
A History of Philosophy | 66 Dewey's "Reconstructive Philosophy"
What this covers
This is a lecture from a Wheaton College history-of-philosophy series, delivered by a philosophy instructor, on John Dewey's "reconstruction" of philosophy. The instructor sets Dewey against the classical inheritance of substance metaphysics and fixed essences, and then builds an account of what replaces it: people as desiring, acting organisms, thought as a biological function, and knowledge as a capacity to change situations. Francis Bacon's dictum is presented as the watershed, and the lecture ties it to Knowledge as Power as distinct from contemplating essences.
The middle of the lecture works through experience. Dewey's version is contrasted with the thin, atomistic notion in John Locke's empiricism. For Dewey, experience is a continuum with internal relations, shot through with emotion and with memory and anticipation, and it is primarily an affair of doing. The instructor also links this to the Hegelian and evolutionary background, and to the claim that personal identity is grounded in how past and future are integrated in present experience.
The range widens from there. The lecture takes up Dewey's account of ideas as hypotheses, or plans for action, and truth as satisfied desire in a given situation. It covers the Pragmatic Theory of Meaning, under which debates with no practical consequences count as empty, and the Fact-Value Continuum. It also argues that Dewey's problem-solving ethics should not be mistaken for utilitarianism, because it looks to the future and to particular conflicts rather than to fixed rules about aggregate happiness. Dewey's setting between the world wars, and his influence on how political science treats conflict resolution, supply historical context.
Late in the lecture the instructor traces later echoes. Richard Rorty argues that the mirror picture of ideas has failed. W.V.O. Quine's web of belief, naturalized epistemology, and rejection of a fixed analytic-synthetic divide are treated as extensions of Dewey's instrumental outlook. The example that "God is good" can be analytic or synthetic depending on its function in discourse is the most concrete illustration.
John Dewey's philosophical reconstruction reconceives human nature as process rather than substance, experience rather than abstract reason, and redirects philosophy from contemplating eternal truths to solving practical problems through experimental intelligence.
- Classical philosophy based on substance metaphysics and fixed essences; Dewey argues humans are processes of experience, shaped by desire and biological continuity, not rational souls with fixed natures
- Old philosophy sought unchanging universal truths through abstraction; new philosophy applies problem-solving intelligence to concrete situations, testing ideas experimentally rather than deducing from fixed principles
- Knowledge is power to effect change, not contemplation; truth is workability and utility in resolving particular problem situations, not correspondence to eternal ideals
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Classical philosophy operates from a substance metaphysics where an unchanging, qualitatively unchanging entity is basic to everything, with emphasis on soul or body substance, whereas Dewey argues human nature must be understood as process, not substance.
“classical philosophy was substance rather than process in its metaphysics that is to say an unchanging qualitatively unchanging entity is basic to everything”
Human beings are creatures of desire, with concrete experience loaded with emotional orientation and affective attitudes, rather than primarily rational souls with fixed essences.
“human beings are first and foremost creatures of desire because concrete experience comes loaded with emotional orientation with effective attitudes towards past present future”
Francis Bacon's famous dictum 'knowledge is power' emphasizes knowing how to affect change and exercise power rather than contemplation of essences, representing a fundamental watershed between old and new knowledge.
“the kind of knowledge is what was introduced by friends is bacon with his classic dictum the knowledge is power not contemplation of his senses but power not knowledge of the unchanging but knowing how to affect change knowing how to exercise the power to change and that is the the big watershed that distinction”
Human personal identity and consciousness are grounded in experience understood as the way memory of the past and anticipation of the future are integrated in present experience, following the empiricist tradition from John Locke.
“how do we talk about personal identity if it is not as in the empiricist tradition back to john locke in terms of the way in which memory of the past an anticipation of the future are identified with in present experience so it is the matter of experience by virtue of which we have any identity of which were conscious”
In the Hegelian tradition, human consciousness is the lens through which everything is understood, and evolutionary processes can only be described as extensive processes of experience, making life itself fundamentally a matter of experience.
