
Worse Than Asbestos? The CIRS Rabbit Hole | Dr. Scott McMahon & Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker | EP 415
What this covers
This is a conversation between Jordan Peterson and two physicians, Ritchie Shoemaker, who developed the CIRS framework, and pediatrician Scott McMahon, who treats it in Roswell, New Mexico. It begins with Peterson's own analogy of lead as a civilizational neurotoxin, then moves through the building science, the immunology, the diagnostic markers, and the treatment sequence for chronic inflammatory response syndrome (CIRS)). Much of the early ground concerns buildings: the claim that 50-85% of American structures are water-damaged, the role of post-1970 antifungal paints, and the argument that musty odor comes mainly from actinobacteria rather than fungi, which the speakers present against the usual attribution.
The diagnostic middle section covers the five primary markers, including visual contrast sensitivity (VCS)), HLA (Human Leukocyte Antigen)) susceptibility, and low melanocyte-stimulating hormone (MSH)). It also takes in NeuroQuant MRI volume changes and a five-step exposure-and-return design that Shoemaker says demonstrates causation. The mechanistic material is dense: ribosomal damage, lactic acidosis, and molecular hypometabolism), with leptin resistance, obesity, and diet advice tied to IRS2 levels. The treatment sequence runs from removing the exposure through binders, anti-inflammatory pretreatment to avoid intensification), and finally intranasal VIP).
The claims grow bolder from there. The speakers fold chronic fatigue, fibromyalgia, depression, childhood headaches and abdominal pain, long COVID, and Alzheimer's into CIRS, citing a Finnish architecture study and a microclot mechanism for the last. Many of these positions are labeled fringe or contested, and the conversation relies heavily on the speakers' own research. The episode also turns to institutions: short primary-care visits that cannot accommodate the evaluation, military housing contamination, and the activism of Sharon Kramer, which they link to lawsuits and a congressional hearing. Peterson closes on the comparison to asbestos.
Shoemaker and McMahon argue that chronic inflammatory response syndrome (CIRS) caused by biotoxins in water-damaged buildings is a widespread epidemic affecting ~25% of the population genetically susceptible to it, responsible for misdiagnosed conditions ranging from depression and fibromyalgia to Alzheimer's, with specific biomarkers and treatment protocols that can reverse neurological damage.
- 50-85% of North American buildings are water-damaged; post-1970 antifungal paints created natural selection for more toxic mold strains via innate immune activation
- 95% of CIRS patients lack proper antigen processing and show ~30 measurable biomarkers (VCS, HLA, TGF-beta-1, cytokine storms, lactic acidosis); genetic susceptibility is HLA-linked with 24% of population at risk
- CIRS causes microtubular dysfunction and CNS degeneration reversible via treatment: binders (cholestyramine), anti-inflammatory prep, and VIP (vasoactive intestinal peptide) restores brain volume and cognitive function in 70-90% of cases
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The Roman Empire fell in part because Romans used lead to seal wine amphorae; lead is a known neurotoxin that when later introduced into gasoline lowered the IQ of populations around the world by a substantial margin, and childhood exposure to deteriorating lead paint in older houses impaired intelligence and increased antisocial and criminal behavior.
“one of the reasons that the Roman Empire fell was because the Romans used lead to seal their wine empora and Lead is a known neurotoxin and when we introduced lead into gasoline to stop the gas from from or our our internal combustion engines from knocking we lowered the IQ of people around the world by a substantial margin”
The healthcare system barriers to diagnosing CIRS include: (1) time constraints (10-15 minute primary care visits vs. 2-hour evaluations needed); (2) physician lack of familiarity with innate immune system testing and biomarkers; (3) systemic focus on specialist expertise rather than comprehensive patient-centered evaluation; (4) derogatory terminology ('GOMER'—'get out of my emergency room') applied to complex patients.
“there is a derogatory term that is in still widespread use I have done a study about Emergency Room Physicians called a patient they would see with multiple symptoms called a Gomer yeah get out of my emergency room yeah because this people take time and when you have a Health Care system that gives you 10 or 15 minutes to see a patient in primary care facilities and you've got someone who needs two hours of time who's going to lose the two-hour patient or the 10-minute patient and who's gonna go without care so I think it's a systemic approach not an individual approach”
Brown fat and beige fat activation can increase energy expenditure via uncoupling protein (UCP) 1, 2, and 3; turning on brown fat 'non-shivering thermogenesis' (as in Finnish sauna + cold water exposure) increases metabolic consumption of energy dramatically. This approach can help defeat the physiologic mechanisms of fat storage and energy conservation seen in CIRS and obesity via molecular hypometabolism.
