
What this covers
Jeffrey Gundlach's webcast, titled "1984" after Orwell, was delivered on September 10, 2024, a week before the Fed's September 18 meeting. It is a single-speaker walk through the data he expects the FOMC to weigh. He begins with market positioning: futures pricing roughly eight quarter-point cuts over twelve months, long-dated Treasuries up 6.3% since the July meeting as the top performer, and a real fed funds rate of 2.43%, the highest in about twenty years.
The inflation section is the most granular. Gundlach argues that core CPI services are the only meaningful source of price pressure left in the basket, that the Bloomberg Commodity Index sits at a two-year low, and that CPI) could drop below 2% within months if oil stays in the mid-60s. He raises the possibility that the Fed might start talking about undershooting its target. He also notes that "super core" measures could be used as ammunition against cuts, and that US CPI would read 1.72% under European methodology. The labor section covers the unemployment rate crossing its 36-month moving average, the 2s-10s-style yield curve de-inversion (the 2-1 spread), falling manufacturing hours, jobless claims, and the quit rate's lead over wage growth. He argues that payrolls have been over-reported and later revised down, that the household survey shows full-time job losses, and that part-time job growth is misleading. He treats recession risk as live.
The range then widens. He covers a 5.5%-of-GDP deficit and the CBO's optimistic projections, housing supply locked up by low-rate mortgages and what sub-6% mortgage rates might do in Austin and Miami, and AI valuations compared with 1999. He also touches on preferring foreign developed markets in local currency and the breakdown of the copper-gold ratio. The most speculative turn is his claim that Strauss-Howe's "fourth turning" has begun, which he links to institutional restructuring.
The speaker argues that despite falling inflation metrics, the Federal Reserve is behind the curve on rate cuts due to massive real (CPI-adjusted) price level increases since 2020, and recession indicators are flashing red even as official employment data is being systematically over-reported through downward benchmark revisions.
- CPI price level is up ~25% since 2020, creating real hardship for consumers even though year-over-year inflation rates are falling toward 2%
- Unemployment rate has crossed above its 36-month moving average by 50 basis points, a near-perfect historical recession indicator that has triggered in all recent recessions
- Non-farm payroll employment has been consistently over-reported and subsequently revised downward, with household survey showing full-time job losses year-to-date in 2024
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The CPI price level (not year-over-year rate) has risen approximately 25% since 2020, creating a significant real hardship for consumers who cannot afford goods and services despite inflation rate approaching 2%.
“you can tell them all about how it's great that inflation is approaching 2% but the price level is still up 25% from where it was four years ago and that is a problem because people are suffering and they can't afford it and there's many many articles and stories about families where the parents are eating every other day because they only can get with them skipping days they they only have to have their kids skip one meal a day”
Core Services inflation (shelter and non-shelter services) is now the only significant source of inflation in the CPI basket, with all other categories effectively at zero inflation, meaning CPI will decline when core Services moderates.
“core Services is the only area of the CPI that has uh any inflation at all to speak of everything else neutralizes out at zero”
M2 money supply was elevated following lockdowns and money printing, then went sideways for a couple of years, which explains why inflation should remain low for a protracted period despite M2 still being above its long-term trend line.
“another thing that's elevated that got elevated right after the lockdown was the M2 money supply with all that money Printing and this has the same look and I say not surprisingly same look as the CPI um here we have the same deal the money supply was exploded higher it led to all that inflation now it's been going sideways for a couple years so it's quite sensible that inflation should be low for a a protracted period because we don't have the money supply being gunned”
The 2-1 yield curve spread has inverted to negative 108 basis points at its maximum and now is positive 6 basis points, crossing zero this week and de-inverting for the first time, which historically is the recession signal.
“the US yield curve is steepening before the recession this the the tw1 got to a negative 108 basis points at its maximum inversion and now it's positive six and you can see in past recessions going back to 1980 or 1984 for that matter you can see that the curve de inverts before the shaded areas every time so we had not we did not give a false signal on recession by the yield curve being inverted the recession signal was only given this week with the 210 spread going positive”
Non-farm payroll employment has experienced years of downward revisions, with 'very few upgrades compared to downgrades,' indicating the government has been systematically over-reporting employment.
