
Scott Sumner on Growth and Economic Policy 06/21/2010
What this covers
Russ Roberts hosts Scott Sumner for a survey of three decades of economic policy, with Sumner making the case and Roberts pressing on it. Sumner recalls that in the 1970s price controls and industrial policy were mainstream liberal positions, and Milton Friedman looked like a crackpot to many economists. He then covers Britain's turnaround after Thatcher, despite a letter from economists predicting failure, and Chile's outperformance of Latin America, which he sets against Paul Krugman's account of disillusionment. He also argues that US deregulation of banking and telephones was broader than people assume. Roberts doubts that policy effects can be isolated, and he cites areas where US government involvement grew, such as permit hurdles for big-box stores.
The middle of the conversation ranges widely. Sumner calls Denmark a near-perfect neoliberal case, citing its free-market scores on Heritage Foundation categories despite high taxes. He argues that Nordic tax structures do less harm than punitive top marginal rates. He explains European work hours through taxes paired with subsidies, and he says Singapore Airlines shows that state ownership matters less than subsidy and barriers to entry. Two statistical cautions follow: Chinese growth is inflated by rural-to-urban migration, and income quintile data mislead because the groups are not the same people over time.
The last stretch turns to culture. Sumner's study of 32 developed countries uses survey questions on cheating the government, alongside Transparency International rankings, to argue that civic-minded countries reformed fastest between 1980 and 2005. He applies this to Denmark, Greece, and Singapore versus Taiwan, and to whether Danish flexicurity could work in Mediterranean countries. He also uses Easterly's example of African schools to show that rule changes can fail when norms do not shift.
Sumner argues that the post-1980 neoliberal shift away from statism (state ownership, price controls, trade barriers, high marginal tax rates) produced faster growth in reforming countries, and that civic-minded culture, not ideology, best explains which countries reformed fastest.
- Nearly all developed countries cut statism after the late 1970s regardless of ideology, while welfare spending as a share of GDP stayed roughly flat
- Countries that reformed most aggressively (e.g., Britain, Chile, New Zealand, Denmark) generally outperformed more half-hearted reformers
- Civic-mindedness surveys predicted the speed of reform between 1980 and 2005 better than other variables
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Privatization per se is not the core problem with state ownership; the real harm comes from governments creating barriers to entry and subsidizing the company, so a government-owned firm like Singapore Airlines that is unsubsidized and faces competition behaves like a private firm.
“the problem with state ownership isn't so much that the state owns the company but they tend to do two other things they create barriers to entry and they subsidize the company”
Measured Chinese growth is inflated by rural-to-urban migration, since activity that was previously uncounted in the informal rural economy enters official GDP as workers move to cities.
“when you have massive migration from a rural area to the cities you're measured economic growth is going to go up a lot”
Economic systems that tax work and consumption heavily but keep capital taxes low (lower corporate taxes, no capital gains or inheritance taxes in some) avoid the Laffer curve problem and cause less investment and growth damage than punitive top marginal rates, so Nordic countries make the best of a bad situation.
“they tend to tax work and consumption very very heavily but don't have a very punitive tax rates at the very high end which you know run into the Laffer curve problem”
When evaluating correlations between policies and outcomes, one must always ask whether a third underlying factor causes both, because one cannot simply flip a policy lever on or off and expect the observed foreign results.
“you always should be asking what's the is there a third factor an underlying factor that's causing both of these”
Explaining the rate of change in reform between 1980 and 2005 is more informative than finding correlations at a single point in time, because many variables correlate at a point in time for many possible reasons, while idealism explained the rate of reform.
“it's easy to find just correlations at a point in time between all sorts of variables and there could be any number of reasons”
Sumner's most interesting research finding is that between 1980 and 2005 the countries that reformed fastest and moved most rapidly away from statism were the countries with the most civic-minded attitudes, as measured by the two surveys on corruption and cheating the government.
“between 1980 and 2005 the countries that reformed fastest that moved most rapidly away from statism were countries that had the sort of most civic minded attitude”
Reforms can fail on the ground if underlying norms do not change: Easterly's example of spending heavily on schools in Africa failed because teachers did not show up, and paying them to show up still fails if they do not teach when present, so changing formal rules may not change actual rules of the game.