“we looked at at at the OC cytoid and and brown fat and we wanted to turn on Brown fat on coupling protein one two and three were found it used to be just one but I'm coupling one two and three are found we can convert beige fat to Brown fat and have increased metabolic consumption of energy by turning on Brown fat activation this is one of the advantages from Finland again here we we heat you up and you have a nice sauna and then we we T to let you go out and jump into a a snow bank we Y without making shivering that turns on Brown fat physiology”
Military housing is particularly affected by water damage, mold, and mold infestation; military families living in contaminated housing face health crises affecting troop readiness, soldier morale, suicide risk, and children's cognitive development. Military personnel are aware family members are suffering from chronic fatigue, cognitive issues, and chronic pain while living in housing, which reduces deployment readiness and psychological resilience.
“the people that that I was meeting with had visited a number of mil milary bases and had seen the military housing so they were already aware of the rad and uh infestations and and the the mole growing on the walls and whatnot”
Depression with seasonal component indicates physiological rather than purely psychological etiology; many cases diagnosed as primary depression have an underlying physiological basis, particularly involving immunological dysfunction.
“there's a long-standing history of depression in my family and my suspicions are strong that it has a physiological basis because first of all it has a seasonal component and that indicates something physiological right off the bat but it's also associated with a lot of immunological trouble”
Sharon Kramer was a key activist and whistleblower on military housing and mold problems; she first alerted to problems around Norfolk naval base. Her advocacy led to lawsuits and eventual $3 billion in settlements. She was instrumental in bringing CIRS issues to Congressional attention via Ted Kennedy's committee.
“in 2004 John Conor's convened a special session of Congress uh Sharon Kramer was the contact person and she's been a real real fighter on all these years for mold rights for mold patience and all that she's the one that first blew the whistle on military housing problems around the norfol energy base and3 billion dollar later that those lawsuits have been settled”
Fungi exposed to environmental stress (such as antifungal compounds) activate abnormal gene expression that leads to increased mycotoxin production; this is not primarily a defense mechanism but rather related to predation—fungi produce compounds like aflatoxins to eliminate plant defenses so they can consume plant tissue.
“fungi also have response to environmental hazards and the environmental hazards of being killed will cause AB normal activation of genes in fungal species such that they'll make toxins where beforehand they didn't with the main role of of of a moto toxin for example has nothing to do with defense it has everything to do with predation uh that the fungus wants to be eating a plant and the plant doesn't want to be eaten so it'll release things like a peroxidase and the fungi make compounds to eliminate the fungi they eliminate the peroxidase therefore eliminate the plant defenses”
Actinobacteria thrive in alkaline environments created by alkaline-producing compounds; they are famous for producing musty odor (geosmin), which has long been attributed to fungal colonization but actually originates primarily from actinobacteria; water saturation (aw 0.9-1.0) initially favors certain fungal species, which are later replaced by actinobacteria as drywall pH increases.
“actino bacteria love and alkaline environment molds like an acid environment and the alkaline environment from antino is created by manufacturer of substances that will kill off fungi and change the pH of the drywall so that as you see a initial building the initial colonization will be with fungi but it'll be replaced by actino bacteria as time goes on”
Prospective causation can be demonstrated by: (1) treating sick patients until biomarkers normalize (matching controls); (2) removing them from exposure; (3) having them voluntarily stop all medications (informed consent); (4) returning them to the suspect building; (5) measuring biomarker changes at 24-48 hours and again at 72 hours. Biomarkers change at day 1, worsen at day 2, and full syndrome reproduces by day 3 with no alternative explanation—this proves causation, not just correlation.