“here we see that there's been a lot of downward revisions if we go back uh for for years we we've got very few upgrades compared to downgrades so it looks like they've been over reporting nonform payrolls only having to adjust them lower”
The federal budget deficit is at 5.5% of GDP with the unemployment rate at 4.2%, and if unemployment rises as expected, the deficit will deteriorate significantly by multiple percentage points, becoming a major issue for Treasury bond supply.
“the deficit is already at 5.5% of GDP uh that's pretty bad the unemployment rat is at 4.2 but we're not in a recession supposedly so um we'll see what happens I mean typically when we go into these recessions we can see the budget deficit gets way worse”
The speaker believes that the fourth turning has begun and societies need to restructure institutions and potentially political systems because the current systems are being rejected at multiple levels.
“being careful not to extrapolate patterns from the past into the future when the institutions that have been Central to the Past over the past um I don't know seven decades or so eight decades are going to be replaced going to need to be replaced because we can all see that the systems that have been in place are being rejected uh many many levels”
The Congressional Budget Office makes overly optimistic projections on interest rates, deficits, and assumes no recession will occur, with their projections showing federal net interest expense reaching 75 billion dollars per month.
“the CBO which is wildly optimistic on their projections they project lower interest rates than are likely they project lower deficits than were even already hap having they and by necessity they predict that there'll never be any recession... we're going to be up to about 25 sorry 75 billion dollars a month in interest payments here very shortly”
The Fed funds rate minus US headline CPI is at 2.43%, the highest level in approximately 20 years since before the global financial crisis, indicating the Fed is now in a tight monetary policy stance.
“this is the Fed funds rate minus the US head CPI we can see that it's the highest that it's been in basically almost 20 years since prior to the global financial crisis and it's been negative for most of this time period the FED funds rate was negative for uh over 10 years with small interruptions and now we can see it's all the way up at 2.43”
Super core inflation (core CPI excluding housing), at 4.48% on the CPI side and 3.25% on the PCE side, could be used as an inflationary "ammunition" to argue against rate cuts if inflation re-accelerates, though PCE super core has been sideways for a year without systematic decline.
“super core inflation this you never hear about this is if you want to be an inflationist and you want to have uh ammunition to support the idea that inflation might re accelerate”
Average weekly hours worked in manufacturing shows a clear downtrend, reaching new local lows, following the historical pattern where 'first they cut the hours then they cut the bodies,' indicating recession ahead.
“average weekly hours worked in manufacturing clear downtrend uh the tan line had been falling anyway uh then the then the pandemic came but now we're we're going to new local lows and first there's an old adage first they cut the hours then they cut the bodies uh this has been enough of a decline that it's starting to have the look of some of the past recessionary periods”
The household survey shows six out of eight months of full-time job losses, with year-to-date employment shrinkage through seven/eight months of 2024, contrasting with headline reports of employment gains.
“it's also the household survey where they've now had six out of eight months of of uh of jobs uh six of eight months of jobs being lost full-time jobs in the household survey and year to date we are now negative on employment we employment shrinkage on the household survey cumulatively here through the first uh seven months coming up on eight months of of uh 2024”
Initial jobless claims have bottomed and are on a gently rising trend, with continuing claims not really improving but going sideways, representing critical indicators to watch for unemployment rate deterioration.
“the initial claims just as a reminder come out every Thursday so that's pretty uh it's every weekly data so we get a high frequency look at things but look at continuing claims this is uh not really improving it's not terrible it's kind of going sideways uh so we'll be following these indicators”
The AI market enthusiasm and valuations today resemble the dot-com frenzy of 1999, with AI likely to have a long profitable future but currently carrying dot-com-era valuations that represent poor risk-reward.
