What this covers

This is a single-lecturer survey of Being and Time by Michael Sugrue, framed as exposition mixed with sustained critique. It begins with Martin Heidegger's background as a Jesuit seminarian and his training in Phenomenology under Edmund Husserl. It then works through the book's central apparatus: Dasein, the finite and uncertain human being through which Being (capital B)) discloses itself, and the components of its condition. These include facticity, the state of being thrown into a world one did not choose, existentiality, the practical appropriation of that world, and fallenness, the pre-reflective deprivation that authentic consciousness is supposed to overcome.

The middle of the talk covers the temporal structure of care). Care is concern for the future, including one's own mortality, for the past, including guilt over unrealized possibilities, and for the present, where a choice of authenticity) becomes possible. Guilt is presented as an existential debt to oneself, not a moral lapse. The lecturer also discusses Heidegger's puns on German, such as unheimlich and heim, and his later turn to the Pre-Socratics in Holzwege. He criticizes Heidegger's treatment of "Nothing" as unintelligible, and his belief that philosophy can only be done in German as chauvinism.

The critical thread is the most contentious part. The lecturer argues that Heidegger's influence has been strongest in theology, citing Paul Tillich and Rudolf Bultmann, and weakest in analytic philosophy, where Carnap dismissed him as gibberish. He sets Heidegger's Nazi affiliation and his break with Husserl at University of Freiburg against the philosophy of authentic confrontation with reality, calling this a "phenomenology of careerism." He also raises the circularity of understanding Being only as a human being, and asks whether authenticity is morally desirable at all.

Sharpest takeaway

Heidegger's ontological project represents a de-theologized version of Christian theology, replacing God with an abstract concept of 'Being' while preserving the fundamental structure of religious obligation and authenticity, making his philosophy ultimately a sophisticated transformation of theology rather than a genuinely novel philosophical enterprise.

  • Heidegger's demand for 'authentic being' mirrors the Christian imperative to 'sell all you have and follow me,' redirecting religious obedience toward Being itself rather than God
  • His analysis of guilt, care, death anxiety, and conscience as fundamental to human existence recapitulates Christian theology's account of original sin and moral obligation without the theological vocabulary
  • His influence has been greatest in theology (Tillich, Bultmann) where his work functions as de-divinized Christianity, suggesting his true philosophical home is theology, not ontology

The claims · ranked38 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.74

Heidegger, despite developing a philosophy demanding confrontation with authentic reality, became a Nazi and publicly disassociated himself from his Jewish mentor Husserl when academic appointments were threatened starting in 1933, later taking Husserl's chair at Freiburg—an instance of 'phenomenology of careerism' that undermines his philosophical authority.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker - Lecturer

“heidegger after all became a nazi heidegger was advanced due to his political connections to national socialism heidegger who um his greatest workers first great published work being in time was in husserl's yard book and husserl was his teacher and it was dedicated to husserah but alas for sure was a jew and so when huster was moved out of academic life starting in 1933 uh heidegger publicly disassociated himself from husserl and heidegger ended up taking husserl's chair at the university of freiburg this sounds to me like the phenomenology of careerism”

0.69

Heidegger began his intellectual career as a Jesuit seminarian, which had significant effects on his cast of mind, his early intellectual habits, and his later philosophical work.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Heidegger: Being and Time [MaobMHescwg]

“heidegger himself has a very interesting background which tells us a great deal about the sort of intellectual activity that he undertakes in the first case he starts out in his intellectual career as a jesuit seminarian which tells you a great deal about the cast of his mind which tells you a great deal about his early intellectual habits and much of this will have i mean influence later on”

0.69

Heidegger's influence has been substantial in theology rather than analytic philosophy: theologians like Paul Tillich explicitly acknowledge Heidegger's debt, and Rudolf Bultmann's 'demythologization' of Christianity is fundamentally Heideggerian—representing Heidegger's transformation back into theology.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker - Lecturer

“where has it been influential this is worth noting in theology paul tillich the great systematic theologian heidegger right turned into theology think about it i mean he makes his debt to heidegger quite explicit those of you that know the work of rudolph bolton demythologized christianity this is all heidegger heidegger redux he's back to haunt us again they just transformed the old theological problem into heideggerianism and then heideggerianism into what is alleged to be a new theological problem”

0.69

Human beings have three temporal concerns constitutive of care (Sorge): concern about the future (projecting oneself into possibilities and confronting one's own mortality), concern about the past (confronting guilt and the unrealized possibilities one did not pursue), and concern about the present (recognizing freedom from inauthenticity and potential for authentic choice).

