What this covers

This is an interview with Doomberg, the pseudonymous Substack writer, conducted for Resource Talks. It begins with oil and then moves across the commodity complex: natural gas, coal, uranium, gold, copper and battery metals. Along the way it takes in recession odds and Germany. Doomberg's main method is to read long charts, such as oil priced in gold or in inflation-adjusted terms, and to argue that peak cheap oil is a story about future consequences rather than a present condition. He ties this to a supply-response argument. Shale operators can toggle production far faster than OPEC, which is why he amends the old maxim to the cure for low prices is low prices times time.

The middle of the conversation is about positioning. Doomberg explains why he turned bearish on energy, why he sees natural gas as oversupplied after a warm winter (he cites Chesapeake's planned 30% output cut), and how long gold can act as a way to short energy. He describes thermal coal briefly trading above metallurgical coal) during Europe's crisis, then normalizing. On uranium he turns cautious after prices passed $100 a pound, with Cameco's earnings as a possible local top, and he discusses what a uranium hedge looks like. He also says the Strategic Petroleum Reserve release under Joe Biden halved oil prices, and that US consumers have benefited from cheap gasoline and home heating.

The contentious stretches come later. He argues that copper's price undercuts the EV narrative, that BYD) is winning through borrowed Western technology and heavy state support, and that graphite, nickel, cobalt and lithium will struggle. His gold case rests on two narratives, paper-market suppression and the end of dollar dominance, which he thinks 2024 will test through Shanghai physical trading and the handling of Russia's reserves. He also forecasts that the Fed will extend and pretend on commercial real estate through the election, and he expects no recession in time to affect it.

Sharpest takeaway

Energy abundance, not scarcity, defines economic outcomes; peak cheap oil is a myth, and technological innovation ensures commodity supply responds to price signals, making catastrophic energy shortages unlikely despite geopolitical tensions.

  • Oil priced in gold is at historical lows, contradicting peak cheap oil fears
  • US shale technology added 2.5 Saudi Arabias of production in 15 years, demonstrating innovation's power
  • Natural gas trading at $10/barrel equivalent in US despite European crisis shows market self-correction

The claims · ranked47 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.74

For decades, people have worried that humanity might run out of oil, but when examining 40-50 year charts of oil prices in gold or inflation-adjusted terms, there is no evidence of this imminent exhaustion; oil price spikes (like the pre-2008 financial crisis spike above $145/barrel) collapse within 12 months because commodities are cyclical and technology rescues supply.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“for as long as there has been oil there has been people worried about the fact that we might run out of it um but when you just look at the 40 or 50-year chart of oil in ounces of gold or the inflation adjusted price of oil it's just not there and I don't know what data people would need to see but take for example that the price spike of the predated the global financial crisis were oil traded above $145 a barrel I believe within 12 months it it collapsed 70%”

0.69

Horizontal drilling and fracking technology has added approximately 2.5 Saudi Arabias worth of energy production to the US mix in the last 15 years; the US is now the world's largest oil producer by a wide margin, largest natural gas producer by a wide margin, and a major coal exporter, while operating with massive resource constraints from environmental regulations.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“the concept of horizontal drilling and and fracking was a dream 15 years ago and in those 15 years the US has added two and a half Saudi Arabia to its energy mix uh we're the number one producer of oil by a wide margin we're the number one producer of natural gas by a wide margin we're a major exporter of coal um we have you know nuclear power um and so the US is an energy gigap power and it's doing this with a hand and a half tied behind its back”

0.69

The Saudis lost their price war against US shale oil because shale operators are far more flexible and able to toggle production on and off than OPEC producers; this flexibility is why the US now produces 20 million barrels per day of oil and 25% of the world's natural gas.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“when the Saudis tried to beat back the Shale oil Revolution with a price War they were just so much more flexible and able to toggle on and off and the Saudis ended up losing that war which which is why the US now produces you know 20 million barrels a day of oil and petroleum products and 25% of the world's natural gas”

0.69

Commodity companies have historically low multiples on Wall Street because growth is valued above profitability; the real money in commodities is made in price, not volume, but Wall Street's preference for growth means commodity stocks are often undervalued relative to other sectors that receive premium valuations.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“CEOs of such companies know that they make all their money in price not volume but Wall Street still rewards um growth and this is why commodity companies have such low multiples because Wall Street hates this stuff they want to see growth like inid and they more than overpay for it over time”

