
Canada is a Warning to the Rest of the World!
What this covers
The video opens in 2012, when Canada was the consensus "best of all worlds" economy: Gulf-state resources, a northern European safety net, and a housing market that only rose. It then works through what went wrong, starting with a productivity gap that is not about hours, since Canadians work about as much per capita as Americans. The argument is about where those hours go: real estate, public administration, retail, and finance. Canada also spends less than half the OECD average on research and development as a share of GDP, even though its AI research hubs in Montreal and Toronto are world class.
The middle of the piece covers the protected domestic economy. Bell, Rogers, and Telus hold roughly 89% of wireless subscribers, and five banks hold about 90% of deposits. The video calls this rent seeking and compares it to a sports league where the same few teams win every year. It also looks at internal trade barriers, which the IMF likens to a 6.9% tariff on domestic commerce. Elimination polls at 95% support, yet the barriers persist. Bell and its peers appear here as examples of captive-market pricing.
Housing gets the most sustained attention. The video argues that tax treatment and low interest rates made maximum-leverage property purchase the rational household choice. About two-thirds of households are owners, which gives most voters a stake in high prices. The video also notes that the TSX has outpaced Canadian housing. The generational cost shows up in the World Happiness Report, where under-25s rank 71st while over-60s rank in the top 10.
The last stretch turns to dependence on the US market. It covers oil sold at a discount for lack of tidewater access, and the Trans Mountain Pipeline, which cost about 34 billion CAD against an original 5.4 billion estimate but narrowed the discount. It closes on the "leaky bucket" of skilled immigrants and the youth brain drain.
Canada has squandered extraordinary natural and institutional endowments through decades of compounding policy errors—protected domestic monopolies, underinvestment in productivity, housing financialization, and over-reliance on the US market—creating a self-reinforcing stagnation that serves as a cautionary pattern visible across the developed world.
- Despite world-class resources and institutions, Canada's labor productivity has fallen 26 percentage points behind the US since 1997, driven by capital flowing into low-productivity real estate instead of innovation
- Domestic monopolies in telecom, banking, and aviation protected from competition reduce innovation incentives, while housing policy creates perverse tax and leverage incentives that lock capital out of productive investment
- Youth happiness has collapsed to 71st globally (below Afghanistan on decline rate), driven by housing prices at 12-17x median income, creating a generational wealth trap dependent on parental transfers or high income
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Approximately 66% of Canadian households own their own homes, meaning two-thirds of the electorate have a direct financial stake in keeping house prices high, creating a structural political obstacle to housing affordability reform
“Approximately 66% of Canadian households own their own homes, meaning that 2/3 of the electorate have a direct financial stake in keeping house prices high. A government that credibly committed to building sufficient new housing to return prices to something resembling affordability would be asking a majority of its voters to accept a substantial reduction in the value of their single largest asset.”
A rational economic choice for Canadian households with savings over the past 20 years has been to put as much money as possible into real estate as early as possible at as high leverage as banks allow, which is entirely logical response to the incentive structure created by tax treatment and low interest rates
“The incentive structure this creates is problematic. The rational economic choice for a Canadian household with savings has been for 20 years to put as much money as possible into real estate as early as possible at as high a leverage ratio as your bank will allow. This is not irrational behavior. It's an entirely logical response to the incentives that the system created. It is after all how everyone you know made most of their money.”
A country that does not invest in the production of new knowledge or new processes eventually finds that its workers are doing the same things in the same ways as a generation ago, which is roughly what has happened in Canada
“A country that doesn't invest in the production of new knowledge or new processes eventually finds that its workers are doing the same things in the same ways as a generation ago, which is roughly what has happened.”
Canada's three dominant telecommunications carriers—Bell, Rogers, and Telus—collectively hold roughly 89% of wireless subscribers, resulting in mobile phone bills roughly twice as high as in the UK or France
“Canada has three dominant carriers, Bell, Rogers, and Telus, who collectively hold roughly 89% of wireless subscribers. Canada has, as a result, some of the highest mobile phone bills in the developed world. A comparable unlimited data plan costs roughly twice as much in Canada as in the UK or France.”