“took people that could have been sick from one building fixed them all the lab micers were the same and then with informed consent they stopped all medicines and away the suspect building three days nothing put them back in the day in the building on day one at the end of day one laboratory findings changed day two laboratory changes finding changed again day three we had the exact syndrome of labs BCS and symptoms prospectively proven upon reexposure only no other choices could have affected it wasn't depression in three days it was s in three days”
A published study identified elevated rates of Alzheimer's disease in Finland and attributed this to specific Finnish architectural designs that made homes more susceptible to biotoxin exposure; this is consistent with CIRS etiology of neurodegeneration. However, early detection of CIRS-related CNS degeneration (via biomarkers like tau, tubulin, and NeuroQuant) in Stage 1/2 patients can prevent progression to symptomatic Alzheimer's.
“I read in some of the work of yours that I reviewed for example that drywall seems to be a particular problem so what what what kind of how widespread is this problem do you suppose and and what buildings are particularly affected... I read a paper here recently while I was doing background research that showed that there's a much higher risk than in most countries in Finland for the development of of Alzheimer's and that that was associated in this paper with a particularity of if I remember correctly a Finnish architectural design that made their houses more susceptible to these biotoxins that you describe”
Chronic inflammatory response syndrome (CIRS) is caused by exposure to biotoxins (primarily from mold, actinobacteria, and their fragments) in water-damaged buildings; approximately 25% of the population has HLA genetic susceptibility that prevents proper antibody production in response to these biotoxins, resulting in a chronic innate immune activation that causes neurological, metabolic, and systemic symptoms.
“a substantial number of buildings especially those built with drywall using um anti-fungal paints have water damage that water damage produces biotoxins of various sorts for a substantial proportion of the population about 25% exposure to those biotoxins produces an immunological response that has all sorts of neurolog iCal and behavioral negative consequences”
Shoemaker and McMahon have published approximately 60 peer-reviewed papers related to CIRS, environmental exposure, and treatment (about 20 per author per ~3 papers per PhD thesis equivalent). In December 2019, Shoemaker testified before the US House and Senate Armed Services Committee about military housing; 16 days later (before news coverage could spread), President Trump's first impeachment dominated the news cycle, followed by COVID-19, causing the issue to fade from public attention despite Congressional appropriation of $300 million for military housing investigation.
“how how many papers have you two published between you that are related specifically to this topic approximately over 360 okay okay so we two together we're 60”
COVID-19 creates an inflammatory response that can trigger latent innate immune susceptibility (same HLA-based genetic susceptibility as CIRS), resulting in long COVID syndrome being functionally equivalent to chronic inflammatory response syndrome but with a viral trigger instead of an environmental/biotoxin trigger; the authors published this finding in June of the prior year.
“covid creates an inflammatory response it turns on an immune responses which turns on Gene based susceptibility so long covid has the same genetic makeup and we've published a paper on this in June of last year as well that creates a new illness a new Target where once wasn't before and we looked at people who had were living in a building and fine got covid got better from covid but then that turned on the innate immune response system that didn't stop and lo and behold a month month later two months later three months later they had long covid syndrome when actually what they had was a chronic inflammatory and metabolic response syndrome it was just a different initiator”
NeuroQuant MRI volumetric analysis shows reproducible, abnormal brain changes in CIRS patients: in water-damaged-building-triggered CIRS, the forebrain parenchyma is enlarged and cortical gray matter is enlarged while the caudate nucleus is atrophic; in Lyme-disease-triggered CIRS, the pattern is different (right thalamus enlarged, putamen atrophic). Treatment (first part of protocol) reduces forebrain and cortical enlargement to control levels; VIP (vasoactive intestinal peptide) treatment additionally reverses caudate nucleus atrophy toward normal.
“if you developed your chronic inflammatory response syndrome as a result of water damaged buildings we tend to see that the forbrain parena will be swollen we see that or enlarged I should say we'll see that the cortical gray matter will be enlarged and that the Cotate nucleus will be atropic will be smaller if you develop chronic inflammatory response syndrome as a result of of Lyme disease and post post- treatment Lyme disease syndrome we see a completely different pattern”
Chronic fatigue syndrome, fibromyalgia, depression, post-Lyme syndrome, and functional abdominal pain syndrome are likely misdiagnosis categories for CIRS; these conditions overlap extensively in symptoms but lack specific biomarkers. Approximately 10% fibromyalgia, 3% chronic fatigue syndrome, 25% depression, plus post-Lyme syndrome adds up to ~25% of the population experiencing what is actually CIRS but diagnosed under other labels.