0.69

We cautioned on uranium when prices exceeded $100/pound (marked by Cameco earnings as potential local top), suggesting it might be prudent to hedge or take risk off after a massive run; market tops are marked by euphoria not despair, and uranium Twitter showed significant excitement after years of being beaten down.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“when you see sort of um what my friend Tony GRE would call Icarus prints like we we've seen recently on the March you know to over $100 a pound um we had cautioned that um if we were in the trade and we're not and we had done very well it might be time to think about hedging a little bit or taking a bit of risk off and um and I think um Cho's earnings sort of marked a local top perhaps”

0.69

We can't beat supercomputers on Wall Street at stock picking; we believe markets are relatively efficient; if forced to invest in public markets, we would buy index funds passively and possibly sell calls for income generation.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“we don't speculate um in in publicly traded Securities by and large um it's just not first of all um we have no Market Edge I mean people can do the same math that you and I can do I think the markets are relatively efficient I think if we were forced to trade or to invest in public markets we would probably just buy the index fonds passively”

0.69

Internal combustion engines won't materially disappear anytime soon; EV market will grow, but hybrid and gas vehicles will remain significant; India continues growing with substantial room to increase BTU per GDP; commodity demand will remain cyclical with pockets of growth and challenge across regions.

forecasthigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“you know these markets are all cyclical as we've said repeatedly um and there was this belief that an enormous amount of demand would materialize and and the market initially responded to that but now we're starting to see these prices come off as um as the realities of the difficulties of owning EVS outside of major population centers shinks the addressable Market H and then again you have whatever's happening in China I recently read someone on Twitter said something among the lines of as China goes so does copper and China is not going copper is not going to be going something among those lines for now but India is going pretty good you know these things these things are all flows that are very difficult to model”

0.69

In the short and medium term, oil prices are driven primarily by where we are in the capital expansion cycle of the commodity sector (often out of sync with broader business cycles), sentiment, risk premiums, and geopolitics; in the long term, technology is the primary driver, and peak cheap oil proponents vastly underestimate the technical powerhouses that modern commodity players have become.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“so our view is that in short term the primary drivers of the price of oil are where we are in the cycle because the capital expansion cycle of the commodity sector is often out of sync with the broader business cycle um and then sentiment so where people think prices are going risk premiums geopolitics and so on uh in the medium term very similar where we are in the cycle um and then in the long term um technology is the primary driver um and the thing that most proponents of peak cheap oil get wrong is they vastly underestimate the the massive technical powerhouses that are the modern commodity players”

0.65

BYD is winning the EV market because they combined stolen Western EV technology with enormous government support, cheap labor, cheap coal-based electricity, and cherry-picked the best features across Western producers; they're producing high-quality plug-in hybrids (e.g., $14,000 for 35-mile range + 1.5L engine) that will dominate against Western automakers.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“when you don't have to when you can just steal all the Western technology and you don't have to create it in house and then cherry pick the best from all of the western producers and then mix in an enormous amount of government support it's impossible that you can't win but man they're producing some amazing EVs and more importantly plug-in hybrids at shockingly cheap prices I saw a report yesterday plug-in hybrid with 35 miles a range and a 1.5 liter engine really well appointed for the equivalent of $14,000”

0.64

During Europe's energy crisis, thermal coal briefly traded higher than metallurgical coal for the first time ever; this inversion has normalized as energy abundance has returned and metallurgical coal reasserts itself as a premium product tied to steel making rather than power generation.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“during the peak of the of the U energy crisis in Europe there was a period of time where thermal coal was was trading higher than metallurgical coal which had never happened before and it was truly um amazing um metallurgical coal especially during times of relative full abundance which we have now tends to price and react to um the steel making sector much more so than um than thermocol does”

0.64

We cannot predict with confidence whether China or Europe will enter recession; Chinese economic data is difficult for Westerners to penetrate; metallurgical coal pricing being relatively stable may signal that markets don't believe worldwide recession is imminent, as coal would respond more sharply if global recession were expected.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“no no I would say no us recession that does not mean there isn't going to be a recession in China or that China CH uh or or Europe is already in one and by the way if a major financial crisis does break out in China that's the kind of thing that could drag the us into a recession we we have been careful to say all things being equal it doesn't look like the US is set for a recession but if all things are no longer equal and something material changes then of course you have to look at the new data set it's very hard to penetrate Chinese economic data as a Westerner”

