
The Bible and Western Culture - Kierkegaard's Leap of Faith
What this covers
This is a single-lecturer talk by Michael Sugrue, part of his Bible and Western Culture series, on Søren Kierkegaard, whom he calls a theologian with a poet's soul and a philosopher's analytical skill. Sugrue places him after the collapse of English deism and the failure of Enlightenment hopes to reconcile religion with reason, and calls him the most important theologian since Pascal. He ties Kierkegaard's intensity to Pascal and to Tertullian's "I believe because it is absurd." The lecture is built around Kierkegaard's favorite and most difficult biblical texts: Abraham and Isaac, as treated in Fear and Trembling, and the Book of Job. Abraham is presented as the test of real faith because his obedience makes no rational or moral sense. Job's friends, who offer theological explanations for his suffering, are the ones who fail.
The middle of the lecture works through the epistemology. Sugrue follows Philosophical Fragments in arguing that if Socrates is wrong that knowledge is recollection, then knowledge must come through revelation. He sets this against the claim that truth is subjectivity, and he reads the choice between faith and reason as criterionless, an Either/Or) with no neutral ground. Some of these claims are contested, notably that theology is itself a kind of blasphemy, that conscience must yield to Scripture, and that Kierkegaard attacks the aesthetic reading of the Bible as hollowing out faith from within.
The lecture also covers the man and his times. It looks at his pseudonyms and his habit of reviewing his own books badly, the broken engagement, the tombstone inscribed only "That individual," and his description of himself as a missionary to Christian Denmark. It then turns to his diagnosis of modernity: anonymous, mechanical societies drain passion, and constant chatter destroys real speech. Sugrue casts Kierkegaard as a Lear-like fool whose questions persist even where his answers fall short. He closes by tracing his influence on both theistic and atheistic existentialism.
Kierkegaard represents a radical theological alternative to Enlightenment rationalism, arguing that authentic Christian faith requires a 'leap of faith'—a criterionless, passionate commitment that abandons rational justification and embraces absurdity, making him both a precursor to existentialism and a devastating critic of modernity's erosion of passion and individuality.
- Faith demands risk and cannot be rationally justified; the attempt to reconcile reason and religion produces only corruption of both
- Modernity's mechanical societies destroy passion and individuality, replacing them with anonymous mediocrity and meaningless chatter
- Kierkegaard's dark ironic humor functions as a jester's truth-telling, forcing Western thought to confront questions about certainty, meaning, and authentic existence that remain unresolved
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The story of Abraham's willingness to sacrifice Isaac exemplifies the 'acid test of real religious faith'—Abraham's greatness lies not in his moral reasoning but in his willingness to abandon his individual conscience and moral intuitions when God demands it, making the sacrifice heroic precisely because it makes no rational sense.
“there are two ways we can take that if you think about a man if suppose a man came to you suppose he was named abraham and said recently i had a visit from the divinity and i was told that i have to sacrifice my son well you might be inclined to think that that was an immoral action and any rational person would say that well you're probably crazy because you think god talks to you directly and the idea of killing your son most immoral in this world of space and time in our lives we would certainly think that was bad if your neighbor came up to you and said that you would look at him very strangely now kierkegaard says well that's just fine provided you're an athenian that's just fine provided you're trying to make rational sense but kierkegaard was or rather uh um god was trying to point out that abraham is a hero of faith and what is heroic about abraham is that he was willing to sacrifice his son”
Kierkegaard insisted that truth is subjectivity, which is a remarkable and counterintuitive idea that makes him a precursor to existentialism, rejecting the Enlightenment's faith in reason as a guide for religious belief and conduct.
“he insisted that truth is subjectivity which is a remarkable idea and his work in this respect is a precursor to existentialism he says that you ultimately cannot reconcile religious belief and reason and reason will not be a satisfactory guide for the conduct of your life”
Kierkegaard wrote his works almost exclusively under pseudonyms with ironic names like 'Victor the Hermit' or 'Anti-Climax,' and after publishing pseudonymous books, he would review his own works anonymously in newspapers and give them bad reviews, suggesting ambiguity about identity or that identity itself is not as fixed as commonly assumed.