“we can let him speak about children's with cognitive issues but the issue are that when we look carefully at chronic fatigue syndrome we find S and I'd like you sir if you could to identify one significant biomarker that distinguishes fibromyalgia from not we have 30 biomarkers for sers and zero for fibromyalgia why does fibromyalgia have such a preponderance of people and how many people adults have fibromyalgia 10% add 3% for for chronic fatigue syndrome how about postline syndrome how about depress boy we've got 25% all of a sudden and we must start looking at those details”
Among children evaluated for chronic headaches (10 million children in US) and chronic abdominal pain (10 million children in US), the large majority (~80-90%) have CIRS when assessed with biomarkers; pediatricians typically attribute these to psychological factors or functional disorders because they do not test for innate immune system dysfunction. When treated for CIRS, chronic headaches and abdominal pain either resolve or become much less frequent and severe, demonstrating that these are not psychological but biomedical in origin.
“at this point I've seen about a thousand children uh for that uh for for 28 years I had my own private practice where I worked with a nurse practitioner uh in the last 10 years I evaluated the children there that had chronic illnesses for Serv also and found that again the majority of children that had chronic headaches and and we're talking 10 million children in the United States alone the majority of those the the large majority they had sers when I evaluated them for that and when I treated them for that their their headaches would either go away or they would become much less severe much less frequent”
Between 50% and 85% of buildings in the United States are water-damaged; the EPA has published this data. Water-damaged buildings from any era can harbor biotoxin-producing organisms, but buildings constructed or retrofitted after 1970 are particularly problematic because anti-fungal and anti-mold paints were introduced to prevent mold growth, which inadvertently selected for mold and bacteria species that produce more toxic secondary metabolites.
“the EPA has published that at least 50% of the buildings and up to 85% of the buildings in the United States are historically water damaged buildings”
The treatment protocol for CIRS consists of sequential steps: (1) remediate or remove exposure from water-damaged building (most critical step); (2) use binders (cholestyramine or other agents) to bind and excrete biotoxins via fecal route (typically 2-3 months for improvement); (3) if initial treatment works, add pre-treatment with anti-inflammatory agents (omega-3 fatty acids, Actos) for 5-7 days before starting binders to prevent 'intensification' (symptom worsening); (4) follow Dr. Shoemaker's 'pyramid' protocol addressing different systems; (5) if 70% recovery not achieved, add intranasal VIP therapy.
“the first part of treatment is taking care of the exposures so if you're living in a home that's water damaged or uh or if it's your workplace or maybe it's school that you're attending you need to either fix that remediate that or or leave that the most important step of any kind of treatment for any kind of immunologic illness is getting away from exposure that is the most important step”
CIRS activates coagulation factor genes at high levels, causing microclot formation that binds to TGF-alpha and TGF-beta in the brain, leading to microbleeds and neurodegeneration that is the pathological starting point of Alzheimer's disease
“coagulation factors these genes are upregulated like crazy and they will bind to TA and T beta in in the brain and then create a microclot which will lice you know micro bleed and that's where Alzheimer's gets it start”
Molecular hypometabolism is a state of metabolic dysfunction characterized by: (1) ribosomal dysfunction—mycotoxins damage the sarcin-ricin loop (nucleotide position 1.15) on rRNA, preventing one adenosine replacement, disabling ~50% of ribosomal protein-making capacity; (2) mitochondrial dysfunction—pyruvate fails to enter mitochondria for ATP production and instead gets converted to lactic acid (Warburg effect), causing lactic acidosis in 85% of CIRS patients; (3) this leads to cellular energy rationing and underperformance across all systems.
“the structure that makes proteins and there's a million of these in every cell it's called a ribosome and if you remember your high school biology ribosomes make proteins and mitochondria make energy but the mechanism of protein production comes from RNA copied in off of DNA and traveling from the nucleus into the cytoplasm of the cell and that messenger RNA gives a signal to the ribosome to assemble one amino acid at a time a given Protein that's coded for by the RNA”
CIRS is associated with the obesity epidemic and leptin resistance; leptin binds to gp130 cytokine receptor in hypothalamus to activate POMC (pro-opiomelanocortin) production of MSH; leptin resistance blocks MSH production, causing fatigue, pain, and obesity. The combination of obesity, leptin resistance, and MSH deficiency is particularly severe; molecular hypometabolism compounds the problem. If 40% of Americans become morbidly obese by 2030, and if CIRS affects 25% of the population, there is massive overlap producing a metabolic catastrophe.
