
$132 Billion in Gold Bought... But Who’s Really Buying? | Joseph Cavatoni
What this covers
Joseph Cavatoni, Chief Market Strategist at the World Gold Council, discusses Q2's record $132 billion in gold demand with Jeremy Saffron, examining which buyers drove it and what it means for price momentum ahead. The 22-minute interview unpacks a paradox: total volume grew modestly at 1,249 tons year-over-year, yet dollar value hit an all-time high—signaling that structural investment strength, not mere speculation or price momentum, now anchors the market. Cavatoni lays out a thesis of compositional shift: traditional retail and jewelry buyers have retreated sharply under high prices, while institutional capital, central banks, and off-market OTC players have stepped in to fill the gap and then some. The conversation moves through geographic divergence, the role of ETF flows, and the measurement puzzle of unreported sovereign accumulation.
The discussion covers a widening fracture in demand patterns. US bar and coin purchases collapsed 53 percent to their lowest point in five years, while Chinese demand surged 44 percent—a reversal Cavatoni traces to shifting political risk appetite rather than pure price elasticity. Jewelry demand in India and China has plummeted to near pandemic lows, a decline he argues requires product redesign toward lower price points before recovery sets in. Central banks accumulated a near-record 166 tons in Q2, with over half from unnamed official sources, a movement he frames as dollar diversification rather than cyclical buying. ETF flows, though modest in absolute terms, are "sticky"—attracting no outflows—and signal a tipping point in European participation. Cavatoni identifies Fed rate cuts and dollar weakness as the critical catalysts for the next leg, while cautioning that the gold market's architecture itself has fundamentally shifted in both who trades it and which channels carry the volume.
Gold markets are experiencing a fundamental structural shift driven by institutional and central bank accumulation rather than retail demand, with ETF and OTC flows replacing traditional jewelry and bar-coin consumption as the primary demand drivers, while unreported sovereign buying is reshaping reserve accumulation patterns.
- Q2 gold demand hit record $132 billion in dollar value despite only 3% volume growth, showing price appreciation driving dollar value while volume growth remains modest
- ETF and OTC flows are surging and 'sticky' while jewelry demand collapses globally (down 20% in China, 17% in India), signaling a shift from consumption to institutional investment
- Central banks are quietly stockpiling gold off the books through unreported channels, with 90 tons of 166 tons in Q2 official sector demand coming from undisclosed sources, suggesting a new reserve accumulation dynamic
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Gold's portability and security make it a store of value in times of conflict; Iran's outlier jewelry demand growth likely reflects gold's role as wearable, portable wealth one can carry to flee a country, combined with limited access to exchange-traded gold products in that market.
“if an an individual is looking at what can I put on my wrist around my neck to get out of a country, I think ultimately um gold can play a role like that in a market like Iran. So I think that there is a sense of saving, there is a sense of portability, there is a sense of security”
Unreported sovereign gold buying carries genuine measurement uncertainty due to time lags and entities used for specific purposes, but the World Gold Council validates its data through partners like Metals Focus, and countries sometimes declare accumulation months later under the IMF framework.
“we spend a lot of time working with metals focus have a very robust process of validating their data... There might be a time lag. There might be um an entity that's being used for a particular purpose... we have had examples in the past where several months after the accumulation has taken place a particular country might come out and make the declaration under the IMF framework.”
Global jewelry demand has fallen to near pandemic-era lows (China down 20%, India down 17%) because the segment is more price-sensitive than investment; recovery requires recycled gold to come online and jewelry fabricators to design lower-price-point, more accessible products, which takes time and is only beginning (e.g., smaller consumable designs in China).
“China was down 20%, India down 17%. That's a big hit for the base”
Official sector central bank gold purchases totaled 166 tons in Q2, with 90 tons (more than half) coming from unreported sources, indicating that over half of official gold accumulation is happening off the books through undisclosed channels.
“when we talk about you know official sector buying the report showed 166 tons in net central bank demand more than half of that I think 90 tons came from these unreported sources.”