0.64

Release of 1 million barrels per day from the Strategic Petroleum Reserve (SPR) for six months by the Biden administration (0.5% of annual global supply) cut the price of oil in half, demonstrating that marginal supply adjustments have outsized price impact.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“we're always one geopolitical crisis away from a massive price bik in Commodities we saw it with the energy crisis developing organically and then Russia taking advantage of European weakness and moving into Ukraine um we saw oil Spike and look what as we said in the piece what happened Joe Biden released 1 million barrels a day for six months that's um 1% of global daily supply for half a year so half a percent of annual Supply and the price of oil was cut in half”

0.63

The Ukraine war won't last forever; current slate of politicians won't rule forever; but the persistence of humanity's desire to improve living standards through discovery, exploitation, and harnessing of primary energy ensures 2% annual energy growth will continue indefinitely.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“the war in Ukraine won't last forever um the current slate of politicians won't rule forever but what will remain is the Persistence of Humanity's desire to EV improve standards of living which can only be done through the systematic Discovery exploitation and harnessing of primary energy which is why it grows at 2% per year forever”

0.63

Oil experienced negative $37/barrel front-month prices at expiration during peak COVID crisis, then quickly rallied above $125; these volatility spikes followed by recoveries demonstrate market self-correction mechanisms work across extreme scenarios.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“you have whatever's happening in China I recently read someone on Twitter said something among the lines of as China goes so does copper and China is not going copper is not going to be going something among those lines for now but India is going pretty good you know these things these things are all flows that are very difficult to model of course but the India is growing at a pretty strong Pace right now and their demand for Commodities is is is growing and if you look at their BTU per GDP they got a long way to go to catch up to China let alone to the US and so there's there's always going to be pockets of growth um there are always going to be pockets of challenges look there's a big challenge in the US with commercial real estate and and you know our view of course is the Fed will extend and pretend that through the election which is again um to the extent that a crisis materializes um I think the FED is very political”

0.61

Peak cheap oil is a myth; while oil prices oscillate between shortage and glut, the long-term upward trajectory of energy consumption continues unabated regardless of crises, and the inflation-adjusted and gold-adjusted price of oil shows it is as cheap as it was when Reagan came to office, contradicting the idea that we face imminent supply constraints.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“Peak cheap oil is a myth which we've long believed to be true um there's no doubt that we oscillate between shortage and glut and crisis and and uh economic uh um piece but that sort of upward sloping S Wave of of energy consumption of humanity continues unabated regardless of the crises that may present themselves”

0.60

Energy is not influenced by the economy; energy IS the economy; all economic activity and growth ultimately depends on access to energy resources, making energy the fundamental driver rather than a secondary factor.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“you wrote that energy is not influenced by the economy energy is the economy”

0.59

US producers of natural gas are reducing expected 2024 outputs due to low prices and oversupply (e.g., Chesapeake cutting 30% of expected output); the market is signaling producers to slow production; primary driver of recent gas price collapse is unusually warm weather in the US affecting heating demand.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“the primary driver of the recent collapse of natural gas prices of course is an unusually warm weather in the US um given natural gases role in home heating it is very very sensitive to um you know heating degree dat numbers and when if you look at the seasonality chart uh aggregated across the us we are having an an exceptionally warm weather pattern for this time of year”

0.53

Commercial real estate represents a major US challenge; the Fed will 'extend and pretend' through the 2024 election to prevent crisis; Fed policy is political, and the Washington establishment will intervene to prevent Trump's return, making economic intervention likely regardless of orthodox monetary policy concerns.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“look there's a big challenge in the US with commercial real estate and and you know our view of course is the Fed will extend and pretend that through the election which is again um to the extent that a crisis materializes um I think the FED is very political and so they will intervene for political reasons the entire Washington DC establishment is U both terrorized and hellbent on preventing a return of Donald Trump and so I think they will do whatever they need to do to prop up the economy”

