
China’s $10 Billion Scam Collapses | Political Assassination in China | Chinese Economy: Consumption
What this covers
This is a roughly 13-minute solo briefing from Tony of China Update, split into three segments: holiday consumption data, a pair of finance-sector stories, and the EU-China dispute over electric vehicles. The consumption segment starts from mid-autumn festival travel, where trips rose 31.1% year on year and the holiday was one of few post-COVID periods to pass pre-pandemic levels. Per-trip spending was only 477 yuan, up 1.6% over five years. Analyst Sing T Pang reads this as no real recovery, and Chang Shu and David Chu of Bloomberg Economics say growth stays unbalanced without a consumer revival. Retail sales rose just 3.4% over the first eight months of 2024.
The middle section turns to finance. Leo wender, head of Hunan's provincial finance department, died in a fall from her apartment building, as did two men who visited her. Police are treating it as a criminal case, and the account gives the timing, the floor, and the open balcony doors. The video then covers the collapse of US-listed Hywin Holdings, accused of taking more than 10 billion US dollars from clients. Overdue wealth management products exceed 71 billion yuan across 24 issuers, and controlling shareholder Han Hongwei and his son are detained. Hywin's close ties to property developers connect the story to the housing crash. TS Lombard's Freya Bish and Rory Green offer a contested framing: that policymakers have chosen demand deflation through mass deleveraging.
The last segment covers the EV tariffs dispute. Commerce Minister Wang Wenzi is lobbying in Brussels, where talks were called "frank and constructive." Spain, echoing Pedro Sanchez, opposes tariffs, and Germany fears retaliation against its car industry. Tony notes that new competitiveness chief Teresa Ribera ranks avoiding a trade war alongside protecting Europe's car industry. He suggests the EU may dilute or drop the tariffs despite its leverage, while arguing China still needs the EU market because the developing world cannot absorb the exports.
China's consumption recovery remains weak despite holiday optimism, while political instability, financial sector collapse, and trade tensions with the EU create structural headwinds for the economy.
- Mid-autumn festival spending per trip grew only 1.6% over 5 years, signaling weak consumer confidence despite absolute trip increases
- High-profile deaths of finance officials and collapse of major wealth management firms indicate institutional instability and loss of confidence
- EU is wavering on EV tariffs despite having leverage, suggesting China's market access leverage is stronger than structural economics alone predict
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Leo wender, director of the Hunan provincial government's finance department since December 2022, has died in a fall from her apartment, with two other men who visited her also dying in falls from the same building, which local police are treating as a criminal case.
“Leo wender director of the Hunan provincial government's finance department since December 2022 has died in a fall from her apartment things took a dark turn when it was leaked in Chinese media that two men who had visited Leo's home also died in the fall local police are calling it a criminal case”
Sing T Pang, senior strategist at A&Z banking group, argues that the underwhelming per-trip increase in mid-autumn festival spending 'doesn't point to a recovery in consumption' and that spending figures have been 'extremely volatile over the past 5 years with wealth effects due to drops in property and stock prices disrupting the normal pace of consumption.'
“Sing T Pang a senior strategist at A&Z banking group expressed in a note that the underwhelming per trip increase quote doesn't point to a recovery and consumption end quot adding quote the spending figures have been extremely volatile over the past 5 years with wealth effects due to drops in property and stock prices disrupting the normal pace of consumption end quote”
US-listed Hywin Holdings (HYWIN), a Chinese wealth management company, has collapsed after being accused of scamming over 10 billion US dollars from clients, with the controlling shareholder Han Hongwei and his son being detained in Shanghai.
“us listed hwin Holdings h y wi i n a Chinese wealth management company accused of scamming over 10 billion US from clients has collapsed and the trolling shareholder and his son have been detained in Shanghai”
Retail sales in China gained just 3.4% year on year in the first 8 months of 2024, less than half the growth seen in the same period in 2023, indicating chronically weak consumption since the end of zero-COVID policies.
“retail sales a proxy for consumption gained just 3.4% year on year in the first 8 months of 2024 less than half the growth seen in the same period in 2023”
Germany is lobbying against proposed EU EV tariffs due to fear that Beijing could retaliate against its politically powerful automotive industry, revealing a structural tension between EU unity and individual member state interests.
“Germany is also lobbying against the tariffs out of fear that Beijing could cause too much pain to its politically powerful Auto industry”
Spain's Industry Minister echoes Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez's position against EU EV tariffs, arguing that 'Europe needs China as a strategic partner' and that 'China is a fundamental partner to develop the EV industry in Europe,' while warning that it would be 'absurd not to build up the relationship.'
“a top Spanish official the Spanish industry Minister echoing prime minister Pedro Sanchez's position against EU plans to slap terrorists on chines cars expressed on Thursday that Europe needs China as a quote strategic partner end quot in helping build the blocks electric vehicle industry arguing that quote China is a fundamental partner to develop the EV industry in Europe end quot adding that quote it would be absurd not to build up the relationship we will always avoid extreme protectionism end quote”
The EU's new competitiveness chief Teresa Ribera, appointed on Tuesday, stated that 'avoiding a trade war is as important as developing Europe's car industry,' signaling that the EU prioritizes avoiding escalation with China over protecting domestic EV producers.
