
Thomas McCraw on Schumpeter, Innovation, and Creative Destruction 10/8/2007
What this covers
Russ Roberts talks with Thomas McCraw, author of a biography of Schumpeter, about the man and his ideas. The biographical thread covers Schumpeter's outsider status, with about thirty moves across five countries, his failure as Austrian finance minister during the 1919 hyperinflation, and his refusal to write for a general audience. McCraw places him within the Austrian School but nearer to Böhm-Bawerk than to Ludwig von Mises or Hayek, and he reads Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy as a subtler, disguised cousin of The Road to Serfdom.
The conceptual middle covers the difference between invention vs innovation, illustrated by Leonardo's flying machine against Arkwright, Watt, and Wedgwood. It also covers the entrepreneur as someone driven by the game rather than money, and a comparison of Ford and Alfred Sloan. McCraw also raises limits to the evolutionary analogy, since Gresham's law shows worse things displacing better. Schumpeter's view of firms as vulnerable is set against John Kenneth Galbraith's picture of immortal corporations, with Gimbel's and Pan Am as evidence. The contested material is Schumpeter's defense of the robber barons and his tolerance of monopoly and oligopoly. Roberts ties the "seen" gains of bigness to Bastiat's unseen ones, and McCraw cites long-run growth in GDP per capita.
The talk then turns to the present. McCraw blames static textbook diagrams, and Roberts blames game-theoretic business strategy, for crowding out institutional detail. McCraw ties the Long-Term Capital Management collapse to models that omit unprecedented events, and he brings in Taleb. Roberts disputes the idea that American manufacturing has been hollowed out, while McCraw describes the postwar "free ride" ending under Japanese and Chinese competition.
McCraw argues that Joseph Schumpeter's dynamic, evolutionary view of capitalism, in which creative destruction drives long-run progress, is the crucial insight that modern economics has lost through its narrow focus on static, mathematical models.
- Economic analysis at a single point in time misleads; time must be put back into the analysis
- Competition works as a process of innovation that displaces incumbents, and the average person is its main beneficiary
- Economics' drift toward formalism and narrow technique has pushed out history, institutional detail, and business practice
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Schumpeter distinguished invention from innovation: an invention is an idea that never becomes economically useful, while innovation requires organizing a company or partnership to bring the new thing to market, and the timing must be right.
“one that comes across people who invent things but nothing ever becomes of them of either the thing or the inventor”
Creative destruction means capitalism is an evolutionary process in which one thing drives out another as surely as night follows day: the Model T made the buggy whip obsolete, and the corporation drove out the partnership and sole proprietorship as the dominant organizational form.
“back to the capitalism is an evolutionary process one thing is going to drive out another thing just as sure as night is going to follow day”
Economists often focus on what is seen, such as a large corporation making money, and ignore the unseen benefits of competition and innovation over time, which leads them to judge bigness as harmful in the moment; this mirrors Bastiat's seen and unseen.
“harken to to BA Scott's idea of the seen and the unseen it what is seen as a giant corporation that's it seems to have very little competition”
Financial crises such as the collapse of Long-Term Capital Management happen because models omit events that never happened before, such as the Russian default, which were not factored into the equations; Nassim Taleb's view is that such blindness is common.
“something that happened that had never before happened I either default at the Russian bond which wasn't factored into the thousands of equations go into that model”
Schumpeter's 'Queen Elizabeth on silk stockings' passage argues that the capitalist achievement is not providing more luxuries to the rich but bringing them within reach of factory girls in return for steadily decreasing effort, which is the real measure of capitalism's benefit to the average person.
“the capitalist achievement does not typically consist in providing more silk stockings for Queens but in bringing them within the reach of factory girls in return for steadily decreasing amounts of effort”
Judging capitalism requires looking across time: news is dominated by bad news, but over long periods GDP per capita for the average American is roughly 20 times its 1800 level and six to eight times its 1900 level, which reflects creative destruction at work.
“if you take the GDP per capita today for the average American it's 20 times what it was in 1800 it's about six or eight times what it was in 1900”
Schumpeter's defense of capitalism rested on the claim that competition is a process, not a static state; judging bigness as dangerous at a point in time is wrong, and monopolies or oligopolies are acceptable because innovation destroys monopoly power over time.
“he rejected monopolies ejected the economist textbook of perfect competition he embraced the idea of what's sometimes called monopolistic competition or oligopoly”
Schumpeter diverged from John Kenneth Galbraith, who believed the modern corporation was effectively immortal; history shows large companies such as Gimbel's and Pan Am failed, which supports Schumpeter's view that dominant firms remain vulnerable.