0.53

Gasoline is less than $3/gallon nationwide and home heating has never been cheaper; these are real economic tailwinds that should be credited to US policy (state-level regulators kept energy spigots open), not dismissed; Biden is a political beneficiary even though he deserves little credit.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“gasoline is less than $3 a gallon Nationwide or close to it um home heating has never been cheaper I mean it it these are real headwinds or Tailwinds sorry for an economy and um and it's it's it's amazing that we can see the negative side but can't give credit to the positive side look Biden deserves very little of the credit for this I mean this is really state level Regulators that kept especially in Texas and Louisiana and so on that kept the the energy spigots open”

0.53

Auto manufacturers are walking back EV expectations: Mercedes-Benz and others are slowing EV production plans and updating combustion engine lineups into the next decade; this confirms the market's copper signal that EV adoption is slower than ESG advocates claimed.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder - interviewer appears to introduce)

“Car makers are confirming that too I just tweeted out something that I pulled up here uh this morning it's a it's a reuter's headline that reads Mercedes-Benz toned down expectations on electric vehicles demand and said it will update its combustion engine lineup well into next decade becoming the latest car maker to flag a slower than expected appetite for battery powered cars”

0.52

The real definition of cheap oil means a price at which economies of the world can grow without much interruption; peak cheap oil proponents are actually selling the negative consequences that would follow, not a current reality; nothing prevents oil from reaching $200-$300/barrel, but the harder you stretch the rubber band, the more violent the reaction will be as substitute supplies flood in.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“the definition of cheap in our view um means a price at which economies of the world can grow um without much Interruption right and and the the real thing that PE Che oil proponents are selling of course is the negative consequences that would come thereafter um and again nothing we have written or spoken about would it would say that it isn't possible that oil could go to 200 or $300 a barrel our view is simply that the harder you stretch the rubber band The more violent the reaction would be”

0.52

When energy is long (abundant), countries with strong manufacturing sectors prosper; when energy is short, countries with large energy production prosper; the US uniquely benefits from both dimensions, making it a distinct petro-state advantage.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“the the headline is when energy is long countries that have manufacturing sectors that could take advantage of that do well and when energy is short countries that have a massive amount of energy production do well the US happens to be both which makes it a very unique um Petro state if you will”

0.52

The classic saying 'the cure for low prices is low prices' should be amended to 'the cure for low prices is low prices times time' because supply response takes time to manifest; given accelerated drilling technology and operator flexibility in the US shale patch, the response timeframe is shorter than historical precedent.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“there's a catchy saying in cyclical industry that the the cure for low prices is low prices but I think you and I have in the past discussed that the cure for low prices is low prices times time so it takes time for the low prices to to cure those low prices”

0.52

Two major gold narratives are (1) gold prices are suppressed by Western paper markets, and (2) US dollar dominance is ending and gold will reassert as neutral reserve asset; 2024 will test both narratives through Shanghai physical gold market growth enabling arbitrage between London/New York, and through potential Western confiscation of Russia's asset reserves.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 1/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“there's sort of two big beliefs in the gold Community which is as uh parentally bullish perhaps as as the uranium folks are um and frankly a high degree of overlap between the two communities um the one is that the price of gold has been suppressed by the paper markets um and the other is that the US dollar dominance is coming to an end and when it does gold will reassert itself uh in in its rightful place as a uh neutral Reserve asset which is different than a reserve currency of course and 20124 looks set to shine a significant light on both of those um driven in the first part by the the growth of the Shanghai physical gold markets”

0.51

Germany's climate and energy policy has reached an 'inevitable end point' of insanity; their current ruling coalition's days are numbered; while transition friction will be formidable, Germany will eventually recover because the cycle of political change and human drive to improve standards of living remains persistent.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“we just put a piece out called Full Circle um which ironically categorized Germany's uh you know as a case study in climate Insanity taken to its sort of inevitable end point but we let we ended that piece with a with a a hopeful message that we suspect that we must be near the bottom in Germany and to the extent that they're a test case we could take take comfort in the inevitability of a rebirth I think the days are of the current ruling Coalition are undoubtedly numbered and the friction of the transition might be formidable but the inevitability of how the cycle turns um will reassert itself as well even in Germany”

