
Anger & Frustration As Beijing Fails To Stem The Bleeding | China Economy: Fiscal Policy | Deflation
What this covers
This 15-minute China Update video is hosted by Tony, who reads through the market reaction to Beijing's Saturday fiscal briefing and then spends its last section on a piece by Arthur Kroeber. Roughly four minutes in the middle go to a sponsored segment for DeFi Technologies, which the description marks as separate from the regular analysis. The opening tracks the whole cycle: equities rose more than 30% in the two weeks after the September 24 announcement, then fell back when no detailed fiscal plan followed. Tony frames it as a gap between investor expectations and economic reality.
The Saturday briefing itself gets a close reading. Finance Minister Lan Foran hinted at more measures and said there is ample room for the central government to add debt and widen the deficit, but he gave no figure, since the amount needs National People's Congress approval. Tony collects reactions from Tony Sycamore, who called the briefing a flop for lacking measures that would revive animal spirits, and from Heron Lim, Raymond Young and Alicia Garcia Herrero, who all flag the missing numbers. He also notes that the central government's balance sheet looks like the only one with room left, given debt at the local government, state enterprise and household levels. One cited estimate, that up to 10 trillion yuan over two years may be needed, is marked as contested.
The September CPI) data follows: a 0.4% year-on-year rise, below forecasts, with food prices up 3.3% and non-food prices down 0.2%. Tony reads this as no demand recovery and a likely slide into deflation without food. The closing section turns to Kroeber's argument that Xi Jinping's priorities limit the stimulus, and that policymakers want to avoid repeating the 2008–2009 infrastructure borrowing and the 2015 stock bubble. Kroeber expects financial returns to pick up in the coming months but sees the long-run vision as unchanged.
Tony argues that China's weekend stimulus announcement represents a tactical shift to stabilize the economy in the short term, but Xi Jinping's long-term strategic vision—shifting capital from property to technology-intensive manufacturing—constrains the scope and effectiveness of stimulus measures, making investor expectations for a major re-acceleration unrealistic.
- Xi's core strategy prioritizes technology investment and self-sufficiency over GDP growth, creating structural deflationary pressure incompatible with traditional stimulus
- Policy makers deliberately constrain stimulus to avoid past mistakes (2008-2009 infrastructure debt accumulation, 2015 stock bubble), limiting near-term market gains
- Market euphoria followed by despair reflects misunderstanding of Beijing's underlying intent: stabilization rather than re-acceleration
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The market is wrestling between expectations for more stimulus and economic realities; investors want to see a quick translation from stimulus measures into improving corporate earnings and better macro data (inflation, employment, local government debt), but there is a time gap between expectations and economic reality.
“the market is tussling between expectation for more stimulus and the economic realities investors want to see a quick translation from stimulus measures into improving corporate earnings better macro data whether that's with inflation employment or local government debt but there is a Time gap between that expectation and the economic reality in quote”
The central government balance sheet appears to be the only one left with enough space; local governments, state-run enterprises, local government financing vehicles, and even households (once known for being incredibly frugal and high-level savers) all now have massive levels of debt.
“the central government balance sheet appears to be the only one left with enough space local governments state run Enterprises local government financing vehicles and even households once known for being incredibly Frugal and high level Savers all now have massive levels of debt”
CPI inflation in China was flat month-over-month in September, coming in below expectations and would probably have been in deflation without a rise in food prices, suggesting no recovery in demand in September.
“the consensus is that CPI inflation in China was flat month on month in September coming in below expectations and would have probably been in deflation without a rise in food prices none of the suggests any recovery in demand in September”
The Minister of Finance cannot specify the amount of fiscal stimulus until it is approved by the National People's Congress, which is expected to meet soon.
“however the Minister of Finance cannot specify the amount of fiscal stimulus until it is approved by the national people's Congress which is expected to meet soon”
Heron Lim, an economist at Moody Analytics, mentioned that helping local governments would enable them to increase spending which could help the economy, however he also cautioned that the absence of clear figures on stimulus might make investors hesitant.
“Heron Lim an economist at Moody analytics mentioned that helping local governments would enable them to increase spending which could help the economy however he also cautioned that the absence of clear figures on stimulus might make investors hesitant”
One past stimulus mistake was the large infrastructure projects of 2008-2009, which helped China recover quickly from the global financial crisis but also began a pile-up of local government debt, which rose from being almost nothing 15 years ago to nearly 80% of GDP today (including liabilities of off-balance-sheet financing vehicles).
“one such mistake was the big infrastructure project of 2008 through 2009 which helped China recover quickly from the global financial crisis but also began a pile up of local government debt which rose from being almost nothing 15 years ago to nearly 80% of GDP today including the liabilities of off-balance sheet financing Vehicles”
Another past stimulus mistake was Beijing's cheerleading of a stock market bubble in 2015, which saw the CSI 300 double in a little over 6 months and then give up almost all its gains in two months.