“I feel that based upon the sentiment into the market the valuations in the market the fact that this chart is double topping against in the context of an AI frenzy which feels quite a bit similar to the doc frenzy I'm not saying AI won't have a long life and have many profitable companies but it sure looks like it has evaluations today that you had in the for the dots back in 1999”
The quit rate (forward-looking labor indicator) leads the Atlanta wage growth tracker by approximately 8 months; the quit rate shows a high correlation with wage growth, and elevated quit rates suggest further wage growth improvement is possible
“here's uh some forward-looking uh indicators we're just comparing the quits rate which is the tan line and we've got it plotted eight months leading the Atlanta wage growth tracker and the W Atlanta wage growth tracker has been falling it's down by about 200 bases points from the high but [33:59] the quit rates there's a high correlation here as you can see the quits rates suggests that we should see further Improvement uh in the wage growth”
For dollar-based investors, owning foreign developed markets in local currency is preferable to dollar-denominated terms, despite uncertain near-term (1-2 year) performance, based on longer-term (decade) outlook.
“I would I would own as a dollar-based investor I would own foreign markets in local currency terms um I don't know if it's going to work in the next year I don't know if it's going to work in the next year and a half but I think it's going to work over the next decade and so sometimes you have to uh just go with h the longer term picture not worry about the shortterm performance because you don't want to lose lose s of the forest for the trees”
Headline CPI is at 2.9% and core CPI at 3.2%, both in declining mode, with predictions that headline CPI will fall below 2% within a few months if oil prices remain in the mid-60s.
“here's the the CPI the headline uh which is at 2.9% and the so-called core which excludes food and energy which is at 3.2% it's pretty obvious that these are in a declining mode but we now are looking at a very substantial drop in this headline CPI in the next six months or so based on the rapid decline in the price of oil”
Long-term treasuries have been the number one performing standardized asset class since the July Fed meeting, up 6.3%, with nothing else performing close to that level.
“since the FED uh in the last several fed meetings since the July meeting the number one performing uh sort of standardized asset class is long-term treasuries up 6.3% nothing else is up anywhere close”
The two-year Treasury yield at 3.6% is substantially below the Fed funds target rate upper end of 5.5%, with a huge gap between the two, suggesting market pricing for aggressive near-term rate cuts.
“the FED is further behind with their upper end of their range being 550 while the twoyear treasury is now down to about 3.6 as of yesterday I guess it was a little bit higher but now there's this huge gap between the FED funds rate and where the two-year treasury is guiding and so no wonder the market is talking about the potential for a 50 basis point cut at the meeting next”
The Bloomberg Commodity Index has fallen to a two-year low and is below the 200-day moving average, indicating broad commodity weakness and weak global demand rather than any inflationary pressures.
“we're right back below the 200 day moving average and in fact uh as of today this was yesterday's print we're down again today we're at the low of the year in fact we're at the low for almost two years on on commod prices so here here we are without any inflationary signals and that's even though the dollar has been relatively weak uh versus say the Euro”
The copper-gold ratio, which previously worked well as a leading indicator, has been 'of no value whatsoever' for approximately 18 months, likely because institutions are now worried about the fourth turning and institutional restructuring.
“the copper gold ratio which if you go back to prior to covid we see the copper gold ratio worked pretty well directionally... but now we're coming on a year and a half where the copper gold model is of no value whatsoever and I think the reason is that now that we've turned the corner perhaps on interest rates... we have mismanagement of developed economies and we have very strong suspicions of our institutions and our Elites”
Many people are taking multiple part-time jobs not by choice but out of economic necessity, and therefore counting part-time job growth as positive job creation is misleading about labor market health.
“there's plenty of evidence that many people have two part-time jobs so it's not like a person wants to have two jobs they have two jobs because they need to have two jobs and so if You've had one job and now you are driving an Uber as a second job that's not exactly great job creation”
If CPI were calculated using European methodology rather than US methodology, US inflation would be 1.72%, or 108 basis points lower than Europe's 2.8%, yet the US has been reluctant to cut rates while Europe has already cut rates.
“we calculate CPI one way uh and the Euro Zone calculates inflation another way their consumer prices and our Consumer Price methodology differs from Europe's we have more of an emphasis on housing in our Consumer Price calculations the interesting thing here is Europe's CPI the way they calculate it is at 2.8 we we saw that ours was up at around three or so but if we calculated our CPI using the European methodology we would calculate it to be 1 . 72 fully 108 basis points lower than European CPI”
If mortgage rates fall below 6%, it could unlock housing supply by making rate-switching economical for existing homeowners, which could lead to home price stabilization or declines in some overheated markets like Austin, Miami, and parts of Florida.
