
Mike Munger on Recycling 7/2/2007
What this covers
This is a conversation between Russ Roberts and Mike Munger, built on Munger's essay at the Library of Economics and Liberty. It works through recycling material by material rather than treating it as one virtue. Munger's ground rule is that individuals need only ask whether someone will pay for what they are discarding. If they must pay to have it taken away, it fails the Garbage-or-Resource Test. He applies the same repair-versus-replace reasoning households already use for clothes and appliances.
The range is wide. Aluminum is the clear success, since recycling clean cans in quantity beats mining bauxite, though cans now contain about 52 percent less metal, which erodes their scrap value. Munger uses diapers and thinner cans to show that resource use changes with prices. Glass is the contested case: cullet from green bottles is so abundant that making new glass from sand uses fewer resources. Clear PET and milk-jug HDPE are described as net losers for cities, and he suggests that burning plastic in scrubbed incinerators may beat landfilling. He also covers city incentives, including aluminum revenue that works as a cross-subsidy, contamination costs pushed onto households, and cities advising residents to run recyclables through the dishwasher.
The last strand is about prices and norms. Flat-fee trash pickup makes the marginal cost of another bag zero, but higher disposal prices invite illegal dumping. Munger favors deposits and pay-by-volume schemes. He treats the virtue of recycling as an emergent moral norm, comparable to the norm against littering, and defends the economist's dollar as a common unit for comparing trade-offs.
Munger argues that recycling should be judged by whether it saves resources at market prices. When recovered material is worth less than the cost of collecting and processing it, recycling wastes resources, and the moral framing of recycling as a duty obscures this.
- Garbage-versus-resource test: an item is a resource only if someone will pay for it or it can be made into something cheaper or higher quality
- Prices reveal resource use, so a recycling process that costs more than virgin production uses more resources
- Cities and households respond to misaligned prices, such as landfill fees, cross-subsidies, and cheap curbside disposal, in ways that distort recycling
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Disposable diapers have become much cheaper and use less plastic over time, and manufacturers did this because it was cheaper, not because they love the environment. Resource use is therefore dynamic and changes with prices.
“it's cheaper to make diapers look less plastic if you can find a way to do it so the answer is dynamic”
Cities have a perverse incentive structure: they profit only from clean, sorted recyclables, while consumers bear the sorting costs. If materials arrive dirty, the city loses money on recycling and is effectively spending money to convert garbage.
“the only way that cities can make money by recycling aluminum is by making sure that all the sorting is done on the front end by consumers”
The virtue of recycling is an emergent cultural norm created through a decentralized movement, comparable to anti-smoking and anti-littering norms. Many people now feel guilty if they do not recycle.
“many many people would feel guilty if they didn't do that and they feel good when they do do it and that is an incredible emergent cultural value”
Cities choose the cheapest disposal option, which for aluminum means selling it to buyers for a profit. Aluminum revenue cross-subsidizes the rest of the recycling program, which can make the program roughly budget-neutral. Newsprint can also make a little money if sorted and in large amounts.
“they use that to subsidize the rest of the recycling program in some cases they make enough money on that that the money they lose on the rest of the recycling program”
The thinning of cans is driven by the self-interest of can makers, since aluminum is expensive. The narrowing neck of a soda can lets a thinner can support stacking weight, which is how producers reduce aluminum per can.
“the reason is go again yeah lumen is expensive and it's in the self narrow self-interest of can makers to find ways to make cans that are thin”
Some people run recyclables through the dishwasher before putting them out, and several cities explicitly advise this on their websites. This converts garbage into a resource for the city, but the household pays water, electricity, and time costs that make the practice economically irrational.
“I actually found several cities that explicitly on their websites suggest that you run all of your jars and plastics through the dishwasher”
Recycling aluminum is only worthwhile when cans are clean and in large quantity. Mixing aluminum with iron, plastic, or even wrappers makes it garbage, so sorting must happen at the household level.
“it requires sorting if there's any commingling of resources at all if they have any iron cancer there's any plastic ... it's not a resource”
Aluminum is a genuine resource: recycling aluminum uses fewer resources than mining bauxite and smelting it with large amounts of electricity, so clean aluminum cans are worth recycling in quantity.
“recycling aluminum has the impact of using fewer resources than mining new bauxite”
Market prices on all resources reveal whether recycling uses more or fewer resources, provided prices are right. Self-interested people will discover which option is cheaper because they can make money by choosing correctly.