0.49

When energy is cheap and abundant, US manufacturers benefit by pricing their products at global rates while paying domestic hydrocarbon costs; this creates a manufacturing boom in the US that explains why there has been no recession despite expectations, because abundant cheap energy is a massive economic tailwind.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“if oil is artificially cheap and manufacturers in the US get to price of their product at Global prices then they would be in a good position to take advantage of these things... there's a whole manufacturing boom underway in the US because of this this pool of of the world's cheapest hydrocarbons here available to be burned we we did a whole piece on this um where we showed just how valuable natural gas is to the economy and and in our view explains why there is no recession in the US”

0.49

If Western nations fully confiscate Russian asset reserves (rather than just freezing them) and give them to Ukraine, it would cause significant dislocation in markets for Western debt that serve as reserve assets, because such acts would erode the neutrality of those reserve assets and be bullish for gold.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“the second is the big question um confronting us here soon is whether the US and the EU will um fully confiscate as opposed to just having Frozen Russia's assets reserves and effectively give them to Ukraine and if they were to do that I think that would cause a significant dislocation in the markets for Western debt which have served as um Reserve assets but such acts would erode the neutrality of those Reserve assets and so that would be pretty bullish for gold as well”

0.49

Copper is puzzlingly cheap if an ESG-driven EV/renewable revolution is actually occurring, because copper is a critical input to EVs, solar, wind; the market's tepid copper response contradicts the stated ambition of massive clean energy buildout, suggesting the market sees either slower EV adoption or smaller scale buildout than proponents claim.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“we have long pondered why it is that coal oh sorry that copper is so cheap um if we're on the cusp of an ESG Revolution and it's just not in there it's just not in the markets like the markets aren't if we were really going to build out electric vehicles and solar and wind to the extent that we've been told you wouldn't expect copper be where it is”

0.48

The speakers shifted their position from being short-term cautious during an energy crisis to becoming long-term bullish on energy abundance after studying global natural gas markets in October-November; they discovered through analysis of Permian, Marcellus, Qatar, and Russia production that natural gas is in a glut despite previous shortage views, representing a significant worldview change.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“we came on the scene during an energy crisis and um we were early to call it and then late to call that it was over if we're being fully honest... but our view on the energy markets that we had flipped from short to long and and I'll pause here and say we've said from the very beginning the most important question and analysts should ask themselves when looking at an economy is whether that economy is net short or net long primary and the Very question implies that there are two potential answers to to that uh question and we really came to the conclusion that we were in a world of energy excess when we spent a month studying the global natural gas markets in October and into November”

0.48

The commitment to being analysts rather than advocates means beliefs must change with data; if global natural gas analysis had concluded shortage rather than glut, they would not have written bullish pieces, avoiding the trap of becoming advocacy-driven content creators.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“we have been conscious to try to to act and to behave as analysts and not Advocates and I think there's an important distinction between those two sets of people in the content creation World um an analyst tries their best to look at the data and come to a conclusion whereas an advocate looks at the data and tries to uh confirm a belief and um our we have always believed by the way that Peak Cho was a myth it just never really came up in any conversations because during an energy crisis you know there's more urgent things to talk about um but our view on the energy markets that we had flipped from short to long”

0.48

Uranium is structurally bullish long-term, but we were short-term cautious recently; uranium is different from oil, gas, coal because uranium cost is not a direct one-to-one input to nuclear plant operation, so uranium could triple or quadruple and have minimal impact on nuclear economics.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“I did mention that I was short-term a little cautious uranium you know things don't go up exponentially I think longterm the case for Uranium is is pretty sound the thing about uranium that makes it different than natural gas and oil and coal is the price of uranium could triple or quadruple from here and and nobody would really care because the the input cost of running a nuclear power plant I mean uranium is certainly a cost but it's it's not like such a direct onetoone cost”

0.48

Private investment framework: we seek deals where we can affect outcomes through direct involvement with management teams, not as passive sidecar investors; we've applied a systematic framework (five pillars: brand, channel, technology, demand creation, operations) that appears programmable and Universal across startups.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“um having built the business ourselves um very systematically through the five pillars of brand Channel technology demand creation and operations um we have been able to help you know aspiring CEOs build great startups using that framework and and and it works it's pretty Universal and so um you know the the outlines of what make for a successful startup are are pretty interesting and I think pretty programmable”