“this is a where he diverges from state Galbraith who who believed that the modern corporation was truly immortal that it you know could not fail and we know now that it can't fail in that many have failed”
Schumpeter was an Austrian economist but not in the emphatic anti-government-intervention mode of Mises or Hayek; he was more like Böhm-Bawerk, and was not primarily a policy-oriented economist but a pure academic who valued understanding how things work over any end in itself.
“Shem Pater was an Austrian but he was not an Austrian economist in the way that Mises or who was Hayek's teacher or Hayek was”
Schumpeter's defense of the 1880s-1900s robber barons: large firms often had the lowest prices and largest outputs, serving the most people, so the common view that bigness harms consumers is wrong.
“as he pointed out the largest firms often had the lowest prices the the largest outputs serving the greatest number of people”
Invention and innovation are different: inventions like Leonardo da Vinci's flying machine can fail because the time was not right, while entrepreneurs such as Arkwright, Cartwright, Watt, and Wedgwood succeeded by bringing new methods to market during the Industrial Revolution.
“Leonardo da Vinci had all these great ideas including things about how to flag how to do artificial flight that is an airplane nothing comes out of it doesn't mean da Vinci wasn't a entrepreneur just means that the time wasn't right”
The evolutionary analogy for creative destruction is useful but limited: evolution and creative destruction are not constant ascents to better things, since worse things can drive out better ones, as in Gresham's law where bad money drives out good.
“sometimes worse things can trash out things isn't as in finance and Gresham's law you can print bad money and it'll drive out good money”
Business strategy in business schools is often taught as a branch of game theory, which strips out institutional and industrial detail; Schumpeter would likely have seen this as a step in the right direction that became an end in itself, where elegance replaces applicability.
“the way business strategy is often taught in business schools today is as a branch of game theory”
Schumpeter believed the destructive side of creative destruction comes from the loss of entrepreneurial obsession: a successful business run with thrift and wisdom is eventually overtaken by someone still obsessed with the product, and family businesses decline as heirs lose the drive.
“if you lose the obsession which everybody does you're going to lose out Shiva Vader said that you know if someone built a successful business and then just continues to run it with thrift and wisdom”
US capitalism enjoyed a 'free ride' from about 1943 to the early 1970s, when US productivity was two to three times that of other advanced industrial nations, and the postwar period of dominance produced a wave of writing by Galbraith and others that assumed American capitalism had no rivals.
“from about 1943 until the early 70s the United States had a sort of freeride its productivity was twice three times that of even other advanced industrialized nations”
Roberts argues that US manufacturing output is still growing and highly competitive, and the decline in manufacturing employment reflects relentless productivity-driven innovation in production rather than the hollowing out of manufacturing.
“I don't think our manufacturing activities being hollowed out it is a but it is incredibly competitive manufacturing output is still growing”
Schumpeter's central irony was that he refused to popularize his ideas, writing for the intellectual elect rather than general readers, and he also failed as Austrian finance minister in 1919 during hyperinflation, which limited his influence and renown.
“he never wanted to be a popularizer he did not he wanted to write for the elect”
Schumpeter's 1942 Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy and Hayek's 1944 Road to Serfdom share the same basic message, but Hayek wrote for a general audience with a polemic aimed at fascist planning, while Schumpeter wrote a subtle, disguised polemic against socialism, aimed at a more sophisticated readership, that forces socialists to read it.
“the messages of the two books are pretty much exactly the same but the methods are quite different Hayek writes for the average reader”
Henry Ford is widely credited as the great entrepreneur in polls of entrepreneurs, but Alfred Sloan of General Motors arguably did more to organize and build a lasting business, and Ford was more inventor than entrepreneur.
“we glorify Henry Ford and we forget Alfred Sloan who just beat the pants off for in this great epic battle of the 1920s between Ford and General Motors”
Static economic theory, such as the textbook supply and demand diagram, is the most dangerous thing undergraduates can be shown, because it shows gains from trade at a point in time without the dynamic process of profits drawing competition that changes the market over time.
“I think that's the most dangerous thing that we can potentially do to our students as undergraduates or graduate sizz to show them a static supply and demand diagram”
Schumpeter's background in Vienna and his outsider status, having moved about 30 times and lived in five countries, gave him the vantage of a Martian observer who saw capitalism freshly and was not at home in either Europe or America.
“he was not at home anywhere he really straddled the two worlds of Europe and America without being at home in either I think this outsider status was a key to his understanding”
Competition from Japan in automobiles and consumer electronics ended the American free ride, and globalization means no company is safe in any industry; China's competition is driven by more than low wages, which is why no one in American business sleeps well.