“he used to write his books almost exclusively under pseudonyms and the pseudonyms were very peculiar they were things like victor aramita which means victor the hermit or someone like anticlimacus which means anti-climax he has constant repertoire of personae that he puts on and all of them are ironic and rather troubling and very peculiar and what's even more troubling and peculiar about kierkegaard's work is that after he published his pseudonymous books he used to review his own books stood anonymously in the newspapers and he used to give them bad reviews”
Kierkegaard wanted only the word 'That individual' inscribed on his tombstone, rejecting names, dates, or religious symbols, because he was fundamentally opposed to being a 'cog in a giant logical wheel' and insisted on being an individual at all costs.
“on his tombstone and kierkegaard was the sort of person that would dwell on the question of what will be on his tombstone why while he is yet alive that was the kind of thing that would entertain kierkegaard he didn't want a name or dates of birth and death or anything directly religious all he wanted to put on his tombstone was the statement that individual here lies soren kierkegaard that individual yes he is a truly romantic man he is not going to be a cogitator a cog in a giant logical wheel he will be an individual at all costs”
Kierkegaard argues in 'Philosophical Fragments' that if Socratic epistemology is wrong—if we are not born omniscient and knowledge is not mere recollection—then knowledge must come through revelation, and only God (possibly Jesus Christ) could provide this revelation, since human teachers have the same ignorance problem.
“kierkegaard said what if that's wrong what if we are born ignorant and what if we can only get insight into the nature of human life and into the human condition by having this revealed to us well if it has to be revealed who can reveal it certainly not another human being because they will have the same problem that we do they will be born ignorant just like us so the only way that if revelation is possible and if we if all knowledge is not recollection if socrates is wrong then revelation is the only possible avenue to real knowledge and revelation cannot be the product of any other human being because they will have the same problem as us thus it is proven if socrates is wrong either no knowledge of any kind exists or what knowledge does exist is revelation who could reveal it to us not man only god who might that be jesus christ the lord and savior”
In the present age, constant chatter and loquacity destroy genuine speech; people talk about nothing constantly and never ask or answer the big questions in life because they cannot remain silent and therefore cannot truly talk.
“he says that one of the problems that we're going to get with the rise of democratic political movements in the age of the machine and the advent of modernity is that everyone's going to be chattering all the time and saying nothing talk talk talk loquacity destroys speech all we're going to do is constantly be gossiping about nothing we're never going to ask or answer the big questions in life he makes a very pointed remark and i've always had it stuck in my brain because i think it's probably true people that do not know how to remain silent do not know how to talk”
The true religious believer should be like Job, who refused all theological explanations for evil and suffering and instead remained God's faithful servant; Job's friends who attempted theological justifications were the ones who failed the test of faith.
“if you remember the three friends of job who tried to explain to him some kind of theological account of why evil should enter the world and why she he should be punished and job insisted to the end that no none of these accounts are satisfactory well it turns out that kierkegaard says yes if you are a theologian you are wrong you are one of those people that was it was in the stance of job's friends the right stance for the true believer to be in is job don't curse god and die take whatever god dishes out because the only stance for the true believer is to be god's faithful servant you shall not judge the lord your god he doesn't want your advice”
Like the Fool in King Lear, Kierkegaard asks strange and pregnant questions that no one had thought before; if his answers are not entirely satisfactory, his questions remain with us, forcing contemporary thought to confront problems that will not go away.
“may i suggest that kierkegaard is like lear's fool he asks strange and pregnant questions that no one had thought up before and if his answers are not satisfactory these questions are with us to stay in other words i'd be inclined to say that what kierkegaard adds to the tradition of western thought is not a set of theological answers he is the most unsystematic of theologians i'd be tempted almost to call him an anti-theologian but although his answers are not entirely plausible or not entirely satisfactory the questions that he proposes are with us today”
Theology itself is a form of blasphemy because human language lacks the tools to accommodate divinity; when theologians claim to understand and explain God, they are raising themselves to the status of understanding the divine, which the true believer should refuse to do.