0.48

We structure our personal investments to avoid conflicts: we disclose gold holdings when writing about gold; we don't trade public equities because we can't beat algorithmic traders and don't have information edge; we instead focus on private equity and venture capital where we can add value through direct involvement with management and our network.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“we earn money in Fiat because we live in a Fiat world we save money by buying real assets like gold and land and collectible so I am long gold and I I don't think you know our position in Gold influences our opinion on it nor can we influence the market if we wrote about it but we always disclose that we're long gold if we write about gold uh and then we mostly invest privately um where we can affect the outcome um we we pretty good experience in our team in private equity and venture capital”

0.47

Western automakers will struggle with EVs as Chinese competition (particularly BYD) floods markets if trade barriers aren't imposed; trade barriers are likely because Western governments won't tolerate job losses from BYD domination.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“we're just at the beginning of the western automakers struggling with EVS in our view and if the Chinese are allowed to import um whatever they can export into markets like Europe boy that the Mercedes and the vws and and the BMWs of the world are in for world to hurt I I'm opening up a an overview of what's in an EV battery um which what all that you're telling me here is is not very bullish graphite nickel lithium um manganese Cobalt all these things well it all depends against current market expectations of course um you know we would say that you could still grow EVs and we do expect them to grow we just don't expect the internal combustion engine to materially go away anytime soon”

0.45

The world currently has more than enough primary energy, evidenced by natural gas trading at $10/barrel equivalent in the US despite being $600/barrel equivalent in Europe during the crisis; oil would be lower than current prices if not for geopolitical tensions from Russia-Ukraine and Middle East conflicts.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“in our view today the world um has more than enough primary energy which is why you see natural gas where it is where why you see coal where is and oil would be lower were it not for the geopolitical tensions that we have both in the proxy war between Russia and Ukraine and also the war in the Middle East”

0.45

Shale production did not peak when expected because drilling technology improved faster than anticipated; the Mountain Valley Pipeline approval and Marcellus production dynamics are key indicators; if Marcellus doesn't show bumped-up production post-MVP, or if Permian production rolls over, the energy outlook changes materially.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“what did we get wrong we got wrong the the proliferation of of production in the Shell patch and and until that turns over so like what are the markers we would look for um marceles gas production you know if we turn on the Mountain Valley Pipeline and we don't see a bump up in production in marceles that means we're seeing Cil or as the team at Garing and rosenb believed perhaps we're reaching geologic limits of the marceles Shale”

0.45

Gold allocation should be approximately 10% of financial net worth as insurance against currency debasement; we view gold as a partial hedge, not a core position; land is viewed as a potentially higher-upside version of gold with more local knowledge benefits.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“for me a reasonable allocation is you know 10% of my financial net worth is probably in gold today plus or minus um so it's not like a core position um most of my core positions are in you know um in privately heal companies”

0.45

Geopolitical crises (Houthi Red Sea disruption, Israel-Palestine war, potential Iran confrontation) have caused surprisingly subdued oil price reaction; market is signaling low probability of direct US-Iran kinetic conflict because oil remains sub-$80/barrel despite what would be $200+/barrel scenarios if war occurred.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“the ongoing war in the Middle East um has surprised Us in the sense that its impact on the oil Market has been relatively subdued you know if you had told me that the houthis would be shutting down the Red Sea with missiles and that there would be a major war between Israel and the Palestinians that looked likely to spread uh to to the north and that the US was uh on the cusp of a kinetic confrontation with Iran I wouldn't have guessed that WTI would be sub 80 a barrel in that scenario”

0.45

If oil reached $200-$300/barrel, politicians who are 'basically Malthusian climate alarmists' would be wiped away in a political revolution rather quickly, and the US would embark on whatever measures necessary to correct the shortage, including drilling in currently restricted areas (Eastern Gulf of Mexico, Atlantic and Pacific coasts, Alaska), because cheap energy is politically non-negotiable.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“if we did see $200 or $300 oil the politician who are basically malthusian climate alarmists would be wiped away in a political revolution rather quickly and we would Embark upon whatever it would need uh to be done to correct the shortage of primary energy the oil uh included amongst them”