“the eu's new competitiveness Zar appointed this week on Tuesday Teresa rera said that avoiding a trade war is as important as developing Europe's car industry quote the main message is that it is important to avoid a clash a trade War end quote adding quote we need to identify the best tools for how we can develop the car industry in Europe but are also effective in terms of avoiding this trade War”
Bloomberg Economics economists Chang Shu and David Chu argue that 'without a consumer revival growth drivers will remain unbalanced with policy makers having to continue to do the heavy lifting,' suggesting China's growth model is stuck relying on government stimulus rather than consumption-led growth.
“Bloomberg economics economists Chang Shu and David Chu similarly expressed in a note quote without a consumer Revival growth drivers will remain unbalanced with policy makers having to continue to do the heavy lifting in quote”
Hywin Holdings worked closely with property developers Everand and Sunic to funnel investor money into their projects, making the wealth management company's collapse directly tied to the broader property market crisis.
“China has launched a criminal probe into the disgrace company which worked closely with property developers everand and sunic to funnel investor money into their projects”
TS Lombard economists Freya Bish and Rory Green argue that 'policy makers have chosen demand deflation' and that 'the mass attempt to deleverage by saving is generating deflation which is killing profits and crushing wages,' characterizing Beijing's economic strategy as intentional deleveraging causing deflationary spiral.
“TS Lombard economists Freya Bish and Rory green for example argue in a report from Wednesday quote policy makers have chosen demand deflation the mass attempt to deleverage by Saving is generating deflation which is killing profits and crushing wages end quote”
PRC Minister of Commerce Wang Wenzi is in Europe this week for talks on proposed EU EV tariffs, with some of his lobbying efforts appearing to bear fruit as various EU member states express resistance to tariffs.
“PRC minister of Commerce Wang vental is in Europe for talks this week and it appears that some of his lobbying efforts may be bearing fruit as we discussed earlier this week Germany is also lobbying against the tariffs”
Chinese state media hailed Spain's position against EV tariffs as 'the right vision for future EU-China cooperation,' while some European commentators accused the Spanish minister of 'deep naivety,' reflecting a fundamental disagreement within Europe about China's role.
“the statement was hailed in Chinese State media as the right vision for future EU China cooperation while some other European commentators accused the senior Spanish minister of deep naive”
Hywin Wealth's typical investment products required minimum investments of 300,000 to 1 million yuan, and as of end of June 2023 the company had 46,600 active customers, meaning tens of thousands of retail investors were exposed to the fraud.
“the starting investment amount for highin weals products was mostly 300,000 or 1 million yen highin Investments financial report also shows that as of the end of June 2023 it had 46,600 active customers”
Hywin's wealth management products collapse came 9 months after the company failed to repay investors when products matured, sparking a crisis of confidence among thousands of depositors worried about the safety of investments in property projects after the nation's housing market crashed.
“this Crackdown comes 9 months after hwin failed to repay investors when some of its wealth management products matured sparking a crisis of confidence as thousands of depositors worried out the safety of its bets on property projects after the nation's housing market crashed”
Hywin Wealth's overdue products since 2023 have involved 24 issuers with a total overdue amount exceeding 71 billion yuan (over 10 billion USD), indicating the massive scale of the wealth management fraud.
“according to data from third party platforms since 2023 highin wealth's overdue products have involved a total of 24 issuers with a total overdue amount exceeding 71 billion yen over 10 billion US”
Tony argues that despite the EU having significant leverage over Beijing—possessing a 'huge trade deficit with China' as a block—the EU 'is getting shaky' and 'some analysts think it may even back down watering down the proposed EV tariffs designed to protect local producers from heavily subsidized Chinese imports or abandon them altogether.'
“frankly however it increasingly looks like the EU which on balance as a block with a huge trade deficit with China has much more leverage over Beijing is getting shaky and some analysts think it may even back down watering down the proposed EV tariffs designed to protect local producers from heavily subsidized Chinese Imports or abandon them altogether”
China needs the large EU market to remain open for its EV exports despite claims about market access in the Global South, because 'the developing world does not have the capacity to pick up the slack' from potential loss of EU market access.
“with massive overcapacity and many trade Partners turning to protectionist measures China very much needs the large EU Market to remain open to its EVS despite all the talk of the market of the so-called Global South the developing world does not have the capacity to pick up the slack”
Mid-autumn festival made this holiday one of only a few post-COVID periods to see absolute consumption surpass pre-pandemic levels, but per-trip spending was just 477 yuan, up only 1.6% from 5 years ago, indicating stagnation in actual consumer spending power.