Five Canadian banks—Royal Bank, TD, Scotiabank, BMO, and CIBC—hold approximately 90% of deposits in Canada, creating a concentrated banking sector that allocates capital conservatively toward proven assets and real estate rather than new ventures and startups
“Five Canadian banks, the Royal Bank, TD, Scotia Bank, and CIBC hold approximately 90% of deposits in the country. The Canadian banking system is by design highly stable. It didn't have a financial crisis in 2008 unlike most of the developed world. This is a genuine achievement and Canadian bankers will remind you of it at every available opportunity. But stability and dynamism are not the same thing. A concentrated banking sector allocates capital conservatively. It lends to proven assets, existing real estate, established corporations rather than to new ventures.”
Canada's hours worked per capita are broadly comparable to the United States, meaning Canada's productivity lag is not a story about working less but about where those hours have been directed—into lower-productivity sectors like real estate, public administration, retail, and financial services
“This is not a story about working less. Hours worked per Canadian are broadly comparable to those in the United States. It's a story about where those hours have been directed. The economy has channeled its investment, human, financial, and physical into sectors that produce lower output per unit of effort. Real estate, public administration, retail, and the financial sector that lends against bricks rather than ideas.”
Canada historically lacked sufficient tidewater export infrastructure to access Asian or European markets, selling oil at a consistent discount to global benchmark prices; the WCS-WTI discount was historically $15-20 per barrel, larger than quality differentials alone would justify, reflecting a transportation premium accruing to American Midwest refiners
“Because Canada has historically lacked sufficient tidewater export infrastructure to access Asian or European markets, it has sold oil at a consistent discount to the global benchmark price. WCS is a heavy sour crude, more expensive to refine than the lighter American benchmark, and some discount is structurally warranted. But the historical gap of $15 to $20 per barrel was consistently larger than the quality differential alone would justify. The excess reflects a transportation premium that acrewed not to Canada but to the American Midwest refiners who for decades were the only buyers with ready access.”
Eliminating Canada's internal trade barriers, which has the support of 95% of Canadians according to Angus Reid polling, could add between 90 billion and 200 billion per year to GDP according to various estimates, yet these barriers have persisted for decades despite being known as a problem
“Eliminating these barriers, which has the support of 95% of Canadians, according to polling by Angus Reed, could, according to various estimates, add between 90 billion and 200 billion per year to GDP. This has been known for decades, but the barriers remain.”
Canada's domestic economy in several important sectors has run an oligopolistic structure for 30 years, with protected incumbents in telecommunications, banking, airlines, groceries, and broadcasting extracting returns from a captive domestic market—an economist's term for this is rent seeking
“Canada's domestic economy has in several of its most important sectors been running this kind of league for 30 years. Take telecommunications. Canada has three dominant carriers, Bell, Rogers, and Telus, who collectively hold roughly 89% of wireless subscribers. Canada has, as a result, some of the highest mobile phone bills in the developed world. A comparable unlimited data plan costs roughly twice as much in Canada as in the UK or France. The Canadian Radio Television and Telecommunications Commission or the CRTC, which is what you'd call it if you'd like to get home before midnight, has for years been theoretically open to new entrance. But the practical and regulatory barriers have ensured that meaningful competition never quite materialized. The industry has spent lavishly on lobbying and regulatory intervention. It spends rather less on network investment per customer than its counterparts in more competitive markets. Banking tells a similar story.”