“if we get to a sub6 mortgage rate it might start to unlock some of that uh OA Supply because buyers didn't want to switch to such a high rate mortgage if we can get down into the fives on the 30 rate 30-year advertising mortgage that might unlock Supply which might take home prices down”
Home prices have surged to new highs and are up 8% in Los Angeles and Manhattan over the past 12 months, with the Case-Schiller National Index rising sharply on steroids since 2020, while disposable income per capita has lagged dramatically, resembling 2006 affordability crisis conditions.
“home prices have gone straight up and they're not stopping this it looked like they maybe were taking a break there a year ago but we say that the K Schiller National home price index is at a new high and it's risen in a lot of places surprisingly like Los Angeles uh and Manhattan not surprisingly but Los Angeles I think surprisingly by about 8% over the past 12 months”
The speaker estimates higher than 10% probability (but not 50%) of the tail risk scenario of rising long-term Treasury yields during recession due to deficit/bond supply concerns.
“I'm not saying it's a 50% chance but I think it's more than the 10% chance that most people would give to the idea that right the long end of the treasury market yields might go up sometime in the when we get into deeper into the recession”
Auto insurance inflation has increased by approximately 19% year-over-year and is still rising significantly month-over-month, with cumulative increases of roughly 40% over two years, representing a mandatory cost that disproportionately affects low-income households.
“one more thing on the FED uh this is an inflation this is a recession indicator for sure auto insurance inflation just imagine what the cumulative inflation is on auto insurance when you have a 19% increase uh for motor vehicle insurance year-over-year”
Core PCE shows seasonal patterns where first quarter is the highest inflation, second quarter elevated, and third and fourth quarters are negative on a seasonal basis, suggesting no upside surprise expected in Q4 2024 inflation data.
“there's seasonality in the in the core pce which I talked about a year ago but here it is again you tend to get uh a bump up on a seasonal basis even though these numbers are supposedly seasonally adjusted the fact is that they don't seem to be adjusting them all the way at the should be because you can see that the first quarter is the highest inflation on a on a median the second quarter is elevated as well and then you have third and fourth quarter which tend to be actually negative”
Consumer confidence expectations have stabilized while present situation confidence has begun deteriorating, causing the gap between them to shrink, which historically precedes recessions by triggering at the front edge.
“the view of the Future Has stabilized and the view of the present is now the one that's deteriorating and that causes the red shaded area to start to shrink and you'll notice in the past three recessions when the red stated shaded area starts to shrink in Earnest you're on the front edge of a recession or slightly past the front edge of the resection”
US S&P 500 has performed in line with MSCI Europe with volatility over the past nearly three years, with both showing similar performance whether measured in dollar or currency terms for dollar-based investors.
“here us S&P versus MCI Europe and it is not underperforming it's basically been performing with volatility in line going back nearly three years so if you own Europe versus the S&P 500 if you're a dollar-based investor you have to think about whether you want to own that in dollar terms or currency terms”
Emerging Markets underperformance versus the S&P 500 has stopped at the peak of the Magnificent 7, though there has been some renewed enthusiasm, with Emerging Markets now in line with S&P 500 on the MSCI basis.
“this one this only goes back a couple of years but we have stopped the underperformance of Emerging Markets versus the S&P and stopped back when the the the real outperformance of The Magnificent 7 hit its apigy although there's been some uh enthusiasm there again we see that Emerging Markets are now in line uh with the S&P 500 on the msci”
The speaker explicitly stated on CNBC July 31st that 'the history books will say with high confidence that in September of 2024 we were in a recession.'
“on CNBC on July 31st I said my my work shows that the history books will say with with high confidence I say the history books will say that in in September of 2024 we were in a recession”
Leading economic indicators have been negative for 12+ months, with 6-month annualized rates negative for even longer, and are heavily manufacturing-oriented, making them ineffective as recession indicators in the current cycle.
“here's the leading economic indicators which have not worked at all uh that's because they're so manufacturing oriented and Manufacturing got weak early on uh in into the lockdowns after the first initial surge of 2020 and 2021 of people buying uh manufactured durable products now we see that the leading indicators for 12 months has been negative for like two years uh and the six months annualized has been negative for even longer”
Labor supply and demand have rebalanced to pre-pandemic levels, though the trend in the green bar dispersion is troubling as it has been declining monotonically for over two years, suggesting further easing pressure ahead.