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Heidegger: Being and Time [MaobMHescwg]

“there are at least three things about which we are concerned and here comes the temporal element first case we are concerned about the future and that means that design conscious human being projects itself into the future right in other words the way we experience the world we experience ourselves not just here and now but we project ourselves into the future and we also project ourselves into our past projecting ourselves into our future causes angst worry almost almost a terminal frightfulness because we must confront the fact that we come to an end”

0.69

If one wants to be human, one must 'get a soul' and face the inelimitable internal facts of psychic experience and ask certain questions about being, even though these questions may have no answers and we may not recognize an answer if we encounter it—this is obscurity combined with honest confrontation of human reality.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Heidegger: Being and Time [MaobMHescwg]

“if we try and escape it by truncating off reality by adopting some sort of human or positivistic position so don't worry about guilt don't worry about your inter the internal facts of your psyche the result is is that you concern yourself with beings you lapse back into that pre-authentic pre-philosophical state that heidegger says you ignore at your parent oh that you engage in extra peril if you want to be human then get a soul and you want to get a soul then face the fact that there are certain inelimitable parts of your experience which you have to confront in order to be human and there are certain questions that you have to ask in order to be human”

0.69

Heidegger's Being and Time explores freedom as something that must be earned rather than given—it must be worked toward as a response to Dasein through confrontation with the real facts of human existence.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Heidegger: Being and Time [MaobMHescwg]

“his great work being in time is uh a very difficult piece of work because it wasn't all published in one whole chunk he published it for various kind of academic contingencies in 27 and the idea behind it is that freedom has to be earned it's not something you get given it's something you work towards as a response to design and you earn your freedom you become a human being you make yourself by your confrontation with the real facts of human existence”

0.68

The most significant difficulty with Heidegger and similar systems is that this nebulous collection of insights, tautologies, unintelligibilities, and neologisms represents a transformation of theology with the god left out—Heidegger's Being functions as a secularized god, and we worship ourselves instead of a deity.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Heidegger: Being and Time [MaobMHescwg]

“my final difficulty with heidegger and i think this is the most interesting and important difficulty with at least from my perspective it is is that this nebulous collection of insights and tautologies and unintelligibilities and neologisms right are a kind of transformation of theology in other words it seems to me that what heidegger's being is what this ontological search is is theology with the god left out right and we worship ourselves and we have obligations to ourselves instead of obligations to the deity”

0.68

Guilt in Heidegger's philosophy is not merely moral guilt but an existential condition: the uncomfortable certainty that we are not what we could have been, that we have not realized all our possibilities and cannot do so given our finite lifespan, creating a debt to ourselves we can never repay.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Heidegger: Being and Time [MaobMHescwg]

“we also project ourselves into our past projecting ourselves into our future causes angst worry almost almost a terminal frightfulness because we must confront the fact that we come to an end and we don't know how to avoid that we can't avoid that we project ourselves into the earlier parts of our life and an interesting fact is that we cannot avoid the experience of guilt and i would be tempted to say that guilt is the uncomfortable certainty that we are not what we could have been”

0.63

Existentiality is the second component of Dasein, involving the appropriation of the world for our own purposes through practical engagement—we manipulate objects and food in pragmatic, utilitarian ways to sustain ourselves.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Heidegger: Being and Time [MaobMHescwg]

“the second element in existence is existentiality and this idea entails appropriating the world for our own purposes we take knowledge we take objects we take food we take things of utility to us and we manipulate them in practical ways right practical utilities very pragmatic sense of how human beings interact with the world around them”

0.63

Fallenness (Verfallen) is the condition of radical deprivation in human existence—there is something wrong with us in our pre-reflective unconscious state, which gives Heidegger his philosophical work: to drive us from unconsciousness toward authentic consciousness of ourselves.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Heidegger: Being and Time [MaobMHescwg]