“this makes this holiday one of only a few postco to see absolute consumption surpass pre-pandemic levels however when measured per trip spending amounted to just 477 Yen up only 1.6% from 5 years ago”
The incident involving Leo wender and two other individuals falling from the Hunan finance department building occurred shortly after 9:00 a.m. on Thursday morning, with witnesses hearing two consecutive sounds of objects falling within less than a minute, and the bodies being found after an ambulance arrived approximately 10 minutes later.
“a witness said that the incident occurred shortly after 9:00 a.m. on Thursday morning in a residential Community for finance department employees Leo's body was found lying beneath the highrise building she lived in multiple sources told Chinese media that the other two individuals who fell from the building simultaneously with Leo wiir were connected to Leo's work”
Leo fell from the 13th floor of the Hunan finance department residential building with two open window doors on the balcony visible, and police have been checking nearby surveillance cameras to investigate the incident.
“according to multiple people at the scene Leo fell from the 13th floor where two open window doors on the balcony were visible one local media Outlet reports quote it is understood that strangers usually find it difficult to enter this residential complex a person near the scene mentioned that the police have been checking nearby surveillance cameras End quotes”
During the mid-autumn festival's 3-day period, China's transportation sectors handled 629.56 million passenger trips, up 31.1% year on year, with 425.7 million by railway, 1.98 million by water, 5.07 million by air, and 579.015 billion yen ($7.2 billion) in road traffic across 107 million trips up 6.3%.
“some 62956 million passenger trips were handled by China's Transportation sectors during the 3-day Festival up 31.1% year on year of the total China reached 42.5 7 million passenger trips by Railway 1.98 Million by water and 5.07 Million by air road traffic took the lion share with 579.015 to 51 billion yen $7.2 billion the number of trips increased 6.3% to 107 million”
Hywin Wealth had shown signs of crisis since May 2020 due to rumors of overdue real estate equity projects, with investors gathering at its offices in May 2023 to defend their rights over failed payouts on private equity investment funds.
“before being reported to the police for suspected illegal fundraising highin wealth had already shown signs of crisis in May 2020 due to rumors of overdue real estate Equity projects H and wealth faced investors coming to their offices to defend their rights in May 2023 media reports claimed that multiple investors gathered at the company's headquarters because the private Equity investment funds they purchased failed to meet expected payouts”
EU Trade Commissioner Dombski and Chinese Commerce Minister Wang had negotiations in Brussels on Thursday that were described as 'frank and constructive' by the European Commission, with both sides committing to intensify talks toward a negotiated solution to the EV tariff dispute.
“Wong failed to reach a deal on ending a bitter dispute over electric vehicles during talks in Brussels on Thursday however the sides committed to intensify talks toward finding a negotiated solution to the quarrel including taking a quote renewed look at price undertakings in quote a European commission readout described the lengthy negotiations between EU trade commissioner drosis and Chinese Commerce Minister Wang as quote Frank and constructive end quote doroski said that he and Wang had a productive meeting”
The EU continues its formal investigation into unfair subsidies for Chinese EVs but stated that this investigation will proceed 'without prejudice to' ongoing negotiations, implying the investigation may not lead to tariffs if negotiations succeed.
“The EU made clear to China that it will continue its formal investigation into unfair subsidies for EVS made in China but quote the two sides agreed to take A Renewed look at price undertakings in quote according to Olaf Gil a spokesperson for the European Commission frankly however it increasingly looks like the EU which on balance as a block with a huge trade deficit with China has much more leverage over Beijing is getting shaky”
Han Hongwei, chairman of Hywin Holdings, claimed in December 2023 that a preliminary solution to payment delays due to recent economic downturn had been developed, but this proved false as the company collapsed months later.
“In December 2023 hwin wealth officially stated that due to the recent economic downturn some projects had experienced delays at that time h hongway the chairman of highwind Holdings claimed that a preliminary solution had been developed”
The EU and China agreed to take a 'renewed look at price undertakings' as part of ongoing negotiations on EV tariffs, suggesting the EU may be considering alternative approaches to tariffs such as negotiated price floors rather than blanket tariff measures.
“the two sides agreed to take A Renewed look at price undertakings in quote according to Olaf Gil a spokesperson for the European Commission”
Chinese travel and shopping related shares fell on Wednesday after the mid-autumn festival numbers were published, indicating market skepticism about the consumption recovery narrative.
“the market was not impressed in a telling development Chinese travel and shopping related shares fell on Wednesday after the numbers were published”
The Shanghai Public Security Bureau filed a case against Hywin Wealth Management on September 11 for suspected illegal fundraising crimes and took criminal coercive measures against civilian suspects.
“on September the 11th the funen branch of the Shanghai public Security Bureau announced that it had filed a case for investigation against hwin wealth management Co for suspected illegal fundraising crimes and had taken criminal coercive measures against civil suspects”
Hywin Holdings changed its name to Stic Holdings early 2024 to distance itself from the repayment default scandal, indicating an attempt at corporate reputation management amid investor crisis.
“hn Holdings changed its name to stic Holdings early this year to distance itself from the repayment default County's Financial media Outlet s”