What this covers

This is a Kitco News interview in which host David Lim questions Macro Compass author Alfonso Peccatiello about whether a recession is already under way and how bad it gets. The case rests on the credit impulse, which he describes as the pace at which spendable credit is created across the five largest economies and treats as a leading indicator with a 6-9 month lag. He ties its 2021 spike to stimulus checks and tax cuts, and its 2022 collapse to the end of government support and sharply higher junk-bond borrowing costs. Lim adds that the Atlanta Fed's GDP Now tracker points to a second negative quarter, which would meet the common two-quarter definition of recession.

The middle of the conversation covers the labor market, wages and the Fed. Peccatiello argues that real wages have fallen 3-5% over 15 months in several economies, and that strong credit card spending reflects people borrowing to make ends meet rather than healthy demand. He also argues that labor supply is structurally tighter than before the pandemic, which should make nominal wages slower to fall. A long historical comparison follows, in which Paul Volcker's two back-to-back tightening episodes are set against the 2020-22 stimulus boom and the current tightening. Citing Goldman Sachs figures, he contrasts the typical recession earnings drop of 14% with analyst consensus still expecting earnings growth.

The more contested turns concern policy and positioning. He claims the Federal Reserve cannot pivot until inflation, the most lagging of indicators, is dead, and that inflation is the lesser evil for workers compared with a recession, a view the framing of the interview pushes against. The closing segments turn to allocation: a quadrant-based model, waiting for the point where earnings and valuations are both depressed, long-dated Treasuries as an entry point, gold as a conditional stagflation play, and a cautious view of Bitcoin after the unwinding of 2021 speculation.

Sharpest takeaway

Pecatiello argues that a severe recession is imminent due to collapsing credit impulse and deteriorating business confidence, and investors should remain defensive in dollar cash until equities reach a genuine trough where valuations and earnings are both severely depressed.

  • Global credit impulse has dropped below levels seen in the Great Financial Crisis, with a 12-month lag predicting -10% earnings decline and 2-3% GDP contraction
  • Forward-looking indicators (NFIB, Philadelphia Fed surveys) show worst business sentiment on record, worse than 2008 or dot-com bubble
  • Labor market is a lagging indicator that will weaken in 6 months; the Fed will not pivot until inflation is killed, requiring continued tight conditions that deepen recession

The claims · ranked32 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.75

Labor supply is now structurally tighter than pre-pandemic because many Americans have permanently exited the workforce, and this constrained labor supply will slow nominal wage declines during the recession compared to historical downturns.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Alfonso Pecatiello

“the supply for labor as you allied it correctly before it's very tight that's because a bunch of americans but also in other countries have retired for good from the labor force they've just disappeared literally from the labor force participation rate is recovering but it's not nowhere near where it was before the pandemic because these guys have some simply disappeared so as there is a lower supply of labor available for employers to top what they have to do is to actually increase wages”

0.74

In the 1980s, the Fed under Volcker created back-to-back boom-bust cycles: first recession (1980-81) when Volcker initially tightened to kill inflation, then credit reflowed and inflation re-accelerated, forcing Volcker to tighten again with fed funds near 20%, creating a second recession. This pattern parallels 2020-2022: massive government stimulus in 2020-21, inflationary boom, now tightening into recession.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Alfonso Peccatiello

“the 80s recession back-to-back recession let's say where the so-called boom and bust cycles and we had them when after the first inflationary spike actually we had walker that came in and tried to take inflation and when he tried to take inflation he ended up slowing down the economy very fast too so we had a first recession straight away and then things stopped for a bit and the credits started flowing again why because people had this inflationary mindset in their head demographics were very strong there was a lot of credit flowing there was a very healthy labor force structurally speaking in the 80s so things restarted very quick again you got this credit dynamic all going and you got the economy picking up again inflation picked up again and then volcker had to go once all over again all the way with fed funds almost at 20 to stop inflation for good”

0.72

Between high inflation and recession, inflation is the lesser of two evils for ordinary workers because if inflation becomes entrenched in wage expectations, workers can at least request nominal wage increases that preserve purchasing power, whereas recession causes unemployment, forced asset sales, and lasting economic damage without compensation.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Alfonso Peccatiello