“another was beijing's Cheerleading of a stock market bubble in 2015 which saw the CSI 300 double in a little over 6 months and then give up almost all its gains in two months”
Markets were right to see the stimulus announcement as an inflection point and opportunity to venture back into oversold Chinese assets, but they must judge the underlying intent, which is to stabilize the economy rather than generate a major re-acceleration; they also underestimated the constraints on stimulus imposed by Xi Jinping's long-run strategy and by policy makers' desire not to repeat past errors.
“the answer is no either markets were right to see the stimulus announcement as an inflection point and an opportunity to venture back into oversold Chinese assets but they must judge the underlying intent which is to stabilize the economy rather than generate a major re acceleration and they underestimated the constraints on stimulus imposed by XI jinping's longrun strategy and by policy makers desire not to repeat past errors”
China's core task is not to maximize GDP growth but to create a self-sufficient, technologically powerful economy immune to the effects of the US seeking to stunt its rise; this program is cogent as a national strategy but unfriendly to financial investors because the emphasis on investment means that supply will always run ahead of demand, leading to deflationary pressure which is bad for corporate profits, even in the favored high-tech sectors that face intense competition eroding margins.
“China's core task is not to maximize GDP growth but to create a self-sufficient technologically powerful economy immune to the effects of the US to stunt its rise this program is cogent as a national strategy but unfriendly to financi investors the emphasis on investment means that Supply will always run ahead of demand leading to deflationary pressure which is bad for corporate profits even the favored high-tech sectors face intense competition that will erode margins”
Raymond Young, Chief Economist for Greater China at AZBZ Bank, agreed that the lack of a specific number was disappointing to investors.
“Raymond young Chief Economist for greater China at A&Z Bank agreed that the lack of a specific number was disappointing to investors”
Over the weekend on Saturday, China announced plans to issue more debt in an effort to stimulate the property market, recapitalize banks, and provide financial support to local governments.
“over the weekend on Saturday China announced plans to issue more debt in an effort to stimulate the property Market recapitalize Banks and provide financial support to local governments”
Finance Minister Lan Foran did not provide specifics on the amount of funding but hinted that further economic stimulus measures are being considered, and noted that there is ample room for the central government to increase debt and the deficit.
“Finance Minister Lan foran during a briefing in Beijing did not provide specifics on the amount of funding but hinted that further economic stimulus measures are being considered he noted that there is ample room for the central government to increase debt and the deficit”
Alicia Garcia Herrero, Chief Economist for Asia Pacific at NAS, expressed concern about the lack of clarity in Beijing spending plans, suggesting this might not significantly boost the market.
“Alicia garciaa herero Chief Economist for Asia Pacific at NAS expressed concern about the lack of clarity in Beijing spending plans suggesting this might not significantly boost the Market”
IG Markets analyst Tony Sycamore stated that Saturday's briefing by China's Ministry of Finance 'has turned out to be a flop' because the fiscal measures needed to remove downside risk to growth and ignite animal spirits within Chinese consumers are conspicuous in their absence.
“IG Market analyst Tony Sycamore was more blunt telling clients in a note today quote Saturday's briefing by China's Ministry of Finance has turned out to be a flop the fiscal measures needed to remove downside risk to growth and ignite the animal Spirits within Chinese consumers are conspicuous in their absence in quote”
In September, food prices rose 3.3% year-over-year (an increase of 0.5 percentage points compared to the previous month) while non-food prices were down 0.2% (reversing a 0.2% uptick in August).
“in Breakdown food prices Rose 3.3% year on year in September an increase of 0.5 percentage points compared to the previous month non food prices were down 0.2% reversing a 0.2% uptick in August”
In late September, China launched its largest monetary stimulus since the pandemic, which initially boosted the stock market but was followed by decline after the holiday due to the lack of detailed fiscal plans.
“in late September China launched its largest monetary stimulus since the pandemic which initially boosted the stock market but was followed by decline after the holiday due to the lack of detailed fiscal plans”
China's consumer inflation unexpectedly eased in September, with the Consumer Price Index rising 0.4% year-over-year (the slowest in 3 months) against a 0.6% rise in August, missing the 0.6% increase expected in a UK-based Reuters poll of economists.
“China's consumer inflation unexpectedly eased in September while producer price deflation deepened heightening pressure on Beijing to roll out more stimulus measures quickly to revive flagging demand and shaky economic activity the Consumer Price Index CPI rose 0.4% from a year earlier last month the slowest in 3 months against a 0.6% rise in August missing a 0.6% increase for in a UK based Reuters poll of economists”
Chinese equity markets surged by more than 30% in the two weeks following Beijing's September 24th economic stimulus announcement, but then fell back on fears that the stimulus might fall short.