High gold prices impact retail jewelry consumption globally, causing significant declines as consumers find jewelry unaffordable or jewelry fabricators must redesign products for lower price points.
“high prices do impact what does take place in retail consumption and that that's actually to your point earlier around the jewelry market which is what we're seeing across the globe a significant decline.”
OTC gold flows include private banks, wealth offices, and physical gold buyers (both global and US), as well as non-disclosed institutional stock held by financial institutions.
“it's anywhere where you're having investment dollars being put to work on the physical form of gold that basically doesn't have a disclosure mechanism. So that would include private banks, that would include wealth offices, that would include those that are buying in physical form, whether it's global or here home with the US or whatever it might be. uh but it also can include some institutional stock that might just be held and not disclosed by by those financial institutions that hold it.”
US asset managers are now discussing 2-5% gold allocations, up from the historical roughly 1.25%, accompanied by messaging that gold is sticky and that investors should hold or add rather than sell.
“this is a market that's actually looking at more like 2 to 5% allocations. That's what asset managers are talking about. It's not this one one and a quarter that we've heard in the past... it's sticky, don't sell. If anything, add to your allocation.”
Recycling rose only ~4% despite high prices and rapid 25-27% year-to-date price growth, which signals that holders (jewelry and investment) expect further price upside and are reluctant to sell; rising pledged-gold collateral in India means financial stress could later trigger liquidation and a supply surge.
“recycling rose just 4%. It's it's kind of muted... in India pledged gold jewelry used as collateral for loans is is kind of spiking”
China allowing insurers to hold physical gold under a pilot program signals institutions and regulators understanding portfolio diversification and gold's benefits, potentially opening a new institutional demand base — though it remains a pilot and should not be over-hyped.
“They've they've now allowed insurers to hold physical gold... opening up this channel under pilot program... that pilot program in works tells us that the government, the regulators... and insurers are understanding portfolio diversification and the benefits of gold as an asset allocation”
OTC demand (about 170 tons, roughly matching ETF demand) consists of investment dollars put into physical gold without a disclosure mechanism — private banks, wealth offices, physical buyers, and some undisclosed institutional stock — and represents consumption consistent with long-term holding.
“it's anywhere where you're having investment dollars being put to work on the physical form of gold that basically doesn't have a disclosure mechanism. So that would include private banks, that would include wealth offices, that would include those that are buying in physical form”
Net central bank gold demand was 166 tons in Q2 with over half (about 90 tons) from unreported sources; though down from 240 tons in Q1, this remains at or near record levels and reflects ongoing diversification away from a weakening dollar and dollar assets, expected to continue (though perhaps below the 1,000+ ton record pace) and showing more price sensitivity than expected.
“the report showed 166 tons in net central bank demand more than half of that I think 90 tons came from these unreported sources”
China bar and coin demand jumped 44% to 115 tons in Q2, while US demand collapsed 53% to 8.8 tons (the lowest level in 5 years), representing a stark geographic divergence in retail gold buying.
“You just mentioned China demand jumped 44% to uh what 115 tons and in the US it happened to collapse by 53% down to 8.8 tons the lowest level in 5 years.”
Mine production hit a Q2 record of about 99 tons but all-in sustaining costs rose above ~$1,530 per ounce, squeezed by energy and labor costs; production growth remains below the pace of demand growth.
“mine production hit a Q2 record, 99 tons, but average all-in sustaining costs kind of rose over about $1,530 per ounce”
Gold demand in Q2 totaled 1,249 tons (a 3% year-over-year increase in volume), but reached a record $132 billion in dollar value, showing that price appreciation is driving the dollar value of demand even as volume growth remains modest.
“total gold demand in Q2 came in at 1,23 49 tons, right? That's only 3% year-over-year increase. But in dollar terms, I mean, demand actually hit a record, $132 billion.”
Total Q2 gold demand was modest in volume (about 1,249 tons, +3% year-over-year) but hit a record in dollar terms at $132 billion, indicating the case for gold remains structurally strong among investors rather than being purely price-driven.