“the final quality of human being particularly this pre-reflective quality is the quality of uh in german it's fair fallen but the best translation index is probably something like there's something wrong with us there's something there's a sort of radical deprivation of the human condition as it starts this is what gives heidegger something to do he wants to start with his pre-reflective kind of unconscious human state and drive us towards consciousness of ourselves”

0.61

Although Heidegger claims not to be an existentialist in a philosophical sense, he is one in a historical sense, because his influence has been greatest in the philosophy of existence rather than in his unique ontological project.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Heidegger: Being and Time [MaobMHescwg]

“heidegger himself claims not to be an existentialist but he is in a historical rather than a conceptual rather than in a philosophical sense it's clear that he does influence people like sartre or camus and despite his protestations his influence has been greatest in the philosophy of existence as opposed to his unique and somewhat idiomatic philosophical project of developing an ontology”

0.61

Kierkegaard, in the tradition of German romanticism, wanted his epitaph to read simply 'that individual,' emphasizing the existential goal of becoming an individual through authentic confrontation with one's existence, which Heidegger echoes in his call for authentic being.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Heidegger: Being and Time [MaobMHescwg]

“one of the formative influences um uh kierkegaard wanted his tombstone to say soren kierkegaard and his date of birth and date of death and then below that he wanted to say that individual which is a beautiful and profound epitaph well what heidegger calls upon us to do is to follow kierkegaard but to follow him in that respect in an individual way”

0.60

Heidegger's later work consists mostly of detailed analysis of Pre-Socratic thinkers, particularly in essays titled Holzwege ('Wood Trails'), treating philosophical investigations as paths that lead nowhere—cul-de-sacs or blind alleys that are more difficult and even more impenetrable than his earlier work.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker - Lecturer

“in the post-war years heidegger's work continued to be difficult and almost impenetrable and he spent most of his time analyzing the pre-socratics um there's a very interesting set of essays called uh uh what's what's the german uh name pulse vega which means wood trails and what is interesting about wood trails the reason why i chose that kind of odd title is that in german wood trails have the idea of cul-de-sacs in other words you take a walk into the woods and there are various trails but they don't lead anywhere they lead towards nothing they lead towards an impasse”

0.60

Facticity (Geworfenheit) is the condition of being thrown into a world not of our own making, into a spatio-temporal world full of people, things, and questions we did not choose—it is not a disease or problem but simply what is, and we must deal with it.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Heidegger: Being and Time [MaobMHescwg]

“the first is facticity in german govorfan height to be thrown into the world we didn't ask for this right no one consulted us you know before we were born or before we became conscious asking us if we would like a kind of spatio-temporal world full of people and things and objects and questions and issues like that we're stuck with it you know this is not a disease it's not a problem it's just it is what it is you don't like it that's tough deal with it”

0.60

Heidegger holds the mystical and untrue view that philosophy can only be done in German (and perhaps Greek), not in other languages; this reflects cultural chauvinism influenced by Nazi-era ideology and makes his already obscure philosophy even more difficult by creating magical, mystical attitudes toward language.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker - Lecturer

“he holds the view that philosophy can only be done in german that is not a joke i know that may sound funny it may sound and i can imagine wittgenstein in his grave turning over and over and over saying nine right no no in any language no all right philosophy can be done in any language that's not correct but heidegger has what i would end up being describing as a sort of mystical or magical view of language”

0.60

Heidegger has had little influence in Anglo-American analytical philosophy; Carnap wrote a scathing critique describing Heidegger's work as 'particularly unpleasant example of what happens to your brain when you do metaphysics—the high point of unintelligible gibberish,' reflecting scientific philosophy's rejection of dread, death, and metaphysical obscurity.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker - Lecturer

“this is i mean i think tells us something about this kind of philosophy it's had rather little influence certainly in the anglo-american philosophical world a karnap wrote a scathing treatment of some of heidegger in which he said this is a particularly unpleasant example of what happens to metaphysics or what happens to your brain when you do metaphysics this is the high point of unintelligible gibberish”