“if it's more expensive it's using more resources provided that prices are right”
Landfill disposal is underpriced because households pay a flat fee regardless of volume, so the marginal cost of an extra bag of trash is zero. This encourages throwing things away rather than recycling, and environmentalists are right to identify this distortion.
“I don't pay extra for throwing more stuff away rather than less that's always going to encourage me to throw stuff away”
Pricing landfills correctly requires enforcement. If disposal is priced high, people dump illegally: a homeowner can save $20 by dumping a $25 washing machine in a vacant lot, so higher prices create a cheating incentive.
“suppose we say that you want to throw away an old washing machine it's gonna cost you 25 bucks I have a pickup truck I just back up into some vacant lot”
Recycling glass is costly because glass must be sorted by color and type, and it breaks easily. Green glass cullet is in such excess relative to demand that recycling green glass into new bottles uses more resources than making new green glass from sand.
“it actually uses more resources to recycle green glass than it does to make new green glass out of sand”
Recycling can use more resources than throwing things away. When it does, recycling destroys valuable resources rather than conserving them, and the 'always better to recycle' claim is false.
“recycling could use more resources than throwing away which means that recycling exhausts precious things rather than conserves them”
Individuals do not need to figure out whether recycling is worth it: they only need to check whether someone will pay for the material. If you must pay someone to take it away, it is garbage and recycling it is inefficient.
“you don't really have to figure out whether you should recycle your cans or not you should just look and see whether someone will pay you for it”
Economists treat all resources in a common unit and assign dollar values at a point in time, which lets them choose the least-resource option. Munger argues this is the humane way to live, since time is precious and cannot be regained.
“it's the human way to lead your life it's the right way it is the humane way because as you said earlier our time is precious it does not come back”
Littering was once normal but is now socially punished, and recycling has become a moral imperative of similar weight, even though littering has clear external harms while recycling's resource effects are uncertain.
“they're saying that the value of recycling is a moral imperative as big as not littering even though not littering has clear external effects”
Munger's proposed test is that reuse is better only if it uses fewer resources than making new goods; if converting used material into a usable item takes more resources, throwing it out and starting from scratch is preferable.
“if it takes more resources to convert something that's used into something that's usable it's better to throw it out and start from scratch”
Households reuse and repair clothes and other goods by comparing the cost of repair with the cost of replacement, which is the same reasoning that should apply to recycling. Curbside recycling is treated as a special category that escapes this calculation.
“we ask ourselves a question then how much will it cost to clean or repair this if it's too much we throw it away”
Clear soft-drink plastic (PET) and milk-jug plastic (HDPE) are net losers for cities. Contamination makes plastic worthless and cities often landfill it, or pay extra to recycle it for political reasons.
“there's two kinds of plastic PET which is the clear kind that we use for soft drink bottles and HDPE which is the kind you use for milk jugs both of those are pretty big net losers”
Aluminum cans now contain about 52 percent less aluminum than before, so the scrap value per can has fallen enough that collecting cans is often no longer worth the time.
“aluminum cans are 52 percent lighter the incentives to reduce the amount of aluminum in each can has gone up”
Some cities charge by weight or by can, and households pay a premium for extra containers. This internalizes the cost of disposal and encourages recycling, which economists see as a good thing.
“some cities I think charge you by weight some charge you by ... you have to pay a premium that is the idea of that is to cause people to internalize”
Economists use dollars as a common unit that lets different resources be weighed against each other. Without some common measure, one cannot add three apples and four oranges, so the economist's dollar is a practical way to compare trade-offs.
“you can't add three apples and four oranges and say well okay it uses seven that's less different resources have different values you need some way of adding them up”
The solution to disposal and recycling problems is to get prices right, for example by charging a deposit up front: a $3 charge on batteries that is refunded as a $3 credit when the old battery is returned.
“charge a little bit extra on the front end for the disposal of batteries ... batteries you charge three dollars on the front end and then when I take an auto battery in I get a three dollar credit”
Burning plastic in municipal incinerators with scrubbers can have essentially no environmental impact and is cheaper than landfilling, so it can be a better use than landfill even though most people would not call it recycling.
“if you have scrubbers there actually is no impact on the environment so is that recycling no not by most people's definition”
In most American cities, the curbside bin is profitable only for aluminum and sometimes newsprint, which subsidizes the rest of the program, while PET clear plastic and HDPE milk jugs are both large net losers, so cities look for ways to avoid handling them.
“there's two kinds of plastic te T which is the clear kind that we use for soft drink bottles and HDPE which is the kind you use for milk jugs both of those are pretty big net losers”
Most of what gets put in curbside recycling is garbage in the economic sense: recycling it costs more than it returns, so it ends up thrown away in some form.