“in the hog alien tradition in which following Kant human consciousness is the lens through which everything is understood and the Hegelian tricia the hag alien tradition with its unfolding of consciousness in the process of history how are you going to describe any evolutionary process and in as much as do we years as we noted last time evolutionary naturalist the the process development is really an extensive process of experience and suddenly for a human being life is experience”
Classical empiricism of Locke was disintegrative in intent, treating ideas as atomistic, isolated, with only external relationships, whereas contemporary philosophy should recognize that in concrete experience there are no isolated units of experience but rather a continuum with internal relations.
“the empiricism of luck was dis integrative in intent now this time last week we were reading a passage from Whitehead which said the same thing you remember that Whitehead said that experience ideas experience for Locke was separative as well as prehensile which was separative and he wants it to be prehensile as well as separative there's to say Locke's ideas are atomistic isolated each and island and day itself and knowing internal into relationships relationships are all external separate”
Experience becomes primarily an affair of doing: the organism acts in accordance with its own structure upon its surroundings, rather than passively waiting for impressions, and this built-in activity creates internal relationships within experience.
“the organism does not stand about micawber like waiting for something to turn up it doesn't wait passive and in nerd for something to impress itself it acts in accordance with its own structure on its surroundings and so you get the built-in relationships because we're creatures of desire in a biological continuum”
Underlying Quine's web of belief is naturalized epistemology—the view that belief arises as part of nature-based psychology and that the value of beliefs is instrumental rather than simply speculative.
“underlying that notion of course is a naturalized epistemology thence to say the the view that belief arises as a part of a nature-based psychology that the value of our beliefs is instrumental rather than simply speculative”
Conflict resolution is a paramount concern in certain aspects of political science, and some people define political science as the science of resolving conflicts, which is a definition derived from John Dewey.
“you see the notion of conflict resolution is one of the Paramount things in certain aspects of political science there are some people who define political science is the science of resolving conflicts this is a John Dewey definition of politics”
Dewey's conception of experience is much richer and more complex than Locke's thin, one-dimensional concept based on simple ideas, and includes emotional and affective orientations toward past, present, and future.
“much richer than that thin sort of one-dimensional concept which john locke has simply made up of simple ideas much richer than that but when you start approaching what is human nature in terms of experience then it's it's understandable that he's going to be saying that human beings are first and foremost creatures of desire because concrete experience comes loaded with emotional orientation with effective attitudes towards past present future the whole thing”
Thought is fundamentally a function of a biological organism in response to experience, which is initially physiologically based and affective, rather than a capacity of a rational soul.
“thought is going to be simply a function of a biological organism in response to experience which initially is being physiologically based is effective initially”
Richard Rorty argued in Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature that the representational view of ideas as mirrors of an otherwise unknown reality (derived from Descartes and Locke) has failed, leaving philosophy with only two alternatives: logical certainty or skepticism.
“his book philosophy and the mirror of nature about whole 10-15 years ago in which the mirror of nature stands for the view that ideas are representations of an otherwise unknown reality the representational view of a Descartes Euler can't so on and so forth and his point is because of the failure of that representational view that thinks that in our minds we have a mirror of nature see because of the failure of that epistemology what is the left for philosophy to expect Yesi in other words for him it's either logical certainty within a representational view or sheer skepticism nothing is knowable”
W.V.O. Quine's web of belief framework describes how ideas, beliefs, and theories interconnect like a spider's web to form a mutually supportive, unified, consistent coherence, rejecting foundationalist approaches where beliefs could be isolated propositions.
“has a little book called the web of belief the web of beliefs in which he talks of the way in which ideas beliefs theories into weaves like a spider's web to form a rather mutually supportive mutually supportive unified consistent hope sort of a coherence to a web of belief what coin is doing you'll see is rejecting any foundationalist approach and is maintaining that beliefs do not come in isolated fashion such that they could be propositions at the end of a syllogistic trope”
Whether a proposition is analytic or synthetic depends on the instrumental function of the proposition—what role it plays in discourse—making pragmatic context determinative of logical status.
“depending on the instrumental function of a proposition get that the instrumental function of a proposition the analytic synthetic status may vary”
Dewey wrote primarily between World War I and World War II (1918-1940), addressing the economic depression, rise of socialism, appearance of communist dictatorship in the Soviet Union, and the failure of World War I as a war to end all wars.
