
JPY weakness implications for markets; Could gold drop to $1800? (yes IMO)
What this covers
This is a 15-minute solo talk by Luke Graham of FFTT, built around the yen's weakness and what it implies for Treasuries, the dollar, oil and gold. He argues that the yen keeps falling as long as U.S. deficits are large, the Fed is not monetizing them, and oil is rising, because Japan then sells Treasuries and repatriates capital. Foreign central banks are described as simultaneously short oil and short dollars, selling Treasuries to defend their currencies and buy energy rather than trading for profit.
The core of the argument rests on the net international investment position (NIIP)), which he puts at negative 70% of GDP, against a range of positive 10% to negative 20% from 1976 to 2012. He lays out a pro-cyclical feedback loop in which a stronger dollar, higher yields, foreign selling and bigger deficits reinforce each other. He adds that shale producers will cut output first as rates rise, which adds a stagflationary push. He calls the U.S. already in fiscal dominance, and says the only brakes are QE) or yield curve control. He is dismissive of ordinary rate-cycle comparisons and points instead to Argentina and Brazil in the 1980s and 1990s, with the extremity tempered.
The talk then turns to markets and gold. Graham says investors buying TLT) are catching a falling knife and should wait. He also flags leveraged hedge funds as the biggest recent marginal Treasury buyers, who face margin pressure if markets move against them. On gold, he allows that it could fall to $1,800 before either treasury market dysfunction forces the Fed back into providing liquidity or the market starts pricing Western sovereign insolvency. A separate, more speculative thread covers Shanghai-versus-COMEX gold premiums. He ties these to yuan-priced commodities and to Russia's planned discounted gas sales to China, and argues they will slowly drain gold from the West. He also cautions that his unlevered, long-horizon positioning does not suit levered players or those with monthly mandates.
The speaker argues that the U.S. faces an unprecedented pro-cyclical debt spiral driven by massive deficits, negative net international investment position, and rising oil prices, creating a system with no brakes that will force the Fed to resume QE or face financial system collapse, making historical rate-hike comparisons misleading.
- The U.S. net international investment position is negative 70% of GDP (foreigners own $18 trillion more in U.S. assets than Americans own abroad), enabling continuous foreign selling of treasuries that will drive rates higher indefinitely
- Rising deficits combined with higher interest rates create a pro-cyclical feedback loop where rate increases expand deficits faster than they reduce them, trapping the Fed in fiscal dominance
- Past rate-hiking cycles are poor guides because they lacked the combination of this magnitude of negative NIIP, high U.S. debt, large deficits, and U.S. marginal oil production dependency
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
As rates go up, U.S. oil production (particularly shale) becomes price and interest-rate sensitive and will drop off first and fastest, creating stagflationary dynamics that feed back into the pro-cyclical spiral of rates up and dollar up
“and then the other side of it is that as rates go up U.S oil production is ultimately a price and interest rate sensitive and will drop off first and fastest and ultimately U.S oil production on the Shale side will after an initial period where it falls uh less fast than demand it will eventually fall faster than oil demand does even in a recession um and that leads to a very stagflationary Dynamic which then leads to feeding back [13:10] into what I just described rates up dollar up foreign selling”
As long as U.S. deficits are large, the Fed is not monetizing them (either directly or indirectly via the banking system or treasuries), and oil prices are rising, the Japanese yen will continue declining because Japan will sell treasuries and repatriate capital from U.S. dollar assets
“as long as U.S deficits uh are as big as they are as long as the FED is not monetizing them either directly or indirectly via the banking system or treasuries running down TGA or the different ways of dollar liquidity being injected to absorb those uh and as long as oil prices are rising uh the answer in my answer in terms of the yen is it's going lower uh they'll sell treasuries [1:40] uh and repatriate Japanese capital from abroad heavily U.S dollar assets in all likelihood um and that's going to keep the dollar up”
The only brakes on foreign selling and the dollar-up/rates-up spiral are Fed and Treasury weakening the dollar by resuming QE or yield curve control, which is critical for people to understand
“the brakes are the fed and the treasury weakening the dollar resuming QE whatever you want to call it um I still like I said I still don't think this last part this net International Investment position size differential is understood by enough people because if it was people wouldn't be falling all over themselves to try to back TLT”