0.60

Continental philosophy's focus on interiority and introspection rather than external inquiry creates fundamental dangers: (1) it becomes difficult to articulate findings intelligibly; (2) one risks talking only to oneself rather than engaging philosophy; (3) nihilism emerges as a possibility when speech becomes indistinguishable from silence.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker - Lecturer

“when you start talking about interiority when you move from the realm of public discourse about stuff out there beings with a small bee to whatever it is you've got going on inside you all right the difficulty is first of all that it's very hard to put words on this to talk about this in any kind of intelligible way the danger here is that you end up talking to yourself right which is the opposite of the philosophical enterprise a second problem is that nihilism is always a possibility because we might want to say almost a definition of nihilism is a speech that's indistinguishable from silence”

0.55

Heidegger's discussions of 'Nothing' (Nichts) and 'thinking about nothing' are impenetrable and internally contradictory: nothing is not negation but 'the source of negation'; this creates logical confusion and unintelligibility that Heidegger dismisses with 'so much the worse for your logic,' demonstrating how his obscurity becomes self-parody.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker - Lecturer

“thinking about nothing is one of the most trying things you can try and do i mean there are long sections i know it sounds like almost a joke but there are long sections which we discuss are encountered with nothing and it means that nothing is not quite negation but the source of negation i have no clear conception of what that means and what what's involved in thinking about nothing i have tried working through it and it runs us into all kinds of logical problems and heidegger will say well so much the worst for you and for your logic confront being as it really is”

0.55

Much of Heidegger's philosophical power derives from elaborate puns and plays on words that exploit German's grammatical features; for example, 'unheimlich' (uncanny) connects to 'heim' (home), merging the concepts of anxiety, homelessness, and longing for Being into linguistic overlap—this creates richness through connotation rather than denotation.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker - Lecturer

“many of heidegger's ideas or many many parts of his writings are elaborate puns and plays on words let me give you an example from the german um he says that our feeling uh with regard to our encounter with design is uncanny and in german that's unheimlich and he says that this uncanny feeling of not knowing our way around in the world amounts to not feeling at home in the world now in german the word for home is haim and so when we have this uncanny feeling we feel on heimlich which means unhomely which means we don't feel at home in the world”

0.52

If denying Dasein and remaining in a pre-philosophical state of denial leads to good behavior, the speaker would prefer to be stupid rather than authentic, raising questions about whether Heidegger's demand for authenticity is morally desirable.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Heidegger: Being and Time [MaobMHescwg]

“in some ways we are if if being in this pre-philosophical state of denying design gets us to behave well i would be inclined to say well i'd rather be stupid that perhaps that's just me”

0.52

Heidegger's project to restore pristine pre-Socratic ontological thinking and return humanity to authentic being structurally parallels the Biblical narrative of return to the Garden of Eden, with fallenness functioning as equivalent to original sin—though Heidegger denies this comparison.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker - Lecturer

“heidegger wants to force us back to an earlier pristine state this sounds remarkably like going back to the garden of eden i could be mistaken this condition of being fair fallen sounds to me an awful lot like sin and since it's so universal it strikes me as an awful lot like original sin but i may be mistaken professor heidegger tells us that it's not original sin he explicitly says so but i have my doubts”

0.52

Heidegger's demand for authenticity and confrontation with Being parallels Jesus's command to the rich young man: 'Go, sell all you have and follow me.' Heidegger similarly demands that we forsake all particular beings (small b) and follow Being itself, making authenticity the only remaining obligation for conscious human beings.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker - Lecturer

“heidegger's stance towards being i mean to take this idea a little bit further reminds me of the gospel story of the rich young man a rich young man who's very virtuous comes to jesus and says how do i really become good how do i really become virtuous and jesus says go sell all you have and follow me is saying something remarkably like that he is saying go forsake all of beings with a small b all the trivialities of your experience and sell all you have and follow me not follow heidegger but follow being itself follow authenticity it is the only obligation left for the conscious human being in the 20th century”

0.48

Dasein, Heidegger's term for human being, is fundamentally finite, contingent, uncertain, and characterized by psychic states like worry, guilt, and anxiety; it is the unique vehicle or matrix through which Being discloses itself to us.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker - Lecturer

