What this covers

This lecture by Michael Sugrue, the third in his Bible and Western Culture series, reads Shakespeare's Measure for Measure through genre and then through allegorical correspondence. He begins with the difference between comedy and tragedy: comedies end in marriage and tragedies end in death. He argues that tragedy is a pagan form resting on a fatalistic worldview that leaves no room for redemption. Tragic heroes such as Othello are specific individuals, whereas comic figures like Don Juan work as types we still apply to people today. Plato's remark at the end of the Symposium, that one artist could write both tragedy and comedy, is offered as the background for Shakespeare's achievement here. One claim, that the tragic hero's fate always carries a realization about the human condition, is flagged as contested.

The second half walks through the cast. The Duke is God, who departs, delegates, returns in disguise and judges by deeds and intentions. Angelo embodies Platonic perfectionism: he believes he is immune to temptation, and he falls through lust, the sin tied to the Fall of Man. Sugrue says the Duke tests him because if the best man in Vienna cannot hold power without corruption, no one can dispense divine justice. Isabella's refusal to yield turns out to be the only path that could have saved Claudio. Angelo's Machiavellian turn after the bed trick is read as a case of one sin leading to another.

Other figures get their own readings. Lucio is the Devil, Escalus stands for Greek wisdom, and Claudio for fallen humanity. The brothel characters supply the slapstick that keeps the play a comedy. Sugrue spends time on the ending: Angelo's confession, Mariana's plea for his life, and the sparing of Lucio, which he treats as comic redemption extended even to the Devil. The title itself is traced to Matthew 7:1-2, and Vienna, a Babylon-like city of man, is changed by the Duke's return.

Sharpest takeaway

Shakespeare's Measure for Measure is a Christian allegory recapitulating the entire Bible as comedy, where the Duke represents God's omniscient judgment, Angelo represents prideful human perfectionism, and Isabella represents the Church's merciful intercession—demonstrating that mercy and justice are inseparable in divine judgment.

  • Comedy characteristically ends in marriage and reintegration into society, making it theologically compatible with Christian redemption in ways tragedy (which ends in death) cannot be
  • Every major character embodies Christian symbolism: the Duke as God/Yahweh, Angelo as Platonic perfectionism/the state, Isabella as the Church, Lucio as the Devil, and the bed trick as the substitution that saves through hidden providence
  • The play's title and repeated imagery of measure-for-measure judgment directly reference Matthew 7:1-2 and the book of Revelation, establishing divine judgment that combines perfect justice with mercy as the play's theological core

The claims · ranked34 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.74

The title 'Measure for Measure' comes directly from Matthew 7:1-2, which states 'Judge not that you be not judged, for with what judgment you judge you shall be judged; for the measure you give will be the measure you get back,' establishing the play's theme about justice and mercy.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unknown Lecturer

“consider just briefly the title measure for measure those of you that know the gospels perhaps know matthew chapter 7 verses 1 and 2 where it says judge not that you may not be judged for with what judgment you judge you yourself shall be judged for the measure you give will be the measure you get back yes indeed this is a play about justice and it's about mercy and it's about the possibility of extending charity to all people because all human governments are made up of frail and fallible and sinful people who are themselves in need of charity and mercy along with justice the measure you give will be the measure you get back”

0.70

Isabella's argument that she would never ask Angelo as his judge to be merciful to her as a supplicant, and therefore Angelo should grant her mercy—the Golden Rule—represents the highest Christian ethical teaching.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unknown Lecturer

“the argument that she's making there is the golden rule if i were the judge and you came pleading to me for clemency i would give it to you but here you deny it to me and insist on sexual blackmail you would corrupt me and you would corrupt yourself and you would corrupt politics far worse than it was before”

0.68

Tragic heroes characteristically meet a realization about the human condition before death, discovering their fatal flaw and finding that there is no recourse for human beings, that all die, and that even superior people cause their own destruction.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Lecturer

“before their death a tragic hero always meets some realization about the human condition finds out about their fatal flaw and the consequence of that is that they realize something about the human condition tragedy is a very fatalistic sort of dramatic form”

0.66

Comedy and tragedy characteristically end differently: comedies end in marriage while tragedies end in death, and this difference reflects deeper structural contrasts in how each genre views human existence and continuity.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unknown Lecturer

“comedies end in marriage tragedies end in death if you think of things like the greek tragedies almost all of greek tragic heroes have some fatal flaw do something wrong make a mess of their lives and at the end of it they die”

0.61

The custom of calling a promiscuous young man a 'Don Juan' demonstrates that Don Juan is not a specific historical person but rather a type—the archetype of the promiscuous man—which is why we apply the name typologically to contemporary behavior.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Lecturer

