in China 2025, the BRICS, they're trying to build an alternative uh economic sphere, if you will, that uh excludes us.”
China is trying to build an alternative economic sphere excluding the US through means such as undermining the dollar, setting up their own financing system, the Belt and Road system, Made in China 2025, and BRICS.
“the Chinese through various means such as trying to undermine the dollar, setting up their own financing system, the Belt and Road system, the Made in China 2025, the BRICS, they're trying to build an alternative uh economic sphere, if you will, that uh excludes us.”
America can reallocate its demand across borders more easily than other countries can move their factories across borders, which determines who bears the cost of tariffs.
“We can reallocate our demand across borders more easily than other countries can move their factories across borders.”
The United States has run current account deficits for five decades; these have widened precipitously from about 2% of GDP in the first Trump administration to nearly 4% of GDP in the Biden administration, all while the dollar has appreciated rather than depreciated as standard models predict.
“The United States has run current account deficits for five decades and these have widened precipitously in recent years, going from about 2% of GDP in the first Trump administration to a high of nearly 4% of GDP in the Biden administration. And this has happened all while the dollar has appreciated, not depreciated as those models might tell you.”
Companies in the US spend nearly five times as many dollars on their own training programs as all state, local, and federal government combined, a 5-to-1 ratio.
“companies in the US spend nearly five times as many dollars on their own training programs as all state and and local and federal government combined. It's a five to one ratio.”
The regulatory environment that firms face is complex, multi-dimensional, and incredibly detail-oriented and non-numerical, making it difficult for economists to study compared to taxes, which causes a classic lamppost problem where economists underappreciate regulatory impact on the economy.
“The regulatory environment uh firms face is complex, multi-dimensional, and uh incredibly detail-oriented and incredibly non-numerical. As a result, it's difficult for economists to study and I think that we have a classic lamppost problem here where economists underappreciate the regulatory impact on the economy.”
In the example of a property tax increase from $10,000 to $30,000 per year, buyers can avoid the tax by moving to the next town, but sellers cannot move their houses, so the incidence of the tax falls on the house sellers through lower prices, not on the buyers.
“And just imagine that you're buying a house and suddenly the town that you're looking to buy a house in says, "Okay, we're raising property taxes uh by 300% and your property tax bill isn't going to be $10,000 a year, it's going to be $30,000 a year." And so if you're very flexible, an economist would say elastic, uh if you're very flexible, you might decide, "Hey, I'm going to look at the next town over instead." because, you know, like I could just live, you know, 3 miles down the road. The person who's selling the house can't move his house across the border. The house is stuck in that town, right? So, because you were flexible, you can adjust your behavior to avoid the burden of the tax, the person selling the house can't adjust his behavior. He's stuck The house is stuck where the house is stuck. So, he has to drop his selling price because demand for that house disappeared, right? And so that lower selling price is now cleared the market. Economists would say the incidence of the property tax fell on the owner of the home, not the buyer of the home.”
Economists use the concept of 'incidence' to refer to who actually bears the cost or benefit of any economic policy (tariff, subsidy, tax, regulation), which is a function of relative elasticities—specifically, who is more flexible and who is inflexible.
“So, economists use the word incidence to sort of refer to who bears the cost or benefit of any economic policy, whether it's a tariff, a subsidy, a tax, a regulation, you know, whatever it is. Who Who actually experiences the consequence? And one of the core results in economics is that the person who bears the economic cost or benefit isn't really a function of who actually has to remit the payment to the government. It's a function of the relative elasticities, which basically is easier to think of as who's more flexible and who's inflexible.”
It is orthodox Treasury issuance policy to respond to sudden spikes in financing needs (war, recession) with bills issuance rather than long-term debt to avoid disrupting financial markets.
“it is orthodox issuance policy to respond to a sudden spike in financing needs with bills issuance. Um if there's a war, if there's a recession, the deficit's going to expand dramatically. Uh you know, you don't really want to disrupt financial markets in financing the deficit, so you issue short-term debt instead of long-term debt because it doesn't, you know, it avoids the disruption to markets.”