“they built all these schools and that turned out the teachers didn't show up now you could pay them to show up but if they don't teach”
Income quintile data are one of the most misleading economic statistics because the bottom quintile is largely made up of people at different life stages (such as young middle-class adults) and the top quintile includes high-cost-area professionals like Boston cops and nurses, so the groups do not measure the same people over time.
“one of the most misleading economic statistics out there are the income distribution data the quintiles don't measure what people visualize”
Denmark may be the most perfect example of neoliberalism: it has very large government and high taxes, yet on the eight Heritage Foundation economic freedom categories other than size of government and taxes, Denmark ranks as the most free-market economy in the world.
“Denmark might be the most perfect example of neoliberalism”
Lower European work hours reflect the combination of high taxes and generous subsidies, since taxed money is returned to people who are not working, a mechanism Ed Prescott has documented; taxes and subsidies together explain much of the work-hour difference, though not all of it.
“it's that combination really of taxes and subsidies that probably explains quite a bit of the fact that hours worked in European countries are lower”
Mainstream liberals in the 1970s supported across-the-board price controls and industrial policy, and the idea that free markets produce faster growth was considered eccentric; Milton Friedman was viewed as a crackpot by many liberal economists, so today's neoliberal consensus is only a few decades old.
“many liberals did believe in those things in the 1970s we did have across-the-board price controls at various times in the seventies”
Civic-mindedness, measured by survey questions on whether it is acceptable to cheat the government on benefits, predicts lower corruption and more neoliberal policy: in Sumner's study of 32 developed countries, Denmark ranked second most honest and first on Transparency International's least-corrupt list, while Greece ranked last on honesty and was embroiled in budget data manipulation.
“Denmark actually comes in second on the list in terms of being most honest or least likely to say it's okay to steal from the government and they come in number one on surveys of corruption”
The welfare state works better in high-trust societies: Denmark's generous unemployment insurance (flexicurity, which combines flexible hiring and firing with social insurance) depends on voluntary compliance, so it may not work in Mediterranean countries where civic attitudes differ and firing is restricted.
“the other part of government of the welfare state part works better in a high trust society”
Cultural differences in corruption are not innate: Singapore (fourth in honesty among the 32) and Taiwan (27th), both majority Chinese, have vastly different corruption levels, so government policy can make a difference beyond the cultural values people bring.
“two countries in East Asia both Chinese predominantly with vastly different levels of corruption so government policy I think can make a difference”
Paul Krugman argued that Latin Americans became disillusioned after the 1990s Washington Consensus of privatization, deregulation, and free trade failed to deliver growth; Sumner counters that Chile, the one Latin American country that aggressively pursued neoliberal reforms, ranks far higher on economic freedom and outperformed the continent.
“if you again look at the rankings there's really one country in Latin America that stands out has aggressively pursuing neoliberal reforms and that's of course Chile”
After the Great Depression discredited capitalism, idealistic people worldwide turned toward socialism; from the late 1970s attitudes shifted back toward free-market economics, though they still retained social insurance, and reform speed was slowed in less civic countries because special interest groups earning economic rents resisted giving up interventions.
“powerful special interest groups that earned economic rents from various sorts of government interventions didn't want to let go of those interventions and so they reformed much more slowly”
In 1979 Britain was almost a basket case, and a large number of British economists signed a letter predicting Thatcher's policies would fail, yet Britain turned around and later overtook France, Germany, and Italy in per capita GDP after an aggressive reform program.
“at the time a large number of British economist signed a letter basically saying sacher's policies were going to fail”
Per capita incomes in larger European countries are about 20-25 percent below US levels after adjusting for cost of living, and overall European output is around 75-80 percent of the US level, with the gap partly due to US entrepreneurial sectors and lighter regulation that lets chains like Walmart expand quickly.
“their per capita incomes are below our levels by usually about 20-25 percent if you adjust for cost of living”
Britain had fallen behind France, Germany and Italy in per capita GDP before its aggressive reforms, and after reforming it caught up and surpassed them; Britain is a better comparison than the US because it was a catching-up economy like Europe.
“Britain had actually fallen behind places like France Germany and Italy and then when it did a much more aggressive reform program yet again caught up and surpassed them in per capita GDP”
The European Union's push for a level playing field forced member countries to cut protection and subsidies for domestic champions, making the EU somewhat more of a free-market economy despite its flaws.