“total gold demand in Q2 came in at 1,23 49 tons... That's only 3% year-over-year increase. But in dollar terms, I mean, demand actually hit a record, $132 billion.”
ETF flows, while not the largest share of investment, demonstrate that investment dollars can move quickly and meaningfully; the flows are 'sticky' because they are not seeing outflows, and Europe is a market that could reach a tipping point producing rapid inflows given its lagging participation relative to record North American and Asian flows.
“these are the ETF flows, which still isn't the lion share of where investment is basically being held. The investment being held in OTC flows... what it does tell us when we see the flows in ETFs that the investment dollars are quick to move and they can move and be meaningful. I think Europe is the one market that I continue to watch”
Current gold investment buying is structural rather than speculative, with investors holding and adding to gold exposure while waiting to see how monetary policy develops; weakening employment data, potential Fed rate cuts, and a weakening dollar are key catalysts for gold.
“I think it's structural. So, what I think we're hearing and seeing more and more from investors is waiting and seeing for what exactly is going to develop on the monetary side... that is a key catalyst for gold. when the Fed will move on rates, when the dollar will show signs of weakness”
The most underappreciated trend for the next 90 days to 6 months is investors' appetite for risk assets and their willingness to sustain shocks; China and the US are the two markets to watch as they will signal the broader risk outlook and the trajectory of gold investment demand.
“the key thing to keep a close watch on for the next 90 days to call it 6 months would be the appetite for risk assets from investors. Their willingness to take risk and sustain kind of shocks... keep all eyes on China as well because those two markets will give us a big significant outlook for risk asset”
ETF gold flows of 170 tons in the last quarter represent the strongest half since 2020, but these flows were concentrated in just a few weeks, suggesting investment dollars are 'quick to move' and can be 'meaningful' when deployed.
“they're not speculative. I mean, it it almost feels like what did they hit? 170 tons last quarter. Strongest half since 2020. But those flows were concentrated in just a few weeks.”
July US payrolls rose by only 73,000 while revisions wiped nearly 250,000 jobs from May and June employment figures, bringing the 3-month average to just 35,000 jobs—the weakest run since the pandemic.
“July payrolls rose by 73,000. But the real damages in the revisions nearly a quarter million. A quarter million jobs wiped off the books from May and June. The 3-month average now sits at just 35,000. That's the weakest run since the pandemic.”
Gold is testing around $3,350 per ounce following the labor market release, catching a bid as investors seek hedges to economic deterioration.
“gold is catching a bid here after this economic data release testing around 3350 an ounce.”
The US labor market is buckling: July payrolls rose only 73,000, but downward revisions wiped nearly a quarter million jobs off May and June, bringing the 3-month average to just 35,000 — the weakest run since the pandemic — while unemployment rises and participation falls.
“July payrolls rose by 73,000. But the real damages in the revisions nearly a quarter million. A quarter million jobs wiped off the books from May and June. The 3-month average now sits at just 35,000. That's the weakest run since the pandemic.”
Bar and coin demand diverged sharply by region: China jumped 44% to about 115 tons while US demand collapsed 53% to 8.8 tons, the lowest in five years, because US bar/coin buying is historically driven by political/fiscal anxiety (typically under Democratic administrations) and those conditions are currently less present.
“China demand jumped 44% to uh what 115 tons and in the US it happened to collapse by 53% down to 8.8 tons the lowest level in 5 years.”
Growth in gold demand is occurring in areas where increased activity and growth are expected—particularly ETF investment and broader investment categories—while traditional consumption categories like jewelry are declining, indicating a positive structural shift toward investment.
“Second, the numbers while modest in terms of their growth, um they're growing and actually growing in areas where we are expecting to see an increased level of activity and growth particularly as you've highlighted uh the numbers in ETFs are telling us that but investment overall. So I think it's giving us certainty that that that the growth potential still stands for gold...with one area that we would have expected to be down jewelry being down. So I think it's a positive number.”