Many analysts argue that China's weak and weakening economy is held up by overinvestment in production capacity and exports, with examples including steel, solar panels, critical minerals, and electric vehicles.
“many analysts have argued that China's weak economy in recent years is only held up by overinvestment in production capacity and the exports which result from the goods production from their overinvestment. Uh this has been seen again and again in industries like steel, solar panels, critical minerals, electric vehicles, among others.”
Many analysts argue that China's weak economy is held up only by overinvestment in production capacity and exports resulting from that overinvestment, seen repeatedly in steel, solar panels, critical minerals, and electric vehicles.
“many analysts have argued that China's weak economy in recent years is only held up by overinvestment in production capacity and the exports which result from the goods production from their overinvestment. Uh this has been seen again and again in industries like steel, solar panels, critical minerals, electric vehicles, among others.”
Electric vehicles from China were not being imported to the US to begin with, so US tariffs on them do not cause incidence on US consumers because there was no change to the tariff rate on those goods.
“Um let me first address the narrow point of the of the electric vehicles, um which is that we weren't importing any of those to begin with from China, right? And so uh you know, so so none of the none of the incidence falls on us by definition cuz we're we're not you know, the tariff rate on those goods isn't changing.”
The United States has run current account deficits for five decades, and these have widened precipitously in recent years, going from about 2% of GDP in the first Trump administration to nearly 4% of GDP in the Biden administration, contradicting standard models' prediction that deficits self-correct through currency adjustment, as the dollar has appreciated rather than depreciated.
“The United States has run current account deficits for five decades and these have widened precipitously in recent years, going from about 2% of GDP in the first Trump administration to a high of nearly 4% of GDP in the Biden administration. And this has happened all while the dollar has appreciated, not depreciated as those models might tell you.”
US manufacturing workforce has declined by over a third since its peak, and US share of world manufacturing has fallen by 40 percentage points.
“forcing a decline in our manufacturing workforce by over a third since its peak, and a reduction in our share of world manufacturing 40%”
The regulatory side of the economy is one of the most important determinants of both potential GDP growth and prices, and a deregulatory thrust combined with pro-energy policy can keep inflation under control.
“I think that the regulatory side of the economy is one of the most important determinants of the supply side of the economy in general um for both potential GDP growth, but also for prices.”
Classical economic theory assumes away trade deficits through a transversality condition rather than addressing them, which allowed economists to ignore the problem, but reality has not conformed to these assumptions.
“You mentioned in your opening remarks that um um uh classical economic theory uh would suggest that uh trade deficits are uh uh self-adjusting in terms of um move- movements in the currencies. It assumes them away. Classic classic economic theory just assumes away uh they call it a transversality condition, but really what they do is they assume away the problem. Well, we know it didn't work.”
In 2018-2019, China bore the cost of President Trump's steel and aluminum tariffs through a weaker currency, meaning Chinese citizens became poorer with less purchasing power on the global stage.
“In 2018-2019, China bore the cost of President Trump's steel work tariffs through a weaker currency, meaning their citizens became poorer with less purchasing power on the global stage.”
If prices are due to not enough stuff to meet consumer demand, the easiest approach is to make more stuff by getting the government regulatory tape out of the way so companies can adjust supply to changing demand patterns and produce more without taking 3 years or longer to get permits to build a factory.
“And if you think high prices are due to not enough stuff to meet consumer demand, the easiest approach is just make more stuff. And the way to make more stuff is to get the government regulatory tape out of the way, let companies adjust their supply to changing demand patterns, let them produce more, reduce the you know, it shouldn't take 3 years to get the permits or or longer to get the permits in place to build a factory”
The Phase One deal between the US and China in 2019 would have delivered concessions across IP, market access, currency, and agricultural purchases, and was fantastic, but the Chinese walked away and Biden administration ignored it.
“Nobody thought the phase one deal with China was going to happen in 2019, and yet it did because the president is such a talented negotiator. And that phase one deal would have delivered a variety of concessions from China across the spectrum of important dimensions in trade, IP, uh market access, currency, purchase purchase of agricultural goods, and I think it would have been fantastic if the Chinese had lived up to had lived up to it. Unfortunately, the Chinese walked away from that phase one deal, and the Biden administration decided to ignore it.”