“all theology is blasphemy she's a very deep thought as well if it is true that our language will not accommodate the divinity if it is true that we lack the tools to undertake that job and we occasionally do succumb to the temptation to write and speak and think about theology perhaps what we are doing then is raising our own selves to the status where we can claim to understand god and not only understand them but explain them to other people kierkegaard says nay if you believe that you have not reached the real pinnacle of religious faith”
Kierkegaard's religious intensity—his fanatical commitment—is comparable to Pascal and Tertullian; if one knows the history of Western thought and Pascal's anguished search for religious meaning, or Tertullian's 'I believe because it is absurd,' one can understand the depth of Kierkegaard's commitment.
“for better or worse there are few people with the same degree of religious intensity as kierkegaard if you know the history of western thought and you are familiar with the work of pascal or if you're familiar with the work of tertullian you will have some idea of the depth and fanaticism if you will of kierkegaard's commitment pascal anguished and anguished and seeking for a way out of this world gave everything to his religious commitment tertullian the great father of the church said i believe because it is absurd well uh kierkegaard's thinking is very much along those lines”
The path toward God is the path toward the self; we cannot move in the direction of God until we have received God's 'unbought and unaccountable grace,' and prior to that, while we are in this world, our identities like the world around us are in flux with nothing we can count on or be certain of.
“the path towards god turns out to be the path towards the self what kierkegaard is doing is saying that we never completely move in the direction of god until we have god's unbought and unaccountable grace and prior to that while we are in this world our identities like the world around us are in flux and there is nothing we can count on there is nothing we can be certain of”
Without risk, there is no faith; there is no rational royal road to divinity, and if one believes in a faith derived from axioms or philosophical stance, that is not real religious faith, which always entails risk and must remain absurd and unjustifiable.
“without risk there is no faith there is no rational royal road to divinity if you want to be a religious believer you must take upon yourself the fact that a it is never going to make sense not now not later on it's not that some great philosopher a hundred years or a thousand years from now is going to figure out some fine proof and will justify your religious faith now faith has no justification if you have a faith that you believe you have derived from some axioms or you have extrapolated from some religious from some philosophical stance in fact that's not the real religious faith the real religious faith is always going to entail risk”
Kierkegaard is intentionally difficult and oblique as a writer; he deliberately makes readers work for insights, testing whether they have enough desire and passion for truth to persevere through his 600-page Philosophical Fragments, seeking readers who will become individuals rather than sheep in a flock.
“he intends to be difficult he is going to make you work for the insights that you glean from him if you do not have enough desire enough passion for the truth to break a 600 page book of fragments well then you're not the kind of reader he wants to talk to he is an individual that means to talk to other individuals he means to turn you into an individual not one sheep among the flock he wants you to confront your own soul and the nature and the true facts of the human condition this will be agonizing this will be difficult this will call upon all of your spiritual resources but it is your only chance to be a real human being”
Søren Kierkegaard was a theologian with the soul of a poet and the analytical abilities of a philosopher, standing at a pivotal point in Western thought when English deism had collapsed and Enlightenment hopes for reconciling religion and reason had failed.
“my inclination would be to say that kierkegaard is a theologian with the soul of a poet and the analytical abilities of a philosopher and bringing all these together at a time when england deism has collapsed and the enlightenment hope that religion and reason could be reconciled means that he is standing at a pivotal point in the history of western thought”
Kierkegaard turned down his fiancée and refused to marry her because he felt marriage would bring him into the domain of this world and endanger his spiritual path, choosing instead to wander alone like 'the rhinoceros' for the whole of his life.
“kierkegaard turned down he was engaged to be married and for no obvious reason turned down his wonderful fiancee of course he was doing this fiance the best turn that had ever been done to her but he turned her down and refused to marry her because he felt that it would bring him into the domain of this world it would endanger his spiritual path so he decided to wander alone like the rhinoceros for the whole of his life”
Kierkegaard forces Western culture into a binary choice: either the life of religious faith or the life of secular, worldly skepticism, but one cannot have both or mix the two; mixing rational worldliness with revealed religion makes rationality either superfluous or wrong.
