
Why is the UN's Summit of the Future so important? | Ian Bremmer Explains
What this covers
This is a four-minute explainer in which Ian Bremmer sets the UN's first Summit of the Future against the state of multilateralism. He opens with the image of a giant broken chair in Geneva, built for the campaign against landmines, and reads it as a picture of an institution that one big push could collapse. He quotes Dag Hammarskjold on the UN's modest mission: to save us from hell, not bring us to heaven. He also cites Guterres's line that the choice is "reform, or rupture." Bremmer discloses that he sits on the UN's advisory body of experts on AI governance, and that he has spent the past year talking to people about what kinds of governance can work.
The middle of the piece lays out the case against the institution. The Security Council could not stop Russia's invasion of Ukraine, a resolution in Gaza remains elusive, and only 15% of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)) are on track, with many going in reverse. Bremmer describes a world splitting into coalitions and blocs, a fragmentation that leaves the UN asking what it can do when countries disagree on basic ideas.
The turn is toward AI. Bremmer notes that Guterres called for a Global Digital Compact in 2021, covering AI regulation, misinformation, and universal internet access, and that members will vote on it at the summit. He argues that the US, EU, and China are absorbed in their own domestic rules and competitiveness, and that no government yet knows how to handle a technology of such promise and risk. His normative claim is that the UN should lead the conversation and not let a patchwork form. He wants voices from the Global South included, so that standards rest on international law and human rights rather than the interests of wealthy countries with large tech firms. He points to the Paris Agreement as precedent, and he ends cautiously optimistic that the UN can adapt.
The United Nations faces a critical test at the Summit of the Future to demonstrate multilateralism's relevance by leading global AI governance, which requires coordination across fragmented national interests and inclusion of Global South voices to prevent regulatory patchwork and ensure standards rooted in international law.
- Multilateralism is collapsing as evidenced by Security Council paralysis on Ukraine/Gaza and SDG failure (15% on track)
- No single government has domestic AI rules figured out, creating urgency for UN-led global standards
- UN can replicate Paris Agreement success by centering human rights and including Global South in AI governance design
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Former Secretary General Dag Hammarskjold stated 'The United Nations was not created to bring us to heaven, but to save us from hell,' capturing the modest realist mission of the organization.
“In the words of former Secretary General Dag Hammarskjold, 'The United Nations was not created to bring us to heaven, but to save us from hell.'”
Major powers like the US, EU, and China are preoccupied with figuring out their own domestic AI rules and driving their own competitiveness, which creates fragmentation in global AI governance.
“major powers like the US, EU, and China are busy trying to figure out their own domestic rules and drive their own competitiveness”
Secretary General Guterres warned that 'the alternative to reform is further fragmentation. It is reform, or rupture,' articulating the binary choice facing multilateralism.
“As Guterres warned last year- - The alternative to reform is further fragmentation. It is reform, or rupture.”
The Paris Agreement serves as a historical precedent demonstrating that multilateral governance can successfully include voices from all nations and produce binding standards rooted in human rights.
“much like what the Paris Agreement did for climate change”
The UN Security Council could not stop Russia's invasion of Ukraine, indicating failure of multilateralism in addressing major geopolitical crises.
“The Security Council couldn't exactly stop Russia's invasion of Ukraine.”
AI carries both significant promise and significant risk, yet no government currently knows how to handle it, making international coordination necessary.
“AI carries a lot of promise, and yes, a lot of risk, too. No government knows how to handle it, and major powers like the US, EU, and China are busy trying to figure out their own domestic rules and drive their own competitiveness.”
In 2021, Secretary General Guterres called for a Global Digital Compact to regulate AI, fight misinformation, and connect the entire world to the internet.
“In 2021, Secretary General Guterres called for a Global Digital Compact to regulate AI, fight misinformation, and connect the entire world to the internet.”
A resolution in Gaza remains elusive, demonstrating continued inability of the United Nations to achieve consensus on major regional conflicts.
“A resolution in Gaza remains elusive.”
The world is currently splitting into coalitions and blocs, fragmenting the previously integrated international system.
“At a time when the world is splitting into coalitions and blocs”
The United Nations' own Sustainable Development Goals are not just off track—they are failing, with only 15% of targets on track and many going in reverse.
“The United Nations own Sustainable Development Goals aren't just off track. They're failing.”
The UN can play a critical role by leading the global conversation on AI governance instead of allowing a patchwork of fragmented regulation to emerge.
“And that's where the UN comes in. Instead of a patchwork of fragmented regulation, it can lead the global conversation, and include voices from countries without big tech firms.”
Including voices from countries across the Global South in AI governance can help ensure standards are rooted in international law and human rights, rather than reflecting only the interests of wealthy nations with tech firms.
“Those across the Global South can help ensure standards are rooted in international law and human rights, much like what the Paris Agreement did for climate change.”
Last year, the United Nations convened a group of experts to make recommendations for what the Global Digital Compact should include, with the speaker Ian being one of the experts.
“Last year, the United Nations convened a group of experts, full disclosure, I'm one of 'em, to make recommendations for what the compact should include.”
A giant broken chair in Geneva, Switzerland opposite a UN office symbolizes the campaign against landmines, but given rising global conflict and polarization, it also represents the state of multilateralism itself as something that could collapse with one big push.
“There's a giant broken chair in the middle of Geneva, Switzerland right across from one of the United Nations' main offices. Apparently, it officially symbolizes the campaign against landmines, but given rising global conflict and polarization, it's also come to represent the state of multilateralism itself. One big push, could come toppling down.”
At a time when the world is splitting into coalitions and blocs, the UN's General Assembly must prove that multilateralism still has a place amid fragmentation.
“At a time when the world is splitting into coalitions and blocs, at this year's General Assembly, it's time to prove that multilateralism still has a place amid all the fragmentation.”
This year could be a turning point for the UN, with the General Assembly holding its first-ever Summit of the Future, which is a test of the organization's ability to tackle one of the world's biggest challenges and opportunities: artificial intelligence.
“But this year could be a turning point. This week, the General Assembly will hold its first-ever Summit of the Future. It's a test of the United Nations' ability to tackle one of the world's biggest challenges and opportunities, artificial intelligence.”
The central question facing the UN is: what can it accomplish in a world where countries can't agree on basic ideas?
“What can the UN accomplish in a world where countries can't agree on basic ideas?”
The UN has the determination and tools to adapt and meet the challenges of its next era of existence, suggesting institutional capacity for reform.
“The United Nations has the determination and the tools to adapt to meet the challenges of its next era of its existence.”
The speaker has spent the last year talking to people around the world about what kinds of AI governance can work, and is optimistic that the UN will make inroads to a safer and more open digital future.
“I've spent the last year talking to people around the world about what kinds of AI governance can work, and I'm optimistic that the UN will make inroads to a safer and more open digital future.”
Only 15% of UN Sustainable Development Goals are on track, which represents a failure of the UN system.
“If only 15% of the Sustainable Development Goals are met, that is a failure.”
Multilateralism, defined as multiple countries working together for common goals, has had a difficult time recently, especially in the United Nations, the world's largest multilateral organization.
“Multilateralism, multiple countries working together for common goals, has had a difficult time recently, especially in the United Nations. That's the world's largest multilateral organization.”
The UN's values of peace and security feel very far from today's geopolitical realities, as the organization struggles to address major conflicts.
“The UN's values of peace and security feel very far from today's geopolitical realities.”
If countries agree at the Summit of the Future, the Global Digital Compact will be adopted and serve as a framework for global AI governance.
“If countries agree, it will be adopted at the Summit of the Future.”