“suppose we had a young man who was excessively attracted to women and slept around a lot we might be tempted to say he's a real don juan the reason why is that don juan is not a specific person don juan is the type of the promiscuous man”

0.61

Plato, at the end of the Symposium, argues that the same artist could write great tragedies and great comedies, a possibility that very few have lived up to but which Shakespeare demonstrates in Measure for Measure.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Lecturer

“i believe it was plato at the end of the symposium that says that the same artist could write great tragedies and great comedies well very few have lived up to that possibility shakespeare has decided that he shall now measure for measure”

0.61

In Measure for Measure, there is a series of minor comic relief characters (Elbow, Pompe, Froth, Mistress Overdone) who are patrons and proprietors of a brothel and whose function is to prevent the play from becoming too serious, maintaining its status as a comedy through slapstick elements.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Lecturer

“there is first of all a series of minor characters that have no real symbolic importance these are elbow pompe froth and mistress overdone and they are the patrons of a brothel and mistress overdone is the proprietor of a brothel and these people offer us throughout the course of the play at various critical moments comic relief and comic relief is very important in a comedy that means to encapsulate all of christianity in other words it would fail in its comic purpose if it didn't have certain slapstick elements in it you would lose the sense of it being a comedy it would be far too serious so shakespeare knowing how to balance these things has written in in an oblique way comic relief that is not part of the essential structure symbolically of the play”

0.57

Shakespeare's Measure for Measure represents an extraordinary intellectual achievement: the attempt to recapitulate the entire Bible and the entirety of Christian history in the allegorical form of a single comedy.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Unknown Lecturer

“first that shakespeare is hunting intellectual big game in measure for measure he is actually trying to recapitulate the entire bible in the form of a comedy which is an amazing intellectual achievement and also it marks an apogee of intellectual aspiration and ambition even if he doesn't completely pull this off the idea of reducing the entire the entirety of the bible and more importantly the entirety of the christian view of history to one narrative taking the form the allegorical form of a comedy”

0.57

Tragedy is intrinsically a non-Christian, fundamentally pagan art form because it rests on a fatalistic worldview that denies redemption, whereas Christianity necessarily includes the possibility of divine judgment and salvation after death.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Unknown Lecturer

“i would like to take it a little bit further and make a more complicated argument i would like to argue that tragedy is intrinsically a non-christian art form the tragedy is intrinsically pagan think about the way in which a tragedy characteristically ends greek tragedy is a good example choose something like antigone the end of the play she dies what she finds out is that she has had some terrible flaw and she has somehow been the cause of her own demise the point of tragedy both greek tragedy and shakespearean tragedy is that this superior hero finds out something about themselves that they didn't know before and they also find out something about the human condition and when they find this out about the human condition that there is no recourse for human beings that eventually we all die and even superior people cause their own destruction we are left with a very fatalistic outlook on life”

0.56

Angelo, having committed sin with Mariana (thinking he was with Isabella) in the bed trick, realizes that one sin leads to another and that he cannot merely let Claudio live; he must kill Claudio to conceal his crime, and thus he becomes a Machiavellian politician who double-crosses Isabella.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unknown Lecturer

“there's no such thing as sin in the singular realizes that he is now an utterly machiavellian individual suppose he lets claudio go and suppose he knows that he has bought his life at the cost of his sister's salvation and that he is damned and she's damned as a consequence of this he may be inclined to take revenge in this world so angelo says he sends off a note to the uh to the jail immediately execute claudio in other words he double crosses the nun that he thinks he has taken advantage of because he has become an utterly machiavellian politician”

0.56

The path of religious morality—Isabella's refusal to compromise her virtue—turns out to be not only ethically correct but also practically the only path to save her brother's life; Angelo would have executed Claudio even if Isabella had yielded.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unknown Lecturer

“suppose he lets claudio go and suppose he knows that he has bought his life at the cost of his sister's salvation and that he is damned and she's damned as a consequence of this he may be inclined to take revenge in this world so angelo says he sends off a note to the uh to the jail immediately execute claudio in other words he double crosses the nun that he thinks he has taken advantage of because he has become an utterly machiavellian politician so it turns out that if she had had sex with him her brother would have died anyway in fact the path of religious morality turns out to be the best of all practical paths as well not succumbing is the only way to keep herself open to salvation and to keep her brother alive”

0.56

Angelo's downfall comes through the sin of lust—specifically the sin connected with the Fall of Man at the beginning of the Bible—a sin he had never experienced before and believed himself incapable of experiencing.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unknown Lecturer

