
Alan Watts on the One Thing Hinduism, Buddhism, and Taoism All Lack
What this covers
This six-minute talk is a single speaker, Alan Watts, working through a question of definition: what the word "religion" actually names. He goes back to the Latin sense of a bond or rule of life, best preserved in the phrase "going into religion," meaning entering a monastic order and living under obedience. From there he sorts traditions by whether they rest on an obedient response to divine revelation, and he argues that the Judeo-Christian tradition and Islam fit while Hinduism, Buddhism, and Taoism do not.
The middle of the talk lays out what he calls the three C's. The creed is the revealed map of the universe and of God's will. The code is the revealed law or exemplar, which in Christianity becomes a person, Jesus of Nazareth, followed through divine grace rather than legal duty. The cult is the revealed way of worship through prayer, rite, and sacrament. Here Watts draws on Meister Eckhart to describe worship as God's own love for himself, with humans acting as instruments. He gives the recitation of the psalms in the divine office as an example.
The more contentious turn is his claim that this whole structure is a political metaphor. He traces the language of "king of kings" to Persian rulers such as Cyrus of Persia, reads Anglican morning prayer as court flattery, and describes an ontological difference between a monarch-God and everything he creates. Eastern traditions, in his account, lack this monarchical picture and the obedience that goes with it. He closes on an open tension in American life: a belief in republican government held alongside a monarchical picture of the cosmos, which makes the idea of democracy in the kingdom of God sound subversive.
The speaker argues that 'religion' in its strict etymological sense applies only to traditions based on obedient response to divine revelation (Christianity, Judaism, Islam), not to Hinduism, Buddhism, or Taoism, which lack the hierarchical monarchical model of the divine-human relationship that defines Western religion.
- Religion derives from Latin 'religare' meaning 'bond or rule of life' and requires obedience to divinely revealed authority
- Western religions share three C's (creed, code, cult) rooted in monarchical metaphor borrowed from Persian emperors
- Eastern traditions lack obedience virtue and do not conceive the Godhead as monarchically related to mankind or universe
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The model of the universe underlying the Judeo-Christian tradition is a political model based on the metaphor of an ancient Near Eastern monarch's relationship to his subjects, in which the monarch imposes his authority and will upon subjects from above by power (whether physical or spiritual), and this monarchical model has been borrowed from Persian emperors such as Cyrus of Persia (Kyrios, hence 'Kyrie eleison').
“the model which lies behind the Judeo-Christian tradition, if there really is such a thing, is a political model. It is based on using the metaphor of the relation of an ancient near eastern monarch to his subjects. And he imposes his authority and his will upon his subjects from above by power, whether it be physical power or spiritual power.”
The word 'religion' should be used strictly according to its Latin root meaning 'bond or rule of life,' most correctly applied when describing someone who has joined a religious or monastic order and lives under obedience to a rule of life.
“I like to use the word religion rather strictly...I want to use it in an exact sense from its Latin root which really means a bond or rule of life.”
The political ordering principle reflected in Anglican morning prayer—where God is addressed as 'Almighty and everlasting God, king of kings, lord of lords'—exemplifies how the court flattery language drawn from earthly monarchs is applied to the divine, establishing an ontological difference between God (the monarch) and creation (subjects).
“in the say the Anglican Church, when the priest at morning prayer addresses the throne of grace, he says, 'Almighty and everlasting God, king of kings, lord of lords, the only ruler of princes, who does from thy throne behold all the dwellers upon earth, most heartily we beseech thee with thy favor to behold our sovereign majesty Elizabeth the Queen and all the royal family.' Now, what are these words? This is the language of court flattery.”
In Christian worship, particularly in the mass and the recitation of the divine office using the Psalms, the metaphysical idea is that worship operates as God's way of loving himself through human participation, not merely man's way of worshipping God—such that humans become instruments through which divine action flows, following Meister Eckhart's principle that 'the love with which I love God is the same love wherewith God loves me.'
“The Christian religion, say in the mass, would say that we worship God with God's own worship, following the saying of Meister Eckhart, that great German mystic, the love with which I love God is the same love wherewith God loves me.”
Christianity, Judaism, and Islam are religions because they are based on the idea of man's obedient response to a divine revelation, whereas other traditions like Hinduism, Buddhism, and Taoism cannot be called religions in this sense because they significantly lack the virtue of obedience.
“If Christianity is a religion, if Judaism is a religion, if Islam is a religion, they are based on the idea of man's obedient response to a divine revelation.”
Between God (the monarch) and all created beings (angels, men, or other forms of existence), there exists an essential difference of kind—an ontological difference—such that God is God and creatures are not God, creating a vast metaphysical gulf between the divine domain and the created domain.
“between the monarch and the subject, there is a certain essential difference of kind, what we might call an ontological difference, so that God is God and all those creatures, whether angels or men or other kinds of existence which God has created, are not God.”
In Christianity, the code is not primarily revealed as a law but as a person—Jesus of Nazareth—and therefore obedience to the code operates not through legal obligation but through the power of divine grace and following Jesus rather than following a law.
“In the case of Christianity, there's a certain variation in this because the principal revelation of the code aspect of things in Christianity as well as the cult is not so much a law as a person. God is said in Christianity to be supremely revealed in the historic Jesus of Nazareth. And so, the code here becomes really the following of Jesus of Nazareth, not so much in obedience to a law as through the power of divine grace.”
Eastern traditions (Hinduism, Buddhism, Taoism) do not conceive the Godhead as related to mankind or the universe in a monarchical sense, lacking the hierarchical obedience structure that characterizes Western religions.
“They do not conceive the Godhead as related to mankind or to the universe in a monarchical sense.”
A fundamental tension exists in American society because citizens believe a republic is the best form of government, yet many members of American society also believe (or feel they should believe) that the universe operates as a monarchy, which creates pressure toward obedience to law and order and makes democracy in the kingdom of God seem subversive to those holding this monarchical worldview.
“How can this be maintained if the government of the universe is a monarchy? For surely in that case a monarchy will be the best form of government. And many of the conflicts in our society arise from the fact that although we are running a republic, many of the members of this republic believe or believe that they ought to believe that the universe is a monarchy and therefore they are above all insistent upon obedience to law and order.”
The three C's that characterize Western religions are: (1) the creed, which is the divinely revealed map of the universe and revelation of God's existence and will; (2) the code, which is the divinely revealed law or exemplar that man is supposed to follow; and (3) the cult, which is the divinely revealed method or way of worship through which man relates to God by prayers, rites, and sacraments.
“religion as we understand it in these three forms of religion consist really of three things. We will call them the three C's, the creed, the code, and the cult. The creed is the divinely revealed map of the universe, the nature of things, the revelation of the existence of God, of Allah, Yahweh, or as we say God, and his existence and his will and his design of the universe.”