“he's trying to force western culture into a binary opposition either or either the life of religious faith or the life of secular this worldly skepticism but you can't have it both ways and you can't mix the two if you try and mix any amount of this worldly rationality with god's revealed religion it is either superfluous or it's wrong”
Kierkegaard described himself as a missionary precisely because he lived in Denmark—a Christian society that was a center of Lutheranism—and believed it was necessary to bring Christianity to Christendom, claiming that none of the nominal Christians around him truly understood the faith.
“he said that he described himself as a missionary right now he lived all his life in denmark right so the idea of being a missionary in a society that has had christianity for a great many centuries and is one of the centers of lutheranism is a very peculiar idea but he said he thought it was necessary for us to bring christianity to christendom and that's the kind of missionary that he was he said fine i could be a missionary right here i don't need to go to someplace that hasn't heard of christianity because none of you have”
Modernity has generated large anonymous societies dominated by machines, making people more mechanical, paltry, insipid, and inhuman; the rise of modernity removes passion from people, making them prosaic and mundane, unable to care about ultimate questions and unable to feel the impetus to find answers.
“the rise of modernity has generated large anonymous societies dominated by the machine and all the implications of the age of the machine for western society and that as a result we have gradually become more mechanical and more paltry and more insipid and more inhuman as a result”
Kierkegaard is a catalyst towards future theological discoveries and thought; many 20th-century theologians and philosophers have been beholden to him, including both theistic existentialists like Marcel and Buber, and the tradition of atheistic existentialism.
“he uh when he lets his mask down those small fragmentary occasions which kierkegaard tells us something about himself he is almost always disarming in his irony and in his candor and i'd be inclined to say that kierkegaard while he is repulsive and repellent is in fact a catalyst towards future theological discoveries and thought on many of the great 20th century theologians and 20th century philosophers have been beholden to kierkegaard there are so many of them like marcel or near nebor but in addition to people like that there's also i think a tradition of secular thought that is kierkegaardian when you if you decide to move in the opposite direction if you decide to make a leap of faith but not towards religion but away from religion what you will generate from that is the tradition of 20th century atheistic existentialism so kierkegaard is the source of both atheistic and theistic existentialism”
Kierkegaard argues that revelation stands on the same intellectual level as Greek rationality, making it not intellectually disrespectable to believe in revelation; this makes revelation a kind of 'Mexican standoff' with Athens—neither can decisively defeat the other rationally.
“kierkegaard is going to try and say well what if it turns out that in that the acceptance of revelation is on a par at least as intellectually respectable as the exception of as accepting reason as our only god that's as close as we'll ever be able to come this kind of mexican standoff between athens and jerusalem and that's what he's going to argue for in a book called philosophical fragments”
Kierkegaard critiques what he calls the 'aesthetic reading of the Bible'—interpreting biblical stories as beautiful symbolic narratives rather than literal truths—as an erosion of authentic Christian faith from within that steals the marrow of religion.
“in his book fear and trembling kierkegaard writes with particular bitterness in particular a criminy about what he calls the aesthetic reading of the bible he says look those of you children of the enlightenment those of you spiritual citizens of athens who believe that the bible can be read as a beautiful set of stories and nothing else that in fact it would be satisfactory to think of the symbolism behind the parables rather than the actual literal miracles there you do not have real christian faith this aesthetic reading of the bible is in fact an erosion from within and what it does is steal the marrow of religion”
The choice between faith and reason is criterionless—any justification one gives for either side presupposes what it is trying to prove; therefore, one must make an existential choice without rational grounds, and if God does not grant grace to believe, one is left to wander alone in despair.
“any justification you would give for being a spiritual citizen of jerusalem or being a spiritual citizen of athens presupposes what it's trying to prove if you assume that it's very important to be rational it's very easy to show later on that it makes sense to be a spiritual citizen of athens and you you have to give up on certain parts of the tradition of biblical religion on the other hand if you presuppose that biblical religion is all important and religious faith is what frees you and saves you then it's possible to show that athens is full of arrogant hubristic men and the tradition that comes out of jerusalem is exactly the right one you ought to be following but kierkegaard says without presupposing any of that how would you show that either choice was better or worse”
Kierkegaard asks whether conscience is the standard by which we judge the Bible, or whether the Bible is the source from which we derive conscience; he argues the proper Christian answer is that the Bible is divine revelation and if our conscience contradicts it, we are 'wicked worms' who must submit to Scripture.