“most of the stuff that we recycle is garbage we just spend more doing it it ends up being thrown away in some form”
Ground glass can be used as cheap road base or aggregate, and it is an inert material whose trapped chemicals will not leach, so treating glass as garbage and using it as fill is cheaper than reusing it as glass.
“ground glass is an excellent way is a terrific Road bit if you'll let me use it that way it's a lot cheaper”
Many US cities stopped accepting green glass because it was too expensive. Some cities then gave in to environmental pressure and started recycling it, handling it two or three extra times, and then sent it to the landfill anyway because the process was too costly.
“they say okay you win we'll recycle the green glass ... when they get to the landfill they take the green class container out of the recycling truck and they put it into the landfill”
When Munger and his family used cloth diapers with a diaper service, the cost was about $29 per month and was cheaper in money than disposables, but it cost much more of their time, and he now believes it was irrational to think he was saving resources.
“it was something like twenty nine dollars a month ... I think it was irrational for me to think I was saving any resources by doing this”
Whether something is garbage or a resource can be determined by two questions: would someone pay me for it, and could I make something with it that costs less or has higher quality? If the answer to both is no, it is garbage.
“is it a resource or is it garbage ... would somebody pay me for it ... could I make something with it that either cost less or has higher quality”
Treating time as if it were worth zero is anti-human, because time cannot be recovered and is spent on family, volunteering, or reading. An economist's approach includes human time in the calculation, which is the humane way to live.
“if you treat your time cavalierly ... they're giving away something that you cannot regain and that is what is precious”
In about 100 years, large-scale plastic mining will occur because plastic is petroleum-based and burns well, so buried plastic is a future fuel reserve that becomes worth recovering as crude oil gets more expensive.
“I have a prediction yes 100 years from now there will be large plastic strip mining operations”
The aluminum can recycling rate fell from 65 percent in 1992 to 48 percent in 2002, a substantial decline in the share of cans recovered.
“65 percent of aluminum cans were recycled in 1992 only 48 percent of aluminum cans were recycled in 2002”
Recycling is a Sabbath-like ritual in which spending time is itself the signal of devotion, and this is why it feels religious rather than purely economic.
“it's the very fact that we spend time that means that we're religiously devout so for example many people don't work on the Sabbath”
The feeling of virtue from recycling depends on the absence of payment: people treat being unpaid for recycling as proof that the act is moral, which is why it feels like a moral imperative rather than an economic choice.
“the reason I know it's good is that nobody's paying me to do it that's the sign that it's virtuous”
The hardcore environmentalist mindset rejects trade-offs entirely, holding that virgin sand and processed materials are incomparable: pristine, precious earth resources should not be weighed against human time spent on recycling.
“I can't put a financial excuse me let me restate it using the calculus of dollars and cents to be able to compare and weigh those two things is not right”
Most people reject the idea that time does not matter in other contexts such as darning socks or fixing appliances, yet they accept it in recycling. That inconsistency makes recycling puzzling.
“I think everyone disagrees with that in other contexts outside of recycling and even in the context of recycle”
People have stopped darning socks and fixing appliances because the cost of labor and time has risen relative to the cost of new goods. Recycling cans, bottles, and newspapers is the only household activity that people treat as exempt from this calculation.
“somehow cans bottles a newspaper enter their own space their own dimension that is not like the socks or the turkey carcass”
People distinguish new from old stuff morally, so they will waste hot water and soap rinsing recyclables while installing fluorescent bulbs to save electricity, even though the energy is burned elsewhere.
“I think people have make a moral distinction between new stuff versus old stuff”
People feel virtuous when they put recyclables at the curb even though they know the material may be wasted, and Munger suggests this feeling is a sign that the act is seen as a moral imperative rather than an economic choice. He admits he himself lingers at the curb hoping neighbors see him.
“I hope some neighbor sees me because I'm doing something that's good for the environment”
Non-economists reject the calculation that adds up the time and resource costs of recycling, so they believe recycling is always worth it. Economists respond that without comparing costs, you cannot tell when you are wasting resources versus building them up.
“economist says no that's what we do we got to do that otherwise we can't tell when we're wasting or destroying versus building up and producing”
Time is the most valuable and scarce resource because it cannot be replenished, so treating it as having zero value, as some recycling advocates do, is a value judgment rather than a fact.