“the lesser of two evils is probably inflation i would say because what i'm going to try and say here is that if inflation becomes entrenched incurred let's say in people's expectations and also wages will start going up as well and at least you can try and preserve your purchasing power by asking a higher nominal wage that meets at least inflation it's a self-fulfilling mechanism because then your purchasing power is actually increasing you will be spending more you will be feeding the inflationary beast it's basically what happened in the 70s but at least you can normally keep your job and ask higher wages it's a very dangerous situation but the recession on the other hand keeps you out of your job yeah it probably if you have a second house it forces you to sell the house if you're the first house sometimes and you have other liabilities you might be forced to sell down your house to pay off your second liabilities the recession is nasty”

0.69

Goldman Sachs data shows the median recession over the last 50 years has lasted four quarters and seen S&P 500 earnings drop by 14%, while current analyst consensus expects 9% earnings growth this year—a cognitive dissonance indicating markets are unprepared for what's coming.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Alfonso Peccatiello

“goldman sachs put out a table last i think a week that shows that the average or the median recession over the last 50 years has last four quarters and has seen earnings drop by 14 on average and now analysts are there expecting earnings in the s p 500 to grow by nine percent this year so there is this cognitive dissonance”

0.68

The Atlanta Federal Reserve's GDP Now forecast is projecting a Q2 2022 contraction of negative 1.2%, which combined with Q1's negative growth means the U.S. is technically in recession by NBER definition (two consecutive quarters of negative real GDP growth).

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· David Lim (host) / Alfonso Peccatiello (guest)

“the atlanta fed gdp now forecast is projecting a contraction negative one point two percent was their latest forecast for q2 in the u.s and this will obviously be the beginning of a recession if we have two consecutive quarters of negative gdp growth”

0.68

The Federal Reserve will not pivot to dovish (accommodative) policy until inflation is fully 'killed,' which requires several quarters and will only occur once all economic damage has already been done—because inflation is the most lagging economic indicator, the Fed only sees confidence inflation is slowing when it's already too late.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Alfonso Peccatiello

“i want people to stop assuming that at the very first slow down in the economy or in the labor market the fed is going to turn rubbish the fed is going to turn rubbish only when they have literally killed inflation and that's going to happen if it's going to happen it's going to take several quarters down the road”

0.68

Rising credit card spending at high levels in early 2022 is not a sign of strong economic fundamentals but rather a 'consistent signal of people grasping for credit to make ends meet,' particularly as real wages have dropped 3-5% over 15 months when adjusted for inflation, forcing consumers to bridge income-consumption gaps through credit rather than sustainable spending.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Alfonso Peccatiello

“when i see credit card spending picking up at the pace we have seen at the beginning of 2022 while the economy is lowing down that's always been a consistent signal of people grasping for credit to make ends meet it's not a sustained long-term uh rosy spending based on the fact that the economy is going to grow and your opportunity set is going to grow when it comes to economic returns it's mostly about making ends meet and so if you look at credit card spending it has gone through the roof to make sure that despite real wages actually took a hit over the last 15 months the average salary earned by an american a canadian an italian german adjust for inflation has actually dropped anywhere between three and five percent so with the basically after inflation you are able to buy less than you were 15 months ago when that happens for so long the only way you bridge the gap is via credit card spending and by spending all your savings”

0.64

The NFIB small business survey shows business confidence peaked right before the COVID-19 pandemic and has never recovered despite reopenings and loosening of restrictions; in April 2021 when stimulus was flowing and vaccines were rolling out, confidence peaked at historical highs, but has been declining steadily since and now sits at depressed levels.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Alfonso Peccatiello

“this chart shows is that by april 2021 david everybody was as optimistic as they could ever be about the the outlook for business conditions 12 months forward so in april 2021 you had a lot of stimulus checks still growing through the economy you had vaccinations you had re-openings everybody was as optimistic as it can be and hey guess what eight months later we had the real gdp in america recording for 2021 plus 5.7 real gdp growth that was very strong now after april 2021 what happened is that the economy kept growing but the pace of growth actually slowed down”

0.64

Global credit impulse spiked in Q1 2021 due to government stimulus checks and tax cuts, driving earnings and GDP growth in 2021; credit has been drying up in 2022 as government support ended and credit conditions tightened dramatically, with corporate borrowing rates for junk companies rising from 4% to 9%.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Alfonso Pecatiello

“the global credit impulse went through the roof in the first quarter of 2021 because governments were sending us checks they were cutting taxes they were making sure we had more available money at our disposal well fast forward nine months later in 2021 earnings to the roof gdp to the roof now you go to 2022 and credit is drying up the government isn't sending us checks anymore corporates are struggling to borrow because credit conditions have tightened so aggressively mortgage rates have gone through the roof so if you want credit to buy a house it's much more complicated today than it was a year ago”