“he's going to try and stand in for the duke but it will turn out that our would-be angel our would-be perfect man is incapable of perfection and sin particularly the sin of lust the sin which is connected with the fall of man at the beginning of the bible turns out to be his downfall a sin that he had never experienced before”

0.56

The Duke tests Angelo because he knows Angelo is the man of highest moral character in his kingdom, and if such a superior individual is incapable of bearing political power without corruption, then no human being can dispense God's justice.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unknown Lecturer

“there is a saying that absolutely power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely well when the duke leaves he leaves under very mysterious circumstances we don't quite know why he would do that it turns out that he wishes to test angelo because he knows that of all the men in his kingdom angelo is the one of the highest moral character and if it turns out that angelo is incapable of bearing the responsibility of political power that means that there is no human being that can dispense god's justice and if that's the case then the idea of perfecting society ignoring the tragic insight that human beings are essentially flawed and incapable of perfection this play is an elaborate christian criticism of that stance”

0.56

Angelo, confronted with his true nature and condemning himself, undergoes a powerful change of heart: he accepts that he was wrong to believe in his own perfection, confesses his sins, and asks only for immediate death.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unknown Lecturer

“angelo has a powerful and remarkable change of heart here angelo says i deserve it the only thing that i crave of you my lord is that you should kill me immediately i finally realize what i am and i'm forced to confront the fact that i am not the man who would be who could be perfect i thought that i could and i failed so all i merit now is death give it to me”

0.56

The Duke, the ruler of Vienna, represents God/Yahweh in the allegorical structure: he departs mysteriously, delegates authority to others, returns later in disguise, and ultimately judges everyone based on their deeds while seeing into their intentions.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unknown Lecturer

“the first is the duke now the duke is the ruler of vienna the city in which this play is set and the duke in the beginning of the play leaves for no reason that's obvious to the people involved and he delegates his authority to two people angelo and and when he leaves he returns later on at the end of the play and judges in disguise and removes his disguise and comes back to judge everyone who has been wicked during the course of the play and that sounds specifically and suspiciously like the end of the world”

0.56

Angelo represents Platonic perfectionism and the belief that one can achieve moral perfection through reason and will; his name itself signals this predisposition, and he believes himself immune to temptation because he has never experienced the sins he sees in others.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unknown Lecturer

“the other element in the greek tradition that's re that obs that gets this authority from the absent duke is named angelo and the name itself gives away angelo's predispositions angelo is the man who thinks that he can be perfect angelo represents the tradition of platonic perfectionism angelo thinks that since he has never been tempted by the various sins that he sees in other people that he is immune to them he believes that he's better than they are he believes that he's capable of standing in for the duke”

0.56

Lucio represents the Devil/Satan in the play: he is a tempter, a great patron of the brothel, involved in comic relief scenes, skilled at blaspheming, and his function is to set virtue against itself rather than to promote virtue directly.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unknown Lecturer

“the first will be lucio now you can guess who lucio is from his name he's lucifer he's the devil he's the tempter and he's a great patron of the house that has been recently pulled down that and he's involved in many of the scenes of comic relief and in addition not only is a hellion and not only is he a tempter he is great at blaspheming he is great at saying that he knows the duke well and he knows full well that the duke likes to drink and likes to uh to chase women and has a great many moral vices”

0.56

Lucio is married to a woman from the brothel (representing the whore of Babylon) in order to make her child legitimate and to legitimize his own responsibility toward her.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unknown Lecturer

“in addition to that i think you should get married too because in the course of the play it turns out that not only has he been frequenting a brothel but he the brother he's been frequenting he has gotten one of the uh the in this bravo with an illegitimate child she says before i hang you i'm going to whip you and before i do any of that i'm going to have you married off so that all your property goes to this and to her child may i suggest that what we have here is lucio the devil being married off to the of babylon that's what the symbolism is yes indeed the of babylon is going to be married off to lucille and he is forgiven even he gets a certain degree of mercy he has forgiven the whipping he has forgiven the hanging all he has to do is make an honest woman of her and make her child legitimate”

0.56

Vienna has been a corrupt city—a City of Man (Babylon in biblical symbolism)—but the Duke's return will transform it into a sacred city through final judgment, mercy, and restoration.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unknown Lecturer

“think back to the bible of all the imagery of holy and profane cities of babylon and jerusalem well it would seem then that for a large part of the history of vienna it has been a sort of corrupt city a city of man rather than a city of god it has been a sword of babylon but this babylon will be transformed this whole world will be moved from the profane to the sacred when the duke comes back”