When the Fed sells bonds on top of Treasury, it leads to a dollar squeeze that drives dollar up and rates up until the system comes unhinged, which is another indicator that the U.S. is in fiscal dominance
“um and so the debt and the entitlements are so big and the economy is so financialized that higher rates sends expenses up and deficits up rapidly and receipts down rapidly so basically it just means the fed's no longer in charge of inflation the fiscal deficit is the fed's just making it worse by raising rates so that is the issue now critically when the FED is selling Bonds on top of Treasury to do this it leads to this dollar squeeze which is going to drive dollar up rates up until the system uh comes unhinged and that's [11:03] another way you can tell we're in fiscal dominance is the deficits are so big they're crowding everything else out”
The combination of negative NIIP, high debt, large deficit-to-GDP, and U.S. marginal oil production creates a pro-cyclical dynamic with no brakes: dollar up → treasury yields up → foreign selling → interest rates up → deficit up → more issuance → treasuries sell more → dollar goes up → Fed sells more → foreigners sell more
“why is that the case the net International Investment position I just described the debt the GDP the deficit the GDP it means you're going to get this Pro cyclical Dynamic um that has no brakes on it dollar up treasury yields up foreign selling interest rates up deficit up more issuance up treasury sells more dollar goes up more fed sells more foreigners [12:37] sell more and there's there's just no breaks on it”
There are no structural brakes on the current dollar-up and rates-up spiral unless the dollar and oil are weakened markedly, which would require renewed QE, yield curve control, or equivalent U.S. policy intervention
“for me the key is that there's really no breaks on this train um unless the dollar and oil are weakened markedly I think that's the key”
Central banks trade to manage domestic currencies and economies and for political reasons, not to maximize profits, so foreign nation treasuries sales are driven by the need to defend currencies and buy energy, not by profit-taking on rate expectations
“central banks don't trade to maximize profits they already have a printing press they literally can print money if they wanted to so that's not they don't they don't uh in act in markets to try to maximize profits like most private sector actors would they man they they trade to manage their domestic currencies and their domestic economies and for political reasons so uh they're selling these these treasuries to support the currencies and to buy oil”
Fiscal dominance means the Fed cannot raise rates without putting the U.S. government into a situation that requires the Fed to print money to prevent default on entitlements, defense, or interest payments (the big three items that cannot be cut)
“fiscal dominance um to simplify or oversimplify is that the FED cannot raise rates without putting the US government into a situation that requires the FED to print money in order to prevent default on entitlements defense or interest which are the big three things you can't cut”
The U.S. already exists in fiscal dominance where the debt and entitlements are so large and the economy so financialized that higher rates send expenses and deficits up rapidly while receipts drop, meaning the Fed no longer controls inflation—the fiscal deficit does—and the Fed's rate increases make it worse
“and we're there and we've been there [10:31] um and so the debt and the entitlements are so big and the economy is so financialized that higher rates sends expenses up and deficits up rapidly and receipts down rapidly so basically it just means the fed's no longer in charge of inflation the fiscal deficit is the fed's just making it worse by raising rates”
The fact that deficits are crowding everything else out is evidence of fiscal dominance—if it weren't the case, market participants would not be seeing the dollar and rate dynamics currently observed to this extent
“if that wasn't the case we wouldn't we wouldn't be seeing um what we're seeing in markets in terms of dollar in rates certainly to the extent we're seeing it”
The pro-cyclical dynamics in an over-leveraged system mean that the biggest marginal buyer of treasuries in recent months (highly leveraged hedge funds) will face margin pressure if markets move against them, further destabilizing the system
“and there's there's just no breaks on it and then the other side of it is that as rates go up U.S oil production is ultimately a price and interest rate sensitive and will drop off first and fastest and ultimately U.S oil production on the Shale side will after an initial period where it falls uh less fast than demand it will eventually fall faster than oil demand does even in a recession um and that leads to a very stagflationary Dynamic which then leads to feeding back [13:10] into what I just described rates up dollar up foreign selling so so there's just this very very all those factors when you combine them together lead to a very Pro cyclical Dynamic into an over levered system where the biggest marginal buyer treasuries in recent months have been highly levered hedge funds Joseph Wong on Twitter has done some really good work on that former New York fed Trader um in recent weeks I'd take a look at that”