The most important trend in the Q2 gold demand report that investors are not paying enough attention to is the appetite for risk assets from investors and their willingness to take risk and sustain shocks to the system, which will determine whether gold investor demand continues to grow.
“I think I think the key thing to keep a close watch on for the next 90 days to call it 6 months would be the appetite for risk assets from investors. Their willingness to take risk and sustain kind of shocks to the system because that's what we're continuing to see.”
Japan is a market with very good conditions for investors to diversify away from yen and bonds into gold market activities, with a very robust ETF market.
“Japan is a market that has very good conditions for investors to look to diversify away from yen and bonds and into uh gold market activities. Um there's an ETF market that's very robust there.”
Central banks are diversifying away from a weakening dollar and weakening dollar assets into gold, suggesting official sector buying is driven by currency and reserve composition concerns rather than inflation or speculation.
“will be a continued theme of ongoing buying from central banks as they diversify away from a weakening dollar and weakening dollar assets.”
A 50 basis point Fed rate cut in September would act as a major catalyst pushing gold higher, providing the next systemic move via lower rates and dollar weakness that prompts investors to reassess portfolio risk.
“it will push gold upwards and then basically it will be a catalyst that we've been talking to... a big conditional move for for gold to kind of get its next wave up... and that will likely be the move in rates and the actual weakness of the dollar”
The economic outlook for the US and major global markets remains supportive of gold prices; even downward forecast revisions keep gold in positive territory, with price appreciation expected through year-end and into 2026, contingent on patience through news-driven headwinds.
“we see those economic conditions continuing to be quite supportive of those that are calling for price appreciation between now and the end of the year, but also into 2026... you're going to see some bit of uh price headwinds when it comes to certain noise and news”
The fact that recycling of jewelry gold has not substantially increased despite high prices signals that jewelry holders are not liquidating, suggesting that the jewelry-holding community is anticipating even higher prices.
“that we haven't seen as much of a as of yet, which tells us that there might be more price upside being signaled by that community.”
China regulators have allowed insurers to hold physical gold, initially as a pilot program, which is significant because it demonstrates that institutional bodies understand portfolio diversification and the benefits of gold as an asset allocation tool.
“on China, I mean, regulators there, we talked a little bit about it. They've they've now allowed insurers to hold physical gold. How significant is this move?”
ETF flows represent only a portion of total investment demand; the larger pool resides in OTC (over-the-counter) flows, which have been continuing strong for the last 5-6 quarters, indicating that institutional commitment extends beyond the more visible ETF channel.
“these are the ETF flows, which still isn't the lion share of where investment is basically being held. The investment being held in OTC flows, which is actually continuing to be strong and has been for the last 5 to six quarters.”
Iran was the only outlier among major regions, with jewelry demand growing in Q2, likely driven by a combination of consumer demand for portability during geopolitical stress and the lack of robust institutional gold investment products in Iran.
“Yeah, there there's there's a long history of the affinity for gold being linked to also the the the portability of gold. So if an an individual is looking at what can I put on my wrist around my neck to get out of a country, I think ultimately um gold can play a role like that in a market like Iran. So I think that there is a sense of saving, there is a sense of portability, there is a sense of security with it”
The market is pricing in a September Federal Reserve rate cut with near certainty in response to deteriorating labor market conditions.
“and the market is now pricing in a September rate cut with near certainty”
In China, bar and coin demand shows consistent flows across both ETF and physical retail channels, indicating accumulation across all market segments and investor types.
“But in China, again, across the board, ETFs and bar and coin showing consistent flows there. So, you're actually seeing a condition of of of accumulation.”
China is showing signs of investors taking slightly more risk in July as markets move beyond Q2, suggesting appetite for risk assets remains strong.
“So, China's had record flows. It continues to be a market that dominates as we move beyond the second quarter report that we have and into July we're showing some signs of the investor maybe looking to take a little more risk in China.”
In India, pledged gold jewelry used as collateral for loans is spiking, which could create a sudden supply surge if financial stress triggers liquidation of collateral.
“in India pledged gold jewelry used as collateral for loans is is kind of spiking which is very interesting. What happens if financial stress triggers liquidation? Could we see a you know sudden supply surge?”