“you describing leptin def leptin resistance leptin is made by gp130 cyto receptor in the brain right in the hypothalamus where msh is involved and leptin must bind to its receptor send off a stat one signal to turn on production of PC Pro opio melanocortin to make msh so if you're LEP and resistant because of weight problems you don't turn on msh and so that by itself will turn on fatigue uh pain and then now obesity and what a Triad”
The primary biomarkers used to diagnose CIRS are: (1) Visual Contrast Sensitivity (VCS) test—abnormally low sensitivity indicating retinal microcirculation dysfunction; (2) HLA-DR genetic susceptibility; (3) Melanocyte-stimulating hormone (MSH)—abnormally low; (4) Cytokine levels—abnormally elevated; (5) TGF-beta-1 (transforming growth factor beta 1)—abnormally elevated. These biomarkers are chosen because they are validated to separate cases from healthy controls and show objective improvement with treatment.
“the first biomarker came from the EPA with Ken hell been studying the neurotoxicologic features of visual contrast sensitivity which is a mechanism to see an abnormal neurologic function of vision contrast is one that's get stabilized over time and is adversely affected as velocity of flow of red cells and retina neural Rim the optic nerve head increases so VCS was our first HLA was our next in that group there was a regulatory neuropeptide melanoid stimulating hormone which is essentially negative in all cases and normal in all controls”
Insulin receptor substrate 2 (IRS2) elevation increases glucose uptake into cells regardless of diet (keto diet doesn't work if IRS2 is elevated because glucose transporters are upregulated); protein wasting occurs on carnivore diet if IRS2 is elevated; the authors recommend testing IRS2 levels before implementing ketogenic or carnivore diets, as diet efficacy depends on IRS2 status.
“we start looking at insulin receptor substrate to that will increase delivery of glucose regardless of what the diet has it in involved a lot of people will be on a diet called a keto diet with keto diets they want to make themselves burning fat well if irs2 is increased then that keto doesn't get into the the cell it'll be turning on uptake of glucose so you wasted the keto function if virus 2 is elevated so if you're going to get a serious about a diet and and the the carnivore Diet also gives tremendous source of glucose remember aspirate and glutamate are broke down in glucose very quickly when your energy is low and so that protein wasting goes along the carnivore diet if irs2 is up and having done a little bit of work with carnivore diet I would just urge people to know what your irs2 is before you stop eating all all carbohydrates”
Peterson notes that if CIRS is as widespread and severe as described, it dwarfs the asbestos problem in scale (which took decades to kill people). The prevalence, severity, and life-altering nature of CIRS (affecting ~25% of population), combined with the complicated and expensive treatment pathway, explains institutional and public resistance to acknowledging the problem.
“it's not surprising as far as I'm concerned because if this problem is as severe and as widespread as you describe then it makes the asbest problem look trivial by comparison person and you know takes a long time to kill you from asbest mold just makes you feel like you want to die”
Patients who recover from CIRS (via remediation and treatment) remain genetically susceptible (HLA type does not change); they retain vulnerability to reactivation if reexposed to water-damaged buildings. However, if MSH levels rise to normal during treatment, some individuals may gain functional resistance. Those who travel extensively or cannot guarantee mold-free environments should take prophylactic medications continuously (e.g., low-dose VIP, which has essentially zero side effects).
“if msh levels don't rise which is the most common situation the S susceptibility has not changed because your HLA has not changed with low msh if you get re go somewhere to a hotel or an airplane and you reacquire marchons because they're ubiquitous in the environment and the Maron starts to grow you will relapse and recres with your symptoms within three days”
Defective apoptosis (programmed cell death) in CIRS leads to uncontrolled cell lysis without membrane coating of internal fragments; antigens released into circulation activate innate immune response, creating endogenous source of CIRS. Genes like RPK1 regulate apoptosis; defective apoptosis genes can be identified and explain why some patients have persistent immune activation even without external exposure.