“he's riding this primarily between the two world wars between 1918 and 1940 so he's thinking in terms of the economic depression he's thinking in terms of the the development of socialism throughout the Western world and the appearance of communist dictatorship and the Soviet Union in other words the immense upheavals in the old system politically economically”
Quine repudiated the analytic-synthetic dichotomy, arguing that whether a proposition is analytic or synthetic depends on its context; for example, 'God is good' can be analytic (unfolding the concept of God) or synthetic (asserting a new property) depending on the discourse context and instrumental function.
“at an earlier stage in his work Quine hood repudiated the old analytic synthetic dichotomy criticized it very severely pointing out that for all practical purposes dear as well a belief maybe a statement of proposition rather maybe analytic or synthetic depending on its context that's the contextual distinction”
Truth in Dewey's pragmatism is not a fixed realm but rather having to do with satisfied desire; an idea is true if it is useful in satisfying the desires present in a given situation, just as a road's usefulness is measured by whether it functions effectively for transportation, not by how it serves a highwayman's purposes.
“truth accordingly is not some fixed realm it's rather having to do with satisfied desire that is to say an idea can be regarded as true if it is useful in satisfying the desires that there are in a given situation”
In Dewey's philosophy, ideas are not fixed conceptions or theoretical dogmas but hypotheses understood as plans for action, with instrumental value rather than intrinsic truth-value, their truth measured by their usefulness in satisfying desires in a given situation.
“ideas or hypotheses so that when you're in a mess and you say well I've got an idea of how to get out of this that's the sort of idea doing once yes a an idea is simply a plan for action what can we do about it”
Theoretical debates and attempts at understanding that have no practical consequences are pragmatically meaningless according to the pragmatic theory of meaning, making them irrelevant to Dewey's project.
“so he's not interested then in theoretical debates and understanding for Dewey those are irrelevant why irrelevant notice that word irrelevant because of the pragmatic theory of meaning the term irrelevant means pragmatically meaningless the cash value is laughing”
There is a fact-value continuum in Dewey's philosophy: although the natural world may be value-free in itself, human experience is not value-free because it is fundamentally constituted by desires, and values emerge when survival or other goals are threatened.
“there is a fact value continuum is the way he puts it this is where he breaks with the not only with Plato's dualism but with the Enlightenment dualism of fact and value living in a value free universe you think values are sort of external intuitions no not so for doing it maybe the nature may be in and of itself a value free universe but our experience is not value free our experience is primarily of desires and if survival is threatened then the ideal of survival comes into focus it's valued”
Dewey should not be confused with utilitarianism: utilitarian ethics is rooted in past empirical generalizations and applies fixed ideals of happiness/good across times, whereas Dewey's ethics is future-oriented, focused on particular situations without fixed ideals, and addresses distinctive problems rather than applying general rules.
“his use of the term utility in talking of ideas may tempt you to say that Dewey is a kind of utilitarian but he would categorically repudiate the suggestion”
Classical philosophy consolidated static doctrines arising from the desire to consolidate and retain the past so that past ideals would be perpetuated, whereas Dewey sees experience as ongoing and philosophy as a reflective attitude about desires and conflicts of desire rather than a set of fixed doctrines.
“philosophies doctrines moral beliefs arise out of the desire desire is the key word you see philosophies doctrines moral beliefs arise out of the desire to to consolidate to retain the past so that the ideals that were successful in the past they should be perpetuated and so it's as if we want a quick freeze-dried past and accordingly philosophy of static positions unchanging”
Dewey's approach is not utilitarian because (1) it is oriented to the future rather than the past, (2) it addresses distinctive particular situations rather than generalizations about aggregate happiness, and (3) it is a morality of problem-solving for particular conflicts rather than applying fixed rules.
“this is not then a utilitarian kind of approach first its oriented to the future of the pet rather than the past second the it's oriented to a distinctive particular situation rather than to generalizations about a supreme good the happiness of the maximum number of people or whatever you see and third it's not a morality of rules in any case it's not going to be a morality of rules in any case but rather of how to resolve this conflict”
Dewey's approach to understanding human nature begins with recognizing humans as fundamentally process-oriented, desire-driven, and experientially engaged, which requires a complete reconception of what philosophy should be and what counts as knowledge.