0.55

The foregiving of Lucio's whipping and hanging in exchange for marriage represents the greatest achievement of comic redemption: even the Devil gets a certain degree of mercy and is restored to society rather than destroyed.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Unknown Lecturer

“i would venture the guest that her child is named sin and this is perhaps the greatest achievement of comic r now there are many more symbolic elements that i could pull out of this”

0.53

Escalus represents Greek wisdom in the allegorical structure: he is a wise old man who understands human frailties and the impossibility of creating a perfect political order, constantly arguing for mercy given the limitations of human nature.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unknown Lecturer

“the two people that he leaves in charge i want to call them the personifications of greek wisdom the two people he leaves in charge are named escalus and angelo escolus did not get his name accidentally escalus is a wise old man who understands human frailties and human flaws he's constantly arguing for mercy given the fact that people cannot always meet the standard of the law escolas understands human frailty and the impossibility of creating a perfect political order”

0.52

We do not apply tragic hero names typologically to contemporary individuals in the way we do comic types; calling a jealous man 'an Othello' does not feel natural, whereas calling a promiscuous man 'a Don Juan' does, because tragic heroes are specific individuals while comic types are abstract categories.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Lecturer

“let's juxtapose that same young man instead of sleeping around a lot let's imagine that he's very jealous about the woman in his life none of us would be tempted to say he's a real othello even though othello himself was a man whose tragic flaw was his excessive jealousy the point is othello is a specific person and we are not inclined to make the analogy from othello or hamlet or king lear to people in the world around us on the other hand comic heroes heroes that are not quite as grand as the tragic strutting and roaring are much more like us and as a consequence of that they become indistinguishable types they are kinds of people”

0.52

Claudio, Isabella's brother, represents fallen humanity: he has been caught in fornication and gotten his betrothed with child, and his condemnation to death by Angelo sets the plot in motion.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unknown Lecturer

“another key figure in this play he has somewhat of a minor role but he sets the ball rolling in terms of the plot is named claudio claudio is isabella's brother and claudio has been caught in fornication he has gotten his betrothed with child and as a result of that when the duke leaves because there have been a considerable amount of license in in vienna when the duke leaves angelo passes judgment on claudio he says claudio you must die for your sins”

0.52

Mariana, a prodigy of kindness and good nature, begs the Duke for mercy toward Angelo despite his treatment of her, and asks Isabella to join her in pleading for Angelo's life.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unknown Lecturer

“at that point marianna a prodigy of kindness and good nature prays to the duke please do not condemn my husband for all his faults for all his evils i love him and i ask that you grant him mercy and the duke is not initially swayed and then she says to isabella isabella lend me your knees kneel and pray ask the duke for mercy and clemency”

0.51

The futility of Platonic perfectionism is demonstrated through Angelo's proposition: the attempt to create a perfect individual or political order is bound to result in worse moral conditions because it ignores human fallibility and the need for charity.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unknown Lecturer

“the attempt to create a perfect political order or to create a perfect individual human being is bound to result in a worse condition morally so the futility of platonic perfectionism is played up here and the idea that the man who would be perfect is in fact a white and sepulcher is in fact a hypocrite is in fact worse than the people he judges is all built into this very powerful very ironic scene”

0.51

Isabella, a novice nun, represents the Christian Church in the allegorical structure: her virginity symbolizes uncorrupted selfhood and freedom from sinful nature, and her role is to represent the Church's relationship to political power (the state represented by Angelo).

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unknown Lecturer

“another key figure in this play is isabella isabella is a novice nun she has not taken her final vows yet but she is extremely pious extremely devoted she spends a great deal of time praying and fasting and involved in mortification of the flesh and she is virgin the key thing here is not virginity by itself but rather virginity as a symbol of uncorrupted selfhood of a lack of a sinful inc sinful nature or at least not succumbing to the temptations of sin she will maintain her chastity throughout the play may i suggest that she may well represent the christian church in fact isabella is an attempt to talk about the relationship between church and state and her interaction with angelo the man that would be perfect will turn out to be most intriguing for understanding of how the christian will view history”

0.51

Angelo does not meet the tragic end of a tragic hero—death—but rather the comic ending of restored life, which is the central structural difference between the tragedy Angelo might have starred in and the comedy Measure for Measure actually is.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unknown Lecturer

“in some ways angelo has many of the qualities of a tragic hero the big difference is that angelo does not meet the end of a tragic hero he meets the end of a comic hero because at the end of the play he is not given death but life”

0.50

Shakespeare was likely not himself a devout Christian, but rather an intellectual show-off demonstrating his ability to organize an entire work of art from the Christian perspective to prove he was the ultimate literary artist capable of mastering any genre.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Lecturer