Housing price appreciation differs fundamentally from stock price appreciation: stocks reflect productive economic activity (products, services, patents, drugs, software), while housing appreciation results from land scarcity, planning restrictions, and capital seeking returns in low-interest environments—the house itself produces nothing
“A company when it rises in value has generally done so by producing something, a product, a service, a patent, a drug, a piece of software. The stock price reflects real economic activity, real production. A house, when it rises in value, has generally done so because land in a desirable location has become scarcer, because planning restrictions have constrained supply, or because a decade of historically low interest rates created a wall of capital seeking somewhere to go. The house didn't invent anything. It didn't employ a research team. It just sat there.”
A professional sports league where the same three or four teams win every year, protected by regulatory barriers and largest resources, experiences not just incumbent dominance but overall decline in quality of play because incumbent teams lack incentive to innovate or improve without genuine competitive pressure
“Consider a thought experiment. Imagine a professional sports league where the same three or four teams win every year. They have the largest stadiums, the biggest TV deals, and the most expensive players. The other teams are technically allowed to compete, but the rules of the game have been structured over the decades to make it very difficult for anyone new to enter. What tends to happen over time is not just that the incumbents win, it's that the whole quality of play declines. Without genuine competitive pressure, there's no incentive to innovate, to take risks, or to improve.”
Canada's brain drain of talented young people looking elsewhere for opportunity is explained by the housing and wealth inequality mechanisms, not by absolute economic failure but by structural disadvantage for new entrants.
“It also incidentally explains why the country's most talented young people increasingly looks out.”
In the 2026 World Happiness Report, Canadians over 60 rank in the global top 10 for happiness while Canadians under 25 rank 71st globally, below countries with a fraction of Canada's per capita income, a divergence reflecting the speed of Canada's decline and the disproportionate impact on youth
“Canada overall ranks 25th, which is a significant fall from sixth a decade ago, but still a respectable position for a country that is by any objective standard wealthy, peaceful, and well-governed. But when you break this down by age, the picture changes substantially. Canadians over 60 rank in the global top 10 for happiness. Canadians under 25 rank 71st. 71st below countries with a fraction of Canada's per capita income.”
Canada spends less than half the OECD average on research and development as a share of GDP, and this figure has been below the average for two consecutive decades
“Canada spends less than half the OECD average on research and development as a share of GDP, a figure that has been below the average for two decades running.”
Canada's AI research ecosystem centered on Montreal, Toronto, and the Vector Institute is genuinely worldclass; Jeffrey Hinton, Yosua Benjio, and Richard Sutton—three of the most consequential figures in modern AI development—did their foundational work in Canada
“Canada's AI research ecosystem centered on Montreal, Toronto, and the Vector Institute is genuinely worldclass. Jeffrey Hinton, Yosua Benjio, and Richard Sutton, three of the most consequential figures in the development of modern AI, all did their foundational work in Canada.”
In 2012, Canada was the global consensus 'best of all worlds' economy—it had natural resources of a Gulf state, the social safety net of a northern European country, and a housing market that seemed to only move upward.
“the global consensus on Canada was that it was the ultimate best of all worlds economy. It had the natural resources of a Gulf state, the social safety net of a northern European country, and a housing market that only seemed to move in one direction.”
Canada holds the third largest proven oil reserves globally, primarily in the Alberta oil sands, making energy one of the world's largest endowments, yet the United States is the overwhelmingly dominant customer.
“Canada holds the world's third largest proven oil reserves. The vast majority in the Alberta oil sands. The United States is the overwhelmingly dominant customer.”
For a very long time, Canada's economic concentration with the United States was a reasonable arrangement because the United States was a stable, rules-based market; the two countries shared a border, language, legal tradition, and broadly aligned foreign policy; and NAFTA and later USMCA provided a framework of predictability, so Canadian businesses rationally chose not to spend money developing Asian or European market access.
“This concentration was for a very long time a reasonable arrangement. The United States was a stable rules-based market. The two countries shared a border, a language, a legal tradition, and a broadly aligned foreign policy. NAFTA and later the USMCA provided a framework of predictability. Canadian businesses rationally chose not to spend money developing Asian or European market access when the American market was so large, so close, and so accessible.”