“if we're going to therefore understand human nature and implement a view of human nature into philosophy we we have first of all to think of the human as a process of experience”
The problem in pragmatism is 'nothing buttery'—the reduction of complex phenomena to a single determinant (e.g., reducing truth to workability, reducing meaning to practical consequences).
“the problem is what somebody has called nothing buttery in the definition of meaning and the definition of truth that nothing buttery in addition if definition of meaning definition of truth”
Three core components of the pragmatic theory that Dewey included are: (1) the pragmatic theory of meaning (meaning is found in practical consequences), (2) the experimental test of truth (truth can be tested experimentally), and (3) the definition of truth as workability.
“distinguished in thinking about pragmatism doing included the pragmatic theory of meaning that the meaning of an idea is found in its practical consequences the test of truth that the truth of a theory can be tested experimentally and the definition of truth the truth is nothing but workability”
The development of a biology-based psychology that views organisms as active, continuously adapted to their environment rather than passive and waiting for impressions has changed the understanding of experience from atomistic to continuous.
“the development of a psychology based on biology this is his functionalist psychology he picks up on that first of all in the immediate paragraphs that follow where he says that the effect of the development of biology is that where there is life there is activity activity which is continuous adapted to environment not passive”
The value of the heritage of learning lies in enriching the human fund of experience from which to draw in solving future problems, based on the principle that those who neglect the past will repeat its mistakes, but the reason for examining the past is not to understand eternal truths but to gain resources for addressing future situations.
“the the value of the heritage of learning it is in enriching the human fund of experience on which to draw in problem situations in the spirit of the adage that he who neglects the past will repeat the mistakes of the past but you see the reason for examining the past is not to understand some eternal truths about human nature or history but rather to have resources for future”
The old logic was formal and deductive, seeking certainty through abstract reasoning, while Dewey's new logic is experiential (experimental), structuring the pattern of thought needed for problem-solving through observation, recognition of what is at stake, and testing of ideas.
“experimental thinking it begins with observation of what the problem is with recognition of what is at stake the values that emerge the values that are threatened the values that are possible”
Every problem situation is unique and somewhat different from other problem situations, so Dewey's approach addresses a distinctive particular situation rather than applying general moral rules derived from past empirical generalizations about aggregate happiness.
“every probe situation is going to be somewhat different from any other problem situation he's not speaking of general rules for the maximum number of people's happiness yes a general rules based on empirical generalizations in the past he's addressing a new problem”
The knowledge Dewey seeks is knowledge of the future in the form of hypotheses suggested by past experience, from which one deduces what is likely to happen if the hypothesis is true, but since the hypothesis concerns the future, one never knows if it will be true.
“the knowledge that you want is not of empirical generalizations from which you deduce something but rather a hypothesis that is oh yes suggests did not deduced suggested by funded experience from the past but from the hypothesis you then turn d deuce what is likely to happen if the hypothesis is true but you don't know if it's true because it's true of if it's true at all of the future”
The real problem of evil for Dewey is not the theoretical logical problem of how purposeless evil is consistent with a good omnipotent God, but the practical problem of what we can do about evil.
“he says the real problem of evil is not the theoretical one but the practical one it's not a logical problem how can you make the existence of purposeless evil seemingly purposeless evil logically consistent with the existence of a God who is altogether good wise and powerful that's the logical problem no the real problem of evil is the practical one what can we do about it”
Dewey seeks to extend Bacon's vision of knowledge as power from natural science to social sciences and human sciences, applying problem-solving techniques to social problems, political issues, and international problems.
“what doing once you see is the same sort of power released in changing human experience now to the social sciences to the human sciences and consequently his thought is that the problem-solving techniques which his new logic develops remember we were commenting briefly on that last time that the problem-solving capacity of knowledge can be applied to the human condition to social problems political issues international problems”
Philosophy should work toward developing specific means for resolving problem situations as they arise, rather than deriving changes from eternal and universal unchanging principles, which is situation ethics applied to public policy.