“then comes the Japanese invasion in automobiles consumer electronics and a couple of other things and so that now you know in other words the sort of preview of globalization now no company is safe in a industry”
Schumpeter's central insight is that time is the major variable in economics: the proper object of analysis is X plus Y where Y is time, or X times Y, because looking at a single moment is like judging New England by one July day or the Titanic by its appearance at the quay.
“you absolutely have to put put the dimension of time back into economic analysis you can't judge the fate of the Titanic by how it looks on the Bund”
Schumpeter's book was a disguised polemic, targeting the Soviet Union as the closest thing to a socialist economy, written at a level that forces socialists to read it and then dismantles socialism so skillfully that socialists themselves may not see how it was done.
“it's a sort of disguised polemic it's a polemic that that forces people who are socialists to read the book and then proceeds to eviscerate socialism”
Schumpeter's entrepreneur was not primarily motivated by money but by the fun of doing it and winning, resembling a sports figure such as Tiger Woods or Michael Jordan, with a compulsion to see a vision stamped on the world.
“it was a particular psychological type who was not in it primarily for the money but just for the fun of doing it and of winning almost like a sports figure”
Large companies try to sustain entrepreneurial fever, and the vulnerability of large firms is often misunderstood, because size makes this drive much harder to maintain; Bill Gates reportedly worried about not making payroll as a way to keep the fire burning.
“Bill Gates supposedly goes to bed at night least he claims worrying that they're not going to make payroll that week”
Entrepreneurship is increasingly a team function rather than a solo act: once a company grows, it requires teams combining technical and organizational talent, exemplified by Intel's founders Robert Noyce and Andy Grove and Microsoft's Gates and Paul Allen.
“the champaner and his lifetime pretty late in life began to see entrepreneurship as a function rather than the product of an individual”
Schumpeter's Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy (1942) defends capitalism at a time when top-down planning seemed inevitable, paralleling Hayek's The Road to Serfdom, so Schumpeter returns at the end of his career to his Austrian roots in seeing economics as an organic process.
“his call to capitalism's defense in the face of the trend is reminiscent of hi X Road to Serfdom”
Schumpeter understood business as a competitive movement among oligopolists who are all vulnerable to extinction, not as an infinite number of firms with perfect information in a perfect-competition model.
“I do think he thought of business as a as a kind of competitive movement not of an infinite number of players all with perfect information and in a sort of perfect competition model but as as oligopolists moving encounter moving and all vulnerable to extinction”
Americans tend to romanticize the inventor and the solitary genius while disdaining the innovator who commercializes an idea, even though the innovator, like Bill Gates bringing computers to every American desktop, does much of the value creation.
“we have a romance about the inventor the genius and we we look at with a little bit of disdain at the innovator who who merely profits from bringing the thing into the into the world”
Historians and economists have dropped economic history and the history of economic thought from curricula, because graduate training has become narrower and more technical, and that loss is a mistake because the baby is being thrown out with the bathwater.
“what gets dropped is the history of economic thought economic history itself”
Economics graduate and undergraduate curricula have become narrower and more technical, requiring more training and technique, which pushed out the history of economic thought and economic history; McCraw thinks this is part of why most economists did not see Schumpeter's dynamic insights.
“the way that the undergraduate and especially graduate curricula and economics and not just economics but many other disciplines as well have become narrower and narrower”
Schumpeter believed economists should understand accounting, and he was frustrated that most economists could not prepare a balance sheet or income statement, arguing throughout his career for reuniting economics with practical business knowledge so it would not drift into abstract matrix algebra and calculus.
“he thought everyone should know accounting and hila mented the fact that most economists seemed to know very little about business almost none knew how to prepare balance sheet or an income statement”
Schumpeter's exceptional memory and his capacity to make connections across fields (the 'only connect' ability) was a key to his greatness as an economist and social scientist.
“Shem Peter was able to connect things that is to see relationships between things that other people could not see”
Schumpeter was a paradox: he was a strong advocate of mathematical formalism in economics, yet he worried that the field's emphasis on mathematics would exclude the institutional, historical, and business knowledge he valued, and McCraw thinks he would be disconcerted by today's mathematical narrowness.
“Shem Pater today would be a little bit disconcerted by the emphasis on mathematics to the exclusion of these other things”
Hayek avoided writing about the Soviet Union in The Road to Serfdom in 1944 because the USSR was critical to Britain's survival as its chief ally on the Eastern Front and had intellectual glamour for American intellectuals.