“my view is that time is our most valuable and scarce resource we can't make any more of that”
Economics should mean trade-offs and choices among scarce resources, not merely financial costs. Financial and resource costs are both part of economics, and the word should be reserved for trade-off reasoning.
“economic means both financial it's about the monetary aspects of it but it's also about the trade-offs and choices which is what I think we really should reserve the word economic for”
Forecast: as the moralization of recycling grows, people will see through the 'hocus-pocus' and stop recycling even for economic reasons, throwing out recyclable materials that do have value, such as copper tubing and cars.
“I'm worried that we'll start to throw away things that actually do have value because people see through this kind of hocus-pocus”
Most people justify recycling on utilitarian grounds, saying it saves resources and the environment, but it is hard to verify that recycling actually saves resources. The test is whether someone will pay for the material.
“it's really hard to tell that it's true ... will somebody pay you for this”
The environmentalist response is that recycling is worth it even if it costs more, and that this has become a political and religious question rather than an economic one.
“it's worth it because it's become a political and religious question and not an economic question”
Oil change shops that charge a disposal fee but pour used oil down the drain pocket the difference, showing how fee-based disposal creates a theft-like incentive to dump pollution on others.
“if they then go and pour it down the sewer drain they make a profit because they save their disposal costs and they pocket your so-called fee”
Repairs such as TV fixing used to be cheaper than replacement, but now most people throw out broken appliances. Consumers do not demand public subsidies for microwave repair, and nobody thinks this is strange, even though recycling gets a different treatment.
“your TV breaks you don't fix it anymore in 1950 1960 you fixed it because yeah TV repair was cheaper”
Economic incentives have made it less rational to recycle cans, and people do recycle less. But recycling still persists because of a religious impulse that throwing things out is wrong.
“economic incentives have caused there to be less aluminum in cans per can and that has made it less practical or rational to recycle”
Green glass has properties that require higher melting temperatures, releasing toxins and colorants that are costly to retrieve, so melting it is expensive.
“I have to melt it at a much higher temperature and it releases toxins and colors that are very difficult and expensive to retrieve”
John Tierney's 1996 New York Times Magazine article described school children sorting garbage and treating recycling as always better regardless of cost, including a child who insisted it was a crime to throw away half a manila folder.
“there was a famous article in The New York Times Magazine by John Tierney 1996 and the title of it was recycling his garbage”
Recycling could be a reasonable middle path: recycle and reuse the things that impose real costs on the environment, rather than imposing a political imperative to run turkey bones through the dishwasher.
“there has to be some kind of middle path not a political imperative to run turkey bones through the dishwasher but let's recycle the things”
Moralized recycling can produce backlash, as with Stendhal's remark about ice cream: people may throw cans away for the thrill of defying the moral norm.
“so you're suggesting that if we make it enough of a moral imperative there's going to be a backlash where people will will throw out stuff for the thrill of bucking”
The environmentalist objection is that sand is finite and irreplaceable, so making bottles from sand depletes a precious resource while recycling cullet is sustainable, even if it costs more.
“every time you make a new bottle out of sand you're using up an irreplaceable resource whereas the collet”
Cities advise rinsing recyclables partly to keep animals away from bins, but if animals are the concern, the real problem is the garbage itself, which would need to be sealed in vacuum packaging.
“we're trying to keep animals away from the recycle bins but then it seems to me if you're trying to keep animals away then the real problem is the garbage”
Cities say animals are the reason recyclables must be cleaned, but the logic does not hold: if animals are the problem, the garbage itself, including turkey carcasses and steak bones, should be cleaned too.
“if you're trying to keep animals away then the real problem is the garbage why not run the turkey carcass through the dishwasher”
Munger's perverse pleasure in throwing an aluminum can into the garbage in front of economics students shows how moral pressure produces reactions, though he would probably retrieve the can afterwards because he feels bad about not recycling.
“I actually have to admit I have a perverse joy in doing this a lot of times in class”
Recycling rates for many products are declining, so the moral framing has not made recycling more successful.
“recycling rates on all sorts of products are declining we're not doing better we're doing worse”
Munger's family's recycling is motivated by taste, not environmental concern: he makes soup from bones because he likes the taste, not to save the environment.
“it's not because I think I'm saving the environment I like the taste”
Turning off lights when leaving a room saves electricity, and Munger suggests going without electricity by using candles or the dark is the more virtuous option.
“why use that electricity when you could just get used to the dark”
Munger owns 35 acres of forestland that he grows trees on so future generations will have paper.
“I own 35 acres of forestland where I'm growing trees”