“they've encouraged this idea of a level playing field and what's that what that has done is forced countries to cut back on the amount of protection and subsidy”
Growth slowdowns after the 1970s were worldwide, so comparing the US before and after 1980 alone is misleading; Italy and Greece's growth fell sharply while the US and Britain slowed less, and countries that reformed more vigorously on average slowed less.
“the whole world sort of not sort of the whole world slowed down at the end of the 1970s this was not you can't just compare America before and after this watershed date”
US economic deregulation was broader than commonly assumed, including sharp banking deregulation in the early 1980s (removal of interest rate price controls, lifting branching restrictions such as Chicago's one-branch rule), removal of hospital and rent controls in some places, and the breakup of AT&T's telephone monopoly.
“banking was very sharply deregulated in the early 80s removal of price controls on her interest rates and all sorts of branching regulations”
In the 1980s Japan's retail sector was heavily protected with little competition despite the US being cited as a model; the US reputation as freewheeling is partly outdated, since in Montgomery County, Maryland large-footprint stores like Walmart and Wegmans require a special permit that creates uncertainty and deters investment.
“if you want to open a store of a certain size and there's cut off in the square feet if it's larger than a certain amount you need a special permit”
The popular left-wing narrative that neoliberalism is a right-wing plot by capital to expropriate workers is wrong; reforms moved fastest in the most idealistic, liberal-in-the-broad-sense countries such as New Zealand and Denmark, so the shift must be understood beyond ideology.
“the narrative you hear in the press that neoliberalism is some sort of right-wing plot it is completely wrong”
Good governance depends on underlying cultural factors such as trust and expectations about others, measured by 'civic mindedness' surveys asking whether it is justified to cheat the government on benefits, not just on the number of forms to fill out.
“it's just the underlying way that people interact with each other level of trust the expectations that people have that probably have a very big and unseen impact on how easy it is to get stuff done”
Privatization of government-owned enterprises is a worldwide phenomenon, and may be the single most important neoliberal reform: the US had little government ownership to begin with, while France, Germany, and Italy and former communist countries privatized substantial state-owned manufacturers such as steel and auto companies.
“that might have been the single most important neoliberal reform so it's it's definitely”
Across countries, low corruption tends to coincide with relatively free markets, low trade barriers, and good governance measures like transparency and ease of starting a business, so the Nordic success is more about government functioning well than being small.
“that sort of economic policy regime does seem to be correlated with various surveys of corruption levels”
The US advantage from low marginal tax rates is that entrepreneurs can get very rich and keep most of their winnings, and this sustains a strong venture capital market where individuals steer capital into high-risk, high-return innovation that few other countries replicate.
“that in turn creates something that the United States has that very few other countries have which is a very strong venture capital market”
China's rapid growth does not show that state involvement works: China was far poorer than Mexico, its growth came from moving from Mao's near-total non-market system toward a half-communist, half-capitalist system, and the more free-market provinces (such as Guangdong) are richer than statist northeastern provinces like Manchuria.
“China is still very poor much poorer than Mexico much of the growth is coming from the fact that it's become much more free market than it was under Mao”
The Heritage Foundation economic freedom index mainly captures good governance (low corruption, transparency, ease of starting a business, rule of law) rather than small government, so a high ranking reflects effective government more than limited government.
“what they call economic freedom is to some extent what should be called a good governance”
Government size as a share of GDP has not changed dramatically since the 1970s in developed countries, so size-of-government measures miss the fall in statism that actually occurred, and healthcare cannot be cleanly classified as pure redistribution because it involves substantial intervention.
“the government as a share of GDP hasn't really changed dramatically since the 1970s but what's happening to love the amount of statism or interference in the markets has been reduced”
A government sector around 50 percent of GDP inevitably creates inefficiencies and distortions, discouraging work and investment, regardless of how well taxes are structured; Switzerland is wealthier than Denmark and Sweden because it has a smaller government and lower taxes.
“in my view that's why a country like Switzerland is wealthier than Denmark and Sweden is that it has a smaller government lower taxes”
After the late 1970s, almost every country in the world, regardless of ideology, substantially reduced statism through cuts in government ownership, price controls, regulation, trade barriers, and top marginal income tax rates, including the Nordic countries.
“almost every country in the world substantially reduce the amount of statism that is actual government ownership price controls regulation trade barriers almost all countries including the Nordic countries sharply cut their top marginal tax rates”
Within China, the more market-oriented coastal provinces such as Jiangsu are the richest, while the more statist northeastern provinces such as Manchuria are laggards, and Taiwan, Hong Kong, and Singapore are much richer than mainland China.