“we start seeing disruptions of of apoptosis this is programmed cell death where cell should die normally being the fragments of cells be coated with membrane released into the circulation but not causing inflammation but here in this illness with apoptosis we have defective apoptosis where the cell is lice without cating of the internal fragments that are antigens so we get now a surge of antigen load in bloodstream with apoptosis and someone who's got defective apoptosis genes rpk1 we can tell you that and that will create an endogenous source for sers”
Initial cholestyramine treatment can cause 'intensification' or temporary worsening of symptoms in some patients, particularly those with colonizing antibiotic-resistant coagulase-negative Staphylococcus or post-Lyme disease syndrome, due to release of toxins from disrupted biofilms creating acute cytokine storms; this can be managed through slow dose escalation or use of low-dose VIP as a starting point.
“when people intensify there are either two problems pre-existing we would know in if we had done the evaluation if you have a multiply antibiotic resistant coagulate negative staff colonizing your nose not infecting your nose not creating symptoms but colonizing your nose and you treat with binders there can be intensification because this organism makes a tox a polycystic ether toxin po polycyclic ether toxin that is released when it's Disturbed in its ecosystem...there will be a response of the receptor to suddenly release all cyto kindes that are bound and so you you frequently will create a cyto kind storm”
Drywall was introduced very rapidly in widespread fashion in the latter half of the 20th century without long-term historical experience of its behavior in humid/wet conditions; this is analogous to how experimental vaccines were introduced widely without complete understanding of long-term effects—both are examples of technological/medical innovations distributed broadly before full consequences are known
“it sounds like that's a case that you're making for drywall is that it's an extraordinarily light easy to work with cheap building substance but it isn't we don't have a lot of historical experience with it it was introduced very in a very widespread manner in the latter half of the 20th century and so and then you're saying that in combination with the fungicides and so forth that was put in the paint”
CIRS treatment can have significant lifestyle impacts including dietary restrictions (nearly complete elimination of normal foods in Peterson's case), reduced ability to travel (due to hotel/airplane mold exposure risk), reduced social engagement (difficulty as a guest due to dietary restrictions), and long-term prophylactic medication dependence to prevent relapse
“I'm contemplating doing something about it I'm wondering well you know what what's the implication here for for travel for visiting other people so Howes I mean I already almost eat nothing which makes me you know an annoying guest in many ways”
In February 2006, Ted Kennedy's Health, Education, and Labor Committee sent physicians (including Shoemaker) to New Orleans to investigate post-Katrina and post-Rita health effects; most of New Orleans was still underwater and moldy. They studied 250 patients aboard a control ship (the Scotia Prince) using symptoms and VCS testing and found distinct CIRS markers. When a Monday report was released to St. Bernard Parish, it was taken down on Tuesday with no further action or public record.
“Ted Kennedy's H committee health education and labor committee sent a group of Physicians including me down to New Orleans to look to see what happened with Katrina and Rita and they're most of new orans this is in February 2006 was still underwater and as moldy as can be and femal is doing things but we had a a ship the Scotia Prince was our control gr none of these people have been in in involved with neurons in any way but they were there and our taking controls for the group and we had people being St stashed on the boat they were from Firemen they were from children there are homeless people people from St Bernard Parish and I had a case control study I did over the weekend always did was was symptoms and visual contrast on 250 patients and we showed distinct markers”
Carnivore diet reduces inflammatory load by eliminating plant-derived compounds; in CIRS patients with low MSH, carnivore diet appears effective at improving symptoms; once CIRS treatment achieves maximum medical improvement and VIP restores metabolic function, dietary restrictions can potentially be expanded beyond carnivore
“as a carnivore diet as you reduce the inflammatory result of using veggies and other things that are not carnivore food you will find that VIP is your good friend and it is will be something helpful to let you expand your diet once you have re achieved the the maximum medical improvement from the Conor diet”
Factor analysis of CIRS symptoms was published in 2006 showing statistical clustering of symptoms; when patients take the visual contrast sensitivity test and symptom cluster assessment, the system can predict CIRS with 98.5% likelihood based on VCS and symptoms alone without additional biomarkers.