The problem with concentrating economic exposure to a single counterparty is dependency on that counterparty's goodwill and continuity of policy, a risk illustrated recently with emphasis by recent events.
“The problem with concentrating your economic exposure to a single counterparty is that you're entirely dependent on that counterparty's goodwill and continuity of policy. Recent events have illustrated this risk with some emphasis.”
The TSX composite stock index substantially outperformed Canadian housing on a straight price appreciation basis, and continues to outperform when dividends are reinvested, contradicting the common narrative that Canadian housing beats stocks
“Now, there's a common comparison made in conversations about Canadian housing that homes have outperformed the stock market over time. It's worth pausing on this. On a straight price appreciation basis, the TSX composite index actually outperformed Canadian housing over the same period and substantially so once dividends are reinvested.”
Canada's Conference Board characterized Canada's skilled immigration pattern as the 'leaky bucket problem'—Canada brings in large numbers of highly educated people but one in five skilled immigrants leaves within 25 years, with the highest attrition in the first 5 years when they are most economically mobile
“The conference board has called this the leaky bucket problem. Canada has one of the world's most generous immigration systems. It brings in large numbers of highly educated people, but one in five skilled immigrants leaves within 25 years with the highest attrition in the first 5 years, precisely when they're the most economically mobile and most likely to be comparing their Canadian prospects to their alternatives.”
Canada has internal trade barriers that function according to the IMF like a 6.9% tariff on domestic commerce; wine producers in BC cannot easily sell to Ontario restaurants, construction workers licensed in Alberta may need to re-qualify in Quebec, and medical devices cleared in one province require reapproval in another
“Canada also has internal trade barriers that function, according to the IMF, like a 6.9% tariff on domestic commerce. A wine producer in British Columbia cannot easily sell to a restaurant in Ontario. A construction worker licensed in Alberta may need to re-qualify to work in Quebec. A medical device cleared in one province requires reapproval in another.”
The Trans Mountain pipeline expansion entered commercial service in May 2024, adding approximately 590,000 barrels per day of capacity and narrowing the WCS-WTI discount from roughly $19.82 to around $12.52 per barrel, representing progress toward market access despite a 530% cost overrun
“The Trans Mountain pipeline expansion entered commercial service in May 2024. It added approximately 590,000 barrels per day of capacity, bringing total Trans Mountain capacity to around 890,000 barrels per day. The WCS WTI discount has narrowed since then from roughly $19.82 to around $1252 per barrel.”
The Trans Mountain pipeline cost approximately 34 billion CAD to build against an original 2012 estimate of 5.4 billion CAD, representing a cost overrun of roughly 530%, one of the more spectacular infrastructure project management failures in recent Canadian history
“The pipeline cost approximately 34 billion Canadian dollars to build against an original 2012 estimate of 5.4 billion Canadian dollars. That is a cost overrun of roughly 530%. It remains one of the more spectacular infrastructure project management failures in recent Canadian history, but it is built and it is moving oil to tide water.”
TE Periq's phrase that Canada has spent too long being a client state and branch plant economy of the United States would have been controversial to say even 5 years ago but is now being quoted in the House of Commons.
“Periq's phrase that Canada has spent too long being a client state and branch plant economy of the United States which would have been controversial to say even 5 years ago is now being quoted in the House of Commons.”
In 2020 and 2021, CIBC estimated that roughly one-third of first-time home buyers received a parental gift to fund their down payment, with an average gift of $82,000 CAD (slightly more than median individual annual after-tax income); in Vancouver the average parental gift was $180,000, and in Toronto it exceeded $130,000
“In 2020 and 2021, CIBC estimated that roughly onethird of firsttime buyers received a parental gift to fund their down payment. The average amount was $82,000 Canadian, which as it happens is slightly more than the median Canadian individual's annual after tax income. In Vancouver, the average parental gift was $180,000 Canadian. In Toronto, it exceeded $130,000.”