0.61

Real wages in the US, Canada, Italy, and Germany have declined 3-5% over 15 months when adjusted for inflation, meaning the average worker's purchasing power has materially deteriorated despite nominal wage growth.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Alfonso Peccatiello

“the average salary earned by an american a canadian an italian german adjust for inflation has actually dropped anywhere between three and five percent so with the basically after inflation you are able to buy less than you were 15 months ago”

0.61

Bank of America agrees that only a 'deep' or 'severe' recession can bring down inflation at this point, not higher interest rates or fiscal tightening alone—recession-driven demand destruction is the only mechanism to achieve sustained disinflation.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· David Lim (host)

“the bank of america actually agrees with you they say that a deep recession in their words a severe or deep recession is the only thing that can bring down inflation right now not higher interest rates not you know tightening fiscal policy a recession”

0.61

Real interest rates (the spread between Treasury yields and inflation rates) spiked significantly higher in recent months, making dollar cash more attractive relative to gold, because the reward for holding dollars (real yield) became higher than in 2021.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Alfonso Peccatiello

“gold wasn't looking good because the real interest rates had gone up very quickly so the appetite for people to buy and hoard dollars rather than gold actually become marginally better to own dollars because the reward you get is higher than you got in 2021 and that actually punished gold”

0.60

Forward-looking surveys like the NFIB (National Federation of Independent Business) and Philadelphia Fed surveys show business outlook for sales and business conditions over the next 6-12 months at their worst levels on record, worse than the 1980s recessions, worse than the dot-com bubble, and worse than the 2008 Great Financial Crisis.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Alfonso Peccatiello

“some of these prints when ceos or small companies are interviewed that they're asked what is your outlook for the next six to 12 months when it comes to sales when it comes to the volume of your sales you're going to be doing your business outlook the answer they just gave is the worst on record it's the worst since the 80s it's worse than the recessions we've had in the in the 80s it's worse than the dot-com bubble it's worse than the great financial crisis answers on average”

0.57

Pecatiello expects at minimum a median recession (4 quarters duration, 2-2.5% annual GDP decline) and possibly worse, not a mild recession, based on the credit impulse collapse being worse than 2008.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Alfonso Peccatiello

“i would say that you have to expect this recession to be at least equal to the median recession we have seen over the last 50 years at least equal and the median recession we have seen over the last 50 years has lost four quarters in median terms and has seen s p 500 earnings drop by 14 and gdp dropped by on average two two and a half percent per year when it lost that's what you should expect i would say at the bare minimum this should be the at least a medium recession if not worse”

0.53

Atlanta Fed wage tracker shows wage growth has remained elevated and sticky, reflecting the broader inflationary environment and constraining Fed's ability to cut rates quickly.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· David Lim

“i'm looking at the atlanta fed wage tracker which some economists argue is one of the cleaner trackers of wages now that's been going up and it stayed it stayed elevated”

0.52

The credit impulse—a metric tracking the pace of creation of spendable money (credit) flowing into bank accounts across households and corporates in the five largest economies—is a leading economic indicator with a 6-9 month lag: when credit impulse rises, economic activity picks up 6-9 months later; when it slows, economic activity slows in the same timeframe.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Alfonso Peccatiello

“the credit impulse is a series i i i develop it tracks the amount of spendable money that we get on our bank accounts we as citizens corporate citizens households and it tracks whether this amount of money is increasing or this or decreasing across the five largest economies and why is it relevant because the more money we get on our bank accounts the more likely we are to spend some of those and to foster economic activity so when this credit impulse goes up if you give it a lag of like six to nine months then also economic activity will pick up when the pace of creation of this credit slows down then also economic activity slows down”

0.50

10-year and 30-year U.S. Treasury bonds, currently yielding around 3.25% (for 30-year bonds at time of purchase), are a good entry point because future Fed cuts will be required after recession; if the Fed keeps tightening into severe recession, it will later need to cut rates to zero and beyond to recover, meaning long-dated bonds bought today capture the yield before rates fall sharply.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Alfonso Peccatiello