“within China the more free market provinces like Jade young are the richest and the more statist ones like those in the Northeast or Manchuria tend to be laggards”
Sumner identifies four main US neoliberal reforms: deregulation, cutting the top marginal income tax rate from about 90 percent to about 40 percent, freer trade (NAFTA and other agreements), and welfare reform that replaced open-ended welfare with the Earned Income Tax Credit.
“a second is the sharp cut in marginal tax rates from about 90 percent the peak to you know more like 40 so now a third was movement towards freer trade nafta”
Sumner's pet theory is that demographics, not oil prices, explains the 1970s-80s growth slowdown: a dramatic rise in divorce increased household counts faster than population, and women entered the workplace with skills they had not planned to use, a cultural-demographic shift that changed growth independently of economic policy.
“the thing I point to that no one seems to talk about is demographics what happened in the 1970s all over the world was an dramatic increase in divorce”
Comparing countries that are similar in other respects, the more neoliberal policy regime usually produces better results; when half-hearted reforms are excluded, neoliberal reforms are associated with better outcomes, though they do not work in every single case (New Zealand's results were disappointing).
“compare likes with likes countries that are fairly similar each other in different respects usually the more neoliberal policy regime does produce better results”
Sumner believes the US would benefit from market reforms if Congress enacted them, but Danish-style social insurance reforms might be abused by Americans and fail to work in the US, even if Congress passed them.
“on the second point I actually think they would work in the United States if we could get them enacted on the other hand if we could enact the Danish reforms here I'm not sure they would work”
Apparently lower European work hours may reflect home production substitution: because of the high tax wedge, people save money by doing their own work (such as painting their own house), which reduces specialization and efficiency rather than reflecting true leisure.
“people are substituting home productions for production at work so because of the high tax wedge you can save a lot of money in many cases doing things yourself”
Roberts challenges the claim that the US became less regulatory, arguing that government's role grew in healthcare, bank bailouts in finance, education, and consumer regulation (cigarettes, trans fats), so the US trend toward freer markets is not as clear as Sumner suggests.
“it's hard to contend that we moved toward a less regulatory regime for example in healthcare government got increasingly larger”
Small Western European economies such as Switzerland and the Nordic countries have a surprising number of billionaires, small successful high-tech firms, and some large multinationals for their size, but the entrepreneurial advantage is less noticeable there because of their small scale; Silicon Valley has no comparable cluster in the larger European countries.
“the Nordic countries which do actually you know for their size have a surprising number of billionaires”
Chile's per capita income was barely half of Argentina's in 1980 and is now about equal to Argentina's, illustrating the economic success of Chile's neoliberal reforms relative to the rest of Latin America.
“back in 1980 it's a per capita income was barely half of Argentina's and now it's about equal to Argentina”
Culture can block reform in two distinct ways: it may prevent reforms from passing the legislature, and reforms imposed by a dictator may fail to work because of different cultural values; Sumner agrees these are separate questions.
“there's two senses in which culture might make it impossible to institute certain kinds of reforms”
Sumner distinguishes three policy categories: classical liberalism (belief in small government), modern liberalism (more socialist in orientation, peaking in the 1970s), and neoliberalism (a postmodern synthesis combining relatively free markets with a sizable welfare state).
“classical liberalism which is sort of belief in small government in economic sense and modern liberalism which is more socialist in orientation and then neoliberalism which I see is sort of a postmodern synthesis of the two”
Government activity divides into social welfare spending, which forms the large bulk of government spending, and 'statism', a catch-all for price controls, market entry controls, trade barriers, company ownership, and high marginal tax rates that distort markets without necessarily involving large spending.
“the other set of government activities is sort of a catch-all I call statism which involves things like price controls market entry controls trade barriers ownership of companies high marginal tax rates”
In a 1980 forecast, Sumner predicted that the US would outpace Japan and Europe in GDP per capita over the next 20 years and that Britain would overtake Germany and France over the following 28 years; such predictions in 1980 would have been met with laughter as right-wing kookery, yet the economic success that followed was real.
“suppose you had gotten a room full of economists together in 1980 I made the following predictions over the next 20 years the u.s. of course fast at Japan and faster than Europe”
The meaningful question for classical liberals is how much economic activity is steered top-down versus bottom-up; contracting out government services can be competitive or uncompetitive, so measuring privatization requires distinguishing these forms.