“I didn't want to alienate my audience because in 1944 the Soviet Union was critical to the survival of Britain”
Schumpeter moved his household about 30 times over 55 years across several countries (including England, Austria, Germany, Czech lands, Egypt, Ukraine, and the United States), whereas Keynes stayed within a Cambridge and Bloomsbury circle, so Keynes's view was distinctly English.
“he moved his household about 30 times in and is in his lifetime”
Schumpeter was a founder-level figure of the Econometric Society, and his 1933 lead article in its first issue argued that a quantitative element was needed to move economics forward without denouncing or squeezing out other approaches, though McCraw argues the pendulum has since swung all the way toward mathematics.
“he said we're no school we we don't we're not trying to denounce anybody we're not trying to squeeze out anybody”
The roughly fifty pages of Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy (chapters six to eight) are the greatest brief analysis of capitalism ever written, capturing both its positive and negative aspects.
“my judgment is the greatest brief analysis of capitalism ever written by anybody”
Schumpeter's 1932 move to a full professorship at Harvard placed him in a generation of mathematical economists, such as Samuelson and James Tobin, while he remained Austrian at heart, treating capitalism as an evolutionary organism that cannot be fully modeled formally.
“his most influential book is about CAPA as an organism as a biological evolutionary organism that that can't be modeled formally”
Schumpeter coined the term 'business strategy' in the sense now used in business schools, drawing on military strategy, though earlier uses of the phrase exist, with the earliest McCraw found dating to 1908 by a labor economist.
“the earliest use I've been able to find of the phrase business strategy is in 1908 by a labor economist”
Schumpeter's shift in his economic thought was shaped by his Vienna seminar classmates, who included Mises, Otto Bauer, Rudolf Hilferding, and Emil Lederer, with Schumpeter's group of brilliant contemporaries ranging from socialist to free-market thinkers.
“Shem Peter is a classmate of Mises but also of these Marxists in a very famous seminar run bapon Bob Eric”
Unemployment in the United States fell from 17.2 percent in 1939 to 1.2 percent in 1944 during wartime mobilization, a swing McCraw cites to show how extreme conditions shape economic narratives.
“in 1939 employment unemployment rate in the United States was 17.2% 1944 it's 1.2 percent”
Creative destruction is an oxymoron that expresses two opposing ideas in one phrase, yet it has become a widely used metaphor across architecture, history, and literature, second only to the invisible hand in economics.
“it's an oxymoron creative destruction it expresses two opposing ideas in one phrase”
In 1942 capitalism was under severe threat: fascism held power in Europe and Japan, communism had triumphed in Russia and China, and by 1950 perhaps 40 to 50 percent of the world lived under communist or near-communist regimes while capitalism covered maybe 30 percent.
“something like 40 or 50 percent of the world was under either either a pure communist regime or something close to it and capitalism was maybe 30%”
Constant change in consumer technology, such as the path of music from vinyl to CDs to iPods to MP3s, illustrates a process of evolution driven by competition that nobody predicted twenty years earlier.
“who on earth would have predicted the you know successes or ah manifestations of or the various ways in which music is listened to”
Successive technologies illustrate creative destruction: the steel plow drove out the wooden plow, the harvester drove out the thresher, the automobile drove out the horse-and-buggy, and air travel drove out train travel in the US because of the country's size.
“a steel plow drove out a wooden plow a harvester drove out a thresher the automobile drove out the horse-and-buggy”
The tradeoff is that scholars cannot all be dilettantes, since they would end up knowing everything about nothing rather than nothing about everything, so each person must choose a balance between depth and breadth.
“we can't all be dilettante you know or you end up knowing everything about nothing instead of nothing about everything”
Schumpeter wrote roughly three million words in German and two million in English, equivalent to about 50 books, which made his biography take six years instead of four.
“he wrote about three million words in chairman about two million in English”
Today most people on earth live under capitalist regimes for the first time in history, including authoritarian ones like China and Russia, while during Schumpeter's time the tide of history ran against capitalism.
“for the first time in history most people on earth live under capitalist regimes of one type or another”
Doug North's insistence on putting time back into economics, and his view of economics as an evolutionary process rooted in Schumpeter's theory, reflects a recent movement against static analysis, though this movement is not dominant.
“there's the Doug north healthy insistence on putting time back in Sochi hater context thought of economics is an evolutionary process”
Bill Gates and Michael Dell dropped out of graduate school because they believed the window of opportunity would pass if they stayed, and their results show the importance of acting at the right moment.