In 2018-2019, China bore the cost of President Trump's steel and aluminum tariffs through a weaker currency, meaning Chinese citizens became poorer with less purchasing power on the global stage, and the tariff revenue was used to finance Trump's tax cuts for American workers and firms.
“In 2018-2019, China bore the cost of President Trump's steel work tariffs through a weaker currency, meaning their citizens became poorer with less purchasing power on the global stage. The tariff revenue paid for by China was used to finance President Trump's tax cuts for American workers and firms.”
The United States cannot provide either defense or reserve assets if its manufacturing capacity is hollowed out.
“We will be able to provide neither defense nor reserve assets if our manufacturing capacity is hollowed out.”
When tariffs are applied, the incidence does not happen immediately on day one, but over the course of time in the fullness of time it will absolutely happen, following the basic economics of incidence and public finance.
“Now, does this automatically happen on day one? No. But will this happen over the course of over the course in the fullness of time? Absolutely. This is just the basic economics of of of incidence and and and public finance.”
This time around, tariffs will help pay for both tax cuts and deficit reduction, and lower taxes on Americans financed in part by revenue from foreigners will create economic growth, dynamism, and opportunity the likes of which the country has never seen, ushering in Trump's new golden age.
“This time around, tariffs will help pay for both tax cuts and deficit reduction. Lower taxes on Americans, financed in part by revenue provided from foreigners, will create economic growth, dynamism, and opportunity the likes of which our country has never seen, ushering in President Trump's new golden age.”
The US should not rely on its biggest adversary, China, for equipment essential to keeping the population safe and secure, and China should not be allowed to benefit so much from the international security and financial architecture that the US finances.
“We clearly should not rely on our biggest adversary for equipment essentially essential to keeping our population safe and secure. Nor should our biggest adversary be allowed to benefit so much from an international security and financial architecture we finance.”
Foreign countries can invest in and install factories in America; they won't face tariffs if they make their products in this country.
“Fourth, they can invest in and install factories in America. They won't face tariffs if they make their if they make their products in this country.”
China alternates between different drivers of growth based on what it feels it can stomach at any given moment, moving between exporting to America, inflating housing bubbles, and exporting to other countries as top-down GDP targets are achieved.
“what you see from China is they tend to alternate between um different drivers of their growth engine based on what they feel they can they can stomach at any at any moment. Um and they they you know, they tend to have these top-down um GDP targets and then okay, what can we do to achieve that GDP target?”
We need to be as careful as we can to develop support from allies or those we hope will be allies in pushing back against China, and the across-the-board tariff approach may move us in the wrong direction because the negative reaction especially from Europeans and others could undermine alliance-building
“So the c- one conclusion that can be drawn from that is that we have to be as careful as we can to develop um um support from our allies or those we hope will be our allies um in pushing back against uh China. And there has been some criticism of the across-the-board tariff approach that that actually uh moves us in the wrong direction because the negative reaction uh especially from uh from the Europeans from uh from others.”
To continue providing global security and financial public goods, there must be improved burden sharing at the global level; if other nations want to benefit from US geopolitical and financial umbrella, they need to pull their weight and pay their fair share rather than relying solely on American taxpayers.
“In my view, to continue providing these twin global public goods, there needs to be improved burden sharing at the improved burden sharing at the global level. If other nations want to benefit from US geopolitical and from the US geopolitical and financial umbrella, they need to pull their weight and pay their fair share. The costs cannot be solely borne by everyday Americans who have already given so much.”
The Europeans don't want to be the destination for Chinese excess capacity either, and other countries will eventually likely decide the same thing—they don't want their own industries hollowed out by Chinese overcapacity.
“the Europeans don't want to be the destination for this Chinese excess capacity either, right? And so, you know, I would expect other countries eventually to decide the same thing. You know, we don't want our own industries to be hollowed out by this overcapacity.”