“he asks a very pointed question when he inquires into the nature of conscience and its connection to our understanding of the bible he says this is our conscience the standard by which we judge the bible in other words if we find something in the bible that we disapprove of are we then to say that the bible is mistaken or wrong or are we trying to wiggle out of our problem by allegorizing and symbolizing the biblical story or is the proper answer to say no the bible is the source from which we derive our conscience and if our conscience tells us that the bible is wrong that just shows us what wicked worms we are because we have god's divine revelation here and if our conscience is inconsistent with that then we're merely wrong”
Kierkegaard is the most important theologian since Pascal; his work is an extended meditation on the problems of faith in the modern age and his favorite biblical passages are the most negative and difficult, particularly Abraham and Isaac and the Book of Job.
“we can think of kierkegaard's work as being a sort of extended meditation on the problems of faith in the modern age kierkegaard is without a doubt the most important theologian since pascal and uh it would be interesting to speculate what his favorite books of the bible are very clearly he likes the story of abraham very clearly he also likes the story of job but he seems to gravitate towards the most negative and difficult and disappointing passages in scripture”
Kierkegaard's life was characterized by intense psychic strain, torment, and anguish—manifestations typical of Romantic writers whose personal spiritual journeys and internal difficulties work themselves out in peculiar ways in their intellectual work.
“he himself was a very very peculiar individual like so many romantic writers he had a troubled personal life and his psyche was constantly the scene of intense strain and torment and anguish a characteristic stance for romantic writers if you know the work of keats or shelley or byron romantic difficulties mean psychic tension psychic problems which are manifest themselves in different ways in their work well kierkegaard's manifestations of his psychic difficulties of his own personal spiritual journeys comes out in some very peculiar ways”
Being a Christian is not an overnight event despite possible infusion of God's grace; it is a gradual process of coming to understand the domain of one's will and reconciling one's will with God's will, humbling one's arrogant tendency to judge God.
“being a christian is not an event it is a process you gradually come to understand what the domain of your will is and you do your best to reconcile your will with god's will to humble your your arrogant tendency to judge god”
The transformation that the leap of faith produces should move the believer toward asymptotic perfection—an approach to divine perfection that can never be fully achieved because it is divine, but the attempt requires willingness to sacrifice everything in pursuit of this impossible goal.
“he is surely not expecting that we will become perfect what he is expecting is that we will sacrifice everything in our attempt asymptotic as it is to achieve a perfection which is actually beyond us because it is divine”
The questions Kierkegaard poses remain live questions in contemporary moral philosophy: How shall we find a way out of our mundane prosaic lives? Is there any way we can have certainty about religious matters? Is it possible for us to make a leap of faith or has the advent of the age of the machine cut us off from the possibility of religious illumination?
“how shall we find a way out of our mundane prosaic lives is there any way in which we can have certainty about religious matters is it possible for us to make a leap of faith or has the advent of the age of the machine cut us off from the possibility of religious illumination all of these questions are forced upon us by the demonic jester soren kierkegaard”
Kierkegaard's work can be thought of as an extended meditation on the parable of the rich young man, where Jesus demands that he 'sell all you have and follow me'; the rich young man wanted adventure but not to wager everything, and Kierkegaard diagnoses the same condition in Western culture.
“i might be tempted to say that kierkegaard's work can be thought of as an extended meditation on the parable of the rich young man those of you that know that it's in the synoptics the rich young man comes to jesus and he thinks very highly of himself and he says what do i need to do lord in order to gain the kingdom of heaven and jesus says obey the law and the commandments and leave me alone and the rich young man comes back and says look i already obey the law and the commandments please tell me what i really need to do give me something spectacular obviously the rich young man is engaging in this religious adventure because he finds it interesting and entertaining because he is still mired in things of this world so jesus immediately diagnosing the spiritual condition of this rich young man and kierkegaard is diagnosing the spiritual condition of the west says fine i have a good retort for you go sell all you have and follow me”
Kierkegaard is a 'serious jester' whose dark comedies represent the most modern form of the Christian literary form; his unpleasantness, kindness-deprivation, and weirdness actually constitute a great theological joke that uses humor to make serious truths accessible.