“i don't mean to say that shakespeare himself was a christian i doubt that very much the man that could write king lear does not have any great hope of eternal salvation and eternal life the man who writes such fine tragedies must have a heavy dose of the pagan in him my feeling is rather that shakespeare is the most extraordinary of intellectual switch hitters he was able to produce both comedy and tragedy and when he was producing this particular comedy in 1604 he decided that he would go and organize this work of art completely from the christian perspective not because he was a devout christian like someone like saint augustine but rather because he was intellectually showing off he wanted to show that he was the ultimate literary artist and that he could write the best possible play in any sort of genre so i think that the intellectual ambitions of measure for measure do not reflect shakespeare's christian leanings they actually reflect something much more like pagan vanity”

0.49

Angelo directly confronts Isabella by proposing sexual blackmail: he will pardon her brother only if she gives him her virginity, knowingly asking her to commit a mortal sin that would damn her soul eternally.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unknown Lecturer

“when Isabella comes back on the second day to angelo he directly confronts her he says look i tell you what i will pardon your brother but i will only pardon him if you have sex with me you must give up your virginity and you must give up your possibility of being safe remember this is a mortal sin she will be damned for all time as a consequence of this on the other hand her brother will be allowed to live”

0.49

The Devil (Lucio) does not escape in the final scene; the Duke pursues him, reveals his sins (blaspheming against God while God listened), and punishes him with a whipping, a hanging, and forced marriage to a woman with whom he has an illegitimate child.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unknown Lecturer

“tries to slink over to the shadows and there's a wonderful saying because the duke knows everything remember he's yahweh he's omniscient so it's not like the devil is going to sneak off stage he says you sir i mean to talk to you i wish to have a word with you and now he can't help but come and meet his maker literally speaking deal with a duke and he says do you know the duke for a drunkard do you know the droot the duke for a woman chaser do you know the duke for a carousel and an evil man i heard you say something along those lines did i not and he says well yeah but i really didn't mean he's trying to get out from under this he says you deserve a whipping and then you deserve a hanging and i think that that would be just a fine thing for you and in addition to that i think you should get married too”

0.46

The Duke, witnessing Isabella's conversation with Claudio and seeing her absolute refusal to compromise her soul to save her brother, devises a plan: he will have the condemned prisoner who died naturally of fever have his head switched with Claudio's to fake Claudio's execution.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unknown Lecturer

“it turns out that not only is there a bed switch but the friar who is the duke in disguise tells the head of the jail the provost do not engage in this execution the execution is a mistake i want you to switch heads put the head of claudio or leave claudio's head on his shoulders put the head of another prisoner who died accidentally due to a fever put that in the bag we will bring that into the prince the angelo will never know”

0.46

When the Duke reveals himself by removing his friar's cowl, Lucio realizes he has been blaspheming against the Duke to the friar and against the friar to the Duke—he has been condemning authority itself while it listened to him.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unknown Lecturer

“at the penultimate moment takes the cowl off the fryer and feels very uncomfortable because there under the fryer's cowl is the duke himself and in fact it turns out that he realizes that oh no i have been blaspheming the duke to the friar i have been blaspheming the friar to the duke i'm nab now there's no way i'm going to get out from under this”

0.42

Claudio appears alive after the Duke commutes his death sentence, and there is a joyous reunion scene; because he has sinned in fornication but has been extended mercy by the Duke and because Juliet (his betrothed) repented her sins earlier, Claudio and Juliet are married.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unknown Lecturer

“and you know at the end of this now that that isabella has prayed for the man who she thinks has killed her brother you see on comes claudio her brother who is still alive we have had the head switch as well as the bed switch here in comes her brother and there's a joyous reunion scene and because her brother has been engaged in fornication he has gotten this woman with child and earlier in the play the friar went to this woman and said do you repent your sins she said yes well since she's repented and claudio has been extended mercy because god's mercy and god's justice are not completely distinguishable she says you deserve death because angelo was right but i will let you slide because this is the end of the world and i am simultaneously extending both justice and mercy those two get married”

0.39

Isabella believes wrongly that her brother has been executed and that Angelo has killed him; she comes to the Duke in heartbroken anguish, not knowing that Claudio is alive and that the head she saw was another prisoner's.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unknown Lecturer

“oh it's marvelous isabella believes wrongly it turns out that her brother has been killed she has gotten the news that corrupt angelo who thinks he has corrupted her has in fact killed her brother and of course she is heartbroken she knows that in terms of morality it is just that her brother be punished but she had so hoped that he would be given mercy and charity along with justice”