“what happens is that if you go and buy third year bonds right now 10 third year bonds debit those bonds actually incorporate 10 or 30 years of inflation and growth and if the federal reserve keeps pushing and smashing down credit conditions and making the recession worse what happens is that later on later on in five ten years from now they'll need to accommodate further which means that if you buy these bonds today 10-year bonds 30-year bonds you are capturing a pretty good entry point i believe because rates at some point will need to be cut to zero and stay to zero in order to recover from this recession we would have generated and worsened because of today's very tight monetary policy so i've started to buy some 30-year and 10-year us treasuries 30 years at 3.25 i started buying some of these because i think they will protect me during the upcoming recession”

0.48

Wages will drop before core CPI drops because wage declines reduce purchasing power and consumer spending, which then slows inflation, unless energy prices drop sharply first.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Alfonso Pecatiello

“if a central bank really commits in slowing down inflation when they try and be firefighters they actually can put down the fire the problem is the collateral damage... uh this depends on energy prices headline cpi dropping faster than wages would probably depend on on gasoline and energy crisis right those drop faster than cpi will drop faster but chatter is variables nothing changes on energy gasoline electricity and all these energy prices then i would expect wages to start dropping before cpi drops and that's because once wages cool down a bit our purchasing power also becomes a bit less so we are prone to spend a bit less as well david in a slowing down economy with our wages growing less than we expect that will also slow down consumer spending and that will slow down cpi as well over time”

0.45

Equity markets are forward-looking pricing mechanisms that trough and bottom before GDP recovers; investors should try to capture the 'double whammy' moment when both earnings and valuations are compressed (earnings revised down, risk sentiment low, P/E multiples depressed), as this is when equities are cheapest and should be bought.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Alfonso Peccatiello

“markets are forward-looking pricing mechanism so right what we're seeing now is a descent in economic growth we're seeing a downward trend in economic growth what you want to try and capture is that trough is that change of sign is one's gdp has bottom basically a straft and earnings as well have been revised down all the way to minus 10 minus 15 that's reflected in equity prices all that pessimism is already priced in then as well valuations might be reduced because risk sentiment is very low people don't want to overpay for stuff during the recession let's be honest guys so at that point you get what i call the double whammy you get earnings revised down because gdp has really gone down and then you got gdp troughing and you get valuations being also very depressed the combination of earnings being hit and valuations expressed makes the equity market very cheap that troughing point is exactly when you want to start buying equities”

0.45

A 10% earnings drop corresponds to 2-3% GDP contraction; this represents a 'relatively serious' economic decline that is 'nothing to be very happy about,' and investors are currently 'extremely comfortable relaxed right now' when they should be 'defensive' and 'watching out.'

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Alfonso Peccatiello

“now when it comes to gdp that normally means that gdp drops to two to three percent when an earnings drop ten to twelve percent gdp drops to three percent two to three percent drop in gdp guys that's that's relatively serious it's nothing to be very happy about and people are extremely comfortable relaxed right now and i don't think that's the right attitude to have you've got to be defensive you're going to watch out”

0.45

The 2020 COVID recession saw S&P 500 earnings drop by more than 14% (the median for recessions), with very large percentage declines compared to historical medians, though the duration was shorter due to the special nature of the pandemic shock.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· David Lim / Alfonso Peccatiello

“the last one in 2008 was 45 okay that's that's pretty significant 14 only 2020 what are we looking at here i think it dropped more than that yeah because this is earnings you're looking at the dropping earnings okay we're talking about earnings okay not the absolute level okay”

0.45

Speculative liquidation from the 2021 boom (highly valued tech companies, Bitcoin, risk assets purchased during 'animal spirits') must unwind and reverse before another risk rally; this cleanup period will generate pain lasting several months to a quarter or more.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Alfonso Pecatiello

“once you clean up all the speculative lungs all the people that were you know enforced by this buoyant animal spirits to go and buy all these highly valued tech companies and you know buy bitcoin at any price once you clean that up you'll have another rally probably later on it's gonna take a little bit there is some more pain to be had in bitcoin as well”

0.43

Pecatiello has developed a simple asset allocation model that categorizes conditions into quadrants based on forward-looking economic indicators and central bank monetary stance (tight vs. easing), with each quadrant prescribing different allocation strategies.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Alfonso Peccatiello

“i have this very simple last location model that looks at forward-looking economic indicators credit inputs and others and looks at how central banks are in their monetary standard are they tight are they easing right and we were at the point when the fed was telling us i'm gonna tighten up and the economy was slowing down in that environment quadrant four”