The U.S. net international investment position is negative 70% of GDP, meaning foreigners own $18 trillion more in U.S. assets than Americans own abroad, whereas from 1976 to 2012 it was positive 10% to negative 20%, giving foreigners a much smaller reserve of dollar assets to draw down before forced currency devaluation
“now the U.S net International Investment position is negative 70 percent seven zero percent of U.S GDP which means foreigners own 18 trillion dollars more in U.S assets than we own of theirs from 1976 to 2012 the U.S net International Investment position was positive 10 of U.S GDP to negative 20 U.S GDP which meant foreigners had a small piggy bank they could sell down”
Gold premiums in Shanghai versus COMEX represent the fact that gold buys more energy in China than in the West, which would be economically irrelevant if oil and gas were not priced in yuan, but because 25-30% of global net exports can now be bought in yuan, this creates a real arbitrage stimulus
“to oversimplify it means gold buys more energy in China than it does in the West uh this would not matter if oil and gas were not priced in Yuan if they were only priced in dollars still however they are priced anyone the Russians are selling in that the Iranians the [7:57] Venezuelans a good 25 30 of global net exports can be bought in you on now that changes everything it sets up an organic Arbitrage where uh it's a real stimulus”
The organic arbitrage of cheaper energy in China via yuan-priced commodities and gold will slowly tighten like a noose, draining gold from the West and pulling energy and growth toward China, which will allow China to out-compete Europe and to a lesser extent the U.S. until the U.S. lets gold rise
“it's a it's a it's an organic economic stimulus slash Arbitrage [9:29] that will be like a slowly tightening noose it'll just slowly drain gold from the west and it'll slowly pull more energy toward China which will slowly allow China to out-compete Europe and to a lesser extent the US until the U.S lets cold rise that's that's what's being set up here in my view”
Many market participants are not factoring in the negative NIIP into their analysis, which is why they have been trying to catch the falling knife on TLT (long-duration treasuries) and getting their heads kicked in
“it's why so many have been trying to catch the falling knife on TLT and getting their heads kicked in which is historically that's how it worked [5:51] foreigners sell down dollar assets they run out and then they have to devalue their currencies restart the game uh now the U.S net International Investment position is negative 70 percent”
If a reader is a levered player or has a monthly mandate (institutional constraints), they should adopt a different investment approach than Graham's long-term unlevered endgame positioning
“take that based on your own personal positioning uh from Edward doesn't it make sense to sell treasuries as a foreign Nation when they knew rates would rise I asked this because you mentioned them dumping them but this makes perfect sense they'll rebuy the [4:49] treasuries when the rate hike hiking cycle”
The key question the audience should be asking but isn't is: why does the net international investment position of the U.S. matter so much for rate cycle analysis
“what's the question you think your audience should be asking but isn't um I would say why does the net International I did a tweet last week I actually got a ton of uh a ton of interaction a ton of views [11:35] highlighting that I I take any rate cycle analysis looking at the last six or seven rate hiking Cycles and unless they attach the caveat that none of those rate Cycles have had the net International Investment position of the US this negative”
Any rate cycle analysis that lacks the caveat that none of previous rate-hiking cycles have had U.S. net international investment position this negative, U.S. debt this high, U.S. deficit-to-GDP this high, or the U.S. as the world's biggest marginal high-cost oil producer should be ignored
“I take any rate cycle analysis looking at the last six or seven rate hiking Cycles and unless they attach the caveat that none of those rate Cycles have had the net International Investment position of the US this negative they've never had U.S debt this High they've never had U.S deficit the GDP this High and the US has never been the world's biggest marginal high-cost energy producer oil producer um if they don't have those caveats I I [12:06] basically ignore that analysis because it's going to be Flying Blind”
Historical rate-hiking cycles in the United States provide misleading guidance; instead, rate-hiking cycles in Argentina and Brazil in the 1980s and 1990s are more instructive for understanding directional implications, though should be tempered in extremity
“it's really important to understand that looking at the last six seven rate hiking Cycles in the United States for guidance is going to lead you to the wrong conclusion um you need to probably be looking at rate hiking Cycles in Argentina and Brazil uh over and call it in the 80s and 90s and kind of tamping down the extremity of the outcomes but in terms of the directional [14:14] implications they have probably they're probably of more use”