“Michael Dell and Bill Gates dropped out of to graduate school because they thought that if they stayed in the moment would pass by”
Schumpeter's influence on the Austrian school is complicated: despite his Austrian roots he stands apart from Hayek and Mises, though his focus on entrepreneurship places him close to the Austrian tradition, and McCraw says he once argued at an NYU Austrian economics seminar that Mises was not a free-market fundamentalist in 1905.
“Mises was a free-market fundamentalist and champagne or was a kind of agnostic and these other other three guys were pretty confirmed socialist”
Ralph Galbraith's books had a self-congratulatory rhetoric that flatters readers as smarter than everybody else, making them admirable as writing but hollow in substance, a 'no there there' quality.
“you wonder you know how much there is there as a Gertrude Stein sort of Oakland California you know you get there and there's no there there”
Galbraith's rhetoric forms a bond with the reader by flattering them ('you and I are smarter than everybody else') with a sneering attitude, and beneath the elegant prose there is little substance, so Galbraith is not comparable to Schumpeter.
“gallery forms a bond with the reader and then too and it's you know you and I are smarter than everybody else”
Economics embarked on a long period of mathematical narrowness after Schumpeter's era, but in recent years behavioral economics and psychology have broadened the discipline back toward the interdisciplinary approach Schumpeter favored.
“economics embarked on a long mathematical narrowness really and yet today economists are increasingly interested in psychology and the so called behavioral economics”
The pace of economic transformation is faster now than ever before; Schumpeter would have been bewildered by it, and history is accelerating in a relentless way that makes it hard for today's generations to keep up.
“the pace of that transformation is faster now than ever and that it must it would have bewildered he must have thought it was fast then”
Schumpeter's Vienna seminar classmates included Mises, Otto Bauer, Rudolf Hilferding, and Emil Lederer, with Schumpeter and Mises less committed to free markets than Mises was later portrayed; McCraw's claim that Mises was a free-market fundamentalist then was unsupported by evidence.
“do you have any evidence that Mises was and he was a free-market fundamentalist at this time”
Business strategy books that recommend Sun Tzu's The Art of War miss the point of Schumpeter's use of military analogy, because Schumpeter viewed business as a competitive movement among oligopolists rather than a battle to be won by tactics.
“you get these one minute manager type business how-to books that all recommend Sun Tzu's the art of war”
Historical memory has faded of the time when the very existence of democratic capitalism was under mortal threat, which makes Schumpeter's defense of capitalism look less urgent than it was.
“our historical memory is just sort of sort of gone of a time when the very existence of democratic capitalism was was under mortal threat”
Graduate economics students want to learn last night's problem set rather than the history of economic thought, and finance attracts the smartest students, which made the graduate seminar McCraw taught for about 25 years steadily more technical.
“they didn't want to know about the past they wanted to know about last night's problem sets”
Economics is both imperialistic toward other social sciences and the most self-critical of the social sciences, with many leading economists now saying the discipline is too narrow and too mathematized and needs to broaden itself.
“it is I think as as many people have said imperialistic toward the other social sciences but it's also the most self-critical of the social sciences”
The internet is the biggest leap forward in business history McCraw can think of, despite its harms; Schumpeter would have been ecstatic about it, and it is only the beginning.
“heaven knows it's the it's the biggest leap forward that I can think of in in business history and we're just getting started”
The current formalism in economics is driven by incentives that could change, so the pendulum may swing back toward a broader discipline over time.
“the incentives are all pushing in that direction but those incentives can change”
Graduate economics students increasingly want technical skills and finance careers rather than the history of the discipline, so McCraw is not optimistic that a broader worldview will return to economics despite George Mason hiring three economic historians.
“I taught a seminar that was required of economics graduate students for about twenty five years”
Schumpeter's view of economic life as a process rather than a static state is what Austrian school thinkers emphasized, making the Austrian tradition thriving today because it understands economics as an organic experience.
“to the extent it's it's thriving is about economics as a process and as an organic experience rather than a static one”
Schumpeter's two-volume Business Cycles is prolix, and it would likely have had more impact as separate books, reflecting a style inherited from grand European social theorists such as Comte and Mill.
“would have been better off as separate books probably would have had a bigger impact”
Schumpeter's writing in Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy is extraordinarily subtle, metaphor-rich, and wide-ranging, and McCraw was struck by it as an undergraduate, which led to his long engagement with Schumpeter.
“I was struck by the subtlety of his writing his after use of metaphors his extraordinary knowledge of seemingly everything from ancient times to the present”
Thanks for listening and the sound engineer credit at the end of the episode are procedural sign-offs.
“thanks for listening talk to you on Monday”