Roughly 22,000 to 35,000 Canadians move to the United States each year, and approximately 60% of those applying for US work authorization from Canada are skilled immigrants who came to Canada first and subsequently moved on, with a median US salary offer of $137,000 primarily in computer, mathematical, and engineering fields
“The study found that roughly 22,000 to 35,000 Canadians move to the United States each year. More striking, about 60% of those applying for US work authorization from Canada are not Canadian-born at all. their skilled immigrants who came to Canada first and subsequently moved on. The median US salary offer for these individuals was $137,000 primarily in computer, mathematical and engineering fields.”
Canada runs a goods trade surplus with the United States but a structural current account deficit when including services and investment income, meaning Canada is a net importer that sells raw materials and manufactures less than it buys, not a mercantilist surplus economy
“Canada runs a goods trade surplus with the United States, but it runs an overall current account deficit when you include services and investment income. This distinction matters because Canada is sometimes characterized in trade discussions as a surplus economy in the Chinese mold. This is not accurate. Canada runs structural deficits in services, in tourism, in intellectual property, in financial services that offset its good surplus. Canada is in aggregate a net importer. It is not a mercantlist economy systematically accumulating foreign reserves at the expense of its trading partners. It's a country that sells raw materials and manufactures less than it buys.”
Canada's median household income relative to the US declined from roughly 80% of the American level in the decade before the pandemic to around 70% today
“National income per head has fallen from roughly 80% of the American level in the decade before the pandemic to around 70% today.”
Approximately 75% of Canada's exports go to the United States, and total merchandise exports to the US represent roughly one-third of Canadian GDP, making Canada comprehensively tethered to a single trading partner unlike any other developed economy
“Approximately 75% of Canada's exports go to the United States. For reference, total merchandise exports to the US represent roughly onethird of Canadian GDP. No other developed economy is so comprehensively tethered to a single trading partner.”
In January 2005, the average Canadian home sold for $237,000 CAD; by early 2026, the average reached $661,000 CAD, a nominal increase of approximately 179% and a tripling in price even when adjusted for inflation
“In January 2005, the average Canadian home sold for $237,000 Canadian. By early 2026, the average had reached $661,000, a nominal increase of around $179% or nearly tripling in price. Even adjusted for inflation, the gain is still huge.”
Housing prices in Canada's major cities sit at 12 to 17 times median household income; the national average price-to-income ratio is approximately 9, with Toronto and Vancouver substantially higher
“Housing prices in Canada's major cities now sit at somewhere between 12 and 17 times median household income. The median after tax income for a Canadian individual in 2023 was $74,000 a year. At the national average price of $661,000, the price to income ratio is approximately 9. In Toronto and Vancouver, it's substantially higher.”
The median senior family in Canada holds net assets of approximately 1.1 million CAD while the median family where the main earner is under 35 holds approximately $159,000, a 6.9x wealth gap driven by housing appreciation accruing to older cohorts
“The median senior family in Canada holds net assets of approximately 1.1 million Canadian dollars. The median family, where the main earner is under 35, holds approximately $159,000.”
Youth unemployment reached 14.7% in late 2025, and approximately 914,000 young Canadians (just under a million) were classified as NEET (not in employment, education, or training), representing a substantial structural barrier to wealth accumulation
“Youth unemployment reached 14.7% in late 2025. Approximately 914,000 young Canadians, just under a million were classified as need, not in employment, education, or training.”
The Bank of Canada's most recent forecast for real economic growth is 1.25% annually, which for an economy with Canada's endowments is unimpressive
“The Bank of Canada's most recent forecast for real economic growth is 1.25% annually. For an economy with Canada's endowments, that is unimpressive.”