The Trump administration should be thinking about the next stage in a global rules-based trading system, possibly excluding China, rather than relying on the ineffective WTO.
“Should we be thinking or is your administration thinking about the next step for rebuilding a rules-based order? Um maybe excluding China, but not necessarily, although they're probably not going to change the the direction they're going in. Should we be thinking about um the the next stage in a global rules-based trading system?”
Countries that run large trade surpluses are inflexible; they cannot find other sources of demand to substitute for America's, so they have no choice but to export, and America is the largest consumer market in the world.
“Country that run Countries that run large trade surpluses are pretty inflexible. They can't find other sources of demand to substitute for America's. Instead, they have no choice but to export. And America is the largest consumer market in the world.”
The Fed has a much better partner in this administration when it comes to inflation than the previous administration because this administration will take steps to expand the supply side and the ability of the American economy to produce things consumers want.
“And in this sense, I think the Fed has a much better partner uh when it comes to inflation than the previous administration. Um you know, this administration will be taking steps to expand to expand the supply side, to expand the ability of the American economy to produce things that consumers want.”
Dollar dominance is not a problem but rather 'a great thing' that should continue for decades or perpetuity; the side effects of reserve currency status are problematic and should be ameliorated while preserving reserve status.
“I don't think the dollar dominance is a problem. I think the dollar dominance is a great thing. Uh, it has some side effects which can be uh problematic, and uh I would like to find ways to ameliorate the side effects that dollar dominance can continue for decades, uh, in perpetuity. I think that would be that would be fabulous.”
Retaliation to US tariffs will exacerbate rather than improve the distribution of burdens and might make it even more difficult for the US to finance global public goods
“Critically, retaliation will exacerbate rather than improve the distribution of burdens. That might make it even more difficult for us to finance global public goods.”
The Federal Reserve will have a much better partner when it comes to controlling inflation under the Trump administration compared to the Biden administration because this administration will be taking steps to expand the supply side and expand the ability of the American economy to produce things that consumers want, rather than relying solely on demand destruction.
“I think the Fed has a much better partner uh when it comes to inflation than the previous administration. Um you know, this administration will be taking steps to expand to expand the supply side, to expand the ability of the American economy to produce things that consumers want.”
Higher tariffs on Lesotho may not have a clear connection to its role in US trade deficits, suggesting a potential gap between the stated diagnostic framework about global trade deficits and the actual bilateral tariff calculations.
“Could you explain why Lesotho has 50% uh tariffs? What global What what con- contribution are they adding to, um, the um, problem you've identified of the um, you know, dollar dominance? Um, and and how you know, so I guess the more broad question is your your the the problem you've identified here seems to have a gap between the sort of bilateral trade deficit measures that the president targeted.”
Myron's advice differs from Peter Navarro's in focus: Myron thinks America deserves better trading terms and is not focused on any one dimension of improvement, while Navarro appears to focus on non-negotiation, but Myron ultimately defers to the president's decision.
“I'm pretty clear that uh you know, I'm pretty clear that I think uh America deserves better trading terms. Um exactly what that looks like I've I've outlined that I'm not focused on any one dimension of better trading terms. Um and so, my my opinion is that there's a variety of improvements that could that could take place. Um but, at the end of the day, you know, the president the president is the decider, and he is going to decide.”
It is orthodox issuance policy to respond to a sudden spike in financing needs with bills issuance rather than long-term debt, as it avoids disruption to financial markets when the deficit expands dramatically due to war or recession.
“it is orthodox issuance policy to respond to a sudden spike in financing needs with bills issuance. Um if there's a war, if there's a recession, the deficit's going to expand dramatically. Uh you know, you don't really want to disrupt financial markets in financing the deficit, so you issue short-term debt instead of long-term debt because it doesn't, you know, it avoids the disruption to markets.”
Services and digital strength are important, and the US should have a diversified economy and industrial base such that, should it need to defend itself, it is able to.
“I think that digital strength is important and I think that services strength is important. I think that all of those things are important. I do think it's also important to have a diversified economy and a sufficiently diversified industrial base that should you need to defend yourself, you are able to.”