“what he wants of course is that the changes in society should be from some investment in eternal and universal and unchanging principles to the development of specific means for resolving problem situations as they arise an ad hoc sort of thing else situation ethics applied to public policy”
Dewey's reconception of reason and experience directly changes educational philosophy: rather than teaching people the art of abstraction and logical deduction needed for grasping eternal truths, education should develop practical problem-solving intelligence that can address situations as they arise.
“you can see with that changed conception of experience why his conception of education was so different because you're not - now trying to teach people the art of dialectic or of abstraction Plato Aristotle dialectic or abstraction which are needed for grasping eternal truths universal principles now rather what you're doing is trying to develop in people the kind of practical intelligence which can find something workable to do when some problem situation arises”
Dewey's repudiation of fixed forms and essences from Plato and Aristotle reflects modern Darwinian evolutionary theory, which shows there are no fixed species or closed definitions, only open-ended evolutionary processes with no predetermined hierarchy or natural law basis.
“the modern version in the light of Darwinian theory of natural selection is that there are no fixed species there are no fixed forms this is an open-ended evolutionary process an open world rather than a closed one and that means of course that there is no feudal hierarchy there is no natural law as a basis for jurisprudence”
Not all contemporary philosophers agree with Rorty's conclusion that philosophy cannot establish truth; the fact that many philosophers continue to practice philosophy suggests there are alternative epistemological approaches beyond representationalism and skepticism.
“you can tell obviously that other people don't agree with him because not everybody has left philosophy and obviously what's happened is that there is a third alternative namely other epistemological directions that aren't representational as in that 19th 18th century sense which should be no surprise those never were the only two alternative skepticism or complete certainty”
Fixed forms and ends in nature paralyze constructive human inventions and condemn efforts to produce and regulate change to failure; it was only when fixed ends were banished from nature that purposes became important as factors in human minds capable of reshaping existence.
“fixed forms and ends mark fixed limits to change they make few whole human attempts to produce and regulate change except within narrow limits they paralyze constructive human inventions burr theory which condemns them in advance to failure it wasn't until fixed inns were banished from nature the purposes became important as factors in human minds capable of reshaping existence”
Dewey argues that in modern times the special problem of philosophical reconstruction is that we have obtained command of nature through science but have not yet systematically applied this command to the relief of human suffering, with applications remaining mostly incidental.
“while we've been reasonably successful in obtaining command of nature by means of science look at the technological revolution our science is not yet such that this command is systematically pre-eminently applied to the relief of the human estate such applications occur that are incidental”
The classical philosophical problem has never been simply between skepticism and absolute certainty; alternative epistemological directions exist that have always been available beyond this false dichotomy.
“those never were the only two alternative skepticism or complete certainty”
The contemporary popular use of the term 'reality' to mean 'what is real in my experience' rather than 'what is real in itself' makes it difficult for beginning students to understand metaphysics, and this shift reflects the movement of thought from 19th century German philosophy into existentialism.
“in our day there's a popular use of the term reality which makes it difficult for beginning students I'm finding to get a handle on what is metaphysics because the popular use of the term reality is what's real in my experience rather than what is real in itself you get the difference metaphysics is concerned with the thing in itself reality but reality has come to mean there reality of my experience well that's part of this whole movement of thought out of the 19th century German tradition into yah will see it into existentialism and so forth”
The ordinary consciousness of an ordinary person is primarily a creature of desires and is activated by hopes and fears; only when subjected to a discipline foreign and artificial to human nature does consciousness become primarily oriented toward intellectual study and inquiry.
“the ordinary consciousness of the ordinary man that's what he's after the ordinary consciousness of the ordinary person experience left to himself is a creature of desires the consciousness is a creature of desires rather than of intellectual study inquiry or speculation ceases to be primarily activated by hopes fears and so forth only when he subjected to a discipline that's foreign the human nature which from the standpoint of the natural is artificial”
Reason in classical philosophy was conceived as a faculty separate from experience, introducing us to a superior realm of universal truths, but Dewey argues that reason is rather intelligent thinking arising in the course of experience, employing concrete suggestions from the past as methods to resolve problem situations.