“design is human being in the world it is finite it is contingent it is uncertain it is a collection of psychic states like worry guilt anxiety and this constellation of human qualities or human entities is not like anything else in the world it is the way in which or the vehicle in which the matrix in which being is disclosed to us”

0.46

The investigation of Dasein and authentic Being requires circularity: we can only understand Being from the perspective of being a human being, and we must be a human being to understand Being—this circularity is characteristic of and an Achilles' heel of continental philosophy.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker - Lecturer

“i know how now can you see how this is going to get awfully circular and strange and that we're going to have whole chapters and perhaps whole volumes of being talks to itself and projects itself into the future of being you're going to get a lot of what appears to be circular reasoning on account of the fact that we're stuck within the internality the what i call the intracosm and it's very hard to break out from the intracosm into the exorcism it's one of the characteristic flaws it's perhaps the achilles heel of continental philosophy”

0.45

Dasein has a three-fold structure: (1) Understanding—the ability to contextualize the world and create meaning; (2) Mood—affective states like happiness and sadness that are ontologically significant; (3) Discourse—language that constitutes our understanding, making everyday depoeticized language incapable of uncovering authentic Being.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker - Lecturer

“we have facticity extension existentiality and forfeiture this condition of being fair fallen of being caught up in a web of maya a web of illusions the world of beings this booming buzzing confusion out there is essentially not real our reality is in being capital b not in any of these trivialities these distractions that we're forced to confront just from being a human being”

0.45

Guilt is not a negative experience to be overcome but an inelimitable fact of human being; any scientific or positivistic position that ignores this or denies its reality produces inauthenticity, causing people to focus on trivial concerns and lapse into unreflective existence.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker - Lecturer

“if we try and escape it by truncating off reality by adopting some sort of human or positivistic position so don't worry about guilt don't worry about your inter the internal facts of your psyche the result is is that you concern yourself with beings you lapse back into that pre-authentic pre-philosophical state that heidegger says you ignore at your parent oh that you engage in extra peril if you want to be human then get a soul and you want to get a soul then face the fact that there are certain inelimitable parts of your experience which you have to confront in order to be human”

0.45

Heidegger transitions from being a philosopher to functioning as a prophet when he calls people to authenticity and to heed their conscience, employing the voice and rhetoric of prophetic tradition (reminiscent of Jeremiah) rather than philosophical argumentation.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker - Lecturer

“he moves from being a philosopher to being a prophet with surprising agility and when he calls you to be yourself when he calls you to hear heed the voice of your own conscience he sounds more like jeremiah than he does sar but i could be wrong here now”

0.43

The inauthentic mode of existence—being caught up with particular beings and distracted from Being—is the source of what Heidegger calls 'the mass man' (das Man), which is the opposite of individuality: herd existence that is unreflective, unthinking, and fails to encounter the world on its own terms.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker - Lecturer

“if you always live your life in this condition of being fair fallen in this condition of forfeiture you have forfeited your claim to being really human to be human is to confront the world the way it is not it's it's to be a grown-up adult that is willing to deal with human life as it is rather than yet then getting distracted or sidetracked by any of the various cul-de-sacs that life might offer us and if you think about what this leads to uh these men or the vast majority of human beings apparently are caught up in this inauthentic mode of existence and that is the source in the 20th century of the thing called the mass man”

0.43

Heidegger's approach to ontology begins with human experience rather than abstract theory, following a phenomenological method: we must remove irrelevant distractions from our lived experience to arrive at pure ontological knowledge, similar to extracting gold from dross.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker - Lecturer

“he says think of it from the perspective of a human being from your perspective now rather than constructing a set of abstractions which later on you you will use to tailor your experience of the world start now with your experience and remove from your experience the things that are irrelevant the dross so that you get the pure gold of ontological knowledge”

0.43

The only real ethical obligation is authenticity: not what you do in life matters most, but how you do it—with conscious awareness of finitude rather than self-deception; this prioritization of mode over content of action creates a tension with traditional ethics and shades toward nihilism.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker - Lecturer

“that ethics kind of not implodes so that the only real obligation that we have left is that we should be authentic and that ends up meaning that it's not so important what you do in life is how you do it right in other words between now and the time you die it's not so important what projects you undertake as it is that you should be conscious of the fact that you're not going to take all of them and that you have to decide which are better the difficulty here is that this very easily shades off into straightaway nihilism”

