YouTube6m· Apr 2024· cataloged

Why biohacking sends the wrong messages about the pursuit of health and longevity


What this covers

This is a seven-minute solo video in which Peter Attia explains why he dislikes biohacking and what he thinks the term gets wrong. He starts from a documentary interview in which he was asked whether biohacking providers are frauds. He calls that the wrong question, because whether a provider knowingly believes the treatment fails matters less than whether the treatment works. He also admits that his wife has told him he sounds contemptuous on the subject, and he attributes this partly to a low tolerance for nonsense.

The main example is an Australian biohacker who spent $700,000 on gene therapy and related treatments in Mexico. Attia walks through the logic behind follistatin therapy: follistatin inhibits myostatin, which itself restrains muscle growth, so more follistatin should mean bigger muscles. He says he has seen no evidence that it works in humans. He adds that even if it did, lifting weights would give the same result for free, and that he would decline the therapy even at $7. Behind this sits an epistemic point: biology has no formal proofs, only probabilities, and some probabilities are high enough to function as certainty.

He sets the biohacks against factors he regards as near-certain: VO2 Max, muscle mass, strength, time outdoors, and social connection. Beside them he puts mostly free practices such as mindful eating, an earlier bedtime, and sleep hygiene habits like putting the phone down two hours before bed. The chance that fashionable supplements and therapies help, he says, lies between zero and epsilon. That claim is flagged as contested, as is his view that costly interventions at best nudge outcomes in an uncertain direction. He also cites people who spend $500 a month on supplements with no demonstrated efficacy.

His sharpest argument is moral rather than financial. He says he does not mind people wasting money; his objection is to wasted mindshare. He also argues that promoting expensive interventions tells people without resources that longevity is out of their reach.

Sharpest takeaway

Most popular biohacking interventions are expensive, unproven, and distract from evidence-based, low-cost practices (exercise, sleep, diet, social connection) that have near-certain longevity benefits; promoting expensive biohacks sends a harmful message that longevity requires wealth.

  • Proven longevity factors (VO2 max, muscle mass, strength, outdoor time, social connection) are inexpensive or free, while biohacks have probability of benefit between 'zero and epsilon'
  • The real harm of biohacking discourse is not wasted money but wasted mindshare—it distorts attention away from what actually works
  • Expensive unproven interventions implicitly communicate to people without resources that they cannot achieve longevity

The claims · ranked20 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.74

In biology, unlike mathematics, there are no formal proofs—only probabilities. When probabilities are sufficiently high, they approximate certainty.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Peter Attia

“the things are proven to matter as much as one can prove anything in biology and let's be really clear this is not mathematics where there are formal proofs but when you start to talk about things in terms of probabilities the probability that having a high V2 Max having solid muscle mass being very strong spending time Outdoors having connections with people the probability that those things are going to lengthen your life and improve the quality of your life is so high that it's as close to being 100% as possible”

0.74

Even if follistatin gene therapy worked to increase muscle mass, resistance training (going to the gym and lifting weights) achieves the same outcome without cost.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Peter Attia

“do you really need to spend money to do that or do you just need to go to the gym and lift weights”

0.69

High VO2 max, solid muscle mass, strength, spending time outdoors, and social connections have a probability of lengthening life and improving quality of life so high it is as close to 100% as possible in biology.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Attia

“the probability that having a high V2 Max having solid muscle mass being very strong spending time Outdoors having connections with people the probability that those things are going to lengthen your life and improve the quality of your life is so high that it's as close to being 100% as possible”

0.69

What really matters for longevity is stuff you don't need to pay for: exercise (beyond gym membership), mindful eating, earlier bedtime, sleep hygiene protocols like putting your phone down two hours before bed.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Attia

“what really matters matters is the stuff that you don't need to pay for okay you don't need to pay to exercise outside of maybe getting a gym membership you don't need to pay to be mindful about how you eat you don't need to pay to go to bed a little bit earlier um and you know incorporate some protocols around sleep hygiene and maybe putting your phone down two hours before bed or things like that I mean the things that move the needle the most are relatively inexpensive”

0.68

Expensive biohacking interventions move the needle, at best, maybe a little bit in an uncertain direction, and at worst could be harmful, while clearly being very expensive.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Attia

“I get so bothered by these incremental things that at best move the needle maybe a little bit in a TBD way at worst could actually be harmful um and clearly are a lot of money”

0.64

Follistatin is a gene that expresses a protein that inhibits myostatin, which itself inhibits muscle growth during development; the theoretical logic of follistatin gene therapy is that enhanced follistatin would inhibit myostatin and produce larger muscles.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Peter Attia