“JP has been using the term that the supply demand of labor has come back into better balance... it kind of looks like it was pre pandemic pre- lockdown uh which was a labor market which seemed to be functioning fairly well but I'll tell you one thing the trend here it might be imbalance but the trend here is a little bit troubling you can see those green bars are going down almost monotonically and have been for over two years”
The S&P 500 has outperformed the Russell 2000 for 14 years (10 years especially post-2014), reaching relative valuation levels rivaling the dot-com bust, with the current pattern showing a potential double top.
“the S&P 500 has outperformed had outperformed the Russell 2000 for basically 14 years uh particularly 10 years after 2014 reaching a relative valuation level rivaling the uh the dot pre- Doom bust situation and it looks to me like that's happening again so we have what looks like a double top”
The Federal Reserve should have begun cutting rates at the July 2024 meeting, not waited until September, because inflation has already proven to be moderating across all major indices.
“I said they should have cut them last July and I I believe that then and I believe it now”
Global shipping/container rates with a six-month lag lead US PPI final goods, and both have bottomed and begun reversing, suggesting potential for future PPI acceleration if global container rates rise.
“Global shipping rates with a six-month lag Global container rates are the blue line and uh they lead this is a six-month lead on the blue line versus the black line us PPI final goods and that has bottomed out as we saw in the chart uh and there is a good correlation here so maybe it's possible I don't really predict it's going to happen uh but it's possible that if you're an inflationist you've got something to lean on here”
If Trump wins, tax cuts will likely be maintained, making the CBO's already optimistic deficit projections 'even more optimistic,' exacerbating the long-term fiscal problem.
“I I suspect that if Trump wins the tax cuts will maintain and that that will make this projection even more optimistic”
WTI crude oil prices now seem to be a better leading indicator than the copper-gold ratio for directionally matching bond yields over the past two years and from COVID through 2022 peak.
“what's better than the copper gold model now seems to be Texas intermediate crew WTI where directionally they look pretty similar and you'll notice the WTI and the tenure have been moving directionally kind of identically for the past uh two years”
The unemployment rate has crossed above its 36-month moving average by 50 basis points and is virtual guarantee of recession, representing strong evidence that we are at the front edge of recession.
“guess what we've crossed over and you don't need a magnifying glass anymore it's definitive we're not only above the low of the unemployment rate by 50 basis points were AB we're almost above the 36-month moving average by 50 basis points which is virtual guarantee of recession”
In the most recent economic indicators report, only two components were positive (stock prices and leading credit index), while all other important components look negative, with dispersion now firmly in negative territory.
“there are only two components that were up in any significant way and those were stock prices and the leading credit index well stock prices have stopped going up the S&P 500 isn't even up since the last fed meeting July 31st but everything that's really kind of important looks like it's negative”
Import and export prices have been running below 2% (imports at 1.7%, exports at 1.4%), providing no concern about the 2% inflation target being reversed.
“everybody knows that I like the best export and import prices these have been volatile for sure as they always are but lately they've been running below 2% at 1.7 for import import prices and 1.4 for export prices nothing here to cause any concern about the 2% Target somehow being reversed”
The 10-year Treasury yield has already declined from 5.02% in October 2023 to approximately 3.65% currently (less than a year later), indicating that much of the expected recession-driven yield decline has already occurred
“we've already had the 10year yield come down from the high of 502 last October into now less than a year later down to about 3.65”
The speaker believes this inflation data and momentum explains why Fed Chair Jay Powell has been expressing increased confidence that inflation is heading toward the 2% target
“here the six-month numbers are similar to The CPI we have 2.3 on the headline and 2.6 so we're getting quite close uh to the pce I think this is what has Jay Powell saying he's got increased confidence that we're heading uh to the right place at the 2% Target rate”
The speaker intends to show WTI more frequently going forward as it appears to be a variable worth noting given its reliable correlation with Treasury yields
“the bond yields peaked a little bit later but I'm going to be showing WTI more frequently as it now seems to be a variable worth noting”