0.45

EV battery commodity demand (graphite, nickel, lithium, manganese, cobalt) is not very bullish given current market valuations; the market is pricing in slower EV adoption than advocates claim, making battery metal prices weak despite ESG rhetoric.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“what all that you're telling me here is is not very bullish graphite nickel lithium um manganese Cobalt all these things well it all depends against current market expectations of course um you know we would say that you could still grow EVs and we do expect them to grow we just don't expect the internal combustion engine to materially go away anytime soon”

0.41

We do not believe there will be a recession in time to affect the 2024 US presidential elections; Biden benefits politically from cheap energy regardless of whether he deserves credit for it, and energy abundance combined with onshoring of manufacturing means the economy has powerful tailwinds.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“we don't believe there will be a recession in time to affect the 2024 presidential elections and this is the real hot button issue you know Biden onics and Trump looks like he's set to win the nomination and it's going to be an ugly fight”

0.41

We could face significant political upheaval in 2024 if the election outcome is disputed and neither side accepts the result; this uncertainty could be an approximate cause of recession, but only after the election, not before it.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“we are fearful that neither side will accept whatever outcome emerges and we could be in store for significant political upheaval in the US which could be approximate cause of a recession down the road but in a time frame that matters I.E 2024 it's the data has supported since we made that call um that there is no real recession on on the horizon”

0.39

US manufacturing base is growing as companies onshore and friendshore out of China; rising China-US tensions make nearshoring from China urgent; this manufacturing expansion, combined with abundant cheap hydrocarbons, means the US economy has structural tailwinds that prevent recession.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“you have manufacturing pretty impressive you know um uh manufacturing base in the US that's only growing as companies see the need to onshore and friend Shore out of China in particular as as tensions rise with with the Communists in China um and you have the world's cheapest and largest source of hydrocarbons readily available um that's not if you inject two and a half Saudi arabas into a manufacturing sector have you been to Saudi Arabia have you seen the buildings I mean energy wealth here's here's the thing that's that's amazing”

0.39

A gold rerate to $2,500-$3,000 would signal currency debasement has become severe; scenarios of $5,000-$10,000 would indicate catastrophic US fiscal conditions; we don't want gold to spike because most of our assets are held in US dollars and the US is where our families live — gold rerate is like an insurance policy that paid off (house burned down but was insured).

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“if a major oil producer started overtly pricing product in ounces of gold again this is an idea that luk groman has articulated that we find compelling and so I want to give credit where credit is due um you would very quickly see a significant reating of gold higher than here I don't know 2500 3,000 some people dream of 5 000 or 10,000 we don't dream of those scenarios because actually that would be a sign of significant catastrophe in the US which is where we live and our families reside”

0.22

We left Twitter because the return on effort no longer justified the cost; throttling of Substack writers and increased difficulty promoting content made Twitter inefficient allocation of limited resources; our business performed well post-departure, confirming the decision.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“we there's possibilities that we might end up going back to Twitter but not under the current ownership and especially not under the policy of subjecting substack writers to throttle and uh and you know making it very difficult for people to um promote their product look we we do this for a living we have a small team there's only so much we can do and we decided that the return on effort on Twitter no longer made sense and nothing about the reasons why we left Twitter um have changed since we have and frankly our business has done fine without it”

0.17

We might return to Twitter only under different ownership and policies; the platform remains valuable despite current problems; we hope it survives and thrives regardless of ownership.

normativespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“we there's possibilities that we might end up going back to Twitter but not under the current ownership and especially not under the policy of subjecting substack writers to throttle... I I still enjoy perusing Twitter it's still a great source of knowledge and information um it is a unique product I hope it survives um I hope it thrives regardless of who owns it”

0.17

The biggest asset in our portfolio is the present value of future earnings from Doomberg; we've earned the majority of personal time allocation to this business because we get to 'eat what we kill' — if we work hard and delight subscribers, we add to net worth; if we fail, we lose.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Doomberg analyst/founder)

“the the biggest asset at um right now my portfolio is the present value of future earnings from doomberg and that gets the vast majority of my time um because um you know we get to eat what we kill um and so we're go we've gone on a good hunt and you know if we get a bison we get the whole bison we're not you know employees who only get whatever piece of the stake our bosses decide to give us”