0.43

Being (capital B) is not like any particular being (small b) in the world; rather, Being functions like light in Plato's cave allegory—it discloses all individual beings to us but is not itself one of those beings, making Being fundamentally mysterious and inaccessible to empirical investigation.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker - Lecturer

“a being is not like the other beings in the world when we get up into the realm of the forms being is like light that discloses the things in the world to us but it is not one of those things that gets disclosed so being allows us to know about the the being that the small be being of tables and chairs and podiums and carpets and things like that”

0.43

To achieve authentic being, one must confront death (Amorphati) as the horizon of human existence; death anxiety, worry, and care—not pleasant emotions—are the necessary preconditions for authentic confrontation with Being and move one beyond distraction with trivial particular concerns.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker - Lecturer

“in the first case if you want to really confront dazine that's what we get from volume 2 you're going to have to get used to the idea of amorphati or acceptance of fate particularly acceptance of your own death death anxiety worry care fear are the main themes of heidegger's second work and this is the good side remember this is the upside you're better off with this rather than dwelling on all the other things that might distract you from these businesses”

0.43

Time is not an infinite horizon but the horizon of human possibilities; we experience time as finite, bounded by death, not as the objective scientific view of time extending infinitely—this temporal finitude is foundational to authentic being and explains why Heidegger titled his work Being and Time.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker - Lecturer

“we experience it as the horizon of our possibilities so time is here to stay now can you see why he titles his book being and time he wants to study being and then he wants to study some essential foundational groundwork for the human experience of being and that turns out to be the fact that we are temporal right”

0.34

Being in Time (Sein und Zeit), published in 1927 in Husserl's Phenomenological Yearbook and dedicated to Edmund Husserl, represents Heidegger's first and perhaps greatest work, which initiated his philosophical influence and established a student-teacher relationship with phenomenology.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker - Lecturer

“his first and perhaps greatest work or the work that got him the most noticed was published in 1927 it's called sign on site which means a being in time and he was a student of husserls and it was published in husserl's phenomenological yearbook and it was dedicated to edmund husserl”

0.34

Heidegger wrote his doctoral dissertation on Duns Scotus, a difficult medieval theologian and scholastic philosopher, indicating his intellectual ambition and fearlessness in tackling forbidding intellectual problems.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker - Lecturer

“he wrote his doctrinal dissertation on dun scotus now any of you at home who've read some scholastic philosophy who know who duns scotus is know how difficult and recondite and intimidating forbidding a doctoral dissertation like that is”

0.34

Being in Time was not published as a single complete work but in installments for academic contingencies; the first volume analyzes the unreflective, inauthentic state of Dasein caught up with particular beings, while the second volume sketches authentic being and conducts a phenomenological destruction of the history of ontology.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker - Lecturer

“his great work being in time is uh a very difficult piece of work because it wasn't all published in one whole chunk he published it for various kind of academic contingencies in 27 and the idea behind it is that freedom has to be earned it's not something you get given it's something you work towards as a response to design”

0.34

By the end of his life, Heidegger's exemplar of philosophical achievement shifts from Plato's dialogues to Parmenides' poem on Being, treating Parmenides as the founder of ontology and model for pristine pre-Socratic thought.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unknown Speaker - Lecturer

“in some ways by the end of his life the great example of a philosophical enterprise is no longer plato's dialogues it has become parmenide's poem about being i don't imagine many of you at home or many of you here have gotten around to reading parmenide's poem about being let me see if i can help you with that um what parmenides says is that we must think and say that being is from the other way i debar you what he means is that ontology is the first and primary and fundamental concern of human beings all else follows from that”

0.20

Heidegger believes that ontology—the study of Being itself—was the great achievement of pre-Socratic and Greek philosophy but has been abandoned or corrupted since Aristotle, with Christianity, Rome, and the Enlightenment contributing little to philosophical understanding.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker - Lecturer

“he thinks that pretty much it's all been downhill since aristotle right that christianity the romans the enlightenment didn't make much of a contribution to the history of thought um after aristotle it's all downhill and the real high point was even before plato was in the pre-socratics”