“Chinese Equity markets have had a wild ride major indices surged by more than 30% in the two weeks following beijing's September 24th economic stimulus announcement they then fell back on fears that the stimulus might fall short”
Xi Jinping's strategic aims have not changed: he wants to shift capital from the property sector into technology-intensive manufacturing, which he sees as the basis of China's future prosperity and power; long-term economic growth, he believes, is driven by investment in technology, which will eventually generate high-wage jobs and rising incomes.
“she's strategic aims have not changed he wants to shift capital from the property sector into technology intensive manufacturing which he sees as the basis of China's future prosperity and power long-term economic growth he believes is driven by investment in technology which will eventually generate High wage jobs and Rising incomes”
Short-run stabilization is needed in order for the long-run plan to succeed, but measures will be rolled out carefully to avoid what policy makers believe were damaging mistakes in previous stimulus episodes.
“short run stabilization is needed in order for the long run plan to succeed but measures will be rolled out carefully to avoid what policy makers believe were damaging mistakes in previous stimulus episodes”
Beijing's government is now determined not to overstimulate the real economy or inflate another stock market bubble; the economic aims are to stabilize growth and prevent deflation from tightening its grip on the economy.
“she's government is now determined not to overstimulate the real economy nor to inflate another stock market bubble the economic aims are to stabilize growth and prevent deflation from tightening its grip in some the economy”
Financial returns are likely to pick up in the coming months, but in the long run China's vision is unchanged: technology and self-sufficiency matter more than growth and profits.
“some the economy and financial returns are likely to pick up in the coming months in the long run though China's vision is unchanged technology and self-sufficiency matter more than growth and profits”
Economists estimate that China may need to spend up to 10 trillion yuan ($1.4 trillion) over two years to effectively stimulate the economy, with much of this targeted at households to boost domestic demand.
“economists estimate that China may need to spend up to 10 trillion Yen $ 1.4 trillion over two years to effectively stimulate the economy with much of this targeted at households to boost domestic demand”
Earlier last week the People's Bank of China and the Ministry of Finance set up a Joint Task Force, with its first official meeting discussing the maintenance of smooth operation of the bond market and the central bank's government bond trading market.
“earlier last week The People's Bank of China and the Ministry of Finance set up a Joint Task Force its first official meeting discussed the maintenance of the smooth operation of the bond market and the central bank's government bond trading Market”
Xi has not retreated from his vision but has accepted a change of tactics: the stimulus decision was driven by poor economic data, including sharp deterioration in manufacturing, sales and employment, a chorus of criticism from Chinese economists, and the rising risk of protectionism against China's exports.
“she has not retreated from his vision but has accepted a change of tactics the stimulus decision was driven by poor economic data including a sharp deterioration in manufacturing sales and employment A Chorus of criticism from Chinese economists and the rising risk of protectionism against China's exports”
Bonds will be issued to allow local governments to repurchase unused land from developers and purchase unsold new homes, and the government also plans to issue a special purpose bond to help large banks boost their capital, enabling them to lend more.
“Lan mentioned that bonds would be issued to allow local governments to repurchase unused land from developers and purchase unsold new homes the government also plans to issue a special purpose bond to help large Banks boost their Capital enabling them to lend more”
On Monday morning trading, the CSI 300 started up just 1% before quickly moving to around 0.1% up, a very modest move versus the surging prices seen two weeks ago.
“today during uh trading Monday morning the CSI started up just 1% before quickly moving to around being up 0.1% as of filming very modest versus the surging prices we saw two weeks ago”
The formation of the PBOC-Finance Ministry Joint Task Force can be seen as the establishment of a mechanism for coordinating monetary and fiscal policies, increasing synergy between the two.
“commentators were quick to point out that the formation of this task force can be seen as the establishment of a mechanism for coordinating monetary infrastru policies increasing Synergy between the two”
Michael Pettis, professor of finance at Peking University, noted that about seven of his students trade actively in the Chinese stock market, and the consensus among them was that the market would open much lower on Monday as disappointed investors left the market, but they would probably buy in the late morning or early afternoon if that happened because a lower market would put more pressure on Beijing to do something.
“on Sunday peaking University professor of Finance Michael Pettis posted quote about seven of my students trade actively in the Chinese stock market and I asked them during Saturday's seminar what they expected to do Monday the consensus was that the market would open much lower as disappointed investors left the market but they would probably Buy in the late morning or early afternoon if that happened because a lower Market would put more pressure on Beijing to do something end quote”
Arthur Kroeber is the founding partner of Gavekal Dragonomics and an excellent commentator on China's economy and financial system; his book 'China's Economy: What Everyone Needs to Know' is recommended as a good introduction to China's economic system.
“Arthur crober founding partner of gal dragonomics an excellent commentator on China's economy and financial system indeed his book China's economy what everyone needs to know remains one of my favorite books to recommend to people seeking a nice introduction to China's economic system”
Additional support will be given to students and low-income groups as part of the stimulus package.
“additional support will be given to students and lowincome groups Lan added”