Foreigners will continue selling U.S. dollar assets and treasuries, driving rates and dollar higher, and will break treasury markets, housing markets, U.S. banks, global banks, and the global economic system before they run out of dollar assets to sell
“now they've got a gigantic Vault of dollar assets and they will sell and they'll keep selling and they will send rates Higher and Higher and the dollar Higher and Higher and they will break treasury markets they will break you as housing markets they will break U.S banks they will break Global Banks they will break the global economy they'll break global system before they run out of dollar assets to sell”
Foreign central banks are simultaneously short oil and short dollars, so they are selling treasuries (dollars) and buying both oil and other hard assets to defend their currencies and secure energy supplies
“they're short oil they're short dollars they're selling treasuries they buy both uh they'll keep selling uh as long as the dollar Rises they have to keep selling”
Cheaper energy acts as stimulus (equivalent to giving a region like New England half-price gas and heating oil), so Russia's announced plan to sell gas to China at half the Europe price from January through 2026 will enable gold to buy far more gas in China than in the West
“what if I gave New [8:29] England for this winter half price gas and heating oil that would be a huge stimulus for the northeastern economy people would go out and they'd have a lot more money to spend on Christmas gifts China's effectively getting that not quite as dramatic in terms of the premium and it's not going to be all right away but particularly if Russia goes through with what they said they're going to do which is sell gas to China at Half Price relative to Europe beginning in January to last for three years through 2026 Gold's gonna buy a whole heck of a lot [8:59] more gas in China than it does in the west”
Gold could decline to $1,800 in the near term if the treasury rate-up feedback loop continues to drive rates higher before either (1) treasury market dysfunction forces the Fed back into supply liquidity or (2) the market determines that Western sovereign insolvency risk justifies buying gold at a much higher rate level
“from John do you feel gold will drop to 1800 ish before the rally near term uh yeah I could uh I wouldn't be surprised about that at all actually uh it depends on on two factors in my opinion number one when does the [3:14] treasury market dysfunction get bad enough to bring Federal treasury back into Supply liquidity and two if fed and treasury don't step in fast enough and let treasury or uh this treasury uh rates up dollar feedback loop keep driving rates up at what rate does the market begin to say the West is insolvent at a sovereign level at this rate buy me gold”
TLT inflows are still massive, but absent a change in fundamentals (dollar and oil weakness), there is just going to be more selling of U.S. dollar assets, so investors should stand aside and wait for a better level rather than catch the falling knife
“there's no breaks on this so uh the brakes are the fed and the treasury weakening the dollar resuming QE whatever you want to call it um I still like I said I still don't think this last part this net International Investment position size differential is understood by enough people because if it was people wouldn't be falling all over themselves to try to back TLT like I saw a tweet today that you know TLT inflows are still massive if nothing else you would stand aside see where its level is because there is just as long as a dollar in oil arising it's just going to be a lot more selling [7:26] to come of US dollar assets that's just how it is”
Luke Graham holds physical gold outside the banking system in regional vaults, is unlevered, and is playing for the endgame, whereas his approach would be different if he were a levered player or if he had a monthly mandate
“uh am I selling it no uh I own physical uh held out of the banking [4:17] system at vaults um uh in in the at cities in the region and I'm unlevered and I'm playing for the end game um I only need to be right once in my life so now I would be doing something different if I was a levered player or if I had a monthly mandate”
Tree Rings product shows the 10 most interesting things grabbing their analysis each week and whether they are confirming or denying prior views held, and what it might mean for various asset markets
“uh in the meantime also check us out fftt llc.com for what we're up to and more information about these updates if you like them you can check out tree rings uh 10 most interesting things what's [14:45] grabbing us about each thing and whether it's confirming or denying uh a a prior view we had held and what it might mean for various asset markets”
Graham has an upgrade cycle for their Tree Rings product this week that readers can learn more about via the link below, and can visit fftt llc.com for more information
“quick reminder that this week we do have uh uh upgrade cycle for our tree rings product there are bonuses you can learn more about it in the link below uh in the meantime also check us out fftt llc.com for what we're up to and more information about these updates”