When President Trump announced tariffs in the first term, nobody thought the phase one deal with China was going to happen, but it did because the president is a talented negotiator.
“Nobody thought the phase one deal with China was going to happen in 2019, and yet it did because the president is such a talented negotiator.”
China played a meaningful role in creating the global financial crisis of 2008, requiring almost a decade for recovery until President Trump's first term restored the economy.
“China played a meaningful role creating the global financial crisis. It took almost a decade to recover until President Trump got us back on track in his first term.”
The tariff rates on electric vehicles from China were not changed because we weren't importing any of those to begin with, so none of the tariff incidence falls on the US by definition
“Um, let me first address the narrow point of the of the electric vehicles, um which is that we weren't importing any of those to begin with from China, right? And so uh you know, so so none of the none of the incidence falls on us by definition cuz we're we're not you know, the tariff rate on those goods isn't changing.”
Myron's paper 'A User's Guide to Restructuring Global Trading System' was written prior to his consideration for the CEA chair role and does not reflect administration policy, despite speculation that the administration is secretly following its framework.
“First of all, let me let me clarify a couple things about that about that piece. First of all, it's not important. You know, I wrote it prior to prior to my consideration for this role. It doesn't reflect administration policy. Lots of people have speculated that we're secretly following, you know, sort of some some policy path laid out in that in that document. Nothing could be further from the truth.”
The administration has emphasized the need to address multiple problems including currency manipulation, subsidies, and intellectual property theft, which should all be factors weighed in trading negotiations, with the president deciding what package to accept as a deal.
“the administration the president have been very clear uh that we want increased access to foreign markets that would boost our exports”
The paper aimed to provide a recipe book of different policy tools and their potential risks and rewards, without advocating for any of them, though much writing has misconstrued it as arguing for particular elements.
“that piece really aims to provide a recipe book, right? Here are the different tools in the in the toolbox and what you can do with them. Some recipes are easy to make, some are difficult to make, some will you know are are are are nourishing nutritious meal and some will leave you hungry again in a half hour. It doesn't advocate for any of them. And I think there's been an enormous amount of writing that has misconstrued myself as arguing for any particular element”
Other countries can boost defense spending and procurement from the United States, buying more US-made goods and taking the strain off American service members while creating jobs here.
“Third, they could boost defense spending and procurement from the United States, buying more US-made goods and taking the strain off our service members and creating jobs here.”
There are conflicting narratives from administration officials (one saying tariffs are a negotiation tool, another saying this is not a negotiation) because everybody has opinions, disagreement enhances arguments and avoids group think, which is healthy.
“They're they're conflicting narratives because, you know, everybody everybody's got an opinion. Um and and that's fine, right? Like this, you know, disagreement is, you know, disagreement is is how you can sort of, you know, enhance your arguments and avoid group think, and I think that's very healthy.”
The formula used to announce reciprocal tariffs was relating to closing trade deficits, as the president declared an emergency with respect to trade deficits, so trade deficits would be heavily involved in calculating tariff rates.
“the president chose to go with a formula relating to um relating to closing trade deficits um suggested by by someone else in the administration. Um I do think it's important to emphasize that the president declared an emergency with respect to trade deficits. Um the executive order uh was with respect to trade deficits. And so, of course, trade deficits would be heavily involved in calculating tariff rates.”
There are conflicting narratives about whether trade talks are negotiations or non-negotiable because everybody has opinions and disagreement helps enhance arguments and avoid group think.
“So, they're they're conflicting narratives because, you know, everybody everybody's got an opinion. Um and and that's fine, right? Like this, you know, disagreement is, you know, disagreement is is how you can sort of, you know, enhance your arguments and avoid group think, and I think that's very healthy.”
The Biden administration ignored the phase one deal that Trump's first administration gave them, throwing away a fabulous trade outcome for no reason whatsoever, and it would have been nice if China had lived up to it at any point in recent months.