“follistatin is follistatin is a gene that expresses A protein that protein then goes on to inhibit another protein called myostatin and myostatin inhibits muscle growth during development so the theoretical argument is if you do this gene therapy to um enhance fallatin make more fallatin you would inhibit myostatin you would have larger muscles”

0.60

The speaker is not opposed to people wasting money; the speaker is opposed to people wasting mindshare—the distraction from what actually works.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Peter Attia

“I'm not opposed to people wasting money I'm really opposed to people wasting mind share I'm opposed to the fact that people think that doing these things is somehow a substitute for doing the things that matter”

0.59

Promoting expensive biohacking interventions, even if the individual promoter has resources and believes in them, amplifies a harmful message to people without resources—that longevity requires wealth.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Peter Attia

“the first is it certainly sends a message that you know if you can't afford a $700,000 fist stattin gene therapy you're hosed um and I mean we can unpack that for a moment but let me just tell you that is the most ridiculous thing I've ever heard”

0.56

There is zero evidence that follistatin gene therapy works in humans to increase muscle mass, at least no evidence the speaker has seen.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Peter Attia

“you could certainly construct an experiment that might suggest that that could happen in animals there's no evidence it's happening in humans at least no evidence that I've seen”

0.56

The distinction between whether an expensive treatment is fraudulent depends on whether the provider knowingly believes it doesn't work—but this distinction is less important than evaluating whether the treatment actually works, regardless of the provider's beliefs.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Peter Attia

“how do you define a fraud a is a fraud someone who is knowingly charging you 700,000 for something that they think is bunk um I would said let's let's even posit that the individuals doing this believe that their magical fista and gene therapy is going to work um uh does that make it any less fraudulent I forget it let's let's just take that off the table”

0.52

Many people think that expensive biohacking interventions are a substitute for evidence-based practices, when in fact proven interventions should be the priority.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Attia

“I'm really opposed to people wasting mind share I'm opposed to the fact that people think that doing these things is somehow a substitute for doing the things that matter the things are proven to matter as much as one can prove anything in biology”

0.51

The probability that questionable supplements and therapies discussed in the biohacking sphere are beneficial is very low—somewhere between zero and epsilon (a small number).

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Peter Attia

“the probability that this Litany of of of of you know questionable supplements and therapies that people are talking about in the biohacking sphere are beneficial is very low I mean we're talking somewhere between zero and Epsilon and epsilon's a small number”

0.47

Biohacking discourse distorts attention away from interventions that are proven to work toward interventions that move the needle only incrementally and with uncertain direction.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Attia

“the second point of why I just find these discussions so infuriating is it distracts from what really matters right what really matters matters is the stuff that you don't need to pay for”

0.47

Biohacking discourse sends the explicit message that if you can't afford expensive interventions like $700,000 gene therapy, you are 'hosed' (unable to achieve longevity benefits).

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Attia

“the first is it certainly sends a message that you know if you can't afford a $700,000 fist stattin gene therapy you're hosed”

0.45

People frequently ask the speaker whether they should take various supplements, and many people spend $500 per month on supplements with no demonstrated efficacy.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Peter Attia

“I feel the same way about so many of the supplements I constantly am asked about right oh Peter should I be taking this supplement and that supplement and before you know it you know person spending $5 $500 a month on supplements for which there is no demonstrated efficacy”

0.43

The speaker would not take follistatin gene therapy even if it cost $7 instead of $700,000, because there is no evidence it works.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Attia

“if it was $7 I wouldn't do it why because there is zero evidence that this works”

0.20

The speaker has a very low tolerance for nonsense and buffoonery, which partly explains why they respond strongly and sometimes angrily when discussing biohacking.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Peter Attia

“I I don't think I'm a jerk but I do tend to respond very strongly to things that are nonsense I have a very low tolerance for nonsense and buffoonery um it's you know maybe it's one of my weaknesses but nevertheless this is something that really grinds my gears”

0.19

An Australian biohacker spent $700,000 on follistatin gene therapy and other treatments in Mexico in pursuit of biological life extension.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Peter Attia

“we heard about this guy who's you know obsessed with you know biohacking his way into you know immortality uh I think he's Australian I don't even know the details of this guy but he went to Mexico to do gene therapy using you know FIS Statin and a few other things and he spent 700,000 to do this”

0.17

The speaker's wife pointed out that the speaker sounds contemptuous when discussing biohacking and suggested the speaker be nicer about the topic.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Peter Attia

“my wife has pointed out to me she's like you really sound like an when you talk about this like you're total and utter contempt for the field of biohacking just exudes out of your pores you should really try to be a little bit nicer”

0.13

The speaker was asked in a documentary interview whether biohacking providers are frauds and clarified that this is the wrong question to ask.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Peter Attia

“in this particular interview the person even asked me do you think that these that these these people are frauds and I said it's it's that's the wrong question”