“reason was supposed separate from experience introducing us to a superior region of the universal truths reason as a county and faculty that introduces generality and regularity strikes as more and more superfluous the unnecessary creation of men addicted to traditional formalism and elaborate terminology”
Dewey rejects Plato's dichotomy between ideal and real: ideals do not exist in a transcendent realm but rather emerge as problems occur, with the ideal being the resolution of the particular problem that one seeks.
“he is simply rejecting plato's dichotomy of the ideal and the real we've noted that Dewey and Whitehead alike very impatient with all of the traditional dualisms mind and body Riel ideal and actual his point is that there is no platonic realm of transcendent ideals unchanging eternal ideals no ideals simply arise as problems occur the ideal is the resolution of the problem that you want”
Pragmatism in Rorty's work involves acceptance of a pragmatic theory of meaning and truth, which allows him to argue that since representational epistemology has failed, philosophy need not pursue logical certainty but can operate within pragmatic frameworks.
“the pragmatism in it is in part here's working within the book we do his ideas along with others and the acceptance of simply a pragmatic theory of meaning and truth because that was the way to say all that's left for philosophy if the representational theory is missing”
The utilitarian ethic has continuity across time in that it operates from a fixed ideal (maximum happiness) that extends from past into future, whereas Dewey has no such continuity; values are situational and different in each problem situation.
“the utilitarian is doing so with regards to some fixed ideal which extends from the past on into the future that fixed ideal being whatever the utilitarian particular utilitarian in mind defines as the highest good for the maximum number of people but it's always that there is this conception of a fixed end our highest good which applies in the past and in the future you have that continuity now we do it you don't have that continuity there is no highest end values our situational goods our situational”
In progressive education, the classroom should be a situation where problem situations arise and people are free to explore the fund of ideas available in books or from experience and to come up with appropriate ways of handling them, rather than systematically developing abstract intellectual ability.
“ideally the classroom is the situation in which as problem situations arise so people are free to explore the fund of ideas which may be in the books in the classroom or in people's own experience and to come up with appropriate ways of handling the thing rather than the systematic kind of attempt to develop intellectual ability which can abstract and work logically from things which are abstracted”
If nothing can be proven (as Rorty argues), then philosophy is left with only the possibility of an interesting conversation among alternative positions, which is why Rorty has moved from philosophy to humanities at Virginia.
“if nothing is knowable for sure if the truth cannot be demonstrated then we simply have a whole variety of alternative positions and the most we can hope for is an interesting conversation which is some people think why he moved to Virginia to humanities”
Dewey's style of writing is dialectical rather than linear, more like Hegel than like Descartes or Hume, in that it unfolds a concept by contrasting thesis of the old with antithesis of the new, with repetition and reworking throughout.
“it's not difficult you have to get used to his style he writes in English rather than German but his style is rather like Hegel's in the sense that it is not linear thinking moving step by step from one proposition to another such as you find in sane law for Hume it's more dialectical thinking at taking a concept and unraveling it in a thesis antithesis synthesis sort of style so it's more a matter of unfolding a concept by contrasting the thesis of the old with the antithesis of the new”
Richard Rorty placed the contemporary debate about religious pluralism in the context of post-modernism, which rejects Enlightenment epistemology with its attempts to prove positions true and instead accepts subjective relativism since the Copernican revolution showed that nothing could be proven.
“what he did was to put the whole contemporary debate about religious pluralism in the context of post-modernism yes the religious pluralism debate is over the over the the tendency to regard different religious positions as equally acceptable as relative so that no truth judgments can be made between one on the other now in trying to then help the audience understand how come a position like that could arise he said it as arisen within the ethos of post-modernism you see which rejects the Enlightenment kinds of epistemology with its attempts to prove a position truth pops instead for such degrees of subjectivity ever since the Copernican revolution that nothing could be proven”
Dewey died in the 1950s, but pragmatism continues to have influence in contemporary philosophy, including in the work of W.V.O. Quine and Richard Rorty.
“a word about pragmatism today due he died in the nineteen fifties but pragmatism continues to have its influence of contemporary work and you find it in a number of individuals the two that I think I said we had take note of one is WVO Quine at Harvard”