“yes every person that takes their visual contrast test will undergo a symptom analysis and a symptom discussion and we look to see if there's cluster analysis a statistical function of saying yes or no based on visual contr contrast and symptoms alone without any of the other biomarkers just statistically we can tell you 98.5% likelihood of s just on VCS and symptom clusters”
A rheumatologist at University of Washington initially resisted testing for TGF-beta-1 in a juvenile rheumatoid arthritis patient who was going blind; Shoemaker noted there are 75,000 published papers on TGF-beta-1, indicating the marker exists in peer-reviewed literature. After testing, TGF-beta-1 was found to be elevated and was causative; treatment normalized it and the patient regained vision.
“I had one uh rheumatologist give me a hard time at univiversity of was Washington and Seattle I sent a patient in from quarterline who needed to have a TGF beta one done because he had juile rumor arthritis was going blind and TGF beta 1 was the cause of that and he goes well I've never heard of a TGF beta 1 this is years ago and being a smartass I said there's only 75,000 papers published on tjf beta 1 I would not admit that you didn't know any of them in public if I were you well right needless to say he got the teachers beta one the child can see now”
Microbiological testing protocols must assess three distinct classes of water-damage organisms: fungi, actinobacteria (including identification of specific species like coagulase-negative Staphylococcus), and endotoxin levels from bacterial components, because presence or absence of any single organism class can change the clinical picture and treatment approach.
“if the building is water damaged and it should have fungi but doesn't and you don't test for actino bacteria you've made a mistake but if you don't have fungi is that because you never had them or is it because it's overrun with with actino bacteria that are making the drywall surface alkaline and fungi don't live very well and then if that's not the case what about the water saturation with endotoxins because of the three things that cause the greatest amount of damage to the brain endotoxins lead the list”
The CIRS case definition requires four elements: (1) potential for exposure to water-damaged buildings; (2) symptoms consistent with published peer-reviewed literature; (3) laboratory findings (biomarkers) consistent with published literature; (4) objective response of biomarkers to treatment. This case definition was developed in 2003 and modified in 2008 by the US Government Accountability Office.
“we need to start with a case definition the case definition in 2003 that our group came up with was modified in 2008 by the US government accountability office when they looked at the potential for exposure this is what CDC used with Feria back in 197 1996 he didn't get sick from a micro Alo Bloom unless you're exposed to it so the potential for exposure is number one number two is symptoms the same or similar to those seen in published peer review literature the third element is laboratory findings the same or similar to those you in published literature and then the fourth is objective response of biomarkers to treatment”
Endotoxins from bacteria (particularly actinobacteria) are the primary cause of brain damage in CIRS, fungi are secondary, and specific gene activation patterns show correlation between endotoxin exposure and observable neuroimaging abnormalities, making endotoxin the 'most important' environmental trigger in terms of CNS injury.
“three things that cause the greatest amount of damage to the brain endotoxins lead the list the specifically for every abnormality that we find in the gene uh that that shows us about specific causation that's the the building contractor's word specific causation for endotoxins we've identified in neuroquant we've also identified in combination with the genie testing or genomic testing”
The optic nerve head retina is part of the central nervous system and exhibits the same cytokine-mediated capillary bed dysfunction that occurs in the brain, kidney, lung, and liver, making retinal blood flow abnormalities a proxy for central nervous system perfusion defects
“the same mechanism of cyto kind response in capillary beds is the same whether it started with a fungus whether it started with atino bacteria whether it started with the flu but this innate immune response is nonspecific in how it responds but it will respond and we can measure its tendency to re reoccur regardless of where it happens it'll happen in kidneys it happens in lung it happens in liver and it happens in the neural rim of the optic nerve head which is the first part of the central nervous system”
Reduced red blood cell flow to peripheral tissues (hands, feet) causes cold extremities, cramping, muscle spasms, and finger/toe discoloration that resembles cyanosis; brain reduced blood flow causes brain fog, memory problems, concentration difficulties, and processing speed deficits through hypoperfusion and reduced glucose/oxygen delivery to neurons
“you have to understand that there's decreased red blood flow to different places in the body not just to the optic disc so for instance you know peripherally as you look at the hands and feet we'll see that there's reduced Red Cell flow there too our patients will often have cold hands or cold feet or both they can have cramping in their hands they can have pains in their hands even sometimes discoloration you know that looks like cyanosis”
Environmental testing can be performed by households through dust sampling: placing a glove on one hand, wiping a Swiffer cloth in one direction over 10-30 horizontal surfaces above the floor, and sending the sample to a reputable laboratory to test for fungi, actinobacteria, and endotoxin levels indicating water damage.