“I think it would have been fantastic if the Chinese had lived up to had lived up to it. Unfortunately, the Chinese walked away from that phase one deal, and the Biden administration decided to ignore it. You know, we gave the Biden administration a fabulous trade outcome, and then they just decided to throw it away for for no reason whatsoever. And I think that was enormously unfortunate. Um and it would have been nice for, you know, for China to try to live up to it you know, at at any point in in in recent years, uh recent months.”
The president will no doubt that the Treasury Department will keep our finances on safe and sound footing and the administration will not be obligated to immediately unwind the past errors of the previous Treasury Department, just because someone points out that someone's building a ticking time bomb doesn't obligate anyone to throw themselves on it in diffusing it
“And I think that just because I point out that uh you know, someone's building a ticking time bomb doesn't obligate anyone to throw themselves on it you know, in in diffusing it. Um you know, and and so, you know, I have I have no doubt that uh that that uh the Treasury Department will will keep our our finances on on safe and sound footing.”
The formula used to announce reciprocal tariffs was chosen by the president and relates to closing trade deficits, as suggested by someone else in the administration, with CEA involved in calculating a variety of means for estimating approaches to thinking about non-tariff barriers.
“uh we were CEA was involved in calculating a a variety of means of estimating, you know, sort of uh uh approaches to to thinking about non-tariff barriers. Um and a variety of approaches were considered. At the end of the day, the president chose to go with a formula relating to um relating to closing trade deficits um suggested by by someone else in the administration.”
The paper 'A User's Guide to Restructuring the Global Trading System' does not reflect administration policy; it was a recipe book laying out various tools and their risks/rewards, not advocacy for any particular policy; the president is the only chef and decides what to make.
“First of all, let me let me clarify a couple things about that about that piece. First of all, it's not important. You know, I wrote it prior to prior to my consideration for this role. It doesn't reflect administration policy... But then beyond the diagnosis of the problem, that piece really aims to provide a recipe book, right? Here are the different tools in the in the toolbox and what you can do with them... I'm not the chef. There's one chef and that's the president and he decides what he's going to make.”
The president has been very transparent for months about what he intended to do and continues to fulfill the promises made on the campaign trail.
“The president has been very transparent for months now about what he intended to do and he continues to fulfill the promises that he made on the campaign trail and I have no doubt will continue to do so.”
Pointing out that someone is building a ticking time bomb does not obligate anyone to throw themselves on it in diffusing it; therefore, identifying Biden-era policy errors does not obligate the current Treasury Department to immediately unwind those policies.
“I think that just because I point out that uh you know, someone's building a ticking time bomb doesn't obligate anyone to throw themselves on it you know, in in diffusing it. Um you know, and and so, you know, I have no doubt that uh that that uh the Treasury Department will will keep our our finances on on safe and sound footing.”
The president is the only one who will decide what will happen with tariffs and negotiations, with choice remaining entirely with the president as always.
“All I can say is that that choice will ultimately remain with the president, as has always been the case”
The Trump administration's first 100 days have already moved forcefully to reorient defense and trading relationships to place Americans on fairer ground, with the president committed to rebuilding the broken industrial base and pursuing trade terms that put American workers and businesses first.
“The Trump administration has already, in its first 100 days, moved forcefully to reorient our defense and trading relationships to place Americans on fairer ground. The president has promised to rebuild our broken industrial base and pursue trade terms that put Americans American workers and businesses first.”
Foreign countries can simply write checks to Treasury to help finance global public goods provision.
“Fifth, they could simply write checks to Treasury. That would help us finance global public goods as well.”
Foreign governments are actively calling the White House about negotiations, as evidenced by the phone 'ringing off the hook' in various White House offices.
“I understand that, you know, the phone's been ringing off the hook uh in various places in the White House. Uh keep it, you know, keep it keep it ringing off the hook.”
The president is a fabled negotiator with a history of creating deals when nobody thought they were possible, and anyone who can negotiate a better trading system for America and the world, he can.
“the president is is a fabled negotiator, right? Who has been negotiating deals his entire career. Um and if there's anybody who can if there's anybody who can negotiate um to create a better trading system for America and the world, uh it's President Trump. Um and I have no doubt found that if anyone can do it, he can.”