US bar and coin demand is depressed because conditions for well-disclosed and high-volume retail gold buying occur during periods when the administration is questioned, particularly during Democratic administrations when there is concern about government spending and mainstream investment conditions.
“We see that the conditions in the US for well-disclosed and high volume uh activities in the bar and coin market usually during a con you a market condition where the administration might be questioned. a Democratic administration where there might be more concern amongst that buying community that the uh cost of of government, the cost of spending, the conditions of government might be leaning more towards having something a little less in the mainstream investment landscape. So bringing it into the barncoin environment.”
Europe is a key market to watch because it is currently behind North American and Asian gold flows, and could experience a significant tipping point where flows move quickly to market.
“I think Europe is the one market that I continue to watch because I think what we compete with in gold is an appetite for ongoing risk, ongoing risk and risk assets. And right now, I think Europe's still behind where you're seeing North American flows, which have been record setting, as well as Asian flows and ETFs. So, I'm keeping a close watch on what going to what's going to develop in Europe and how risk assets are going to continue to play a role there because I think that that's the market that we could see yet again another one of these tipping points where flows come quickly to market.”
Gold ETF flows are 'sticky'—not experiencing outflows—which is a key indicator that institutional positioning is structural rather than tactical or speculative.
“And again, it's sticky. Remember, it's sticky. The flows are not seeing outflows. That's what's key right now.”
Economic conditions in the US and major markets will remain supportive of gold price appreciation between now and the end of 2024, and continuing into 2026, requiring patience as the market processes price volatility and news shocks.
“But personally and I think from the perspective of our organization, we see those economic conditions continuing to be quite supportive of those that are calling for price appreciation between now and the end of the year, but also into 2026. I think people just need to understand that there's patience that needs to be played out with the gold market and you're going to see some bit of uh price headwinds when it comes to certain noise and news that are going to hit the market.”
The World Gold Council validates unreported central bank gold data through robust processes with Metals Focus and stands behind the accuracy of unreported gold accumulation figures before publishing them.
“So we work with a couple of organizations and in particular we spend a lot of time working with metals focus have a very robust process of validating their data. So we stand behind the numbers and we feel comfortable and confident on them.”
Investors are standing holding their gold, increasing their overall level of exposure to gold and looking to continue to put more to work in gold, indicating conviction-based accumulation rather than opportunistic buying.
“And investors are standing there holding their gold, increasing their overall level of exposure to gold and looking to continue to put more to work in gold.”
Gold miners are moving as fast as possible to increase production, and while they are succeeding in growing output, persistent cost pressures from energy and labor will continue to impact their ability to produce at higher levels.
“I think they're moving as fast as they possibly can to get production online. I think they're doing uh a good job of that. What is interesting though is that some of the factors that really do play into the costs are continuing to plague them...So I think what we need to see are are are the production levels continuing to grow because at this stage the factors that are around it are going to continue to be somewhat volatile and somewhat impactful on their ability to produce at higher levels.”
A 50 basis point Fed rate cut in September would be a catalyst that pushes gold upward and unlocks 'the next wave up' beyond the strong run gold has already had in 2024, with higher price targets as markets reflect dollar weakness and risk asset repricing.
“Certainly. it it will push gold upwards and then basically it will be a catalyst that we've been talking to which we've been looking for. We're looking for another big systemic kind of like a big conditional I should say a big conditional move for for gold to kind of get its next wave up beyond this very strong run we've had so far this year and that will likely be the move in rates and the actual weakness of the dollar and those conditions for questions on what and how to handle your risk assets in your portfolio.”
Gold caught a bid after the economic data release, testing around $3,350 an ounce.
“gold is catching a bid here after this economic data release testing around 3350 an ounce”
The gold market has fundamentally changed: the players are different, flows are moving in the dark, and the old demand drivers are no longer what they used to be.
“this isn't the same gold market. The players are changing and the flows are moving in the dark. The old demand drivers aren't what they used to be.”