“you can do that on one dust sample collected at home by someone who can put a glove on one hand and wipe a Swiffer cloth in One Direction over 10 to 30 surfaces that are horizontal above the floor and send that off to a lab that's reputable the licens it's not a Fly by Night insure and Sh your organization but you there there are those that are out there they really are”
Restricted lung disease (not obstructive) is common in CIRS patients presenting with cough, shortness of breath, and difficulty with exertion; this is distinct from asthma despite being sometimes misdiagnosed as such.
“with cough and shortness of breath and difficulty with exertion we had lung involvement didn't have a lot of speed in production and the biomarker was restricted lung disease not not obstructive it wasn't asthma was called asthma by some but it's not it's restrictive”
The blood-brain barrier is formed by 5 days of fetal life as specialized cells interpolate into cerebral blood vessels; the brain is more sensitive than other tissues to chemical and toxin exposure and requires selective permeability. Understanding BBB function is critical to understanding how biotoxins cause CNS degeneration in CIRS.
“most people including myself when I was going through medical schools thought of uh an artery that carries blood as being like a garden hose the the blood enters one end and it comes out the other but it turns out that actually the cells that make up the lining of blood vessels is pretty porous and small proteins and fluid can flow outside of the blood vessels and into the body where the cells are and the cells don't seem to mind that maybe they get a little extra snack and in addition you've got the lymph system to clean that up but the brain is much more sensitive tissue and the brain doesn't want all those potential chemicals and possibly toxins oozing into it so by five days of Life the brain has sent cells to interpolate into the uh those arteries that are feeding the brain and create”
Peterson has mold-tested properties he owns and found them 'quite mold saturated'; he is uncertain about how to remediate the problem, especially since one property was recently remodeled. The difficulty and expense of building remediation creates a practical barrier to treatment for many people.
“we had our houses mold tested um and you know the results were rather dismal and I'm not exactly sure what to do about that because I have properties now that appear to be quite mold saturated and you the step after that's not exactly clear one of them was just remodeled and I'm not that inclined to bloody well do the whole thing again”
Peterson personally has been investigating CIRS through his daughter, who has experienced long-standing health disorders. His daughter convinced him to look into CIRS as a possible cause of her immunological problems, which she has partially addressed through restricted diet. Peterson and his wife have also tried carnivore diet with positive results. Peterson's family had brain scans done looking for neurological damage associated with biotoxin exposure.
“I found out about this through my daughter who's been wrestling with health disorders of various sorts for her whole life she's convinced me that it was at least worth a um it was worth some investigation and that's what I'm doing”
Peterson tested positive on visual contrast sensitivity test and 'failed it... quite dramatically', consistent with CIRS diagnosis. Peterson has tried cholestyramine therapy (a binder) at variable doses and experienced psychomotor slowing, pain, and depressive symptoms at higher doses, which resolved at lower doses, suggesting dose-dependent intensification reaction.
“I've taken this test by the way and failed it and quite dramatically and so there's an online test which is a visual contrast sensitivity test”
Surviving Mold (survivingmold.com) and CIRS-X (cirsx.com) are the most comprehensive and trusted online resources for CIRS information, literature, videos, and local provider directories for people who suspect CIRS.
“the places where the most knowledge the most trusted trusted knowledge is the most uh literature the most videos about this are either from Dr shoemakers www.s surviving mold or CX csx.com I think you go to those two places you can find just about anything you need including uh a local provider Who would know something about this if you think that you have this illness”
The textbook 'Art and Science of CIRS Medicine' co-authored by Shoemaker and McMahon is the primary clinical reference for treating CIRS; it describes the 'pyramid' treatment protocol that forms the basis of stepwise biomarker-driven therapy
“there two goodbites Scott Scott one s x surviving molds another one Scott tell about s x well I was going to say the places where the most knowledge the most trusted trusted knowledge is the most uh literature the most videos about this are either from Dr shoemakers...Art and Science of Sir medicine okay so that's where medical practitioners can learn about this”
Genetic lessons from CIRS are available as free downloads from the Surviving Mold website, providing accessible molecular/genetic education to patients without requiring physician consultation
“lessons from Genie available on free downloads from surviving World website you just take a look you don't have to pay a doctor and you can just get it read yourself”