The Maple Aid—Canada's eight largest pension funds—collectively manage around 1.6 trillion CAD in assets and are among the world's most sophisticated institutional investors; if structured as a sovereign wealth fund, they would be the third largest in the world
“The Maple Aid, Canada's eight largest pension funds, collectively manage around 1.6 trillion Canadian dollars in assets. They are amongst the most sophisticated institutional investors in the world. If structured as a sovereign wealth fund, they would be the third largest in the world.”
Approximately 17 million university-educated people globally would choose to move to Canada if they could, according to a 2025 survey, indicating strong global demand for Canadian residency and opportunity
“A 2025 survey suggested that approximately 17 million university educated people globally would choose to move to Canada if they could.”
Canada holds the G7's lowest net debt to GDP ratio and deficit as a share of the economy, giving it a genuine fiscal strength and the capacity to invest if it chooses to
“Canada also holds the G7's lowest net debt to GDP ratio and deficit as a share of the economy. Its fiscal position is relative to peers a genuine strength which means that it has the capacity to invest if it chooses to.”
If Canadian provinces were ranked as American states by per capita income, Alberta (oil-rich) would rank around 20th between Colorado and Tennessee; Ontario (most populous and economically central) would rank 48th below Montana and Alabama; New Brunswick would rank last, below Mississippi
“If Canadian provinces were American states, Alberta, the oil rich outlier, would rank around 20th wealthiest. somewhere between Colorado and Tennessee. Ontario, Canada's most populous and economically central province, would rank 48, below Montana, below Alabama, and below every southern state except Mississippi. New Brunswick would rank dead last, below Mississippi.”
Canada's startup ecosystem, particularly in AI, has found that growth-oriented capital came primarily from American funds rather than Canadian banking institutions, indicating that Canadian venture capital markets are underfunded relative to the US
“The startup ecosystem that Canada has quietly built, particularly in AI, has often found that the most growthoriented capital came from American funds, not from Bay Street.”
Energy East was a proposed 4,600 km pipeline carrying 1.1 million barrels per day from Alberta to St. John, New Brunswick, that would have opened Atlantic and European markets; it was cancelled in October 2017 after years of regulatory review, and several Canadians described its cancellation as the most consequential strategic error in recent Canadian economic history
“Energy East was a proposed 4,600 kilometer pipeline that would have carried 1.1 million barrels per day from Alberta to St. John, New Brunswick. The Canaport terminal at St. John had already received 300 million Canadian dollars in upgrades and can accommodate super tankers, much larger vessels than those serviced by the Vancouver terminus. Energy East would have opened Atlantic and European markets in addition to Asian ones. It was cancelled in October 2017 following years of regulatory review, shifting political winds, and organized opposition. Several Canadians I spoke to in researching this video described the cancellation as the single most consequential strategic error in recent Canadian economic history.”
Trade tensions of recent years have created in Canada a political consensus around economic self-sufficiency that was absent for most of the last three decades, suggesting that external pressure might finally produce the internal reforms that domestic politics have persistently failed to deliver
“The trade tensions of recent years have created in Canada a political consensus around economic self-sufficiency that was absent for most of the last three decades. The internal trade barrier discussion which has been a polite academic conversation for decades suddenly became urgent. The pipeline question acquired new political salience. Periq's phrase that Canada has spent too long being a client state and branch plant economy of the United States which would have been controversial to say even 5 years ago is now being quoted in the House of Commons.”
Canada is not suffering from a classic brain drain but is functioning as a very efficient talent incubator for the United States economy—a service Canada did not intend to provide
“Canada is not on this evidence suffering from a brain drain in the classic sense. It's functioning as a very efficient talent incubator for the United States economy, which is a service, I suppose, just not one that Canada intended to provide.”
Canada is failing gradually, systematically, and in ways that are entirely legible because of compounding errors that reinforce each other, with each individual error defensible but collectively ruinous; these same patterns are visible across developed countries but Canada got there first
“It is failing gradually, systematically, and in ways that are entirely legible. Compounding errors that reinforce each other, each one individually defensible collectively ruin us. The same patterns are visible in countries across the developed world. Canada just got there first.”