“how much economic activity is steered from the top down versus the bottom up”
Black market, underground, and barter activity in high-tax European countries like Italy and the Scandinavian countries avoids taxes and is missing from official data, so official measures of European output and leisure are unreliable.
“in a lot of these high tax countries in Europe the black market underground tax free sector is also particularly in Italy”
Classical liberals, including Adam Smith, Hayek, and Friedman, supported limited government but not a zero-state; they accepted government roles in courts, property-rights enforcement, and policing fraud, though Friedman and Hayek would accept some state-run redistribution.
“the classical liberals were anarchists it's not like they believed in and they believed in a limited state now zero state”
The cost of living for affluent households has risen faster than for lower-income households partly because Walmart lowered prices for poorer consumers, while wealthier households compete for scarce goods like oceanfront homes and elite private schooling, so the top quintile's real resources are distorted by local prices.
“the cost of living for the wealthy arguably has risen faster than for the lower income groups because lower come groups of benefited from to the Walmart phenomena”
High oil prices were overrated as a cause of the late-1970s growth slowdown, because economies were more energy-dependent then but later large price increases did not produce comparable effects.
“a lot of people blame high oil prices which I find very uncompelled although it's true that our economies were more dependent on energy”
European countries have privatized airports, air traffic control, highways, some rail lines, and post offices; Sweden has many for-profit schools and school choice; the Netherlands has largely privatized water systems that the US has also partly privatized.
“they privatize things like you know airports air traffic control highways some rail lines passenger train post office in Sweden you have a lot of for-profit schools”
The blogosphere and political debates make it hard to hold a rigorous discussion because people easily construct ex post rationalizations that fit their worldview: those who think markets improved growth point to the 1980s-2000s, while opponents point to slower growth as proof government grew.
“how easy it is to ex post struct Adair ative that conforms to your worldview”
Charter schools introduce only limited competition within a public monopoly, so real school choice requires going further, such as the for-profit schools emerging in European reforms like Sweden.
“that's why I think you have to go further than just charter schools and that's why some of the European reforms like the for-profit schools are so promising”
In 1980 the US was already a fairly free-trade country with thousands of tariffs and quotas that were low compared with prior decades, but other countries made much bigger trade-liberalization strides after World War Two, so the US now is probably not the most free-trade developed economy.
“the u.s. probably not the most free trade economy of the developed countries anymore”
Bob Virgil's account of an Egyptian guard asking for a tip after taking a photo at Sadat's tomb illustrates that bribery-as-custom is normal in some countries, where it functions as a constant transfer that reduces uncertainty but also invites negotiation and exploitation.
“the guard asked Bob if he wanted to have his picture taken and Bob said that'd be great”
Heritage Foundation economic freedom rankings and similar indices are dubious, but a value-added view is that they still track state intervention beyond size of government.
“we've talked about the fact that the various rankings of economic freedom are kind of dubious”
Walmart faces opposition in some places (Chicago's union concerns, elite liberal areas' political objections) but is welcomed in most of the US, and similar barriers make fast food restaurants hard to open in cities like Cambridge, Massachusetts.
“cities like Chicago have not allowed them because the union workers and maybe some of the less efficient stores are worried about cutting jobs”
Sumner's conclusion that idealism explained the rate of reform rests on Denmark and New Zealand being both the fastest reformers and the most idealistic, a pattern that sits uneasily with his own remark that New Zealand's reform results were disappointing.
“so the places that reform fastest like New Zealand and Denmark were those were the most idealistic values”
Roberts is skeptical that precise causal connections can be made between large, hard-to-measure economic variables, and says he doubts clean policy-outcome links from such data.
“I'm a as most of our listeners know a big skeptic on the ability to make precise statements about these correlate connect connections causal connections”
Privatization is an ongoing process not ended by the financial crisis, and Sumner expects a lot more privatization worldwide over the next decade despite news narratives that the neoliberal era is ending.
“I would expect over the next decade there will continue a lot of privatization all over the world”
Sumner says he is a classical liberal and prefers a model somewhere between neoliberalism and classical liberalism, with Hayek and Friedman placed in the classical liberal camp, and Adam Smith probably also in it, since he favored some state roles such as courts and property rights enforcement.
“I would put myself in the classical liberal camp”