“i would be tempted to say that kierkegaard is a serious jester and this will hearken back to an argument that i was making earlier when i talked about shakespeare comedy is the christian literary form and kierkegaard for all his unpleasantness and unkindness and kind of weirdness is a great theological joker”
When Romantic writers move from lyric poetry and novels to the domain of religion, the result is volatile and produces output that is unparalleled for its caustic ironic bitterness combined with a strangely good-natured sense of humor.
“and when romantic writers remove from the domain of lyric poetry and uh novels like frankenstein or the sonnets of keats to the domain of religion the result is very volatile indeed and some of the output of kierkegaard is unparalleled for its caustic ironic bitterness and at the same time a strangely good-natured sense of humor”
The leap of faith costs not less than everything; you must be willing to put up everything in this wager, unlike Pascal's wager which claims good odds, because the choice is criterionless—like spinning a roulette wheel putting money on red or black with no way to know the outcome in advance.
“the problem is that you are not willing to make the leap of faith which would allow you to be a whole and integrated soul because the leap of faith costs not less than everything you have to be willing to put up everything in this wager and unlike pascal's waitress not merely this is a good idea because the odds are with you here you have no grounds for making the judgment it's criterion-less it's like spinning the roulette wheel putting your money on either red or black but you have no way of knowing in advance whether it's going to come up red or black at the end you take your best chance you take a shot at your best hunch that's all you're ever going to get”
Kierkegaard argues that the Lutheran alternative of faith alone will not work because although Luther emphasized faith and salvation in Augustinian piety, he tried to make Christianity completely inward with no necessary connection between faith and works.
“and the lutheran alternative will not work and that's quite surprising if you think about luther and his emphasis on faith alone you might say that that kierkegaard would find luther quite a congenial intellectual comrade but no kierkegaard thought luther was soft he wasn't really dug into religious faith because although that he emphasized the importance of faith and salvation had that augustinian tradition of piety the problem with luther from kierkegaard's perspective is that he tries to make christianity completely inward he says that there's no necessary connection between faith and works”
The first part of the nineteenth century is paltry because people lack the capacity for either great good or great evil; they cannot sin on any grand scale because their souls are too small, making them incapable of the integrated wholeness that would require a leap of faith risking everything.
“he argues that the first part of the 19th century is paltry that you would that the people around him would not know how to be very good or very evil the tiny size of your soul precludes you from any from doing any big sin you haven't gotten to the point where you could sin on any kind of scale so you are incapable of doing good incapable of doing evil you are truncating the domain of the psyche to this tiny fragment of what you could be the problem is that you are not willing to make the leap of faith which would allow you to be a whole and integrated soul because the leap of faith costs not less than everything”
Kierkegaard argues that resentment, hatred of superiority, hatred of achievement, and hatred of excellence will erode Christianity and lack of moral commitment, as envious people will badmouth those who achieve and impose a conception of right and wrong based on utility and voting by the masses, reducing all questions to insipid mediocrity.
“he takes this argument a little bit further and he says that resentment the hatred of superiority the hatred of achievement the hatred of excellence is going to be a part of this erosion of christianity and this lack of moral commitment this decline of passion all you're going to have is people who are envious of those few who ever get anything done and they will do their best to badmouth that and do their best to impose a conception of right and wrong that reduces all questions to to utility to voting by the mass of people and to an insipid mediocrity”
The Enlightenment was a historical period when Western thinkers hoped to reconcile religious faith with reason, treating reason as capable of validating religious claims.
“at a time when england deism has collapsed and the enlightenment hope that religion and reason could be reconciled means that he is standing at a pivotal point in the history of western thought”
Romanticism as a movement values emotion, individual uniqueness, and the sublime, standing in opposition to Enlightenment rationalism and universal principles.
“Kierkegaard is a truly romantic man he is not going to be a cogitator a cog in a giant logical wheel he will be an individual at all costs... this general mood of melancholy of isolation and of individuality are all main themes in romanticism”