Between 2015 and 2025, public sector employment in Canada grew by approximately 30%, representing a growing share of the highest-security employment in sectors that do not produce exportable goods or generate productivity growth
“Between 2015 and 2025, public sector employment in Canada grew by approximately 30%. I'm not arguing that public servants don't provide valuable services. Many of them do. It's just worth noting that a growing share of the highest security employment in Canada is in sectors that do not by definition produce exportable goods or generate productivity growth in the conventional sense.”
A Canadian real estate industry publication suggested that Canada's housing market needed further tax relief for property owners to stimulate housing transactions, a recommendation that is analogous to treating high blood pressure by increasing salt intake given the environment of 17x price-to-income ratios in Vancouver
“Amusingly, in researching this, I found a Canadian real estate industry publication where the author argued that what Canada's housing market needed was further tax relief for property owners on the grounds that this would stimulate more housing transactions. I don't like to beat up on someone, but consider the environment in which it's being made. The average home in Vancouver costs more than 17 times the average income. The suggested solution is to make property ownership even more tax advantage than it already is. This is a bit like a doctor seeing a patient with high blood pressure and suggesting that they eat more salt.”
Elon Musk was born in South Africa, moved to Canada at 17 for citizenship, stayed approximately 2 years, then relocated to the United States for better economic opportunities—an example of the dominant pattern identified in Statistics Canada research of skilled individuals arriving in Canada and subsequently departing for the US
“Elon Musk was born in South Africa. At 17, he moved to Canada where he held citizenship through his mother and stayed for approximately 2 years before relocating to the United States. He's now variously the world's richest person, the owner of Twitter, which he acquired for 44 billion and renamed X and a figure of considerable political controversy in the country that eventually kept him. I bring him up not as evidence of Canada's loss, but because of the underlying pattern. Talented individual arrives in Canada, acquires residency, departs for the United States for better economic opportunities. There's nothing really unusual about this story.”
The Canadian Radio Television and Telecommunications Commission (CRTC) has theoretically been open to new telecommunications market entrants for years, but practical and regulatory barriers have ensured that meaningful competition never materialized, with the industry spending lavishly on lobbying and regulatory intervention while spending less on network investment per customer than counterparts in more competitive markets.
“The Canadian Radio Television and Telecommunications Commission or the CRTC...has for years been theoretically open to new entrance. But the practical and regulatory barriers have ensured that meaningful competition never quite materialized. The industry has spent lavishly on lobbying and regulatory intervention. It spends rather less on network investment per customer than its counterparts in more competitive markets.”
If a Toronto home purchased in 2005 for $300,000 with a 20% deposit ($60,000) is now worth $900,000, the original $60,000 generated a capital gain of $600,000—a 10:1 return on actual cash invested and entirely tax-free if it was the primary residence. By contrast, the same $60,000 in a TSX index fund would be worth roughly $195,000 today, a solid result diluted by capital gains tax on the profit.
“If you bought a Toronto home in 2005 for $300,000 with a 20% deposit, so $60,000 down, and that home is now worth around $900,000, your original $60,000 has generated a capital gain of $600,000. That is a 10:1 return on the actual cash invested. It's also in Canada entirely tax-free if it was your primary residence. If you had instead taken that same $60,000 and put it into a TSX index fund, it would be worth roughly $195,000 today. A solid result, but it gets diluted because of capital gains tax on the profit.”
The Bank of Mom and Dad has in certain Canadian cities become the largest mortgage lender in the country and does not publish accounts or regulatory reporting
“The Bank of Mom and Dad has in certain Canadian cities become the largest mortgage lender in the country. It doesn't, however, publish accounts.”
Crises are occasionally useful because they create conditions for reform that domestic politics alone cannot produce.
“Crises, as it turns out, are occasionally useful.”