0.42

If the economy slows and inflation remains 'stubbornly high' (a stagflation-like environment), gold could benefit and become a buying opportunity; Peccatiello is 'not long gold yet' but 'watching for this potential scenario' and will buy when conditions align.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Alfonso Peccatiello

“now what happens over the next six months is if the economy starts to slow down let's say and inflation remains stubbornly high this might be an environment where gold actually benefits from this i haven't made up my mind yet i'm not long gold yet but i'm watching for this potential scenario to play as an opportunity to buy gold right now i'm just staying away from gold as well”

0.42

Since November 2021, Peccatiello's asset allocation strategy has been 'quadrant four' (tight monetary policy + slowing economy = worst environment), requiring 100% defensive positioning: hold dollar cash, sell all speculative assets (Bitcoin, equities), avoid all risk assets.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Alfonso Peccatiello

“since november 2021 on the macro compass people know that myastha location has been what i call my quadrant four asta location...in that environment quadrant four it's the worst table you really can't do much you have to have dollar cash a lot of dollar cash you have to sell all your speculative assets remember bitcoin bitcoin was i think 50 000 when i came here 45 000. i told you 26 was my next target it's a speculative asset it's an asset that needs risk sentiment to be strong buoyant to rally that's exactly the opposite of where we are today equities as well you need to get you stay away from risk as much as you can you need to be defensive now”

0.39

Pecatiello predicts labor market cracks will appear in 6 months, with fewer hiring signs and increased job search difficulty, because the current strength reflects a coincident/lagging indicator lag, not true economic strength.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Alfonso Peccatiello

“my bet my wager is that in six months from now you'll see some cracks appearing in the labor market too okay so we'll see fewer hiring signs and uh it will probably be a little bit more difficult to find a job”

0.32

Bitcoin's previous price target of 26,000 has been broken to the downside; Peccatiello's next targets are 15,000 and possibly 12,000, with 'some more pain to be had' before a sustained recovery.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Alfonso Peccatiello

“so right now i think it is still not time to lift bitcoin i would say the next price target i have is fifteen thousand it's probably going to even trade all the way down to twelve thousand uh at some point so there is some more pain to be had in in all the pockets that benefited a lot from very strong risk sentiment and very cheap credit in 2021”

0.24

Peccatiello publishes his detailed macro analysis weekly on the Macro Compass newsletter (free, available via Google or Substack at macrocompass.substack.com), providing forward-looking economic indicators, asset allocation guidance, and market views.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Alfonso Peccatiello

“the easiest way is to subscribe to my free newsletter it's called the macro compass you can google it or you can find it on substance the macrocombust.substance.com i publish once a week i give you guys macro economic insights my view on markets forward leading indicators asta location all of that for free”

0.19

Recent Google Trends data shows 'recession' searches spiking, which while not a reliable leading indicator of actual recession, demonstrates that recession concerns have spread from investors to the general public.

factualnovelty 0/4durability 1/4· David Lim

“if you look at google trends for example the word recession has been trending up so it's not just investors it's regular people looking up the word out of interest that usually is not a leading indicator for recession but it does show that people are interested and concerned”

0.17

The quadrant-four defensive stance ('capital preservation, avoiding losses, staying in dollar cash') has 'played well for seven months,' protecting portfolio purchasing power.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Alfonso Peccatiello

“now that has played well for seven months dollar is appreciating dollar cash is doing okay at least preserving some of your purchasing power you are avoiding losses it's about capital preservation it's about making sure your purchasing power remains as close as possible to where it was before the storm started”

0.13

The economy is moving down further and earnings won't pick up; the Fed is 'very stubborn' and not easing; therefore, conditions are not changing to justify moving away from defensive positioning.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Alfonso Peccatiello

“now are we changing here is there anything changing well the economy is moving down further so from that perspective sorry guys but earnings aren't gonna pick up so you can't count on that what about the federal reserve and now the federal reserve is very stubborn they are not easy as well so that doesn't help”

0.10

When the recession trough arrives and the Federal Reserve capitulates (signals sufficient inflation control to accommodate), that moment will be the time to call Pecatiello back for an investment advice update.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 0/4· David Lim

“let's let's hope it doesn't go to 8 000 and then we'll have you back on alphonso what happened to the target way below but uh we'll see what happens in the next couple months thank you so much for your analysis today uh very good talk very enlightening and uh hope to speak with you again very soon”